NEW YORK
1952 - Jacqueleen "Jackie" Virginia Loughery (winner)
1953 - Reta Knapp (SF)
1954 - Karin Hultman (2nd RU, then 1st RU)
1955 - Janet Kadlecik (SF)
1956 - Kay Douglas
1957 - Sanita Pelkey (SF)
1958 - Virginia Fox (SF)
1959 - Arlene Nesbitt (4th RU)
1960 - Mary Rodites (1st RU)
1961 - Alexandra Stuard Currey (3rd RU)
1962 - Sherralyn Patecell (SF)
1963 - Jeanne Marie Quinn (SF)
1964 - Dorothy Langhans (SF)
1965 - Gloria Jon (SF)
1966 - Nancy Self (SF) (Best State Costume)
1967 - Wendy Cox
1968 - June West (SF)
1969 - Rosemary Hradek (SF)
1970 - Christina Tefft (SF)
1971 - Barbara Lopez
1972 - Alberta Phillips (1st RU)
1973 - Susan Elizabeth Carlson (1st RU)
1974 - Barbara Gail Cooper (1st RU) (Miss Photogenic)
1975 - Sonja Beverly Anderson
1976 - Carol Doerr
1977 - Debbie Martin
1978 - Darlene Javits
1979 - Mary Therese Friel (winner)
1980 - Debra Sue Maurice (SF)
1981 - (DQ) Deborah Ann Fountain
1982 - Anne Marie Henderson
1983 - Jennifer Anne Mikelinich (SF)
1984 - Caroline Flury
1985 - Lovey King
1986 - Beth Laufer
1987 - Constance McCullough
1988 - Linnea Mancini
1989 - Jennifer Fisher
1990 - Patricia Murphy
1991 - Maureen Ann Murray (SF)
1992 - Christine Elizabeth Beachak
1993 - Wendy Marie Mock (SF)
1994 - Jennifer Lynne Gareis (Top 6)
1995 - Shanna Lynn Moakler (1st RU, then MISS USA)
1996 - Keelin Curnuck
1997 - Ramona Reuter
1998 - Susan Wisdom
1999 - Kimberly Ann Pressler (winner)
2000 - Carrie Tucker (SF)
2001 - Lisa Paulakis
2002 - Karla Cavalli (SF)
2003 - Nadia Behette
2004 - Jaclyn Nesheiwat
2005 - Meaghan Jarensky (Top 10)
2006 - Adriana Diaz
2007 - Gloria Sophia Almonte
2008 - Danielle Roundtree
2009 - Tracey Chang
2010 - Davina Marie Reeves
2011 - Amber Marie Collins (Top 16)
2012 - Johanna Sambucini
2013 - Joanne Nosuchinsky
2014 - Candace Marie Kendall
2015 - Thatiana Diaz (Top 15)
2016 - Serena Bucaj
2017 - Hannah Lopa (Top 10)
2018 - Genésis Camila Suero Matos
2019 - Florinda Kajtazi
2020 - Andreia Gibau (Top 10)
2021 - Briana Siaca
2022 - Heather Nunez
2023 - Rachelle Di Stasio