USA
as Miss UNITED STATES:
1960 Charlene Lundberg (4th RU)
1961 Jo Ann Marie Dyer
1962 Carolyn Joyner (4th RU)
as Miss AMERICAN BEAUTY:
1963 Joyce Bryan (3rd RU)
1964 Linda Ann Taylor (1st RU)
1965 Gail Karen Krielow (1st RU)
1967 Pamela Elfast (2nd RU)
1968 Karen Ann MacQuarrie (2nd RU)
1969 Gayle Kovaly (SF)
1970 Randi Susan Blesner (SF)
1971 Jacqueline Lee Jochims (3rd RU)
1972 Lindsay Diane Bloom (4th RU)
1973 Pia Nancy Canzani
1974 Karen Brucene Smith (winner)
1975 Patricia Lynn Bailey (3rd RU)
1976 Susan Elizabeth Carlson (3rd RU)
1977 Laura Jean Bobbit (4th RU)
1978 Katherine Patricia Ruth (winner)
1979 Anna Maria Rapagna (1st RU)
1980 Charissa Ann Ewing (1st RU)
1981 Lisa Margaret Schuman (SF)
1982 Christie Ellen Claridge (winner) (Miss Photogenic)
1983 Kimberly Anne Bleier (SF)
1984 Sandra Lee Percival
1985 Sarie Nerine Jourbert (1st RU)
1986 Cindy Jane Williams (SF)
as Miss UNITED STATES:
1987 Paula Jean Morrison (SF)
1988 Dana Michelle Richmond (1st RU)
1989 Deborah Lee Husti (SF)
1990 Shawna Lea Bowman (SF)
1991 Kimberly Anne Byers
1992 Sandra Lee Allen
1993 Lynette Jonene MacFee
1994 Karen Kristie Doyle
1995 Krista Loskota
1996 Maya Yadira Kashak
1997 Tanya Lorraine Miller
1998 Susan Paez
1999 Jennifer Jean Glover
2000 Kirstin Anne Cook
2001 Eleana Thompson
2002 Mary Elizabeth Jones
2003 Masielle Otero
2004 Amy Lynne Holbrook (1st RU)
2005 Anna Ward
2007 April Strong
2008 Kelly Ann Best
2009 Aileen Jan Valdehueza-Yap
2010 Cassandra Nicole Tressler
2011 Kristen Little
2012 Amanda Renee Delgado (SF)
2013 Andrea Neu (SF)
2014 Samantha Brooks
2015 Lindsay Lauren Becker (4th RU)
2016 Kaitryana Michelle Leinbach (4th RU)
2017 Shanel Kapri James
2018 Bonnie Lee Walls
2019 Ghazal Gill
2022 Corrin Ashley Stellakis (Miss International America)
2023 Kenyatta Michelle Beazer (Continental Queen)