Nádleehí : The Forgotten beliefs regarding LGBTQIA2S+ people
Nolan Hall
Navajo/Tsalagi
Nádleehí : The Forgotten beliefs regarding LGBTQIA2S+ people
Nolan Hall
Navajo/Tsalagi
Within “Sharing One Skin” by Jeannette Armstrong, the author explains the importance of culture and one’s responsibilities to their culture. She is of Okanagan descent, Okanagan means “the ones who are dream and land together.” As stated within the meaning of Okanagan, Armstrong feels responsibility and connection to her sacred lands. As for the dream part, within the Okanagan culture there are 4 selves, The Physical self, Emotional Self, Thinking-Intellectual self, and the Spirit self. All selves are extremely important, as they feel you cannot be a whole person without all selves being intact and utilized. Armstrong shows through her extensive knowledge of her culture and introduction, that you must know yourself in order to have a connection with traditional beliefs. Finally, the ending of this story emphasizes your birth responsibility to your community and family as more important than self.
Armstrong, Jeanette. “Sharing One Skin: The Okanagan Community,” in Jerry Mander and Edward Goldsmith (eds), The Case Against the Global Economy. San Francisco, CA, Sierra Club Books, 1996. Pp 460-470.
Zhukovskyi. “Hands holding each other showing unity vector image.” VectorStock. Web. Accessed on 9 December, 2022. https://www.vectorstock.com/royalty-free-vector/hands-holding-each- other-showing-unity-vector-6026103
“How place names impact the way we see landscape” represents the indigenous experience and the connection between a name and the land. Many sacred landmarks and areas have been named after colonizers or government officials as opposed to the names originally given by native people for native land. There are stories ranging from creation to traditional family or tribal, and you must pay respect to those stories, blessings, and spirit connection to the land. When places are named after colonizers with histories of genocide and relocation, it only emphasizes and preserves the trauma of native communities. While many do not know the stories of their land, they believe that you have to know the stories in order to preserve your culture and understand indigenous connection to the land
Toastie, B. “How place names impact the way we see landscape.” High Country News: Know the West, 1 May 2022, Web. Accessed 27 August 2022. https://www.hcn.org/issues/54.5/people-places- how-place-names- impact-the-way-we-see-landscape.
Pham, An. “Canyon De Chelly National Monument.” Arizona The Grand Canyon State. Web. Accessed on 9 Dec. 2022. https://www.visitarizona.com/places/parks- monuments/canyon-de- chelly-national-monument/
RESEARCH LOG 2
Many Indigenous people discuss the history of being a two-spirited person. Within the documentary, "Two-Spirit People" many people discuss historical Two-Spirit roots. Including historical leader, We'Wha. There often is a misunderstood connection between two spirits, assigned gender, and sexuality, when there is no crossover whatsoever.
Beauchemin, Levy & Vogel, Michel, Lori & Gretchen, director. Two-Spirit People.
YouTube, Frameline , 23 May 2011,https://youtu.be/8JcmAo derl 4. Accessed 13 Oct. 2022.
Hall, Nolan. "Importance." 6 December, 2022. Photographers Personal Photo.
Two Spirit people are ancient, sacred, and recognized within several Indigenous tribes. Through colonialism, many have lost touch with these beliefs and traditions. The Human Rights Campaign discusses this history and the impact of colonialism within “Two Spirit and LGBTQ+ Identities: Today and Centuries Ago.” This article shows the emergence of modern religion and the religious persecution and forced assimilation Native people faced. This relates to generational trauma and the modern impacts of colonialism. Through this persecution and oppression, many traditional beliefs were lost. As many were forced to convert religion or disregard their Native traditions, the sacredness and acknowledgement of Two Spirit people began to be forgotten. This article re-educates many of what is often considered forgotten regarding Two-Spirit people.
Swan-Perkins, Samuel White. “5 Two-Spirit Heroes Who Paved the Way for Today's Native LGBTQ+ Community.” KQED, 20 Nov. 2018, https://www.kqed.org/arts/13845330/5-two-spirit-heroes-who- paved-the-way-for-todays-native-lgbtq-community.
Hall, Nolan. "Connection." 6 December, 2022.
Photographers Personal Photo.
While it may take awhile, traditional LGBTQIA2s+ beliefs are being reincorporated back to Indigenous communities. Native people specifically have come a long way in such little time. Through Samuel White Swan-Perkins' article, “5 Two-Spirit Heroes who paved the way for today's Native LGBTQ+ communities” we see the the true impact of colonialism, as people adjust their views to fit the norm. Many know that at one time LGBTQIA2S+ people were sacred, but still laugh at their expense due to the modern discrimination of them. These beliefs have not left a lot of Indigenous communities, but several have considered them outdated, as now LGBTQ+ people are ostracized and condemned. Instead of retaining traditional culture and honoring these members of their communities, they still continue to be unaccepting of their “lifestyle.” Which again, is a result of colonialism and religion, which enforce the heteronormative viewpoint that being LGBTQ+ is “unnatural.” This article spreads awareness to discrimination and homophobia in order to reduce those colonial mindsets.
Swan-Perkins, Samuel White. “5 Two- Spirit Heroes Who Paved the
Way for Today's Native LGBTQ+ Community.” KQED, 20 Nov. 2018.
Hall, Nolan. "Traditions." 6 December, 2022. Photographers Personal Photo.
Alabama’s legislature is currently utilizing the Supreme Court’s argument in the overruling of Roe V. Wade in order to ban and criminalize gender-affirming care. When overturning Roe V. Wade, The Supreme Court used the argument that abortion is not “deeply rooted in this nation’s history and tradition” (The Associated Press). Now, Alabama is using that same argument in the case against transgender reaffirming procedures. Within the article, “Alabama is using the case that ended Roe to argue it can ban gender-affirming care”, more in depth information is given about this current issue. It discusses the Supreme Court's decision and Justice Clarence Thomas’ declaration on human rights, explaining that he will come after same-sex marriages, contraceptives, and gay relations. Earlier this year, Alabama Governer Kay Ivey criminalized transgender drug distribution, stating that an individual could spend up to 10 years in prison for dispensing them.
Press, The Associated. “Alabama is using the case that ended Roe to argue it can be gender-affirming care.” NPR. 3 July, 2022. Web. Accessed on 17 November, 2022.
https://www.npr.org/2022/07/03/1109613520/alaba ma-abortion-rights-gender-affirming-c
Hall, Nolan. "Candlelight." 6 December, 2022. Photographers Personal Photo.
Texas governor, Greg Abbott is actively working to consider trans identities and healthcare, “child abuse.” He is urging investigations into supportive homes who support LGBTQ+ procedures and medications. I learned specific legislation and dates through the NPR article entitled “Texas Supreme Court OKs state child abuse inquires into the families of trans kids.” The Texas Supreme Court unanimously ruled that the child welfare agency can continue investigations on doctors and families who support gender-affirming care (Chappell). This is causing several transgender people as well as their families to consider moving from their home state of Texas due to fear of investigation or prosecution on the basis of “child abuse.”
Chappell, Bill. “Texas Supreme Court OKs state child abuse inquires into the families of trans kids.” NPR. 13 May, 2022. Web. Accessed on 17 November, 2022.
Hall, Nolan. "Solidarity" 10 November, 2022. Photographers Personal Photo.
There have been monumentally progressive strides for the LGBTQIA2S+ community within legislation recently. The most notable being documented within, “Same-Sex Marriage Rights Bill Clears a Crucial Senate Hurdle.” In which, the advancement of the Respect for Marriage Act was enforced. The Act was supported by both Democrats and Republicans, reaching a bipartisan majority. This Act repeals the Defense of Marriage Act, which “denied federal benefits to same-sex couples” (Karni). This has created controversy with some elected officials stating they do not believe LGBTQ+ rights are currently at risk. With others stating that with the current conservative Supreme Court, legal arguments used to overrule Roe V. Wade can be utilized in other cases.
Karni, Annie. “Same-Sex Marriage Rights Bill Clears a Crucial Senate Hurdle.” The New York Times. 16 November, 2022. Accessed on 17 November, 2022.
https://www.nytimes.com/2022/11/16/us/politics/same- sex-marriage-bill-senate.html
Hall, Nolan. "Two-Spirit." 8 November, 2022. Photographers Personal Photo.
I watched a video in which Florida Governor, Ron Desantis shared his remarks as he signed the Don’t Say Gay law into action. He believes that several services have been put into place that support LGBTQIA2S+ people and journeys without parental consent. He believes that it is harmful to not involve parents within their child's education and uses that as a basis to defend this “Don’t Say Gay” bill.
“WATCH: Governor Ron DeSantis gives remarks as he signs into law Florida's "Don't Say Gay" bill” PBS Newshour. 28 March, 2022. Web. Accessed on 17 November, 2022. https://youtu.be/IVuniz7w1bQ
Hall, Nolan. "Community and Education" 10 November, 2022. Photographers Personal Photo.
At my action plan meeting with Superintendent Abetya, we discussed my proposals. She is in support of my proposal for an LGBTQIA2S+ safe space within the dormitory, and suggested I send out a survey to ensure that we have an accurate number of students to designate an entire pod. To ensure that we are able to meet dormitory requirement she also stated that there is a staff bathroom in which she suggests LGBTQ+ students utilize when uncomfortable changing in gender specific locker rooms.
I created a survey to help identify the amount of students who would utilize these LGBTQ+ inclusive spaces. I had received 93 responses. Out of those, 50.5% said they would utilize an LGBTQIA2S+ space within the dormitory . I will add these to my proposal paper in order to present an exact number of students to Superintendent Abeyta.
Hall, Nolan. "Proposal." 6 December, 2022.
Photographers Personal Photo.
Hall, Nolan. "Safe Spaces." 6 December, 2022.
Photographers Personal Photo.
While many LGBTQIA2S+ people have dealt with the constant threat and fear that their rights to marriage and equality will be revoked or challenged, there is one specific group that have similar concerns. With the overturning of Roe v. Wade, there has been concern that the Supreme Court will consider overturning the right to interracial marriage. As explained within the article, “As the Supreme Court overturns Roe v. Wade, some experts fear interracial marriage may be the next target” (Hall, Han). This right has been challenged by Justice Clarence Thomas, as it is similarly protected by the 14th Amendment’s Equal Protection Clause (Hall, Han). Hall and Han state that after the overruling of Roe v. Wade, “Justice Clarence Thomas expressed that the Court should also "reconsider" rulings that protect contraception access, same-sex-relationships, and same-sex marriage.” Throughout history, the Supreme Court of The United States have utilized the Due Process Clause in order to justify citizens rights to several important issues, such as same-sex marriage but Justice Clarence Thomas has fought against this interpretation of this Consitutional Clause (Hall, Han). Therefore, many feel that due to his stance on this Constitutional interpretation, he will urge the court to overrule the right to interracial marriage.
Hall, Madison, Han, Yoonji. “As the Supreme Court overturns Roe v. Wade, some experts fear interracial marriage may be the next target.” Insider. 24 June, 2022. Web. Accessed on February 16th, 2023.
https://www.insider.com/roe-wade-loving-virginia-interracial marriage-scotus-overturns2022-6
Petteway, Steve. "Collection of the Supreme Court of the United States." 2007. Web. Accessed on March 2 2023.
https://www.britannica.com/biography/Clarence-Thomas
Many countries have similar stories of colonial homophobia and LGBTQIA2S+ criminalization. Ancient Egypt acknowledged and revered a third gender, with a much more open viewpoint to sexuality and identity. Another example is men found caressing each other as lovers within their tombs, which further represents the ancient Egyptian belief system. However, as many countries were colonized by British rule and became apart of the Commonwealth, there were several LGBTQIA2S+ phobic legislation written into their constitutions. 66% of the Commonwealth countries criminalize homosexuality. Some of the Commonwealth countries include Australia, Jamaica, Canada, Cameroon, Belize, and South Africa. As Buckle states, “There is a direct correlation between countries which belong to the Commonwealth, and therefore have previously been under British rule, and countries that still have homophobic biphobic and/or transphobic legislature in their constitutions.” There are several countries who similarly opposed colonialism and practiced their beliefs, such as the Ghana and Nigerian people. Within Nigeria, there was not a gender binary and children were not assigned a gender until later within their life as opposed to birth. Similarly, the Ghanan people found that gender was assigned based on energy and not anatomy. However, with the arrival of Christian missionaries, Christian quickly became the dominant religion, making up 63% of the population. With the religion's newfound popularity, anti-LGBTQ+ legislation and rhetoric has been incorporated into African culture (Buckle). Even countries with an LGBTQ+ safe space history, such as Uganda, continuously criminalize homosexuality. These laws and anti LGBTQ+ ideals are generational effects of colonialism and the continuous cycle of colonization.
Buckle, Leah, “African sexuality and the legacy of imported homophobia.” Stonewall. 01 October, 2020. Web. Accessed on February 16th, 2023. https://www.stonewall.org.uk/about- us/news/african-sexuality-and-legacy-imported-homophobia
History is Gay. "HAPI, GOD OF THE NILE, DEPICTED AS HAVING BOTH MALE AND FEMALE PRESENTATION." 2018. Web. Accessed on March 1 2023.https://www.historyisgaypodcast.com/notes/2018/3/18/episode-6-3-genders-in-ancient-egypt-its-more-likely-than-you-think
Similar to the previous article this article takes another look at the homophobic and anti-LGBTQ+ history of the British Empire and the Commonwealth countries. This time, it takes a look at a variety of places that Britain impacted and the inequality many people still face today as a result of British colonialism. British people forced chemical castration and prosecution among LGBTQ+ people throughout their historical empire. There are countless examples such as Barbados, Pakistan, Guyana, Kenya, Ghana, and Singapore (VICE). The British exported penal codes, which implemented homophobia and hatred towards LGBTQ+ people. While many countries have a past of acceptance towards LGBTQ+ people, British impact quickly reversed those beliefs. Over 600+ people were prosecuted under Kenya’s anti homosexuality laws between 2010-2014. Homosexuality continues to be criminalized as a result of the exportation of British homophobia. In March 2020, Singapore ruled in favor of keeping homosexuality illegal, and Jamaica once being known as the most homophobic country on Earth with endless violence and lynching against LGBTQ+ people. Former Prime Minister Theresa May also expressed remorse and regret over “Britains role in introducing anti-gay laws to its former colonies” (VICE).
VICE. “How the British Empire Exported Homophobia | Empires of Dirt.” VICE. 5 Nov, 2020. Web. Accessed on February 16th, 2023. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6DQYu4iBNiQ
Worldatlas. "Commonwealth Countries." Worldatlas. Web. Accessed on March 1 2023.https://www.worldatlas.com/geography/commonwealth-countries.html
In my final meeting with Superintendent Abeyta, Presented my updated information collected within my "Safe Spaces (Updated) " survey. I provided Superintendent Abeyta with a list of names and grade levels for students who would live within the LGBTQIA2S+ safe space and their preferences regarding a co-ed or gender designated dormitory pod. The superintendent said she will begin planning the Safe Space for next year, after meeting with the head of the dormitory and ensuring there is a staffing schedule. I sent out a survey entitled "Pronouns and Gender Preferences" to the entirety of the school. The data from this survey is compiled and sent to IT in order to ensure that students' identities feel validated and represented. Their email names will be edited to represent their identities and their pronouns are added. An example would be changing "Nolan Hall" to "Nolan Hall (He/Him). I sent out the data collected within my ""Pronouns and Gender Preferences" survey to IT and Kevin Lewis in order to ensure that changes and edits to student names would be completed. 65 students and well as one staff member responded to this survey and wanted their pronouns added to their email name. All people who responded to the survey successfully had their pronouns added and are spreading gender awareness!
Hall " IT LIST"
Hall "Identity"
cccHall "Meeting #2"
Armstrong, Jeanette. “Sharing One Skin: The Okanagan Community,” in Jerry Mander and Edward Goldsmith (eds), The Case Against the Global Economy. San Francisco, CA, Sierra Club Books, 1996. Pp 460-470.
Beauchemin, Levy & Vogel, Michel, Lori & Gretchen, director. Two-Spirit People. YouTube, Frameline , 23 May 2011,https://youtu.be/8JcmAo derl
4. Accessed 13 Oct. 2022.
Buckle, Leah, “African sexuality and the legacy of imported homophobia.” Stonewall. 01 October, 2020. Web. Accessed on February 16th, 2023. https://www.stonewall.org.uk/about us/news/african-sexuality-and-legacy-imported-homophobia
Chappell, Bill. “Texas Supreme Court OKs state child abuse inquires into the families of trans kids.” NPR. 13 May, 2022. Web. Accessed on 17 November, 2022.
Hall, Madison, Han, Yoonji. “As the Supreme Court overturns Roe v. Wade, some experts fear interracial marriage may be the next target.” Insider. 24 June, 2022. Web. Accessed on February 16th, 2023.
https://www.insider.com/roe-wade-loving-virginia-interracial marriage-scotus overturns2022-6
Hall, Nolan. "Community and Education" 10 November, 2022. Photographers Personal Photo.
Hall, Nolan. "Connection." 6 December, 2022. Photographers Personal Photo.
Hall, Nolan. "Importance." 6 December, 2022. Photographers Personal Photo.
Hall, Nolan. "Proposal." 6 December, 2022. Photographers Personal Photo.
Hall, Nolan. "Safe Spaces." 6 December, 2022. Photographers Personal Photo.
Hall, Nolan. "Solidarity" 10 November, 2022. Photographers Personal Photo.
Hall, Nolan. "Traditions." 6 December, 2022. Photographers Personal Photo.
Hall, Nolan. "Two-Spirit." 8 November, 2022. Photographers Personal Photo.
History is Gay. "HAPI, GOD OF THE NILE, DEPICTED AS HAVING BOTH MALE AND FEMALE PRESENTATION." 2018. Web. Accessed on March 1 2023.https://www.historyisgaypodcast.com/notes/2018/3/18/episode-6-3-genders-in-ancient-egypt-its-more-likely-than-you-think
Karni, Annie. “Same-Sex Marriage Rights Bill Clears a Crucial Senate Hurdle.” The New York Times. 16 November, 2022. Accessed on 17 November, 2022.
https://www.nytimes.com/2022/11/16/us/politics/same-sex-marriage- bill-senate.html
Petteway, Steve. "Collection of the Supreme Court of the United States." 2007. Web. Accessed on March 2 2023.
https://www.britannica.com/biography/Clarence-Thomas
Pham, An. “Canyon De Chelly National Monument.” Arizona The Grand Canyon State. Web. Accessed on 9 Dec. 2022. https://www.visitarizona.com/places/parks- monuments/canyon-de- chelly-national-monument/
Press, The Associated. “Alabama is using the case that ended Roe to argue it can be gender-affirming care.” NPR. 3 July, 2022. Web. Accessed on 17 November, 2022.
https://www.npr.org/2022/07/03/1109613520/alaba ma- abortion-rights-gender-affirming-c
Swan-Perkins, Samuel White. “5 Two- Spirit Heroes Who Paved the
Way for Today's Native LGBTQ+ Community.” KQED, 20 Nov. 2018,https://www.kqed.org/arts/1 3845330/5-two-spirit-heroes- who-paved- the-way-for-todays- native-lgbtq-community.
Toastie, B. “How place names impact the way we see landscape.” High Country News: Know the West, 1 May 2022, Web. Accessed 27 August 2022. https://www.hcn.org/issues/54.5/people-places- how-place-names- impact-the-way- we-see-landscape.
VICE. “How the British Empire Exported Homophobia | Empires of Dirt.” VICE. 5 Nov, 2020. Web. Accessed on February 16th, 2023. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6DQYu4iBNiQ
Worldatlas. "Commonwealth Countries." Worldatlas. Web. Accessed on March 1 2023.https://www.worldatlas.com/geography/commonwealth-countries.html
Zhukovskyi. “Hands holding each other showing unity vector image.” VectorStock. Web. Accessed on 9 December, 2022. https://www.vectorstock.com/royalty-free- vector/hands-holding-each- other-showing-unity-vector-6026103