2003 FRQ #1
Post date: Dec 03, 2013 9:14:10 PM
The following poems are both concerned with Eros, the god of love in Greek mythology. Read the poems carefully. Then write an essay in which you compare and contrast the two concepts of Eros and analyze the techniques used to create them.
EPQE1
Eros
I call for love
But help me, who arrives?
This thug with broken nose
And squinty eyes.
5 ‘Eros, my bully boy,
Can this be you,
With boxer lips
And patchy wings askew?’
Why hast thou nothing in thy face?
Thou idol of the human race,
Thou tyrant of the human heart,
The flower of lovely youth that art;
5 Yea, and that standest in thy youth
An image of eternal Truth,
With thy exuberant flesh so fair,
That only Pheidias2 might compare,
Ere from his chaste marmoreal3 form
10 Time had decayed the colours warm;
Like to his gods in thy proud dress,
Thy starry sheen of nakedness.
Surely thy body is thy mind,
For in thy face is nought to find,
15 Only thy soft unchristen’d smile,
That shadows neither love nor guile,
But shameless will and power immense,
In secret sensuous innocence.
O king of joy, what is thy thought?
20 I dream thou knowest it is nought,
And wouldst in darkness come, but thou
Makest the light where’er thou go.
Ah yet no victim of thy grace,
None who e’er long’d for thy embrace,
25 Hath cared to look upon thy face.
—Robert Bridges (1899)
‘Madam,’ cries Eros,
10 ‘Know the brute you see
Is what long overuse
Has made of me.
My face that so offends you
Is the sum
15 Of blows your lust delivered
One by one.
We slaves who are immortal
Gloss your fate
And are the archetypes
20 That you create.
Better my battered visage,
Bruised but hot,
Than love dissolved in loss
Or left to rot.’
--Anne Stevenson (1990)
1 Eros (in Greek)
2 Greek sculptor of the fifth century B.C.
3 marble