Goats

Wild Goats vs Feral Goats

Wild goats were the original ancestors of modern domesticate goats, and they still serve important functions in the ecosystems where they evolved. 

Feral goats are goats who (either themselves or their ancestors) were domesticated goats who either got loose or were released into the wild. Since they are invasive in those environments, they cause catastrophic damage to these unique ecosystems.

Problems of Goats Farming

Environmental Impacts

Emissions

Biodiversity Loss

Goats, along with sheep and cattle which have been released into new habitats such as the Hawaiian Islands have caused devastating losses in biodiversity.

Most of this destruction is driven by the animals' apatite for vegetation, tearing bark of trees and eating plants down to the root. Once those plants die off, the species that rely on them for survival soon follow after. Over time, lush forests and grasslands turn bare, even suffering from erosion which can lead to dangerous land slides in hilly regions.

In addition to eating or starving out various species, predators are often targeted by farmers, hunters, and even government agencies to "protect" livestock including goats and their kids. Unfortunately hunting predators has been scientifically proven to be problematic on many levels, causing issues including:

The following species have suffered terrible losses to the sheep farming industry and illegal persecution from farmers:

Birds of Prey including eagles and vultures.

Some species are already extinct, while others still face illegal persecution from farmers.

Carnivores including the Sicilian Wolves were hunted to extinction because of farmer's fear of them hurting their goats.

Frogs including Australia's Creek Frogs

Trees including Hawaii's Māmane 

Goats vs Trees


Soil Health & Erosion

Livestock, their hooves, their habits, and their manure all have a variety of impacts on our soil. 

Water Use & Pollution

Safety of Goat Products

Milk

Prions can be passed from infected animals to other animals or humans, via the consumption of milk. Prions are damaged neurons which act like "zombies" in that they damage and infect healthy brain cells even after their own death. This causes more healthy cells to become damaged and go on to infect more. Prions are famous for causing mad cow disease outbreaks which (when they infect a human) become "a human form of mad cow disease called variant Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (vCJD), which is fatal. Over time, vCJD destroys the brain and spinal cord." - My Health Alberta

"Surprisingly, pasteurisation (heating for 30 seconds to 72°C) and ultra-high temperature treatment (heating for 1–4 seconds to 135°C) only leads to a partial reduction of the amount of PrPC. This supports the observation that PrPC is highly stable in milk. Thus, the heating procedures used to inactivate DNA-containing pathogens are not sufficient to eliminate endogenous prion proteins." - NCBI: Prion Protein in Milke 

Dangerous Goat Dip Chemicals

Affects of Goat Dip Chemicals on Humans

Affects of Goat Dip Chemicals on Animals


Goat Dip Residue's Impacts on Crops


Organochlorine Residues in Animal Products

"Organochlorine pesticides accumulate in the fat of animals and their concentration in body fat can be much greater than in soil. Organochlorine pesticides are slowly excreted and are broken down very gradually in animal livers. It can take several months for the concentration of organochlorine pesticides in an animal’s fat to reduce by half once the animal is no longer being exposed to organochlorine pesticides. Organochlorine pesticides can also accumulate in wool and lanolin, and milk. Animals are exposed to organochlorine No. 2 Sheep Dip Factsheet ORGANOCHLORINE PESTICIDES 01 Swim through dip Source: Tasman District Council pesticides through soil ingestion (including soil attached to grass roots), by drinking contaminated water and to a lesser extent through feed and contaminated dust. Sheep eat an estimated 125 g of soil per day and cows about 1kg. Wet muddy conditions, short pasture, feeding out of hay and silage, and consumption of fodder crops such as turnips and chowmollier can increase the amount of soil eaten by stock. Where residues are present, animals that dig or disturb the soil, including pigs, chickens and bulls, will have increased exposure to organochlorine pesticides. There are regulatory limits under organochlorine pesticides (Maximum Residue Limits or MRLs) in animal products, including meat, fat, milk, offal, poultry and eggs. Organochlorine residues in animal products are a risk to local and international trade and farmers can be prosecuted if organochlorine residues exceed regulatory limits. In 1987 Australian meat exports to the United States and Japan were banned because of detections of organochlorine residues in meat. The Australian ‘Beef Crisis’ cost millions of dollars in lost product, and on-farm management practices for organochlorines remain in place today. In 2007 NZ beef exports to Korea were suspended when endosulfan (a newer organochlorine insecticide licensed for use on plants) was detected in a consignment of beef." - Sheep Dip Factsheet (PDF)

Welfare

Goat & Kid Welfare

Goats are prey animals who become easily stressed when chased or captured. This includes being stalked by herding dogs or grabbed by farm workers for medical care or sheering.

Wool Harvesting

Sheering accidents are common, especially in the corporately-owned facilities where poor workers are forced to work as fast as possible, resulting in bloody, or even deadly cuts for the sheep. Workers also suffer from injuries, which can put them at risk of disease, infection, or even loss of limbs.

Welfare

Animal Welfare

Worker Welfare

"Some known problems include workplace health and safety, sweatshops and child labor, gender inequality, inadequate pay, wage theft and exploitation. Workers can even experience harassment, humiliation and violence. Unfair employers often fail to provide laborers with access to shade, drinking water, restrooms and breaks.

Consequently, laborers can face nausea, dizziness, heat exhaustion, dehydration and heat stroke -the leading cause of farmworker death! 

Such mistreatment is like modern day slavery. Workers are often afraid to report issues because they fear it will result in losing their jobs or deportation." - HEALable: Wool

Solutions

Buy & Produce Alternatives

Consumers

Scroll down on the Personal Care & Hygiene page to find apps and lists of products that avoid animal products such as lanolin.

Protect Water Quality

The best way to protect our water supply is to stop wasting and polluting so much water with our growing meat and dairy industries, but the next best options are listed beneath.

Riparian Borders

Farmers with livestock can help protect waterways by protecting or restoring riparian zones around waterways. This will help keep dangerous chemicals, as well as bacteria and viruses from fecal matter from getting into the local water supply.

Planting Fields with Hedges & Trees

Providing vegetative cover for livestock such as cattle and goats helps protect them from harsh weather, including the hot sun which can in turn reduce water requirements and stress for the animals. Hedgerows have been shown to reduce erosion from wind and rain, which in turn keeps nutrients inside the boundaries of the land, and in turn helps protect the local water quality.

Welfare

Animal Welfare

Worker Welfare

"Fair trade organizations fight to ensure better social, environmental and economic standards. 

We can improve people’s lives simply by being mindful to buy items that are certified fair trade." - HEALable: Wool

Resources

Production Impacts

The following resources explain the environmental, humanitarian, and animal welfare impacts of products and practices including skins, wool, as well as the use of "sheep dip".

Tools & Apps