FILM REVIEW

Elsword taught us that fresh fish is the best fish.


Directed by: Gim Dongjun

Creative Director: Nexon Korea

Release Date: December 10, 2016 (First Episode), December 29, 2017 (Season 1 Finale)

Genre: Anime, Fantasy, Adaptation of Game

Based on the Korean MMORPG, Elsword: El Lady is an exciting addition to the Elsword franchise. Full of loveable characters and a constantly flourishing plot, the game created a high standard for its anime adaptation. But did it reach the standards and break the curse of the game-derived film genre? There are two ways to look at films like this-- as a film, and as a film adaptation of a game. In order to provide a thorough review of Elsword: El Lady, I’ll be providing insight from both of these lenses.

Firstly, let’s look at Elsword: El Lady as a film overall. In comparison to most films, the anime features a relatively bland and cliche plot - stop the demons. The El Search Party (including the protagonist Elsword Sieghart and his older sister) begin in the beautiful city of Hamel and defeat a lowly demon named Victor. Unbeknownst to them, a strange and awkward man who calls himself Add is observing them, his attention mostly on Eve, the queen of a robot race called Nasods.

Elesis Sieghart in Episode 1

Eve and Add in Episode 2

Claiming to have no other motive than being irritated by the demons, Add joins the El Search Party, with Elesis’ suspicion leading her to keep a close eye on him and stick close to Eve. The plot carries out with this tension present in the background, with the El Search Party discovering that the demons are kidnapping the priestesses and using their power to create unbalance and destruction. Upon progressing to Lanox Village, they meet the fire priestess Ignia who asks for their help to save her friends - the other priestesses. They arrive at the fire temple and are betrayed by Ignia, who then reveals that she has agreed to assist the demons in exchange for the safety of her friends.

What happens next? Elsword spends the next six episodes trying to talk her into coming back to them and fighting the demon general Scar together. Yeah, cliche anime protagonist move right there! Sure, she is still a good person with good intentions, but did he really think that simply talking to her would change something she feels so strongly about? The level of cliche only increases as after all of Elsword’s talking, and a ridiculous amount of scenes involving Ignia dramatically dropping her spear, she agrees to rejoin them and fight against the demons. Come on, really?

Ignia facing Scar’s blade in Episode 8

Aisha and Elsword in Episode 1

Aside from the overall plot itself, there were other aspects to the series that disappointed many viewers. Specifically, the relationships between the characters and how little they were allowed to progress, including themes that were started and forgotten somewhere along the series. There were three character relationships in particular that were quite disappointing in their depictions in the anime. Firstly, the relationship between Elsword and Aisha. If when you think of an anime relationship you think of a tsundere (mean to their crush to hide their feelings) girl and a dense boy who unintentionally ignores her, I am disappointed to say that this is exactly the case in the anime depiction.

We have Aisha, the renowned elemental mage who likes Elsword but won’t admit it. There’s the typical anime-esque insults directed to Elsword from her, and the constant denial of how much she cares about Elsword. And speaking of Elsword, here is the typical bland protagonist who is somehow completely oblivious to the fact that someone likes him despite her horribly unsuccessful attempts of hiding it. Fast forward a few episodes when Elsword’s sister is presumed dead and he is injured, we have the scene that every tsundere love story must have for some reason.

Rena and Raven in Episode 2

The-lash-out-because-I-care-so-much-about-you scene. Oh my god Aisha!!! To sum it up, she has a go at Elsword for being too harsh on himself and makes it even more obvious that she likes him. Not. That. Elsword. Would. Notice. Or. Anything. Right? To make things worse, this character relationship with minimal progression is the one with the most progression. Because now it’s time for character relationship number two - Rena and Raven. I love them together, just like how I love Elsword and Aisha together, but the anime didn’t do them justice. In Episode 2, we are given a scene that I loved involving a tidal wave in which Rena had to shyly cling to Raven for safety as his nasod arm held them from the edge of a cliff. Cliche, but I’m a sucker for cliches when they’re done right. Unfortunately, this is the only time we get to see anything between Rena and Raven, and as the anime progresses, this relationship is completely forgotten. Thanks Nexon, really. And finally, the relationship between Eve and Add. No, it’s not a romantic one this time. For context, since the anime doesn’t really go into detail about this, Add grew up in an ancient library after the death of his village at a young age and grew to be obsessed with the nasod race, and upon discovering Eve, decides that he needs her for research so that he can pull her apart and use her pieces to enhance his equipment. But anyway, back to the anime. Add clearly has his eye on Eve for the reason I stated, yet as the anime progresses he seems to lose interest in her. Um, excuse me? What about literally the only reason why he joined the El Search Party? In addition, Elesis’ suspicion of Add fades so quickly, despite her personality dictating that she would be very protective of Eve for much longer (sure, she supposedly died halfway through the series, but before this she seemed to lose any concern she had regarding Add). Another character relationship left to rot in favour of Elsword pointlessly nagging Ignia.

Overall, Elsword: El Lady when considered through the film perspective isn’t really that great. Granted, it’s not the worst I’ve seen, but it just lacks the interesting features a series needs to have. There is no character development or character relationship development, and the plot is just too bland and cliche. But before I rate and recommend the anime, let’s have a look at Elsword: El Lady in the perspective of a film adaptation of a game.

As most people would (hopefully) know, films adapted from games have a reputation for being terrible. A perfect example of this would be Mortal Kombat, with it’s movie having too many flaws to count (I’ll put it this way: I have attempted to watch the movie at least five times and only reached even half way once). When this reputation is considered, Elsword: El Lady’s rating would be aided. Here’s the fun part of the review, at least for me; the comparison between the film adaptation and the game. Let’s get started...

Screenshot from Elsword: Map of Elrios

Firstly, let’s start with the plot. Sure, it was bland and stretched out during the anime, but there’s a good reason for that. The Elsword animation only feature a fraction of the original plot. To give you a better idea of how little we’re talking, I’ll put it this way: the Elsword anime features the plot in Hamel and Lanox, whereas in game, the regions in order are: Ruben, Elder, Bethma, Altera, Feita, Velder, Hamel, Sander, Lanox, Elysion, Elrianode, and Varnimyr. Notice how the anime plot starts towards the middle, skips a region, and then ends at the next? And with 12 episodes each at a length of 15 minutes (on average), such a small part of the plot would be stretched out for far too long in order to reach runtime. So for this aspect of the comparison, yeah, the anime still isn’t that great.

But let’s move on to the characters. In the game, there are 12 different playable characters to choose from (technically 13, as two characters are played in a duo style in which the player switches between the two at will). These characters are: Elsword (swordsman), Aisha (mage), Rena (archer), Raven (blade and nasod arm), Eve (nasod queen), Chung (paladin/crusader), Ara (martial artist aided by an ancient fox), Elesis (swordswoman), Add (use of a unique weapon called dynamos - made from nasod pieces), LuCiel (a demon duo featuring Luciella, the ex demon queen who was overthrown and Ciel, who is a half-demon by contract with Lu), Rose (guest character from the online game Dungeon Fighter Online), and Ain (an angel sent by the goddess Ishmael to aid the El Search Party). Of these characters, all except for Ain and Rose are present in the anime, with Ain being an irregularity that cannot be seen by the El Search Party and Rose being from a different game. In the anime, each character’s personality has been maintained and kept true to the game - an impressive achievement for a film based on a game. In addition, the voice actors (who much to my relief and joy are the same as the voice actors used in the game) have done an incredible job in maintaining the personality of the characters without sounding cheesy or awfully scripted. Take that, Mortal Kombat!!!

Revamp official art for all characters, prior to the release of Rose and Ain

Ignia’s in-game model in the dungeon

In addition to keeping the plot and characters true to the game, another feature of the anime that makes it impressive is the fact that although it may have stretched the scene for too long, it went into detail about why Ignia betrayed the El Search Party. In the dungeon in the game featuring Ignia titled ‘Volcanic Flame Entrance’, Ignia betrays the El Search party at the entrance of the fire temple just like in the anime, however, she never really explains why and gives the impression that she simply used them for the fun of it, and you only really see this explanation for a fraction of the game plot if you actually read the post-quest-completion scenes. The Elsword anime actually explained more about a feature of a plot then the actual game did, which is a surprise considering that the expectation would be that everything in the anime would be a dumbed down version of the game. Sure, it was unnecessary to centre majority of the series around it, but the fact that it revealed something about the plot that the game itself barely describes. This might not seem like an important aspect of the review, but keep in mind that this isn’t an original film, it’s an adaptation of a game.

Solace at the end of Episode 12

The final comparison I will make between the anime and the game regards the post-credit scene at the end of the season. In this short scene, it shows Solace - the master of the sun. Before I explain this, I’ll give some information about the goddess and the important characters relevant to her. The goddess in Elsword is named Ishmael, and she chooses who becomes the El Lady. When someone is chosen to become the El Lady, they have no choice and will become a celestial being and will lose all mortal memories. In addition to the El Lady, there are the masters who protect the El, which is the source of all power and balance (it’s a giant rock located in Elrianode). These masters include the master of wind (Ventus), master of water (Denif), master of fire (Rosso), and several others including Solace, the master of the sun. He was originally a hero like the other masters, however a woman named Hernia who is implied to be his love interest is chosen by Ishmael to become the El Lady. Solace is enraged at the loss of Hernia, and becomes an antagonist. This is the game plot in the later half of the Elysion region. But now that this has been explained, we can go back to the anime again. The short scene at the end of episode 12 not only implies a second season (which has been somewhat confirmed but not completely), but also shows that the anime has the potential to depict a much more complex plot (Elysion, Elrianode, and Varnimyr).

I know this has been a long review, but it’s difficult to review a game-derived film without giving proper context from the original story. So in case you skimmed this review, here’s a very quick summary.

Perspective 1 - Elsword: El Lady as a film:

  • Bland and cliche plot
  • Bland and cliche protagonist
  • Little to no growth in characters or character relationships

Rating: 2.5/5

Perspective 2 - Elsword: El Lady as a film-adaptation of a game:

  • True to majority of the character’s personalities
  • True to the plot, even if it’s a minimal aspect of the plot
  • Despite expectations, revealed an important aspect of the plot in detail that the game didn’t do as successfully

Rating: 3/5

And so in conclusion, I can easily say that despite the fact that it was a very average anime, Elsword: El Lady is certainly one of the better representations of the game-derived film category. If I were asked if I would recommend the series, I would have to say that although it would excite me to see more Elsword fans, I would suggest (as an Elsword superfan) playing the game for a bit first and then watching the series in order to have a better understanding of the franchise and a chance to see Elsword at it’s best, rather than having the anime give an unimpressive first impression on the viewer. Of course, I am in no way saying that you shouldn’t watch the anime, I am only saying that in comparison to other films, it isn’t very impressive. Without any further ado, I will end this review with my rating, and I hope you have enjoyed reading my thoughts and opinions and consider investing in the Elsword franchise. Thank you for reading~!

Film: Elsword: El Lady

Rating: 5.5/10

-K Schipp, Year 11