Looking into the Past and Future: The Evolution of Navajo Education and the Transformation of Pueblo Bonito School
Gwilym Johnson - Navajo Nation
Looking into the Past and Future: The Evolution of Navajo Education and the Transformation of Pueblo Bonito School
Gwilym Johnson - Navajo Nation
“Sharing One Skin: Okanagan Community” by Jeanette Armstrong
In this source, Armstrong talks about her Okanagan heritage, and how the Okanagan culture views the modern world from a very pessimistic viewpoint. Armstrong is Okanagan, and she comes from British Columbia. Her maternal family is River Indian, while her paternal family is Mountain Indian, each having their role. The Okanagan believe in four “beings” that make us human. Firstly, the Physical self, which is the body of the Earth. It is sacred to the Okanagan culture. Secondly, the Emotional self is viewed as the essential part of being human. The Thinking-Intellectual self is the discipline to work, instead of having an automatic response to it. The Spiritual self is the individual being, the true self, which holds great power. Both the Thinking-Intellectual and the Spiritual self have no direct translation into English. On the other hand, the Okanagan culture believes that every person is born into a family and a community. Without this bond to a family and a community, a person is considered to be “crippled” or “incapacitated” and will fall apart. The bond with the community and family is very important. The Okanagan culture is deeply rooted in its bond with the Earth and the community, but unfortunately, however, as technology advances and governments grow, this bond seems to be falling apart. The result of the dispassion for Earth and the community are disease, famine, war, and refugees trying to escape environmental and social destruction. Technology is also rapidly causing destruction to this bond, as communicating via the internet gives no physical or personal link. People rapidly get disconnected from reality and the Earth as a whole. However, communities are still being built despite the odds being against them.
Armstrong’s perspective of today’s society is all but irrelevant in 2022. Big corporations are destroying the world for profit, and people are all but ignorant of it. Communication via the internet has become the biggest way to do anything, ever since the rise of COVID-19, and maybe even Monkeypox. And even if we are face-to-face, technology is a big component of our lives that we can’t live without it. There are a lot of commodities any traditional Native Americans can’t live without. Still, however, there are people who are trying to make a change for Native Americans. But overall, I understand why the Okanagan tribe sees the world as nothing but a husk.
Armstrong, Jeanette. 1996 “Sharing One Skin: The Okanagan Community” Pp. 460-470 in Jerry Mander and Edward Goldsmith (eds.), The Case Against the Global Economy, San Francisco, CA: Sierra Club Books.
How name places impact the way we see landscape” by B. Toastie
Many places currently are named by and for colonizers – or in this case, important landmarks like the El Capitan summit at Yosemite. However, many of these names have Native roots. El Capitan’s Native name was based of a Native story, and was called Measuring-Worm Stone. Many of these places have mythical significance because of these Native stories, which is why the Diné usually treat these places with respect. Unfortunately, many of these Native landmarks have been polluted, as is the case with the San Francisco peaks – originally named Dook’o’oosłííd. These names, are deeply rooted in community. However, changing these names disrupts that mythic connection. This is also the case with towns named after English colonizers. The Diné culture refuse to use names of those who have died, as to not give power to the dead. These ideals of the settlers and that of the Indigenous people don’t align, which results in multiple communities deciding on multiple names for the mountains. Historians Bill Tucker and Vernett Calhoun were unaware of the true name of El Capitan, because of this complication. It also doesn’t undermine the fact that the English settlers tried to erase Native culture, but small and very poor attempts to undo the damage lie in the retellings of these stories. The story of Measuring-Worm Stone was adapted into a children’s book where bears were trapped atop the mountain, instead of children.
Instead of looking at a larger community in the eyes of a Native one, this article talks about another instance of cultural erasure, and how it affects the Navajo culture. Like the Okanagan tribe, the Navajo culture highly respects the land and its stories. For example, the Hero Twins fought a monster atop what would become Mt. Taylor. Unfortunately, I can’t help but be upset at what are the worst attempts of trying to undo the damage the colonizers caused. It’s like putting a band-aid on a stab wound. Yet because of the historical inaccuracies, it’s more like putting a $2 Wal-Mart branded Band-Aid on a bleeding artery. It’s disappointing to see, yet I feel like the more people preach the truth, the slowly the damage will undo.
B. Toastie Image credit: Tony Abeyta May 1, 2022 From the print edition. “How Place Names Impact the Way We See Landscape.” High Country News – Know the West, High Country News, 1 May 2022, https://www.hcn.org/issues/54.5/people-places-how-place-names-impact-the-way-we-see-landscape.
“Federal Boarding Schools and the Indian Child: 1920 - 1960” by Margaret Connell Szasz
This article showcases some of the conditions of the boarding schools, the people who tried to change the boarding school practices, and the many programs that have also tried to change them. When the Meriam Report was published in 1928, it revealed many of the conditions of the Indian/Boarding Schools. One, for example, was the lack of federal funding. Many of the boarding schools did not have enough funding to provide food or clothing to their students. However, after the Meriam Report was published, Will Carson Ryan - the former Director of Indian Education - and John Collier - the former commissioner of Indian Affairs - tried to introduce changes to the boarding school system, but Collier’s Indian New Deal fell off during World War II. Will Carson Ryan and Williard Walcott Beatty - Ryan’s successor - only had a few years to change the boarding school system. Fortunately, Ryan and Beatty were successful, as they provided funding for the schools, and most notably, closed down many of the boarding schools that were mentioned in the Meriam Report. Finally, in 1946, the Navajo Special Program sought to “overcome some of the deficiencies in Navajo Education.” (Szasz, pg. 381) The project proved to be successful.
Much of the information brought up in this article is important to my topic, for example, the Meriam Report of 1928. It also brought up programs that I have never heard of, like the Navajo Special Program. Considering that Pueblo Bonito Boarding School was a federal Boarding School, I feel like many of the programs, changes, and conditions mentioned in the article heavily influenced the school, even throughout its changes.
Szasz Margaret Connell. Federal Boarding Schools and the Indian Child: 1920-1960. South Dakota State Historical Society, https://www.sdhspress.com/journal/south-dakota-history-7-4/federal- boarding-schools-and-the-indian-child-1920-1960/vol-07-no-4-federal- boarding-schools-and-the-indian-child.pdf
Unknown. "Pupils at Carlisle Native Industrial School, Pennsylvania (c. 1900)" Frontier Forts, 8 Dec. 2022, https://www.texasbeyondhistory.net/forts/images/carlisle.html
“The Navajo's Long Walk of Education: History of Navajo Education; Chapter 1 - Navajo Education Before 1930” by Hildegard Thompson
This chapter focuses on the creation of Boarding Schools and how the Miriam Report came to affect Native American Education as a whole - Including Navajo Education. Before Bosque Redondo or the Navajo Long Walk, the Federal Government never forced the Navajos to attend school. However, when the Treaty of 1868 was signed, many Navajos were obligated to attend school. However, many of the early Boarding Schools failed, and eventually, the Rev. Eleazor Wheelock approach was used to assimilate Native Americans. Eventually, the boarding schools grew in size, and by the end of 1930, 5,000 Navajos attended primary school. However, in 1926, Lewis Meriam released the Meriam Report, which highlighted the problems in Native areas, or in our case, education. Some of the recommendations included removing the “routinization” in boarding schools, not requiring a uniform and standardized curriculum, and other demands that would’ve improved the boarding schools for Native Americans as a whole.
The information and recommendations from the Meriam Report have a big impact on Boarding Schools as a whole, as many schools closed down as a result of the Meriam Report. I can see how this affects Pueblo Bonito, as many photos of the old school seem to have been when the boarding school was militarized, like many of the other boarding schools at the time. Unfortunately, many of the recommendations in the Meriam Report have gone ignored, as the boarding schools changed ever so slightly.
Thompson, Hildegard. “Navajo Education before 1930.” The Navajo's Long Walk of Education: History of Navajo Education, Navajo Community College Press, Tsaile, AZ, 1975, pp. 25–34.
Unknown. "Wounded Yellow Robe, Henry Standing Bear and Chauncy Yellow Robe, Sioux boys before and after they entered school in 1883 and three years later." Dickinson College Archives, 10 Dec. 2021, https://www.kare11.com/article/news/local/the-history-of-minnesotas-native- american-boarding-schools/89-78048d07-1af1-475f-bf15-0a47fc59bfe6.
“Navajo Boarding School” by Tracie Jackson
The video is a collection of many personal stories of the Navajo Boarding Schools. The video begins by explaining the 19th-century boarding schools, and how they took Navajo children away. The rest of the video explains the many experiences of boarding schools from different perspectives. For example, one person claimed they never learned basic English or Math, and another person claimed that they could never learn their language in the boarding schools.
Many of the experiences shared in the video are universal to any Native American who had to live in Boarding Schools, but in our case, the Boarding Schools did more damage than good. It stripped away many of people’s native identities, and it gave many other non-native people a bad interpretation of Native Americans. Considering many of the policies and programs at this time, this video gives us a glimpse at what Pueblo Bonito could’ve been when it was first established.
Jackson, Tracie. “Navajo Boarding School.” YouTube, YouTube, 3 Jan. 2014, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9_5HFmvw2ZM.
Johnson, Gwilym. Personal Photo, 13 Nov, 2022
“Crownpoint, New Mexico: Past and Present As Viewed Through the Crownpoint Baahane’ Newsletter” by Leonard Perry
The book includes multiple articles from the Crownpoint Baahane’ Newsletter. I’ve decided to look at the introduction Leonard Perry wrote, and the first article that was provided in the book. Perry begins the book with his own prospect on history, and why he’s doing what he’s doing as a historian. The Crownpoint Baahane’ was curated by Perry and the Crownpoint Historical & Cultural Heritage Council (CHCHC). The first article that caught my attention was about the construction of the new Crownpoint Community School (CCS) building. Many BIA school buildings have a 40-year expectancy, and CCS reached that limit - the old building had “various facilities that were deemed poor and unsafe.” (Perry)
It may seem weird why I chose a local newsletter article, but it’s mostly because of Leonard Perry’s involvement in the book. He’s the president of the CHCHC, a chapter house member, and is - or what I would consider - an expert in the history of Crownpoint. Because of this, much of his research was included in the Crownpoint Baahane’ newsletter, and I would believe many important facts about Pueblo Bonito would arise within the articles. He also states that as “an elder passes, the riches of past events has passed as well,” (Perry) which is something I agree with, especially since many Navajo experiences and stories are poorly recorded. For example, if it weren’t for the poor, low-quality animated Navajo coyote stories, many people wouldn’t have remembered them and these stories would’ve died with the elders who told these stories.
Perry, Leonard. “Crownpoint, New Mexico.” Past and Present As Viewed Through the Crownpoint Baahane’ Newsletter. Self-Published. Print. Pg. 1 - 6
Johnson, Gwilym. Personal Photo, 13 Nov, 2022
Crownpoint to celebrate 100 years” by Leonard Perry, published by the Navajo Times
2010 marks the 100th year of Crownpoint as a whole - and the Crownpoint Historical & Cultural Heritage Council wants to preserve the town’s history. The CHCHC began in 2007 as a non-profit organization certified by the Navajo Nation. In the article, the CHCHC plans to “identify, protect, and restore historical buildings and landmarks,” plan a Crownpoint Boarding School reunion, as well as curate a collection of biographies of Crownpoint’s influential people and present them at a planned symposium.
Some of the issues here are that none of these events went through, or as far to our knowledge. However, we know that the CHCHC is a part of the Crownpoint Chapter House. Unfortunately, no documentation or information about Crownpoint’s history was ever shown to the public - despite what they planned to do in the article.
Perry, Leonard. “Crownpoint to Celebrate 100 Years.” The Navajo Times. 2010. Web. Accessed 3 Nov. 2022. https://www.navajotimes.com/entertainment/culture/0710/072310crownpo int.php.
Johnson, Gwilym. Personal Photo, 13 Nov, 2022
“Crownpoint Boarding School Demolition” by U.S. Indian Affairs
In 2013, after the construction of T’iis Ts’ozi Bi’ Olta’ (Crownpoint Boarding School or CCS) has completed, the Office of Facility Management and Construction (OFMC)’s Space Reduction Program had begun to demolish the Crownpoint Boarding School (CBS) building. About 250,000 sq. ft. of CBS was demolished. It also handled “the remediation of hazardous material” within the CBS building before it was demolished.
The video states that OFMC handled the “remediation of hazardous material” during the demolition of CBS. This “material” was asbestos. The main reason why I’ve included this video was that many of the files, documentation, and history of Pueblo Bonito were in the CBS building. Due to the presence of asbestos, everything within the CBS building had to be left behind, including the recorded history of the school. Thus, the only recorded history of Pueblo Bonito is Satcher’s Biography of his father, which even then, was lost for a period of time in CCS. Only very few photos were taken from the CBS building and were properly archived by CCS, but the demolition of CBS is the main reason why documentation on Pueblo Bonito is very hard to find and uncover.
U.S. Indian Affairs. “Crownpoint Boarding School Demolition.” YouTube. 2013. Web. Accessed Nov. 18, 2022. https://www.youtube.com/watch? v=kYdX0wXz-M8
Johnson, Gwilym. Personal Photo, 13 Nov, 2022
“A Brief History of Digital Preservation” by Erin Baucom
This article shows the efforts of Digital Preservation made internationally, the laws that affect digital preservation, and the preservation of the hardware itself. Foundations like the Open Preservation Foundation create software and tools that benefit digital preservation, like the open-source PLANETS Project. The Internet Archive, started in 1996, preserves media from books to software - and allows for internet preservation through Archive-It and the Wayback Machine. However, the biggest issue when discussing digital preservation is the legality. In the United States, the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) requires that Digital Rights Management (DRM) be respected unless it’s for preservation purposes. Although this benefits the rights holder, it makes it harder for preservationists to request exemptions when preserving content. On the other hand, the WIPO Copyright Treaty (WCT) directly addresses digital preservation. The WCT allows nations to “create limitations and exceptions to the treaty so that it may conform to national law.” (Baucom, 16.)
With the advent of preservation projects like the Internet Archive (big fan), understanding the process, history, and laws shows us what the average user can preserve right from their home. In the case of preserving Pueblo Bonito Boarding School, the biggest challenge I have when considering posting the book I copied online is a DMCA takedown, or worse, a cease and desist. Unfortunately, this is common among many preservationists - especially with the uprising of the Lost Media community in recent years.
Baucom, Erin. “A Brief History of Digital Preservation” 2019. Mansfield Library Faculty Publications. Web. Accessed 15 Feb. 2022. https://scholarworks.umt.edu/ml_pubs/31
"Untitled" Digital Image. GettyImages. Web. Accessed Mar. 2, 2023.
https://en.unesco.org/themes/information-preservation/digital-heritage/digital-preservation-programmes
“Preservation in the Age of Google: Digitization, Digital Preservation, and Dilemmas” by Paul Conway
This article touches on some of the most important preservationists face when it comes to digital preservation, and also on some of the practices many preservationists use. One of the most important documents Conway touches on is the book “Preserving Digital Information: Report of the Task Force on Archiving of Digital Information” - on how the book is a “touchstone in digital preservation” (Conway, 65) and on some of the book’s recommendations. Notably, Conway touches on the dilemmas when digitizing information. Specifically, the quality of digital preservation, the environmental degradation of information, the issues of preserving mediums other than books, and the lack of expertise when it comes to broad preservation efforts. Conway concludes his article with some of his own recommendations, one of which include the “Shift of precious preservation resources away from item-level treatment of books to the digital rescue of audio-visual resources.” (Conway, 75)
Although some of the issues of digital preservation were addressed in Baucom’s article, Conway addresses more specific practices archivists use, and some of the issues that come with digital preservation. Some of the issues I faced when digitizing Satcher’s book were addressed in this article - namely, the lack of expertise. On the other hand, it’s good to learn about the issues when considering digital preservation, especially if T’iis Ts’ozi Bi’Olta decides to curate a digital repository of their own.
Conway, Paul. “Preservation in the Age of Google: Digitization, Digital Preservation, and Dilemmas.” 2010. University of Chicago Press. Web. Accessed 15 Feb. 2023. https://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/handle/2027.42/85223/J15%20Conway%20Preservation%20Age%20of%20Google%202010.pdf?sequence=1
"Server room with rack-mounted servers." Digital Image. TechTerms.com. Web. Accessed Mar. 2, 2023.
https://techterms.com/definition/server
“Why Digital Preservation is Important for Everyone” by the Library of Congress
A short video explaining the importance of preserving media on a mass scale. From photos, videos, and music that is important to us - we must make sure nothing harms this data. However, media storage devices and files themselves are extremely fragile. Not to mention, new technology may render old formats obsolete. The Library of Congress partners with other libraries internationally to actively manage their databases.
As far as I’m aware, there are no “databases,” or full-on digital archives in T’iis Ts’ozi Bi’olta today. Considering how fragile both physical and digital media are, it’s important to take into consideration the risks. Perhaps the school could work with the Bureau of Indian Education to produce a digital library that is available to the students. Overall, the school would need to actively manage this new database - if they were to curate one.
Library of Congress. “Why Digital Preservation is Important for Everyone.” Youtube, uploaded by Library of Congress. April 2010. Accessed 15 Feb, 2023. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qEmmeFFafUs
"Main Reading Room of the Library of Congress in the Thomas Jefferson Building" Digital Image. Carol M. Highsmith. 2009. Web. Accessed Mar. 2, 2023.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:LOC_Main_Reading_Room_Highsmith.jpg
Action Plan
On the week of Nov. 6, I began searching for Herbert C. Statcher's book, "History of Crownpoint, New Mexico: 1910 to 1935 while Samuel Franklin Stacher was in charge as Superintendent." The book contains photos and a biography of Samuel F. Stacher, who established Pueblo Bonito Indian School. Previously, this book has been missing from the T'iis Ts'ozi Bi'olta school library. My goal with this Action Plan is to make this book readily available to those at T'iis Ts'ozi Bi'olta, and make it available online through the Internet Archive. I was able to scan a copy of the book at the UNM Zimmerman Library.
Johnson, Gwilym. Personal Photo, 13 Nov, 2022