The Eyes of the community: Community dogs and vets, what resources do we have to help?
The Eyes of the community: Community dogs and vets, what resources do we have to help?
Tyra Joelise Lovato
Laguna Pueblo, Navajo Nation and Kewa Pueblo
Tyra J. Lovato
Laguna pueblo, Navajo nation, and Kewa pueblo.
Jeannette Armstrong
The article “Sharing One Skin” from Jeannette Armstrong she says what she talks about in this section is to see what different keys that her community has and what the outside world has to offer. She first explains what the word ‘Okanagan’ means and each syllable means who they are as people, their spirit is, and what they do to keep themselves together. She also talks about different things that in her culture and community have to stay alive, and has many stories to show and tell. When reading this section ‘The Four Capacities of self’ physical, emotional, thinking-intellectual, and spiritual are ways to create peace and good health to all creation. When talking about society it’s completely the opposite and it has its gray areas. Where people just stay on their phone and never interact like she would in her community. How many people can ignore what is around them and not say a thing.
Armstrong, Jeanette. “Sharing One Skin: The Okanagan Community,” in Jerry Mander and Edward Goldsmith (eds), The Case Against the Global Economy. San Francisco, CA, Sierra Club Books, 1996. Pp 460-470.American Indian , Republic. Native Americans Are Not All the Same: An Exploration of Indigenous Diversity. 22 Oct. 2021.
"How has place names impact the way we see landscape?"
In the article “How has place names impact the way we see landscape” by the High Country News, they interviewed a woman named Laura Tohe who is from the Navajo Nation. She explains that most of the land is named in the Dinè language, which has a meaning, story or reason and going forth most of it is related to history. When changing most of the American names because in the Navajo language they would put “yee” at the end of a bad person to not give them power or anything special means to their names. American names that had repeatedly reminded them of the colonizers that had really decimated their land and what it stands for. Most of the lands that had started out from the colonizers, everyone only knew the stereotype of what they know from just books that are from non-native speakers, writers and more. Most of the deeper meanings are kept within the sacred hands of the people who surround them.
This article was a little tough for me to understand and to read, mostly because there were a lot of things that were going on. As being part of the Navajo nation this was a learning experience and to know that most of these terms may affect the way most natives see the land. One good quote that stood out to me was ‘Convoluted stratification of inaccurate histories and dubious Indigenous stories reflects the many layers of colonization: dispossession, removal, abuse, environmental and cultural degradation, followed by feeble attempts at restitution” said by Cash Cash.
Citation:Toastie, Tony Abeyta May 1, 2022 From the print edition. “How Place Names Impact the Way We See Landscape.” High Country News - Know the West, 1 May 2022
Lovato, Tyra.The Scenery of the Land. Personal Photo. 23 July 2022.
History of women veterinarians
The “History of women veterinarians” article written by Nicky Vincent. They write the evolution of different women becoming veterinarians and MRCVS. There were 2 women that had a lot of trouble and success during the 19th century. A lady named Aileen was the first to experience the complications, such as making testimonies which led to a personal recommendation to the founder of veterinary school, taking an appointment twice for the RCVS to recognize her practices in 1915, during World War I,until they couldn’t deny her entry in 1919. Mary Brancker was the second to experience the second war, and the foot and mouth outbreak in 1967 which really helped her get many awards. She became part of RCVS in 1977 and was awarded with an “Honorary doctorate by the University of Stirling” in 1996.
In this article there were some few good points and great history that really led me to believe that there has been a lot that happened within the topic I chose. My community veterinarian has been in the military, and it seems that she has gone beyond like these women who had to take classes and their education a step further in order to have their success be recognised. Learning that most women couldn’t work like they would a long time ago is still a thing in my community. We don’t know how long it is going to take for my pueblo to recognise our veterinarian work and what she can do, and provide for our community. As the years go on, we may have to just wait what will happen until we can take that extra step forward.
Vincent , Nicky. “History of Woman Veterinarians .” Vettime, 12 Aug. 2013, https://www.vettimes.co.uk/app/uploads/wp-post-to-pdf-enhanced-cache/1/history-of-women-veterinarians.pdf.
Lovato, Tyra.Three Dogs. Personal Photo. 21 Nov. 2022.
Lovato, Tyra.Scared Dog. Personal Photo. 21 Nov. 2022.
"Fellow creatures:Kris Shares a Story” by an unknown author shares a section of a story about a woman by the name of Kris. “It is generally believed that humans and domesticated dogs have lived together for more than 30,000 years.” For humans and dogs and other animals to be together that long is a strong bond in which Kris states in an interview she was in “The key question is bonding. If we could figure out how to do that, then they would keep them. Homeless person might give food to the dog before himself, but a person who paid $1,200 for a puppy will happily give it away. How do we get them to bond?” In the present day we don’t see them the way we used to now these days. Many shelters have to maintain balance between what animals can survive and the ones that don’t.
When reading this, I didn't really get to read as much as I wanted to, but within a few paragraphs I felt very connected to the story. Kris tells a story of her own experience in California and gives us insight into the numbers of stray dogs and cats. These were a few compelling stories. As she talks more about animals, it becomes more and more about the negative side of how humans keep these animals off the streets and how to make them more domesticated.
Unknown author. “Fellow Creatures: Kris Tells a Story”. https://scholar.google.com/. Web Unknown date.
Lovato, Tyra.Smile. Personal Photo. 3 Sept. 2022.
Domesticated Dogs
Artificial selection, That means we humans, for thousands of years, selected the dogs we liked the most because of their fluffy fur or friendly personality or intelligence or even ferocity,and we kept those dogs around, and we bred them.” Jacqueline Howard says in this short video. By saying this she meant for 10,000 years we maintained the same dogs of what our ancestors have chosen for who they are and what they can do to help their family out. She also said “In a span of less than 10,000 years,breeders have changed dogs' personality traits and body shapes so they'd have aspects that we preferred.A dog may have been bred for its hunting and herding behavior.” and this is really true because we have been changing the breed of a specific type of dogs or animals that we may want to protect us.
In this video it is really important to know why we choose these different types of dogs and why they are really unique in their own way. Most people don’t really think about this, not about why they chose the dog, but what is the history behind it. In the community we have what we call “rez dogs” and it’s because they are our own alarm system. Jacqueline Howard said humans may have domesticated these dogs and wanted more from the breed that has what they want into their own dog.
Bighistoryproject, Jacqueline, director. Jacqueline Howard: History of Domestic Animals | Big History Project. YouTube, YouTube, 8 July 2015, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yCQqiO5zXok&t=29s Accessed 13 Oct. 2022.
Cundy, Carmen. Savannah Howe-Smith. 21 Mar. 2022.
Native American veterinarian
In this article a woman who is part of a tribe in Canada and this is also a show where she finds her connection with her tribe's connection to free animals. Metis, the tribe from Canada is where she is mostly focusing on. One of Howse-smith's projects was helping people with their animals and how to take care of them. This is a short abbreviation of her show. But this is also her life. When becoming a vet she wanted to know why her community doesn’t say anything about the free roaming dog population. She offers her help to any animal.
When reading this about her show, I was trying to find it, and it wasn’t online. But knowing another Native American veterinarian was willing to help any animal which would be domestic or wild. She has the care for them and loves them all equally. At the same time she is also trying to learn her heritage in her community. I found it fascinating that she is learning both languages about herself and animals.
Lovato, Tyra.Sleepy UCONN.Personal Photo. 13 July 2021.
Philosophy of a “good death
“Philosophy of a “Good Death”” is an article written by Dr. Steele, et al, have been explaining the word Euthanasia, and how many ways this could mean murder, life, or painless harm. Also the confusion of involuntary and non voluntary euthanasia. The different ways that most of the veterinary clinics use this can cause chaotic grief in the way they understand vs how the real world would use it. Laws and guidelines have been made for the use of euthanasia on small animals and when to use it in a state of emergency. “While all laws and guidelines agree on some form of euthanasia being ethically justifiable, there is a broad spectrum of legally accepted good reasons. Most of those reasons are derived from a sentientist perspective, giving highest priority to the avoidance of animal suffering (narrow hedonism, cf. 2.3.1. Narrow Hedonism) and either denying the harm of death for nonhuman animals or weighing it as less important.”
This article has made me realize that most of the time when homeless dogs are taken to shelters or any means of aggression veterinarians act by saving them so they don’t harm anyone. They also explained the positive and negative mental state of the animals' welfare. “Ending a life with net positive well-being might be seen as doing harm when adopting an account of broad hedonism . This view is also supported by the suggestion of promoting a “live worth living” in addition to preventing a “live worth avoiding””
Persson, K.; Selter, F.; Neitzke, G.; Kunzmann, P. Philosophy of a “Good Death” in Small Animals and Consequences for Euthanasia in Animal Law and Veterinary Practice. Animals 2020, 10, 124. https://doi.org/10.3390/ani10010124
Michael Black, who talks about the profit and non-Profit organizations, what they need to have and the strengths that they have as well. If they have a lot of communication, a lot of people looking for jobs can find certain people for those things, many times it can be a lot. He said “there could be some unfair competition” could be a concern. But most importantly the non-profit organization fills in the gaps that most profit organizations don't and that is one way that they can work together.
This quick video Michael had expressed some things that the profit organization for veterinarians were lacking. To think that m
Kumar Srivastav, Ashish. Non-Profit v Profit. 9 Dec. 2022.
Diabo, Montana. volunteered at puppy vaccination clinics. April 02, 2022.
A Canadian reporter by the name of Ka’nhehsí:io deer, recently wrote an article about a woman named, Montana Diabo, who is in her 30’s being a veterinarian and who is part of the Kanien'kehá:ka in translation the Mohawk Kahnawake, south of Montreal in Canada. In order to get the dream job she wanted she had to move to the Caribbean Island to a school in Saint Kitts. After going to school for a couple of years she wanted to bring back some education to her community, and to open up her own clinic. As a retired veterinarian by the name of Roberta Duhaime said “The Canadian Veterinary Medical Association said it did not have statistics on what the national representation may be of Indigenous veterinarians.” Which is something that they struggle to have younger generations to do like Montana who is willing to be a huge role model to the younger generation in the indigenous community.
I felt a sense of connection to this article because it was just relatable to the background of my hero. To know that a community in Canada is struggling to have Indigenous people have a clinic in their community is really interesting, since most tribal communities don’t really care that there is a veterinary clinic because their land is small or there isn’t enough money to support the clinic. Also what Raberta Duhaime said about their CVMA did not have statistics of representation for indigenous veterinarians is mind blowing since it’s hard to tell how many are representing. Those Numbers could be good or could be low and that’s where a lot of education and studying comes along.
Deer, Ka’nhehsí:io. “Kanien'Kehá:Ka Veterinarian Hopes to Inspire More Indigenous People into the Profession | CBC News.” CBCnews, CBC/Radio Canada, 2 Apr. 2022, https://www.cbc.ca/news/indigenous/indigenous-veterinarian-1.6402204. Accessed 7 Feb. 2023Lovato, Tyra. Brady Profile. Personal Photo. February 20th, 2023
After a big earthquake that hit turkey on February 6th, 2023, the Humane world organization had received a call for help from one of their employee who was working with a civilian who owns his own clinic. Unfortunately it collapsed. The team went out to the country to help any animals who needed help. Many Turkish civilians had come together to help the team and volunteer as much as they could. In return the Humane World International had provided financial support to two foundations/ organizations in Turkey. “It's obvious that in Antakya the locals who evacuated are desperately worried for their animal companions left behind, and warmly welcome our help in locating them.”
The fact that there had been an earthquake and there are many disasters around the world and Turkey is a country who had a lot of support from these people who were willing to help and put their own health on the line. I honestly didn't know that there was a foundation/organization that was willing to go help out to other countries. Humane World organization is a bigger spread and well known organization that can go across the seas or land to help animals who are in desperate need of help and health. Since they are mostly from volunteers this sets a good example of what each small organization should have since it could be known world wide! Also to think that most of the turkish people were in need of their animals to come back safe to them is something that I probably won’t understand from their perspective.
Editor, Blog. “We're on the Ground in Turkey to Help Save Animals.” A Humane World, 21 Feb. 2023, https://blog.humanesociety.org/2023/02/humane-society-animal-rescue-turkey-earthquake.html.
Lovato, Tyra. Peaceful times. Personal Photo.
This was a multiple article and videos, and it was about different veterinarians who had been chosen for a Global Animal Welfare awards to different parts of the world. Each vet had to say something about what they wanted to do with the prize that they got. A man name Dr. Parntep Ratanakorn from Thialand talks about the importance of what a role a vet has to be and what they should do. “The award will help me serve many species that are under threat in Thailand and create a young generation who will be responsible for animal welfare in the future.” Since this prize was something big to him, and to other vets they have to make an action plan for what they will do next into the future.
I know that this man is there for the livestock, but it’s crazy to hear about other people around the world who can make a change, and since he is part of the veterinarian service. Also I learned that there can be major changes in the world with many of the vets to be recognized through these foundations. Since Dr. Partner Ratanakorn is a professor at this local university and is teaching younger generations.
Article: Health, Pig. “Global Animal Welfare Awards Highlight the Special Role Veterinarians Play in Protecting the Health and Welfare of Animals.” Https://Www.pig333.Com , Home, 2019, https://www.pig333.com/company_news/global-animal-welfare-awards-highlight-the-role-of-veterinarians_14938/.
On November 9th during the lunch period in Humanities commons room I had a Presentation set. Students came in and listened to me talk about what it takes to be a veterinarian, what it's like to be a veterinarian that works with a nonprofit organization, and I provided a link to an veterinarian page with more information.