Casey was a two-year starter for the Falcons, and twice led North to a Catholic League championship, in 1962 and 1963. In fact, North didn’t lose a Catholic League game during his time on the team, including his senior year when he was a captain. He also was First-Team All-Catholic and the team MVP. Also named a Philadelphia All-School Boy selection. Ended up scoring the winning goal against Dougherty in overtime to help North win the championship in 1963.