Mutual Attraction

Title: Mutual Attraction

Author: Diane

Pairing: Nathan/Haley

Category: AU

Table/Prompt: #5/04 - Bathroom

Rating: Adult Rated

Disclaimer: I don’t own a thing!

Spoilers/Warnings: None as it’s AU. The main thing to know with this story is that Nathan and Lucas are best friends and that Haley is Lucas’ younger sister. Story contains scenes and language of a sexual nature.

Summary: As he walked towards the bathroom, he was still so fuzzy with sleep that he didn’t hear the water running and it was only when he had opened the door and was hit by a cloud of steam that he realised he’d forgotten about his houseguest.

Author’s Notes: Just so there’s no confusion, this is an adaptation of a story I wrote a long time ago for a different fandom, and it’s dedicated to Sophie as a belated birthday gift. I know it’s not what you originally asked for, but I hope you like it.

It’s also part of my fanfic table for 5x10prompts.

Nathan Scott groaned at the sudden shrill beeping sound of his alarm clock and, reaching over to his nightstand, he forcibly hit the appliance’s snooze button before finding the off switch, sighing in relief when the noise ceased. Rolling over onto his back, he pushed himself up into a sitting position and ran a hand over his face; cursing himself under his breath for having automatically set his alarm the night before, forgetting yet again that the following day was a Saturday and he had nothing planned which needed him to be up this early for.

Unfortunately, he’d always been one of those people who once they were awake couldn’t fall back to sleep so he decided he might as well get up and the first thing on the agenda was making himself some strong coffee which would hopefully help perk him up. Padding barefoot into the kitchen, he headed over to the percolator and after filling the jug with water and adding his favourite coffee to the machine, he switched it on.

While he waited, he stretched his arms above his head, working out the tiredness in his back and shoulders. Knowing he had some time before the coffee would be ready, he decided to take a quick shower. As he walked towards the bathroom, he was still so fuzzy with sleep that he didn’t hear the water running and it was only when he had opened the door and was hit by a cloud of steam that he realised he’d forgotten about his houseguest.

Haley James… The person who’d had a starring role in more than a few of his dreams and fantasies over the years. The fact she was his childhood best friend’s little sister didn’t seem to matter to his subconscious mind and there’d been several times recently when he’d woken up in the middle of the night hard and aching, her name falling from his lips as he came all over his hand.

He’d known letting her stay in his spare room while her and her roommate’s apartment building was being renovated would probably be a big mistake but he’d found himself offering anyway. Despite knowing each other since they were five and ten years old respectively and having spent a fair amount of time together over the years, a part of him had felt sure she’d feel more comfortable staying with one of her girlfriends which is why he’d been surprised when she took him up on his offer. He’d figured that he was the closest thing she had to family living in the area where she was currently attending college and that maybe that was the reason for her choosing to stay at his place.

The first couple of weeks, he had to admit, had felt a bit awkward but they’d soon gotten over that and were now teasing each other the way they’d done ever since they’d been kids. One thing he’d worried about having her stay with him had come true though… his attraction to her was getting stronger by the day and, as he lay in bed each night, he couldn’t help wondering if she had any idea as to how he felt about her.

While Nathan’s mind wandered, his feet were rooted to the spot as his eyes roamed all over Haley’s curvaceous form standing in his shower and he couldn’t help mentally patting himself on the back for having decided to go for a clear glass cubicle instead of a frosted design. Her back was to him but he wasn’t complaining since he was getting an awesome view of her pert little ass.

When she turned and faced him, he held his breath ready for her tirade at him standing and staring at her but it never came and when he looked at her face he saw the reason why. Her eyes were shut as she tilted her head back to wet her long, honey-blonde hair under the strong spray of water.

While he knew he should leave now, he couldn’t seem to move from his position, his hungry eyes taking in every gorgeous inch of her body. Her more than ample breasts were high and firm and, lowering his gaze, a smirk tugged at his lips when he saw the dainty silver butterfly embellishment dangling from her belly button, almost beckoning his attention to the neatly trimmed curls covering her sex. Licking his lips, he couldn’t help wondering what she’d taste like…

Realising where his thoughts were going, Nathan knew he needed to get out of there before he did something he would later regret. Okay, he knew he wouldn’t regret it but if Lucas knew his best friend was standing there gawping at his little sister while she showered… he’d be kicking his ass and then some.

Turning around to leave, he had only taken a couple of steps when he heard her tiny moans echo around the steam-filled room. Once again, he stood frozen to the spot and when her voice got slightly louder, his eyebrows rose in surprise. Was he really hearing her moaning his name? Slowly, he turned around to face her again and his mouth dropped open as he saw the vision before him.

The front of her body was still facing him and he saw that her eyes were still tightly closed but now she was leaning with her back against one of the cubicle’s walls. One leg was raised and her foot resting on the in-built tiled seat while her arm was braced on the wall beside her. The fingers of her right hand were frantically rubbing between her legs as she tried to bring herself to orgasm.

He couldn’t believe what he was seeing and hearing. His cock, which had been rock hard from the second he’d first seen her in his shower, got even harder if that was possible and he desperately wanted to touch himself. The only thing stopping him from doing that was the fear that she’d suddenly open her eyes and scream at him to get out. That fear slowly dissipated though when he heard her clearly call out his name and he somehow, in that moment, knew that this wasn’t the first time she had done this while thinking of him. Knowing that she more than likely felt something for him had Nathan beaming from ear to ear.

His eyes were concentrating on her face and he loved how beautiful Haley looked in the throes of passion. Her skin was flushed and she was biting her bottom lip, something he felt she might be doing to prevent herself from making any further sounds. Letting his gaze drop, he took in her pebbled, dusky rose-tipped nipples which were just begging to be sucked on and he licked his lips again. Finally, his eyes landed on her fingers and he saw that instead of just rubbing, she was now plunging two fingers into herself while her thumb circled her clit.

A tiny voice in the back of his mind told him to get out of there but he ignored it; instead, holding his breath as he waited for her to finally come. When he looked at her flushed face, he noticed a small bead of blood on her bottom lip from where she had bitten through the skin. Her frustration was clearly etched upon her pretty features. Watching her fingers again, he saw that she had inserted another digit and judging by the look on her face, it still obviously wasn’t enough to get her off.

Without thinking about what he was doing, Nathan stripped off his boxers and curled a hand around his shaft, stroking it up and down a couple of times and spreading the precum that had gathered at the tip. Almost in a daze, he walked forward and quietly slid open the shower door before stepping in. He moved in close to her, letting his cock brush against her stomach and he watched as her eyes flew open. Before she could say a word, he lowered his head to hers and seized her lips in a hard, bruising kiss.

As he kissed her, he slid a hand between them and removed her fingers from her body before replacing them with two of his own. The moan she released into his mouth reverberated throughout his body and he was sure he heard his teeth rattle.

Breaking the kiss to breathe in some much needed air, Haley released another loud moan as she felt his slightly calloused thumb rubbing circles on her throbbing clit. His long fingers were plunging in and out of her and although she knew her orgasm was finally in reach, she didn’t want to climax that way… not anymore. Placing a hand on his wrist, she stilled his movements and tried to tell him what she wanted with her eyes which were slowly trailing down his chest and abs until they reached his cock which, she had to admit, was pretty damn impressive.

When her eyes met his again, she saw him smirking and placing a hand on each of his shoulders, she pushed herself up onto her tiptoes and captured his mouth with her own. She nibbled and sucked on his lips before letting her tongue slip inside to glide against his. So lost was she in the kiss that she almost missed the fact that he had wrapped his arms around her waist and was lifting her up. Her legs automatically wrapped around his hips and she felt his cock brush against where she needed to feel him the most. His strong, muscular body was pressing her up against the shower wall and, God, it felt so good. She’d wanted this for so long and part of her couldn’t believe it was actually happening… If she was dreaming she definitely didn’t want to be waking up any time soon.

Finally feeling him poised at her entrance, she opened her eyes and saw him watching her as they still continued to kiss.

Breaking the kiss, Nathan looked at her for a moment longer before commanding, “Keep your eyes open.”

She inadvertently moaned at the huskiness of his voice and all she could do was nod. A second later, she cried out when he finally pushed inside of her in one hard thrust, feeling tears prickling behind her eyelids at the sudden unfamiliar intrusion. She took a few small, deep breaths as he held still and, thankfully, the feeling of him filling her so completely quickly became a pleasurable one. Her fingernails curled into his skin as he began to move using a series of hard and fast strokes, obviously determined to help her finally achieve that elusive orgasm he had seen her fighting for just a few minutes ago.

Her eyes fluttered closed as she savoured the way the base of his cock hit her clit with each down-stroke and using her hands on his shoulders as leverage, she slid herself up and down his body. When she felt his lips on her neck, she tilted her head to the side to give him better access and the feel of his teeth nipping sharply at her skin was driving her insane. The combination of his thick, hard length deep inside her, his teeth grazing her neck and his fingers pinching one of her nipples was something she didn’t think she would ever get enough of.

“Ohhh… Nathan… yes… right there…”

Hearing his name on her lips and feeling her little feet digging into his ass spurred him on and he began thrusting into her tight wet heat even faster and harder than before. Being with her felt so fucking incredible. He felt his balls start to tighten and he knew he was close to the edge and wanting her to join him when he fell over it, he began grinding the base of his cock against her clit, feeling her response all the way to his toes.

“Oh…Yes! Yesss!” She screamed so loudly when she finally came that she was sure that the whole building must have heard.

Feeling her pelvic muscles rhythmically clench and release around him as she climaxed brought on his own orgasm and he emptied himself inside of her. He continued to slide in and out of her body until he softened and slipped out.

They stayed pressed against each other, their breathing coming in harsh, ragged pants as they let their bodies recover from the intense feelings they had just experienced.

Starting to feel more than a little embarrassed about what had just happened between her and her brother’s best friend, she began to turn from him but he stilled her movements.

“Haley…”

“Don’t, Nathan. I don’t want to hear you tell me this was a mist—”

He cut off her words with a scorching hot kiss and he only broke it when the need for air became an issue. “I wasn’t going to say that.”

“Sure you weren’t. I know you and I know how your mind works. You’re already thinking of Lucas and what he’s going to say if he finds out. Well, don’t worry, he won’t. This can be our dirty little secret.” Haley felt like she was about to start crying and she squeezed her eyes shut in an attempt to stop any tears from falling.

“I can assure you that Luke is the last thing on my mind right now. And what happened between us wasn’t dirty. It felt incredible,” he told her, nuzzling his nose against hers in a soft Eskimo kiss.

“Really?” she asked shyly and she watched him nod his head.

“Yeah, really. Look, the water is starting to go cold so let’s finish up in here and we can talk about it afterwards.”

“Okay.” Turning her upper body, she reached up and grabbed her shower gel off the shelf and squeezing some into her hands, she began lathering her body with it. She gasped when she felt Nathan’s hands slip around her and work the lather into her skin, paying special attention to her breasts. Turning around to face him, she rubbed her own soapy hands on his chest before letting them trail down his toned stomach before finally arriving at his cock which was once again standing at full attention.

Wrapping his hand around hers which was stroking him up and down, he showed her how he liked to be touched and a minute or two later he removed his hand so she was once again doing it alone. Leaning back against the tiled wall behind him, he closed his eyes as he felt her small hand sliding up and down his cock but they flew open a second later when he felt her take him into her mouth.

“Fuck! That feels so good… you feel so good, baby,” he told her as his hands tangled in her wet hair. He tried hard not to thrust into her mouth but he couldn’t help it. Her tongue licked up and down the length of him before suckling the head and then sliding her lips down as far as she could take him into her mouth. The feel of her teeth grazing his hard flesh combined with her fingernails trailing up and down his inner thighs was his undoing though and the second time she did it he came without warning, pouring his seed down her throat. Looking down at her, he watched her swallow—something he hadn’t expected her to do—and that alone was enough to get him hard again. God, he couldn’t remember anything feeling half as good as this.

Taking his offered hand, Haley let him pull her to her feet and she was surprised when he pulled her into his arms and kissed her thoroughly. She’d never done that for anyone before and she’d figured if this was her only chance of being with Nathan, she was going to at least make the most of the experience. Her arms wrapped around his neck, the fingers of one hand burying themselves into his thick, dark hair as she kissed him back just as hard.

The sudden burst of cold water raining down upon them broke them out of their kiss and made them laugh.

“C’mon, let’s try once more to finish up in here,” she teased.

A few minutes later they were all done and she turned off the shower. Sliding the door open, Nathan stepped out and grabbed a towel off the warming rail and after shaking it out, he wrapped it around her body. Grabbing another one, he wrapped it around his waist before taking her hand in his and leading her out of the steamed up bathroom.

Haley expected him to leave her at her bedroom door but he didn’t. Instead, he pulled her past it and led her into his own room.

“Nathan?”

He didn’t answer her. Opening her towel, he proceeded to gently pat her body dry with it and she stared at him in awe.

“You’re so beautiful,” he finally told her and he watched her cheeks flush a rosy pink in what he assumed to be embarrassment at his compliment.

At that moment, she looked all of her nineteen years and he was reminded of the fact that he was five years older than her and while that didn’t necessarily sound like much of an age gap, he knew they were at different stages in their lives but he couldn’t be sorry about what had just happened between them.

“S-So are you,” she replied in a quiet voice. “I’ve always thought so.”

His fingers lightly brushed her collarbone as she stood before him, looking up at him with those beautiful rich chocolate brown eyes. “Is that so?” he teased.

She nodded shyly. “I’ve wanted to be with you for so long but I-I…”

“What?”

“I never thought I stood a chance. I’m so different to the women you normally date and…”

“Yeah, you are,” he said cutting her off. “But that’s a good thing. You’re so good… so innocent…”

“Not that innocent,” she chipped in, her blush deepening, as he chuckled.

“You’re innocent to me and I’ve always liked that about you.” Cupping her cheek in his palm, Nathan took a deep breath and finally admitted his true feelings to her. “I’ve always liked you, Haley. And I don’t just mean because you’re Luke’s little sister. I mean, I’ve always been attracted to you.”

Haley’s eyes widened at hearing him say that. “Are you serious?”

“Yeah, I am. I could never do anything about it before though because you were younger than me. That’s still true but…”

“But now it’s not illegal?”

Nathan smiled. “There is that but it was more that I didn’t know how you felt. There were times I got the feeling that you might have had a crush on me but I didn’t know for sure.”

“It started out as a crush,” she confessed. “But it’s so much more than that, Nathan. For the past three years you’re all I’ve been able to think about. I never thought I stood a chance though so that’s why I dated Ryan. He was a nice guy but deep down he knew I wasn’t…” she trailed off, not wanting to reveal more than she already had. Unfortunately for her, Nathan wasn’t about to give up.

“Wasn’t what?”

Taking the towel from his hands, Haley covered herself with it. “Nothing. Listen, I’m just gonna go and get dressed. I’m starting to feel cold and…”

He grabbed her wrist before she could move further away from him. “No, don’t go.” Satisfied that she wasn’t going to leave, he released her hand and going over to his closet, he removed a sweatshirt from it before walking back to her and handing the garment to her. In spite of how intimate they’d just been, he averted his eyes while she pulled it on over her head and slipped her arms through the sleeves. When he took in her appearance, he couldn’t get over how hot she looked wearing his clothes.

Taking a deep breath, Haley said, “I think we should just forget what just happened between us.”

“Is that what you want?” he asked, looking at her sharply. He couldn’t understand why she was suddenly saying this after what they’d just shared.

“I-I… I think it’s for the best,” she said before finally admitting, “I just don’t want to cause a problem between you and my brother.”

“You won’t. Look, I’m not going to lie and say that Luke won’t be pissed when he finds out about us but…”

“Wait! What are you suggesting?” she asked when his words filtered through to her brain.

Inching closer to her, he took her hands in his and rubbed his thumbs over her knuckles; bringing them up to his mouth and placing a kiss on each of them. “What happened in the shower… it meant something to me. It was more than just sex and…”

“Really?”

Grabbing a handful of her sweatshirt, he pulled her flush against him before banding his arms around her waist. “Yeah... I knew I’d be crossing a line but I didn’t care. I couldn’t stop myself from joining you in there and while I probably should be sorry I’m not. I… I’ll never be sorry.”

“Neither will I,” she told him as her arms twined around his neck. Leaning into him, she whispered shyly into his ear, “You were amazing.”

His lips curled up in a smirk and he rubbed his cheek against hers. “You were, too. You felt so tight around me… so hot...”

“Nathan!” Her cheeks flushed and she buried her face in his shoulder.

He laughed at her response but his voice was husky when he whispered, “I can’t wait to taste you.”

Haley felt herself become even wetter than she already was at hearing his words and his lust-filled voice was making her toes curl. She’d never had anyone do that to her and her body trembled with a mixture of nervousness and anticipation.

He noticed her body’s reaction and his embrace tightened. “Will it be your first time?”

“Um… yeah,” she replied shyly.

“We don’t have to, Haley. I’d never push you into anything, you know that.”

“I know and I want to do it… I want you to be my first for that, too.”

Nathan was just about to kiss her when her words registered and he froze. “What do you mean ‘for that too’?”

She mentally berated herself for having let that slip. Looking at him from under her lashes, she bit her lip before admitting, “In the, uh, shower when we…um…”

He sensed what she was struggling with so he cut in. “We made love, Hales.” The smile she gave him warmed his heart and he lowered his head and kissed her mouth softly.

“It was my first time. I-I’d never done that before with anyone.”

“But I thought you and…”

“No. Ryan and I didn’t do much more than kiss. The real reason I broke up with him was because he was spreading rumours about me having gone further than that with him. He kept pressuring me so I finally ended it. I was never in love with him and I think deep down he knew that.”

“Oh. I didn’t hurt you, did I?” He silently cursed himself for having pushed inside her so roughly.

She shook her head. “No, you didn’t.” Tilting her head back, she met his lips and they shared a sizzling kiss which quickly grew in intensity.

Before she knew it, he had stripped the sweatshirt off of her and thrown his own towel to the floor before carrying her over to his bed and gently laying her down upon it. His body blanketed hers and after drawing back from her, he peppered her face, neck and breasts with kisses before travelling lower and doing the same to her stomach, not missing the opportunity to take the end of her belly button jewellery into his mouth and gently tugging on it.

Haley was shivering with anticipation and looking down at him where his head rested between her thighs, she nervously waited for him to make his next move. The first swipe of his tongue along her slit had her hips raising up off the bed and she then felt his large hands holding them down, one of them sliding upwards to cup and knead her breast. As his wickedly talented tongue lapped at her sensitive flesh, she felt herself break out in a sweat as she grinded her lower body against his mouth. The way he was making her feel was indescribable and she lost count of the number of times he made her come just from using his mouth.

From his position, Nathan watched her sweat-slicked body rise and fall with each breath she took as she calmed down from her multiple orgasms and he couldn’t help smiling like the cat who’d caught the proverbial canary. Crawling up her body, he kissed each of her breasts in turn before covering her mouth with his and kissing her slow and deep. When she sucked on his tongue he felt his cock leap in response.

Panting into his mouth, Haley let her hands wander all over his body, savouring the feel of the hard muscles beneath his soft skin. Slipping a hand between them, she grasped his cock and placed it at her entrance, eager to have him fill her once again.

Nathan was just about to thrust inside again when he remembered something. “I’d better grab a condom, Haley. I know we were a little careless before and—”

“I’m on the Pill… for my cycle,” she interrupted.

Resting his weight on his forearms, he smiled down at her. “I should probably still…”

“No. I like… uh…”

“What?” he asked when she didn’t continue.

“I like feeling you… er… without anything between us.”

Ducking his head, he kissed her hungrily before pushing inside her in one hard stroke. His eyes were fixed on hers as he slid in and out of her. Her sharp little nipples were grazing his chest, creating a wonderful friction that complimented the feel of her tight sheath surrounding his cock like a wet velvet glove.

Haley’s hands wandered all over her Nathan’s shoulders and back before coming up to tangle and grip his hair. Tilting her hips up slightly, she felt him sink even further into her and she gasped at the sensation. The base of his cock grinding against her clit was sending her body soaring and it didn’t take long for the feeling to overwhelm her to the point of orgasm. Her legs tightened around him as she rode it out but when she felt him suddenly stiffen before coming inside her, it triggered off another strong climax which had her panting even harder.

Completely exhausted, Nathan collapsed on top of her before rolling onto his side and pulling her into his arms. Their breathing was laboured but after a little while it returned to some semblance of normal.

“I think we’re gonna need another shower,” she said a few moments later in a playful voice.

“Yeah, I think so, too. We need to let the hot water tank fill up again though so I think we’ve got time to, uh, play some more.”

Lifting her head from where it rested on his chest, she smiled up at him. “I think you’re right.”

“I’m always right.”

“Oh really? Were you right when you told Luke you thought me staying with you was a bad idea?”

“You know about that?” he asked, remembering the recent phone conversation he’d had with his best friend. “Okay fine, you got me there.” Tightening his arms around her waist, he looked into her eyes. “I was worried that I wouldn’t be able to keep my hands off of you, not that I told him that, of course.”

She giggled at that last part. “Mmm, you were definitely right about not being able to keep your hands off me.”

“I know. And I’m not going to be able to stop myself from doing it now we’ve been together.”

Sliding up his body, she kissed his lips. “Good because I know I’m not going to be able to stop either.”

They snuggled together in a comfortable silence until Haley could smell something. “Is that coffee I can smell?”

Nathan laughed. “Yeah. I put some on before I came into the bathroom.”

“I know you like it strong but I think even you might have trouble drinking that.”

Pushing away a stray lock of hair, he ran his thumb along her cheekbone. “Well, as long as I’ve got you, my little ray of sunshine, I’ve got a feeling I won’t be needing caffeine to jumpstart my day,” he teased.

Haley smiled at hearing those words and she kissed him again. “Glad to hear it ‘cause caffeine’s not good for you.”

His hands lightly stroked over her hips before giving her rump a little squeeze. “Just as well that you are good for me then ‘cause you’re one addiction I’m not giving up.”

They both laughed at his cheesy line but silently both knew they felt exactly the same way about each other and that this was just the beginning of something great for the both of them. They could only hope that their family and friends would see it the same way.

Fin

Send Feedback