Feedback Summary
An overall theme from my peers' feedback is that they think that my log idea is most practical as the speakers will fit nicely on either side. They also posed helpful questions about materiality and which parts I plan to buy vs. make myself.
Detailed Drawing
I think that this is a good idea to design and build because the speakers fit on either side seamlessly, and while it is a simple shape there is a lot of opportunity for adding details. This design will challenge my current skillset by trying to incorporate all of the circuit components (volume, lights, speaker, on/off button) discreetly. My end goal is for this to look like a fairy log without any exposed components at first sight.