A member of the class of 1971, Hogan was named All-Catholic in each of the two years he was a varsity player. He was one of the leaders of the team that won the 1970 Catholic League championship by knocking off Cardinal Dougherty. That year, the Falcons also earned a share of the city championship, as Hogan was named First Team All-American. Hogan went on to play soccer at La Salle.