III. RECORDS記録
(1) MEMOIRS OF HYDROGRAPHY INCLUDING Brief Biographies of the Principal Officers who have Served in H.M. NAVAL SURVEYING SERVICE
BETWEEN THE YEARS 1750 and 1885 COMPILED BY COMMANDER L. S. DAWSON, R.N. IlsT T"WO PABTS. Part II.—1830 to 1885. EASTBOURNE, 1885.
p.110
In China and Japan, 120 miles of the Yang-tse-kiang, above Hankow, were explored, as far as Yo-chow-foo, at the entrance of the Tung-ting lake. In addition to this service Captain Ward in the Actaon, and Lieut. Bullock in the Dove, were employed, the former on the coast of Japan, the latter on the shores of the Shantung peninsula. The ActeBon arrived in England early in 1862, the Swallow relieving her in northern China. In Australia, an organised system of coast surveys, the suggestion of Captain Denham of H.M.S. Herald, were set going. Thus we find Commander Sidney in New South Wales, Cox in Victoria, Hutchison in South Australia, Brooker in Tasmania, and Jeffreys in Queens land.
[訳]中国と日本では、長江の上流120マイルほどの漢口まで調査された。この業務に付随して、アクティオン号のワード船長は日本海域を、またドーヴ号のブロック船長は山東半島を調査した。1862年初めにアクティオン号はイングランドに到着し、代わってスワロー号が北部中国に派遣された。
p.139
Progress of Marine Surveys, 1863 to 187k, under Vice-Admiral Sir George Richards. In the year 1863, in which Admiral Washington died, reductions in the surveying service took place owing to the completion of some surveys and the retirement of officers, amongst whom were Captains Spratt, Alldridge, and Thomas. On the English coast, Staff-Commander Calver, in the Porcupine, re-surveyed the estuary of the Thames, and was to continue to trace the changes along the coasts of Suifolk and Norfolk. Captain George Williams, in the Bann, re-surveyed and sounded the Scilly islands, and was to continue completing the deep-sea soundings between the Eddystone lighthouse and Portland.
[訳]1863年から71年の海洋測量の進捗は、ジョージ・リチャーズの指揮の下にあった。1863年、ワシントン大尉が亡くなり、測量業務はこれまでの測量が終わり、士官らちの退職が重なり減少した。イギリスの海岸では、カルバーがポーキュパイン号テームス川河口を測量し、その後サフォークとノーフォークへと続いていった。バン号のジョージ・ウィリアムは、シシリーを再測量し、そしてエディストーン燈台とポートランドの間の深海調査を完了した。
p.143
The Serpent, Commander Bullock, forwarded many valuable contributions to the hydrography of the China Seas, more especially connected with the coasts of Japan. The Nassau,Captain Mayne, sailed from England on this service in the fall of 1866, and had commenced her work in the straits of Magellan, with the co-operation of the Chilian Government. The West Indian survey, carried on by a hired vessel and boats, had been in abeyance
[訳]ブロック艦長の乗ったサーペント号は、日本まで達する中国海域に関する多くの知見をもたらした。1866年秋まで、ナッサウ号に乗ったメイン艦長はイギリスを発ち、この海域の業務に参加した。そして、チリ政府と協力しマゼラン海峡まで調査をした。
p.145
Commander E. W. Brooker, in H.M.S. Sylvia, had been employed on the coasts ofFormosa. He also had searched for, and pronounced not to exist, Harp island and Alceste rock, and settled the position of Botel Tobago island. On the voyage to China, Commander Brooker visited the Andaman islands and Cocos group, rectifying the geographical positions of certain points reported to be considerably in error. He then carried a line of soundings along the coast of Martaban, through the strait of Malacca and up the China sea, from Saigon to Hong Kong.
A report on the lighting of the coast of China between Hong Kong and Shanghai had been furnished by Commander Brooker. The Serpent, Commander C. Bullock, was employed examining anchorages on the coasts of Nipon, with a view to the selection of treaty ports. The ports of Hiogo and Oosaka, in the inland sea, and Nanao harbour on the west coast, were surveyed, and the entrance to Kagosima gulf and the coast about Cape Chichakoff examined.
[訳]ブローカー艦長の乗ったシルヴィア号は、台湾沿岸の測量に従事した。
香港から上海までの燈台設置の報告書は、ブローカー艦長が作成した。サーペント号のブロック艦長は、条約港を選ぶために日本海岸の停泊地の調査に従事した。兵庫と大阪の港、瀬戸内海、西海岸の七尾港、鹿児島湾の入り口、チチャコフ岬などを調査した。
p. 147
Commander Brooker, in the Sylvia, surveyed the coast of Kiu-siu between the port of Nagasaki, through Spex strait, as far as the Strait of Simonoseki. In November, 1868, the Sylvia was called away from Japan and crossed over to the Great Yang-tsze bank to search for a reported shoal at the entrance of the river.
A re-survey of the entrance of the river Min was executed, where great changes were found to have taken place since the former surveys of 1843-54; and a system of buoyage was proposed to the Chinese authorities.
Staff-Commander J. W. Reed, in the Rifleman, examined the eastern edge of the passage from Singapore to Hong Kong, as also some reefs in the Palawan passage, both routes being considered thereby sufficiently known for navigation with ordinary caution. The survey of Balabac strait, between Borneo and Palawan, together with the island of Balabac and Balambangan, were also well advanced. During a visit to the Gulf of Siam, the positions of some doubtful dangers were searched for and found not to exist.
The Rifleman made additions to the survey of Singapore strait, by which that chart was improved, and 30 miles of the Malay peninsula, northward of Singapore, were also resurveyed and sounded. Staff-Commander Reed and his officers observed the total eclipse of the sun, which occurred on the 18th August, 1868, and for this visited Baram point, on the west coast of Borneo, accompanied by Mr. Pope Hennessey, the Governor of Labuan, who went for the same purpose. The Rifleman's observations were communicated to the Royal Society.
Surveys of the Philippine isles and seas adjacent were in course of progress, under the conduct of Captain Claudio Montero, of the Spanish Navy, by whose co-operation with Staff-Commander Reed, and courtesy in sending copies of his surveys immediatel
[訳]シルヴィア号のブローカー艦長は、長崎港からスペックス海峡、そして下関海峡の海岸を測量した。1868年11月、シルヴィア号は日本海域を離れ、長江河口に達した。ミン河の河口部を再測量し、それにより1843年から54年に実施した測量とかなり異なっていることがわかった。
p.149
The Sylvia was employed in surveying portions of the inland sea of Japan. A part of the west shore of the Gulf of Yeddo had also been surveyed. A considerable portion of the Upper Yang-tsze river had been explored and mapped by Lieutenant Dawson, and Mr. Palmer, of the Sylvia. The highest point on this river previously explored was the southern entrance of the Tung-Ting lake, about 125 miles above Hankow, and 700 miles from the sea. These officers had mapped as far as Kwei-chow, or nearly 1,000 miles from the sea. During the year 1869, Commander Brooker was compelled to resign from ill-health and return to England, and Navigating-Lieutenant Maxwell remained in charge. The Sylvia had been re-commissioned in China, and Commander H. C. St. John appointed to conduct the survey.
[訳]シルヴィア号は日本の内海の測量を行った。江戸湾の西海岸部を測量した。シルヴィア号のドーソン、パーマーは長江上流を再測量した。1869年に、ブローカー艦長は健康を害してイギリスに帰国し、マックスウェルが代理艦長となった。その後、シルヴィア号は中国任務が与えられ、セント・ジョンが測量に従事した。
p.152
Commander St. John, in the Sylvia, had completed the passages on either side of the "Conqueror" bank, from Cone island on the east to Mutsu Sima on the west, in the inland sea of Japan. The ports of Mataya and Owasi, on the south coast of Nipon, had been surveyed. Commander St. John furnished observations on the Japan Current and on Typhoons, which prevail in this region.
[訳]シルヴィア号のセントジョン指揮官は、東側のコーン島から、西側のムツシマを通り「征服」岩礁の片側を通過し終え、日本海側に出た。日本海の南岸にあるマツヤとオワシの港の測量を完了した。セントジョン指揮官は日本海海流と台風の観測を準備し、それはこの地域に卓越する。
p.153
Commander H. C. St. John, in the Sylvia, in Japan, had circumnavigated Yezo, the northern island of the group, determined the positions of its salient points, and surveyed the harbours on large scales. The Sylvia also surveyed Nambu harbour in Yamada bay, on the east coast of Nipon.
[訳]シルヴィア号のセントジョン指揮官は北側の島々である蝦夷をぐるりと廻り、航海のポイントを見つけ、大縮尺で港を測量した。シルヴィア号は、日本の東海岸の山田湾の南部港を測量した。
p.154
The Sylvia, Commander St. John, in Japan, surveyed Goza harbour, Muro bay, and the coast and off-lying dangers of Cape Sima, on the east side of Nipon ; subsequently Susaki and Nomi harbours, on the south coast of Sikok, were surveyed. The Boungo channel had been partially sounded, the anchorage off the island of Uimi Sima and adjacent coast examined, and the east part of the strait of Simonoseki re-sounded. In August the Sylvia was ordered to England, where she arrived in April, 1873. On her voyage she carried a line of deep soundings for telegraphic purposes from the entrance of the Gulf of Aden to the Seychelles, thence to Mauritius and Natal on the east coast of Africa.
p.155
The survey of the Japan coast was about to be resumed by Captain St. John in H.M.S. Sylvia, that vessel being again commissioned for the service in February, 1874.
p.162-163
COMMANDER E. W. BROOKER, R.N.1861-1870.
--Edward Wolfe Brooker, born Nov., 1827, entered the Navy April, 1842, as master assistant on board the ShtarwaUr, in which vessel, and the Blazer, both commanded Captain John Washington, he was employed for three years and a half in surveying North sea.
--Joining then, in October, 1846. the Raltlttnakt, Capt. Owen Stanley, he was, duriag in next four years, engaged on similar service in Australia, particularly in surveying the Great Barrier reef on the cast coast, and in examining the islands of the Loaisiade Archipelago and New Guinea.
--In April, 1851, Mr. Brooker, who attained the rank of second-master 16th May, 184.9, was appointed to the Spitfire, Capt. Spratt. In that vessel, in which he was made an Assistant Surveyor in April, 1852, and promoted to the rank of Master, March, 1855, he was employed until the commencement of the Russian war, in surveying the islands in the Great Archipelago, and afterwards in performing surveys of the Dardanelles, the sea of Marmara, the Bosphorus, Varna, the Drobutscha, Alma Bay, Sebastopol, Khersonese bay, Balaklava. Kertch, &c He was present at the embarkation of the troops at Varna and at the landing in the Crimea, at the bombardment of Sebastopol, Oct., 1854, in the expedition to Kertch, and at the capture of Kinburn.
[訳]エドワード・ウォルフ・ブローカーは1827年11月に生まれ、1842年に海軍に入隊し、シュタウェア号に乗船した。次いでブレーザー号にジョン・ワシントン艦長の指揮であった。そして、3年半にわたり北海地方の測量に従事した。1846年にオーウェン・スタンレィ艦長指揮の下でオーストラリア、特にグレート・バリア・リーフの測量に従事した。その後、ロシアとの戦争地に派遣され、ボスポラス海峡からクリミア半島までの水域を測量調査した。
--During the operations connected with the latter affair, Mr. Brooker, then additional master of the Spitfire, was detached on board the Cracker gunboat, Lieut.-Commander J. H. Marryat, for the purpose of determining the course of the channel leading into the river Dnieper, and for laying down buoys along the south side of it, a service which was accomplished so completely that he was in a position to inform the Rear-Admiral of his ability to pilot in the men-of-war, the object being to take the enemy's forts in reverse. Sir H. Stewart, in his despatch addressed to Sir Edmund Lyons, writes, " to do full justice to merit and exertion must be my excuse for presuming to request your most favourable notice of Lieut. Marryat and Mr. Brooker. They have had anxious, difficult, and dangerous work to perform, and they have each of them executed it admirably." For his meritorious conduct he was promoted to the rank of Lieutenant 5th Nov., 1855. He continued in the Spiifin until February, 1856, and then in the Tartarus, Capt. Mansell, in surveying the coast of Syria, where he continued until 1861, in July of which year he was appointed to the charge of the coast survey of Tasmania. Having surveyed George's bay and Hobartown, and made the necessary arrangements for following up the triangulation of the whole of the coasts of that colony, in March, 1863, the survey was suspended, owing to the local government of Tasmania failing to vote the necessary funds for bearing half the working expenses.
--On his return to England he received the annual surveying promotion to the rank of Commander on the 1st January, 1864, and was subsequently appointed to the charge of the survey of Portsmouth harbour and bar, where he continued until appointed in 1866 to the command of H.M.S. Sylvia, for surveying service in North China and Japan. The Sylvia did good work on the coast of Formosa, on the west coast of Nipon between Nagasaki and Shimonoseki, in the inland sea of Japan, and at the entrance of the river Min in China.
--The President of the Royal Geographical Society, in his annual address for the year 1870, marked that "During the last year (1869) Commander Brooker, who had ably conducted North China and Japan survey up to that time, was compelled to resign from ill-healthed return to England." His illness ended fatally, and he died in the course of the year 1870.
[訳]
--Commander Brooker, who was an admirable water-colour marine artist, as well as a clever surveyor, wore the Crimean medal and Sebastapol clasp. He had been created a Knight F the Legion of Honour, and received the order of Medjidie of the fifth class.
The following charts were published from his surveys t—.
Tasmania.-- George's Bay. Hobartown. Strait.
S.C. England.-- Cowes Harbour
Japan.-- Atsusi-no-o-sima to Mats-sima.
Hirado-no-Seto (Spex Strait) to Simonoseki
Kurusima-no-Seto.
. . N. entrance to Spex Strait and Yebukuro-no-
Minato Harbour.
Kagosima Gulf. Yobuko Harbour.
Sagistu-no-ura. Min River (entrance).
(2) HYDROGRAPHIC NOTICE. [No. 11.], 1890.
IN THE LINSGHOTEN GROUP-SOUTH OF JAPAN.
D. N. M., 1866, Part I, p. 166.
The commander of the Netherland war steamer Medusa, on a cruise from Nagasaki to Yokohama, discovered a reef, indicated by discoloration of the water and high breakers, and about two miles in extent north and south. He states that it should be placed on the British Admiralty Chart No. 2412, in lat. 30° 13’ N., long. 130° 04:’ E, (which is eight miles due north of the Firasc or Lapelin Rocks.)
JAPAN.
The following information is obtained from British Admiralty Hydrographic Notice No. 43, 1870. and from British Admiralty Charts.
KIUSIU, WEST COAST—INLAND SEA—GULF OF YEDO NII’ON AND YESSO ISLANDS.
The following remarks on the navigation of the west coast of Kiusiu Island are by the late Commander E. W. Brooker, H. B. M. Surveying vessel Sylvia, 1869.
(All Bearings are jllagnetic. Variation 3° 30' Westerly in 1870.) KIUSIU, WEST COAST.
GENKAI-NADA is the sea'comprised between Iki-sima, ()ro-no-sima, and Kosime-no-o'osima, and the mainland of Kuisiu. With the exception of a rock having only eight feet at low water, lying three-fourths of a mile southward of the low flat rocks of Idzumi, off the eastern coast of Iki-sima, the western portion of this sea is free from all dangers, the soundings varying from twenty to thirty fathoms with generally a sandy bottom ; coral and shells are occasionally obtained, but very little gravel.
In the eastern waters of the Genkai-Nada, in which a depth of twenty fathoms, and under, is found, there are three tidal and sunken dangers, viz.: the Dove, Ellis, and Swain reefs, and as they are nearly awash at high water, and steep-to, great care in the navigation is required in thick weather. In ordinary weather the usual route taken by steamers is easy and safe.
TIDES.—The fiood streams meet otl' Hakosaki about the center of the Genkai-nada, and the ebb separate. The velocity at springs is one and a half knots.
INLAND SEA.
The following remarks on the navigation of the Inland Sea are by Navigating Lieutenant W. F. Maxwell, H. B. M. surveying vessel Sylvia, 1870:‘( Variation 4° 0' Westerly in 1870.)
In these directions a description is given, first, of the islands and coasts in the immediate vicinity of the general track through the Inland Sea, embracing the channels through the archipelago which divides Misima-nada and Bingo-nada, known as Aogi-seto, Kuruma-no-seto, and Kurusima-no-seto; followed by directions from Bingo-nada to Hiogo, and through the Kii Channel.
NORTHEAST COAST OF JAPAN.
The following information relative to the coast of Nipon and Yesso Islands, by Captain Du Petit Thonars of H. I. M. S Dupleiw, has been translated and forwarded by Navigating Lieutenant William F. Maxwell, of II. M. Surveying vessel Sylvia.‘ (Variation 3° lVeslerlg/ in 1870.)
SENDAI BAY lies on the east coast of Nipon in lat. 38° 20' N.; the land north of it is deeply indented, high, and steep, and apparently thinly populated, fishing boats being seen only off Simidzu. Most of the bays are open to seaward.
At ten miles from the coast, inland, there is a high,' easily recognizable mountain, about four thousand six hundred feet high, in lat. 39° 28' N., long. 141° 41' E., approximately; unfortunately it is seldom uncovered, and points of recognition on this coast are much wanted.
At the entrance of a bay, in lat. 39° 18’ N. there is a mass of white rocks, that at a distance resembles a town, a little northeast of a wooded isle, halt- a mile in extent, quite close to the shore. A similar island is seen five or six miles south of the port of Namb'u.
PORT OF NAMBU.—The bay of this name, in lat. 39° 30' N., opens out between two mountains, of one thousand six hundred and forty feet in height; it is a large basin, well sheltered, but unknown generally to Europeans; there is said to be a danger on the north side of the passage.
The high land on the north may be easily recognized when coming from the northward or southward, in following the coast of which, it forms the most salient point. Outside the port the water changes its color, but there is no bottom in thirty-eight fathoms at two miles from the shore.
MIYAKQ—The Port of Miyako opens at eight miles north of Nambu. The Point of Tayomani that forms it is surmounted by a conical hill. On leaving Miyako, the coast runs to the N. N.E.T and changes its aspect gradually. Instead of steep hills falling abruptly to the sea there are long plateaus with gradual slopes, ending in low white cliffs.
CAPE DE VRIES is low and fiat, about three hundred and thirty feet high, and is remarkable from the. way it stands out between two bays. The Dupleiz sailed along this coast from Cape Kiori to Cape Vries, ata distance of from two to four miles, and saw no danger except close tothe shore.
AWOMORI BAY.—The Bay of Awomori, a vast interior basin at the north end of Nipon, opens on the south side of Tsugar Strait. According to the Japanese, no hidden dangers exist. Toward the center the water is too deep to anchor, but at two miles from the shore along the east and west coast there is generally nineteen to twenty-two fathoms mud, with gravel or sand round Natsu-sima, the point on the southern side of the bay. The coast can generally be approached within half a mile, but often the depth decreases suddenly, so that without a pilot orachart it is not advisable to go nearer than eleven fathoms. The entrance is five miles wide, with highland on both sides. Off the salient part of the west point, some half-tide rocks lie one cable from the shore.
On the east coast is the Singapore Rock, and the dangers ofi' Toriwisaki, that ought to he more carefully avoided as the land at its extreme is lower than the rest. The outer coast to Cape Kusodomari, the eastern point of entrance, is steep, sharp, and well populated; while after rounding it and entering the bay, creeks more or less deep, sandy beaches, and fishing vilages are found,
BEN-TEN-SlMA.—At two miles S.E. } E. from Kusodomari, and at five and a half cables from the shore are the two islets of Ben-ten-sima, the smallest being nothing more than a mere pinnacle rock about one hundred feet high. A rock breaks at one cable S. S.W. from the island. There is a passage for junks between the islets and the shore, but the Japanese said it would be imprudent to take it with a large ship. A depth of thirty-three fathoms was found one mile south of the islets. On leaving Ben-ten-sima, the coast runs E. N.E. eighteen miles, then turns toward the south for an equal distance, the Port of Ando being in the angle so formed. In this part of Awomori Bay are long sandy beaches and numerous villages, the largest being Kawa-atchi, at the entrance of a river and generally with five or six junks at anchor before it. Toward the angle of the bay, a considerable range approaches the the coast, the summit nearest to Ando being three thousand one hundred and twenty feet high and visible from nearly all the bay. To the east ward of these 'mountains the land is very low and has the aspect of a 'uniform plain covered with wood; beyond this the summit of Whale back is seen.
BAY OF ANDO.—The Bay of Ando is open to the south, and there is no water at its head. vessels can go in until the peak over Ando bearsW. by N. g N ., where there is anchorage in six and a half to eight fathoms mud. The bottom here rises abruptly.
Southwest of the anchorage there is a fine basin, sheltered by a bank of sand running parallel to the coast. It may be entered safely by steering up mid-channel until abreast of the sandy point, when the northeast coast must be kept on board until abreast the second village, where there is good anchorage in three and three-fourths to six fathoms, muddy bottom.
The sandy tongue and the southwest shore of the bay have off them banks of mud and muddy sand that reduce the space for vessels of ordinary dimensions to eight cables by two and a half cables. The entrance is nearly two cables wide. The extreme of the sandy point
covers a short distance at high water. The large village on the northeast side of the interior basin can be approached within a cable, where anchorage may be had in five and one-third fathoms. I
The Japanese villages are poor, their inhabitants subsisting by fishing. Six junks were moored before the principal village (Kanaya) and there was a large one being built.
'Supplies.—The slopes of the hills are partly cultivated and partly wooded with a species of pine. The Dupleix bought wood here for steam purposes, and also fresh provisions. Water fiows down the mountains by many streamlets, and is easily obtained; also at the head of the bay fish is plentiful. The place belongs to the Prince of Nambu, and is part of the district of Tanabu.
On leaving Ando the coast is low and uniform, an isolated hill one thousand three hundred feet in height rising from the middle of the space between the bay and the sea. At twenty miles south of Ando it defiects gradually to the northeast and forms the Bay of Nofitsi.
Tides.—The tides are felt more at Ando than at any other part of the bay, and have a strength of one and three-fourths knots. It is evidently their action that has formed the bay.
NOFITSI lies in the southeast hight of Awomori Bay; toward the south the land is tolerably low and uniform. The anchorage may be recognized some distance off by an isolated wood, that stands out against the sky. The anchorage is in a large semi-circular indentation in front of the town at six cables from the shore in six and a half fathoms gravel. The depth decreases rapidly from eleven fathoms; the holding ground is fair; a heavy sea comes in with northerly winds. On the northwest side of ' the bay, two and a half miles from the town, is a bank of large stones running out four cables. The end is nearly awash and breaks often. The cast part is composed of little red clifi's with sandy beaches between.
(3) The Nature, June 5, 1873, p.111.
The proceedings of the Asiatic Society of Bengal contain remarks on winds-, typhoons, 4c, on the south coast of Japan, by Commander II. C. St. John, 11. M.S. Sylvia. The most prevalent winds in the southern parts of Japan are from the north-east. Throughout an entire year the proportion was as follows, taking 1,000 hours as an index : —Between N. and E., 500 ; between N. and W., 200 ; between S. and E., 100 ; between S. and W., 0 99. During April, May, June, July, August, and September, N.E. winds prevail, hauling more easterly in June, July, and August. In August and September S. E. winds are more frequent than during any other months. In October variable winds prevail, and the N.W. wind begins. During November, December, January, and February the N. VV. winds prevail and blow hard. In March the N.W. and N.E. winds are equally distributed. The S. W. winds most frequently occur during the early parts of September. It appears the winds on the southern coasts of Japan are easterly during April (spring), and hauling Jto the S. as the summer approaches, pass through S . and \V. to N.W. during winter, coming again through N. to N.E. and E. in spring and summer. Typhoons occur between June and October, inclusive. From the middle of August to the middle of October they may b; expected to occur most frequently. Thiusual tracks of these storms on the Japan coasts appear very regular ; approaching from the S. E. travelling about N. W.
--On reaching the hot stream in about the latitude of the lionin Islands, or between here and the Foochoo Islands, they be^iu to curve to the north, and following the course of the Kuro Siwo, strike the south coasts of Nipon. Owing chiefly to the high land along the coast, the northern disc of the storm beco lies much flattened in, causing more easterly wind than would occur if the storm were in mid ocean. Retaining the course of the stream, they pass along in a north-easterly course, and, if not broken up previously, pass out into the Pacific Ocean on reaching Inaboya saki.
--February 26, 1874, p.335.
Edinburgh
Scottish Meteorological Society, Jan. 29.—Mr. M. Home, of Wedderburn, in the chair.—From the report of the council it appears that two new stations, viz., Broadlands, PeebTeshire, and Ochtertyre, Crieff, have been added to the society's stations, and that Kettisis and Caimdow have ceased to be stations. Thus the number of stations in connection with the society is the same as at last meeting, viz., 92 in Scotland, 5 in England, 4 on the Continent, 2 in Iceland, 1 in Faro, and I in South America.
--Observations have also been begun to be made for the society at Melstad, in the north of Iceland, and at Fairlie Plains, Paroo River, near the northern watershed of the River Darling, Australia. The council had had offers of many more stations, some in most eligible districts ; but the establishment of these would have entailed additional expenditure which the society's funds would not justify. Teachers of several schools had also made known their wish to observe for the society, provided they were furnished with instruments, at the same time proposing to introduce into their schools some instruction in meteorology. The council, however, had been obliged to decline these applications for want of funds. The membership of the society is at present 560. In room of the three members of council who retired, Prof. Alexander Dickson, Dr. J. Robson- Scott, and Mr. George Hope, of Broadlands, were elected.
--An application has been made to the council by Mr. Colin McVean on behalf of the Government of Japan for advice regarding the establishment of a system of meteorological observations in Japan. In answer to this application, the council has forwarded a memorandum regarding suitable instruments, their position, hours of observation, the establishment of a central observatory, inspection of stations, publications, and special observations of storms.
--Mr. Buchan submitted a second report of the committee app jinted to carry out the Marquis of Tweeddale's proposal to investigate the relations of the herring- fisheries to meteorology.
--The committee had, with the assistance of the Hon. Bouverie F. Primrose, of the Fishery Board, obtained complete returns of the daily catch of herrings and state of the weather from all the fishing districts of Scotland during the past season. Thirty-five weather map; at 9 p.m., specially constructed with reference to this question, and showing the number of boats out fishing in each district each day and the average catch of each boat, were shown to the meeting. Some interesting relations between the catches of the different districts and the prevailing weather were pointed out; and as these were in general accordance with the results stated in the first report, presented in July last, it is highly probable that when the statistics of three or four years' fishings similar to the very satisfactory returns of the past year have been collected, valuable conclusions will be arrived at.
--Mr. Thomas Stevenson, in bringing before the meeting a proposed inquiry regarding storms, remarked that the barometric gradients hitherto ascertained having been deduced from readings at stations many miles apart, necessarily could not give more than a rough appioximative gradient. What is wanted in order to get a formula for computing the velocity of the wind due to a given gradient is, as he (Mr. Stevenson) suggested in to have a string of stations at short distances apart. It is now proposed to establish such storm stations, arranged in lines radiating from Edinburgh for a distance of about twenty miles, and it is believed that in addition to the existing stations of the Scottish Society many farmers and others possess good barometers, which could be compared with the society's standard.
--It is proposed that observations of the instruments and of the weather should be limited to the periods during which storms last, and a special schedule for the observations had been prepared.
--Mr. Buchan gave an account of the proceedings of the Meteorological Congress held at Vienna in September last, to which he and Mr. Scott, of the Meteorological Office, London, had been sent as delegates from the British Government.
(4) The History of Anglo-Japanese Relations Volume 1: The Political-Diplomatic Dimension, 1600-1930
Edited by Ian Nish Professor Emeritus of International History London School of Economics and Political Science and Yoichi Kibata Professor University of Tokyo Japan With assistance from Tadashi Kuramatsu
Foreword by Chihiro Hosoya and Ian Nish,
From Conflict to Co-operation: British Naval Surveying in Japanese Waters, 1845-82 W.G. Beasley (Professor Emeritus of Far Eastern History, University of London)
Commodore Lord John Hay, to tell him that 'serious difficulties' had arisen. The Tokugawa government had informed him that the eastern shore of Owari Bay, as far down as 30° N, was not under its own juris-diction, but that of the emperor, who had insisted that no surveying vessels should approach it (this was the area in which the Ise shrines were located). Not to comply with the court's wishes, Alcock considered, would disturb the political relations between the Tokugawa Shogun and the emperor, something which Britain would wish to avoid. Since surveying was not a treaty right in any case, there seemed no alternative but to instruct Ward not to visit this part of the coast. Edo had offered in return to carry out a survey of it themselves 'and place it at our disposal'." As a result of this intervention, Actaeon's survey was less complete than mere lack of time might otherwise have made it.
The first part, taking in Sagami Bay and the Izu peninsula, including Shimoda, was fairly thorough. From there the ships moved across to the southern tip of the Ise peninsula at the beginning of October, by-passing Owari Bay, to survey the eastern entrance to the Inland Sea. The subsequent passage through the Inland Sea itself, followed by the Shimonoseki Straits, took only the first two weeks of November, so the work cannot have been done in any detail, even allowing for the help which Ino Chukei's map provided. The Japanese officials landed at Nagasaki on 18 November, the day after the ships arrived there. Less than a week later Actaeon left, homeward bound. She reached Spithead in June 1862.
By the end of 1861, therefore, British ships had made satisfactory surveys of the three principal treaty ports (Nagasaki, Yokohama and Hakodate), together with their approaches (over varying distances); had conducted a patchy survey of the route from Yokohama to Nagasaki along the Pacific coast and through the Inland Sea; and had made soundings and observations at scattered points elsewhere in Japan, when opportunity offered. The information thus made available was by no means adequate, even for a trade still in its infancy. For example, many foreign vessels had to engage Japanese as pilots, despite doubts about their competence and problems with the language. Even warships did so. Both the French and American ones which sailed to the Shimonoseki Straits in 1863 to afford a measure of protection to their country's merchant ships, which had been fired on by the Japanese coast batteries there, did so, it appears, with the help of Japanese pilots provided by 'local authorities'.
Vice Admiral Augustus Kuper, who took a substantial British force to Kagoshima the same summer, in order to demand satisfaction for an attack on British citizens near Yokohama in 1862 — he ended by bombarding the city —later informed the Admiralty that having been 'unable to obtain any correct information respecting the Gulf or Bay of Kagosima', and having as pilot only la Japanese who had been once at that place', he had found it necessary 'to approach with great caution'. So cautious was he, indeed, that the squadron was overtaken by nightfall on its way in: `we had to feel our way for nearly two hours, seeking for an anchorage'.'5 Despite such ignorance, no further surveys of Japan were undertaken before the end of 1867. Two factors then made action seem desirable. One was the incidence of shipwrecks on the Japanese coast, among them the loss of the MO steamer Singapore, which struck an uncharted rock 12 miles out of Hakodate in August 1867.
Another was the knowledge that Hyogo (Kobe) and Osaka were to be opened to foreign trade on 1 January 1868. Since these places would give access to the commercial heart of Japan, it was confidently predicted that the opening of them would give rise to a considerable increase in merchant shipping. It was in these circumstances that the steam sloop, HMS Sylvia (Commander Edward Brooker), was ordered to Japan at the end of 1867. She arrived in Osaka Bay on 27 December, but this proved not to be well timed. First, the Commander in Chief, Vice Admiral Sir Henry Keppel, required her assistance, and that of her boats, to give general support to the squadron he had assembled for the opening of Hyogo and Osaka. No sooner had that event taken place than the political situation in Japan was thrown into confusion by a coup d'etat in Kyoto on 3 January 1868, by which the Tokugawa were overthrown.
Since the local fighting that this provoked quickly developed into civil war, Keppel's decision to release the Sylvia to her surveying duties was not immediately effective. Indeed, it was no longer clear when or where surveying would be possible. Sylvia was sent to Yokohama to coal, then to Shanghai. When she did return to Japan (21 March) it was to Nagasaki, where she was based for the rest of the season. By that time the civil war had spread to northern Japan — it was to continue intermittently until the surrender of the last Tokugawa adherents in Hokkaido in the early summer of 1869 — so surveys were confined during 1868 to Kyushu, where the ship worked her way round the coast from Nagasaki to Fukuoka, via Hirado, Karatsu and Imari. This done, she left on 28 October to visit Foochow, checking on a reported shoal at the entrance to the Yangtse while en route to winter in Hong Kong.
This was the beginning of a lasting commitment to surveys in Japan on the part of the hydrographic service. Sylvia returned there for the 1869 season, spending the spring and early summer in the Inland Sea, based in Kobe, and going back again for the months of September to December. This enabled her to carry out a much more thorough examination of the area than Actaeon had had time to do in 1861. In July and August, and again at the end of the year, she operated out of Yokohama. It was not until 21 February 1870 that she sailed for Hong Kong for a refit and repairs. In May 1870, because Commander Brooker had had to go back to England on account of illness, Sylvia was recommissioned in Hong Kong with a new commanding officer, Commander Henry St. John, and a replacement crew sent out from home.
By the end of May, however, she was back in Japan, resuming the surveys of the Inland Sea, which were pushed as far west as Hiroshima. She paid some attention also to the southern part of the Ise peninsula. This time the work continued all through the winter, that is, until she moved to Yokohama in the middle of March 1871. Keppel had reported to the Admiralty in June 1869 that Sylvia was being afforded `every facility' by the new Japanese government, despite some restrictions — presumably on the areas she could enter — imposed by the existence of 'rebellion' in the north.16 In 1870 there were signs that cooperation might be expanded. In July of that year the British minister, Sir Harry Parkes, informed the Foreign Office that he had received an official request in October 1869 for help in securing the assistance of British surveyors to join a Japanese survey of the coasts of Ezo (Hokkaido). Officers due to be paid off from the Sylvia, when she recommissioned, were apparently what the Japanese government had in mind.
Parkes was in favour of the scheme. Those were dangerous coasts, he said, still little known, as was demonstrated by the wreck of HMS Rattler in the La Perouse Strait in September 1868. Moreover, Ezo was close to the Russian settlements in Sakhalin, which made it strategically important to both Britain and Japan. When consulted, however, the new Commander in Chief, Vice-Admiral Sir Henry Kellett, had expressed some doubts. He was reluctant to release British officers for a service of this kind, partly because they might not find the kind of facilities they would need, partly because of the personal risks to which they might be exposed. He would prefer to see the survey carried out by Sylvia, once she had completed her 1870 programme in the Inland Sea: the Japanese, after all, could be asked to give active support to her, and perhaps contribute part of the cost.
Since this had proved acceptable to Japan, Parkes reported, a survey on these terms could begin in the spring of 1871.'7 The Foreign Office and the Admiralty approved the arrangement.18 The Admiralty readily accepted that the survey was needed. Ezo, it stated, `like a great portion of other parts of Japan', was still `entirely unsurveyed', being 'merely shown on the Admiralty Charts from a map made by the Japanese themselves ... wanting in all nautical require-ments' (a judgement that seems unduly dismissive of the efforts of the Saracen in 1855). Nevertheless, the Navy wished to lay down a number of conditions.
The Japanese must provide an escort vessel for the Sylvia; furnish local pilots; and give suitable protection to landing parties. For his part, the commanding officer of the Sylvia would be instructed in the usual terms to avoid becoming entangled in any dispute between 'the Japanese authorities and the subjects of any foreign Power who might be involved in similar pursuits'. Despite this somewhat supercilious beginning, all went well in the event. Sylvia left Yokohama on 5 April 1871, arriving at Hakodate on the 12th. During the spring and summer, working in consort with a Japanese ship known to the British as the Keang-su, she carried out surveys up the southeast coast of Ezo as far as Nemuro, then round the corner into the straits between Nemuro and Kunashiri.
This much had been completed by late August, when the weather was expected to deteriorate. Early in September she sailed south to Nambu, where she spent three weeks surveying, then on to Yokohama. There were no complaints about Japanese co-operation during these operations, either ashore or afloat, but the Ezo survey had always been understood to be a temporary diversion from Sylvia's main task. To this she now reverted. Between mid-October 1871 and the following August she spent two short periods in Owari Bay and round the coast of the Ise peninsula, filling the gap left by the Actaeon in 1861; another working her way from Kobe southward round Shikoku, returning through the Bungo Straits and the Inland Sea; and finally made a transit through the Inland Sea to Nagasaki, surveying as she went.
The sequence was broken in December 1871 by a visit to Yokohama for repairs, for which she had to be docked at Yokosuka. They seem not to have been completely successful, for when she arrived in Hong Kong from Nagasaki at the beginning of September 1872, she went into dock again, then was ordered home. The voyage ended at Spithead on 29 March 1873. Just before Sylvia left Japan there had been a moment of diplomatic embarrassment on the subject of surveys. In February 1872 the British
legation in Tokyo sent the Japanese Foreign Ministry a letter of thanks for the support given to the Sylvia in Ezo during 1871, offering further assistance, should that be required. A reply on 21 March declined this offer, on the grounds that Japan planned to begin 'exact surveys' of her own. In these circumstances, it was said, it would not be necessary 'to give any trouble to the British surveying ships'.
The choice of words seems to have caused umbrage at the Admiralty. In commenting on it, an Admiralty letter to the Foreign Office in May observed that it would not be 'to the interests of British commerce and navigation' to with-draw from surveys in Japan 'until the Government of Japan have given some decided proofs of their ability to conduct operations which have hitherto never been conducted by any but the maritime nations of Europe and the U.S. of America'. The work begun by Sylvia would need to be continued.° The Japanese decision in favour of surveys of its own in 1872 did not in fact reflect hostility to foreigners, such as had been encountered by Samarang in 1845 and Mariner in 1849. Rather, it reflected aspirations to national sovereignty in an age of reform and hoped-for treaty revision.
The process of creating a modern navy, officered by men trained in Europe or America, had already started. Steps had also been taken to establish a lighthouse service (under the direction of a British engineer, R.H. Brunton). Japanese surveys of the Japanese coast were a logical concomitant. Nor did British naval irritation last very long, or result in public disagreement. Sylvia, having been refitted, was re-commissioned in February 1874 and sent back to Japan again under the command of Henry St. John (who was promoted to Captain later in the year). She continued to carry out surveys, mostly in the western part of Honshu and round the coasts of Kyushu, until 1880. She was then replaced by the Flying Fish (Lieut. R.E. Hoskyn) in time for the 1881 season.
During that year and the next the new ship operated in Ezo and the north, before transferring her attention to Korea. Meanwhile the Japanese surveys had also been proceeding. In the summer of 1877 the British admiral on the station, who apparently did not share London's doubts about their quality, asked if he might have a set of the resulting charts. These were promptly handed over. At the same time the Japanese navy (through the legation in Tokyo) asked if it could have in exchange a set of Admiralty charts, covering both Japan and Ryukyu (Loochoo). This time the Admiralty made no demur. Indeed, it not only added charts of the Kurils, Sakhalin and Korea to those that had been requested, but also suggested that this kind of exchange, which had been intermittent