"My doctor told me to quit throwing dinner parties for 4 unless there are 3 other people - [sigh]" - Gramps
This is the recipe I use for all my caramel needs – for apples, popcorn, ice cream, cashew starkles, etc. Just change the temperature to get a different hardness. Low temperatures will produce runny/softer caramel and high temperatures will make brittle/harder candy (toffee, etc).
From the kitchen of: The Boren's
1 ½ C light corn syrup
1 C butter
1 can sweetened condensed milk
2 C white sugar (or brown sugar if you want it to look browner especially at lower temperatures)
¼ tsp. salt
INSTRUCTIONS:
Cook to 230-240 °F (depending on desired softness – I think I go around 223°F for apple slices, 228°F for whole caramel apples, 230-234°F for starkles and for dipping caramels). If you want to make good candy, a digital thermometer is a must, but I also use the “cold water” method that my Grandma Tippetts used (see Candy Testing) just to be sure that it’s right.
Remove from heat and add:
1 tsp vanilla
Pour in to buttered pan and let cool and cure for 2 days before cutting and dipping.
MAKES: 6 dozen dipped caramels