Chalk Reefs

Introduction

Definition

Chalk reefs are a subtype of rocky reef. Rocky reefs are created when rocky outcrops (including limestone and chalk) crumble into the sea, providing safe nooks, crannies, and valleys for ocean life to attach or hide. 

Rarity

"57% of coastal chalk in Europe is found in UK waters, which amounts to just 0.6% of our coastal habitat, making this an internationally important site for protection." - The Chalk Reefs of Cromer Shoal 

Strongholds for Biodiversity

"Chalk beds are important because their cracks and crevices provide refuge for wildlife, especially juvenile invertebrates and fish. It is also a source of substrates for burrowing organisms." - Chalk Bed Marine Conservation

Norfolk’s Chalk Reef

11:07 minute video about this extremely rare type of reef including the species who live there.

Subtypes of Chalk Reefs

Bubbling Reefs

"Bubbling reefs are formed by prolonged leaking of methane gasses from deep deposits (Jensen et al, 1992). The reef structures are formed in the near-surface sediment layer in a chemical process binding chalk to the sediment in an oxygenated sediment environment along the gas-seeping channels. Large bubbling reefs have caves and overhangs hosting communities dominated by hard bottom fauna on shady parts that are not found at the same water depth on nearby boulder reefs. Bubbling reefs in Kattegat are often located on sandy bottoms and thus significantly increase the complexity of these habitats.

The appearance of the reef structures above the seabed is due to erosional processes likely over very long time-scales. The structures are fragile and very sensitive to physical disturbance." - Ecologically or Biologically Significant Areas (EBSAs): Danish Kattegat

Chalk Flats

Instead of large pieces of chalk, these are flattened places made from chalk, which also allow wildlife colinization, including worms who burrow into the sediment.

Geography & Biology of Chalk Beds

"Cromer Shoal Chalk Beds MCZ supports a diverse range of habitats and species, within a relatively small area. Different habitats are not spread evenly across the MCZ. For example, chalk seabed typically gets more irregular with increasing distance from shore. Chalky seabeds supported much greater diversity than did clay seabeds. Seabeds with an irregular surface (eg with gullies and cobbles) supported more biodiversity than did less complex habitats." - Seasearch: Cromer Shoal Chalk Beds MCZ Report

Dangers to Chalk Beds & Chalk Reefs


Ocean Acidification

This poses an increasing danger to many ocean habitats, but perhaps especially chalk reefs, which are already extremely rare.

"Currently, new anecdotal evidence shows that there may be impacts on chalk habitats from some fishing activities after all. But given the rarity of this habitat, we still need more evidence to improve our understanding." - Chalk Bed Marine Conservation

Commercial Fishing & Shellfish Hunting

Fishing and dredging have damaged these delicate eco systems. Abandoned fishing gear or "ghost gear" has also been found in these reefs.

Lobster & Crab Potting

These areas have been fished for hundreds of years, but modern equipment is harming these reefs.

Beach Combers

A growing number of people  are comming down to beaches in huge groups to fill builder's buckets with shellfish, damaging the coastline itself, and destabilizing the ecosystem by removing massive numbers of creatures from the marine food web.

Energy Production

Natural Gas

Natural gas fields are close to some of the UK's known chalk reefs.

Offshore Wind

According to the PDF, Vattenfall Wind Power Ltd Thanet Extension Offshore Wind Farm, there would be a chance of temporary habitat loss or disturbance while laying the electric cable for the wind farm, and possibly again for maintenance. The threat was considered low.

Sheringham Shoal and Dudgeon Offshore Wind Farm Extension Projects PDF states that "Cromer Shoal Chalk Beds MCZ is unique and protects features rare within English waters. Cabling could cause damage and loss of habitat within the MCZ which could put the conservation status of the MCZ at risk. The impacts from cabling are twofold. Firstly, the siting of the cable in the wrong location, such as in the chalk reef area, would cause irreparable damage to this habitat. Secondly, due to the location of chalk bedrock along the north Norfolk coast, cable burial may be difficult or impossible in some locations, increasing the need for rock protection. This would result in a loss of habitat. In addition, repeated cable burial works due to cable burial failure during the lifetime of the project could result in disturbance and damage to habitats within the MCZ." The document then discussed mitigation and plans to avoid damage to the reefs.

Oil Industry

Oil spills are considered a big threat due to the proximity of major shipping lanes.

Boating & Tourism

Ship Wrecks & Illicit Wreck Diving

"Illicit wreck diving on the fragile chalk reefs causing damage to the marine ecosystem, as well as impacts on the maritime archaeology associated with the wrecks." - Kent: Dover Strait Seascape Character Assessment (PDF) 

Anchors are also a threat due to the delicacy of the calk and organisms living on the reefs.

Invasive Species

These have been outcompeting native species. Scroll down for a list of identified invasives.

Toxic Contaminants

"The deterioration of waters quality by pollutants and nutrients has caused respectively the replacement of fucoid dominated biotopes by mussel-dominated biotopes, and the occurrence of nuisance Enteromorpha spp. blooms..." - UK BAP Priority Habitat Descriptions 

Solutions

Continued & Improved Monitoring

"Natural England, as a statutory conservation agency, is obliged to monitor the marine environment, and to assess the condition of protected species and habitats. Making such condition assessments is challenging, time-consuming and expensive, so there is a clear need to explore options that support this process. One possibility is to use data from citizen science (like Seasearch)." - Seasearch: Cromer Shoal Chalk Beds MCZ Report

Fishing Industry

Dietary

Eat alternative foods, including plant-based proteins and seafood alternatives.

Fishing Industry

Boundaries of protected marine zones need to be better protected, with no dredging or bottom trawling allowed.

If fishing in the area, fishermen should adhere to the Code of Best Practice for potting in Cromer Shoal Chalk Beds Marine Conservation Zone (MCZ)

Energy Production

Proper surveys need to be performed before permits are given for projects. Mitigation should be planned with scientific and local collaboration. 

Boating & Tourism

"Work with local, regional and national tourism organisations and businesses (in both England and France) to support initiatives that promote the sustainable use of assets within this SCT to people arriving by sea. Include information on the underwater environment, including particularly the area’s chalk reefs and the ancient creation of the Strait. Such visitor information should be readily available both upon port exit/ entry and on the ferries themselves." - Kent: Dover Strait Seascape Character Assessment (PDF) 

Locations

Europe

North Sea

According to Wikipedia, "The Skagerrak contains some of the busiest shipping routes in the world, with vessels from every corner of the globe. It also supports an intensive fishing industry.[1] The ecosystem is strained and negatively affected by direct human activities. Oslo and Gothenburg are the only large cities in the Skagerrak region."

"The Skagerrak serves as a habitat for approximately 2,000 marine species, including a unique variety of Atlantic cod. It also contains sandy and stony reefs and cold-water coral reefs. Environmental institutions have expressed concern about increasing pressure on the ecosystem due to human activities and climate change. Protections are in place, with several marine protected areas in Skagerrak, including Ytre Hvaler National Park in Norway and Kosterhavet National Park in Sweden."

Denmark

France

Iceland

Ireland

UK

"57% of coastal chalk in Europe is found in UK waters, which amounts to just 0.6% of our coastal habitat, making this an internationally important site for protection." - The Chalk Reefs of Cromer Shoal 

"... There are other chalk reefs in Kent and Yorkshire, where they are much flatter, but Norfolk’s chalk reef is the longest by far and probably the most rugged. It is a very special habitat.

The Chalk platform exposed along parts of the North Norfolk coast is not a new landform, in marked contrast to the Chalk platforms along the Channel coast which are being created by undercutting and collapse of often high Chalk cliffs." - The Chalk Reef

Revealed: the hidden secrets of Norfolk's seas - chalk reefs

4:40 minute video showing the fascinating creatures and shapes of these reefs.

Oceana

 New Caledonia

Loyalty Islands

Native Species

These have been given tags for the areas that each species has been recorded. It is possible each species may also be found in other chalk reefs, we just haven't verified. Over 300 species have been cataloged in the Norfolk chalk reefs, and over 1,000 are estimated to live in the reefs between Denmark, Norway, and Sweden.

Algae

Seaweed

Kelp

Kelp was mentioned many times while researching chalk reefs, but no specific types were listed.

Anemone

Birds

Coral

Anthozoan communities have been found on subtidal rocky habitats 

Crustaceans

Crabs

Lobsters

Prawns

Shrimp

Cephalopoda 

Cuttlefish

Echinoderms

Brittlestars

Sea Cucumber

Sea Urchins

Starfish 

Fish

Flat Fish

Seahorses & Relatives

Rays

Gastropods

Sea Slugs

Sea Slugs some of the most colourful animals on the reef are slugs. They eat stinging or poisonous prey to re-use their defences. (UK)

Sea Snails

Jellyfish

Mammals

Porpoise

Seals

Sea Squirts

Sharks

Shellfish

Barnacles

Limpets

Mussels

Oysters

Sponges

Worms

Invasive Species

Algae

Seaweeds

Oysters

Pacific Oysters 

This paper lists different ways people have tried to combat this invader, and recommends "Removing individual oysters for immediate destruction on-site In Kent, United Kingdom, a trial was conducted by volunteers to combat Pacific oysters with the aim to return to former abundances. The trial lasted a whole year and was conducted simply by crushing the oyster shells one by one with ordinary handheld hammers (McKnight and Chudleigh, 2015). In the first-place whole oysters were removed but an unintended side effect appeared where the substrate was severely damaged. The substrate inhabited by the Pacific oysters were chalk reef structures declared as a fragile and protected habitat. To overcome that negative side effect the oysters were eradicated by crushing only the upper valve leaving the lower valve on the substrate. On non-protected chalk substrates entire individuals were crushed. The trial resulted in significant reduction of individuals' present leading to a habitat change from a dense oyster reef to a situation of less dense and mainly solitaire M. gigas on the location. The benefit was that the improved method was targeted on the alien oyster with minimal impact on the protected chalk formations and the naturally associated invertebrates but the disadvantage was the high cost of labor it required. McKnight and Chudleigh (2015) even did a cost benefit analysis of effectiveness and negative impacts from their oyster removal trial. They concluded this mitigation tool could effectively be used elsewhere if the goal sanctifies the means and the high cost is justified. In Northern Ireland, M. gigas individuals were crushed likewise. In the year after the eradication treatment oysters were almost 100% eradicated (Herbert et al., 2016). Hence, although labor-intensive and therefore relatively costly this simple mitigation strategy apparently works." This source offers a native vs invasive map of Pacific Oysters.


Click the Handle Invasive Species button for apps and other resources to help reduce the impact of invasive species.

Resources

Europe

UK

Organizations

Europe

UK

Maps

Europe

UK

Beachy Head East

Beachy Head West Marine Conservation Zone

Cromer Shoal Chalk Beds

Kingmere

Educational Opportunities

Europe

The Channel

UK

Related Topics