First Time, First Love - Chapter Sixteen
Chapter Sixteen
Upon entering the room, Haley couldn’t help the small gasp that left her throat. The room was large and airy, decorated in cream and yellow, and from the large windows she could see a view of the beach. She turned and watched Nathan as he closed the door behind him and placed the bag he was carrying on the floor.
“So, what do you think?” he asked, biting the tip of his tongue nervously as he waited for her answer.
“It’s beautiful, Nathan.” Walking over to where he was standing, she wrapped her arms around his neck and hugged him before drawing back slightly so she could look into his face. Their eyes locked on each other, drinking each other in and ever so slowly they began inching closer together.
Sparks seemed to fly the instant their mouths touched and when her arms tightened around his neck, he wrapped his arms around her waist, pulling her even closer into him. They devoured each other and when the need for air become an issue, they drew back and after taking a few gulping breaths, Nathan latched onto the smooth skin of Haley’s neck. She couldn’t help the moans that tore through her throat as she relished in his sucking kisses. Her fingers tangled in his thick hair as she held him as close as she could.
As he kissed a path to the other side of her neck, Nathan’s hands cupped her ass and he pushed their lower bodies even closer together. While he didn’t want to rush things, he couldn’t help wanting more. The smell of her skin seemed to be intoxicating him and spurring him on. He remembered how good she smelled on the occasions they had been intimate before and he couldn’t believe she was back in his arms.
Releasing her grip on his hair, Haley brought her hands down between them and she quickly began unbuttoning his shirt. She couldn’t wait to feel his naked skin against hers after all this time. It had been so long since the last time they had been together.
“Hales... maybe we should wait and...”
“No! I don’t want to wait anymore, Nathan. We’ve waited long enough. I-I want to be with you... completely,” she said shyly.
“I want that, too. I guess I’m just worried we’re maybe moving too fast.”
“Fast? Before today we hadn’t kissed or touched each other in months.”
Taking her hand in his, he led her over to the bed and gestured for her to sit which she did. He followed suit and took a seat beside her. “That’s kinda my point. I want you to be sure that this is what you want.”
Looking into his eyes, she smiled. “I am sure. I couldn’t be more sure of anything.” Hesitating for a second, she asked, “You wanna know a secret?”
“Always,” he told her returning her smile.
Haley took a deep breath before making her confession. “I, um, I’ve been in love with you since I was 14 years old.” She watched his eyes widen with what she assumed to be surprise and her eyes lowered to look at their intertwined hands.
Staring at her incredulously for a moment, he placed his fingers under her chin and raised it so that she was once again looking into his face. “Are you serious?” She nodded before biting her bottom lip. “So, when you... uh...asked me for help that day...”
“I wasn’t totally lying,” she said interrupting. “I was nervous about starting college without any experience but... you were the only one I wanted to experience anything with. I’d known you for so long and I knew you would be the one person I’d feel most comfortable with and I was right.”
Nathan was speechless and he continued to stare at her. All those times he’d hung out with her since she was a kid and she had felt more than brotherly or friendly feelings for him. And then those times they were together just a while back... “I-I can’t believe it.”
Feeling the sting of tears, Haley tried to remove her hand from his but he wouldn’t let go. “Are you mad at me?” she whispered.
Pulling her onto his lap, he cuddled her close. “No, I’m not mad at you. Why would I be? It’s just a bit of a shock, that’s all. I wasn’t expecting you to tell me that. I wish I hadn’t been so blind as to not see it.”
“You weren’t blind. I just hid it really well. I’ve never told anybody how I felt... feel about you, not even Peyton or Brooke. I was so scared of you and Lucas finding out and making fun of me.”
Stroking a hand over her hair, he shook his head. “I would never have made fun of you,” he told her, bending his head to press a kiss to her forehead. Tilting her head back to look up at him, she covered his mouth with hers and kissed him softly.
Breaking the kiss, he took a couple of deep breaths before saying, “I have something to tell you, too.” Seeing the curious look in her eyes, he gave her a reassuring smile before he continued. “Remember that day at the beach house when things were getting out of hand and I stopped it going further?”
Haley nodded. “Yeah. I figured you didn’t want to do that with me and—”
“No! That wasn’t it at all. You don’t know how badly I wanted to make love to you that day but I didn’t think you were ready to go that far. And I figured that when you were ready, you wouldn’t want me to be your first.”
“Nathan...”
“I was starting to fall for you and... I-I thought you considered it just practice,” he admitted.
“Oh God. I told you it was practice just to get you to agree to help me but deep down in here,” she took his hand and placed it over her heart, “I always thought of everything we did as the real thing.” Placing her hands either side of his head, she directed his mouth back to hers. She sucked his bottom lip into her mouth before tugging on it. “I would have made love with you that day in a heartbeat.” Seizing his lips with hers again, she kissed him slow and deep.
The kiss quickly became passionate and somehow they found themselves in the center of the bed. Nathan was on his back and Haley was straddling his waist. Her hands moved down to finish unbuttoning his shirt and seeing his naked chest for the first time in a long while had her almost salivating, and she couldn’t resist lowering her head and planting hot, open-mouthed kisses all over it. Special attention was given to his nipples and she had them erect in no time at all.
As Haley concentrated on his chest, Nathan’s arms went around to her back and he lowered the zipper to her sundress, slipping the straps down her shoulders and arms. Stopping what she was doing, she sat up and pulled the dress up and over her head revealing what she was wearing underneath.
The pale pink lace bra and matching panties looked incredible against her lightly tanned skin and he was having trouble taking his eyes off her. “God... Hales, you look so beautiful.”
She blushed under his scrutiny and moving forward, she kissed him. He kissed her back and as he did so, he turned them over so that he was now on top. Breaking the kiss, he raised up on his forearms and looked into her rich chocolate brown eyes, taking a moment to really look at her. “I love you,” he told her and he watched as the smile broke out across her face.
“I love you, too,” she replied cupping his cheeks in her palms and pulling him down for another kiss.
Nathan couldn’t help groaning when he felt her legs wrap around his waist and her little feet digging into his ass pulled him in closer to the cradle of her groin. A second later he felt her lithe fingers on his belt buckle and she made quick work of unfastening it. Part of him felt like he should stop things before they got out of hand but another part of him didn’t want to and he remembered her words from earlier when she had said she couldn’t be more sure that this was what she wanted. He felt exactly the same way.
Haley couldn’t wait to touch him and as soon as she had popped the buttons on his button-fly jeans, her hand delved inside his boxers and wrapped around his cock. She moaned at the feel of his hot, throbbing flesh in her hand. Nathan’s breath was coming in pants as she stroked her hand up and down his length and moving her hand a little lower, she fondled his balls. As she worked him, she managed to get him to turn over so he was once again lying on his back.
Nathan’s eyes were narrow slits as he watched her over him and he reveled in the feel of what she was doing. He had almost forgotten how good she was at this and reaching out a hand, he brought it up to one of her breasts and massaged it.
She moaned, desperately wanting to feel him touching her naked skin. Keeping up her ministrations on him, she raised a hand to undo the front clasp of her bra but he stopped her.
“Let me do it,” he whispered huskily and she automatically nodded. A second later he had undone the clasp and the bra cups had fallen away. He immediately began kneading and massaging her breasts in turn and the deep sigh she released made him smirk. She wiped that off his face a moment later when she gently raked her fingernails over his balls as she began pumping him faster. The precum was oozing from the tip and she gathered that and used it to slicken his shaft, making her hand glide over him that little bit faster.
He couldn’t help closing his eyes as the sensations built up and he could feel his climax fast approaching. It had been so long since he had been with someone and he still couldn’t believe that he was finally with the one person he’d been dreaming about for months. His eyes shot open when he felt a wet warmth on his cock and looking down, he saw her lips suckling on the tip. Her eyes were on his as she watched him watching her and that sent an added thrill through his body. Her mouth swallowed him deeper and the sensation of her throat muscles working him had him even closer to the edge.
Nathan’s hands clenched and unclenched the bedding as Haley’s oral assault continued and the hand which had been pumping him was now caressing his lower stomach. The gentle caress she was bestowing upon him was in stark contrast to the feel of her hot mouth sucking on him. The second she grazed her teeth along his shaft on the upstroke had him spilling into her mouth with a loud yell and the feel of her throat contracting as she swallowed his seed had him moaning incoherently.
After licking him clean, Haley rested the side of her head on his stomach as one of her hands continued to stroke the fine trail of hair there. Slowly, she calmed down and let her breathing return to normal before crawling up his body, planting kisses on his stomach and chest along the way.
One of his hands caressed over her back and shoulders and once her face was above his, he wrapped a hand around the back of her neck, under her hair, and pulled her down on top of him. She moaned into his mouth as she kissed him thoroughly and shared his taste with him. This seemed to jumpstart his heart. He could feel it thumping wildly in his chest and running his hands up her body, he removed the bra that was still hanging open from her shoulders.
Her body was pressed flush against his and her face was buried in his neck where she was licking the skin there.
“You wanna get my jeans and boxers off the rest of the way?” he asked with a chuckle. He couldn’t believe that she’d gotten him off while they were bunched around his knees.
Pausing in her ministrations, Haley looked at his smirking face and she grinned at him. “Guess I got a little carried away, huh?”
“I ain’t complaining,” he told her raising up slightly to drop a kiss onto the tip of her nose. “Do you see me complaining?”
Shaking her head, she giggled and replied, “No.” Moving off him, she reared up on her knees and started pulling his jeans and underwear down. Untying the laces on his shoes, she pulled them off before removing the garments the rest of the way and throwing them to the floor. Before she had a chance to get back into her original position though, Nathan quickly moved and grabbed her, flipping them over so she was on the bottom and he was straddling her waist.
“Nathan!”
Leaning forward, he placed his hands either side of her head and just looked at her. He couldn’t seem to take his eyes off her and he didn’t want to. Her hair was fanned out over the pillows and her skin was flushed pink. Lowering himself down, he covered her mouth with his own and kissed her softly, his tongue coming out to gently part her lips.
Haley brought her arms up and removed Nathan’s shirt which she had forgotten to do earlier, too eager to touch and kiss him when his chest had come into view. Breaking the kiss for a moment, he sat up and practically ripped the shirt off and threw it to the side.
“Impatient, are we?” she teased.
“Yeah, you got a problem with that?” he teased back, his lips curling up in a half-smile.
“No,” she replied and wrapped her arms around his waist to pull him forward.
They started kissing again but before it got too intense Nathan started travelling down her body, planting kisses down her throat, her neck and then to her shoulders. As he did so, one of his hands came up to cup and knead her breasts. He shifted his position so he was lying in the space between her legs and giving her another heated look, he bent his head to her right breast and sucked as much of the flesh into his mouth as he could. His hand continued to play with her other breast, his thumb and forefinger pinching her nipple.
Haley’s fingers gripped his hair as he lavished his undivided attention on her and the feel of his hot mouth sucking, kissing and licking on her sensitive flesh had her moaning loudly. She had missed this so much while they were apart and the erotic dreams she’d had of him hadn’t compared in the slightest. His erection was rubbing against one of her thighs and she was desperate to find out how it would feel deep inside her.
When he came up for air and to switch to her other breast, she felt the cool air on her wet skin and she nearly cooed when he covered it with his large, slightly calloused hand and started massaging it. The sensation of him plucking at her nipple went straight to her clit and she ached for his fingers to finally touch her there.
“Oh... oh Nathan... pleeease...” she begged as the glorious feelings continued.
He didn’t stop what he was doing but he did look up at her from his position and the blatant lust in his eyes gave her butterflies in her stomach. Knowing that he wasn’t done with the task in hand, she removed one of her hands from his hair and placed it over his hand which was on her breast. Taking it in hers, she trailed their hands down her body and showed him what she wanted.
Together, they stroked her through her panties and her moans increased in volume. He was gently biting her nipple as he worked her and while he did so, he kept his eyes trained on her. The colour of her eyes was darkening as she got closer and closer to her peak and it was turning him on even more.
Releasing her nipple with a pop, he moved up her body quickly and took her mouth in a deep, sucking kiss before once again kissing his way downwards. Reaching her stomach, he tongued her belly button which made her giggle and he did it again just so he could hear that tuneful sound once more. Continuing on his travels, he moved further down until his face was hovering over her panty covered sex and he kissed her mound through her underwear.
Haley was biting her bottom lip in anticipation of what was going to happen next and without being aware of it, she was also holding her breath. When he looked up at her with the silent question she nodded without a second thought and a moment later, he had hooked his thumbs into the sides of her panties and was easing them down her hips. As soon as they were off, he spread her legs and looked at her for a couple of seconds before slowly lowering his head and taking his first taste of her.
Gasping at the sudden sensation, she closed her eyes as she savoured the feel of his tongue and lips kissing and licking her. God, it felt so good and even better than she remembered from the last time he’d done it. Maybe it had something to do with the fact that she now knew he was in love with her. She found herself raising her hips and grinding against his face and raising one of her arms behind her, she gripped the bars of the headboard to aid her. Her other hand tangled in his hair as she tried to get him even closer to where she needed him.
Nathan crawled up the bed slightly as he was pleasuring her and without missing a beat, he managed to hook her legs over his forearms which tilted her further backwards so he was as close as he could possibly get. He licked her with broad strokes from bottom to the top and reaching the top, he sucked her clit into his mouth and nibbled it with his teeth.
Haley was nearly sobbing with pleasure. Her moans and shrieks were getting louder and louder as she felt the first tingles of her orgasm swirling in the pit of her stomach. As soon as he thrust one of his long fingers inside her she came all over his mouth and when he added two more fingers and hooked them to stroke over her g-spot, she came again.
As he licked up her juices, Nathan glanced up so he could watch her and he couldn’t help smiling at how beautiful she looked. Her shoulders and breasts were infused with colour and there was a fine sheen of sweat over her, too. All in all it looked like she was glowing and he couldn’t help feeling proud that he was the one responsible for her looking that way.
His cock felt like it was going to explode and he rubbed it against the bed to try and relieve the pressure before slowly crawling up her body. She watched him with wide eyes as he looked down at her. They smiled at each other before he laid on top of her, his weight pressing her further into the mattress. Haley sighed at the feeling, again remembering how it had felt months before when it had first happened.
“I missed this so much,” Nathan whispered into her ear before nibbling on the lobe. “I missed you so much.”
She shivered at the feeling of his hot breath blowing into her ear and her arms came up to hold him tightly against her. “Me too,” she replied.
Feeling his throbbing length touching her entrance had her rubbing herself against it and she kept her eyes open to look into Nathan’s face as she did so and he groaned at the feeling of his slickened flesh sliding against hers.
“I want to feel you inside me,” she mumbled against his lips before kissing him passionately. “Y-you feel so good... so hard...”
“I want that, too, Haley. You don’t know how much.”
“Yes I do.” Capturing his bottom lip between her teeth, she tugged on it before releasing it to ask, “Did you bring any... um... condoms?”
Kissing her again, he nodded. “Yeah, they’re in my bag.”
Raking her nails up and down his back, she grinned at him. “Well you’d better get your gorgeous ass over there and grab them, hadn’t you?”
“Yes, Ma’am,” he replied before getting up and walking over to where he’d left the bag.
While he did that, Haley pulled the covers back on the bed and got underneath them. “So what else is in that bag?” she queried.
“Just a few bits and pieces I thought we’d need,” he replied vaguely.
Turning around and walking back to the bed, he stopped when he saw her covered up. “What’s the matter? Why did you get under the covers?”
She blushed and shook her head. “I just felt a bit cold,” she lied. In truth, she felt a little strange being totally naked in front of him despite what they’d just done together.
Going over to her, he sat beside her and cupped her cheek in his palm. “You’re beautiful, Haley, and you have nothing to be embarrassed about. I like seeing you naked and knowing that I’m the only one who gets to do that.” Taking the corner of the covers in his fingers, he asked her a silent question and when she slowly nodded, he pulled the covers off the bed and threw them to the floor. Leaning over her, he kissed her softly and let her take the lead. It wasn’t long before she was moving to kneel beside him and he helped get her into a position where she was straddling him as he sat on the edge of the bed.
His arms held her tightly to him as he felt her warm body rocking against his. The anticipation of what was going to happen next was almost making his head spin and he couldn’t wait. He had been waiting for this to happen for such a long time and he wanted it to be perfect... for both of them.