First Time, First Love - Chapter Six
Chapter Six
Groaning at what he had just heard her say, Nathan’s first instinct was to start shaking his head no. This whole situation was beginning to get out of hand and things were moving so fast. But as he thought that, he couldn’t seem to lose the feeling that while they were moving fast, what they were doing also felt right. He was so hard and he was desperate for some relief but the question was, could he let her do this for him?
Haley watched the conflicting emotions flash across his face and she realised that she probably shouldn’t have said anything. Determined not to let her nerves get the better of her, she said, “I want to do this, Nathan. If we stop now it’ll feel forced when we’re next able to meet up, whenever that will actually be. Besides, I thought we agreed that this feels natural.”
He was still hovering over her but then he rolled onto his back and stared up at the ceiling. “We did but... it just feels too soon. You asked me to help you on Friday and it’s only Sunday now, and now you’re offering to... what exactly are you offering to do?”
She could practically feel herself blushing. “I, uh, don’t know. I haven’t exactly been in this position before.”
“That’s what I mean, Hales. If you were in an actual relationship I don’t think you’d be moving this fast so soon.”
“But I’m not in a relationship and that’s the whole point of this. I don’t want to find myself in this position with a guy and not know what to do or say. I thought you were finally okay about helping me.”
“I am. I meant what I said before.”
“Then we can continue now?” She asked, her voice hopeful and Nathan found himself slowly nodding. Turning onto her side and propping herself up on one elbow, she asked, “Why don’t we start by you showing me what you... um... do in this situation?”
His eyes closed at the image that suddenly popped into his head but they flew open when he felt her small hand touching him through his jeans and a low growl resonated from his throat.
“God! Haley...”
“What?” she asked innocently.
Searching the rich chocolate pools of her eyes, he saw them sparkle with mischief and suddenly he realised that although this was the same girl he had practically grown up with, she was also a beautiful young woman determined to learn about sex. Not only that, she was offering to help him as much as he was going to be helping her so who was he to refuse?
“You know things will never be the same between us after this, don’t you?” he warned, wanting her to be absolutely clear on the implications of what they were about to do.
“I know, Nathan. I’m not about to let this ruin our friendship,” she said seriously.
“Good, because that’s the last thing I want to happen either.”
Haley grinned at him and leaning forward she kissed his cheek noisily. She shrieked when he suddenly pushed her over onto her back and covered her with his body, his hands tickling her sides. “Nooo, stop it! You... oh God... you know I h-hate being tickled...”
“Do I?” he teased. “I must have forgotten.”
“Stop! Please Nathan... nooo!”
Ceasing the tickle torture, Nathan shifted down the bed a little and ran his hands over her waist, soothing the areas where he had tickled her. As he glanced up at her face, he saw her eyes darken even more and her tongue slip out to moisten her lips. Not able to resist, he quickly scooted up and covered her lips with his, kissing her softly. As he savoured the closeness of their bodies, he felt her arms come up and wrap around his neck before she pulled him down on top of her. He didn’t know how she did it but the next thing he knew she had managed to flip them over so she was now straddling his waist.
Breaking the kiss, he gave her a smirk before asking, “How the hell did you do that?”
“I’ll have you know, Mr Scott, that I’m surprisingly strong,” she replied laughing softly at his question. Without thinking, she lowered herself to rest on his thighs and she gasped when she came into direct contact with his erection and she quickly moved up again.
“Oh God... Haley!” Her name left his lips in a husky, lust-filled moan at the sudden contact. His heart was thumping wildly and he could almost feel the blood rushing throughout his body. For the first time in his life, he was feeling totally and utterly out of control. He knew that their present position was too much of a temptation for him so he maneuvered them so that she was once again laying beside him. He couldn’t seem to take his eyes off her; her skin was lightly flushed, her rosy nipples were hard and begging for his attention, and her lips were swollen from their kisses.
“Nathan? Are you okay?” she asked, concerned at his silence.
“Yeah,” he said smiling down at her. “Just taking a moment.”
She smiled back at him before asking, “So, uh, what should I do?”
“We could... um... get undressed but only if you feel completely comfortable doing that.”
Hesitating for a second, Haley finally nodded yes as she moved her fingers between them to the zipper at the side of her skirt. She was just about to slide it down when Nathan’s hand covered hers.
“Wait, let me do it.”
Her heart sped up at his words and once again she nodded. “Okay.” Her hand moved to rest on the back of his as she felt him slide the zipper downwards. She felt a little jittery when she saw him move off her slightly so that he could begin sliding the denim down her hips but she forced herself to keep her eyes on his face as he completed the task, dropping her skirt to the floor afterwards.
If Nathan wasn’t able to take his eyes off her before, he was having even more difficulty now as she lay before him in only a pair of white silk and lace panties. The colour contrasted nicely with her lightly tanned skin and the style suited her perfectly. He could see that she was feeling self-conscious as she lay there on her bed in just her underwear and so he gave her what he hoped was a reassuring smile as his fingers moved to the button of his jeans. When she moved into a sitting position and placed her hands over his, he was the one that felt reassured that he wasn’t pushing her to do something she wasn’t ready for.
Haley made quick work of unfastening his button fly jeans and seeing his black boxers come into view made her heart rate increase that little bit more. Within seconds they were both down to their underwear, Nathan’s socks having been toed off after his jeans were discarded. She couldn’t help but marvel at how much he had filled out since she had last seen him in his swimming trunks the previous summer.
He was still lean but now his muscles were more defined and he just seemed to have this strength about him which was making her feel weak in the knees. Her mouth was watering so much, she was sure she’d need to check for drool in a second.
They were both kneeling on the bed in front of each other and very gently, Nathan lowered them both so that she was on her back with him hovering over her. He was resting his weight on his forearms and he simply just drank her in before lowering his head to take her lips in a long, passionate kiss. Parting her lips with his tongue, he let it slide inside and stroke against hers before withdrawing. He smiled against her mouth when she did what he had been hoping for and did the same thing to him with her tongue.
When the need for air became an issue, they broke apart and he buried his face into the nook between her neck and shoulder, breathing in her unique scent. He desperately wanted to mark the tender skin but he knew he couldn’t, that it would raise too many questions particularly as they had the family dinner at his place later. There was no need to raise anyone’s suspicions unnecessarily.
Haley was moaning at the feel of Nathan’s lips and tongue worrying her flesh and without realising what she was doing, she found herself hooking a leg over his hip and stroking it up and down. It was her turn to smile when he groaned against her skin, obviously enjoying what she was doing.
Once again, he knew they were veering into dangerous territory so he flipped them over so that she was now draped all over him. He couldn’t help laughing at the loud gasp she released at his sudden movement. The laughter died in his throat though when he felt her hand take a firm hold of his throbbing erection through his boxers.
“Is that okay?” she whispered breathlessly as she looked deep into his eyes.
The only response he could give was to nod as he felt her stroke him slowly. He would give anything to be able to feel her skin on his without any barriers and as soon as that thought popped into his head, he felt her hand slip through the gap at the front of his boxers and he gasped with pleasure at the sensation of her silky, soft skin sliding up and down his own. If he didn’t know better, he would have sworn she had done this before.
Without removing her hand from him, Haley managed to raise up onto her knees and licking her lips slowly, she gestured to his boxers and asked, “Can I... um... take them off?”
He didn’t hesitate for a second and nodded eagerly as his hands clenched and unclenched the fabric of her comforter. When her hand released him so she could pull his underwear off, he groaned at the loss of her warmth. As soon as they were off, he saw her toss them to the floor to accompany their previously discarded clothing.
Haley stared at his hardened length for a moment or two and, as if she was in a trance, she found herself reaching out a hand to touch it like she had before except this time there would be no restrictions.
Nathan’s breathing was laboured as through heavy lidded eyes he watched her hand move up and down at a torturously slow pace before circling the head and spreading the moisture that had gathered there. “H-Haley... oh God... faster... please... do it faster...” he pleaded.
His words put her mind at ease and she realised that what she was doing felt good to him and so she did as he asked. As her hand moved faster, she kept her eyes focused on his face and watched as it contorted in pleasure.
Stroke by delicious stroke, the pressure was building for Nathan and he didn’t know how much longer he would be able to last. His hold on the sheets became tighter and he thought he heard himself yell as she alternated between stroking him and fondling his balls. All thoughts left his mind as he concentrated on the feel of her slick hand moving back and forth and he couldn’t help closing his eyes as the sensation became too much for him. With a final shout of her name, he came all over her hand. His breathing was ragged and he took deep breaths to calm his racing heart. Opening his eyes slowly, he was greeted by the sight of Haley licking her fingers as she watched him. Despite having just climaxed, he felt himself harden again at her actions. He made to sit up but she quickly placed a hand on his chest preventing him from moving.
“Uh, where are you going?” she asked nervously.
“Nowhere,” he told her honestly. “Except I was just gonna go to the bathroom and, um, get cleaned up.”
“Oh, okay,” she replied before adding shyly, “I could do that... if you want me to, I mean.”
“Hales, you don’t have to do that.”
“Yeah, I know but I... um... want to.”
He finally nodded his consent and feeling her shift on the bed, he expected her to lean over him to grab some tissues from the box that he’d seen on her nightstand but instead, she shifted further down in the bed and tossing her long auburn hair to one side, she bent down and licked the tip of his shaft.
Instinctively, one of Nathan’s hands went back to gripping the comforter while his other hand rested on the back of Haley’s head as she used her tongue to circle the head of his cock. “Wh-what are... oh God... Haley... what are you doing?” he finally choked out.
From her position, she raised her eyes to his before releasing him from her mouth. “I just thought it... uh... best to keep going, I mean keep the lesson going. Don’t you want to?” While she anxiously waited for him to reply, she kept up a slow pumping motion which made him stiffen even more. After a few moments had passed and he still hadn’t answered, she removed her hand from and said, “I guess that’s my answer then.”
Before she had a chance to move too far away, Nathan quickly sat up and grabbed her hand. “What? No, I’m sorry. I do want to continue. Don’t go... please.” Placing his fingers under her chin, he raised her face to his and gave her a smile. “This whole thing’s just... it’s pretty confusing, you know. What you were doing felt so good but then I felt guilty for feeling that way. I mean, you’re like my little sister.”
She sighed as she rubbed her thumb back and forth across the knuckles of his hand which was still in hers. “I thought we’d already dealt with that stuff earlier. If this is too weird, then we can stop...”
“See, that’s the thing, Haley. It should feel weird but it... it doesn’t,” he admitted. “But I still think we’re going too fast too soon.”
Haley couldn’t help smiling at Nathan’s comment about it not feeling weird for him. “It doesn’t feel weird to me either. If things are moving too fast for you, what do you suggest we do?” she asked.
He thought about it for a minute or two before he replied, “Well, sex isn’t just about what you do to the other person. It’s also about receiving pleasure as well as giving it so how about I show you how good you made me feel?” Her body spiked up a few more degrees at the lustful look he was giving her. She nodded yes and he couldn’t help smirking at the way she shivered in what he took to be a mixture of nerves and anticipation. Pulling her as close as possible, he reached up and cupped her cheek in his palm before drawing her in for a kiss which started out soft and sweet but soon turned hot and passionate.
As Nathan laid back amongst the pillows, Haley followed him without breaking the kiss and, once again, she found herself straddling his waist. He wound his fingers in her hair, holding her face to his as he devoured her lips while his other hand palmed one of her breasts.
Regretfully, she broke the kiss so that she could breathe in some air and she rested her forehead against his as he continued to touch her. “Nathan...” she whispered as her hands gripped his shoulders.
“Uh huh?” he whispered back, just as breathless as she was.
“This feels really good.”
“I know.” The hand he was using to tease her nipples dropped to stroke her through her panties and he watched as her eyes shuttered closed and her mouth formed a perfect ‘o’. Leaning forward, his tongue traced the outline of her lips and it wasn’t long before her tongue came out to join with his. Bending his head, he circled a nipple with his tongue before sucking it between his lips and then using his teeth to graze it. The response he got from Haley was such that he repeated the action a couple more times on the same breast before switching to the other.
The fingernails of one of her hands raked across his scalp as she held him in place. Her free hand joined his which was still caressing her through the silk and lace of her underwear. He was driving her mad with longing and she desperately wanted to feel his fingers on her bare flesh. Without thinking about it, she pulled the fabric aside and released a long drawn out moan at the first contact of his skin on her lower lips.
Feeling that first contact had Nathan stopping what he was doing with her breasts and looking up at her, he groaned at the intense look of concentration on her face as he intimately stroked her. She opened her eyes at that moment and watched him watching her and she smiled at him. Taking the hand he was stroking her with in hers, she placed his fingers at her entrance and he knew what she was silently asking him for. He hesitated for a brief moment before he slowly inserted two of his fingers into her moist passage and gently moved them in and out.
“Oh... oh God... yesss...”
Smiling at the knowledge that he was the one responsible for her feeling this way, he asked huskily, “Does that feel good, Haley?”
She nodded frantically before starting to move herself on his fingers. “Oh god... I... I need... uh...”
“What, baby? What do you need?” He couldn’t take his eyes off her face as it contorted with pleasure and he was unable to stifle his response when she answered.
“I need more...”