Huntley, Aaron 5

Aaron 5 HUNTLEY (1680 - 1748) and Deborah DE WOLF (1690 - aft. 1748)

my 6g-grandparents

Aaron 5 HUNTLEY was born on 1 Dec 1680 in Lyme, Colony of Connecticut, the son of Aaron 3 HUNTLEY and Mary CHAMPION.

He married in Lyme, 27 Jul 1707, to Deborah DEWOLF, born in Lyme on 25 Jul 1690, daughter of Stephen and Hannah (JONES) (RANSOM) DEWOLF. He was 26 and she was 2 days past 17. They had 11 children, in Lyme, from 1708 to 1731.

Aaron 5 HUNTLEY died on 26 Sep 1748, in Lyme, and Deborah (DEWOLF) HUNTLEY survived her husband.

Please see my page on Lyme for more information.

Several vital records for Lyme are replicated in the records of Gill, Franklin, MA. Records on Ancestry, listing the same person, on the same date, in both Lyme, CT and Gill, MA. This seems to be a systematic error. Maybe a book of vital records was misfiled. I doubt if many HUNTLEYs ever lived in Gill, MA.

I am using the numbering system of [VH]. Unfortunately, this only kept track of males. It would be useful to have a way to distinguish between all the Hannah and Ruth HUNTLEYs!

There is some overlap between the families of Aaron 5 and his brother John 4, because John 4's son Samuel 13 married Aaron 5's daughter Ruth. Yes, they were first cousins! See the ancestor chart on the Benjamin HUNTLEY page.

Descendants

Aaron 5 HUNTLEY and Deborah DE WOLF had 11 children, and 55 grandchildren, that I've found. Several of the grandchildren married each other, as 1st cousins. Others intermarried with the MACK, GEE, SMITH and other prominent families in Lyme. The HUNTLEYs and allied families stayed in Lyme for more than 100 years. In the decade before the American Revolution, several branches of these families removed about 120 miles north, along the Connecticut River valley, and settled in Marlow, Cheshire, NH.

Aaron 5 HUNTLEY b: 1 Dec 1680 in Lyme, Colony of Connecticut, d: 26 Sep 1748 in Lyme
+ Deborah DE WOLF b: 25 Jul 1690 in Lyme, m: 27 Jul 1707 in Lyme, d: aft. 26 Sep 1748
1. Hannah HUNTLEY b: 22 Jul 1708 in Lyme, d: 1796 in Lyme
+ Ebenezer MACK b: 08 Dec 1697 in Lyme, m: 30 Apr 1728 in Lyme, d: 08 May 1777 in Lyme
2. Aaron 14 HUNTLEY b: 14 Sep 1710 in Lyme, d: 18 Nov 1763 in Lyme
+ Mary LEACH b: 9 May 1719 in Windham County, CT, d: aft. 1797
3. Solomon HUNTLEY was born 1 Sep 1712 in Lyme, and died 11 Feb 1724 in Lyme
4. Deborah HUNTLEY b: 20 Aug 1714 in Lyme, d: 26 Mar 1807 in Lyme
+ Solomon GEE b: abt. 1698, in Devon, England, m: 29 May 1731 in Lyme d: 13 Apr 1769 in Lyme
5. Ruth HUNTLEY b: 1 Mar 1716 in Lyme, d: 15 Jun 1805
+ Samuel 13 HUNTLEY b: 23 Dec 1713 in Lyme, m: 5 May 1736 in Lyme, d: 11 May 1770, in Lyme
6. Stephen HUNTLEY b: 28 Feb 1719, in Lyme
7. Phebe HUNTLEY b: 1 Mar 1722 in Lyme, d: 1797, Marlow
+ Capt. Nicodemus MILLER b: 16 Feb 1715, in Lyme, m: 13 Mar 1740, in Lyme, d: 14 Jun 1781 in Marlow
8. Esther HUNTLEY b: 21 May 1724 in Lyme, d: aft. 1800
+ William ROBBINS m: 20 May 1741, in Lyme, d: aft. 1800
9. Nathan 15 HUNTLEY b: 2 Jun 1726 in Lyme, d: 30 Apr 1798, in Marlow
+ Lucy/Luce SMITH b: 25 Mar 1729, in Lyme, m: 6 Oct 1746, in Lyme, d: 25 Mar 1802, in Marlow
10. Jemima HUNTLEY b: 30 Aug 1728, in Lyme
+ Ebenezer "Eber" LEWIS b: 18 Mar 1733 in Derby, CT, m: 26 May 1754, in Lyme
11. Timothy HUNTLEY b: 22 Oct 1731, in Lyme, d: young

1. Hannah HUNTLEY was born 22 Jul 1708 in Lyme, and died in 1796. She married on 30 Apr 1728 in Lyme, to Ebenezer MACK, who died in 1777, "while bringing in the back log." Ebenezer was the son of John MACK and Sarah BAGLEY, of Lyme. [IHH, p. 21]

Ebenezer MACK (1697 - 1777) is sometimes conflated with his nephew, Ebenezer MACK (1715 - 1792), who was Pastor of the First Baptist Church of East Lyme.

1 Hannah HUNTLEY b: 22 Jul 1708 in Lyme, d: 1796 in Lyme
... + Ebenezer MACK b: 08 Dec 1697 in Lyme, m: 30 Apr 1728 in Lyme, d: 08 May 1777 in Lyme
......i Phebe MACK b: 20 Jan 1729, d: 1816 in Lyme
...... + Amos 19 HUNTLEY b: 31 Oct 1727 in Lyme, m: 21 May 1749 in Lyme, d: 1 Sep 1804 in Lyme
......ii Deborah MACK b: 16 Sep 1730 in Lyme, d: 21 Dec 1828 in CT
...... + Nathan WOODWORTH bapt. 21 Jan 1733 in Norwich, CT, m: 23 Jun 1756 in Lyme, d: 7 Nov 1771 in Lyme
......iii Solomon MACK b: 15 Sep 1732 in Lyme, d: 9 Aug 1820 in Gilsum, Cheshire, NH
...... + Lydia Matilda GATES b: 3 Sep 1732 in East Haddam, CT, m: 4 Jan 1759 in East Haddam, CT, d: 9 Mar 1817 in Royalton, Windsor, VT
......iv Hannah MACK b: 15 Oct 1734 in Lyme
...... + Levi BARTHOLOMEW b: 1732 in Branford, New Haven, CT, m: 11 Oct 1757 in Lyme, d: 1788 in Branford
......v Samuel MACK b: 15 Nov 1736 in Lyme, d: 10 Oct 1783 in Nova Scotia, Canada
...... + Lydia BRAINARD/BRAINERD b: 18 Aug 1736 in Haddam, CT, m: 23 Feb 1758 in Chatham, Middlesex, CT
...... + Desiah "Desire" COHOON b: 19 Apr 1747 in Chatham, d: 1 Sep 1809 in Port Medway, Queens County, Nova Scotia, Canada
......vi Hepsibah MACK b: 07 May 1740 in Lyme, d: 15 Jun 1818 in Marlow, Cheshire, NH
...... + Abisha TUBBS b: 16 Jun 1740 in Lyme, m: abt. 1761, d: 25 Oct 1814 in Marlow, Cheshire, NH
......vii Stephen MACK b: 15 Jun 1742 in Lyme, d: 15 Sep 1762 in Hebron, CT
......viii Elisha MACK b: 16 Jul 1745 in Lyme, d: 15 Nov 1820 in Deerfield, MA
...... + Diadamia RATHBONE b: Mar 1743 in Lyme, d: Nov 1799 in Deerfield, MA
......ix Azuba MACK b: 28 Nov 1748 in Lyme, d: Aft. 1812
...... + Jasper 26 HUNTLEY b: 04 Sep 1749 in Lyme, m: 31 Dec 1768 in Lyme, d: 12 Jun 1816 in Lyme

i. Phebe MACK married Amos 19 HUNTLEY, son of Daniel 6 HUNTLEY, who was son of Aaron 3 Huntley, so Phebe and Amos 19 were 1st cousins, 1x removed.

iii. Solomon MACK married Lydia GATES. One of their 8 children was Lucy MACK, who married Joseph SMITH Sr. Lucy and Joseph were the parents of Joseph SMITH, founder of the Mormon church. [SFA] The Mormon Church, a.k.a. Latter Day Saints, take genealogy very seriously, so there is a large amount of information available on this family. In addition, Solomon wrote an extensive autobiography [SM], describing his adventures, military service, illnesses, and conversion to Christianity. It is a priceless resource for all of his descendants. Their son Stephen MACK also has a Wikipedia page.

v. Samuel MACK was born on 15 Nov 1736 in Lyme, and died on 14 Oct 1783 in Nova Scotia, at the age of 46. He moved to Port Medway, Nova Scotia, Canada, and started a lumber business.

Samuel MACK married (1) Lydia BRAINARD or BRAINERD on 23 Feb 1758, in Chatham, Middlesex, CT. Lydia was born 18 Aug 1736 in Haddam, Middlesex, CT, daughter of Abijah BRAINERD and Esther SMITH. Samuel and Lydia had 2 daughters, in East Haddam, Middlesex, CT. The family moved to Nova Scotia about 1764. Lydia must have died, and Samuel married (2) Desiah "Desire" COHOON, born 19 Apr 1747 in Chatham, Barnstable, MA. They had 3 sons, in Nova Scotia.

vi. Hepzibah MACK married Abijah TUBBS, probably before 1761, when the 1st of their 7 children was born. Abisha TUBBS served as a Sergeant for at least 1 month 7 days, in the New Hampshire Militia, in Col Benjamin BELLOWS’ Regiment, from 6 May 1777 to 13 Jun 1777.

vii. Stephen MACK was born 15 Jun 1742 in Lyme. He served in the French and Indian wars, and died on 15 Sep 1762 in Hebron, CT, probably in action. He was 20, and had no known wife or children.

viii. Elisha MACK was born 16 Jul 1745 in Lyme, and died 15 Nov 1820 in Deerfield, MA, age 75. His wife was Diadamia RATHBONE, born Mar 1743 in Lyme, died Nov 1799 in Deerfield, MA. They moved around in New England, and had at least 5 children, from 1771 to 1786, so they were probably married about 1770.

ix. Azuba MACK married Jasper 26 HUNTLEY, son of Peter 10 HUNTLEY, so Azuba and Jasper were 1st cousins, 1x removed.

2. Aaron 14 HUNTLEY was born 14 Sep 1710, in Lyme, and died 18 Nov 1763 in Lyme, age 53. He married in Jun 1738 to Mary LEACH, born 9 May 1719 in Windham County, CT, still living in 1797. They lived in Lyme, and had 6 children: Stephen 33, Naomi, Sylvanus 34, Reuben 35, Bethuel 36, and Zenas 37.

Aaron 14 HUNTLEY b: 14 Sep 1710, in Lyme, d: 18 Nov 1763 in Lyme
+ Mary LEACH b: 9 May 1719 in Windham County, CT, d: aft. 1797
i. Stephen 33 HUNTLEY b: 25 Mar 1740 in Lyme, d: 28 Aug 1825
+ Lydia BROCKWAY b: 20 Apr 1755 in Lyme, m: 27 Nov 1777 in Lyme, d: 14 Mar 1815
ii. Naomi HUNTLEY b: 14 Feb 1742/43 in Lyme, d: 30 Dec 1825
+ John TILLOTSON b: 6 Apr 1742/43 in Lyme, d: 11 Mar 1819
iii. Sylvanus 34 HUNTLEY was born 31 Aug 1749 in Lyme, d: 12 Sep 1825 in NY
+ Mehitable
iv. Reuben 35 HUNTLEY b: 25 Sep 1752 in Lyme, d: 13 Aug 1847
+ Lovice HUNTLEY, born 11 Feb 1759 in Lyme, m: 14 Mar 1776, d: 1828 in Lyme
v, Bethuel 36 HUNTLEY b: 15 Oct 1755 in Lyme
+ Eunice CHURCH b: 8 Sep 1778
vi. Jemima HUNTLEY b: 30 Aug 1758 in Lyme, d: 27 Jan 1849 in Marlow
+ Bethuel MILLER b: 19 Sep 1751 in Lyme, m: 11 May 1780 in Alstead, NH, d: 16 Nov 1821 in Marlow

i. Stephen 33 HUNTLEY was born 25 Mar 1740 in Lyme, and died 28 Aug 1825, age 85. He married Lydia BROCKWAY on 27 Nov 1777 in Lyme. Lydia BROCKWAY was born 20 Apr 1755 in Lyme, and died 14 Mar 1815, age 59. They moved to NY between 1779 and 1789, and appeared in the 1790 US Census in Canaan, Columbia, NY, with a household of 2, presumably Stephen and Lydia. They settled in Chenango County, NY by 1813. They had at least 1 son in Lyme, and 2 more born in NY. Stephen 33 and Lydia are buried in East Hill Cemetery, Sherburne, Chenango, NY.

ii. Naomi HUNTLEY was born 14 Feb 1742/43 in Lyme, and died 30 Dec 1825, age 82, She married about 1765 to John TILLOTSON, born 6 Apr 1742/43 in Lyme, died 11 Mar 1819, age 75. Their movements are uncertain, but they had at least 3 children, and appeared in 1810 alongside Naomi's brother Stephen, in Sherburne, Chenango, NY. They are both buried in East Hill Cemetery, Sherburne, Chenango, NY.

iii. Sylvanus 34 HUNTLEY was born 31 Aug 1749 in Lyme, died 12 Sep 1825 in NY. His wife's name was Mehitable. They lived in Marlow, Cheshire, NH in 1790, 1795 and 1800, and by 1810 they had settled in Smithville, Chenango, NY. Sylvanus is buried in Perkins Cemetery, Smithville Flats, Chenango, NY.

iv. Reuben 35 HUNTLEY was born 25 Sep 1752 in Lyme, and died 13 Aug 1847, age 94. He married on 14 Mar 1776 to Lovice HUNTLEY, born 11 Feb 1759 in Lyme, died 1828 in Lyme, age 69. So they were 23 and 17 when they married. They had 7 children, in Lyme.

He was a soldier in the Revolutionary War, serving in the First Company, Capt. PARSONS, Sixth Regiment, Col. PARSONS, Connecticut Continental, and was placed on the pension rolls on 10 Apr 1833, at age 84.

Reuben and Lovice were double 1st cousins, 0x removed and 1x removed, because Lovice was a daughter of Amos 19 HUNTLEY and Phebe MACK, a grandson and g-granddaughter of Aaron 3 HUNTLEY and Mary CHAMPION. The HUNTLEYs has been in Lyme for 115 years by 1776!

Reuben 35 HUNTLEY stayed in Lyme, not following his siblings to Chenango, NY, until 1840, when he appeared as an 89-year-old veteran in the Ezra HUNTLEY household, in New Berlin, Chenango, NY. He is buried in East Hill Cemetery, Sherburne, Chenango, NY.

v, Bethuel 36 HUNTLEY was born 15 Oct 1755 in Lyme. His wife was Eunice CHURCH, born 8 Sep 1778, daughter of Titus CHURCH and Mary LOWELL. Bethuel and Eunice went to Marlow, Cheshire, NH with several other HUNTLEY families, and the 1790 US Census has them in Marlow, with a family of 4. They later settled in Gwillimsbury, near Newmarket, a suburb of Toronto, Ontario, Canada. Bethuel had served in the American Revolution, and appeared on the muster roll of the Second NY Regiment, 29 Jun to 12 Sep 1775, before his future wife was born!

vi. Jemima HUNTLEY was born on 30 Aug 1758 in Lyme, and died 27 Jan 1849 in Marlow, age 90. She married on 11 May 1780 in Alstead, Cheshire, NH to Bethuel MILLER, born 19 Sep 1751 in Lyme, died 16 Nov 1821 in Marlow. Bethuel was a son of Nicodemus MILLER and Phebe HUNTLEY (see below) so Bethuel and Jemima were 1st cousins.

vi. Zenas 37 HUNTLEY was born 16 Jan 1759 in Lyme. He married on 14 Feb 1784 in Lyme, to Elizabeth PECK, born 24 Aug 1751 in Lyme. So he was 25 and she was 33 when they married. He appeared on the 1801 tax list for Sharon, Schoharie, NY. Zenas was sometimes spelled Zenus, and in one marriage record, he was called James.

3. Solomon HUNTLEY was born 1 Sep 1712 in Lyme, and died 11 Feb 1724 in Lyme, at age 11.

4. Deborah HUNTLEY was born 20 Aug 1714 in Lyme, and died 26 Mar 1807, in Lyme. She married on 29 May 1731 in Lyme, to Solomon GEE, who was born about 1698, in Devon, England, and died 13 Apr 1769, in Lyme.

Solomon GEE appeared in Lyme in 1731 when he married Deborah HUNTLEY. His journey from England to New England is the subject of speculation. He gradually acquired more property, which came to be known as the Pattaganset Farm, in Lyme. [SG]

1 Solomon GEE b: Abt. 1698 in Devon, England, d: 13 Apr 1769 in Lyme
... + Deborah HUNTLEY b: 20 Aug 1714 in Lyme, m: 29 May 1731 in Lyme, d: 26 Mar 1807 in Lyme
......2 Sarah GEE b: 1723 in Lyme, d: 13 Dec 1821 in New London, CT
...... + James DOUGLAS b: 5 Apr 1710 in New London, CT, m: 13 Dec 1745 in New London, CT, d: 21 Apr 1803 in New London, CT
......2 Stephen GEE b: abt. 1732 in Lyme, d: 15 Oct 1808 in Marlow, Cheshire, NH
...... + Eunice MOORE b: 1743 in Lyme, m: 1763, d: 29 Mar 1828 in Marlow, Cheshire, NH
......2 Deborah GEE b: abt. 1732 in Lyme, d: 1820 in CT
...... + Silas SMITH b: abt. 1720, d: 8 Jan 1776 in East Lyme
......2 Solomon GEE b: abt. 1736 in Lyme, d: 13 Aug 1803 in Marlow, Cheshire, NH
...... + Martha BINGHAM b: 1739, m: 24 Dec 1758 in Lyme, d: 15 Nov 1828 in Marlow, Cheshire, NH
......2 William GEE b: 05 Apr 1739 in Lyme, d: Sep 1817 in Lyme
...... + Abigail MACK b: 14 Mar 1740 in Lyme, m: 01 Jan 1761 in Lyme, d: Mar 1838 in East Lyme
......2 Ruth GEE b: abt. 1741 in Lyme, d: 7 Apr 1826 in Lyme
...... + William Norman MACK b: 26 Jan 1737/38, m: 12 Jun 1759 in Lyme, d: 25 Apr 1808 in Lyme

Deborah (GEE) SMITH and Stephen GEE were both born about 1732, so they may have been twins.

Deborah GEE married Silas SMITH, who was a soldier in the French and Indian War, 1759, in the Third Company, Major & Captain John SLAPP, First Connecticut Regiment, Major-General, Colonel & Captain Phinehas LYMAN. Silas in buried in the Old Stone Church Burial Ground, in East Lyme.

Brother and sister William and Ruth GEE married sister and brother, Abigail and William MACK. Abigail and William were siblings of Zophar MACK, who married Hepzibah HUNTLEY, daughter of Samuel 13 and Ruth HUNTLEY.

5. Ruth HUNTLEY was born 1 Mar 1716 in Lyme, and died 15 Jun 1805. She married on 5 May 1736 in Lyme, to Samuel 13 HUNTLEY, who was born 23 Dec 1713 in Lyme, and died on 11 May 1770, in Lyme. They had 12 children, in Lyme. Samuel 13 was the son of John 4 HUNTLEY, so Ruth and Samuel 13 were 1st cousins. They were also my 5g-grandparents.

See the Samuel HUNTLEY page.

6. Stephen HUNTLEY was born 28 Feb 1719, in Lyme. He could be the Stephen HUNTLEY who married Phebe TUBBS on 2 Apr 1764 in Lyme.

7. Phebe HUNTLEY was born 1 Mar 1722 in Lyme, and died in 1797, Marlow, NH, age 74-5. She married on 13 Mar 1740, in Lyme, to Capt. Nicodemus MILLER, born 16 Feb 1715, in Lyme, and died 14 Jun 1781, in Marlow, NH, age 66. So they were 18 and 25 when they married. They are buried at the West End Cemetery, in Marlow. They had 7 children, in Lyme.

Nicodemus MILLER married (1) Patience BATES on 21 Feb 1736 in Lyme. Patience was born about 1720 in Haddam, Middlesex, CT, and died 21 Aug 1738 in Lyme, They had one child, Joanna MILLER, born 13 Jul 1737 in Lyme. So Phebe HUNTLEY was his second wife.

Nicodemus MILLER and his family were among the earliest settlers in Marlow, coming from Lyme in the 1760s. He was chairman of the first town meetings, and also first storekeeper, known for keeping a good stock of rum. Marlow was 90 miles inland, with no real roads or bridges leading to it, but only bridle paths, sometimes widened enough for oxcarts. Nicodemus had been a merchant in Lyme, and brought his merchandise with him, which consisted mainly of "Rumbe and Melases" according to his account books.

Phebe HUNTLEY b: 1 Mar 1722 in Lyme, d: 1797 in Marlow
+ Nicodemus MILLER b: 16 Feb 1715 in Lyme, m: 13 Mar 1740 in Lyme, d: 14 Jun 1781 in Marlow
i. Lemuel MILLER b. 21 Jun 1742 in Lyme, d: 1 Dec 1833 in Marlow
+ Mary BECKWITH b: 9 Oct 1743 in Lyme, d: 24 Jun 1823 in Marlow
ii. Esther MILLER, b. 1 Jul 1744 in Lyme, d: 21 May 1830 in Marlow
+ James MUNSELL b: 20 Apr 1743 in Lyme, d: 31 Mar 1821 in Marlow
iii. Pathama MILLER, b. 16 Jul 1746 in Lyme
iv. Phebe MILLER b. 10 Jan 1748/49, d: 29 Jan 1777 in Marlow
+ Zopher MACK b: 7 Feb 1743 in East Lyme, d: 16 Apr 1824 in East Lyme
v. Bethuel MILLER, b. 19 Sep 1751 in Lyme, d: 16 Nov 1821 in Marlow
+ Jemima HUNTLEY b: 30 Aug 1758 in Lyme, m: 11 May 1780 in Alstead, NH d: 27 Jan 1849 in Marlow
vi. Eunice MILLER
vii. Amy Amma Anne MILLER, b. abt 1762 in Lyme, d: 1 Jun 1829 in Marlow
+ Russell 42 HUNTLEY b: 26 Jun 1758 in Lyme, m: 17 Feb 1779 in Alstead, NH, d: 9 Mar 1808 in Marlow

i. Lemuel MILLER was born 21 Jun 1742 in Lyme, and died 1 Dec 1833 in Marlow. He married Mary BECKWITH, born 9 Oct 1743 in Lyme, died 24 Jun 1823 in Marlow. They moved to Marlow with his parents in the 1760s and had 13 children there.

In 1777, Lemuel MILLER was in Col. BELLOWS' unit, Capt. FLOOD's Company, answering the call to reinforce the garrison at Ticonderoga.

ii. Esther MILLER was born 1 Jul 1744 in Lyme, died 21 May 1830, age 85. She married James MUNSEL, born 20 Apr 1743 in Lyme, died 31 Mar 1821, age 77. They are buried in West End Cemetery, Marlow.

James MUNSEL was a Sergeant in BELLOWS' Regiment of New Hampshire Militia, Canfield's Company, on the roll 28 Jun 1777.

iii. Pathama or Patience MILLER was born 16 Jul 1746 in Lyme. Nothing else is known.

iv. Phebe MILLER was born 10 Jan 1748/49 in Lyme, and died 29 Jan 1777 in Marlow. She married Zopher or Zophar MACK, as his 1st wife. Zopher was born 7 Feb 1743 in East Lyme, and died 16 Apr 1824 in East Lyme. He was a son of Ebenezer MACK and Abigail DAVIS (see above).

On 14 Oct 1777 in Alstead, Cheshire, NH, less than 9 months after Phebe died, Zopher married (2) Hepzebah HUNTLEY, daughter of Samuel 13 and Ruth HUNTLEY. Zopher's wives were 1st cousins to each other.

v. Bethuel MILLER was born 19 Sep 1751 in Lyme, and died 16 Nov 1821, age 70. He married on 11 May 1780 in Alstead, Cheshire, NH to Jemima HUNTLEY, born 30 Aug 1758 in Lyme, and died 27 Jan 1849 in Marlow. Jemima was a daughter of Aaron 14 HUNTLEY and Mary LEACH (see above), so Bethuel and Jemima were 1st cousins, sharing grandparents Aaron 5 HUNTLEY and Deborah DE WOLF.

vi. Eunice MILLER may be the one who died on 1 Jun 1821 and was buried in West End Cemetery, Marlow.

vii. Amy Amma Anne MILLER was born about 1762 in Lyme, and died 1 Jun 1829, age 66 or 67, in Marlow. She married on 17 Feb 1779 in Alstead, NH to her 1st cousin Russell 42 HUNTLEY, born 26 Jun 1758 in Lyme, and died 9 Mar 1808 in Marlow, age 49. So she was 16 or 17 and he was 21 when they married. They lived in Marlow and had at least 5 children. Russell was a son of Nathan 15 HUNTLEY and Lucy SMITH (see below).

8. Esther HUNTLEY was born 21 May 1724 in Lyme. She married on 20 May 1741, in Lyme, to William ROBBINS. They had 7 children in Lyme, then removed to Stillwater, Saratoga, NY, where they were still living in 1800. William ROBBINS had married (1) Mary INGLES on 27 Mar 1732 in New London, CT, and she probably died before 1741.

William ROBBINS
+ Mary INGLES m: 27 Mar 1732 in New London, CT
+ Esther HUNTLEY b: 21 May 1724, m: 20 May 1741 in Lyme
i. Phebe ROBBINS b: 27 May 1742 in Lyme, d: 15 Dec1799 in Fayetteville, Onondaga, NY
+ Ezra 25 HUNTLEY b: 4 Oct 1738 in Lyme, m: 14 Mar 1759, d: 19 Feb 1779 in Bangall, Dutchess, NY
+ Nathan GREEN m: 26 Oct 1783 in Bangall, Dutchess, NY
ii. Esther ROBBINS b: 5 Mar 1744 in Lyme
+ Jacob FEYNHOUT b: 1735 in NY, d: 1824 in NY
iii. William ROBBINS b: 10 Sep 1745 in Lyme, d: 20 Jan 1838 in Stillwater, Saratoga, NY
+ Sarah CARPENTER b: 29 Sep 1750 in Dutchess, NY, d: 27 Feb 1803 in Stillwater, Saratoga, NY
iv. Jemima ROBBINS b. 3 Apr 1747 in Lyme, d: 19 Jan 1770 in NY
v. Birnhall ROBBINS b: 20 Apr 1754 in Lyme, d: 1809
vi. Lydia ROBBINS b: 18 Oct 1756 in Lyme
vii. Reuben ROBBINS b: 10 Mar 1759 in Lyme

i. Phebe ROBBINS was born on 27 May 1742 in Lyme, and died 15 Dec1799 in Fayetteville, Onondaga, NY, age 57. She married (1) on 14 Mar 1759 to Ezra 25 HUNTLEY, born 4 Oct 1738 in Lyme, son of Peter 10 HUNTLEY and Sarah ROBBINS (no known relation to William ROBBINS), grandson of John 4 HUNTLEY and Elizabeth PEARSON. So Phebe and Ezra were 2nd cousins, both having great-grandparents Aaron 3 HUNTLEY and Mary CHAMPION. They were 16 and 20 when married. Ezra died on 19 Feb 1779 in Bangall, Dutchess, NY, age 40. At age 41, Phebe married (2) Nathan GREEN, on 26 Oct 1783, in Bangall. It is unclear when Phebe and Ezra went to NY, and whether Phebe had any children, with either husband.

ii. Esther ROBBINS was born 5 Mar 1743/44 in Lyme. She married Jacob FEYNHOUT, born 1735 in NY, died 1824 in NY.

iii. William ROBBINS was born 10 Sep 1745 in Lyme, and died 20 Jan 1838 in Stillwater, Saratoga, NY, age 92. He married Sarah CARPENTER, born 29 Sep 1750 in Dutchess, NY, died 27 Feb 1803 in Stillwater, Saratoga, NY, age 52. They lived in Watervliet, Albany, NY in 1790, and Stillwater, Saratoga, NY in 1800.

iv. Jemima ROBBINS was born 3 Apr 1747 in Lyme, died 19 Jan 1770 in NY, age 22. She was buried in the Baptist Cemetery in Coram, Suffolk County, NY.

v. Birnhall ROBBINS was born 20 Apr 1754 in Lyme, and died in 1809.

vi. Lydia ROBBINS was born 18 Oct 1756 in Lyme. She was admitted as a member of the First Congregational Church in Lyme on 9 Jun 1793.

vii. Reuben ROBBINS was born 10 Mar 1759 in Lyme. He appeared as a Private on the 4 Aug 1778 roster of the 3rd Battalion, Connecticut Militia.

9. Nathan 15 HUNTLEY was born on 2 Jun 1726 in Lyme, and died 30 Apr 1798, in Marlow, NH. He married on 6 Oct 1746, in Lyme, to Lucy/Luce SMITH, born 25 Mar 1729, in Lyme, and died 25 Mar 1802, in Marlow, NH. They are buried in the West End Cemetery, Marlow.

Lucy SMITH was a daughter of Quarles SMITH and Mary TINKER.

Nathan and Lucy had 7 children in Lyme, and moved the family to Marlow, Cheshire, NH in 1761. Nathan 15 HUNTLEY and Eber LEWIS became the first selectmen of Marlow in 1770.

In the Revolution, Nathan served in Capt. Nathaniel STILES' company, New Hampshire militia, and fought in the Siege of Boston.

Nathan 15 HUNTLEY b: 2 Jun 1726 in Lyme, d: 30 Apr 1798 in Marlow
+ Lucy Luce SMITH b: 25 Mar 1729, in Lyme, d: 25 Mar 1802 in Marlow
i. Azuba HUNTLEY b. 28 Jun 1747 in Lyme, d. 31 Oct 1748 in Lyme
ii. Capt. Rufus 38 HUNTLEY b. 4 Jun 1749 in Lyme, d: 27 Apr 1802 in Marlow
+ Esther MOORE d: 17 Mar 1817 in NH
iii. Isaiah 39 HUNTLEY, b. 24 Nov 1751 or 12 Nov 1752 in Lyme, d: 21 Dec 1820
+ Elizabeth CHURCH b: 28 Nov 1753 in Saybrook, CT, m: 5 Sep 1779 in Saybrook, CT, d: 13 Feb 1841
iv. Nathan 40 HUNTLEY, b. 9 Aug 1754 in Lyme, d: 20 Sep 1798 in NH
+ Mary PEARSON b: 28 Feb 1754 in Lyme, d: 15 Sep 1790
+ Eunice ROYCE b: 19 May 1776 in Alstead, Cheshire, NH, m: 16 Nov 1791 in Marlow
v. Luman 41 HUNTLEY b. 15 May 1756 in Lyme
+ Rebecca NOYES m: 27 Oct 1817 in Lisbon, NH
vi. Russell 42 HUNTLEY b. 26 Jun 1758 in Lyme
vii. Elisha 43 HUNTLEY b. 15 Dec 1760 in Lyme, d: 17 Jan 1845 in Marlow
+ Clarissa GUSTIN b: 6 May 1764 in Lyme, m: 11 Jul 1781 in Marlow, d: 23 Sep 1850 in Marlow

i. Azuba HUNTLEY was born 28 Jun 1747 in Lyme, and died 31 Oct 1748 in Lyme, at age 16 months.

ii. Capt. Rufus 38 HUNTLEY was born 4 Jun 1749 in Lyme, died 27 Apr 1802 in Marlow. His wife was Esther MOORE, who died on 17 Mar 1817 in NH.

Rufus was a Captain in the Revolution, and served in CANFIELD's company, along with several of his cousins. He is buried in the West End Cemetery, Marlow.

iii. Isaiah 39 HUNTLEY was born 24 Nov 1751 in Lyme, died 21 Dec 1820. He married on 5 Sep 1779 in Saybrook, CT, to Elizabeth CHURCH, born 28 Nov 1753 in Saybrook, CT, died 13 Feb 1841. They were buried in Duxbury Corner Cemetery, Duxbury, Washington, VT.

iv. Nathan 40 HUNTLEY was born 9 Aug 1754 in Lyme, and died 20 Sep 1798 in NH. He married (1) about 1777 to Mary PEARSON, born 28 Feb 1754 in Lyme, and died 15 Sep 1790, probably in Marlow. They had at least 2 children.

Mary PEARSON was a great-grandchild of Samuel PEARSON and Dorcas JOHNSON, my 7g-grandparents on the other side of my tree. The records for Mary have spellings: PEARSON, PIERSON, PERSON, PARSONS.

Nathan 40 HUNTLEY married (2) on 16 Nov 1791 in Marlow, to Eunice ROYCE, born 19 May 1776 in Alstead, Cheshire, NH, He was almost 37 and she was 15. They had at least 2 children. Eunice was a daughter of Samuel ROYCE and Rebecca BECKWITH.

Nathan and his 1st wife, Mary, are buried in the West End Cemetery, Marlow.

v. Luman 41 HUNTLEY was born 15 May 1756 in Lyme. He married on 27 Oct 1817 in Lisbon, NH to Rebecca NOYES.

vi. Russell 42 HUNTLEY was born 26 Jun 1758 in Lyme, and died 9 Mar 1808 in Marlow, age 49. He married on 17 Feb 1779 in Alstead, to Amy MILLER, born about 1762 in Lyme, died 1 Jun 1829 in Marlow, age 66 or 67.

Amy (Ama, Amma, Anne) was a daughter of Nicodemus MILLER and Phebe HUNTLEY (see above), so Amy and Luman were 1st cousins. They are buried in the West End Cemetery, Marlow.

vii. Elisha 43 HUNTLEY was born 15 Dec 1760 in Lyme, died 17 Jan 1835 in Marlow. He married on 11 Jul 1781 in Marlow, to Clarissa GUSTIN, born 6 May 1764 in Lyme, died 23 Sep 1850 in Marlow.

Clarissa (Clarinda, Clarry, Clary) was a daughter of John GUSTIN and Lydia MACK.

In the Revolution, Elisha served as a Private in Captain Benjamin Bellow's New Hampshire company. After the war, he was a post master, justice of the peace, and hotel-keeper in Marlow. Elisha and Clarissa are buried in the West End Cemetery, Marlow. He was called Hon. Elisha HUNTLEY.

10. Jemima HUNTLEY was born 30 Aug 1728, in Lyme. She married on 26 May 1754, in Lyme, to Eber LEWIS, born 18 Mar 1733 in Derby, CT.

Child:

i. Lydia LEWIS b. 28 Oct 1770, in Lyme

11. Timothy HUNTLEY was born 22 Oct 1731, in Lyme, and probably died young.

Sources

[1790NH] The First US Census, 1790, New Hampshire, transcribed

[DLC] Davison Lumber Company

[ED] Early Dublin : a list of the Revolutionary soldiers of Dublin, N.H. (1901) by Samuel Carroll Derby

[FGM] Florence Griswold Museum

[FSL] Map, First Society of Lyme

[IHH] John Huntley. of Lyme, Connecticut. And His Descendants (1953) by Ivy (Huntley) Horn

[LPH] Lyme Public Hall Association

[MG] Mack genealogy : the descendants of John Mack of Lyme, Conn. with appendix containing genealogy of allied families, etc. (1903) by Sophia Smith Martin

[OLHS] Old Lyme Historical Society

[OPMC] Old Port Medway Cemetery in Nova Scotia, Canada

[SFA] Smith Family Ancestors

[SG] Descendants of Solomon Gee of Lyme, Connecticut (1981) by Charles E. Benjamin

[SM] A narraitve [sic] of the life of Solomon Mack, containing an account of the many severe accidents he met with during a long series of years, together with the extraordinary manner in which he was converted to the Christian faith to which is added a number (1811) by Solomon Mack

[VH] John Huntley, Immigrant of Boston & Roxbury, Massachusetts and Lyme, Connecticut 1647-1677, and Some of His Descendants, Book I (1978) by Virgil W. Huntley

[WRC] Genealogical and family history of the state of Connecticut; a record of the achievements of her people in the making of a commonwealth and the founding of a nation (1911) by William Richard Cutter, et al Vol I Vol II Vol III Vol IV

Last updated 14 Jun 2022 by William Haloupek. Contact haloupek at gmail dot com.