LinkedIn Lead Generation Strategy
Performance Discussions
Managing Director
Internal Team Members: Marketing Manager
Agency: Nemo Media Group
External Team Members: Amy Larger, Project Manager | Becca Arco, VP Client Strategy | Nichole Naoum, Content Writer
Agency Engagement Term:
Duration: 3 months (initial engagement)
Period: 20 May to 8 November 2025 (minimum commitment, extended by a week + month)
Continuation: Rolling monthly after the initial 3 months
LinkedIn Profile and Messaging (for 1:1 interaction)
LinkedIn Sales Navigator (for lead identification & targeting)
Skylead (for outreach automation & management)
To make LinkedIn a top and steady source of good leads for our business, helping us grow sales predictably.
To create a clear, repeatable, and growing system for using LinkedIn to get leads and make sales, making sure we use our time and money well on this platform.
The primary goal of the outreach project is conversion through personal engagement — turning warm marketing leads into booked sales calls.
Generate 24-60 qualified leads
Secure 10 keynote demos
James aims for 10 discovery calls in 90 days, converting 3-4 to cover costs
John Nemo projects 24-60 calls possible in 90 days
Achieve 2 closed deals for "Uncharted Ice"
1st-degree connections increased from 3,533 → 4,596
3 booked demo calls, 0 closed deals
Invite acceptance rates averaged 22–31% (above benchmark of 10%)
Reply rates averaged 6–23% (above benchmark of 3%)
Strong engagement early on, but it didn’t convert into sales opportunities
The profile and banner updates worked well — they made your services clear and professional.
Many prospects engaged but didn’t book calls.
Some messages came across as automated or AI-generated.
The team improved results when they tried warmer, more conversational scripts toward the end.
ROI was negative — we spent around $15k on the project.
Project was extended to until 8 November 2025 because of the unachieved number of target demo calls
Developed campaign assets
Ensured brand consistency in outreach messaging
Monitored engagement metrics (reach, impressions, CTR, etc.)
Created sales copy for 1:1 LinkedIn direct messaging and InMail
Developed positioning and target audience criteria
Built and managed campaigns for different target groups (segments)
Conducted direct outreach to leads generated by the campaign
Track engagement with leads and send chase messages
Monitored engagement metrics (reach, impressions, CTR, etc.)
Managed 1:1 conversations on emails (from referrals and booked calls)
Scheduled and conducted demo/consultation calls
The agency managed the entire LinkedIn outreach process, from rewriting your profile and company page to building lead lists, writing message scripts, and automating outreach.
Contractor: John Nemo | Nemo Media Group
Point of Contact: Amy Larger, Project Manager
Term: 3 months (initial engagement) | 20 May to 1 October 2025*
*extended by a week (until 8 October) due to the writer's absence (LinkedIn Message Script Rewrite).
extended by another month due to lack of demos booked from campaigns.
External Team:
Amy Larger (Project Manager)
Amy will serve as the primary point of contact for all project-related communications, including approvals, deployments, and general project management.
Becca Arco (VP Client Strategy)
Becca will contribute to the project's strategic elements, offering feedback on target audience identification, messaging frameworks, and overall outreach strategy as needed. She is also available to address any questions or concerns that may arise.
Nichole Naoum (Content Writer)
Nichole is responsible for content creation and strategic input related to marketing materials.
Agency:
One-time Setup Fee: $5,000 USD
Monthly Retainer: $3,750 USD
Original Proposed Fees: $5,000 USD setup fee + $4,500 USD monthly (discounted from Initial offer: $12,500 USD setup + $4-8k/mo)
Tools:
Sales Navigator
Skylead
The Nemo Media Group rewrote James's LinkedIn profile with a clear, results-driven strategy: focusing exclusively on the elements that directly contribute to generating cash and converting profile viewers into prospective clients.
LinkedIn is a dynamic platform with countless features. Based on their experience and data, Nemo Media Group concentrates its efforts on the most impactful areas that serve as direct "cash-generating features."
This means the team prioritised optimizing:
Header: The visual banner at the top of James's profile.
Headline: The concise, descriptive line positioned directly under James's name.
"About" section: His professional summary, designed to convey his unique value proposition.
Nemo Media Group understands that these sections are what potential clients first see and value most. They are crucial for quickly communicating James's expertise and leading to meaningful conversations and deals. Features like the "Services Page" or extensive project listings, while present on LinkedIn, often do not directly translate to new business in their experience. Therefore, the team intentionally de-emphasised or bypassed optimising these less impactful areas to focus on what truly works.
For James's Skills section, Nemo Media Group approached LinkedIn as a powerful search engine. They conducted thorough keyword research to identify the top skills that LinkedIn itself recommends and that people search for when seeking professionals like James. These keywords were strategically integrated into his profile, with particular emphasis on the top three skills. These are given the most weight and prominent display by LinkedIn's algorithm, significantly boosting James's visibility and relevance in searches by prospective clients.
In essence, Nemo Media Group's objective for James's LinkedIn profile was to transform it into a highly effective tool. Their strategy was to build a profile that efficiently attracts, engages, and converts his ideal prospects into valuable client opportunities.
See the LinkedIn profile rewrite copy here:
Personal page - James Castrission
Company page - MyAdventure Group
Attendees:
James Castrission
Marketing Manager: Nicki Ann Venezuela
Nemo Media Group
Becca Arco
Amy Larger,
Nichole Naoum
Summary:
The Group discussed the LinkedIn marketing strategies, including target audience identification (primarily Australia and New Zealand, focusing on conference organisers), desired communication style (warm, upbeat, professional, and authentic), and access to James Castrission's LinkedIn profile for campaign setup. The team agreed on weekly Loom updates and bi-weekly catch-up calls, defined initial keywords and phrases for branding (like "building leadership capabilities" and "explorers mindset"), and outlined the initial lead generation process involving connection invites and soft follow-ups with lead magnets, with Nikki Ann Venezuela being the primary decision-maker for James Castrission's team. The primary objectives for James Castrission include growing LinkedIn connections, generating demo calls, achieving ROI, and learning from Nemo Media Group's LinkedIn expertise, initially focusing the marketing on conference speaking engagements.
Next steps:
The team will log into the LinkedIn account and discuss next steps for the project, ensuring they understand the target audience for outreach.
The team is open to trialing a more aggressive marketing approach if suggested by the marketing team, showing flexibility in their strategy.
Amy will go through the LinkedIn profile, create a CSV file of first-level connections, and send it for review to ensure the outreach targets are appropriate.Amy will continue to send weekly updates and will be available for later calls to accommodate the team’s schedules.
James mentions that his commitment to the Tasman crossing was a way to introduce chaos and uncertainty into his life, which he felt was necessary for personal growth.
James Castrission offers to provide anecdotes related to the main topics discussed, including mindset for success and leadership, to enhance the content for Nicole. This indicates a proactive approach to content development.
The team discussed the importance of incorporating storytelling and authenticity in their messaging to better connect with the Australian audience, with a commitment to review the messaging before it is sent out.
Next steps include building specific lists in Sales Navigator based on job titles and industries, and tweaking messaging for different campaigns as feedback is received.
The next steps involve focusing on growing connections on LinkedIn and measuring the performance of their campaign through booked demos and calls, as discussed by James.
Becca clarified that there will be a lead time before the project launches, indicating that messaging will not start immediately as preparations are needed.
Amy will manually engage leads who have shown interest in the content sent, following up with them to gauge their thoughts and encourage further interaction.
Amy is responsible for sending follow-up messages to leads after they have engaged with the content, ensuring they receive the necessary information and support.
The team will monitor and test different invite messages to see which ones yield the best acceptance rates and leads.
Becca outlined that the next steps would involve reviewing to-do items assigned by Amy, which would include explanations and directions for the tasks ahead.
It was agreed that participants would have a call with Amy to discuss the strategies and clarify any questions they might have, making the process more interactive.
The team aims to expedite the approval process to ensure a timely project launch, indicating a proactive approach to client engagement.
Amy Larger provided an update on James Castrission's LinkedIn rewrite approval and addressed Skylad login issues. The team discussed outreach strategies for first, second, and third-degree connections, including automated messaging sequences and filtering criteria identified by JC and the marketing manager. Amy Larger demonstrated Skylad campaign examples and clarified the manual handling of replies and the project's progress.
LinkedIn Rewrite Approval and Next Steps
Amy Larger confirmed that James Castrission's LinkedIn rewrite was approved by the marketing manager, Nicki and the next step involves sending it to the marketing strategist. The strategist will develop a header concept (copyright and design), which will then be sent to JC and Nicki for approval before going to the graphic designer (00:00:00).
Skylad Login Issues and Authentication
Amy Larger apologized for the email and Skylad login difficulties, explaining it's a new LinkedIn security feature affecting other project managers as well (00:00:52). James Castrission provided the authentication code, and Amy Larger confirmed it was authenticated, resolving the issue for future access (00:01:59).
First Connections Outreach Strategy
Amy Larger will send James Castrission a CSV file of first connections to review for messaging approval, clarifying that the initial outreach to these connections with their ebook or free content will occur after the messages are approved (00:01:59). Amy Larger clarified that the purpose of messaging first-degree connections is immediate lead generation since they are already known to James Castrission (00:04:08).
Automated Messaging Sequence for Connections
Amy Larger explained that after a connection request is accepted (for second and third-degree connections) or immediately for first-degree connections, an initial message will be sent, followed by automated follow-up messages over several days (00:04:50). James Castrission inquired about the recipients of these messages, and Amy Larger clarified that the CSV file will allow them to specify who should and should not be contacted (00:06:32).
Filtering Connections and Target Audience
James Castrission and Nikki Ann Venezuela discussed excluding certain connections like friends, other keynote speakers, and leadership coaches (00:07:17). Amy Larger suggested James Castrission provide a list of criteria to help narrow down the target audience in Skylad (00:07:56). Amy Larger confirmed that the first-level outreach will focus on the target audience, excluding unwanted contacts (00:08:38).
Repeat Outreach and Lead Magnet Strategy
James Castrission inquired about the strategy for repeat outreach if there's no initial response. Amy Larger explained that after the initial six to eight messages, non-responsive contacts can be placed in a new campaign with different messages and content, while direct replies are handled manually for personalized follow-up (00:09:37). Amy Larger and James Castrission discussed using Nikki Ann Venezuela's Inspire magazine or other lead magnets, with the marketing strategist determining the most valuable option (00:10:29).
Second and Third-Degree Connection Campaigns
Amy Larger outlined that campaigns for second and third-degree connections will run concurrently with the first-degree campaign. These campaigns involve sending connection requests, and upon acceptance, contacts enter a LinkedIn message campaign; if the request is ignored, an InMail campaign is used (00:11:46).
Skylad Campaign Demonstration and Insights
Amy Larger shared their screen to show James Castrission and Nikki Ann Venezuela examples of active campaigns for another client in Skylad, including statistics on messages sent and profile views (00:13:44). They demonstrated the typical lead campaign flow, including connection invitations, automated LinkedIn messages, and inmail messages for those who don't connect (00:14:46). Amy Larger explained that follow-up messages after initial responses are personalized (00:15:43).
Manual Reply Handling and Project Status
Amy Larger confirmed that replies to campaign messages will be handled manually. Amy Larger assured James Castrission and Nikki Ann Venezuela that despite the initial login difficulties, the project is progressing smoothly on their end (00:17:25).
Headline Concept and Message Approval
Amy Larger mentioned they would next send the headline concept for approval before working on the company site. James Castrission confirmed that all messages for both first connections and broader outreach will be sent for their approval before deployment (00:18:15).
Amy will send an official project update on Monday
Amy Larger and James Castrission discussed project timelines impacted by a writer's absence. The main discussion focused on the LinkedIn outreach strategy, with James Castrission advocating for a broader approach to first-degree connections, which Amy Larger agreed to, and reviewing the message content and Sales Navigator filters; the team decided to send the message to all first-degree connections after James Castrission manually reviews and excludes specific individuals. Amy Larger also outlined the strategy for second and third-degree connections and acknowledged James Castrission's feedback on value-driven outreach, with campaign launch anticipated in the coming weeks pending approvals.
Project Extension
The project was extended by one week due to the writer's absence.
1st-Degree Strategy
The team approved a broader outreach to first-degree connections for wider reach. James Castrission and Nicki Ann Venezuela will manually exclude specific contacts after messages are sent.
2nd & 3rd-Degree Strategy
Amy Larger detailed the strategy for second and third-degree connections. This involves creating targeted Skylead campaigns (optimally around 2,000 results per campaign), using Sales Navigator filters for job titles and industries. The flow for these connections includes connection requests, follow-up LinkedIn messages, and InMails for those who don't connect, with potential for retargeting.
Message Content
James Castrission reviewed and approved the first-degree direct message draft with minor word changes. James Castrission questioned the initial outreach being review-focused; feedback for a value-driven approach was sent to the writer and strategist.
Sales Navigator & Skylead
Amy Larger demonstrated Sales Navigator filters; campaigns are limited to around 2,000 people but can be set up in multiples.
Approvals & Tasks
The company page and regular profile rewrite were approved.
Campaign Launch
Campaigns are estimated to launch by the end of next week or early the following week, pending final approvals.
Amy Larger provided updates on the new LinkedIn outreach campaigns targeting second and third-degree connections, which have shown promising initial connection acceptance rates. Nicki Ann Venezuela and James Castrission discussed the automated messaging sequence, invite message testing, and the timing of messages, while James Castrission also inquired about invoicing and social posting strategy for a future meeting, with Amy Larger agreeing to schedule the latter. Participants also touched upon content approval, responding to LinkedIn messages, and the availability of training resources.
Campaign Updates and Initial Results
Amy Larger provided an update on the LinkedIn campaigns, noting that the new campaigns targeting second and third-degree connections have just started (00:03:57). Three campaigns are currently active, showing initial lead numbers, and early connection requests have resulted in a 10% and 21% acceptance rate for two of them within three days, which Amy Larger considers a positive start (00:05:37).
Messaging Automation and Workflow
Amy Larger explained that once connections are made and the messaging is approved, an automated sequence will begin until a contact shows interest, at which point one-on-one messaging will commence (00:07:31). Nicki Ann Venezuela sought clarification on the order of messages, and Amy Larger confirmed that messages one through six will be sent sequentially after a connection is established (00:08:24) (00:10:56). For those who don't connect, the first two messages will be sent as InMails (00:09:56).
Invite Testing and Message Sequencing
James Castrission inquired about testing different invite messages and how they would be implemented across campaigns (00:08:24). Amy Larger clarified that only one connect message can be used per campaign at a time, allowing for testing different messages on different campaigns to see which performs best (00:09:56). The subsequent messages (one through six) will follow in order once a connection is made (00:10:56).
Messaging Timing and First-Level Connections
Amy Larger outlined the typical timing between messages, with the first message going out shortly after connection, followed by intervals of a few days and then weekly (00:12:06). James Castrission also clarified that first-level connections will start directly with message one (00:12:57).
Content Approval and LinkedIn Profile
James Castrission confirmed that the writer had adjusted the notes as requested by Nicki Ann Venezuela. James Castrission also expressed satisfaction with the updated LinkedIn profile header, and Amy Larger encouraged them to send over any further feedback (00:03:18) (00:12:57). James Castrission stated they would approve the copy that day, allowing Amy Larger to add the messages and start the campaigns (00:13:36).
Financial Inquiries and Next Steps
James Castrission inquired about the invoicing process, and Amy Larger directed them to the project message board to contact Becca for that information (00:13:36). It was confirmed that the only immediate task was reviewing the campaign copy (00:14:18).
Future Discussion on Social Posting
Nicki Ann Venezuela raised the topic of general posting and content strategy (00:14:18). James Castrission suggested focusing on the outreach campaigns first and then having a more in-depth discussion about social posting on LinkedIn the following Friday, requesting direction on content, frequency, and strategy (00:15:07). Amy Larger agreed to schedule this discussion and consult with Becca (00:16:11) (00:19:14).
Responding to LinkedIn Messages
Amy Larger shared an example of a LinkedIn message James Castrission had received to discuss how to handle such interactions (00:16:11). James Castrission explained their approach of being friendly but not investing significant time in individuals unlikely to become clients (00:17:02). Amy Larger indicated they would send more examples to understand the preferred response style (00:17:53).
The LinkedIn Sales Project Manager has provided the following progress update for this week:
The automated LinkedIn outreach campaign is now fully operational in Skylead. The team is currently A/B testing four different connection invitation messages to determine which ones perform most effectively.
It was clarified that there is no specific training available beyond the onboarding materials already provided. Readers are encouraged to reach out with any specific questions they might have.
47 new 1st Degree Connections were established.
The invite acceptance rate reached 18%, which is above the optimal target of >10%.
The reply rate stands at 23%, significantly exceeding the optimal target of >3%.
The team will continue to monitor engagement rates (including accepts, replies, and clicks). They will also focus on replying to opt-ins and creating chase messages for approval.
The Project Manager has also included an updated engagement tracker, which now reflects the recent activity from opt-ins:
The Leads Tab lists everyone who has opted in.
The First-Degree Connections Tab is updated weekly with the current number of 1st-degree connections.
The Booked Calls Tab lists all individuals with scheduled calls.
The Dashboard provides a quick visual overview of key data.
The Data Tab tracks all detailed project numbers.
The Data Tab and First-Degree Connections Tab are updated every Monday, while the Leads Tab and Booked Calls Tab are updated daily.
Lead Management and Engagement Tracking
Amy Larger presented an engagement tracker to James Castrission and Nicki Ann Venezuela, detailing new first-degree leads from a campaign, the messages sent, and the date of ebook requests (00:05:09). Amy Larger requested their input on which leads to prioritize for follow-up and offered to create a task in Basecamp for this (00:06:52). James Castrission also inquired about the limits of the lead tool, to which Amy Larger explained the 200 in-mail per month limit and the warm-up mode for SkyLead to avoid being flagged as spam (00:08:12).
Campaign Performance Metrics
Amy Larger reviewed the SkyLead report, highlighting 19 accepted connections, 27 replies, a 13% response rate, and a 15% acceptance rate for friend requests (00:09:06). Amy Larger explained that the accepted connections are based on approved copy and that the system is gradually sending messages to avoid spam flagging (00:10:13). Amy Larger also clarified that "zero viewed profiles" means SkyLead has not yet touched those profiles due to being in warm-up mode (00:11:13).
Lead Qualification and Follow-up
James Castrission sought clarification on how to annotate the Google sheet with lead information, specifically asking how much detail to provide for viable leads versus those not to pursue (00:12:04). Amy Larger advised James Castrission to indicate whether she should continue chasing a client or leave them alone, and also to note any specific follow-up actions desired (00:13:13). Amy Larger also explained their process of replying to messages directly in LinkedIn and Sales Navigator for immediate response, as SkyLead has a delay (00:15:34).
Overall Campaign Performance and Data Insights
Amy Larger confirmed a good conversion rate of 10% for ebook requests from 190 reached first-degree connections, which James Castrission found fantastic. Amy Larger also outlined various tabs on the dashboard, including booked calls, first-degree connections, and weekly data updates on invites sent, acceptance rates, messages, in-mails, and calls booked (00:17:19). Amy Larger explained the ramp-up period for SkyLead, where daily limits are gradually increased to prevent accounts from being shut down (00:19:20).
Client Communication and Content Strategy
James Castrission asked Amy Larger to respond to a client who mentioned him, suggesting to inquire about upcoming conferences or offer a call with the CEO (00:20:19). James Castrission also requested all meeting recordings from Amy Larger for reference. Furthermore, James Castrission expressed a desire to discuss content strategy with Becker, requesting a meeting to strategize on LinkedIn articles and newsletters, to which Amy Larger agreed to arrange (00:21:52) (00:23:17). James Castrission also asked if Amy Larger's copywriter could provide feedback on their email outreach messages (00:24:06).
✅ What’s Been Done
Sent messages for 13 new Opt-Ins since Thursday
Sent 19 chase messages for the Opt-ins from last week.
📈 Highlights
45 new 1st Degree Connections
8% invite acceptance overall. IT and Finance are 16% each. Wonderful!
14% reply rate (>3% is optimal)
🎯 What’s Next
Monitor engagement rates (accepts, replies, clicks)
Reply to Opt-Ins and Chase Messages
Summary:
The meeting between Amy Larger, Nicki Ann Venezuela, and James Castrission covered several key updates, starting with Amy's computer issues and the need for two-factor authentication to access James's LinkedIn account. Amy presented James's SkyLead report, showcasing strong performance with 37 accepted connections and 46 replies, while James requested a new column in the engagement spreadsheet for lead categorization. They discussed individual campaign reporting, the limitations of AB testing (only at new campaign setup), James's suggestion to add industry-specific language to campaign messages, and plans to develop industry-specific lead magnets and landing pages. Amy also explained the SkyLead ramp-up process, and James inquired about using SkyLead for email outreach campaigns with their own connections.
Details:
SkyLead Campaign Performance Review
Amy presented James's SkyLead report, highlighting strong performance with 37 accepted connections (19% acceptance rate) and 46 replies (12% response rate) across all campaigns. They noted that 43 people have opted into the magazine so far, with 13 more responses needing to be added to the engagement spreadsheet (00:08:35).
Streamlining Lead Management in Engagement Spreadsheet
James requested a new column in the engagement spreadsheet between columns R and S for dropdown options to quickly categorize leads (e.g., "yes, absolutely," "no idea," "keep relationship going") and allow for additional comments (00:10:17). Amy confirmed this change is acceptable and they can customize the labels and level of detail provided (00:11:50).
Individual Campaign Reporting and AB Testing
Amy demonstrated a new SkyLead feature allowing users to view detailed reports for individual campaigns, including the step each lead is on and acceptance rates (00:13:15). James inquired about AB testing for niche messaging within campaigns, and Amy explained that AB variants can only be set up when a new campaign is initially built (00:15:01).
Niche Targeting Strategy
James suggested adding industry-specific language to campaign messages, especially for advertising industry targets, to potentially improve conversion rates, aligning with concepts from John Nemo's podcasts (00:15:01) (00:16:27). Amy confirmed they could modify existing messages but emphasized that AB testing for this would require new campaign setups (00:15:45) (00:17:28).
Developing Industry-Specific Lead Magnets
James revealed plans to develop industry-specific lead magnets and landing pages, such as modifying the Inspire magazine and creating relevant case studies for particular industries like advertising (00:16:27). They discussed testing the impact of niching down messages on acceptance rates once current campaigns conclude (00:17:28).
Lead Status and Future Campaigns
Amy showed James the status of their automotive campaign, which had not yet sent out messages, explaining that new campaigns could be built as current ones progress. They discussed identifying additional target industries, with James suggesting professional services and accounting, and Amy noting that accounting is a separate industry filter in Sales Navigator (00:18:14) (00:21:28).
Email Outreach with SkyLead
James inquired about using SkyLead for email outreach campaigns with their own connections, aiming to automate follow-up processes currently handled manually (00:25:37) (00:29:34). Amy confirmed SkyLead's capability for email campaigns, including sending from a personal Gmail account and tracking opens, but noted that previous email campaigns through SkyLead have not shown high engagement (00:26:23) (00:28:36).
SkyLead Warm-up Process and Settings
Amy updated James on the SkyLead ramp-up process, confirming that current activity levels are within SkyLead's recommended ranges and no flags for spam have been issued (00:30:51). James reviewed the email settings to ensure their personal testing would not interfere with Amy's ongoing campaigns (00:31:38).
Next Steps:
Amy Larger will send out the ebook requests tonight.
Amy Larger will ask Becca and the writer to add a line to the message that mentions the industry to test the niching concept.
Amy Larger will rename the campaign titles in Sales Navigator to make them more obvious.
James Castrission and Nicki Ann Venezuela will send Amy Larger a list of three to five more industries to target.
James Castrission and Nicki Ann Venezuela will update the tracking document with a new column and some copy for Amy Larger.
📈 Highlights
48 new 1st Degree Connections
22% invite acceptance overall
16% reply rate (>3% is optimal)
1 Pending Proposal!
64 opt-ins this week! (Incredible!)
🎯 What’s Next
Monitor engagement rates (accepts, replies, clicks)
Reply to Opt-Ins and Chase Messages
Reviewing your campaigns and building lists for your next 3-5 industries.
The engagement has been outstanding, with a high volume of people responding positively to the content. Early indicators show that the message is resonating strongly. Most of the responses are from first-degree connections, with many showing genuine interest.
High-quality leads are coming through as well—the one booked call so far was a prime example: highly qualified and likely to convert, exactly in line with the goal.
Amy has been consistently following up, steadily moving leads through the chase messages and laying the groundwork for stronger follow-ups in the weeks ahead.
Summary
Amy provided an update on campaign performance, noting high acceptance and response rates, and explained that Skylead settings are maxed out, resulting in a 20% acceptance and 10% response rate. James and Amy discussed strategies for non-responsive contacts, agreeing to use a second set of messages and a new lead magnet based on leadership lessons from the Penrith Panthers rugby league team, particularly targeting Australian audiences. James' homework is to update the Google Sheet and provide the Penrith Panthers content to Amy, who will provide a Loom update next week and review sales emails for tone if sent via Base Camp.
Details
Campaign Performance Overview Amy Larger provided an update on the campaign's progress, noting that acceptance rates are phenomenal, with some campaigns reaching 50%. They also highlighted strong response rates, particularly for the first-degree campaign, which has a 15% response rate. Amy Larger confirmed that the added columns for "viable or not" and relationship type are very useful for them (00:05:40).
Skylead Settings and Message Volume Amy Larger explained that the Skylead settings are currently maxed out to optimize message sending, with 656 messages and 209 in-mails sent in the last week, resulting in a 20% acceptance rate and a 10% response rate (00:06:37). James Castrission inquired about the meaning of the red highlighting in the spreadsheet, and Amy Larger clarified that it indicates when a follow-up message is due (00:07:41).
Future Campaign Strategies James Castrission discussed the strategy for contacts who have not responded after multiple chase messages, inquiring if they should be placed into a new campaign or given a rest period. Amy Larger confirmed that a second set of messages is available for their project and they will begin setting those up (00:09:13). James Castrission then proposed a new lead magnet based on leadership lessons from the Penrith Panthers rugby league team, suggesting it could be used in a second or third campaign, particularly targeting Australian audiences (00:11:00). Amy Larger agreed this would be a good lead magnet and offered to target Australians specifically if desired (00:11:53).
Lead Management and Calendar Bookings Amy Larger updated James Castrission on the number of opt-ins, mentioning approximately 177 leads so far, with 56 of those appearing since last Thursday (00:13:26). Amy Larger also noted that they are sending approximately two hours of messages daily to warm up leads and book more calls (00:14:27). James Castrission confirmed their homework is to update the Google Sheet and provide the Penrith Panthers content to Amy Larger (00:12:40) (00:15:08).
Logistics and Upcoming Schedule James Castrission inquired about the naming convention for the next message set, confirming it would be referred to as "set two" for the Penrith Panthers campaign. Amy Larger informed James Castrission that they will provide a Loom update next week due to a family commitment (00:15:56). James Castrission also asked if Amy Larger's copywriter could review some sales emails for tone, to which Amy Larger agreed, instructing them to send anything to be checked via Base Camp (00:15:56).
Next Steps:
James will update the engagement tracker in the Google sheet today or tomorrow.
James will send the Penrith Panthers assets (videos and the PDF ebook) to Amy as soon as they are finished, so she can get the writer to build messaging around them.
James will send the cold sales emails to Amy for her copywriter to review and provide feedback on the tone.
Amy will send the meeting recordings to James.
📈 Highlights
72 new 1st Degree Connections
22% invite acceptance overall
11% reply rate
1 Pending Proposal!
21 opt-ins this week!
🎯 What’s Next
Monitor engagement rates (accepts, replies, clicks)
Reply to Opt-Ins and Chase Messages
📈 Highlights
22 new 1st Degree Connections
22% invite acceptance overall
10% reply rate
1 Pending Proposal!
65 opt-ins this week
🎯 What’s Next
Monitor engagement rates (accepts, replies, clicks)
Reply to Opt-Ins and Chase Messages
Becca and Amy are going to meet to discuss the project and schedule a time to meet
55 new 1st-degree connections were established, bringing the total number of new connections to 616.
The campaign achieved an overall invite acceptance rate of 28%.
The reply rate stands at 7%.
There is 1 pending proposal.
44 opt-ins this week.
The team will continue to monitor engagement rates, including accepts, replies, and clicks.
They'll also reply to all opt-ins and chase messages.
The Project Manager will track job titles and industries from the 1st-degree connection list to identify engagement patterns. This information will be used to backfill data for contacts who have already opted in, making future targeting more strategic.
Once all the information is gathered, the team will build Message Set 2 and create additional targeted campaigns.
The Project Manager asked Nicki if there's anyone specific James should target with a voice or video message, and offered to set up Basecamp assignments with relevant information on warm leads.
Highlights:
61 new 1st-degree connections were established, bringing the total number of new connections to 561
The campaign achieved an overall invite acceptance rate of 25%
The reply rate stands at 7%
There is 1 pending proposal
42 opt-ins this week
What's Next:
The project manager will continue to monitor engagement rates, including accepts, replies, and clicks. The team will also focus on replying to opt-ins and chase messages. The project manager is building out new campaigns focusing on the following industries:
Event Services → Event Producer / Event Director: These individuals are ideal for direct bookings, as they are the key decision-makers who hire keynote speakers.
Financial Services / Insurance → Chief Marketing Officer / Head of Talent / Senior Manager: These roles typically own or influence event budgets for leadership development and client-facing events.
Software Development / IT & SaaS → Enablement Lead / Program Manager / Director of People: These titles are tied to internal Learning and Development (L&D), leadership offsites, and company culture programs.
Highlights
65 new 1st-degree connections were established, bringing the total number of new connections to 500.
The campaign achieved an overall invite acceptance rate of 31%, which is an incredible result.
The reply rate stands at 6%.
What's Next
The project manager will continue to monitor all engagement rates, including accepts, replies, and clicks.
The team will reply to all opt-ins and chase messages.
The project manager built two new campaigns and plans to create another one this week, utilising Message Set 2 for these campaigns.
The Project Manager and team have decided to pause the 1st-Degree Leads campaign. This was done to free up messaging capacity for other campaigns that are more tightly targeted to the ideal audience in the 2nd and 3rd level campaigns.
This week's stats:
997 Total Outreach! (Invites and Messages sent)
70 new LinkedIn Connections, our 2nd highest week yet!
9 opt-ins for your eBook outside of your 1st level campaign!
The campaign's invite acceptance rate landed at a strong 22%. This is excellent traction and reflects positive momentum for the project.
Two potential event inquiries have come in from the campaign. The project manager has sent them a calendar link and will be monitoring the situation closely. Please send an update if they book a call.
An extra month has been added to the project, and the team looks forward to the upcoming meeting. The meeting will be an opportunity to review progress, discuss what's working best, and plan how to take advantage of the next few weeks.
Invite acceptance continues to hold steady at 75% - shows that our targeting and messaging are resonating well.
Consistent engagement across campaigns, with several new opt-ins coming through, and we’ll be keeping an eye on those for potential calls.
This week, we’re re-engaging 1st-degree connections with a warmer, more natural tone after taking a short pause. The goal is to spark more genuine conversations and lift response rates.
High Engagement, Zero Conversions: Campaigns drive strong engagement (24–29% acceptance rates) but have yielded zero booked calls from over 400 opt-ins, creating a major ROI problem.
New Strategy: The underperforming email campaign will be replaced with a new IT-focused campaign to test a different industry and message set.
Project at Risk: The project ends Nov 1. James is frustrated by the lack of ROI and will decide on renewal next week, noting his other sales channels (Google Ads, DMs) are highly successful.
Problem: High engagement isn't converting to booked calls.
Metrics: 24–29% acceptance rates (vs. 7–10% benchmark) and 400+ opt-ins.
Outcome: Zero booked calls.
Significance: This is the core issue, as James's other sales channels are thriving, proving the offer is strong.
Solution: Replace the underperforming email campaign.
Decision: Launch a new campaign targeting the IT industry.
Rationale: The IT sector previously showed promise.
Goal: Test if a new audience and message set can break the conversion barrier.
Timeline: The project ends Nov 1, which includes the free month extension.
Decision: James will decide on renewal next week.
Rationale: The decision hinges on whether the campaigns can demonstrate ROI.
Context: James's other sales channels (Google Ads, DMs) are highly effective, proving the offer's value.
Example: An inbound lead from a Google Ad resulted in a full-day delivery for Apple's marketing team.
Christian Black: A connection who was attempting to sell services, not a qualified lead.
Deanne Monks: Lost the proposal; the client chose another speaker.
Launch the new IT-focused LinkedIn campaign.
Send the pre-drafted message to 1st-level connections.
Confirm the Nov 1 end date with Becca.
Prepare offboarding documents (if needed).
Decide on project renewal next week.
Most leads have only received 1–3 touches so far. Based on typical patterns, it generally takes 5–10 well-timed follow-ups before people are ready to book.
Interest is high—many prospects simply need an extra nudge or reminder. Often, it’s a matter of timing or highlighting the right benefit or pain point.
The campaign is still in the early stage of the chase sequence, where calls usually start to convert. The majority of viable leads haven’t yet been exposed to the booking link, which is exactly what the next few weeks are designed to deliver.
Next Focus Areas
Turning interest into action: Updating chase messages to feel more timely and relevant (e.g., team planning season, offsite prep, etc.). This will be explored further in the upcoming call.
Prioritizing the warmest leads: Creating more personalized chase messages for leads tagged as “prior relationship,” “event organiser,” or “L&D.” Amy will also begin tracking job titles and industries across the first-degree list to identify patterns, and will backtrack to add these details for existing opt-ins.
Big Picture
The foundation is very strong—the first six weeks of outreach have delivered excellent results. The team is now building on that momentum with more strategic follow-ups and smarter targeting, informed by clear insights into which campaigns are performing best and which should be adjusted.
James was not satisfied with their performance.
We barely received 5 booked discovery calls compared to the 10 target number they themselves set.
Site: https://john-s-school-dc47.thinkific.com/enrollments
Login:
user email: nicki@myadventuregroup.com.au
password: L3ARN$2025
Last Updated: 29 October 2025
Updated By: Eyo Faithe and Nicki Ann