114-3. A better way to understand hadith stories.
Updated.
22 December 2022 (1444 AH).
Index A.
1. The guidance of Allaah.
Allaah asks when you have the word of Allaah in the Quran what other report would you believe?
2. Hadith break the cross and kill the pigs contradicts the Quran.
2A. Who goes to Paradise in the Quran?
3. Hadith Prophet Jesus Isa is returning to this earth contradicts the Quran.
3A. Prophet Jesus Isa said he was not killed on the cross.
3B. The body of Prophet Jesus Isa was not raised to Allaah.
4. Hadith punishment in the grave contradicts the Quran.
5. Hadith the reward of 72 virgins in Jannah contradicts the Quran.
6. Hadith whoever changes his Islamic religion kill him contradicts the Quran.
7. Hadith women hung from their breasts contradicts the Quran.
8. Hadith stoning to death for adultery contradicts the Quran.
9. The claim that Prophet Muhammad cannot read and write contradicts the Quran.
9A. Hadith Prophet Muhammad aorta cut contradicts the Quran.
9B. Hadith Prophet Muhammad created from light contradicts the Quran.
9C. Hadith Prophet Muhammad night journey to Jerusalem riding Buraq contradicts the Quran.
9D. The claim Prophet Muhammad said the son to be sacrificed is Prophet Ishmael Ismail contradicts the Quran.
10. The claim that the Torah Taurat is corrupted contradicts the Quran.
10A. The sins of the prophets of Allaah in the Torah Taurat are confirmed in the Quran.
10B. Prophet Ishmael Ismail is the son in the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim contradicts the Quran.
10C. Jews are commanded to observe the Sabbath Day forever.
11. The claim that the Gospel Injil is corrupted contradicts the Quran.
11A. The story of Prophet Jesus Isa and Prophet Isaac Ishaq is the same story.
11B. The meaning of the mysterious letters in the Quran.
12. The claim that there are abrogated verses in the Quran contradicts the Quran.
13. The September 11 attacks and Islam show how people are inventing stories today which contradict the Quran.
14. Temporary pleasure marriage contradicts the Quran,
14A. Sex with slaves contradicts the Quran.
15. The Gospel of Barnabas contradicts the Quran and Torah Taurat and Gospel Injil.
16. How to find false hadith stories invented after the death of Prophet Muhammad which contradict the Quran.
17. A better way to understand examine teach study and check hadith stories by contradictions with the Quran.
17A. Quran 51:47 the expansion of the Universe?
17B. Quran 21:30 the big bang theory?
17C. Prophet Ishmael Ismail or Prophet Isaac Ishaq to be sacrificed?
17D. Hadith Jew is hiding behind me so kill him.
Index B.
A better way to understand hadith stories is by using critical thinking and the Quran as shown in these examples..
Example 1. Did Prophet Muhammad say "there is punishment in the grave?"
Did Prophet Muhammad say "Prophet Jesus Isa is returning to this earth?"
Example 2. What is the meaning of “Do not curse fever. Verily, it removes the sins of the children of Adam just as a furnace removes dirt from iron”
Example 3. Why is stoning to death for adultery not in the Quran?
Example 4. Did Prophet Muhammad say “whoever changed his Islamic religion then kill him?”
1. Abu Bakr explained where false hadith stories come from.
2. Umar ibn Al-Khattab explained where false hadith stories come from.
3. Conclusion.
4. References.
A better way to analyse hadith stories.
A better way to appraise hadith stories.
A better way to assess hadith stories.
A better way to authenticate hadith stories.
A better way to certify hadith stories.
A better way to challenge hadith stories.
A better way to check hadith stories.
A better way to cross-examine hadith stories.
A better way to cross-question hadith stories.
A better way to confirm hadith stories.
A better way to consider hadith stories.
A better way to education in hadith stories.
A better way to evaluate hadith stories.
A better way of enquiry in hadith stories.
A better way to examine hadith stories.
A better way to explore hadith stories.
A better way to grade hadith stories.
A better way to inspect hadith stories.
A better way to interrogate hadith stories.
A better way to investigate hadith stories.
A better way to judge hadith stories.
A better way to measure hadith stories.
A better way to probe hadith stories.
A better way to prove hadith stories.
A better way to question hadith stories.
A better way to query hadith stories.
A better way to quiz hadith stories.
A better way to rate hadith stories.
A better way to research hadith stories.
A better way to vet hadith stories.
A better way to review hadith stories.
A better way to scholarship in hadith stories.
A better way to schooling in hadith stories.
A better way of scrutiny in hadith stories.
A better way to scrutinize hadith stories.
A better way to study hadith stories.
A better way to teach hadith stories.
A better way to test hadith stories.
A better way to trial hadith stories.
A better way to tuition in hadith stories.
A better way to understand hadith stories.
A better way to validate hadith stories.
A better way to verify hadith stories.
A better way to weigh hadith stories.
A better way to analyse Haadeeth stories.
A better way to appraise Haadeeth stories.
A better way to assess Haadeeth stories.
A better way to authenticate Haadeeth stories.
A better way to certify Haadeeth stories.
A better way to challenge Haadeeth stories.
A better way to check Haadeeth stories.
A better way to cross-examine Haadeeth stories.
A better way to cross-question Haadeeth stories.
A better way to confirm Haadeeth stories.
A better way to consider Haadeeth stories.
A better way to education in Haadeeth stories.
A better way to evaluate Haadeeth stories.
A better way of enquiry in Haadeeth stories.
A better way to examine Haadeeth stories.
A better way to explore Haadeeth stories.
A better way to grade Haadeeth stories.
A better way to inspect Haadeeth stories.
A better way to interrogate Haadeeth stories.
A better way to investigate Haadeeth stories.
A better way to judge Haadeeth stories.
A better way to measure Haadeeth stories.
A better way to probe Haadeeth stories.
A better way to prove Haadeeth stories.
A better way to question Haadeeth stories.
A better way to query Haadeeth stories.
A better way to quiz Haadeeth stories.
A better way to rate Haadeeth stories.
A better way to research Haadeeth stories.
A better way to vet Haadeeth stories.
A better way to review Haadeeth stories.
A better way to scholarship in Haadeeth stories.
A better way to schooling in Haadeeth stories.
A better way of scrutiny in Haadeeth stories.
A better way to scrutinize Haadeeth stories.
A better way to study Haadeeth stories.
A better way to teach Haadeeth stories.
A better way to test Haadeeth stories.
A better way to trial Haadeeth stories.
A better way to tuition in Haadeeth stories.
A better way to understand Haadeeth stories.
A better way to validate Haadeeth stories.
A better way to verify Haadeeth stories.
A better way to weigh Haadeeth stories.
A better way to analyse Haadiith stories.
A better way to appraise Haadiith stories.
A better way to assess Haadiith stories.
A better way to authenticate Haadiith stories.
A better way to certify Haadiith stories.
A better way to challenge Haadiith stories.
A better way to check Haadiith stories.
A better way to cross-examine Haadiith stories.
A better way to cross-question Haadiith stories.
A better way to confirm Haadiith stories.
A better way to consider Haadiith stories.
A better way to education in Haadiith stories.
A better way to evaluate Haadiith stories.
A better way of enquiry in Haadiith stories.
A better way to examine Haadiith stories.
A better way to explore Haadiith stories.
A better way to grade Haadiith stories.
A better way to inspect Haadiith stories.
A better way to interrogate Haadiith stories.
A better way to investigate Haadiith stories.
A better way to judge Haadiith stories.
A better way to measure Haadiith stories.
A better way to probe Haadiith stories.
A better way to prove Haadiith stories.
A better way to question Haadiith stories.
A better way to query Haadiith stories.
A better way to quiz Haadiith stories.
A better way to rate Haadiith stories.
A better way to research Haadiith stories.
A better way to vet Haadiith stories.
A better way to review Haadiith stories.
A better way to scholarship in Haadiith stories.
A better way to schooling in Haadiith stories.
A better way of scrutiny in Haadiith stories.
A better way to scrutinize Haadiith stories.
A better way to study Haadiith stories.
A better way to teach Haadiith stories.
A better way to test Haadiith stories.
A better way to trial Haadiith stories.
A better way to tuition in Haadiith stories.
A better way to understand Haadiith stories.
A better way to validate Haadiith stories.
A better way to verify Haadiith stories.
A better way to weigh Haadiith stories.
A better way to analyse Haadith stories.
A better way to appraise Haadith stories.
A better way to assess Haadith stories.
A better way to authenticate Haadith stories.
A better way to certify Haadith stories.
A better way to challenge Haadith stories.
A better way to check Haadith stories.
A better way to cross-examine Haadith stories.
A better way to cross-question Haadith stories.
A better way to confirm Haadith stories.
A better way to consider Haadith stories.
A better way to education in Haadith stories.
A better way to evaluate Haadith stories.
A better way of enquiry in Haadith stories.
A better way to examine Haadith stories.
A better way to explore Haadith stories.
A better way to grade Haadith stories.
A better way to inspect Haadith stories.
A better way to interrogate Haadith stories.
A better way to investigate Haadith stories.
A better way to judge Haadith stories.
A better way to measure Haadith stories.
A better way to probe Haadith stories.
A better way to prove Haadith stories.
A better way to question Haadith stories.
A better way to query Haadith stories.
A better way to quiz Haadith stories.
A better way to rate Haadith stories.
A better way to research Haadith stories.
A better way to vet Haadith stories.
A better way to review Haadith stories.
A better way to scholarship in Haadith stories.
A better way to schooling in Haadith stories.
A better way of scrutiny in Haadith stories.
A better way to scrutinize Haadith stories.
A better way to study Haadith stories.
A better way to teach Haadith stories.
A better way to test Haadith stories.
A better way to trial Haadith stories.
A better way to tuition in Haadith stories.
A better way to understand Haadith stories.
A better way to validate Haadith stories.
A better way to verify Haadith stories.
A better way to weigh Haadith stories.
A better way to analyse Hadeeth stories.
A better way to appraise Hadeeth stories.
A better way to assess Hadeeth stories.
A better way to authenticate Hadeeth stories.
A better way to certify Hadeeth stories.
A better way to challenge Hadeeth stories.
A better way to check Hadeeth stories.
A better way to cross-examine Hadeeth stories.
A better way to cross-question Hadeeth stories.
A better way to confirm Hadeeth stories.
A better way to consider Hadeeth stories.
A better way to education in Hadeeth stories.
A better way to evaluate Hadeeth stories.
A better way of enquiry in Hadeeth stories.
A better way to examine Hadeeth stories.
A better way to explore Hadeeth stories.
A better way to grade Hadeeth stories.
A better way to inspect Hadeeth stories.
A better way to interrogate Hadeeth stories.
A better way to investigate Hadeeth stories.
A better way to judge Hadeeth stories.
A better way to measure Hadeeth stories.
A better way to probe Hadeeth stories.
A better way to prove Hadeeth stories.
A better way to question Hadeeth stories.
A better way to query Hadeeth stories.
A better way to quiz Hadeeth stories.
A better way to rate Hadeeth stories.
A better way to research Hadeeth stories.
A better way to vet Hadeeth stories.
A better way to review Hadeeth stories.
A better way to scholarship in Hadeeth stories.
A better way to schooling in Hadeeth stories.
A better way of scrutiny in Hadeeth stories.
A better way to scrutinize Hadeeth stories.
A better way to study Hadeeth stories.
A better way to teach Hadeeth stories.
A better way to test Hadeeth stories.
A better way to trial Hadeeth stories.
A better way to tuition in Hadeeth stories.
A better way to understand Hadeeth stories.
A better way to validate Hadeeth stories.
A better way to verify Hadeeth stories.
A better way to weigh Hadeeth stories.
A better way to analyse Hadis stories.
A better way to appraise Hadis stories.
A better way to assess Hadis stories.
A better way to authenticate Hadis stories.
A better way to certify Hadis stories.
A better way to challenge Hadis stories.
A better way to check Hadis stories.
A better way to cross-examine Hadis stories.
A better way to cross-question Hadis stories.
A better way to confirm Hadis stories.
A better way to consider Hadis stories.
A better way to education in Hadis stories.
A better way to evaluate Hadis stories.
A better way of enquiry in Hadis stories.
A better way to examine Hadis stories.
A better way to explore Hadis stories.
A better way to grade Hadis stories.
A better way to inspect Hadis stories.
A better way to interrogate Hadis stories.
A better way to investigate Hadis stories.
A better way to judge Hadis stories.
A better way to measure Hadis stories.
A better way to probe Hadis stories.
A better way to prove Hadis stories.
A better way to question Hadis stories.
A better way to query Hadis stories.
A better way to quiz Hadis stories.
A better way to rate Hadis stories.
A better way to research Hadis stories.
A better way to vet Hadis stories.
A better way to review Hadis stories.
A better way to scholarship in Hadis stories.
A better way to schooling in Hadis stories.
A better way of scrutiny in Hadis stories.
A better way to scrutinize Hadis stories.
A better way to study Hadis stories.
A better way to teach Hadis stories.
A better way to test Hadis stories.
A better way to trial Hadis stories.
A better way to tuition in Hadis stories.
A better way to understand Hadis stories.
A better way to validate Hadis stories.
A better way to verify Hadis stories.
A better way to weigh Hadis stories.
A better way to analyse Hadiths stories.
A better way to appraise Hadiths stories.
A better way to assess Hadiths stories.
A better way to authenticate Hadiths stories.
A better way to certify Hadiths stories.
A better way to challenge Hadiths stories.
A better way to check Hadiths stories.
A better way to cross-examine Hadiths stories.
A better way to cross-question Hadiths stories.
A better way to confirm Hadiths stories.
A better way to consider Hadiths stories.
A better way to education in Hadiths stories.
A better way to evaluate Hadiths stories.
A better way of enquiry in Hadiths stories.
A better way to examine Hadiths stories.
A better way to explore Hadiths stories.
A better way to grade Hadiths stories.
A better way to inspect Hadiths stories.
A better way to interrogate Hadiths stories.
A better way to investigate Hadiths stories.
A better way to judge Hadiths stories.
A better way to measure Hadiths stories.
A better way to probe Hadiths stories.
A better way to prove Hadiths stories.
A better way to question Hadiths stories.
A better way to query Hadiths stories.
A better way to quiz Hadiths stories.
A better way to rate Hadiths stories.
A better way to research Hadiths stories.
A better way to vet Hadiths stories.
A better way to review Hadiths stories.
A better way to scholarship in Hadiths stories.
A better way to schooling in Hadiths stories.
A better way of scrutiny in Hadiths stories.
A better way to scrutinize Hadiths stories.
A better way to study Hadiths stories.
A better way to teach Hadiths stories.
A better way to test Hadiths stories.
A better way to trial Hadiths stories.
A better way to tuition in Hadiths stories.
A better way to understand Hadiths stories.
A better way to validate Hadiths stories.
A better way to verify Hadiths stories.
A better way to weigh Hadiths stories.
A better way to analyse Hadees stories.
A better way to appraise Hadees stories.
A better way to assess Hadees stories.
A better way to authenticate Hadees stories.
A better way to certify Hadees stories.
A better way to challenge Hadees stories.
A better way to check Hadees stories.
A better way to cross-examine Hadees stories.
A better way to cross-question Hadees stories.
A better way to confirm Hadees stories.
A better way to consider Hadees stories.
A better way to education in Hadees stories.
A better way to evaluate Hadees stories.
A better way of enquiry in Hadees stories.
A better way to examine Hadees stories.
A better way to explore Hadees stories.
A better way to grade Hadees stories.
A better way to inspect Hadees stories.
A better way to interrogate Hadees stories.
A better way to investigate Hadees stories.
A better way to judge Hadees stories.
A better way to measure Hadees stories.
A better way to probe Hadees stories.
A better way to prove Hadees stories.
A better way to question Hadees stories.
A better way to query Hadees stories.
A better way to quiz Hadees stories.
A better way to rate Hadees stories.
A better way to research Hadees stories.
A better way to vet Hadees stories.
A better way to review Hadees stories.
A better way to scholarship in Hadees stories.
A better way to schooling in Hadees stories.
A better way of scrutiny in Hadees stories.
A better way to scrutinize Hadees stories.
A better way to study Hadees stories.
A better way to teach Hadees stories.
A better way to test Hadees stories.
A better way to trial Hadees stories.
A better way to tuition in Hadees stories.
A better way to understand Hadees stories.
A better way to validate Hadees stories.
A better way to verify Hadees stories.
A better way to weigh Hadees stories.
A better way to analyse Haadiths stories.
A better way to appraise Haadiths stories.
A better way to assess Haadiths stories.
A better way to authenticate Haadiths stories.
A better way to certify Haadiths stories.
A better way to challenge Haadiths stories.
A better way to check Haadiths stories.
A better way to cross-examine Haadiths stories.
A better way to cross-question Haadiths stories.
A better way to confirm Haadiths stories.
A better way to consider Haadiths stories.
A better way to education in Haadiths stories.
A better way to evaluate Haadiths stories.
A better way of enquiry in Haadiths stories.
A better way to examine Haadiths stories.
A better way to explore Haadiths stories.
A better way to grade Haadiths stories.
A better way to inspect Haadiths stories.
A better way to interrogate Haadiths stories.
A better way to investigate Haadiths stories.
A better way to judge Haadiths stories.
A better way to measure Haadiths stories.
A better way to probe Haadiths stories.
A better way to prove Haadiths stories.
A better way to question Haadiths stories.
A better way to query Haadiths stories.
A better way to quiz Haadiths stories.
A better way to rate Haadiths stories.
A better way to research Haadiths stories.
A better way to vet Haadiths stories.
A better way to review Haadiths stories.
A better way to scholarship in Haadiths stories.
A better way to schooling in Haadiths stories.
A better way of scrutiny in Haadiths stories.
A better way to scrutinize Haadiths stories.
A better way to study Haadiths stories.
A better way to teach Haadiths stories.
A better way to test Haadiths stories.
A better way to trial Haadiths stories.
A better way to tuition in Haadiths stories.
A better way to understand Haadiths stories.
A better way to validate Haadiths stories.
A better way to verify Haadiths stories.
A better way to weigh Haadiths stories.
Index A.
1. The guidance of Allaah.
Allaah asks when you have the word of Allaah in the Quran what other report would you believe?
2. Hadith break the cross and kill the pigs contradicts the Quran.
2A. Who goes to Paradise in the Quran?
3. Hadith Prophet Jesus Isa is returning to this earth contradicts the Quran.
3A. Prophet Jesus Isa said he was not killed on the cross.
3B. The body of Prophet Jesus Isa was not raised to Allaah.
4. Hadith punishment in the grave contradicts the Quran.
5. Hadith the reward of 72 virgins in Jannah contradicts the Quran.
6. Hadith whoever changes his Islamic religion kill him contradicts the Quran.
7. Hadith women hung from their breasts contradicts the Quran.
8. Hadith stoning to death for adultery contradicts the Quran.
9. The claim that Prophet Muhammad cannot read and write contradicts the Quran.
9A. Hadith Prophet Muhammad aorta cut contradicts the Quran.
9B. Hadith Prophet Muhammad created from light contradicts the Quran.
9C. Hadith Prophet Muhammad night journey to Jerusalem riding Buraq contradicts the Quran.
9D. The claim Prophet Muhammad said the son to be sacrificed is Prophet Ishmael Ismail contradicts the Quran.
10. The claim that the Torah Taurat is corrupted contradicts the Quran.
10A. The sins of the prophets of Allaah in the Torah Taurat are confirmed in the Quran.
10B. Prophet Ishmael Ismail is the son in the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim contradicts the Quran.
10C. Jews are commanded to observe the Sabbath Day forever.
11. The claim that the Gospel Injil is corrupted contradicts the Quran.
11A. The story of Prophet Jesus Isa and Prophet Isaac Ishaq is the same story.
11B. The meaning of the mysterious letters in the Quran.
12. The claim that there are abrogated verses in the Quran contradicts the Quran.
13. The September 11 attacks and Islam show how people are inventing stories today which contradict the Quran.
14. Temporary pleasure marriage contradicts the Quran,
14A. Sex with slaves contradicts the Quran.
15. The Gospel of Barnabas contradicts the Quran and Torah Taurat and Gospel Injil.
16. How to find false hadith stories invented after the death of Prophet Muhammad which contradict the Quran.
17. A better way to understand examine teach study and check hadith stories by contradictions with the Quran.
17A. Quran 51:47 the expansion of the Universe?
17B. Quran 21:30 the big bang theory?
17C. Prophet Ishmael Ismail or Prophet Isaac Ishaq to be sacrificed?
17D. Hadith Jew is hiding behind me so kill him.
1. The guidance of Allaah.
Allaah asks when you have the word of Allaah in the Quran what other report would you believe?
.
Quran 77:50 Koran 77:50 In what statement (words, news, reports, information, message, hadith), after it (the verses of Allaah in the Quran), shall they (the humans and the jinn) believe?
Note 1. Quran 7:185, Quran 25:29, Quran 25:30, Quran 31:6, Quran 39:23, Quran 45:6 and Quran 77:50 asks when you have the word of Allaah in the Quran what other report would you believe?
.
Quran 17:88 Koran 17:88 Say (Prophet Muhammad), "If humans and jinn (such as Satan Shaitan) came together to help each other to produce something like the Quran, they could not do it."
Note 1. In the hereafter Satan Shaitan might boast he obeyed Quran 17:88 by whispering hundreds of false hadith stories which teach the opposite to what Allaah and Prophet Muhammad teach in the Quran.
.
Quran 25:30 Koran 25:30 And (on the Day of Resurrection and Judgement) the messenger (Prophet Muhammad) said, “My Lord (Allaah) my people have abandoned (deserted) this Quran (to follow false messages, false words, false news, false reports, false information, false statements, false hadith).”
Note 1. On the Day of Resurrection and Judgement Prophet Muhammad will say “My Lord my people have abandoned this Quran (to follow false messages, false words, false news, false reports, false information, false statements, false hadith).”
.
If hadith stories and the actions of humans agree with the Quran then accept it and learn from it.
If hadith stories and the actions of humans do not agree with the Quran then reject it and also learn from it.
On the Day of Judgement Allaah judges by the words in the protected Quran.
On the Day of Judgement Allaah does not judge by the words in unprotected human hadith stories.
The Quran is the protected word of Allaah including the words and actions of Prophet Muhammad which are described and protected by Allaah.
.
Video: Obsession with false hadith culture Is corrupting Islam.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SOQGOaNvLSU
2. Hadith break the cross and kill the pigs contradicts the Quran.
Sometimes the word of Allaah in His Books can be confused by the words of humans.
For example in the Gospel Injil Prophet Jesus Isa prayed to Allaah but some humans said Jesus Isa is Allaah and other humans believed Jesus Isa is Allaah meaning they followed the words of humans and not the words in the Gospel Injil.
The same thing can happen in Islam.
There are no contradictions in the Quran means whatever contradicts the Quran did not come from Allaah or from Prophet Muhammad.
The hadith “break the cross and kill the pigs” contradicts Quran 2:62, Quran 2:256 (see Quran 4:123, Quran 5:48 and Quran 9:29), Quran 3:55, Quran 3:64, Quran 3:85, Quran 3:144 (see Quran 5:75 and see “passed away” always means died in Quran 2:134, Quran 2:141, Quran 3:144, Quran 5:75, Quran 7:38, Quran 13:30, Quran 41:25 and Quran 46:17), Quran 4:114, Quran 4:123 (see Quran 2:256, Quran 5:48 and Quran 9:29), Quran 4:157 (see Quran 39:42), Quran 4:158 (see Quran 39:42), Quran 4:159 (see Quran 7:6 and Quran 5:117), Quran 5:48 (see Quran 2:256, Quran 4:123, Quran 5:48 and Quran 9:29), Quran 5:75 (see Quran 3:144 and see “passed away” always means died in Quran 2:134, Quran 2:141, Quran 3:144, Quran 5:75, Quran 7:38, Quran 13:30, Quran 41:25 and Quran 46:17), Quran 5:117 (see Quran 7:6), Quran 6:158, Quran 7:6 (see Quran 5:117), Quran 9:29 (see Quran 2:256 and Quran 5:48), Quran 21:95 (see Quran 23:99-23:100), Quran 23:99-23:100 (see Quran 21:95), Quran 28:54 (see Quran 34:37 and Quran 57:28), Quran 33:40 (see Gospel of Mark 13:5-13:6 and Gospel of Mark 13:21-13:23), Quran 39:42 (see Quran 4:157 and Quran 4:158), Quran 41:8, Quran 98:5, Gospel of Mark 13:5-13:6 and Gospel of Mark 13:21-13:23 (see Quran 33:40) meaning this hadith story was invented by story tellers after the death of Prophet Muhammad and repeated by people who were deceived to believe false stories.
Break the cross and kill the pigs contradicts the good news message from Allaah for Jews and Christians delivered 1400 years ago by Prophet Muhammad in Quran 28:54, Quran 34:37 and Quran 57:28.
A. Jews and Christians who follow their Book and also believe the Quran shall receive a double reward in the hereafter in Quran 28:54, Quran 34:37 and Quran 57:28.
B. Jews who follow the Tanakh Jewish scripture and believe the Quran are correctly observing the Torah Taurat.
C. Christians who follow the Gospels and believe the Quran are correctly observing the Gospel Injil.
D. Muslims who follow the Quran so that it agrees with the Tanakh Jewish scripture and the Gospel Injil are correctly observing the Quran.
Quran 28:54 Koran 28:54 They (the Jews who truly believe the Torah Taurat and the Christians who truly believe the Gospel Injil and also believe the Quran) shall be given their reward twice (in Quran 28:54 meaning twofold in Quran 34:37 meaning double in Quran 57:28) because they are steadfast (in their belief in Allaah) and they repel evil with good (deeds) and they spend (in charity) from what We (Allaah) have provided to them. (Jews and Christians who follow their Book in Quran 5:68 and also believe the Quran will receive a double reward in the hereafter in Quran 28:54, Quran 34:37 and Quran 57:28 meaning the reward for every good deed they do will be doubled because they believed the Quran which tells the Jewish people to follow the Torah Taurat which is their eternal covenant between Allaah and the Hebrew people forever and tells the Christian people to follow the Gospel Injil which is explained in the Quran and tells the Muslim people to follow the Quran in Quran 2:40, Quran 2:41, Quran 2:62, Quran 2:106, Quran 3:93, Quran 4:123, Quran 5:43, Quran 5:47, Quran 5:48, Quran 5:69 and Quran 13:39).
Note 1. Jews and Christians who follow their book and also believe the Quran will receive their reward twice in the Hereafter.
.
Quran 34:38 Koran 34:38 (Jews and Christians who followed their Book and also believed the Quran will receive their reward twice in Quran 28:54, twofold in Quran 34:37 and double in Quran 57:28 in the hereafter however) Those (Jews and the Christians who did not believe the Quran for example if Jews did not correctly observe the Torah Taurat by keeping the Sabbath Day which is their everlasting covenant with Allaah in every generation forever or if Christians did not correctly observe the Gospel Injil where Prophet Jesus said he is not Allaah "Allaah is my Allaah and your Allaah" meaning Allaah is my Lord and your Lord and "Allaah is my Father and your Father" meaning Allaah is my Creator and your Creator in Gospel of John 20:17 and) who strive against Our (Allaah’s) revelations by trying to make them (Allaah’s revelations) to fail (for example Jesus is the son of Allaah means Jesus is the servant of Allaah delivering the message of Allaah so his mention with angels in Gospel of Mark 13:32 and Gospel of Matthew 24:36 means that angel messengers of Allaah and human messengers of Allaah both do not know the hour meaning do not confuse angel and human messengers with Allaah because only Allaah knows the hour but His angel and human messengers like Jesus and Moses and angels do not know the hour meaning pray only to Allaah and not to the angel and human messengers of Allaah because those who do), they shall be brought to the punishment (of Hell Jahannam in the Hereafter).
Quran 28:51 Koran 28:51 And We (Allaah) have made the Word (of Allaah in the Quran) to reach them (the stone idol worshippers of Makkah Arabia) so that they might be reminded (of Allaah, their creator).
Quran 28:48 Koran 28:48 But when the truth came to them (the stone idol worshippers of Makkah Arabia) from Us (Allaah), they said, “Why is he (Prophet Muhammad M Mim م M-uhammad م-uhammad) not given (signs) like what was given to Prophet Moses Musa (represented by Mount Sinai S’ Sin س Sin-ai س-ai)? But did they (the stone idol worshippers of Makkah Arabia) not disbelieve in what was given to Prophet Moses Musa in the past? (Because) they say, “(They are both only books about magic) two magic (books the Torah Taurat T Ta ط Ta-urat ط-urat given by Allaah to Prophet Moses Musa and the Quran Q Qaf ق Qaf-uran ق-uran given by Allaah to Prophet Muhammad) supporting each other” and they (the stone idol worshippers of Makkah Arabia) say, “In all (that is in the Torah Taurat and the Quran) we do not believe.”
Quran 28:49 Koran 28:49 Say (Prophet Muhammad to the stone idol worshippers of Makkah Arabia), “Then bring a Book from Allaah that gives better guidance than these two (the Torah Taurat and the Quran) so that I (Prophet Muhammad) may follow it, if you are telling the truth.”
Note 1. The best guidance is the Quran and the Torah Taurat meaning both are correctly understood when they confirm and explain each other.
See. Hadith break the cross and kill the pigs.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/hadith-break-the-cross-and-kill-the-pigs
2A. Who goes to Paradise in the Quran?
Quran 2:62 Koran 2:62 (In the hereafter) truly those (Muslims) who believed and those who are Jews, Christians and Sabians, whoever believed in Allaah and the Last Day (The Day of Resurrection) and did good deeds, they shall have their reward from their Lord, and they shall not fear or grieve (and this is confirmed in Quran 6:158 for those in the hereafter who “believed” and did good deeds. Quran 5:69 repeats Quran 2:62 meaning stop and think about what Allaah is saying in these verses confirming what is in the Hebrew Bible and the Gospel Injil of the promise of Paradise Jannah from Allaah in the books of Allaah on the Day of Resurrection and Judgement for those who “believed” and did good deeds. The Quran brings the same truth which Allaah brought to the Jewish people in the Hebrew Bible and to the Christian people in the Gospel Injil of Jesus Isa by Mark, Matthew, Luke and John. The Quran is a confirmer of what came before it in the same way as the Gospel Injil is a confirmer of what came before it meaning the Books of Allaah confirm each other as proof Allaah is real and as proof His promise is real showing that without His permission no one can change His words in His Books which are with all humans today and until the Day of Judgement so that you can believe Allaah is real and His promise is real).
Note 1. The Jews who believed in Allaah and did good deeds go to Paradise Jannah.
Note 2. The Christians who believed in Allaah and did good deeds go to Paradise Jannah.
Note 3. The Sabians who believed in Allaah and did good deeds go to Paradise Jannah.
Note 4. The Muslims who believed in Allaah and did good deeds go to Paradise Jannah.
Note 5. Everyone who believed in Allaah and did good deeds goes to Paradise Jannah.
Note 6. This revelation is so important that Allaah has repeated it in Quran 5:69.
In Quran 2:62 and Quran 5:69 the promise of Paradise Jannah is not for those who “believe” but only for those who “believed” meaning who died (past tense) because it is not until the time of death that your true belief or disbelief and your good and evil deeds are judged,
Allaah repeated Quran 2:62 and Quran 5:69 two times because it is only with Quran 2:62 and Quran 5:69 that there are no contradictions within the Quran and between the Quran and the Torah Taurat and between the Quran and the Gospel Injil as proof in Quran 4:82 to the Jews in the time of Prophet Muhammad who are promised Paradise Jannah in Quran 3:113-3:115 and to the Christians in the time of Prophet Muhammad who are promised Paradise Jannah in Quran 5:82-5:85 and to the stone idol worshippers 1400 years ago who are not promised Paradise Jannah in Quran 3:85 and to all people today and in the future that the Quran is from Allaah because the Quran contains no contradictions.
If Quran 2:62 and Quran 5:69 did not exist then it would be proof that the Quran was not from Allaah because without Quran 2:62 and Quran 5:69 the Quran would contradict its self and contradict the Torah Taurat and contradict the Gospel Injil.
Quran 2:62 and Quran 5:69 is good news for Jews, Christians, Sabians, Muslims and all the people in the world confirming they will all come together again in a life after death.
Quran 4:123 Koran 4:123 (Entry to Paradise Jannah) shall not be based on your (the Muslim's) desires or on the desires of the people of the Scripture (the Jews and the Christians). (Instead) whoever does wrong (on the earth) shall earn (the punishment for the wrong) and that person shall not find any protector or helper other than Allaah (in the hereafter).
Note 1. Allaah will judge Muslims and Christians and Jews and every creation justly in the hereafter.
Quran 3:85 Koran 3:85 And whoever seeks a religion other than submission (to Allah Adonai Allaah Elohim G-d Allah HaShem Jehovah Yahweh YHWH which includes every human from the beginning of time until the end of time, for example stone idol worship) it shall not be accepted by Him (Allaah) in the Hereafter and (such a person) shall be one of the losers (in the hereafter. The word Islam has two meanings, the general meaning is submission in Quran 3:85 meaning anyone who submits to Allaah).
Note 1. The Muslim religion Islam is the religion of submission to Allaah (Quran 3:64).
Note 2. The Jewish religion Judaism is the religion of submission to Allaah (Quran 3:64).
Note 3. The Christian religion Christianity is the religion of submission to Allaah (Quran 3:64).
Note 4. Islam means submission and the Quran tells the Jews to observe the Sabbath Day meaning all Jews who observe the Sabbath Day are submitting to Allaah which means the word in Quran 3:85 is submission otherwise it would contradict other verses in the Quran and the Quran says it has no contradictions.
This means only one word "submission" is correct because it is the word with which there are no contradictions in the Quran.
Quran 3:64 Koran 3:64 Say, “O People of the Scripture (the Jews and the Christians) let us come to an agreement between you and us (Muslims), that we shall worship no one but Allaah, and that we shall ascribe no partner to Him (meaning, there is only one Allaah, we pray only to our creator the one Allaah and no one else, not to sons, not to saints, not to any idol), and that none of us shall take others for Lords instead of Allaah.” And if they turn away, then say, “Bear witness that we have submitted to Him (Allaah).”
Note 1. Allaah does not require humans to all be in one religion (Quran 5:48).
Note 2. Allaah does require that every religion worship only Allaah (Quran 3:85).
Note 3. Allaah says if the Jews and the Christians and others worship only Allaah like the Muslims worship only Allaah then the Jews and the Christians and others are correctly guided by Allaah (Quran 3:64).
Quran 5:48 Koran 5:48 “... For each (community of Jews, Christians and Muslims) We (Allaah) have appointed a divine law and a way (of religion). If Allaah willed He (Allaah) could have made you (the Jews, the Christians and the Muslims) one community. But He (Allaah) tests you (the Jews, the Christians and the Muslims) by what He (Allaah) has given you (in the Torah Taurat and the Gospel Injil and the Koran Quran to show who is best in behaviour). So strive for all that is good. To Allaah you shall all return and He (Allaah) shall then inform you (in the Hereafter) about (the correctness of) the religious matters in which you (the Jews, the Christians and the Muslims) argue among each other.
Note 1. Allaah does not require humans to all be in one religion (Quran 5:48).
Note 2. Allaah does require that every religion worship only Allaah (Quran 3:85).
Note 3. Allaah says if the Jews and the Christians and others worship only Allaah like the Muslims worship only Allaah then the Jews and the Christians and others are correctly guided by Allaah (Quran 3:64).
Note 4. Allaah commands the Jews, the Christians and the Muslims to do what is good according to what Allaah has given them in the Torah Taurat and the Gospel Injil and the Koran Quran to show which humans are the best in behaviour.
Note 5. Allaah says that on the Day of Resurrection and Judgement in the hereafter every human will return to Allaah and Allaah shall inform them about the religious matters about which they argued.
Note 6. Allaah protects the Torah Taurat for every Jewish generation until the Day of Judgement (Quran 5:48).
Note 7. Allaah protects the Gospel Injil for every Christian generation until the Day of Judgement (Quran 5:48) in the following way.
Quran 5:68 says observe the Torah Taurat and the Gospel Injil and Quran 5:47 tells Christians to judge by the Gospel Injil meaning whatever in the Gospel Injil is confirmed in the Jewish Torah Taurat came from Prophet Jesus Isa and whatever contradicts the Jewish Torah Taurat came from Mark, Matthew, Luke and John.
Note 8. Allaah protects the Gospel Injil for every Christian generation until the Day of Judgement (Quran 5:48) in the following way.
Prophet Jesus Isa did not write anything because everything Prophet Jesus Isa taught by his mouth was already written in the Tanakh Jewish scripture meaning Prophet Jesus Isa did not add or subtract from what is in Tanakh Jewish scripture.
The four Gospel Injil are four reports about Prophet Jesus Isa meaning Prophet Jesus Isa never wrote anything and what he said was passed by mouth until it was written many years later.
Quran 5:68 says observe the Torah Taurat and the Gospel Injil and Quran 5:47 tells Christians to judge by the Gospel Injil (not by the other books in the Christian New Testament Bible because what Paul teaches contradicts what Jesus is teaching in the Gospel Injil and anything about fallen angels found in the Book of Enoch and in the Book of Revelation are all rejected in Judaism because in the Hebrew Tanakh scripture angels always obey Allaah. Jewish people do not use the Christian produced Old Testament Bible because many contain wrong translations of the Hebrew Tanakh meaning whatever in the Gospel Injil is confirmed in the Jewish Torah Taurat came from Prophet Jesus Isa and whatever contradicts the Jewish Torah Taurat came from the unknown writers who are traditionally called Mark, Matthew, Luke and John in a test from Allaah described in 1 Kings 13:14 - 13:24 teaching that the word of Allaah will not change and do not believe anyone or any verse in Mark, Matthew, Luke or John which contradicts the teachings in the Tanakh which Prophet Jesus Isa said is with the Jewish people forever and will never change and must be followed forever by the Jewish people in Gospel of Matthew 5:17 - 5:20 and Gospel of Matthew 23:1 - 23:3. In this way a Christian can know what came from Prophet Jesus Isa confirming Tanakh and what did not come from Prophet Jesus Isa because it contradicts the Tanakh (which is the Torah law and the prophets and the writings like the Psalms) which Jesus was teaching in Gospel of Luke 24:44.
Note 9. Allaah protects the Koran Quran for every Muslim generation until the Day of Judgement (Quran 5:48).
Note 10. Entry to Paradise the Garden of Eden the Garden of Righteousness Jannah is not based on the question of Sunni or Shia or Muslim or Jew or Christian but it is based on your good behaviour towards all humans and creatures in this world and your relationship with Allaah (Quran 5:48).
Note 11. In the sight of humans Judaism and Christianity and Sabians and Islam are different religions.
Note 12. In the sight of Allaah Judaism and Christianity and Sabians and Islam are “different communities of Allaah” because they were all created by Allaah for only one reason which is “to submit to Allaah.”
Quran 4:114 Koran 4:114 There is no good in most of their (the people’s) private conversation except in the person who calls for charity, kindness and peace making between humans, he (the person) who does this (charity, kindness and peace making between humans) and seeks the approval of Allaah, We (Allaah) shall give them a great reward (in Paradise Jannah in the Hereafter).
Note 1. Allaah calls all humans to work together in charity and in kindness and in peacemaking in seeking the approval of Allaah.
Quran 6:158 Koran 6:158 "... belief in it (Allaah and the Day of Resurrection and Judgement) shall not help any soul …. if in belief (he or she) did not earn good (by doing righteous deeds in their life). ....”
Quran 41:8 Koran 41:8 “For those who believe and do good deeds, for them is an everlasting reward (in Paradise Jannah).”
Quran 48:14 Koran 48:14 To Allaah belong the dominion of the heavens and the earth. He (Allaah) forgives whom He (Allaah) will and punishes whom He (Allaah) will. Allaah is forgiving and merciful.
Note 1. Mercy and forgiveness and punishment in the hereafter is with Allaah.
Quran 98:5 Koran 98:5 They (the Jews and the Christians) were not commanded anything (from Allaah in the Torah Taurat and in the Gospel Injil) except that they (the Jews and the Christians) should worship Allaah and be faithful in religion to Him (Allaah) and establish prayer (only to the one Allaah who created them) and give charity (to the needy people). That is the correct religion of Allaah.
Note 1. Allaah explains why Judaism with the Torah Taurat and Christianity with the Gospel Injil and Islam with the Quran are the same belief in one Allaah who is the creator of every creation.
1. Not all Christians and Jews and Muslims are the same meaning in every generation there are some Christians and Muslims and Jews who are correctly worshiping Allaah.
The Christian and Jew who believed in one Allaah like the Muslim who believed in one Allaah and who did good deeds on the Earth will be successful (Quran 2:62 and Quran 5:69).
2. The sins of the prophets is a reminder to humans not to elevate the prophets instead of elevating Allaah.
Moses Musa sinned by killing a man and the messiah king David Dawud sinned by adultery (represented in the story of a man who had one female sheep in the sin of ewe, the sin involving a female) and murder (represented in the story by another man who caused to die something that did not belong to him in the sin of ewe, the sin involving a female) and the messiah king Solomon Sulaiman sinned by marriage to foreign wives who brought idol worship to Israel so that every human who comes after them can know that when you repent and correct your behaviour Allaah will forgive all your sins without a blood sacrifice in Psalm 32:5, Psalm 51:17 - 51:19 in Tanakh or Psalm 51:15 - 51:17 in a Christian Bible, 1 Kings 8:46 - 8:50, Ecclesiastes 7:20, Proverbs 24:16, Ezekiel 18:20 - 18:23, Isaiah 1:18, Isaiah 55:7, Hosea 6:6, Hosea 14:2 - 14:3 and Micah 6:6 - 6:8.
3. Those Muslims in the past who elevated Prophet Muhammad after his death and those Jews who elevated Prophet Ezra in the time of Prophet Muhammad and those Christians who elevated Prophet Jesus Isa in the time of Prophet Muhammad will have problems because they elevated prophets instead of elevating only Allaah (Quran 3:64 and Quran 4:123).
Appalled Christian Caller! "You call my religion idolatry?" Rabbi Tovia Singer responds.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nr_v_93p3SE
See. Hadith break the cross and kill the pigs.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/hadith-break-the-cross-and-kill-the-pigs
3. Hadith Prophet Jesus Isa is returning to this earth contradicts the Quran.
Sometimes the word of Allaah in His Books can be confused by the words of humans.
For example in the Gospel Injil Prophet Jesus Isa prayed to Allaah but some humans said Jesus Isa is Allaah and other humans believed Jesus Isa is Allaah meaning they followed the words of humans and not the words in the Gospel Injil.
The same thing can happen in Islam.
There are no contradictions in the Quran means whatever contradicts the Quran did not come from Allaah or from Prophet Muhammad.
The hadith “Prophet Jesus Isa is returning to this earth” because he did not die 2000 years ago contradicts Quran 3:144 (where “passed away” in the Quran always means died in Quran 2:134, Quran 2:141, Quran 3:144, Quran 5:75, Quran 7:38, Quran 13:30, Quran 41:25 and Quran 46:17), Quran 4:157 (see Quran 39:42), Quran 4:158 (see Quran 39:42), Quran 5:75 (where “passed away” in the Quran always means died in Quran 2:134, Quran 2:141, Quran 3:144, Quran 5:75, Quran 7:38, Quran 13:30, Quran 41:25 and Quran 46:17), Quran 5:117 (see Quran 7:6), Quran 7:6 (see Quran 5:117), Quran 21:95 (see Quran 23:99 – 23:100), Quran 33:40 (see Gospel of Jesus Isa by Mark 13:5 – 13:6, 13:21 – 13:22) and Quran 39:42 (see Quran 4:157 and Quran 4:158) meaning this hadith story was invented by story tellers after the death of Prophet Muhammad and repeated by people who were deceived to believe false hadith stories.
In the Quran Prophet Jesus Isa was saved on the cross from death with sleep and woke up after 3 days of sleep to continue living on the earth teaching the people he is not god until his natural death 2000 years ago as proof to his people that he is not god and in this way the Quran explains the story of Prophet Jesus Isa in the Gospel of Mark, Matthew, Luke and John which was with the Christian people 1400 years ago and is with them today and will be with them until the Day of Judgement.
Allaah knew how the first Muslims would feel about the death of Prophet Muhammad.
To help the first Muslims accept the death of Prophet Muhammad Allaah revealed in Quran 5:75 that the messengers before Jesus Isa died and Jesus Isa and his mother Mary Maryam “both use to eat food” meaning they also both died (Allaah is saying this so that the first Muslims will understand that if all the messengers died would you not also expect that Prophet Muhammad will also die).
The same words are in Quran 3:144 except now Allaah says the messengers before Prophet Muhammad have died meaning Prophet Jesus Isa who is the messenger before Prophet Muhammad has died (Allaah is saying this so that the first Muslims will understand that if all the messengers died would you not also expect that Prophet Muhammad will also die).
In these two revelations the hearts of the first Muslims are comforted by Allaah making it easier for the first Muslims to accept the death of the prophet.
This is proof from Allaah in the protected Quran that all hadith stories about Jesus Isa returning to this earth because he did not die a natural death like every human before him and after him were invented after the death of the prophet.
The hadith stories are opposite to the story Allaah is teaching the first Muslims in the Quran.
It is proof from Allaah that these are false hadith stories invented by story tellers who lived their life inventing stories or told by people who were deceived to believe false stories which are opposite to what Allaah and Prophet Muhammad are teaching in the protected Quran.
See 1. Hadith Jesus returning.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/hadith-prophet-jesus-returning
See 2. How did Allaah save Jesus.
See Quran 4:157 and Quran 4:158 comments in Quran chapter 4.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/quran-chapter-4-surah-4
See 3. Psalm 22 My Allaah my Allaah why have you forsaken me?
Why did David say my Allaah my Allaah why have you forsaken me?
Why did Jesus say my Allaah my Allaah why have you forsaken me?
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/my-allaah-my-allaah-why-have-you-forsaken-me-psalm-22
See 4. Why did Jesus say my Allaah my Allaah why have you forsaken me?
See 5. Was Jesus killed on the cross?
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/was-jesus-killed-on-the-cross
See 6. What happened to Jesus at the end of his life?
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/what-happened-to-jesus-at-the-end-of-his-life
See 7. Jesus died a natural death 2000 years ago in the Quran and in the Gospel.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/prophet-jesus-died-a-natural-death
See 8. The body of Jesus was not raised to Allaah.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/the-body-of-jesus-was-not-raised-to-allaah
See 9. Who is to blame for the death of Jesus?
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/who-is-to-blame-for-the-death-of-jesus
3A. Prophet Jesus Isa said he was not killed on the cross.
In 1 below Jesus said he was not killed on the cross.
In 2 below Paul showed that Jesus was not resurrected from the dead.
1. Three days after the crucifixion Jesus said he did not die meaning he was not sacrificed.
Three days after the crucifixion Jesus told Mary Magdalene to tell all the disciples that Jesus did not die on the cross in Gospel of John 20:17 “I have not yet ascended to the Father” meaning Allaah saved the life of Jesus on the cross with a miracle which made people think Jesus was dead on the cross in the same way Allaah made people believe a sleeping person was dead in Gospel of Mark 5:39, Gospel of Matthew 9:24 and Gospel of Luke 8:52.
The soul of every human ascends to Allaah during sleep and when they die (Quran 39:42).
When Jesus says “I (Jesus) have not yet ascended to the Father (Allaah)” Jesus is not talking about sleep because every human ascends to Allaah every night during sleep therefore the meaning is Jesus has not yet died meaning Allaah saved the life of Jesus on the cross with sleep (Gospel of Mark 5:39, Gospel of Matthew 9:24, Gospel of Luke 8:52, Quran 4:158 and Quran 39:42) meaning Jesus did not die on the cross with death but was saved on the cross with sleep which looked like Jesus was dead and in this way Allaah saved the life of Jesus meaning no one killed Jesus (Gospel of Luke 8:54 – 8:55 and Quran 39:42) meaning no one crucified Jesus to death (Quran 4:157).
When Jesus says "I (Jesus) am ascending to my Father (Allaah) and your Father (Allaah)" it means Jesus will die like every human dies meaning Jesus died a natural death at the end of his life 2000 years ago (Quran 3:144 and Quran 5:75) as proof Jesus is human and as proof Jesus is not Allaah.
Gospel of John 20:17 Jesus says to her (Mary Magdalene), "Do not hold on to me, for I have not yet ascended to the Father (Allaah); but go to my brothers (my disciples), and tell them: 'I am ascending to my Father and your Father; to my Allaah and your Allaah.'"
Note 1. After the crucifixion Jesus says do not hold on to me to see if I am really alive, I have not yet ascended to my Father meaning I am not yet dead meaning I am really alive meaning I am not a ghost.
Note 2. Jesus said tell the brothers that Allaah is My Father and your Father meaning Allaah is my creator and your creator because the father is the creator of every creation.
Malachi 2:10 Have we not all one father (Allaah)? Has not one Allaah created us? …”
Note 3. Jesus said tell the brothers that Allaah is My Allaah and your Allaah meaning Allaah is my Lord and your Lord.
Note 4. Three days after the crucifixion Jesus tells Mary to tell his brothers (his disciples) that “I have not yet ascended to the Father” meaning Jesus was saved by Allaah from the death of crucifixion.
Note 5. Three days after the crucifixion Jesus tells Mary to tell his brothers (his disciples) that “I am ascending to my Father” meaning Jesus will die like every human dies as proof Jesus is human meaning do not let a miracle make you think that Jesus is more than a man like you meaning Jesus will die like you will die because all humans die as proof they are humans.
Note 6. Three days after the crucifixion Jesus tells Mary to tell his brothers (his disciples) that Allaah is “my Father and your Father” meaning Allaah is my creator and your creator meaning do not let a miracle make you think that Jesus is more than a man like you.
Note 7. Three days after the crucifixion Jesus tells Mary to tell his brothers (his disciples) that Allaah is “my Allaah and your Allaah” meaning Allaah is my Lord and your Lord meaning Allaah is my Master and your Master meaning do not let a miracle make you think that Jesus is more than a man like you.
Note 8. No one tells people they are not Allaah unless something amazing has happened which might cause confusion about who Jesus is. This is the reason Jesus is telling Mary Magdalene (who is the first person Jesus meets after the crucifixion) to say these things to his brothers (who are his disciples) so that no one is confused by a miracle from Allaah. Jesus fainted into sleep on the cross making everyone believe Jesus was dead on the cross and in this way Allaah saved the life of Jesus.
Gospel of Mark 5:39 "... The child is not dead but sleeping",
Gospel of Matthew 9:24 "... For the maiden meaning the girl has not died but sleeps ..."
Gospel of Luke 8:52 "... She is not dead but sleeping."
Gospel of Luke 8:54 – 8:55 “…"Damsel meaning girl, wake up!" And her spirit returned, and she stood up at once, and he ordered that she be given something to eat. (This was proof that she was alive and not dead and that she was a physical body who could eat food and not a resurrected spiritual body that does not need food meaning she was a physical body who woke up after sleep and not a spiritual body which was resurrected after death as described by Paul in 1 Corinthians 15:35 and 1 Corinthians 15:44).
Note 1. In the Gospel after the crucifixion Jesus also asks for something to eat as proof he is alive and human and not a ghost.
2. Paul confirms Jesus did not die on the cross when Paul says that the dead are resurrected in a spiritual body.
Jesus was not resurrected in a spiritual body therefore according to the revelations of Paul Jesus did not die meaning Jesus was not sacrificed.
1 Corinthians 15:35 “How are the dead raised (resurrected) in what kind of body will they (the resurrected dead) come?
1 Corinthians 15:44 It is raised (resurrected) a spiritual body (however 3 days after the crucifixion Jesus showed that his body was a physical body which Mary could touch and by eating food and showing nail marks on his hand and a wound on his side to his disciples meaning Jesus showed he was not a resurrected spiritual body but was saved from death on the cross by falling into sleep on the cross and waking up after 3 days in his physical body in the same way as other people who appeared to be dead were only sleeping in their physical body in Gospel of Mark 5:39 "... The child is not dead but sleeping", Gospel of Matthew 9:24 "... For the maiden meaning the girl has not died but sleeps ..." and the Gospel of Luke 8:52 "... She is not dead but sleeping". ” … and Gospel of Luke 8:54 – 8:55 “…"Damsel meaning girl, wake up!" And her spirit returned).
Jesus in 1 above tells us that Jesus was not killed on the cross and Paul in 2 above shows that Jesus was not resurrected 3 days after the crucifixion meaning both Jesus and Paul give the proof that Jesus was not sacrificed on the cross to remove the sins of the world..
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/was-jesus-killed-on-the-cross
Three days after the crucifixion Jesus said “I have not yet ascended to the Father (Allaah in Gospel of John 20:17)” meaning Jesus was not killed on the cross but Allaah saved the life of Jesus with sleep on the cross that looked like death meaning Jesus was not sacrificed and this was foreshadowed in the Gospel in the following way.
Gospel of Mark 5:39 "... The child is not dead but sleeping",
Gospel of Matthew 9:24 "... For the maiden meaning the girl has not died but sleeps ..."
Gospel of Luke 8:52 "... She is not dead but sleeping."
Gospel of Luke 8:54 – 8:55 “…"Damsel meaning girl, wake up!" And her spirit returned, and she stood up at once, and he ordered that she be given something to eat. (This was proof that she was alive and not dead and that she was a physical body who could eat food and not a resurrected spiritual body that does not need food meaning she was a physical body who woke up after sleep and not a spiritual body which was resurrected after death as described by Paul in 1 Corinthians 15:35 and 1 Corinthians 15:44).
See 1. Was Jesus killed on the cross?
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/was-jesus-killed-on-the-cross
See 2. What happened to Jesus at the end of his life?
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/what-happened-to-jesus-at-the-end-of-his-life
See 3. Jesus died a natural death 2000 years ago in the Quran and in the Gospel.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/prophet-jesus-died-a-natural-death
See 4. The body of Jesus was not raised to Allaah.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/the-body-of-jesus-was-not-raised-to-allaah
3B. The body of Prophet Jesus Isa was not raised to Allaah.
The soul of Prophet Jesus Isa was raised to Allaah when Allaah saved the life of Prophet Jesus Isa by causing him to faint into sleep on the cross in Quran 4:157, Quran 4:158, Quran 6:60 and Quran 39:42.
Gospel of Luke 8:54 – 8:55 “…"Damsel meaning girl, wake up!" And her spirit returned, and she stood up at once, and he ordered that she be given something to eat. (This was proof that she was alive and not dead and that she was a physical body who could eat food and not a resurrected spiritual body that does not need food meaning she was a physical body who woke up after sleep and not a spiritual body which was resurrected after death as described by Paul in 1 Corinthians 15:35 and 1 Corinthians 15:44).
In the same way Prophet Jesus explains that he did not die on the cross in Gospel of John 20:17 when after 3 days of sleep Prophet Jesus woke up in his physical body meaning Prophet Jesus was not sacrificed and was not resurrected after death as described by Paul in 1 Corinthians 15:35 and 1 Corinthians 15:44 where those who are resurrected after death will return to life in a spiritual body which exists forever and does not need food and cannot be touched by people who are in a physical body.
This is why Prophet Jesus in Gospel of John 20:17 said don’t hold on to me (to see if I am really alive). I have not yet ascended to the Father Allaah meaning I have not yet died meaning 3 days after the crucifixion Jesus said I was not killed on the cross meaning I was not sacrificed on the cross meaning I was not resurrected from death to life meaning 3 days after the crucifixion in Gospel of John 20:17 Jesus said I am not a ghost a spiritual body that cannot be touched because I have not yet died meaning the life of Jesus was saved when he fainted into sleep on the cross which made everyone believe that Jesus was dead on the cross until Jesus woke up and explained in Gospel of John 20:17 that he has not yet died because Jesus was saved from death on the cross with sleep on the cross as Allaah had foreshadowed before the crucifixion in Gospel of Mark 5:39, Gospel of Matthew 9:24,.Gospel of Luke 8:52 and Gospel of Luke 8:54 – 8:55.
Gospel of Mark 5:39 "... The child is not dead but sleeping",
Gospel of Matthew 9:24 "... For the maiden meaning the girl has not died but sleeps ..."
Gospel of Luke 8:52 "... She is not dead but sleeping."
Gospel of Luke 8:54 – 8:55 “…"Damsel meaning girl, wake up!" And her spirit returned, and she stood up at once, and he ordered that she be given something to eat. (This was proof that she was alive and not dead and that she was a physical body who could eat food and not a resurrected spiritual body that does not need food meaning she was a physical body who woke up after sleep and not a spiritual body which was resurrected after death as described by Paul in 1 Corinthians 15:35 and 1 Corinthians 15:44).
Malachi 2:10 Have we not all one father (Allaah)? Has not one Allaah created us? …”
See 1. Was Jesus killed on the cross?
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/was-jesus-killed-on-the-cross
See 2. What happened to Jesus at the end of his life?
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/what-happened-to-jesus-at-the-end-of-his-life
See 3. Jesus died a natural death 2000 years ago in the Quran and in the Gospel.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/prophet-jesus-died-a-natural-death
See 4. The body of Jesus was not raised to Allaah.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/the-body-of-jesus-was-not-raised-to-allaah
4. Hadith punishment in the grave contradicts the Quran.
Sometimes the word of Allaah in His Books can be confused by the words of humans.
For example in the Gospel Injil Prophet Jesus Isa prayed to Allaah but some humans said Jesus Isa is Allaah and other humans believed Jesus Isa is Allaah meaning they followed the words of humans and not the words in the Gospel Injil.
The same thing can happen in Islam.
There are no contradictions in the Quran means whatever contradicts the Quran did not come from Allaah or from Prophet Muhammad.
In the Quran every human both the righteous and the wicked will swear on the Day of Resurrection that death feels like nothing but waking up from a short one hour sleep or short ten hour sleep.
The hadith “Punishment in the grave” contradicts Quran 2:259, Quran 18:19, Quran 20:103, Quran 20:104, Quran 23:113, Quran 30:55, Quran 46:35 and Quran 79:46 meaning this hadith story was invented by story tellers after the death of Prophet Muhammad and repeated by people who were deceived to believe false hadith stories.
On the Day of resurrection every human will say
1. Quran 20:103 says “You have stayed ten (hours sleeping in death like the 7 sleepers and Prophet Ezra Uzair described).
2. Quran 20:104 says "You did not stay for more than one day (sleeping in death like the 7 sleepers and Prophet Ezra Uzair described).
3. Quran 23:113 says they (the evil doers) shall say, “(It feels like) we stayed a day or part of a day (sleeping in death on the Earth before we were resurrected like the 7 sleepers and Prophet Ezra Uzair described).
4. Quran 30:55 says the wrong doers shall swear (in the Hereafter) that they only stayed (sleeping in death) for an hour (meaning only one hour had passed since they had died on the Earth like the 7 sleepers and Prophet Ezra Uzair described),
5. Quran 46:35 says it shall seem to them) as though they had stayed (sleeping for) only one hour of a day (before they were resurrected from death to life on the Day of Resurrection and Judgement like the 7 sleepers and Prophet Ezra Uzair described)
6. Quran 79:46 On the day they see it (the Day of Resurrection), it shall be as if they (each human) had not stayed (sleeping in death) except for an evening or a morning (like the 7 sleepers and Prophet Ezra Uzair described).
Quran 7:187 says the Hour of the Day of Resurrection “will come suddenly” meaning there will be no warning after death like punishment in the grave otherwise everyone would know that the Day of Resurrection was coming and it would not be a surprise to anyone.
7. The Quran, Gospel Injil, Psalm Zabur and Tanakh Jewish scriptures all agree that there is no punishment in the grave.
If punishment is happening now in the grave then Prophet David Dawud would not say there is no memory in death and that no one will thank Allaah in death meaning in the grave.
.
Ecclesiastes 9:5 For the living know that they shall die; but the dead know nothing, neither have they (those who died have) any more a reward (for praising Allaah); because (in death) they have no memory (of anything).
Note 1.In death there is no memory and this is why on the Day of Resurrection when people are asked how much time has passed it will feel like only a day or part of a day had passed between the time of their death and the Day of their Resurrection in Quran 2:259, Quran 18:19, Quran 20:103, Quran 20:104, Quran 23:113, Quran 30:55, Quran 46:35 and Quran 79:46.
Ecclesiastes 12:7 And (in death) the dust returns to the earth as it was and the spirit returns to Allaah who gave it.
Zabur Psalm 6:6 For there is no memory of You (Allaah) in death; in the grave, who will thank You (Allaah)?
Note 1. Humans have no memory in death meaning no memory when they are in the grave.
Note 2. Humans have no memory of Allaah when they are in the grave meaning nothing happens in the grave.
Note 3. Dead humans can only know Allaah when they are resurrected back to life meaning nothing happens during death in the grave.
Note 4. In death there is no memory and this is why on the Day of Resurrection when people are asked how much time has passed it will feel like only a day or part of a day had passed between the time of their death and the Day of their Resurrection in Quran 2:259, Quran 18:19, Quran 20:103, Quran 20:104, Quran 23:113, Quran 30:55, Quran 46:35 and Quran 79:46.
Zabur Psalm 146:4 (When death comes) his breath goes out, he returns to the earth (as dust); in that very day (of his death) his thoughts perish (meaning he has no memory in death).
Note 1. In death there is no memory and this is why on the Day of Resurrection when people are asked how much time has passed it will feel like only a day or part of a day had passed between the time of their death and the Day of their Resurrection in Quran 2:259, Quran 18:19, Quran 20:103, Quran 20:104, Quran 23:113, Quran 30:55, Quran 46:35 and Quran 79:46.
8. If punishment is happening now in the grave then Allaah would not be teaching in Quran 20:103, 20:104, 23:113, 30:55, 46:35 and 79:46 that on the Day of Resurrection every human will wake up and swear that death feels like staying in a 1 hour sleep or a ten hour sleep like the 7 sleepers in Quran 18:19 said and like Prophet Ezra Uzair in Quran 2:259 said when he was resurrected from death.
9. If punishment in the grave is real it would be revealed to the Christians in the Gospel Injil but there is nothing in the four Gospel Injil of Jesus Isa by Mark, Matthew, Luke and John.
10. If punishment in the grave is real it would be revealed to the Jews in the Torah Taurat but there is nothing in the Torah Taurat instead in the Tanakh Jewish scripture Allaah revealed the opposite teaching in Ecclesiastes 9:5, Zabur Psalm 6:6, Zabur Psalm 146:4 and Isaiah 38:18.
Isaiah 38:18 For the dead in the grave cannot praise You (Allaah), death cannot celebrate You (Allaah); they that go down into the grave cannot hope for Your (Allaah’s) truth (because those in the grave have no memory).
Note 1. In death there is no memory and this is why on the Day of Resurrection when people are asked how much time has passed it will feel like only a day or part of a day had passed between the time of their death and the Day of their Resurrection in Quran 2:259, Quran 18:19, Quran 20:103, Quran 20:104, Quran 23:113, Quran 30:55, Quran 46:35 and Quran 79:46.
Isaiah 38:19 The living, the living, he shall praise You (Allaah), as I (Prophet Isaiah) do this day; the father to the children shall make known Your (Allaah’s) truth.
Isaiah 26:19 Your dead shall live, “My dead bodies shall arise, awake and sing, you that dwell in the dust (grave) for Your (Allaah’s) dew (the Torah) is like the dew of light (of guidance), and the earth shall bring to life the shades (those in the graves).
Daniel 12:2 And many of them that sleep in the dust of the earth shall awake, some to everlasting life, and some to reproaches and everlasting abhorrence.
See. Hadith punishment in the grave.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/hadith-punishment-in-the-grave
5. Hadith the reward of 72 virgins in Jannah contradicts the Quran.
Sometimes the word of Allaah in His Books can be confused by the words of humans.
For example in the Gospel Injil Prophet Jesus Isa prayed to Allaah but some humans said Jesus Isa is Allaah and other humans believed Jesus Isa is Allaah meaning they followed the words of humans and not the words in the Gospel Injil.
The same thing can happen in Islam.
There are no contradictions in the Quran means whatever contradicts the Quran did not come from Allaah or from Prophet Muhammad.
Men and women will be resurrected as new creations meaning as virgins.
Prophet Muhammad did not tell people that when a man dies tell his wife that he is with 72 virgins in Jannah.
The hadith “72 virgins” in Paradise Jannah contradicts the description of the family life of men and women and children resurrected in Paradise Jannah described in Quran 30:11, Quran 30:27, Quran 40:8, Quran 37:47-37:49, Quran 44:54-44:56, Quran 52:20-52:21, Quran 55:54-55:60, Quran 55:68-55:74, Quran 56:15-56:18, Quran 56:22-56:24, Quran 56:35-56:38, Quran 76:17-76:19 and Quran 78:31-78:33 meaning this hadith story was invented by story tellers after the death of Prophet Muhammad and repeated by people who were deceived to believe false hadith stories.
Quran 56:35 Koran 56:35 We (Allaah) have produced (resurrected) them (both male and female in the Hereafter in) a (new, second) creation.
Quran 44:54 Koran 44:54 That is how it shall be (in Paradise Jannah). And We (Allaah) shall marry them (the resurrected husbands and wives and those who were not married in Quran 56:35 - Quran 56:38) to (resurrected) companions with beautiful eyes.
Note 1. Bihurin inin means “to companions with beautiful eyes” called Houris meaning fair ones.
Quran 37:48 Koran 37:48 And with them (resurrected men) shall be modest (meaning humble resurrected) companions with beautiful eyes (in Quran 56:35-Quran 56:38).
Quran 78:33 Koran 78:33 And (in Quran 56:35-Quran 56:38 are resurrected males and resurrected females who are) youthful companions, of equal age (whose youth and age shall never change. These are the humans and the jinn who were righteous and have been resurrected as new creations. Since they are new creations both the resurrected males and the resurrected females are virgins. Females resurrected in Paradise Jannah are called ““houris” meaning “beautiful ones” or “fair ones” because everything about them is beautiful meaning “fair” as a reward for what women earned from their good deeds meaning from their good behaviour in their first life on the earth).
Quran 44:55 Koran 44:55 There (in Paradise) they (the resurrected husbands and wives and children and their descendants and friends are new creations in Quran 56:35 - Quran 56:38 and) shall enjoy every kind of fruit in peace and security.
Quran 44:56 Koran 44:56 There (in Paradise Jannah) they (the resurrected husbands and wives and children and descendants and friends) do not taste death, except the first death (in their first life in the world) and He (Allaah) shall have protected them (those who are in Paradise Jannah) from the punishment of Hell Jahannam.
See. Hadith 72 virgins.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/hadith-72-virgins
6. Hadith whoever changes his Islamic religion kill him contradicts the Quran.
Sometimes the word of Allaah in His Books can be confused by the words of humans.
For example in the Gospel Injil Prophet Jesus Isa prayed to Allaah but some humans said Jesus Isa is Allaah and other humans believed Jesus Isa is Allaah meaning they followed the words of humans and not the words in the Gospel Injil.
The same thing can happen in Islam.
There are no contradictions in the Quran means whatever contradicts the Quran did not come from Allaah or from Prophet Muhammad.
Allaah gave freedom of religion 1400 years before the United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights (Quran 2:256).
In the Quran Muslims are not like stone idol worshippers who killed people for leaving the worship of stone idols instead Islam gives every human freedom of religion because until the time of death every humans is free to find their true belief.
The hadith “whoever changes his Islamic religion kill him” contradicts Quran 2:256, Quran 3:159, Quran 4:137, Quran 5:54, Quran 10:99 – 10:100, Quran 18:29, Quran 28:54, Quran 50:45, Quran 88:21 - 88:26 and Quran 109:2 –109:6 meaning this hadith story was invented by story tellers after the death of Prophet Muhammad and repeated by people who were deceived to believe false hadith stories.
Quran 2:256 Koran 2:256 There is no compulsion in religion (meaning, religion must come voluntarily from the human heart and not from the fear of humans or by force) …”
Quran 18:29 Koran 18:29 And say, “The truth (of the Quran) is from your Lord (Allaah)" sowhoever wishes let them believe and whoever wishes let them disbelieve. We (Allaah) have prepared for the wrongdoers a Fire whose walls shall surround them (in the Hereafter). …”
Note 1. Prophet Muhammad did not punish people for peacefully leaving religion instead Prophet Muhammad said what Allaah revealed in Quran 2:256 that there is no compulsion in religion and in Quran 18:29 whoever wishes let them believe and whoever wishes let them disbelieve and that punishment for disbelief comes from Allaah in the hereafter not from humans in this world.
Quran 4:137 Koran 4:137 Those who believed (in Allaah and) then disbelieved (in Allaah meaning for the first time they left Islam or they left Christianity or they left Judaism meaning for the first time they lost their belief in Allaah and), then again believed (in Allaah for a second time meaning they returned to Islam or Christianity or Judaism meaning for a second time they found their belief in Allaah and) then again disbelieved (in Allaah for a second time meaning they left Islam or Christianity or Judaism meaning for a second time they lost their belief in Allaah and) then increased in disbelief (in Allaah meaning they did not return to Islam or Christianity or Judaism meaning their belief in Allaah did not return to them before the time of their natural death), Allaah shall not forgive them (on the Day of Judgement) and will not guide them to the (right) way (of behaviour in this world).
Note 1. Prophet Muhammad did not punish people for peacefully leaving religion instead Prophet Muhammad said what Allaah revealed in Quran 4:137 that humans have a life time to find their true belief because it is not until the time of natural death that the true belief of each human is shown.
Quran 5:54 Koran 5:54 O you who believe (in Allaah), whoever among you turns back (leaves) from his religion (allow them to leave), soon Allaah shall bring a people (to replace those who leave) whom He (Allaah) loves and who love Him (Allaah) and (they shall be) humble toward those with faith (in Allaah) and stern (by standing up for their rights) toward those without faith (in Allaah), striving in the way of Allaah and without fear of anyone who may criticize them (for their faith in Allaah). This is the grace that Allaah gives to whomever He (Allaah) wills. Allaah encompasses all (the things in our life) and (Allaah) knows all things.
Note 1. Prophet Muhammad did not punish people for peacefully leaving religion instead Prophet Muhammad said what Allaah revealed in Quran 5:54 that “whoever leaves religion will be replaced by people whom Allaah loves and who love Allaah.”
Quran 10:99 Koran 10:99 And if your Lord (Allaah) had willed then all who are on the earth would have all believed together. (Allaah asks Prophet Muhammad), “Would you force people (against their will) to believe (in Allaah when it is Allaah who decrees who will believe and who will disbelieve)? (The answer is no, Islam does not force belief in Allaah because -).”
Quran 10:100 Koran 10:100 It is not for any soul to believe except by the permission of Allaah and He (Allaah) will place the anger (of Allaah in the hereafter) on those who do not use reason (to follow good behaviour).
Note 1. Prophet Muhammad did not punish people for peacefully leaving religion instead Prophet Muhammad said what Allaah revealed in Quran 10:99 – 10:100 that no one can believe unless it is the will of Allaah and it is not for humans to force a person to believe if they disbelieve.
Quran 109:2 Koran 109:2 “I do not worship what you (the stone idol worshippers in Makkah) worship (that are stone idols).”
Quran 109:3 Koran 109:3 “Nor do you (the stone idol worshippers in Makkah) worship what I worship (that is Allaah).”
Quran 109:4 Koran 109:4 “And I shall not worship what you worship (that are stone idols).”
Quran 109:5 Koran 109:5 “Nor shall you worship what I worship (that is Allaah).”
Quran 109:6 Koran 109:6 “For you is your way (of religion, of belief) and for me is my way (of religion, of belief).”
Note 1. Prophet Muhammad did not punish people for peacefully leaving religion instead Prophet Muhammad said what Allaah revealed in Quran 109:2 – Quran 109:6 that no one can believe unless it is the will of Allaah and that people with different beliefs must be respected as you would like them to respect your belief in Allaah.
See 1. Apostasy.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/apostasy-in-islam
See 2. Hadith do not punish people for leaving Islam.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/hadith-do-not-punish-people-for-leaving-islam
See 3. Hadith whoever changed his Islamic religion then kill him.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/whoever-changed-his-islamic-religion-then-kill-him
7. Hadith women hung from their breasts contradicts the Quran.
Sometimes the word of Allaah in His Books can be confused by the words of humans.
For example in the Gospel Injil Prophet Jesus Isa prayed to Allaah but some humans said Jesus Isa is Allaah and other humans believed Jesus Isa is Allaah meaning they followed the words of humans and not the words in the Gospel Injil.
The same thing can happen in Islam.
There are no contradictions in the Quran means whatever contradicts the Quran did not come from Allaah or from Prophet Muhammad.
The hadith story that claims Prophet Muhammad saw in Hell women hung from their breasts is fabricated.
The hadith story one of her breasts to be cooked and the other to be roasted is fabricated.
Quran 77:50 Koran 77:50 In what statement (words, news, reports, information, message, hadith), after it (the verses of Allaah in the Quran), shall they (the humans and the jinn) believe?
Note 1. Quran 7:185, Quran 25:29, Quran 25:30, Quran 31:6, Quran 39:23, Quran 45:6 and Quran 77:50 asks when you have the word of Allaah in the Quran what other report would you believe?
Allaah has described the punishment in Hell Jahannam in the Quran.
The warning in Quran 77:50 shows that the following hadith seek to add something to the Quran that is not there.
`Aly ibn Abu Talib reported:
`Aly ibn Abu Talib reported:
"Fatimah and I went to the Messenger of Allaah (peace be upon him) and found him crying profusely.
I said, 'O Messenger of Allaah! May my father and mother be sacrificed for you!
What has made you cry?'
He (peace be upon him) said, 'O ‘Aly! On the Isra' (Night Journey) when I was taken to the Heavens, I saw women from my Ummah (nation based on one creed) in great torment and I hated their condition due to what I saw of the severity of their punishment.
I saw a woman hung by her hair and her brain was boiling.
I saw a woman hung by her tongue and scalding water was being poured down her throat.
I saw a woman hung by her breasts.
I saw a woman eating her own flesh and the Fire was burning under her.
I saw a woman who was bound hand and foot who was being assailed by serpents and scorpions.
I saw a blind and deaf woman in a coffin of fire, whose brain was coming out of her thighs, and her body was being torn by gangrene and leprosy.
I saw a woman hung by her feet in the Fire, and another cutting off her flesh from her front and her back with scissors of fire.
I saw a woman whose face and hands were burning, and who was eating her own entrails.
I saw a woman with a pig's head and a donkey's body being tormented in a thousand of ways.
I saw a woman in the form of a dog, with fire entering from her buttocks and coming out of her mouth, and the angels were beating her head and her body with maces of fire.'
Fatimah exclaimed, 'My beloved and delight of my eye!
Tell me what they had done for Allaah to inflict them with such torments.'
The Prophet (peace be upon him) replied, 'My daughter! The woman hung by hair did not cover it from men.
The one hung by her tongue used to hurt her husband with it.
The one hung by her breasts used to refuse her husband in bed.
The one hung by her feet used to go out of her home without her husband’s consent.
The one eating her own flesh used to dress herself up for people (who had no right to see her. Trans). The woman bound hand and foot who was assailed by serpents and scorpions did not perform ablution often, wore dirty clothes, did not perform Ghusl (ritual bath) following Janabah (major ritual impurity related to sexual discharge) and menstruation, and was not clean. She made light of Salah (Prayer).
The one who was blind, deaf and dumb, conceived children through Zina (sexual intercourse outside marriage) and made her husband support them.
The one whose flesh was being cut off with the fiery scissors was a pander.
The one with a pig's head and donkey's body was a slanderer and liar.
The one in the form of a dog with fire going in her buttocks and coming out of her mouth was because she was a singer and public mourner.'
Then, the Messenger of Allaah (peace be upon him) said, 'Woe to the woman that angers her husband and blessed is she who pleases him.' The Messenger of Allaah (peace be upon him) spoke the truth."
Ishaq:185 "In hell I saw women hanging by their breasts. They had fathered bastards."
Hadith punishment of women.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/hadith-women-hung-from-their-breasts
8. Hadith stoning to death for adultery contradicts the Quran.
Sometimes the word of Allaah in His Books can be confused by the words of humans.
For example in the Gospel Injil Prophet Jesus Isa prayed to Allaah but some humans said Jesus Isa is Allaah and other humans believed Jesus Isa is Allaah meaning they followed the words of humans and not the words in the Gospel Injil.
The same thing can happen in Islam.
There are no contradictions in the Quran means whatever contradicts the Quran did not come from Allaah or from Prophet Muhammad.
The hadith that “stoning to death for adultery” applies to Muslims even though it is not mentioned in the Quran contradicts the warnings of Allaah to follow the Quran above all other information in Quran 7:185, Quran 25:29, Quran 25:30, Quran 31:6, Quran 39:23, Quran 45:6 and Quran 77:50.
In the Quran the law for illegal sexual intercourse for unmarried Muslims is Quran 4:15 – 4:18.
In the Quran the law for adultery by married Muslims is Quran 4:25 and Quran 24:1 – 24:2.
Forgiveness for all sins including adultery is in Quran 3:135 – 3:136, Quran 4:17 – 4:18, Quran 4:110 and Quran 25:68 – 25:71 meaning this hadith story was invented by story tellers after the death of Prophet Muhammad and repeated by people who were deceived to believe false hadith stories.
1. The first time Allaah removed stoning to death for adultery in the Quran was when the wife of the prophet was falsely accused of adultery.
Allaah explains why stoning to death for adultery was removed from Islam.
Allaah showed Prophet Muhammad the false accusation of adultery against his wife Aisha who was saved only because she lived in the time of the prophet.
Who would save people from false accusations after the time of Prophet Muhammad?
Prophet Muhammad said about stoning to death “I cannot write it down anymore” (From Abu Ya‘la al-Mawsili who died 307 AH recorded in his Musnad and al-Nasa`I who died 303 AH recorded in his Sunan record).
Prophet Muhammad said I cannot write it (the verse on stoning to death for adultery) anymore meaning Allaah decreed the removal of stoning to death in Islam.
2. The second time Allaah removed stoning to death for adultery in the Quran was on the day of the death of Prophet Muhammad when Allaah caused a goat to eat away the paper on which was written stoning to death for adultery.
Aisha (Aishah the wife of Prophet Muhammad) said “When the verses “Rajm” (Stoning) and ayah “Rezah Kabir” descended, they were written on a piece of paper and kept under my pillow.
Following the demise (death) of Prophet Muhammad a goat ate the piece of paper while we were mourning.”
(From Sunan Ibn Majah, Book of Nikah, hadith 1934 and Sunan ibn Majah, Volume 2, Page 39 and Sunan Ibn Majah (Arabic), Book of Suckling 2020).
Only Allaah has the power to command an animal to devour and take away the “Word of Allaah.”
Aisha Aishah clearly understood what had happened when Prophet Muhammad had just died and a goat immediately came and ate away the paper with the verse of stoning to death for adultery and she did not write it again.
A goat ate away the word of Allaah meaning Allaah decreed the removal of stoning to death in Islam.
Once the word of Allaah had been written by Prophet Muhammad no one could remove it.
Even Prophet Muhammad could not remove it even though he had said that he cannot write it anymore.
Only Allaah himself had the power to remove His word by commanding a goat to eat it away on the day of the death of Prophet Muhammad.
Allaah himself removed stoning to death for adultery from Islam.
3. The third time Allaah removed stoning to death for adultery in the Quran was when the Quran was compiled after the death of the prophet when two people could not be found to testify that stoning to death for adultery was in the Quran.
Ibn Abi Shaybah reported, concerning al-masahif, from al-Layth bin Sa‘d who said, “The first to collect the Quran was Abu Bakr and Zayd bin Thabit wrote it.
And people came to Zayd bin Thabit (with parts of the Quran) (but) Zayd did not write anything (in the Quran) without the testimony of two reliable witnesses.
The last part of Surah Bara`ah (Repentance) was not found except with Khuzaymah bin Thabit.
He (Zayd) said, “Write it, for the Messenger of Allaah had declared the testimony of Khuzaymah equivalent to that of two men.”
So he wrote it.
And ‘Umar came with the verse of stoning (rajm) but Zayd would not write it because ‘Umar was alone (in his testimony) (From Al-Suyuti as quoted in ‘Awn al-Ma‘bud 3130 and "The Itqan" by Suyuti Part 1, Page 168).
Umar was alone in his testimony meaning Allaah decreed the removal of stoning to death for adultery in Islam.
The first thing to note is the wisdom of Zayd bin Thabit and his team regarding compiling the Quran as shown when he said “Write it, for the Messenger of Allaah had declared the testimony of Khuzaymah equivalent to that of two men” and that when Umar came with the verse of stoning (rajm) Zayd would not write it because Umar was alone in his testimony.
Zayd bin Thabit and his team compiled the completed the perfected Quran and Zayd bin Thabit and his team rejected stoning to death for adultery because Allaah did not allow a second person to confirm that command.
This means the Quran we have today that was compiled by Zayd bin Thabit and his team made Quran chapter 24 as the punishment for adultery for free married Muslims because Zayd bin Thabit and his team could not find a second person to confirm that stoning to death for adultery is commanded by Allaah because Allaah removed stoning to death for adultery when Allaah commanded Prophet Muhammad not to write it anymore and confirmed its removal from Islam by commanding on the day of the death of Prophet Muhammad a goat to eat away the words of Allaah containing the stoning verse.
4. The Umar hadith about stoning to death for adultery.
Muhammad bin Ja‘far and Hajjaj said that, Shu‘bah said that, Sa‘d bin Ibrahim said that, ‘Ubayd allah bin ‘Utbah said that, Ibn ‘Abbas said that, ‘Abd al-Rahman bin ‘‘Awf said, Umar (Umar bin Khattab) performed hajj and intended to address the people.
Abd al-Rahman bin ‘Awf said (to ‘Umar), all kinds of riff raff (ra‘a‘) have gathered around you (in the season of hajj), so delay it till you go to Madinah.
When he arrived in Madinah, I sat close to him near the minbar and I heard him (Umar bin Khattab) say,There are people who say, “What is this al-rajm (the stoning) when in the Book of Allaah there is only flogging?”
The Messenger of Allaah stoned and we stoned after him.
Were it not that they (the people) shall say I (Umar bin Khattab) have inscribed in the Book of Allaah (the Quran) what is not there, I (Umar bin Khattab) would have inscribed it as it was sent down (by Allaah).”(Ahmad 333).
If you were Umar would you say “Were it not that they (the people) shall say I (Umar bin Khattab) have inscribed in the Book of Allaah (the Quran) what is not there, I (Umar bin Khattab) would have inscribed it as it was sent down (by Allaah).”
In this hadith Umar is more afraid of the people than the command of Allaah which Umar said should be written by him in the Quran.
Surely Umar would have said “I am not afraid of the people but I am afraid of Allaah so I am going to write this command in the Quran so that I can face Allaah on the Day of Judgement.”
If Umar wrote in the Quran then today we would say it was the will of Allaah because Allaah protects the Quran.
However Umar did not write in the Quran because it was the will of Allaah to remove stoning to death for adultery from Islam confirmed by Prophet Muhammad who said “I cannot write it down anymore” and confirmed on the day of the death of Prophet Muhammad when Allaah commanded a goat to eat away the verse on stoning to death for adultery.
The Umar hadith on stoning to death for adultery is a false hadith story because Umar would not fear people more that he feared Allaah.
5. The guidance of Allaah.
Quran 77:50 Koran 77:50 In what statement (words, news, reports, information, message, hadith), after it (the verses of Allaah in the Quran), shall they (the humans and the jinn) believe?
Note 1. Quran 7:185, Quran 25:29, Quran 25:30, Quran 31:6, Quran 39:23, Quran 45:6 and Quran 77:50 asks when you have the word of Allaah in the Quran what other report would you believe?
Quran 17:88 Koran 17:88 Say (Prophet Muhammad), "If humans and jinn (such as Satan Shaitan) came together to help each other to produce something like the Quran, they could not do it."
Note 1. In the hereafter Satan Shaitan might boast he obeyed Quran 17:88 by whispering hundreds of false hadith stories which teach the opposite to what Allaah and Prophet Muhammad teach in the Quran.
Quran 25:30 Koran 25:30 And (on the Day of Resurrection and Judgement) the messenger (Prophet Muhammad) said, “My Lord (Allaah) my people have abandoned (deserted) this Quran (to follow false messages, false words, false news, false reports, false information, false statements, false hadith).”
Note 1. On the Day of Resurrection and Judgement Prophet Muhammad will say “My Lord my people have abandoned this Quran (to follow false messages, false words, false news, false reports, false information, false statements, false hadith).”
If hadith stories and the actions of humans agree with the Quran then accept it and learn from it.
If hadith stories and the actions of humans do not agree with the Quran then reject it and also learn from it.
On the Day of Judgement Allaah judges by the words in the protected Quran.
On the Day of Judgement Allaah does not judge by the words in unprotected human hadith stories.
The Quran is the protected word of Allaah including the words and actions of Prophet Muhammad which are described and protected by Allaah.
See. Stoning to death is not in the Quran but comes from hadith stories.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/quran-chapter-24-surah-24
9. The claim that Prophet Muhammad cannot read and write contradicts the Quran.
Sometimes the word of Allaah in His Books can be confused by the words of humans.
For example in the Gospel Injil Prophet Jesus Isa prayed to Allaah but some humans said Jesus Isa is Allaah and other humans believed Jesus Isa is Allaah meaning they followed the words of humans and not the words in the Gospel Injil.
The same thing can happen in Islam.
There are no contradictions in the Quran means whatever contradicts the Quran did not come from Allaah or from Prophet Muhammad.
In Quran 10:16 the people of Makkah knew Prophet Muhammad all his life and in Quran 25:5 they said someone is dictating the Quran and Prophet Muhammad is writing it down meaning Allaah is telling us that everyone in Makkah knew Prophet Muhammad could read and write.
Allaah never said Prophet Muhammad cannot read and write but tells us he can and everyone in Makkah knew it.
In Quran 29:48 Prophet Muhammad did not recite any book or write any book before the Quran was revealed to him otherwise people might have had a reason to doubt him.
People in Makkah did not recite books or write books but they wrote messages and put it on the wall of the Kabah and they used the letters of the alphabet to represent numbers and make mathematical calculations during commercial trading because they did not have numbers like we have today.
Quran 10:16 Koran 10:16 “... I (Prophet Muhammad) lived among you (the stone idol worshippers of Makkah) all my life before it (the Quran was revealed to me) …”
Quran 25:5 Koran 25:5 And they (the stone idol worshippers in Makkah) say, “(The Quran is the) stories of the people of the past which he (Prophet Muhammad) has written down and they (another person) are dictating (meaning speaking the words) to him (Prophet Muhammad) in the morning and evening (in secret so that Prophet Muhammad can write down the words of the Quran and learn those words so that in the day Prophet Muhammad can recite the Quran in public to the people of Mecca Makkah).
Quran 29:48 Koran 29:48 (In Quran 25:5 the stone idol worshippers in Makkah Arabia said Prophet Muhammad is writing the words of the Quran that another person is dictating to Prophet Muhammad to write down. Allaah replies in Quran 25:4 declaring as unjust and false the accusation that the Quran is invented and that other people are helping Prophet Muhammad with it by explaining in Quran 16:103 that the speech of the person a Christian blacksmith named Barbarous whom they suggest is helping Prophet Muhammad by dictating the words of the Quran speaks a foreign language whereas the Quran is in clear Arabic speech. To the statement in Quran 25:5 that Prophet Muhammad can read and write said by the people in Makkah who in Quran 10:16 had lived with Prophet Muhammad all their life Allaah replies not by saying that Prophet Muhammad cannot read and write but by saying) And you (Prophet Muhammad) did not recite any book (to the people) before this (Quran was revealed to you) nor did you write it (any book) with your hand (before this Quran was revealed to you) otherwise the doubters might have had reason to doubt (your truthfulness about the Quran because they would have suspected you were reciting and writing the Quran for them like you had recited and written books for them before you became a prophet if you had been a reciter of books and a writer of books before you became a prophet. The people of Makkah 1400 years ago were known as the Ummi Unlettered people meaning the people who were uneducated in the Scriptures and they wrote contracts, agreements, announcements and poetry on pieces of paper, leaf and bone which they put on the wall of the Kabah however they did not write books. Buyers, sellers and traders in Makkah used the Arabic alphabet to represent numbers to make calculations because numbers as we know them today did not exist 1400 years ago in the Arabic language. Quran 29:48 is not saying Prophet Muhammad could not read and write but only that he did not recite or write books before he was a prophet like other unlettered Ummi people in Makkah who could read and write but also did not write books. The most well known people writing books near Makkah were the Lettered people meaning the people who were educated in the Scriptures and the books they wrote were the Scriptures. In Quran 2:78 an unlettered Ummi is a Jew who is uneducated in the Book of Allaah the Torah Taurat. In Quran 3:20 and Quran 3:75 the lettered people are the people of the Book who are educated in the book of Allaah and everyone who is not educated in the book of Allaah is called the unlettered Ummi. In Quran 7:157 and Quran 7:158 Prophet Muhammad is the unlettered Ummi meaning he was uneducated in the Book of Allaah before it was revealed to him. In Quran 62:2 the unlettered Ummi are the people who are uneducated in the Book of Allaah and from among themselves has come a messenger Prophet Muhammad who is also called the unlettered Ummi meaning he was uneducated in the Book of Allaah before it was revealed to him. In Quran 42:52 Allaah confirms that Prophet Muhammad did not know the book of Allaah meaning he was uneducated in the book of Allaah before it was revealed to him in the same way as the people of Makkah were uneducated in the book of Allaah meaning the prophet and his people were unlettered Ummi meaning uneducated in the Book of Allaah. Quran 29:48 does not say Prophet Muhammad cannot read and write on pieces of paper, leaf and bone but only says that before Muhammad was a prophet he did not recite or write books meaning why would you doubt the Quran is from Allaah when the Quran is a book recited and written by a man who had never before recited and written a book? If he had recited and written a book before the Quran was revealed to him then you might have had a reason to doubt Prophet Muhammad meaning why do you doubt the honesty of Prophet Muhammad when he has given you no reason that you should doubt him?).
See 1. Quran 25:5 shows that the people of Makkah knew that Prophet Muhammad can read and write meaning the idea that Prophet Muhammad cannot read and write is not from Allaah and not from Prophet Muhammad and not from the Quran but came from people who did not understand the meaning of lettered meaning educated in the scripture of Allaah and unlettered meaning not educated in the scripture of Allaah.
See Quran 25:5 comment in Quran chapter 25.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/quran-chapter-25-surah-25
See 2. What does Ummi mean?
What does lettered and unlettered mean?
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/what-does-ummi-mean
See 3. Hadith Prophet Muhammad can read and write.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/hadith-prophet-muhammad-can-read-and-write
See 4. Can Prophet Muhammad read and write?
Can Prophet Muhammad read?
Can Prophet Muhammad write?
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/can-prophet-muhammad-read-and-write
9A. Hadith Prophet Muhammad aorta cut contradicts the Quran.
Sometimes the word of Allaah in His Books can be confused by the words of humans.
For example in the Gospel Injil Prophet Jesus Isa prayed to Allaah but some humans said Jesus Isa is Allaah and other humans believed Jesus Isa is Allaah meaning they followed the words of humans and not the words in the Gospel Injil.
The same thing can happen in Islam.
There are no contradictions in the Quran means whatever contradicts the Quran did not come from Allaah or from Prophet Muhammad.
The hadith story claiming Prophet Muhammad said “it feels like my aorta is being cut from that poison” was invented after the death of the prophet.
1. In the Quran the sign of a false prophet is cutting of his aorta.
Quran 69:43 Koran 69:43 (The Quran is) a revelation from (Allaah) the Lord of the Worlds (of humans and jinn).
.
Quran 69:44 Koran 69:44 And if he (Prophet Muhammad) were to invent any sayings in Our (Allaah’s) name,
Quran 69:45 Koran 69:45 We (Allaah) would have seized him (Prophet Muhammad) by the right hand -
Quran 69:46 Koran 69:46 And We (Allaah) would have cut off his (Prophet Muhammad’s) Aorta (the artery of his heart to give him an immediate, sudden and unexpected death).
Quran 69:47 Koran 69:47 And not one of you could have prevented Us (Allaah) from (punishing) him (Prophet Muhammad).
A. The aorta carries oxygenated blood from the heart to the heart and throughout the body so if it is cut by Allaah your heart will stop and you will be dead immediately.
B. If the aorta is cut by Allaah you will not be able to speak because you will be dead immediately.
C. Poisoning is not Allaah cutting the aorta because there was no immediate and unexpected death.
D. To say the aorta feels cut means the Aorta is not cut by Allaah because you have not died an immediate and unexpected death.
E. When Allaah cuts the aorta “with His right hand” no one feels anything because they will die immediately.
F. The sign of a false prophet is immediate unexpected death which happens when the aorta is cut by “Allaah’s right hand.”
G. Prophet Muhammad lived for four years after the poisoning incident and made long journeys in the heat of the desert meaning he did not die an immediate death which happens when the aorta is cut by Allaah.
H. Prophet Muhammad did not die from an immediate and unexpected death meaning his aorta was not cut by Allaah meaning all hadith stories which contradict the above were invented after the death of the prophet in the same way as stories that Jesus is Allaah in a Trinity were invented after the death of Jesus.
2. Any prophet who claims their aorta is cut is saying they are a false prophet.
If this had been said during the life time of Prophet Muhammad then every Muslim would have understood its meaning from what the Quran says regarding a cut aorta.
If Prophet Muhammad said “it feels like my aorta is being cut” it would be the same as saying "I am not a prophet of Allaah."
The person who invented this story added "it feels like my aorta is being cut from that poison” to complete their story and put this story at the end of a well known true hadith story in the following way.
3. The false hadith story about the aorta has been added to the end of a true hadith story narrated by Ibn Abbas.
Narrated Ibn Abbas:
'Umar bin Al-Khattab used to let Ibn Abbas sit beside him, so 'Abdur Rahman bin 'Auf said to 'Umar, "We have sons similar to him." 'Umar replied, "(I respect him) because of his status that you know." 'Umar then asked Ibn 'Abbas about the meaning of this Holy Verse:-- "When comes the help of Allaah and the conquest of Mecca . . ." (110.1) Ibn 'Abbas replied, "That indicated the death of Allaah's Apostle which Allaah informed him of." 'Umar said, "I do not understand of it except what you understand."
Narrated Aisha: The Prophet in his ailment in which he died, used to say, "O Aisha! I still feel the pain caused by the food I ate at Khaibar, and at this time, I feel as if my aorta is being cut from that poison."
(Sahih al-Bukhari Vol. 5, Book 59, Hadith 713, Sahih al-Bukhari Vol. 5, Book of Expeditions, Hadith 713, al-Bukhari Book of Expeditions 713, al-Bukhari 4430).
Note 1. The hadith narrated by Aisha is added at the end of a hadith narrated by Ibn Abbas however these are two different hadith stories by two different people meaning someone has joined these two stories together to make the second story seem authentic only because the first story is known to be authentic.
4. In the false aorta hadith story Prophet Muhammad lived for four years after the poisoning incident meaning the aorta was not cut by the right hand of Allaah which gives immediate death.
"Narrated Aisha: The Prophet in his ailment in which he died, used to say, "O Aisha! I still feel the pain caused by the food I ate at Khaibar, and at this time, I feel as if my aorta is being cut from that poison."
(Vol. 5, Book 59, Hadith 713, Sahih al-Bukhari 4428, Book 64, Hadith 450).
Note 1. The battle of Khaiber was in June 7 AH 628 CE.
Note 2. The death of Prophet Muhammad was in June 11 AH 632 CE.
Note 3. Four years passed between the poisoning at Khaibar and the death of the prophet.
5. The true hadith story “narrated by Ibn Abbas” (after which the false hadith story “narrated Aisha” about the aorta is placed) came from the following hadith story.
Narrated Ibn Abbas:
`Umar used to make me sit with the elderly men who had fought in the Battle of Badr.
Some of them felt it (did not like that) and said to `Umar "Why do you bring in this boy to sit with us while we have sons like him?"
`Umar replied, "Because of what you know of his position (i.e. his religious knowledge.)"
One day `Umar called me and made me sit in the gathering of those people; and I think that he called me just to show them. (my religious knowledge).
`Umar then asked them (in my presence). "What do you say about the interpretation of the Statement of Allaah: 'When comes Help of Allaah (to you O, Muhammad against your enemies) and the conquest (of Mecca).' (110.1)
Some of them said, "We are ordered to praise Allaah and ask for His forgiveness when Allaah's Help and the conquest (of Mecca) comes to us."
Some others kept quiet and did not say anything.
On that, `Umar asked me, "Do you say the same, O Ibn Abbas?"
I replied, "No."
He said, 'What do you say then?"
I replied, "That is the sign of the death of Allaah's Messenger which Allaah informed him of.
Allaah said: '(O Muhammad) When comes the Help of Allaah (to you against your enemies) and the conquest (of Mecca) (which is the sign of your death). You should celebrate the praises of your Lord and ask for His Forgiveness, and He is the One Who accepts the repentance and forgives.' (110.3)
On that `Umar said, "I do not know anything about it other than what you have said."
(Sahih al-Bukhari Vol. 6, Book 60) (Book 65, Hadith 4970).
Note 1. Notice that the story about the aorta has not been added to this story even when this story narrated by Ibn Abbas is in greater detail compared to the story about the aorta which is added to a shorter version of the same story from Ibn Abbas.
This shows how some story tellers deceived people to believe their stories by coping lines of transmission and connecting their false story to well known stories.
Question 1. Did Prophet Muhammad say it feels like my aorta is being cut from that poison?
Answer 1. No.
Question 2. How can you know that the hadith story claiming Prophet Muhammad said “it feels like my aorta is being cut from that poison” was invented after the death of the prophet?
Answer 2. Allaah tests who understands the difference between the word of Allaah and the word of humans which contradict Allaah in the Quran.
Those who believe the word of humans which contradict the word of Allaah have put their trust in the word of humans above the word of Allaah.
If hadith stories and the actions of humans agree with the Quran then accept it and learn from it.
If hadith stories and the actions of humans do not agree with the Quran then reject it and also learn from it.
On the Day of Judgement Allaah judges by the words in the protected Quran.
On the Day of Judgement Allaah does not judge by the words in unprotected human hadith stories.
The Quran is the protected word of Allaah including the words and actions of Prophet Muhammad which are described and protected by Allaah.
Prophet Muhammad aorta cut..
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/prophet-muhammad-aorta-cut
9B. Hadith Prophet Muhammad created from light contradicts the Quran.
Sometimes the word of Allaah in His Books can be confused by the words of humans.
For example in the Gospel Injil Prophet Jesus Isa prayed to Allaah but some humans said Jesus Isa is Allaah and other humans believed Jesus Isa is Allaah meaning they followed the words of humans and not the words in the Gospel Injil.
The same thing can happen in Islam.
There are no contradictions in the Quran means whatever contradicts the Quran did not come from Allaah or from Prophet Muhammad.
Hadith stories claiming Prophet Muhammad was created from light.
A. False hadith story 1.
It is related that Jabir ibn Abd Allaah said to the Prophet, “O Messenger of Allaah, may my father and mother be sacrificed for you, tell me of the first thing Allaah created before all things.” He said: O Jabir, the first thing Allaah created was the light of your Prophet from His light, and that light remained in the midst of His Power for as long as He wished, and there was not, at that time, a Tablet or a Pen or a Paradise or a Fire or an angel or a heaven or an earth. And when Allaah wished to create creation, he divided that Light into four parts and from the first made the Pen, from the second the Tablet, from the third the Throne, then He divided the fourth into four parts (and from them created everything else).
(Abd al-Razzaq died 211 AH narrates it in his Musannaf. Bayhaqī died 458 AH narrates it with a different wording in Dala'il al-nubuwwa according to Zurqani in his Sharh al-mawahib 1:56 of the Matba‘a al-‘amira in Cairo. Diyarbakri in Tarikh al-khamis 1:20).
Note 1. Notice how the hadith starts “may my father and mother be sacrificed for you” as a way to make this hadith story sound authentic.
B. False hadith story 2.
On the authority of Ibn Abbas, the Muhammadan Light goes from prophet to prophet (min nabīyyin ila nabīyyin) until the moment when Allaah (swt) causes it to emerge (akhraja) as the historical Prophet Muhammad.
(Ibn Sa‘d Tabaqāt in Leiden: 1909, vol. 1, page 96; Cf. Tabari, Tafsīr, in Cairo: 1323 AH, vol. xxi, page 79.).
Note 1. Notice that a well known person like Ibn Abbas is said to narrate this hadith story to make it sound authentic..
C. False hadith story 3.
Know that since Allaah first created the soul of Muhammad from the light of His beauty, as He said: I created Muhammad from the light of My Face, and as the Prophet said: The first thing Allaah created is my soul, and the first thing Allaah created is the Pen, and the first thing Allaah created is the Intellect - what is meant by all this is one and the same thing, and that is the haqīqa muhammadīyya. However, it was named a light because it is completely purified from darkness, as Allaah said, “There has come to you from Allaah a Light and a manifest Book.”
(Shaykh Abd al-Qadir Jilani died 561 AH in his book Sirr al-asrar fi ma yahtaju ilayh al-abrar).
Note 1. Notice how the hadith ends by mentioning the Quran as a way to make this hadith story sound authentic.
Summary.
1. Everything known about the soul is in the Quran meaning hadith stories that include any additional information about the soul were invented after the death of the prophet.
2. In the Quran Allaah teaches that Prophet Muhammad is not different from the other messengers of Allaah.
3. In the Quran Allaah teaches that Prophet Muhammad is like all the other messengers of Allaah.
Prophet Muhammad created from light.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/prophet-muhammad-created-from-light
9C. Hadith Prophet Muhammad night journey to Jerusalem riding Buraq contradicts the Quran.
1. In Quran 6:60 and Quran 39:42 the human soul is taken on a journey to Allaah at death and during sleep at night by an angel with wings not by a horse with wings.
The hadith story about the flying winged horse named Buraq contradicts the Quran meaning it was invented by story tellers after the death of the prophet or repeated by people who were deceived to believe false stories..
Allaah and Prophet Muhammad do not contradict the Quran.
False hadith stories contradict the Quran.
2. In the Quran the human body is not raised to Allaah (Quran 6:60 and Quran 39:42).
3. In the Quran only the soul is raised to Allaah (Quran 6:60 and Quran 39:42).
4. In Quran 6:60 and Quran 39:42 the soul of Prophet Muhammad was taken on a night journey during a vision dream and his body remained in Makkah in the same way as on the cross Jesus Isa was saved with sleep in Quran 6:60 and Quran 39:42 and the soul of Jesus Isa was taken for 3 days to Allaah in Quran 4:158 but the body of Jesus Isa remained on the earth and woke up after 3 days to continue living until his natural death 2000 years ago in Quran 5:75 where Mary Maryam and Jesus Isa “use to eat food” meaning they both died 2000 years ago and Quran 3:144 where the “the messengers before Prophet Muhammad have died” meaning Jesus Isa is dead because Jesus Isa is the messenger before Prophet Muhammad.
5. In a vision in Quran 17:60 meaning in a dream Allaah took the soul (not the physical body) of Prophet Muhammad on a night journey during his sleep in Quran 6:60 and Quran 39:42.
6. Allaah takes the soul on a journey when a person dies or when they sleep and returns the soul to wake up the sleeping body in Quran 6:60 and Quran 39:42 “Allaah is the one who takes your souls at night”.
7. When Prophet Muhammad was sleeping in Makkah his soul was taken on a one night journey to show Prophet Muhammad a vision meaning a dream where his eyes during sleep saw the signs of Allaah in Makkah (the Kabah which is the nearest mosque) and Jerusalem (the ruins of the first and second temples which is the furthest mosque) and Heaven in Quran 17:1, Quran 17:60 and Quran 53:17.
8. The Quran is describing the journey of the soul of Prophet Muhammad meaning the physical body of Prophet Muhammad was sleeping in Makkah in Quran 6:60 and Quran 39:42 when Allaah took the soul of Prophet Muhammad on a journey to show the prophet in a vision meaning in his dreams the signs of Allaah in Makkah and in Jerusalem and in Heaven in Quran 17:1, Quran 17:60 and Quran 53:17.
9. The physical body of Prophet Muhammad was sleeping in Makkah when Prophet Muhammad with his eyes during sleep saw the vision meaning the dream when his soul was taken on the night journey in Quran 17:1 and Quran 17:60 meaning this is not a physical journey seen when the physical body is awake instead this is the journey of the soul seen during sleep with the eye in Quran 53:17 during a vision meaning during dream in Quran 17:60 when a person is sleeping in Quran 6:60 and Quran 39:42.
Quran 6:60 Koran 6:60 He (Allaah) is the one who takes your souls at night (when you sleep) and He (Allaah) knows everything you did in the day. Then He (Allaah returns your soul and) wakes you again so that your life span may be fulfilled. Afterward (when you die) to Him (Allaah) you (your soul) shall return (in the Hereafter). Then He (Allaah) shall inform you of what you used to do.
Note 1. The night journey of Prophet Muhammad.
Note 2. Allaah does not take the human body to heaven (Quran 6:60 and Quran 39:42).
Note 3. Only the human soul is raised to heaven (Quran 6:60 and Quran 39:42).
Note 4. The human body is only needed on the Earth (Quran 6:60 and Quran 39:42). .
Note 5. The human body is not needed in heaven (Quran 6:60 and Quran 39:42).
Note 6. The human soul is alive in heaven without a human body (Quran 6:60 and Quran 39:42).
Note 7. What the soul of Prophet Muhammad saw in the night journey in Quran 6:60 and Quran 39:42 is described in Quran 17:1 and Quran 53:17 as a vision dream in Quran 17:60.
Note 8. Quran 48:27 describes a different dream of Prophet Muhamamd using the same word vision meaning dream.
Quran 38:45 the vision meaning dream of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim, Prophet Isaac Ishaq and Prophet Jacob Yaqub Israel and Quran 48:27 Prophet Muhammad’s vision meaning dream, Quran 17:60 l-ru'ya meaning “the vision” means the dream of Prophet Muhammad’s night journey and ascension to heaven in the same way as in Quran 37:105 l-ru'ya meaning “the vision” means the dream of Prophet Abraham sacrificing his son and in Quran 48:27 l-ru'ya means “the vision” meaning the dream of Prophet Muhammad worshipping at the Kabah and in Quran 12:5 ru'yaka meaning “your vision” means your dream had by Prophet Joseph Yusuf and in Quran 12:43 ru'yaya means “my vision” meaning my dream and lilrru'ya means “of visions” meaning of dreams had by the King of Egypt and Quran 12:100 ru'yaya means “my dream” had by Prophet Joseph Yusuf
Quran 39:42 Koran 39:42 Allaah takes the souls at the time of their death and (also takes the souls of) those who have not died (but are alive) during their sleep (when Allaah saved the life of Jesus Isa with sleep so that his body did not move making everyone believe that Jesus Isa was dead on the cross in Quran 4:157 by raising the soul of Jesus Isa to heaven and to Allaah in Quran 4:158). He (Allaah) keeps those (souls) for which He (Allaah) had decreed death and sends the rest (of the souls to awaken the sleeping body) for a predetermined period of time (such as when Allaah returned the soul of Jesus Isa three days after the crucifixion to wake up the sleeping body of Jesus Isa on the earth in the Gospel of John 20:17, Quran 5:72, Quran 5:117 and Quran 19:36 when Jesus Isa delivered the message that Jesus Isa is not Allaah by saying Allaah is my Allaah and your Allaah meaning Allaah is my Father and your Father meaning Allaah is my Creator and your Creator meaning Allaah is my Master and your Master meaning Allaah is my Lord and your Lord as proof that no one had killed him on the cross or crucified him to death on the cross, after which they return to sleep again or die as in Quran 5:75 where Mary Maryam and Jesus Isa “use to eat food” meaning they both died 2000 years ago and Quran 3:144 where the “the messengers before Prophet Muhammad have died” meaning Jesus Isa is dead because Jesus Isa is the messenger before Prophet Muhammad. In Quran 5:117 Jesus died when he lived with the children of Israel 2000 years ago when he was raised by the angel of death). In this are signs (of Allaah) for people who think.
Note 1. Allaah does not take the human body to heaven (Quran 6:60 and Quran 39:42).
Note 2. Only the human soul is raised to heaven (Quran 6:60 and Quran 39:42).
Note 3. The human body is only needed on the Earth (Quran 6:60 and Quran 39:42). .
Note 4. The human body is not needed in heaven (Quran 6:60 and Quran 39:42).
Note 5. The human soul is alive in heaven without a human body (Quran 6:60 and Quran 39:42).
Note 6. What happened to Prophet Jesus Isa on the cross in Quran 4:157 and Quran 4:158 is explained in Quran 6:60 and Quran 39:42.
Note 7. The Quran explains what is in the Gospel Injil of Isa by Mark, Matthew, Luke and John that is with the Christians today as proof that no one can change the words of Allaah and as proof of the truthfulness of the Quran.
10. The Quran tells us that the one night journey was a vision meaning a dream like the vision dream of Allaah commanding Prophet Abraham Ibrahim to sacrifice his son Isaac Ishaq meaning the soul of Prophet Muhammad was shown the signs of Allaah in Makkah and Jerusalem and in Heaven during a one night journey in a vision dream as described in Quran 17:60 which was a trial meaning it was a test to show who in Makkah believed the prophet and who in Makkah disbelieved the prophet in the same way as the vision dream of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim to sacrifice his son Isaac Ishaq showed if Isaac Ishaq believed or disbelieved the vision dream.
Quran 17:60 Koran 17:60 And (mention Prophet Muhammad) when We (Allaah) said to you, “Your Lord has encompassed the people (meaning Allaah has knowledge of everything people do and think)." And We (Allaah) did not make the vision (meaning the dream see Quran 6:60 and Quran 39:42 “Allaah is the one who takes your souls at night”, Quran 17:60 “the vision” of Prophet Muhammad meaning the dream, Quran 38:45 the vision meaning dream of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim, Prophet Isaac Ishaq and Prophet Jacob Yaqub Israel and Quran 48:27 Prophet Muhammad’s vision meaning dream, Quran 17:60 l-ru'ya meaning “the vision” means the dream of Prophet Muhammad’s night journey and ascension to heaven in the same way as in Quran 37:105 l-ru'ya meaning “the vision” means the dream of Prophet Abraham sacrificing his son and in Quran 48:27 l-ru'ya means “the vision” meaning the dream of Prophet Muhammad worshipping at the Kabah and in Quran 12:5 ru'yaka meaning “your vision” means your dream had by Prophet Joseph Yusuf and in Quran 12:43 ru'yaya means “my vision” meaning my dream and lilrru'ya means “of visions” meaning of dreams had by the King of Egypt and Quran 12:100 ru'yaya means “my dream” had by Prophet Joseph Yusuf) which We (Allaah) showed you (meaning showed to your soul while your body was sleeping in Makkah) except as a trial for (the faith of) mankind and (when We took your soul Prophet Muhammad on the night journey from the blessed Kabah in Mecca Arabia today Makkah Saudi Arabia to the blessed ruins in Zion which contain the ruins of the First and Second Jewish Temples of Allaah in Jerusalem Al-Quds Palestine today Israel and Palestine in the Jewish Hebrew Bible Psalms 84:6 – 84:8 and made your soul ascend up into Heaven to see) the accursed tree (called the Zaqqum Zaqqoom which is the tree with the terrible food that wrongdoers shall eat in the hereafter and is mentioned) in the Quran. We (Allaah) warn (people to do what is good and avoid what is evil) and make them afraid (of Allaah by describing the home for evil doers in Hell Fire in the Hereafter) but it only increases them (some of the humans) in nothing but greater disobedience against Allaah (and the commandment to do what is good and avoid what is evil. This understanding of Quran 17:1 and Quran 17:60 is confirmed in Quran 53:17 which describes dreaming during sleep and by Quran 6:60 and Quran 39:42 which show that Allaah does not raise the physical human body to Himself or to heaven. Only the soul is raised by Allaah to Himself or to heaven. The physical human body is designed for life and death on the earth. The soul is designed for life with Allaah and in heaven during sleep and after death. On the Day of Resurrection in the hereafter on a new earth meaning a new land, a new ground, the soul will be given a new physical body that can feel reward or punishment and every human will testify that death felt like nothing but a one hour sleep or a ten hour sleep or a sleep during part of a morning or part of an afternoon and no one will say that death felt like anything more than sleeping for part of one morning or part of one afternoon. Since death for every human will feel like nothing but sleeping for part of one day no one will know how long it really was between the time of their death and the time of the Day of Resurrection. See Quran 2:259, Quran 18:19, Quran 18:21, Quran 20:103, Quran 20:104, Quran 23:113, Quran 30:55, Quran 46:35 and Quran 79:46 here https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/hadith-punishment-in-the-grave
11. The night journey of Prophet Muhammad was during the time when Muslims faced towards the ruins of the Jewish Temples at Mount Moriah in Jerusalem Al-Quds during prayer as commanded in 1 Kings 8:22 - 8:50.
The Dome of the Rock commemorates the place where the soul of Prophet Muhammad ascended to heaven to be shown the signs of Allaah when his soul was taken on a night journey from Makkah to Jerusalem Al-Quds.
The Dome of the Rock is located on the Temple Mount known as Mount Moriah near the Al-Aqsa Mosque and the ruins of the First Jewish Temple which was destroyed by Babylon and the ruins of the Second Jewish Temple which was destroyed by the Roman Empire and towards which Jews pray and the first Muslims prayed as commanded in 1 Kings 8:22 - 8:50.
Quran 17:1 Koran 17:1 Exalted is the One (Allaah) who took His (Allaah’s) servant (Prophet Muhammad on a journey) by night (see Quran 6:60 and Quran 39:42 “Allaah is the one who takes your souls at night”, Quran 17:60 “the vision” of Prophet Muhammad meaning the dream, Quran 12:6 and Quran 38:45 the vision meaning dream of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim, Prophet Isaac Ishaq and Prophet Jacob Yaqub Israel and Quran 48:27 Prophet Muhammad’s vision meaning dream) from the Sacred Mosque (“the Sacred Mosque” is l-masjidi l-harami, Al-Masjid Al-Haraam. See Quran 5:97 where the sacred House is l-bayta l-harama and is the Kabah. See Quran 9:19 the Sacred Mosque is l-masjidi l-harami in Makkah. See Quran 9:28 the Sacred Mosque is l-masjida l-harama in Makkah. See Quran 14:37 Your Sacred House baytika l-muharami. See Quran 22:25 the sacred mosque is wal-masjidi l-harami. From the Kaaba in Mecca Arabia today the Kabah in Makkah Saudi Arabia) to the farthest mosque (“the farthest mosque” is l-masjidi l-aqsa, Al-Masjid Al-Aqsa in Zion in the Jewish Hebrew Bible Psalms 84:6 – 84:8 which contains the ruins of the first Jewish Temple and the ruins of second Jewish Temple in Jerusalem Al-Quds Palestine today Israel and Palestine. The second Jewish Temple in Zion in the Jewish Hebrew Bible Psalms 84:6 – 84:8 was destroyed by the Army of the Roman Empire in 569 BH 70 CE 70 AD and is called Bayt al-Muqaddas, Bayt al-Maqdis from the Hebrew Beit Ha-Miqdash Beit Hamikdash meaning “The House of the Holy” which is the ruins of the Jewish Temple on the Temple Mount meaning the Temple Mountain in Jerusalem Al-Quds. In Quran 17:1 the Jewish Temple is called “the farthest mosque” Al-Masjid Al-Aqsa and in Quran 17:7 the Jewish Temple is called “Mosque” meaning place of worship) whose surroundings We (Allaah) have blessed (as the Holy Land in Quran 5:20 - 5:21) so that We (Allaah) may show (Prophet Muhammad) Our (Allaah’s) signs (for the remembrance of Allaah in Zion meaning in the place of the ruins of first and second Jewish Temples of Allaah in Jerusalem Al-Quds in the same way as everything on the earth and in the heavens are signs and symbols for the remembrance of Allaah. See Quran 2:158 mountains are signs of Allaah, Quran 3:97 the Kabah is a sign of Allaah, Quran 5:97 the Kabah and the sacred months and animals for offering and the garlands are signs of Allaah, Quran 22:32 “honour the symbols of Allaah”, Quran 22:36 camel and cattle are symbols of Allaah, Quran 39:42 life and sleep and death are signs of Allaah and the Jewish Hebrew Bible Psalms 84:6 – 84:8 where Baca and Zion are signs of Allaah). He (Allaah) is the All-hearer and the All-Seer. (This understanding of Quran 17:1 and Quran 17:60 is confirmed in Quran 53:17 which describes dreaming during sleep and by Quran 6:60 and Quran 39:42 which show that Allaah does not raise the physical human body to Himself or to heaven. Only the soul is raised by Allaah to Himself or to heaven. The physical human body is designed for life and death on the earth. The soul is designed for life with Allaah and in heaven during sleep and after death. On the Day of Resurrection in the hereafter on a new earth meaning a new land, a new ground, the soul will be given a new physical body that can feel reward or punishment and every human will testify that death felt like nothing but a one hour sleep or a ten hour sleep or a sleep during part of a morning or part of an afternoon and no one will say that death felt like anything more than sleeping for part of one morning or part of one afternoon. Since death for every human will feel like nothing but sleeping for part of one day no one will know how long it really was between the time of their death and the time of the Day of Resurrection. See Quran 2:259, Quran 18:19, Quran 18:21, Quran 20:103, Quran 20:104, Quran 23:113, Quran 30:55, Quran 46:35 and Quran 79:46 here https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/hadith-punishment-in-the-grave ).
Quran 53:17 Koran 53:17 The sight (of Prophet Muhammad) did not turn away (meaning his eyes did not change direction which is what happens during sleep) nor did it (his sight) exceed its limit (to see anything that Allaah had not decreed Prophet Muhammad to see. This describes the vision meaning the dream a human can see when the soul is raised by Allaah during sleep in Quran 6:60 and Quran 39:42 “Allaah is the one who takes your souls at night” as explained in Quran 17:60 comments. This understanding of Quran 17:1 and Quran 17:60 and Quran 53:17 is confirmed by Quran 6:60 and Quran 39:42 which show that Allaah does not raise the physical human body to Himself or to heaven. Only the soul is raised by Allaah to Himself or to heaven. The physical human body is designed for life and death on the earth. The soul is designed for life with Allaah and in heaven during sleep and after death. On the Day of Resurrection in the hereafter on a new earth meaning a new land, a new ground, the soul will be given a new physical body that can feel reward or punishment and every human will testify that death felt like nothing but a one hour sleep or a ten hour sleep or a sleep during part of a morning or part of an afternoon and no one will say that death felt like anything more than sleeping for part of one morning or part of one afternoon. Since death for every human will feel like nothing but sleeping for part of one day no one will know how long it really was between the time of their death and the time of the Day of Resurrection. See Quran 2:259, Quran 18:19, Quran 18:21, Quran 20:103, Quran 20:104, Quran 23:113, Quran 30:55, Quran 46:35 and Quran 79:46 here https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/hadith-punishment-in-the-grave )
12. A second vision dream foretells the victory of the Muslims in Makkah when Prophet Muhammad will enter the Kabah.
Quran 48:27 Koran 48:27 Allaah has fulfilled (decreed) His (Allaah’s) Messenger’s vision (dream) in truth (when Prophet Muhammad in a dream saw himself and his companions enter Makkah to worship Allaah at the Kabah. See Quran 6:60 and Quran 39:42 “Allaah is the one who takes your souls at night”, Quran 17:60 “the vision” of Prophet Muhammad meaning the dream, Quran 38:45 the vision meaning dream of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim, Prophet Isaac Ishaq and Prophet Jacob Yaqub Israel and Quran 48:27 Prophet Muhammad’s vision meaning dream). You shall enter the Sacred Mosque (“the Sacred Mosque” is l-masjida l-harama, Al-Masjid Al-Haraam in Makkah at a future time), if Allaah wills, in safety, (you and some others with their hair) shaven and (others with their hair) cut (short), without fear (of the stone idol worshippers in Makkah). He (Allaah) knew what you did not know (in Quran 48:25) and has given you a victory that is near (with the peace Treaty of Al-Hudaybiyyah between the stone idol worshippers in Makkah and the Muslims in Yathrib Madinah which will make the vision dream come true if Allaah wills).
Hadith Prophet Muhammad night journey to Jerusalem and Buraq.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/prophet-muhammad-ascended-to-heaven
9D. The claim Prophet Muhammad said the son to be sacrificed is Prophet Ishmael Ismail contradicts the Quran.
Why is the name of the son in the vision dream of the sacrifice important?
When we ask which son was sacrificed we are asking was the Torah Taurat which is with the Jewish people changed?
Some Muslims say that in Genesis 22:2 Allaah said sacrifice your “only son” means Ishmael Ismail because Ishmael Ismail was the only son until the age of 13 and this is proof the Torah Taurat which says “sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq” was changed.
However if you read Genesis you will see that both Ishmael Ismail and Isaac Ishaq were living before the sacrifice in Genesis 22:2.
In Genesis 21 Ishmael Ismail and Hagar are sent into the desert when Isaac Ishaq is living with Abraham Ibrahim meaning before the sacrifice “the only son” living with Abraham Ibrahim is Isaac Ishaq after Ishmael Ismail and Hagar are sent into the desert.
After the death of Prophet Muhammad how did Allaah test humans? Satan Shaitan whispered false stories like “the Jews changed the word of Allaah from Ishmael Ismail to Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat” and some Muslims believed it and other Muslims did not believe it in the same way as after the death of Prophet Jesus Isa, Satan Shaitan whispered “Jesus Isa is Allaah” and some Christians believed it and other Christians did not believe it.
This means some Muslims and some Christians are reading their Book through a filter by inserting into everything they read a belief in stories that come from outside their Book for example when some Christians read the scripture they insert a belief in Trinity which is not in the Gospel Injil but comes from outside the Gospel Injil and some Muslims insert a belief that the son to be sacrificed is Ishmael Ismail which is not in the Quran but comes from outside the Quran.
The claim Prophet Muhammad said the son to be sacrificed is Prophet Ishmael Ismail.
1. Ishmael Ismail or Isaac Ishaq?
Why is the name of the son in the vision dream of the sacrifice important?
A. If the son to be sacrificed is Ishmael Ismail it means the Quran is teaching that the Torah Taurat which names Isaac Ishaq as the son to be sacrificed and commands the Jewish people to observe the Sabbath Day in all their generations forever was changed meaning the Quran contradicts the Torah Taurat and the Torah Taurat contradicts the Quran.
B. If the son to be sacrificed is Isaac Ishaq it means the Quran is teaching that the Torah Taurat which names Isaac Ishaq as the son to be sacrificed and commands the Jewish people to observe the Sabbath Day in all their generations forever was not changed meaning the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat and the Torah Taurat confirms the Quran.
Quran 2:41 Koran 2:41 And believe in what I (Allaah) have revealed (in the Quran) confirming that which is with you (the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat as proof to the stone idol worshipers of Makkah in Quran 6:114, Quran 46:10 and Quran 10:94 that the Quran is not an invented story) ..."
Note 1. The Quran confirms the Torah Taurat which is with the Jewish people forever.
2. Prophet Muhammad did not say the son to be sacrificed is Prophet Ishmael Ismail.
Beware of claims which say words that Prophet Muhammad did not say and which contradict the Quran.
Most of the first Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Prophet Isaac Ishaq (see in C below).
3. Two hadith stories from Prophet Muhammad about the life of Prophet Ishmael Ismail narrated by Ibn Abbas the cousin of Prophet Muhammad show that Prophet Ishmael Ismail is not the son in the sacrifice (see in D below).
C. Most of the first Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Prophet Isaac Ishaq.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CANtmlGngiw
D. Prophet Muhammad hadith about Prophet Ismail.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/prophet-muhammad-hadith-about-prophet-ismail
1. The Prophet Muhammad hadith story claimed to be through Ibn Abbas shows that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was well past the time when he “was old enough to work with him (Prophet Abraham Ibrahim)” which is the time in Quran 37:102 when Prophet Abraham Ibrahim was to sacrifice his son.
This is because Prophet Abraham Ibrahim did not see Prophet Ishmael Ismail until Prophet Ishmael Ismail had already started working and was supporting a wife after his second marriage.
It was because Prophet Ishmael Ismail had already started working as a married man that Prophet Abraham Ibrahim had to return 3 times to Mecca Makkah until he was able to meet with Prophet Ishmael Ismail.
So Prophet Ishmael Ismail was well passed the age of being old enough to work because Prophet Ishmael Ismail was already working and twice married before he saw Prophet Abraham Ibrahim.
2. This hadith gives the story of Prophet Ishmael Ismail mentioning everything except the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in the vision dream.
3. Quran Chapter 37 which describes the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and names that son as Prophet Isaac Ishaq is supported by this hadith story.
4. Quran chapter 37 which describes the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim names Prophet Isaac Ishaq not one time but four times (twice by his name and twice by his title “the good news” son) however Prophet Ishmael Ismail is never mentioned.
5. Quran chapter 37 which describes the sacrifice blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq but there is no blessing from Allaah for Prophet Ishmael Ismail because Prophet Ishmael Ismail is not in the story of the sacrifice.
6. The Prophet Muhammad hadith story claimed to be through Ibn Abbas shows that the story of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is not the story of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Ishmael Ismail.
7. The story of the building of the Kaaba Kabah is the story of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Ishmael Ismail.
8. How could the Prophet Muhammad hadith claimed to be through Ibn Abbas describe the life of Prophet Ishmael Ismail and Prophet Ishmael’s Ismail’s marriages and mention Prophet Ishmael’s Ismail’s fame for arrows and building of the Kaaba Kabah and not mention the sacrifice of Prophet Ishmael Ismail (just as the Quran does not mention Prophet Ishmael’s Ismail’s name anywhere in Quran chapter 37 which describes the sacrifice) unless in fact Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim that was to be sacrificed?
9. No conclusion based only on hadith (stories from humans) is protected from error.
10. A conclusion must also be supported by the Quran to be absolutely sure that you are not among the misguided.
11. Look in the Quran to confirm that the story of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is the story of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq.
12. The Quran confirms that Prophet Isaac Ishaq is the son sacrificed in the vision dream of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 (note Quran 38:48 showing it was not Prophet Ishmael Ismail because Prophet Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with the vision dream and Prophet Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with his father meaning Prophet Isaac Ishaq was “the only son” living with his father during the time of the vision dream in Torah Genesis 22:2) and is proof that no one has the power to change the word of Allaah because the Quran and the Torah Taurat confirm each other as proof from Allaah that Allaah is real and the Quran is the truth.
13. Allaah gave Prophet Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim twice.
The first time Allaah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:101 which is the good news delivered by an angel of the birth of Isaac Ishaq.
The second time Allaah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:112 which is the good news delivered by an angel that Allaah stopped the sacrifice of Isaac Ishaq and for a second time gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim
E. Which son was to be sacrificed?
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/which-son-was-to-be-sacrificed
10. The claim that the Torah Taurat is corrupted contradicts the Quran.
Tell Jews what the prophet told Jews which is that the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat which is in their hands.
Stories claiming the Torah Taurat is corrupted contradict all the teachings in the Quran telling us that the Jewish people have the Torah and telling us that the Torah is from Allaah and telling us that no one can change the word of Allaah because that is the proof that Allaah is real for every human until the Day of Judgement.
The Jewish people judge scripture as true if it confirms the Torah Taurat.
Many Muslims say the Quran does not agree with the Torah Taurat and therefore to a Jew it means the Quran cannot be from Allaah.
If Muslims said the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat it would mean the Quran is from Allaah but this is not what many Muslims are telling the Jewish people today.
1400 years ago Prophet Muhammad said the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat meaning confirms the Torah Taurat is correct as proof the Quran is from Allaah but this is not the message many Muslims say to Jewish people today.
Rabbi Tovia Singer has studied the Torah Taurat and Gospel Injil and Quran and explains that the Jews have the scripture and therefore whenever anyone claims they also have the scripture the Jewish person compares their scripture to all other scriptures and if another scripture agrees with the Jewish scripture the Jew will applaud it in other words Jews are not asking if someone is or is not a prophet but a Jew asks do scriptures like the Gospel and the Quran which both say they confirm the Torah Taurat agree or disagree with the Jewish scripture.
When a Jew reads in the Quran that Allaah is only one the Jew applauds it meaning it agrees with the Torah Taurat.
.
When a Jew reads some Christian opinions that Allaah is a Trinity the Jew does not applaud it meaning it disagrees with the Torah Taurat.
Evidence for the truth is the Quran confirming the Torah Taurat is correct.
Quran 3:93 Ayah 3:93 “… Say (Prophet Muhammad, to the Jews of Yathrib), "Bring the Torah Taurat here and recite it (to me as evidence) if what you say is true."
Note 1. The proof of truth in the Quran is the Torah Taurat meaning no one changed the Torah Taurat.
Note 2. The Quran confirms the Torah Taurat is with the Jewish people and the Quran confirms no one can change the word of Allaah.
Note 3. Allaah tells the Jews to recite the Torah Taurat meaning the Jews have the Torah Taurat and no one changed it.
Note 4. If anyone can prove the Torah Taurat was changed then they have found the proof that Allaah does not exist.
Note 5. Allaah says the proof of truth is the Quran confirming what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat meaning there are no contradictions between the Quran which is with the Muslim people and the Torah Taurat which is with the Jewish people.
Quran 2:41 Ayah 2:41 And believe in what I (Allaah) have revealed (in the Quran) confirming that which is with you (the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat as proof to the stone idol worshipers of Makkah in Quran 6:114, Quran 46:10 and Quran 10:94 that the Quran is not an invented story) ..."
Note 1. The Quran confirms the Torah Taurat which is with the Jewish people forever.
Every prophet after Moses Musa confirmed the Torah Taurat.
The proof Allaah is real is every prophet after Moses Musa confirming that humans do not have the power to change the word of Allaah meaning every truthful prophet must confirm that no one had power to change the Torah Taurat.
If anyone found proof that humans changed the Torah Taurat then they have found proof Allaah does not exist because they have found the proof that humans changed the word of Allaah which Allaah said must be followed for 100,000 years in Torah Deuteronomy 5:10 meaning forever in Torah Deuteronomy 29:28.
Torah Deuteronomy 5:10 - And showing mercy to the thousandth generation of them that love Me (Allaah) and keep My (Allaah’s) commandments.
Note 1. Allaah promises to protect the Torah for every Jewish generation by commanding the Jewish people to keep following the Torah for 100,000 years in Torah Deuteronomy 5:10.
The Third commandment of Allaah says to the children of Israel that those that love Allaah shall keep these commandments to the thousandth generation.
If humans lived for 100 years then the thousandth generation of humans would be in 100,000 years.
Torah Deuteronomy 29:28 (in Jewish Tanakh or Deuteronomy 29:29 in a Christian Bible) The secret things belong to the LORD our Allaah; but the things that are revealed belong to us and to our children for ever (for all time), so that we may do all the words of this law (Torah).
Note 1. The Torah Taurat has been given to the children of Israel as their covenant agreement with Allaah to follow forever.
Torah Deuteronomy 13:1 (in Jewish Tanakh or Deuteronomy 12:32 in a Christian Bible) All this word which I (Allaah) command you, to do and to observe; you shall not add to it nor subtract from it.
Note 1. Allaah forbids anyone from adding or subtracting from the Torah Taurat meaning anyone who does this is a false prophet and this is explained by all the prophets below.
Prophet Muhammad.
The last revelation for the Jewish people is in the Quran and is the same message Allaah sent to the children of Israel through every prophet from Moses to Jesus to follow the Torah Taurat forever as proof that Prophet Muhammad fulfilled the prophecies in the Torah where Allaah promised to send prophet after prophet as a reminder to the Jewish people to follow the Torah without adding or subtracting from the Torah forever.
Every Jew who follows the Torah Taurat is obeying the message in the Gospel Injil and in the Quran which is the same message delivered to the Jewish people by every prophet after Prophet Moses Musa reminding them to follow the Torah Taurat as they are commanded in the Torah Taurat to follow it forever and not add or subtract from it forever.
Did anyone change the Torah Taurat after the time of Prophet Muhammad?
Has the Torah been corrupt or changed as claimed by some Muslims (not all Muslims) today in Islam?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HTmIPlJ0T7w
See 1. Understanding the Jewish Scripture. Part 1. The Torah Taurat.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/understanding-the-jewish-scripture
See 2. Understanding the Jewish Scripture. Part 2. The prophets.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/understanding-the-jewish-scripture-2
See 3. Understanding the Jewish Scripture. Part 3. The writings.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/understanding-the-jewish-scripture-3
See 4. Forgiveness of sin in the Tanakh Gospel and Quran. Part 4.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/understanding-the-jewish-scripture-4
See 5. Tanakh Jewish Bible questions and answers.
http://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/tanakh-jewish-bible-questions-and-answers-part-1
See 6. Contradictions in the Jewish Bible explained.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/contradictions-in-the-hebrew-bible-explained
See 7. Torah Quran contradictions explained.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/torah-quran-contradictions-explained
See 8. Talmud questions and answers.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/talmud-questions-and-answers
See 9. The 13 pillars of Jewish faith explained by the Quran.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/13-pillars-of-jewish-faith-explained-by-the-quran
10A. The sins of the prophets of Allaah in the Torah Taurat are confirmed in the Quran.
The Quran never says the Torah Taurat with the Jewish people is corrupted.
The Quran says many times that the Torah Taurat with the Jewish people is from Allaah.
The Quran tells the Jewish people many times to observe the Torah Taurat.
A. In the Torah Taurat Allaah teaches that all the prophets are humans and no prophet knows everything because only Allaah knows everything.
1. Prophet Noah Nuh.
Prophet Noah Nuh drank from the first grapes he grew after the flood.
Allaah shows that Prophet Noah Nuh is affected by alcohol in Genesis 9:20 - 9:21 like every human is affected by alcohol and was seen when his son entered his tent to teach humans who will descend after the flood from the family of Prophet Noah Nuh to beware of alcohol and to teach humans to worship Allaah and not the prophets of Allaah by clearly showing that Prophet Noah Nuh is not Allaah.
Quran 11:46 Koran 11:46 He (Allaah) said, “Prophet Noah Nuh, he (who you called “my son”) is not of your family (or of those that shall be saved). His conduct is evil so do not ask Me (Allaah) something about which you have no knowledge (regarding saving the person you called “my son”). I (Allaah) caution you (Prophet Noah Nuh so as) to save you from becoming one of the ignorant (when you ask about what you do not know, meaning, the people who are ignorant of the consequences from Allaah for their actions when they support evil doers like the person who Prophet Noah Nuh had called “my son” in a matter that was only for Allaah to determine. It is not for humans to ask forgiveness for someone else regarding such a matter in which humans have no knowledge and in which Allaah has decreed Allaah’s judgement on those who are evil doers).” (Allaah confirms that the boy who was drowned was not of the family of Prophet Noah Nuh which means that when Prophet Noah Nuh used the words “my son" or "my boy" it means he was calling out to a boy he saw in the water who was brought close to his heart but was not related by blood to his family).
Quran 11:47 Koran 11:47 He (Prophet Noah Nuh) said, “My Lord (Allaah) I take refuge (from sin) with you so that I do not ask you about something for which I have no knowledge. Unless you forgive me and have mercy on me I shall be lost (from Allaah’s mercy).”
Note 1. A person with no knowledge is like a person who has lost judgement because of alcohol.
Note 2. A person with no knowledge is like the behavour of a person affected by alcohol.
2. Prophet Ishmael Ismail.
Allaah shows that Prophet Ishmael Ismail is human so that humans worship Allaah and not the prophets of Allaah by clearly showing that Prophet Ishmael Ismail is not Allaah.
Genesis 21:9 And Sarah saw the son of Hagar the Egyptian, whom she (Hagar) had borne to Abraham Ibrahim (the son Ishmael Ismail), making sport (making fun meaning teasing his baby brother Isaac Ishaq which made Sarah angry and caused the brothers to separate to fulfill the prophecy that Abraham Ibrahim would be the father of many nations both Arabic and Hebrew which would not happen if both brothers lived together in the same house and to show that Ishmael Ismail who was a prophet was human as a reminder to worship Allaah and not the prophets of Allaah)
B. In the Koran Quran Allaah teaches that all the prophets are humans and no prophet knows everything because only Allaah knows everything..
3. Prophet Muhammad.
Allaah shows that Prophet Muhammad is human so that humans worship Allaah and not the prophets of Allaah by clearly showing that Prophet Muhammad is not Allaah.
Quran 80:1 Koran 80:1 He (Prophet Muhammad) frowned and turned away (from a blind man).
Quran 80:2 Koran 80:2 Because a blind man (Abdullah bin Umm Maktum, Abdullah ibn Umm Maktum) came to him (Prophet Muhammad and interrupted Prophet Muhammad while he was taking to a chief of the Quraish tribe of stone idol worshippers in Mecca Arabia today Makkah Saudi Arabia).
Quran 80:3 Koran 80:3 But how do you (Prophet Muhammad) know (what the blind man wanted from you)? Maybe he (the blind man) wanted to be cleaned (of his sins by asking for your guidance).
Quran 80:4 Koran 80:4 Or to listen to what you (Prophet Muhammad) said so that what he (the blind man) remembered might benefit him.
Quran 80:5 Koran 80:5 As for the person (a chief of the Quraish tribe of stone idol worshippers in Makkah) who think they have no need (of you or of Allaah).
Quran 80:6 Koran 80:6 You (Prophet Muhammad) gave that person (a chief of the Quraish tribe of stone idol worshippers in Makkah your) attention (even though they think they have no need of you or of Allaah instead of attending to the blind man who interrupted you because he wanted you and Allaah).
C. The sins of the prophets of Allaah in the Torah Taurat are confirmed in the Quran.
4. Prophet Lot Lut.
Prophet Lot Lut committed no sin in the Torah Taurat and Allaah shows that Prophet Lot Lut is human so that humans worship Allaah and not the prophets of Allaah by clearly showing that Prophet Lot Lut is not Allaah..
When Prophet Lot Lut and his two righteous daughters were saved from the destruction of Sodom they lived in a cave in Genesis 19:30.
His two daughters through that they were the only 3 people alive on the Earth after the destruction of Sodom and so they decided to put alcohol in the drink of their father because in their eyes he was the last man alive on the Earth and without having children through him the human race would end meaning Prophet Lot Lut had no knowledge of what was done meaning he committed no sin.
There are many lessons in Tanakh to remind people that prophets are humans meaning give all worship to Allaah and not to the messengers of Allaah.
5. Prophet Moses Musa.
Moses Musa sinned by killing a man, then repented and became a prophet so that every human who came after Prophet Moses Musa can know that when you repent and return to good behaviour Allaah will forgive your sins and Allaah shows that Prophet Moses Musa is human so that humans worship Allaah and not the prophets of Allaah by clearly showing that Prophet Moses Musa is not Allaah.
Quran 28:19 Koran 28:19 “… he (a righteous Egyptian man) said, “Prophet Moses Musa, Are you going to kill me like you killed the other person yesterday? Do you want nothing but to be a tyrant in the land (by killing people)? Do you not want to be a reformer (by doing good deeds for Allaah which improve the life and behaviour of the people on the earth?)
6. Prophet Aaron Harun.
The sin of Prophet Aaron Harun is unintended In Genesis 32:1 - 32:6 when the people told Aaron Harun to make a god for them because they do not know what happened to Moses Musa so Aaron Harun tells the people to break off the jewellery that is on the ears of their wives and sons and daughters (thinking they will not do it but they did it) and made a molten calf and the people said “This is your god, O Israel, which brought you up out of the land of Egypt.” Prophet Aaron Harun tried to delay the people from making this sin greater by saying he will build an altar and tomorrow they can make a feast to Allaah (hoping Prophet Moses Musa might return but he did not return) and Allaah shows that Prophet Aaron Harun is human so that humans worship Allaah and not the prophets of Allaah by clearly showing that Prophet Aaron Harun is not Allaah.
Quran 20:92 Koran 20:92 He (Prophet Moses Musa) said, “Aaron Harun, What prevented you (from correcting the people) when you saw them going astray,
Quran 20:93 Koran 20:93 – that you did not (tell them to) follow me? Did you disobey my order?
Quran 20:94 Koran 20:94 He (Prophet Aaron Harun) said, “O son of my mother, do not seize me by my beard nor by (the hair on) my head, I feared that you (Prophet Moses Musa) would say, ‘You (Prophet Aaron Harun) have caused division among the Children of Israel and you (Prophet Aaron Harun) did not follow my word (to wait for me Moses Musa to return to you Aaron Harun as I Moses Musa promised I would return after my Moses Musa’s meeting with Allaah on Mount Sinai Horeb).’”
7. Prophet David Dawud.
The sin of ewe is told to King David Dawud by Prophet Nathan meaning David Dawud was not a prophet when he made the great sins of adultery and murder in the same way as Moses Musa was not a prophet when he made the great sin of murder.
The King messiah David Dawud sinned by adultery (represented in the story of a man who had one female sheep in the sin of ewe, the sin involving a female) and murder (represented in the story by another man who caused to die something that did not belong to him in the sin of ewe, the sin involving a female), then repented and became a prophet so that every human who came after Prophet David Dawud can know that when you repent and return to good behaviour Allaah will forgive your sins and Allaah shows that Prophet David Dawud is human so that humans worship Allaah and not the prophets of Allaah by clearly showing that Prophet David Dawud is not Allaah.
Quran 38:23 Koran 38:23 This is my brother (in religion who) has ninety nine ewes (female sheep which really represented the many wives that Allaah had given to King David Dawud) but I have one ewe (female sheep meaning one wife which really represented Bath-sheba the wife of Uriah the Hittite) and he said, "Give it (the one ewe) to me (so that I can add your one female sheep to my 99 female sheep) and (the power of) his speech forced me to give it (my only female sheep)."
Quran 38:24 Koran 38:24 (King David Dawud) said, “He has done wrong by demanding your (one) ewe (female sheep) and adding it to his (ninety nine) ewes (female sheep). Many brothers (in religion) oppress one another except those who believe (in Allaah) and do good deeds, and they are few. And then Prophet David Dawud understood that We (Allaah) were telling (a story) about him (King David Dawud and what King David Dawud did to Uriah the Hittite and his wife Bath-sheba) and he (King David Dawud) asked forgiveness of his Lord (Allaah) and he bowed (prostrating) and repented (to Allaah for his sins).
2 Samuel 12:3 but the poor man had nothing except one little ewe lamb (female sheep), which he had bought and reared; and it grew up together with him and with his children; it ate of his own bread and drank of his own cup, and lay in his bosom, and was to him like a daughter.
2 Samuel 12:4 And there came a traveller to the rich man, and he did not take of his own flock and of his own herd to prepare (food) for the travelling man that had come to him, but took the poor man's lamb and prepared it (as food) for the man that had come to him.'
2 Samuel 12:13 And King David said to Prophet Nathan: 'I have sinned against the LORD.' And Nathan said to David: 'The LORD also has put away your sin; you shall not die.
Note 1. Allaah forgave the sins of David.
When Allaah forgives sin it is often with a reminder to humans that there are consequences in this world for you and for other people when a person sins meaning although Allaah has forgiven your sin there are consequences in this world for you and for other people which are a reminder for humans not to sin.
Why did David’s newborn baby have to die after Allaah forgave the king? Rabbi Tovia Singer explains.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DeJVxnuFGTM
8. Prophet Solomon Sulaiman.
The King messiah Solomon Sulaiman sinned by preferring the love of good things in this world like horses in Quran 38:31 - Quran 38:33 which is the same as preferring the love of good things in this world like foreign wives (who brought idol worship to Israel in the Tanakh), then repented and became a prophet so that every human who came after Prophet Solomon Sulaiman can know that when you repent and return to good behaviour Allaah will forgive your sins and Allaah shows that Prophet Solomon Sulaiman is human so that humans worship Allaah and not the prophets of Allaah by clearly showing that Prophet Solomon Sulaiman is not Allaah.
Quran 38:31 Koran 38:31 (Mention) the afternoon when he (Prophet Solomon Sulaiman) was shown excellent racing horses.
Quran 38:32 Koran 38:32 And he (Prophet Solomon Sulaiman) said, “I preferred the love of good things (like my horses in this world) over the remembrance of my Lord (Allaah, and I would watch them) until they (the horses) disappeared into the distance.”
Quran 38:33 Koran 38:33 (Then I would say) "return them (horses) to me." Then he (Prophet Solomon Sulaiman) began (with love) to stroke their legs and their necks.
Quran 38:34 Koran 38:34 And certainly We (Allaah) tried (tested) Prophet Solomon Sulaiman (with wives and horses which he loved), …”
Quran 38:35 Koran 38:35 He (Prophet Solomon Sulaiman) said, “My Lord (Allaah), Forgive me (and Allaah forgive him) …”
9. The human behaviour of Prophet Noah Nuh, Prophet Ishmael Ismail, Prophet Muhammad, Prophet Lot Lut, Prophet Aaron Harun and the sins of Prophet Moses Musa, Prophet David Dawud and Prophet Solomon Sulaiman are-
a. A reminder that the prophets are human.
b. A reminder that no human is infallible (never makes mistakes) so that all humans know that only Allaah is infallible (never makes mistakes).
c. A reminder that the prophets are not Allaah.
d. A reminder not to worship humans as Allaah.
e. A reminder that even after the greatest sin Allaah forgave and Allaah rewarded with prophethood and priesthood..
f. A reminder that Allaah forgives people who repent and return to good behaviour.
10. The sins of the prophets are lessons for the sinless and the sinner and the leaders of nations.
a. A humble sinless man (Lot Lut) was made a prophet meaning Allaah rewards humble sinless people.
b. A killer (Moses Musa) repented and was made a prophet meaning Allaah rewards the person who asks for forgiveness and returns to good behavour.
c. A prophet who did not intentionally sin (Aaron Harun) was made the High priest.
d. A leader of a nation (David Dawud) repented for adultery and murder and was made a prophet meaning Allaah rewards the person who asks for forgiveness and returns to good behavour.
e. A leader of a nation (Solomon Sulaiman) repented for marriage to foreign wives who brought idol worship to his nation and was made a prophet meaning Allaah rewards the person who asks for forgiveness and returns to good behavour.
Ezekiel 18:22 None of his transgressions (wrongdoing) that he has committed shall be remembered against him; for his righteousness that he has done he shall live (in Paradise).
Note 1. Repentance to Allaah and returning to righteous behaviour removes intentional sins like adultery, murder and idol worship which sacrifices cannot remove.
The Tanakh is guidance given to each generation of the Israelite people who knew Allaah for thousands of years containing details of the sins of the prophets as a warning to each generation against the idol worship of the prophets for example the sin of ewe which is in both the Tanakh and the Quran is the sin involving a female sheep meaning the sin involving a female which is the story of the sin of adultery and the sin of the murder of her husband.
The Quran was revealed in only 23 years to people who did not know Allaah and the prophets are an example for the stone idol worshippers where the details of the sins of the prophets is not explained in detail because the main lesson in the Quran for the stone idol worshippers is that when the prophets sinned they repented and Allaah forgave them like Allaah can forgive you meaning all prophets are humans like you are human so do not elevate them to be more than a human.
The Quran is revealed so that a Jew who knows Tanakh will fully understand the meaning of the sin of ewe in the Quran and people who are new to Islam such as the stone idol worshippers will understand that the sin of ewe means Allaah forgives people when they repent for their sins.
The prophets in the Quran are an example of righteousness to the stone idol worshippers who might have become confused if the Quran explained the exact nature of the sins for which the prophets repented in the Quran.
All prophets repented as proof they are humans.
A Muslim today can read about the sins of the prophets in Tanakh and understand that Allaah revealed Tanakh in the best way to the Israelites who had known Allaah over thousands of years and Allaah revealed the Quran in the best way to stone idol worshippers who did not know Allaah 1400 years ago meaning the Tanakh and Quran confirm each other as proof the Quran is from Allaah because no one was able to change His words in His Books.
11. The Quran tells us the prophets repented for their sins.
12. The Tanakh tells us about those sins.
13. The proof the Quran is from Allaah is that it confirms the Torah Taurat.
14. The proof the Quran is not from Allaah is that it contradicts the Torah Taurat.
15. The Quran confirms the Torah Taurat (not denies it or corrects it) as proof the Quran is the truth meaning both the Quran and the Torah Taurat are true.as proof Allaah is real because no one could change the truth of the Torah Taurat which is with the Jewish people forever or the truth of the Quran which is with the Muslim people forever meaning both books confirm and explain each other.
16. In the Quran Allaah tells us that the prophets repented for their sins and in the Torah Taurat Allaah reveals the full details of those sins.
Quran 2:41 Koran 2:41 And believe in what I (Allaah) have revealed (in the Quran) confirming that which is with you (in the Torah Taurat as proof to the stone idol worshipers of Makkah in Quran 6:114, Quran 46:10 and Quran 10:94 that the Quran is not an invented story) ..."
Note 1. The Quran confirms the Torah Taurat which is with the Jewish people forever.
Quran 3:3 Koran 3:3 “… He (Allaah) revealed the Torah Taurat …”
Quran 3:93 Koran 3:93 “… Say (Prophet Muhammad, to the Jews of Yathrib), "Bring the Torah Taurat here and recite it (to me as evidence) if what you say is true."
Note 1. Allaah confirms the Torah Taurat with the Jews is correct and is evidence for the truth as proof no one can change the word of Allaah.
Quran 4:136 Koran 4:136 “... and whoever has no faith in … Allaah's Books … then he has strayed far away (from Allaah).”
Quran 5:43 Koran 5:43 How is it that they (the Jews of Yathrib Arabia) come to you (Prophet Muhammad) for judgment when they have the Torah Taurat in which Allaah has already revealed to them judgment …”
Note 1. Allaah tells the Jews to follow the Torah meaning the Jews have the Torah and no one changed it.
Quran 5:68 Koran 5:68 Say, “O People of the Scripture, You have nothing (of guidance) until you observe the Torah Taurat …”
Note 1. Allaah tells the Jews to follow the Torah meaning the Jews have the Torah and no one changed it.
Quran 6:34 Koran 6:34 “… no one can change the words of Allaah…”
Quran 28:48 Koran 28:48 But when the truth came to them (the stone idol worshippers of Makkah Arabia) from Us (Allaah), they said, “Why is he (Prophet Muhammad M Mim م M-uhammad م-uhammad) not given (signs) like what was given to Prophet Moses Musa (represented by Mount Sinai S’ Sin س Sin-ai س-ai)? But did they (the stone idol worshippers of Makkah Arabia) not disbelieve in what was given to Prophet Moses Musa in the past? (Because) they say, “(They are both only books about magic) two magic (books the Torah Taurat T Ta ط Ta-urat ط-urat given by Allaah to Prophet Moses Musa and the Quran Q Qaf ق Qaf-uran ق-uran given by Allaah to Prophet Muhammad) supporting each other” and they (the stone idol worshippers of Makkah Arabia) say, “In all (that is in the Torah Taurat and the Quran) we do not believe.”
Quran 28:49 Koran 28:49 Say (Prophet Muhammad to the stone idol worshippers of Makkah Arabia), “Then bring a Book from Allaah that gives better guidance than these two (the Torah Taurat and the Quran) so that I (Prophet Muhammad) may follow it, if you are telling the truth.”
Note 1. The best guidance is the Quran and the Torah Taurat meaning both are correctly understood when they confirm and explain each other.
Quran 52:1 Koran 52:1 (I Allaah swear to the truth) by the Mount (mountain at Mount Sinai which represents Prophet Moses Musa in Quran 26:1, Quran 27:1, Quran 28:1, Quran 36:1, Quran 42:2 and Quran 95:2 and is the place where Allaah revealed the Torah Taurat to Prophet Moses Musa) –
Quran 52:2 Koran 52:2 And (I Allaah swear to the truth) by a written Book (which is the Torah Taurat that is) –
Quran 52:3 Koran 52:3 in an unrolled parchment (which is the Torah Taurat in a rolled parchment that is unrolled when it is read) –
Note 1. Allaah swears to the truth by the truth of the Torah Taurat.
Mysterious letters in the Quran.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/mysterious-letters-in-the-quran
10B. Prophet Ishmael Ismail is the son in the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim contradicts the Quran.
Why is the name of the son in the vision dream of the sacrifice important?
A. If the son to be sacrificed is Ishmael Ismail it means the Quran is teaching that the Torah Taurat which names Isaac Ishaq as the son to be sacrificed and commands the Jewish people to observe the Sabbath Day in all their generations forever was changed meaning the Quran contradicts the Torah Taurat and the Torah Taurat contradicts the Quran.
B. If the son to be sacrificed is Isaac Ishaq it means the Quran is teaching that the Torah Taurat which names Isaac Ishaq as the son to be sacrificed and commands the Jewish people to observe the Sabbath Day in all their generations forever was not changed meaning the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat and the Torah Taurat confirms the Quran.
Quran 2:41 Koran 2:41 And believe in what I (Allaah) have revealed (in the Quran) confirming that which is with you (the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat as proof to the stone idol worshipers of Makkah in Quran 6:114, Quran 46:10 and Quran 10:94 that the Quran is not an invented story) ..."
Note 1. The Quran confirms the Torah Taurat which is with the Jewish people forever.
.
Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and 38:48 explains the meaning of “the only son” in Torah Genesis 22:2 meaning the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat is correct as proof the Quran is truthful and as proof no one can change the written word of Allaah.
1. Quran chapter 38 is the chapter after the story of the sacrifice.
In Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and 38:48 Allaah is blessing Abraham and Isaac with the vision dream and Ishmael is in the next verse without his father and without the blessing of the vision dream.
2. Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and 38:48 shows that Allaah did not give the blessing of the remembrance of the famous vision dream of the sacrifice to Prophet Ishmael Ismail.
3. Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and 38:48 shows that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not with his father at the time of the sacrifice.
4. Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and 38:48 shows that Prophet Isaac Ishaq was “the only son” living with Prophet Abraham Ibrahim at the time of the sacrifice.
5. Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and 38:48 shows that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not with his father at the time of the sacrifice meaning Prophet Isaac Ishaq was “the only son” living with Prophet Abraham Ibrahim at the time of the sacrifice.
6. Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and 38:48 shows that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not with his father at the time of the sacrifice because many years earlier Prophet Abraham Ibrahim was tested by sending Hagar and Prophet Ishmael Ismail away into the desert meaning Prophet Isaac Ishaq was “the only son” living with Prophet Abraham Ibrahim at the time of the sacrifice.
7. The remembrance of the famous vision dream of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 38.
After the story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 Allaah gave the blessing of the remembrance of the famous vision dream of the sacrifice to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the next chapter Quran chapter 38.
Quran 38:45 Verse 38:45 And mention Our (Allaah’s) servant Prophet Abraham Ibrahim, Prophet Isaac Ishaq and Prophet Jacob Yaqub Israel (who were), men with strength (of faith in Allaah) and vision (to understand the meaning of dreams).
Note 1. Prophet Isaac Ishaq is blessed with his father.
Note 2. Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq are blessed with the vision dream.
Quran 38:46 Verse 38:46 We (Allaah) chose them (Prophet Abraham Ibrahim, Prophet Isaac Ishaq and Prophet Jacob Yaqub Israel) for an exclusive (quality which is their) remembrance of the home (in the hereafter which is the final destination after death).
Quran 38:47 Verse 38:47 And indeed they (Prophet Abraham Ibrahim, Prophet Isaac Ishaq and Prophet Jacob Yaqub Israel) to Us (Allaah) from the chosen ones are the best (of humans).
Quran 38:48 Verse 38:48 And mention Prophet Ishmael Ismail and Prophet Elisha Al-Yasha and Prophet Ezekiel Zulkifl Dhul-Kifl. And all are from the best (of humans).
Note 1. Prophet Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with his father compared to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq in Quran 38:45 - 38:47.
Note 2. Prophet Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with the vision dream compared to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq in Quran 38:45 - 38:47.
Genesis 22:2 And He (Allaah) said: “Take your son, your only son (who still lives with you, reminding him that Allaah had earlier taken Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar away from him into Allaah’s care in the desert in Genesis chapter 21 meaning Ishmael Ismail was not living with Abraham Ibrahim in Genesis chapter 22 when Allaah is testing Abraham Ibrahim a second time to show if Abraham Ibrahim will give Allaah his second son who is the only son still living with him after Abraham Ibrahim gave Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar to Allaah in the desert in Genesis chapter 21), whom you love (Allaah makes the test very hard by demanding his second son and reminding him that this is his only remaining son and reminding him that he already gave Allaah one son in Genesis chapter 21 and reminding him of his love for these sons), even (namely, that is) Isaac Ishaq and go to the land of Moriah; and offer him there for a burnt-offering on one of the mountains which I (Allaah) will tell you. (Will Abraham Ibrahim give Allaah the only son who is living with him after he already gave Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar to Allaah in the desert in Genesis chapter 21. Will Abraham Ibrahim give Allaah both his sons?).
Quran 37:101 Koran 37:101 (In the story of Isaac Ishaq, Allaah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim twice. The first time Allaah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:101 which is the good news of the birth of Isaac Ishaq. The second time Allaah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:112 which is the good news that Allaah stopped the sacrifice of Isaac Ishaq and for a second time gave Isaac Ishaq to Abraham Ibrahim) So We (Allaah through His angels) gave him (Prophet Abraham Ibrahim) the good news of a forbearing (meaning patient, not complaining) son (Prophet Isaac Ishaq who is also unnamed in Quran 15:53, 15:54, 15:55 and 51:28 because good news is always the name Allaah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran chapters 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51).
Quran 37:112 Koran 37:112 (In the story of Isaac Ishaq, Allaah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim twice. The first time Allaah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:101 which is the good news of the birth of Isaac Ishaq. The second time Allaah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:112 which is the good news that Allaah stopped the sacrifice of Isaac Ishaq and for a second time gave Isaac Ishaq to Abraham Ibrahim) And We (Allaah) gave him (Prophet Abraham Ibrahim) the good news of Isaac Ishaq (a second time after Allaah stopped the sacrifice of Isaac Ishaq in Quran 37:102 - 37:107 and blessed Abraham Ibrahim in Quran 37:108 - 37:111. The good news is always the name of Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran chapters 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51), a prophet of the righteous (requested in Quran 37:100 and given by Allaah as the good news son in Quran 37:101 and when in Quran 37:102 Prophet Isaac Ishaq is old enough to work with Prophet Abraham Ibrahim they both understand the vision in a dream that showed Prophet Isaac Ishaq will be sacrificed and is remembered in Quran 12:6 and Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and showing in the next verse in Quran 38:48 that it was not Prophet Ishmael Ismail by blessing Prophet Ishmael Ismail without his father and without the blessing of vision and so Allaah decreed those revelations in Quran chapter 38 after the story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 to guide by Allaah’s word those who understand what Allaah is teaching. Those who understand are guided by the words of Allaah. Those who do not understand are misguided by the words of humans. The righteous good news son is named Prophet Isaac Ishaq in Quran 37:112 and Allaah blesses both the father Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and the son Prophet Isaac Ishaq in Quran 37:113. Quran 11:69 where good news is unnamed like in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:101 and together with Quran 11:71 where the good news is named as Prophet Isaac Ishaq like in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:112 show that good news both when it is named or not named is the name for Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran. Quran 11:74 where good news is unnamed like in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:101 and together with Quran 11:71 where the good news is named as Prophet Isaac Ishaq like in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:112 show that good news both when it is named or not named is the name for Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran. Quran 29:31 which mentions good news is related to Quran 29:27 which mentions Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the same way as in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:101 which mentions good news is related to Quran 37:112 which mentions Prophet Isaac Ishaq because good news is always the name of Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran).
1. Library chats E7: Ismā`īl vs. Isḥāq as the sacrifice: A case study of tafsīr and scholarly influence.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CANtmlGngiw
2. Which son was to be sacrificed?
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/which-son-was-to-be-sacrificed
3. Quran chapter 37. The story of the sacrifice.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/quran-chapter-37-surah-37
4. Was Abraham commanded to sacrifice Isaac or Ishmael?
http://www.judaism-islam.com/was-abraham-commanded-to-sacrifice-isaac-or-ishmael/
10C. Jews are commanded to observe the Sabbath Day forever.
Jews do not follow any commandments other than that which was sent down to them at Mount Sinai because every truthful prophet after Moses Musa like Prophet Jesus Isa (Gospel of Matthew 5:17 - 5:20) and Prophet Muhammad (Quran 2:40 - 2:41) reminded the Hebrews to follow what was sent down by Allaah at Mount Sinai as proof Allaah does not change His promises and His covenants meaning the Torah Taurat is the truth which the Jewish people must obey forever.
A. Allaah reminds the Jews to keep the Sabbath Day in the Torah Taurat, the Psalm Zabur, Gospel Injil and in the Quran.
In the Torah Taurat Allaah commands the children of Israel to observe the Sabbath Day forever in all their generations.
There are no contradictions in the Quran because the Quran is confirming the Torah Taurat is correct.
Paul is a false prophet because in Hebrews 8:13 Paul claims the Torah Taurat will fade away meaning Jews do not need to keep the Sabbath Day meaning Paul is contradicting Allaah in the Torah Taurat and Paul is contradicting Prophet Jesus in the Gospel of Matthew 5:17 - 5:20 and Gospel of Matthew 23:1 - 23:3.
B. Why do Muslims not observe the Sabbath Day?
The Sabbath Day was given only to the children of Israel, the Hebrew people, the Jewish people forever.
Non Jews are allowed to observe the Sabbath Day only if they do not observe it fully because it is only the Jewish people who have been commanded to fully observe the Sabbath Day forever in every generation or only if they do not claim that they have been commanded to observe it because Allaah has only commanded the children of Israel to observe it fully forever in all their generations
The Fourth of the Ten Commandments of Allaah.
Torah Deuteronomy 5:12 (The Fourth Commandment from Allaah) Observe the Sabbath day, to keep it holy, as the Lord your Allaah commanded you.
Torah Exodus 31:13 (Moses) speak to the children of Israel, saying: You shall keep My (Allaah’s) Sabbaths, for it is a sign between Me (Allaah) and you throughout your generations, so that you may know that I am the LORD who sanctify you (by showing you holy behaviour).
Exodus 31:16 So the children of Israel shall keep the Sabbath and observe the Sabbath throughout their generations, as a perpetual (never ending) covenant (agreement with Allaah).
Exodus 31:17 It (the Sabbath) is a sign between Me (Allaah) and the children of Israel forever; for in six days the LORD (Allaah) made heaven and earth, and on the seventh day He (Allaah) ceased from work and rested (rested means completed the creation and this is why the Sabbath is a day of rest and remembrance of Allaah on every seventh day).'
Exodus 31:18 And when He (Allaah) finished speaking with him (Moses) on mount Sinai, He (Allaah) gave Moses the two tables of the testimony (of Allaah), tables of stone, written with the finger of Allaah.
Note 1. Finger of Allaah means by the decree of Allaah.
Torah Deuteronomy 5:13 (For) six days you shall labour, and do all your work;
Deuteronomy 5:14 but the seventh day is a Sabbath to (remember) the Lord your Allaah, in it you shall not do any manner of work, you, nor your son, nor your daughter, nor your man-servant, nor your maid-servant, nor your ox, nor your ass, nor any of your cattle, nor your stranger that is within your gates; that your man-servant and your maid-servant may rest as well as you.
Deuteronomy 5:15 And you shall remember that you were a servant in the land of Egypt, and the Lord your Allaah brought you out of there by a mighty hand and by an outstretched arm; therefore the Lord your Allaah commanded you to keep the Sabbath day (to remember Allaah).
Quran 16:124 Verse 16:124 The Sabbath (Day) was only decreed for those (children of Israel , the Hebrew people, the Jewish people) who differed in (observing) it (in Quran 2:65 – 2:66, Quran 5:60, Quran 7:163 – 7:166 meaning the Sabbath Day was decreed for the Jewish people of whom some obeyed and some did not obey). Your Lord (Allaah) shall judge between them (the Jewish people) on the Day of Resurrection in what they used to differ in (observing the Sabbath Day which the Jewish people are commanded in the Ten Commandments of Allaah in Deuteronomy 5:12, to observe the Sabbath Day forever in Exodus 31:13, by observing the Sabbath Day in every generation in Exodus 31:16, to observe the Sabbath Day as a sign forever between Allaah and the children of Israel in Exodus 31:17 in the Torah covenant in Deuteronomy 31:9, Deuteronomy 4:13, Deuteronomy 28:69, Deuteronomy 4:31, Deuteronomy 7:9 – 7:12 commanding that no one shall add or subtract from the Torah in Deuteronomy 4:2 and Deuteronomy 13:1 in Jewish Tanakh or Deuteronomy 12:32 in a Christian Bible and forever in Deuteronomy 5:10, Deuteronomy 29:28 in Jewish Tanakh or Deuteronomy 29:29 in a Christian Bible, Psalm 111:9, Isaiah 59:21 is the promise to the Jewish people who are mentioned in Isaiah 36:11, Isaiah 36:13, Gospel of Matthew 5:17 – 5:20 and Quran 2:40 – 2:41).
1. Jews who observe the Sabbath Day are submitting to Allaah.
2. Jews who follow the Torah Taurat are following the message delivered to them by Prophet Muhammad and every prophet after Prophet Moses Musa reminding the Jewish people to follow the Torah Taurat forever because it is the covenant agreement between Allaah and the Jewish people.
3. The Jewish people will be judged concerning their observance of the Sabbath Day which is an everlasting covenant agreement between Allaah and the Jewish people in Quran 2:40 – 2:41.
4. Quran 16:124 is confirmed in Quran 2:106 where Allaah has not abolished anything in the Torah for the Jewish people meaning the Jewish people must follow the Torah as the Torah has commanded it must be followed forever.
5. Quran 16:124 is confirmed in Quran 13:39 where Allaah eliminates from the Quran the laws which are only binding on the Jewish people such as the Sabbath Day.
6. In Judaism Saturday is the day of rest from Friday sunset to Saturday sunset.
In Christianity Sunday is the day of rest except for a few Christian sects whose day of rest is on Saturday.
In Islam Friday is the day of rest. After midday on Friday is the time of Friday congregational prayers at the mosque and after those prayers Muslims can return to work if they wish.
7. The Muslim belief in Prophet Jesus is not a sin according to Judaism.
Does Judaism Regard Muslims as B’nai Noah (Righteous Gentiles)? Rabbi Tovia Singer
Muslims correctly worship Allaah means Muslims are righteous gentiles.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=udYM4FuYdiA
8. The Jewish understanding of Jesus.
Is Jesus in the Talmud?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jVr6ouBA-3Q
9. The Jewish understanding of Prophet Muhammad
Do Jews believe Mohammad was a prophet and is the Quran anti-semitic? Rabbi Tovia Singer Responds.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w5pwwh5io9I
11. The claim that the Gospel Injil is corrupted contradicts the Quran.
Tell Christians what the prophet told Christians which is that the Quran explains the Gospel Injil which is in their hands.
Explain that Jesus Isa did not write anything because everything Jesus taught by his mouth was already written in the Tanakh Jewish scripture meaning Jesus did not add or subtract from what is in Tanakh Jewish scripture.
Explain that the four Gospels are four reports about Jesus meaning Jesus never wrote anything and what he said was passed by mouth until it was written many years later.
Explain that there are no names on the original earliest four Gospel Injil manuscripts meaning the names Mark, Matthew, Luke and John were all added later meaning no one knows who wrote them.
Explain that Quran 5:68 says observe the Torah Taurat and the Gospel Injil and Quran 5:47 tells Christians to judge by the Gospel Injil (not by the other books in the New Testament because what Paul teaches contradicts what Jesus is teaching in the Gospel) meaning whatever in the Gospel Injil is confirmed in the Torah Taurat came from Jesus and whatever contradicts the Torah Taurat came from the unknown writers who are traditionally called Mark, Matthew, Luke and John in a test from Allaah described in 1 Kings 13:14 - 13:24 teaching that the word of Allaah will not change and do not believe anyone for example a verse in Mark, Matthew, Luke and John if it claims the word of Allaah has changed.
1. In Quran 4:157 Jesus was not killed on the cross confirms the words of Jesus 3 days after the crucifixion in Gospel of John 20:17 “I have not yet ascended to the Father (Allaah, meaning I have not yet died)” ...
2. In Quran 4:158 Jesus was saved on the cross with sleep when his soul ascended to heaven in Quran 39:42 and the way Allaah would save Jesus on the cross is foreshadowed before the time of the crucifixion in the Gospel Injil as follows.
Gospel of Mark 5:39 "... The child is not dead but sleeping",
Gospel of Matthew 9:24 "... For the maiden meaning the girl has not died but sleeps ..."
Gospel of Luke 8:52 "... She is not dead but sleeping."
Gospel of Luke 8:54 – 8:55 “…"Damsel meaning girl, wake up!" And her spirit returned, and she stood up at once, and he ordered that she be given something to eat. (This was proof that she was alive and not dead and that she was a physical body who could eat food and not a resurrected spiritual body that does not need food meaning she was a physical body who woke up after sleep and not a spiritual body which was resurrected after death as described by Paul in 1 Corinthians 15:35 and 1 Corinthians 15:44).
3. In Quran 5:75 and Quran 3:144 is the natural death of Jesus 2000 years ago which is mentioned three days after the crucifixion in Gospel of John 20:17 Jesus says to her (Mary Magdalene), "Do not hold on to me, for I have not yet ascended to the Father (Allaah, meaning I have not yet died); but go to my brothers (my disciples), and tell them: 'I am ascending to my Father (Allaah, meaning Jesus will die like every human dies as proof to his people that he is human meaning do not let a miracle make you believe I am not a human like you) …”
4. In Quran 19:36 Jesus said “Allaah is my Lord and your Lord” meaning Jesus is teaching his people that he is not Allaah and this is said 3 days after the crucifixion in Gospel of John 20:17 Jesus says to her (Mary Magdalene), "Do not hold on to me, for I have not yet ascended to the Father (Allaah, meaning I have not yet died); but go to my brothers (my disciples), and tell them: 'I am ascending to my Father (to my creator Allaah, meaning Jesus will die like every human dies as proof to his people that he is human meaning do not let a miracle make you believe I am more than a human like you) and your Father (to your creator Allaah); to my Allaah (to my Lord) and your Allaah (to your Lord).”
5. Allaah chose the Israelites and gave them the Torah Taurat and told them to observe the Sabbath Day in all their generations forever meaning Allaah decreed Judaism and the Torah Taurat forever so that the following might be fulfilled.
A. The Torah Taurat shows which verses in the Gospel Injil confirm the Torah Taurat meaning they came from Jesus and which verses in the Gospel Injil contradict the Torah Taurat meaning they came from Mark, Matthew, Luke or John in a test described in 1 Kings 13:14 - 13:24 teaching that the word of Allaah will not change and do not believe anyone who claims the word of Allaah has changed.
See 1. The 8 signs of Prophet Muhammad in the Gospel of Mark.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/the-gospel-of-mark-1-5
See 2. The 50 signs of Prophet Muhammad in the Gospel of Matthew.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/the-gospel-of-matthew-1-7
See 3. The 377 signs of Prophet Muhammad in the Gospel of Luke.
See 4. The hundreds of signs of Prophet Muhammad in the Gospel of John.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/the-gospel-of-john-chapters-1-3
B. In the same way Allaah is testing Muslims in every generation in the story of the sacrifice in a test described in 1 Kings 13:14 - 13:24 teaching that the word of Allaah will not change and do not believe anyone who claims the word of Allaah has changed.
1. Library chats E7: Ismā`īl vs. Isḥāq as the sacrifice: A case study of tafsīr and scholarly influence.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CANtmlGngiw
2. Which son was to be sacrificed?
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/which-son-was-to-be-sacrificed
3. Quran chapter 37. The story of the sacrifice.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/quran-chapter-37-surah-37
4. Was Abraham commanded to sacrifice Isaac or Ishmael?
http://www.judaism-islam.com/was-abraham-commanded-to-sacrifice-isaac-or-ishmael/
11A. The story of Prophet Jesus Isa and Prophet Isaac Ishaq is the same story.
1. Before the test of Prophet Isaac he is told he will die in the same way as before the test of Prophet Jesus he is told he will die.
2. Prophet Isaac had faith like Prophet Jesus had faith.
3. Prophet Isaac passed the test of faith and was saved from death like Prophet Jesus passed the test of faith and was saved from death.
4. The lesson of the story of Prophet Isaac and Prophet Jesus is Allaah does not forsake a person who has faith and who does good deeds in the world like Prophet Jesus and Prophet Isaac did good in the world and trusted in Allaah with prayer by repenting to Allaah and asking for forgiveness from Allaah and returning to good behaviour because when a person does these things they become sinless.
This is why Jesus and Isaac prayed to Allaah many times a day.
In Isaiah 1:16 - 1:18 Allaah tells humans to reason and know that when you repent and return to good behaviour all your sins are forgiven meaning you become sinless.
5. When Prophet Jesus cried out to Allaah “My Allaah my Allaah why have you forsaken me” Prophet Jesus showed Allaah that he had not lost his faith in Allaah by crying out to Allaah for help and this is when Prophet Jesus passed the test of faith and was saved from death with sleep and woke up after 3 days to reveal that “I has not yet ascended to Allaah” in Gospel of John 20:17 meaning Prophet Jesus was saved from death with sleep so that Prophet Jesus could deliver the good news that Allaah does not forsake people who trust in Allaah and do good on the earth like Prophet Jesus and Prophet Isaac did good in the world and trusted in Allaah with prayer by repenting to Allaah and asking for forgiveness from Allaah and returning to good behaviour because when a person does these things they become sinless.
This is why Jesus and Isaac prayed to Allaah many times a day to remove their sins as explained in Ecclesiastes 7:20, Proverbs 24:16, 1 Kings 8:46 - 8:50, Ezekiel 18:20 - 18:23, Isaiah 1:18, Isaiah 55:7, Hosea 6:6, Hosea 14:2 - 14:3 and Micah 6:6 - 6:8.
6. Three days after the crucifixion Prophet Jesus said in Gospel of John 20:17 "I have not yet ascended to the father" meaning Prophet Jesus is telling Mary Magdalene that he did not die on the cross meaning Allaah saved Prophet Jesus from death on the cross with sleep on the cross and woke him up after 3 days so that Prophet Jesus could continue to live on the earth teaching his people that he is not Allaah until his natural death 2000 years ago.
7. In Gospel of John 20:17 Prophet Jesus said “Allaah is my Allaah and your Allaah” meaning Allaah is my master and your mater.
And “Allaah is my Father and your Father” meaning Allaah is my creator and your creator.
8. In Gospel of John 20:17 Prophet Jesus says he did not die on the cross (but was saved on the cross with sleep) meaning Prophet Jesus was not sacrificed and Prophet Jesus is telling us that he is not Allaah.
9. Here is what Prophet Jesus said 3 days after the crucifixion.
Gospel of John 20:17 Jesus says to her (Mary Magdalene), "Do not hold on to me, for I have not yet ascended to the Father (Allaah, meaning I have not yet died); but go to my brothers (my disciples), and tell them: 'I am ascending to my Father (to my creator Allaah, meaning Jesus will die like every human dies as proof to his people that he is human meaning do not let a miracle make you believe I am more than a human like you) and your Father (to your creator Allaah); to my Allaah (to my Lord) and your Allaah (to your Lord).”
Prophet Jesus was saved from death meaning Prophet Jesus was not sacrificed and this was foreshadowed in the Gospel in the following way.
Gospel of Mark 5:39 "... The child is not dead but sleeping",
Gospel of Matthew 9:24 "... For the maiden meaning the girl has not died but sleeps ..."
Gospel of Luke 8:52 "... She is not dead but sleeping."
Gospel of Luke 8:54 – 8:55 “…"Damsel meaning girl, wake up!" And her spirit returned, and she stood up at once, and he ordered that she be given something to eat. (This was proof that she was alive and not dead and that she was a physical body who could eat food and not a resurrected spiritual body that does not need food meaning she was a physical body who woke up after sleep and not a spiritual body which was resurrected after death as described by Paul in 1 Corinthians 15:35 and 1 Corinthians 15:44).
In the same way 3 days after the crucifixion Prophet Jesus explains in Gospel of John 20:17 that he did not die meaning he woke up in his physical body after 3 days of sleep meaning he was not sacrificed meaning he is not a spiritual body which was resurrected after death as described by Paul in 1 Corinthians 15:35 and 1 Corinthians 15:44).
10. Faith without doing good deeds is a false faith and is not righteous.
Faith and doing good deeds is the correct faith and is righteous.
In Isaiah 1:16 - 1:18 Allaah tells humans to reason and know that when you repent and return to good behaviour all your sins are forgiven meaning you become sinless.
Epistle of James 2:20 You foolish man, do you want evidence that faith without deeds is useless?
Epistle of James 2:21 Was not our ancestor Abraham Ibrahim considered righteous for what he did when he offered his son Isaac Ishaq on the altar?
Epistle of James 2:22 You see that his faith and his actions were working together and his faith was made complete by what he did.
https://sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel/allaah-answers-2
11B. The meaning of the mysterious letters in the Quran.
Some claim that the mysterious letters in the Quran are unknown and they say do not listen to anyone regarding its meaning however this advice contradicts all the verses about knowledge, understanding and wisdom in the Quran.
The meaning of the mysterious letters in the Quran confirm the central teaching in the Quran.
The letters N, Q, S, ALM, ALR, ALMR, ALMS, HM, TH', TS', TS'M, YS', A'S'Q, KH'YA'S shows the Quran is revelation from Allaah through the Holy Spirit Angel Gabriel Jibril to the mind of Prophet Muhammad confirming what was revealed before the Quran in the Scripture of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in the Torah Taurat and the Torah Taurat and the Psalm Zabur of David Dawud in the Tanakh Hebrew scriptures and the Tanakh Hebrew scriptures which is with the Jewish people today and explaining the story of Prophet Jesus Isa in the Gospel Injil of Jesus Isa by Mark, Matthew, Luke and John which is with the Christian people today as the proof that Allaah is real and the Quran is truthful.
Prophet Jesus Isa did not write anything because everything Jesus taught by his mouth was already written in the Tanakh Jewish scripture meaning Jesus did not add or subtract from what is in the Tanakh Jewish scripture in Gospel of Matthew 5:17-20 and Gospel of Matthew 23:1-3
The four Gospels are four reports about Jesus meaning Jesus never wrote anything and what he said was passed by mouth until it was written many years later.
Quran 5:68 says observe the Torah Taurat and the Gospel Injil and Quran 5:47 tells Christians to judge by the Gospel Injil (not by the other books in the New Testament Bible because what Paul and others teach contradicts what Jesus is teaching in the Gospel) meaning whatever in the Gospel Injil is confirmed in the Torah Taurat came from Jesus and whatever contradicts the Torah Taurat came from the unknown writers who are traditionally called Mark, Matthew, Luke and John in a test from Allaah described in 1 Kings 13:14-24 teaching that the word of Allaah will not change and do not believe anyone (for example Mark, Matthew, Luke and John) if in stories they claim the word of Allaah has changed.
Allaah would never allow the proof that Allaah is real to be lost because Allaah is just to every generation of humans who put their trust in the Books of Allaah in Quran 4:136.
Anyone can reveal a book and claim all other books are corrupted but only Allaah can reveal a Quran to Muslims and a Torah Taurat to Jews which confirm and explain each other in Quran 28:48-49 meaning the Quran and Torah Taurat are correctly understood when they confirm and explain each other.
Every prophet after Moses Musa reminded the Jewish people to observe the Sabbath Day forever in each generation as instructed in the Torah Taurat because it is their eternal covenant with Allaah in Quran 2:40-41.
1. Jews and Christians who follow their Book and also believe the Quran shall receive a double reward in the hereafter in Quran 28:54, Quran 34:37 and Quran 57:28.
2. Jews who follow the Tanakh Jewish scripture and believe the Quran are correctly observing the Torah Taurat.
3. Christians who follow the Gospels and believe the Quran are correctly observing the Gospel Injil.
4. Muslims who follow the Quran so that it agrees with the Tanakh Jewish scripture and explains the story of Prophet Jesus in the Gospel Injil are correctly observing the Quran.
Quran 3:3 Koran 3:3 “… He (Allaah) revealed the Torah Taurat and the Gospel Injil …”
Quran 4:136 Koran 4:136 “... and whoever has no faith in … Allaah's Books … then he has strayed far away (from Allaah).”
1. Not all Christians and Jews and Muslims are the same meaning in every generation there are some Christians and Muslims and Jews who are correctly worshiping Allaah.
The Christian and Jew who believed in one Allaah like the Muslim who believed in one Allaah and who did good deeds on the Earth will be successful (Quran 2:62 and Quran 5:69).
2. The sins of the prophets is a reminder to humans not to elevate the prophets instead of elevating Allaah.
Moses Musa sinned by killing a man and the messiah king David Dawud sinned by adultery (represented in the story of a man who had one female sheep in the sin of ewe, the sin involving a female) and murder (represented in the story by another man who caused to die something that did not belong to him in the sin of ewe, the sin involving a female) and the messiah king Solomon Sulaiman sinned by marriage to foreign wives who brought idol worship to Israel so that every human who comes after them can know that when you repent and correct your behaviour Allaah will forgive all your sins without a blood sacrifice in Psalm 32:5, Psalm 51:17 - 51:19 in Tanakh or Psalm 51:15 - 51:17 in a Christian Bible, 1 Kings 8:46 - 8:50, Ecclesiastes 7:20, Proverbs 24:16, Ezekiel 18:20 - 18:23, Isaiah 1:18, Isaiah 55:7, Hosea 6:6, Hosea 14:2 - 14:3 and Micah 6:6 - 6:8.
3. Those Muslims in the past who elevated Prophet Muhammad after his death and those Jews who elevated Prophet Ezra in the time of Prophet Muhammad and those Christians who elevated Prophet Jesus Isa in the time of Prophet Muhammad will have problems because they elevated prophets instead of elevating only Allaah (Quran 3:64 and Quran 4:123)..
4 Allaah protects the Torah Taurat for every Jewish generation because the Jewish people are commanded to observe the Sabbath Day forever in all their generations and information about this observance is in the Torah Taurat for every Jewish generation until the Day of Judgement.
5. Allaah protects the Gospel Injil for every Christian generation until the Day of Judgement (Quran 5:48) in the following way.
Prophet Jesus Isa did not write anything because everything Prophet Jesus Isa taught by his mouth was already written in the Tanakh Jewish scripture meaning Prophet Jesus Isa did not add or subtract from what is in Tanakh Jewish scripture.
The four Gospel Injil are four reports about Prophet Jesus Isa meaning Prophet Jesus Isa never wrote anything and what he said was passed by mouth until it was written many years later.
Quran 5:68 says observe the Torah Taurat and the Gospel Injil and Quran 5:47 tells Christians to judge by the Gospel Injil (not by the other books in the Christian New Testament Bible because what Paul teaches contradicts what Jesus is teaching in the Gospel Injil and anything about fallen angels found in the Book of Enoch and in the Book of Revelation are all rejected in Judaism because in the Hebrew Tanakh scripture angels always obey Allaah.
Jewish people do not use the Christian produced Old Testament Bible because many contain wrong translations of the Hebrew Tanakh meaning whatever in the Gospel Injil is confirmed in the Jewish Torah Taurat came from Prophet Jesus Isa and whatever contradicts the Jewish Torah Taurat came from the unknown writers who are traditionally called Mark, Matthew, Luke and John in a test from Allaah described in 1 Kings 13:14 - 13:24 teaching that the word of Allaah will not change and do not believe anyone or any verse in Mark, Matthew, Luke or John which contradicts the teachings in the Tanakh which Prophet Jesus Isa said is with the Jewish people forever and will never change and must be followed forever by the Jewish people in Gospel of Matthew 5:17 - 5:20 and Gospel of Matthew 23:1 - 23:3.
In this way a Christian can know what came from Prophet Jesus Isa confirming Tanakh and what did not come from Prophet Jesus Isa because it contradicts the Tanakh (which is the Torah law and the prophets and the writings like the Psalms) which Jesus was teaching in Gospel of Luke 24:44.
Sometimes the Gospel contradicts the Tanakh however some publishers of the Gospels have added foot notes explaining problem verses in the past therefore Christians in the present or in future can add foot notes to show verses that cannot be true such as the claim that Jesus descended from David because it contradicts the Tanakh (where a person can only inherit a tribe like David biologically through the father and not by adoption and not through the mother and not by choice) which Jesus said will never change and must be followed forever in Gospel of Matthew 5:17 - 5:20 and Gospel of Matthew 23:1 - 23:3 in a test from Allaah described in 1 Kings 13:14 - 13:24 teaching that the word of Allaah will not change and do not believe anyone or any verse in Mark, Matthew, Luke or John which contradicts the teachings in the Tanakh Jewish scripture.
6. In the same way Allaah tests Muslims with the story of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim to show who believe the Books of Allaah in the Quran and the Torah Taurat and who believes humans who contradict the Books of Allaah.
1. Library chats E7: Ismā`īl vs. Isḥāq as the sacrifice: A case study of tafsīr and scholarly influence.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CANtmlGngiw
2. Which son was to be sacrificed?
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/which-son-was-to-be-sacrificed
3. Quran chapter 37. The story of the sacrifice.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/quran-chapter-37-surah-37
4. Was Abraham commanded to sacrifice Isaac or Ishmael?
http://www.judaism-islam.com/was-abraham-commanded-to-sacrifice-isaac-or-ishmael/
A. The creator and his angel messenger. (A and L).
1. The creator of every creation (A).
Allaah 13 times in ALM Quran 2:1, Quran 3:1, Quran 29:1, Quran 30:1, Quran 31:1, Quran 32:1, ALR Quran 10:1, Quran 11:1, Quran 12:1, Quran 14:1, Quran 15:1, ALMR Quran 13:1 and ALMS Quran 7:1.
2. The Holy Spirit. The Holy Ghost (L).
Angel Gabriel Jibril 13 times in ALM Quran 2:1, Quran 3:1, Quran 29:1, Quran 30:1, Quran 31:1, Quran 32:1, ALR Quran 10:1, Quran 11:1, Quran 12:1, Quran 14:1, Quran 15:1, ALMR Quran 13:1 and ALMS Quran 7:1.
B. The books of the creator. (H, T, A' and Q).
1. Tablet sheet Lawh 7 times in HM Quran 40:1, Quran 41:1, Quran 42:1, Quran 43:1, Quran 44:1, Quran 45:1, Quran 46:1.
2. Torah Taurat 4 times in TH' Quran 20:1, TS' Quran 27:1 and TS'M Quran 26:1, Quran 28:1.
3. Gospel Injil 2 times in A'S’Q Quran 42:2 and KH’YA’S Quran 19:1.
4. Quran 2 times in Q Quran 50:1 and A'S’Q Quran 42:2.
C. Human messengers inspired by the creator. (M, Ra, S’, Ya, S, S for wisdom, H’, H’ for sister of Harun, K and N).
1. Prophet Muhammad 17 times in ALM Quran 2:1, Quran 3:1, Quran 29:1, Quran 30:1, Quran 31:1, Quran 32:1, ALMR Quran 13:1 and ALMS Quran 7:1. HM Quran 40:1, Quran 41:1, Quran 42:1, Quran 43:1, Quran 44:1, Quran 45:1, Quran 46:1 and TS'M Quran 26:1, Quran 28:1.
2. Prophet AbRaham IbRahim 6 times in ALR Quran 10:1, Quran 11:1, Quran 12:1, Quran 14:1, Quran 15:1 and ALMR Quran 13:1.
3. Prophet Moses Musa (Sinai) 5 times in TS' Quran 27:1, TS'M Quran 26:1, Quran 28:1, YS' Quran 36:1 and A'S’Q Quran 42:2.
4. Prophet Jesus Isa Yasu 2 times in YS' Quran 36:1 and KH’YA’S in Quran 19:1.
5. Prophet Solomon Sulaiman 2 times in S Quran 38:1 and ALMS Quran 7:1.
6. Prophet John Yahya wisdom (Solomon) 1 time in KH’YA’S Quran 19:1.
7. Prophet Aaron Harun 1 time in TH' Quran 20:1.
8. Virgin Mary Maryam sister (Harun) 1 time in KH’YA’S Quran 19:1.
9. Prophet Zakaria Zachariah Zakariya 1 time in KH’YA’S Quran 19:1.
10. Prophet Jonah Yunus 1 time in N Quran 68:1.
The meaning of the mysterious letters in the Quran confirm the central teaching in the Quran.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/mysterious-letters-in-the-quran
12. The claim that there are abrogated verses in the Quran contradicts the Quran.
The Quran does not contain abrogated verses.
Sometimes the word of Allaah in His Books can be confused by the words of humans.
For example in the Gospel Injil Prophet Jesus Isa prayed to Allaah but some humans said Jesus Isa is Allaah and other humans believed Jesus Isa is Allaah meaning they followed the words of humans and not the words in the Gospel Injil.
The same thing can happen in Islam.
There are no contradictions in the Quran means whatever contradicts the Quran did not come from Allaah or from Prophet Muhammad.
Quran 4:82 says there are no contradictions in the Quran as proof the Quran is from Allaah meaning there are no abrogated verses in the Quran because nothing in the Quran is a contradiction.
A verse in the Quran is claimed to be abrogated when it contradicts another verse in the Quran.
There are no abrogated verses in the Quran.
1. In the Quran all verses are in harmony and they do not cancel each other.
2. No verse in the Quran cancels another verse instead each verse is implemented in the past or the present or the future according to its appropriate situation.
3. No verse in the Quran was completely abolished by another verse in the Quran instead each verse in the Quran has a specific context and applicability.
4. No verse in the Quran was completely abolished by another verse in the Quran because they all exist to provide greater understanding.
5. One verse does not cancel another verse because both verses explain each other.
6. No verse is abrogated in the Quran because every verse in the Quran has its place and its time in the past or present or future depending on the situation and the conditions.
Quran 2:106 Koran 2:106 (Allaah says in 1 Samuel 15:29 Allaah does not change His mind promises covenants agreements because only humans change their mind promises covenants agreements so the Jews asked Prophet Muhammad about the Torah and the Quran. Allaah reveals) We (Allaah) do not abolish a verse (in the Torah for the Jewish people) or let it be forgotten (by the Jewish people until the Day of Judgement as Allaah promised in Quran 2:40 - 2:41, Quran 2:62, Quran 3:113 - 3:115, Quran 5:69, Exodus 2:24, Leviticus 26:4 - 26:45, Deuteronomy 4:2, Deuteronomy 4:31, Deuteronomy 5:10, Deuteronomy 7:7 - 7:8, Deuteronomy 12:1, Deuteronomy 29:28 in Jewish Tanakh or Deuteronomy 29:29 in a Christian Bible, 2 King 13:23, Psalm 19:8 - 19:12 in Jewish Tanakh or Psalm 19:7 - 19:11 in Christian Old Testament Bible, Psalm 111:7 - 111:9, Hosea 3:4 - 3:5, Daniel 12:2, Isaiah 59:21 is the promise to the Jewish people mentioned in Isaiah 36:11 and Isaiah 36:13 and Gospel of Matthew 5:17 - 5:20). We (Allaah) bring (to the Muslims in the Quran) something better than it or similar to it (confirming the Torah which is in the hands of the Jewish people until the Day of Judgement in Quran 2:40 - 2:41 and explaining the story of Jesus which is in the four reports that are in the hands of the Christian people until the Day of Judgement in Quran 5:46 - 5:47 and Allaah told the Jewish people to observe the Torah Taurat and told the Christians to observe the Gospel Injil in Quran 5:68. Allaah reminded the Jewish people in the Quran to observe the Sabbath and confirmed Prophet Ezra is a human servant of Allaah like every human is a willing or unwilling servant of Allaah. Allaah reminded the Christian people in the Quran that Prophet Jesus is a human servant of Allaah like every human is a willing or unwilling servant of Allaah). Do you not know that Allaah is capable of everything? (including protecting the Jewish Scriptures that are with the Jewish people until the Day of Judgement as shown in the story of the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran chapter 37 where Allaah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq and leaves no other blessings in the story of the sacrifice and this famous vision dream is remembered in the next chapter Quran chapter 38 where Allaah blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq with the vision dream in Quran 38:45 – 38:47 and shows in the next verse that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not the son in the vision dream and Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not living with his father during the vision dream by blessing Prophet Ishmael Ismail without his father and without the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:48. This is confirmed in Quran 12:6 and in Torah Genesis 22:2 “And Allaah said: Take now your son, your only son” who still lives with you, reminding him that Allaah had earlier taken Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar away from him into Allaah’s care in the desert, “whom you love” Allaah makes the test very hard by demanding his second son and reminding him that this is his only remaining son and reminding him that he already gave Allaah one son and reminding him of his love for these sons, “even” namely, that is “Isaac Ishaq and go into the land of Moriah” today in the Temple and Al-Aqsa mosque area in Jerusalem Al-Quds in Israel and Palestine; “and offer him there for a burnt-offering on one of the mountains which I Allaah will tell you of.” The proof Allaah is real is the Quran confirming the Torah Taurat is correct in Quran 2:41 “And believe in what I Allaah have revealed” in the Quran “that confirms what you already have” in the Torah Taurat and in Quran 3:93 “… Bring the Torah Taurat here and recite it as evidence if what you say is true" and in Quran 5:43 “How is it that they come to you for judgment when they have the Torah Taurat in which Allaah has already revealed to them judgment …” and Quran 5:68 “… You the Jewish people have nothing until you observe the Torah Taurat …” as explained here https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kQ3o3ybc-KA
so hold tightly to what Allaah is teaching in the Quran and beware of stories which contradict the Books of Allaah. Allaah explains the story of Jesus which is in the hands of the Christian people by explaining in the Quran what the human eye could not see without adding anything to the story in the Gospel of what the human eye saw in the story of Prophet Jesus Isa in Quran 3:144 see Quran 5:75, Quran 4:157, Quran 4:158 see Quran 39:42, Quran 5:75 see Quran 3:144, Quran 5:117 see Quran 7:6, Quran 7:6 see Quran 5:117, Quran 21:95 see Quran 23:99 – 23:100, Quran 33:40 see Gospel of Jesus Isa by Mark 13:5 – 13:6, 13:21 – 13:22 and Quran 39:42 see Quran 4:158. In Quran 3:144 and Quran 5:75 see “passed away” in the Quran always means died see in Quran 2:134 and Quran 2:141 and Quran 7:38 and Quran 13:30 and Quran 41:25 and Quran 46:17. The Quran gives humans freedom to find their religion).
Note 1. In Quran 2:106 Allaah says the Quran is similar to what is with the Jewish people or better and this is explained in Quran 13:39 where Allaah does not include in the Quran some laws that are binding only on the Jewish people.
Quran 13:39 Koran 13:39 Allaah eliminates (from the Quran the laws which are only binding on the Jewish people such as the Sabbath Day) and confirms what He (Allaah) wills (in the Quran which confirms the Torah which is in the hands of the Jewish people until the Day of Judgement in Quran 2:40 - 2:41 and explaining the story of Jesus which is in the four reports that are in the hands of the Christian people until the Day of Judgement in Quran 5:46 - 5:47 and Allaah told the Jewish people to observe the Torah Taurat and told the Christians to observe the Gospel Injil in Quran 5:68. Allaah reminded the Jewish people in the Quran to observe the Sabbath and confirmed Prophet Ezra is a human servant of Allaah like every human is a willing or unwilling servant of Allaah. Allaah reminded the Christian people in the Quran that Prophet Jesus is a human servant of Allaah like every human is a willing or unwilling servant of Allaah) and with Him (Allaah) is the Mother of the Book (the Preserved Tablet, Al-Lauh al-Mahfuz which contains the basis of each Scripture as Allaah intended in the Torah Taurat for the Jews and the four reports about Jesus Isa in the Gospel of Jesus Isa by Mark, Matthew, Luke and John which are with the Christians and the Quran which is with the Muslims as explained in Quran 2:106, Quran 5:48 and Quran 7:170).
Note 1. In Quran 2:106 Allaah says the Quran is similar to what is with the Jewish people or better and this is explained in Quran 13:39 where Allaah does not include in the Quran some laws that are binding only on the Jewish people.
Quran 4:82 Koran 4:82 Do they not think about the Quran (and where it came from)? Had it (the Quran) been (revealed) from someone other than Allaah surely they would have found in it (the Quran) much contradiction (within it and between it and the Torah Taurat and the Gospel Injil. The Quran confirms the Tanakh Jewish Scripture is correct and the Quran explains the story of Jesus in the Gospel Injil of Jesus Isa by Mark, Matthew, Luke and John).
Quran 25:32 Koran 25:32 And those who disbelieve (the stone idol worshippers in Makkah) say, “Why is the Quran not revealed to him (Prophet Muhammad) all at once?” (It is revealed) so that We (Allaah) may strengthen your heart (strengthen your belief) with it and We (Allaah) have recited it (part by part in the correct order of revelation, revealed as it was decreed to be revealed).
Quran 16:101 Koran 16:101 And when We (Allaah) replace one verse (in the Quran) by another verse (meaning reveal verse after verse in the Quran about similar matters, these verses do not abrogate each other but together they add more details and understanding) and Allaah knows best what He (Allaah) should reveal, they (the stone idol worshippers in Makkah) say, “You (Prophet Muhammad) are an inventor (of the Quran and of verses because Allaah would have revealed His command in one verse on one day because Allaah needs no time to think instead of several verses on different days which a human would do because a human needs time to think).” But most of them (the stone idol worshippers of Makkah Arabia) do not understand (the way Allaah reveals His verses which is explained in Quran 16:102).
Note 1. Quran 16:101 - Quran 16:103 is addressing the accusations of the stone idol worshippers in Makkah who are claiming the Quran is invented by Prophet Muhammad and that another man is helping him.
The Quran was revealed verse after verse in public recitations and some verses are very similar with some small differences and to the ear of the stone idol worshippers sounded like one verse (heard on one day) replacing another verse (heard on another day).
For example
Quran 6:51 Koran 6:51 “… there is no protecting ally or intercessor except for Him (Allaah) …”
Quran 20:109 Koran 20:109 “… there shall be no intercession except by him to whom the Most Merciful (Allaah) has given permission and whose word He (Allaah) has permitted (to be spoken).
Note 1. In this example the words spoken will be the words Allaah has put into the mouth of a person or an angel meaning it does not contradict with what is reveled in Quran 6:51 which says all intercession comes from Allaah.
Quran 16:102 Koran 16:102 Say (Prophet Muhammad, to the people), “The Holy Spirit (Ruh Al-Qudus, Angel Gabriel Jibril) has descended it (meaning brought down from heaven the revelations in the Quran) from your Lord (Allaah) with the truth, in order to strengthen (the faith of) those who believe and as a guidance and Good News to the Muslims (Muslim is an Arabic word meaning those who submit, to the will of Allaah. Islam is an Arabic word meaning submission, to the will of Allaah. Muslims submit to Allaah in Quran 47:19 “…there is no Allaah except Allaah …” and Jews submit to Allaah in Torah Exodus 20:2 “.... You shall have no other gods before Me Allaah” and Christians submit to Allaah in the Gospel of Jesus Isa by Luke 4:8 “… You shall worship the Lord your Allaah, and him only shall you serve” because Allaah inspired the same belief in the one creator of every creation among many communities of Allaah throughout history as explained in Quran 5:48 where Allaah said He could have made humans to be one community of Allaah but made more than one community of Allaah and gave laws to each community of Allaah and told them to strive for all that is good so that Allaah can show who are the best in behaviour within and between the different communities of Allaah such as the Jews and Christians and Muslims and others).
Quran 16:124 Koran 16:124 The Sabbath (Day) was only decreed for those (children of Israel , the Hebrew people, the Jewish people) who differed in (observing) it (in Quran 2:65-2:66, Quran 5:60, Quran 7:163-7:166 meaning the Sabbath Day was decreed for the Jewish people of whom some obeyed and some did not obey). Your Lord (Allaah) shall judge between them (the Jewish people) on the Day of Resurrection in what they used to differ in (observing the Sabbath Day which the Jewish people are commanded in the Ten Commandments of Allaah in Deuteronomy 5:12, to observe the Sabbath Day forever in Exodus 31:13, by observing the Sabbath Day in every generation in Exodus 31:16, to observe the Sabbath Day as a sign forever between Allaah and the children of Israel in Exodus 31:17 in the Torah covenant in Deuteronomy 31:9, Deuteronomy 4:13, Deuteronomy 28:69, Deuteronomy 4:31, Deuteronomy 7:9-7:12 commanding that no one shall add or subtract from the Torah in Deuteronomy 4:2 and Deuteronomy 13:1 in Jewish Tanakh or Deuteronomy 12:32 in a Christian Bible and forever in Deuteronomy 5:10, Deuteronomy 29:28 in Jewish Tanakh or Deuteronomy 29:29 in a Christian Bible, Psalm 111:9, Isaiah 59:21 is the promise to the Jewish people who are mentioned in Isaiah 36:11, Isaiah 36:13, Gospel of Matthew 5:17-5:20 and Quran 2:40-2:41).
.
Note 1. Jews who observe the Sabbath Day are submitting to Allaah.
Note 2. Jews who follow the Torah Taurat are following the message delivered to them by Prophet Muhammad and every prophet after Prophet Moses Musa reminding the Jewish people to follow the Torah Taurat forever because it is the covenant agreement between Allaah and the Jewish people.
Note 3. The Jewish people will be judged concerning their observance of the Sabbath Day which is an everlasting covenant agreement between Allaah and the Jewish people in Quran 2:40-2:41.
Note 4. Quran 16:124 is confirmed in Quran 2:106 where Allaah has not abolished anything in the Torah for the Jewish people meaning the Jewish people must follow the Torah as the Torah has commanded it must be followed forever.
Note 5. Quran 16:124 is confirmed in Quran 13:39 where Allaah eliminates from the Quran the laws which are only binding on the Jewish people such as the Sabbath Day.
Quran 5:48 Koran 5:48 “… We (Allaah) have appointed a divine law and a way (of religion). If Allaah willed He (Allaah) could have made you (the Jews, the Christians and the Muslims) one community. But He (Allaah) tests you (the Jews, the Christians and the Muslims) by what He (Allaah) has given you (in the Torah Taurat and the Gospel Injil and the Koran Quran to show who is best in behaviour). So strive for all that is good. To Allaah you shall all return and He (Allaah) shall then inform you (in the Hereafter) about (the correctness of) the religious matters in which you (the Jews, the Christians and the Muslims) argue among each other.
For example the verses about drinking alcohol in Islam are not abrogated.
1. Verses about alcohol in the Quran are not abrogated.
Quran 2:219 reveals that there are some benefits in alcohol and today alcohol is widely used in medicines and these benefits are not prohibited to the Muslim..
Verses in the Quran which allow alcohol allow it today when alcohol is a benefit like in medicines today.
Many medicines contain alcohol in solutions that are drunk and they are also in tablets that are swallowed and Muslims are not forbidden from those benefits meaning the drinking of alcohol is not forbidden when it is for medical reasons.
Verses in the Quran that do not allow alcohol is when the drinking of alcohol does more harm that good as seen in road deaths caused by drink driving accidents today.
2. Abstaining from alcoholic drink is an appeal to common sense.
In early revelations of the Quran is guidance and reasons against drinking alcohol and the final revelation says in Quran 5:90 – 5:91 for these reasons you should not drink alcohol.
See Quran 2:219, Quran 4:43 and Quran 5:90 – 5:91.
3. In Quran 5:48 Allaah explained that He gave different laws to the different communities of Allaah meaning alcohol is not forbidden to Jews in the Torah Taurat or to Christians in the Gospel Injil.
Alcohol is only forbidden to Muslims in the Quran in the same way as only the Jews are commanded to observe the Sabbath Day.
Muslims do not observe the Sabbath Day.
What is forbidden to Jews and Christians and Muslims is contained in their Books and only applies to them and not to the other communities of Allaah.
Quran 2:219 Koran 2:219 They (the people with faith in Allaah) ask you (Prophet Muhammad, what to do) concerning the drinking of alcohol and gambling? Say, "In them (alcohol and gambling) is great sin and some profit for humans but the sin is greater than the profit." (It is better for you not to drink alcohol and not to gamble because alcohol and gambling give more disadvantage than benefit in the hereafter). …”
Quran 4:43 Koran 4:43 All you who believe, do not go to prayers when you are drunk (from alcoholic drink) until you know (the meaning) of what you are saying,
Quran 5:90 Koran 5:90 All you who have faith (in Allaah), alcoholic drink, games of chance (games based on luck), idols and divining arrows (for decision making) lead to the evil work of Satan Shaitan, therefore stay away from them so that you may succeed (in the hereafter).
Quran 5:91 Koran 5:91 Satan (Shaitan) wants to bring to you hostility and hatred though alcoholic drink and games of chance and to make you forget Allaah and forget to worship Him (Allaah). Is it then not correct for you to abstain (from doing those things)?
Abrogated verses in the Quran contradicts the Quran.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/abrogation-in-the-quran
13. The September 11 attacks and Islam show how people are inventing stories today which contradict the Quran.
1. The danger of believing you have 100% proof of truth (for example the many claims on the internet that Muslims were not involved in the 911 attacks) is that you can believe a false story.
For example some Christians are blind to anything in the Gospel Injil of Jesus Isa by Mark, Matthew, Luke and John that show Jesus Isa is not Allaah.
In the same way some Muslims are blind to anything in the Quran that show Jesus Isa died a natural death 2000 years ago in Quran 3:144 and Quran 5:75 and Quran 5:117.
2. Today some people including some Muslims believe humans have not walked on the moon.
3. Today people are inventing false stories about Prophet Muhammad adding to the many other false stories that were invented after the death of Prophet Muhammad for example there is no evidence that the name of Prophet Muhammad is on the Moon as is claimed today on the Internet.
4. Quran 21:30 is not about the big bang theory as is claimed today.
Protect Islam by rejecting invented false stories.
Do not turn the Quran into a book of science.
The meaning of “one entity and then we separated them” in Quran 21:30 is explained in the Quran and confirmed by the Torah Taurat and in hadith stories.
Quran 21:30 Koran 21:30 Do those who disbelieve not know that the heavens and the earth were one entity (called “smoke” in Quran 41:11 and called the “formless empty” entity in Torah Genesis 1:2), then We (Allaah) separated them (in Torah Genesis 1:6 – 1:8 dividing by separating the earth from the heavens with the firmament meaning the sky and in Quran 41:11 by raising the sky above the earth to separate the earth and the lowest heaven so that water can fall on the Earth and bring life as confirmed in the interpretation Tafsir of Ibn Kathir where Ibn Abi Hatim recorded that Ibn Umar sent a man who asked the meaning of this verse to Ibn `Abbas and confirmed in Quran 21:32 Allaah has made the sky to be like a protected roof over the earth like a dome to separate the heavens from the earth. In Quran 17:92, Quran 22:65, Quran 26:187 and Quran 52:44 the sky is held up by Allaah to prevent it from falling down and to separate the heavens from the earth and in Quran 31:10 Allaah made the heavens meaning the sky to be like a high roof without supports that you can see to separate the heavens from the earth and in Quran 52:5 the sky is like a roof that has been raised high up above you to separate the heavens from the earth and in Quran 79:27 – 79:28 Allaah is the one who raised the sky up high above you to separate the heavens from the earth), and We (Allaah) made every living thing from water (in Quran 24:45. The authority of Allaah was over water in Torah Genesis 1:2 and Quran 11:7 meaning life would be created from water by the permission of Allaah in Quran 21:30, Quran 24:45, Torah Leviticus 26:4 and Zabur Psalm 147:8)
.
5. Quran 51:47 is not about the expansion of the Universe as is claimed today.
.
Quran 51:47 Koran 51:47 And the heavens (the sky) We (Allaah) have constructed it with (Our) power (in Quran 21:32 Allaah has made the sky to be like a protected roof over the earth like a dome. In Quran 17:92, Quran 22:65, Quran 26:187 and Quran 52:44 the sky is held up by Allaah to prevent it from falling down and in Quran 31:10 Allaah made the heavens meaning the sky to be like a high roof without supports that you can see and in Quran 52:5 the sky is like a roof that has been raised high up above you and in Quran 79:27–79:28 Allaah is the one who raised the sky up high above you) and We (Allaah) are its expanders (meaning “We are its spreaders” in the Jewish Tanakh Job 9:8, meaning “We stretched out the heavens” in the Jewish Tanakh Isaiah 40:22, Isaiah 42:5, Isaiah 44:24, Isaiah 45:12 and Zechariah 12:1 meaning “We spread out the heavens” in the Jewish Tanakh Isaiah 48:13 and “We spread out the earth” in Quran 91:6, meaning Allaah is the one who created what you can see from one horizon to another horizon meaning Allaah is the one who spread out the heavens from one horizon to another horizon meaning the stars and the Moon and the Sun and the planets across the blue sky in the day and the black sky at night which you can see above the earth from one horizon to another horizon meaning Allaah is the expander of the sky that you see above you from one horizon to another horizon in the same way as Allaah spread out the land across the earth from one horizon to another horizon meaning Allaah is the expander of the land that you see from horizon to horizon meaning Allaah is the one who created everything that you can see in the sky which is like a protected dome around the earth meaning Allaah made the atmosphere in which you can see the heavens spread out across the sky meaning Allaah is the expander or spreader of everything you see across the sky).
6. The Tanakh Jewish scripture confirms the Quran.
Expanders means spreaders.
Job 9:8 Who by himself spread out the heavens (the sky from horizon to horizon) and rules (has power over) the waves of the sea?”
Psalm 19:2 The heavens (the sky) declare the glory of Allaah, the ceiling of heaven (the sky) reveals his (Allaah’s) handiwork.”
Psalm 102:26 In times of old you (Allaah) lay the foundation of the earth; and the heavens (the sky) are the work of your (Allaah’s) hands.
Psalm 104:2 “… (It is Allaah) who stretches out the heavens like a curtain.
Isaiah 40:22 It is He (Allaah) that sits above the circle of the earth, and the inhabitants there (on the Earth) are like grasshoppers; (It is Allaah) that stretches out the heavens like a curtain (in the sky), and spreads them out (the heavens) like a tent to dwell in (is spread out);
Isaiah 45:12 I (Allaah) have made the earth, and created man upon it; My (Allaah’s) hands, have stretched out the heavens (the sky from horizon to horizon), and all their host (creatures) have I (Allaah) commanded.
Isaiah 48:13 My (Allaah’s) hand has laid the foundation of the earth, and My right hand has spread out the heavens (the sky from horizon to horizon); when I (Allaah) call to them (everything in the heavens and the earth), they stand up together (by obeying what I Allaah have decreed).
Zechariah 12:1 A prophecy: The word of the LORD concerning Israel says the LORD, who stretched out the heavens (the expander of the heavens from one horizon to the other horizon) and laid the foundation of the earth and formed the spirit of man within him:
7. Beware of claims that the Quran is confirming the Books of Science.
The Quran says many times that it is confirming what came before it in the Torah Taurat which is with the Jewish people and what is in the Gospel Injil which is with the Christian people and will never change and not what will come after it in the Books of Science which always change in every generation.
The September 11 attacks and Islam show how people are inventing stories today which contradict the Quran.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/9-11-attack-and-islam
14. Temporary pleasure marriage contradicts the Quran,
Quran 4:24 Koran 4:24 – And all married women are forbidden to you (to marry) except those (married women) whom your right hands possess (as decreed by Allaah in Quran 60:10). Allaah has ruled this for you. All others (not on the forbidden marriage list in Quran 4:23 and Quran 4:24) that you seek with your wealth are lawful (to marry). (Marry a person) desiring to be chaste and not lustful (meaning they do not work in prostitution see Quran 24:3). You benefit of it (marriage with such women) so give them (the women) their bridal due (dowry, mahr, mehr, meher, mahrieh given by the husband to his wife at the time of marriage) as an obligation (on the husband). And there is no sin on you concerning what you both agree of it from beyond the obligation (by decreasing or increasing the bridal gift). Allaah is all knowing and all wise.
Quran 24:3 Koran 24:3 (When the Muslims arrived in Yathrib one person asked if he could marry a girl who worked as a prostitute and the following was revealed) a fornicator (a male working in prostitution) will not marry anyone except a fornicatress (a female working in prostitution) or a polytheist woman (a women who believes in more than one god). And a fornicatress (a female working in prostitution) will not marry anyone except a fornicator (a male working in prostitution) or a polytheist man (a man who believes in more than one god). That (marriage to people working in prostitution or to people who believe in more than one god) is forbidden to the believers (meaning do not seek marriage with people in Yathrib who are working in the business of prostitution).
Quran 60:10 Koran 60:10 All you who believe (in Allaah), When (believing women who married stone idol worshippers before the time of Islam or when women who were stone idol worshippers claim to be) believing women come to you as refugees (who are fleeing from a husband who worships stone idols, those women are in your right hand meaning in your control), examine (test) them (women for their faith) although it is Allaah who best knows their faith. If you determine that they are believers (in Allaah) then do not send them back to the disbelievers (the stone idol worshippers) because they (the believing women) are not lawful (wives) for the disbelievers (the stone idol worshippers) nor are the disbelievers (the stone idol worshippers) lawful (husbands) for them (women who believe in Allaah). But give them (the stone idol worshiping husband) what they (the stone idol worshiping husband) had spent (when he gave his marriage gift, dowry, mahr, mehr, meher, mahrieh so as to compensate) them (the stone idol worshiping husband by returning his marriage gift Mahr). And there shall be no sin on you to marry them (believing women who have fled from a stone idol worshiping husband) if you have given them (the believing women) their marriage gift (dowry, mahr, mehr, meher, mahrieh after she has accepted your marriage proposal from her own free will). Do not hold on to disbelieving (stone idol worshiping) women as wives and ask for (the return of) what you spent (in your marriage gift, dowry, mahr, mehr, meher, mahrieh) to them (the stone idol worshiping wife) and let them (the disbelievers who worship stone idols also) ask back for what they spent (in their marriage gift, dowry, mahr, mehr, meher, mahrieh for their women who have come to you). That is the Judgement of Allaah. He (Allaah) judges (with justice) between you (the believers and the disbelievers). Allaah knows all and is wise.
Quran 4:25 Koran 4:25 “… The (slave girl) should be chaste (and not) commit unlawful intercourse randomly (prostitution) nor have secret lovers. …”
Quran 17:32 Koran 17:32 And do not come near to (situations that would lead to) unlawful sexual intercourse; certainly it is an immoral and an evil way (of life).
Quran 23:5 Koran 23:5 And (righteous are those) who guard their private parts (from being seen by other people) –
Quran 23:6 Koran 23:6 – Except from their wives (or husband) or the (servants) that their right hands possess (meaning, the servants which they legally own. For example a person who is unable to look after them self such as the elderly, the disabled and the sick can be bathed and dressed by a servant), then it is not a sin,
Quran 24:33 Koran 24:33 And let those who cannot find a match (for marriage) keep chaste (by staying away from sexual relations) …”
Quran 24:33 Koran 24:33 “… Do not force your slave-girls to prostitution when they desire chastity in order that you may seek the (temporary) enjoyment of the life of the world. …”
Quran 24:33 Koran 24:33 “… And if anyone forces them (to prostitution), then Allaah shall be forgiving and merciful (to the slave girl because she was forced to do evil against her will and to slave owners who did such things in the time of ignorance before accepting Islam).
Temporary pleasure marriage contradicts the Quran,
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/pleasure-marriage-in-islam
14A. Sex with slaves contradicts the Quran.
A. Sex without marriage is forbidden.
1. Allaah said marry a free woman or a slave girl.
Quran 4:3 Koran 4:3 And if you fear that you shall not be able to deal justly by (marriage to) orphan (girls because you fear that you shall not offer them their full bridal money or for fear that you shall unfairly take their wealth because they are an orphan in your care), then marry (other) women of your choice, two or three or four but if you fear that you shall not be able to deal justly (by providing their full bridal money and support) then only (marry) one (free woman) or (marry a girl slave) that your right hand possess (meaning whom you own), these ways are most likely to prevent you from doing injustice (to any woman).
2. Allaah said do not seek a wife for doing shameful behaviour such as using your wife to make money for you through the forbidden business of prostitution.
Quran 4:24 Koran 4:24 – And all married women are forbidden to you (to marry) except those (married women) whom your right hands possess (as decreed by Allaah in Quran 60:10). Allaah has ruled this for you. All others (not on the forbidden marriage list in Quran 4:23 and Quran 4:24) are lawful (to marry) provided you seek (them in honest marriage) with bridal money (dowry, mahr, mehr, meher, mahrieh given by the husband to his wife at the time of marriage) from your property and you do not seek them for doing shameful behaviour (such as using your wife to make money for you through the forbidden business of prostitution). Those of whom you seek to marry give them their bridal money (dowry, mahr, mehr, meher, mahrieh) as promised. If after the bridal money is prescribed you both freely agree (to change the bridal money conditions by waiver, decreasing or increasing it) then there is no sin on you. Allaah is all knowing and all wise.
Note 1. Quran 60:10 Koran 60:10 All you who believe (in Allaah), When (believing women who married stone idol worshippers before the time of Islam or when women who were stone idol worshippers claim to be) believing women come to you as refugees (who are fleeing from a husband who worships stone idols, those women are in your right hand meaning in your control), examine (test) them (women for their faith) although it is Allaah who best knows their faith. If you determine that they are believers (in Allaah) then do not send them back to the disbelievers (the stone idol worshippers) because they (the believing women) are not lawful (wives) for the disbelievers (the stone idol worshippers) nor are the disbelievers (the stone idol worshippers) lawful (husbands) for them (women who believe in Allaah). But give them (the stone idol worshiping husband) what they (the stone idol worshiping husband) had spent (when he gave his marriage gift, dowry, mahr, mehr, meher, mahrieh so as to compensate) them (the stone idol worshiping husband by returning his marriage gift Mahr). And there shall be no sin on you to marry them (believing women who have fled from a stone idol worshiping husband) if you have given them (the believing women) their marriage gift (dowry, mahr, mehr, meher, mahrieh after she has accepted your marriage proposal from her own free will). … He (Allaah) judges (with justice) between you (the believers and the disbelievers). Allaah knows all and is wise.
3. Allaah said a slave girl should be chaste and not commit prostitution nor have secret lovers.
Quran 4:25 Koran 4:25 “… The (slave girl) should be chaste (and not) commit unlawful intercourse randomly (prostitution) nor have secret lovers. …”
4. Allaah said do not come near to situations that would lead to unlawful sexual intercourse because it is an immoral and an evil way of life.
Quran 17:32 Koran 17:32 And do not come near to (situations that would lead to) unlawful sexual intercourse; certainly it is an immoral and an evil way (of life).
5. Allaah said be proper and righteous in your private behaviour.
Quran 23:5 Koran 23:5 And (righteous are those) who guard their private parts (from being seen by other people) –
Quran 23:6 Koran 23:6 – Except from their wives (or husband) or the (servants) that their right hands possess (meaning, the servants which they legally own. For example a person who is unable to look after them self such as the elderly, the disabled and the sick can be bathed and dressed by a servant), then it is not a sin,
Note 1. See Quran 70:29 below.
6. Allaah said let those who cannot find a match for marriage keep chaste by staying away from sexual relations and do not force your slave-girls into prostitution.
Quran 24:33 Koran 24:33 And let those who cannot find a match (for marriage) keep chaste (by staying away from sexual relations) …”
Quran 24:33 Koran 24:33 “… And those of your slaves who request a contract (for eventual freedom from their slavery, emancipation from slavery), make a contract with them (so they can purchase their freedom from their owner) if you know there is some goodness in them and give to them something from the wealth of Allaah which He (Allaah) has given to you. …”
Quran 24:33 Koran 24:33 “… Do not force your slave-girls to prostitution when they desire chastity in order that you may seek the (temporary) enjoyment of the life of the world. …”
Quran 24:33 Koran 24:33 “… And if anyone forces them (to prostitution), then Allaah shall be forgiving and merciful (to the slave girl because she was forced to do evil against her will and to slave owners who did such things in the time of ignorance before accepting Islam).
7. Allaah said release the wives who disbelieve in Allaah.
Quran 60:10 Koran 60:10 All you who believe (in Allaah), … Do not hold on to disbelieving (stone idol worshiping) women as wives and ask for (the return of) what you spent (in your marriage gift, dowry, mahr, mehr, meher, mahrieh) to them (the stone idol worshiping wife) and let them (the disbelievers who worship stone idols also) ask back for what they spent (in their marriage gift, dowry, mahr, mehr, meher, mahrieh for their women who have come to you). That is the Judgement of Allaah. He (Allaah) judges (with justice) between you (the believers and the disbelievers). Allaah knows all and is wise.
8. Allaah said be proper and righteous in your private behaviour.
Quran 70:29 Koran 70:29 And those (the righteous) who guard their private parts (from being seen by other people) -
Quran 70:30 Koran 70:30 Except with their wives and those who are legally theirs (meaning, their children and their servants which they legally own. For example a person who is unable to look after them self such as the elderly, the disabled and the sick can be bathed and dressed by a servant or by their children), then it is not a sin.
B. A slave has freedom to accept or reject marriage.
Allaah said you and your slave are equal as far as religion is concerned meaning no one can force a slave girl to marry against her will because Allaah gives each human the freedom to accept or reject marriage.
Quran 4:25 Koran 4:25 And if you do not have the means (not wealthy enough) to marry free believing women then you may marry believing girls from among those (slave girls) whom your right hands possess (meaning whom you own). Allaah has full knowledge about your faith and you (and your slave girl) are equal to one another as far as religion is concerned (meaning no one can force a slave girl to marry against her will because Islam gives each human the freedom to accept or reject marriage). You shall obtain permission from their guardians before you marry them and give them (the girl) their bridal money according to what is reasonable. The (slave girl) should be chaste (and not) commit unlawful intercourse randomly (prostitution) nor have secret lovers. After marriage if she commits illegal sexual intercourse (fahishah, illegal sexual intercourse after marriage, adultery) then her punishment is half of that of a free (married) women (meaning a punishment of fifty lashes). This (rule from Allaah) is for those who are afraid of committing sin (afraid they might commit illegal sexual intercourse if they do not marry someone) but it is better for you to be patient (because it is possible that a slave girl has agreed to marriage only because of her weak position as a slave and this is why Allaah has shown mercy by halving her punishment if the slave girl commits adultery). Allaah is always ready to forgive and most merciful (to those who sincerely repent for their sins).
C. A slave has freedom to accept or reject Islam.
1. Allaah said there is no compulsion in religion meaning religion must come voluntarily from the human heart and not from the fear of humans or by force.
Quran 2:256 Koran 2:256 There is no compulsion in religion (meaning, religion must come voluntarily from the human heart and not from the fear of humans or by force). …”
2. Allaah said Allaah decrees who shall believe in Allaah and when they shall believe in Allaah or disbelieve in Allaah.
Quran 10:99 Koran 10:99 And if your Lord (Allaah) had willed then all who are on the earth would have all believed together. (Allaah asks humans), “Would you force people (against their will) to believe (in Allaah when it is Allaah who decrees who will believe and who will disbelieve)? (The answer is no, Islam does not force belief in Allaah because -).”
Quran 10:100 Koran 10:100 It is not for any soul to believe except by the permission of Allaah and He (Allaah) will place the anger (of Allaah in the hereafter) on those who do not use reason (to follow good behaviour).
3. Allaah said respect the right of each human to follow their belief.
Quran 109:4 Koran 109:4 “And I shall not worship what you worship (that are stone idols).”
Quran 109:5 Koran 109:5 “Nor shall you worship what I worship (that is Allaah).”
Quran 109:6 Koran 109:6 “For you is your way (of religion, of belief) and for me is my way (of religion, of belief).”
D. Slaves should be freed.
1. Allaah has imposed a duty on Muslims to use their wealth to free a slave.
Quran 2:177 Koran 2:177 “… righteousness is this, that you … give away (your) wealth out of love for Him (Allaah) … and in freeing the necks (slaves) …”
2. Allaah has decreed that marriage is one path to freedom from slavery.
Quran 4:25 Koran 4:25 And if you do not have the means (not wealthy enough) to marry free believing women then you may marry believing girls from among those (slave girls) whom your right hands possess (meaning whom you own). Allaah has full knowledge about your faith and you (and your slave girl) are equal to one another as far as religion is concerned (meaning no one can force a slave girl to marry against her will because Islam gives each human the freedom to accept or reject marriage). You shall obtain permission from their guardians before you marry them and give them (the girl) their bridal money according to what is reasonable. ..."
3. Allaah has decreed that sin is forgiven by the freeing of a slave.
Quran 4:92 Koran 4:92 A person with faith in Allaah must not kill another person that also has faith in Allaah except by mistake. Whoever kills a person with faith in Allaah by mistake, (Allaah has ordered that) he must free a slave that has faith in Allaah and pay compensation (blood money) to the dead person’s family, unless (that family) do not want any compensation. If the dead person belonged to a people at war with you and he had faith in Allaah then (Allaah has ordered that) you free a slave that has faith in Allaah. (If the dead person belonged to a people) with whom you have a treaty of mutual alliance then (Allaah has ordered that) you pay to his family compensation (blood money) and you must also free a slave that has faith in Allaah. Whoever finds that the (repentance done by the freeing of a slave) is beyond their means then they must fast for two consecutive months so as to seek repentance from Allaah. Allaah is all knowing and all wise.
4. Allaah has decreed that sin is forgiven by the freeing of a slave.
Quran 5:89 Koran 5:89 Allaah shall not hold you responsible for what is unintentional in your oaths (such as when you become angry and swear in the name of Allaah to do something that you later realize you did not intend, or swear in the name of Allaah during conversation something unintentional during “a slip of speech” when you say something that you did not intend to say, or if you swear in the name of Allaah to do something that later you realize is illegal or the cancelling of oaths made in the name of Allaah when you forbid your self from doing something that Allaah has not forbidden) but He (Allaah) shall hold you responsible for oaths that you sincerely intended. To repent (to Allaah, for breaking an oath that you intentionally gave and that you intended to sincerely fulfill first ask forgiveness from Allaah and then) feed ten needy people with food equal to that which you feed your own people, or cloth them, or free a slave, but for the person for which these are not possible the person should fast for three days (by not eating or drinking during daylight). This is to make amends for your oaths that you have sincerely sworn (in the name of Allaah). But (in future) be careful to fulfill your oaths (that are made intentionally of your free will). Allaah accepts your repentance according to these revelations so that you may give thanks (to Allaah for his mercy).
5. The use of funds collected for charity to free a slave is a duty imposed by Allaah.
Quran 9:60 Koran 9:60 Charity (Zakah, Zekat) is only for the poor and the needy and those who collect the charity, and those whose hearts are to be reconciled (with Allaah) and to free the captives (or the slaves) and the debtors (those owing money) and for the cause of Allaah and for the (stranded) traveler. It (the distribution of charity) is a duty imposed by Allaah. Allaah is all knowing and wise.
6. Allaah decreed freedom for slaves through a contract.
Quran 24:33 Koran 24:33 “… And those of your slaves who request a contract (for eventual freedom from their slavery, emancipation from slavery), make a contract with them (so they can purchase their freedom from their owner) if you know there is some goodness in them and give to them something from the wealth of Allaah which He (Allaah) has given to you. …”
7. Allaah has decreed that sin is forgiven by the freeing of a slave.
Quran 58:3 Koran 58:3 Those who divorce their wives by Zihar (Thihar, by saying that their wife is their mother and therefore unlawful to them as was done by Arabs in Arabia before the time of Islam) and wish to cancel what they said (to cancel the divorce), should free a slave before they (the husband and the wife) touch each other. That is your punishment (so that in future you remember to behave correctly). Allaah is aware of what you do.
8. Allaah ordered the releasing of wives who disbelieve in Allaah.
Quran 60:10 Koran 60:10 All you who believe (in Allaah), … Do not hold on to disbelieving (stone idol worshiping) women as wives and ask for (the return of) what you spent (in your marriage gift, dowry, mahr, mehr, meher, mahrieh) to them (the stone idol worshiping wife) and let them (the disbelievers who worship stone idols also) ask back for what they spent (in their marriage gift, dowry, mahr, mehr, meher, mahrieh for their women who have come to you). That is the Judgement of Allaah. He (Allaah) judges (with justice) between you (the believers and the disbelievers). Allaah knows all and is wise.
9. Allaah decreed that righteous behaviour is the freeing of slaves.
Quran 90:11 Koran 90:11 But he (the human) has not attempted the (difficult) steep path (of righteousness).
Quran 90:12 Koran 90:12 And what can explain to you (humans) what the (difficult) steep path (of righteousness) is?
Quran 90:13 Koran 90:13 It is the freeing of a slave (or captive). (That is difficult for you to do but it is pleasing to Allaah if you do it).
Quran 98:7 Koran 98:7 And those who believe and do righteous deeds are the best of creations (because they have obeyed Allaah, their creator).
E. The treatment of slaves.
1. Allaah said do goodness to both your parents and your slaves.
Quran 4:36 Koran 4:36 “… do good for parents, relatives, orphans, the poor, neighbours who are related, neighbours who are strangers, companions that are with you, travellers (whom you meet) and those (slaves) whom your right hands possess (meaning, do goodness to the servants whom you own). Allaah does not like those that are proud and boastful (meaning the good that you do should be done to please Allaah).
2. Allaah said free the slave.
Quran 24:33 Koran 24:33 “… And those of your slaves who request a contract (for eventual freedom from their slavery, emancipation from slavery), make a contract with them (so they can purchase their freedom from their owner) if you know there is some goodness in them and give to them something from the wealth of Allaah which He (Allaah) has given to you. …”
3. Allaah said do not force your slave-girls into prostitution.
Quran 24:33 Koran 24:33 “… Do not force your slave-girls to prostitution when they desire chastity in order that you may seek the (temporary) enjoyment of the life of the world. …”
Quran 24:33 Koran 24:33 “… And if anyone forces them (to prostitution), then Allaah shall be forgiving and merciful (to the slave girl because she was forced to do evil against her will and to slave owners who did such things in the time of ignorance before accepting Islam).
Sex with slaves in Islam.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/sex-with-slaves-in-islam
15. The Gospel of Barnabas contradicts the Quran and Torah Taurat and Gospel Injil.
The Gospel of Barnabas contradicts all the Books of Allaah and contains 34 contradictions meaning it is not from Allaah.
Error 1 The Jewish Jubilee is every one hundred years contradicting Taurat Torah Leviticus 25:10.
Error 2 Prophet Jesus Isa said “I am not the messiah” contradicting Quran 3:45, 4:157, 4:171, 4:172, 5:17, 5:72, 5:75 and 9:31.
Error 3 Prophet Jesus Isa said the messiah is Prophet Muhammad contradicting Quran 3:45, 4:157, 4:171, 4:172, 5:17, 5:72, 5:75 and 9:31.
Error 4 the rank of Prophet Jesus Isa is changed to the rank of Prophet John Yahya contradicting the Quran and is a rewriting of the Gospel Injil of Jesus Isa by Mark, Matthew, Luke and John.
Error 5 the Virgin Mary Maryam gives birth to Jesus Isa with no pain contradicting Quran 19:23.
Error 6 there are nine heavens contradicting Quran 65:12.
Error 7 the Jewish meaning of “son of Allaah” which is “servant of Allaah” in the time of Jesus Isa and in the Torah Taurat is confused with the incorrect meaning of “a real biological son of Allaah” which started after the time of Jesus Isa.
Error 8 the prophecy that before the arrival of Prophet Muhammad there will not be 30 people in the world who correctly believe that Jesus Isa is not Allaah did not happen.
Error 9 Jesus Isa was not killed on the cross because it was Judas Iscariot who was made to look like Jesus Isa who was killed contradicting Quran 4:158 and 39:42.
Error 10 the inventor of the Gospel of Barnabas had no faith in the Gospel Injil of Jesus Isa by Mark, Matthew, Luke and John contradicting Quran 4:136, 7:157 and 30:30.
Error 11 Prophet Ishmael Ismail was the son to be sacrificed contradicting the Quran where in the story of the sacrifice Allaah blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Isaac Ishaq. Allaah has left no other blessing in that story.
Error 12 the rabbis changed the Torah Taurat contradicting Quran 2:41, 2:106, 3:3, 4:136, 5:48, 5:68, 13:39 and 30:30
Error 13 is the rewriting of the Gospel Injil of Jesus Isa by Mark, Matthew, Luke and John by removing the word “Son of Allaah” which in the time of Jesus Isa meant nothing but servant of Allaah.
Error 14 if Jesus Isa had not been called Allaah then Jesus Isa would not have been questioned on the Day of Judgement contradicting Quran 7:6, 7:7 and 5:117.
Error 15 Satan Shaitan was priest and head of the angels contradicting Quran 18:50.
Error 16 Adam will be in Hell Jahannam for a time in the hereafter because he sinned when he was in Paradise Jannah contradicting Quran 2:37.
Error 17 those who did not do any good deeds but had faith will be released from Hell Jahannam contradicting Quran 6:158 and 41:8.
Error 18 Ishmael Ismail is the father of Messiah Prophet Muhammad and Isaac Ishaq is the father of Prophet Jesus Isa who is the messenger of the Messiah Prophet Muhammad contradicting all the Books of Allaah which are with all humans today.
Error 19 When the Roman soldiers and the priests came to arrest Jesus Isa outside of Jerusalem four angels took Jesus Isa out of the window to the third heaven contradicting the Quran and rewriting the Gospel Injil of Jesus Isa by Mark, Matthew, Luke and John.
Error 20 Judas Iscariot whom Allaah makes look and talk like Prophet Jesus Isa tells the disciples of Jesus Isa that he is Judas Iscariot is a rewriting of the Gospel Injil of Jesus Isa by Mark, Matthew, Luke and John.
Error 21 at court in Jerusalem the man who looks and talks like Jesus Isa tells the high priest that he is Judas Iscariot is a rewriting of the Gospel Injil of Jesus Isa by Mark, Matthew, Luke and John.
Error 22 in Jerusalem the man who looks and talks like Jesus Isa tells Governor Pilate that he is Judas Iscariot is a rewriting of the Gospel Injil of Jesus Isa by Mark, Matthew, Luke and John.
Error 23 the man who looks and talks like Jesus Isa tells Herod the King of Galilee that he is Judas Iscariot is a rewriting of the Gospel Injil of Jesus Isa by Mark, Matthew, Luke and John.
Error 24 the last words on the cross said by Judas Iscariot who was made to look and talk like Jesus Isa is a rewriting of the Gospel Injil of Jesus Isa by Mark, Matthew, Luke and John.
Error 25 the body of Judas Iscariot who looks like Jesus Isa is put in the tomb is a rewriting of the Gospel Injil of Jesus Isa by Mark, Matthew, Luke and John.
Error 26 the body of Judas Iscariot who looks like Jesus Isa was stolen and hidden is a rewriting of the Gospel Injil of Jesus Isa by Mark, Matthew, Luke and John.
Error 27 Jesus returns to Earth from the third heaven is a rewriting of the Gospel Injil of Jesus Isa by Mark, Matthew, Luke and John.
Error 28 Allaah made Mary Maryam and the disciples of Jesus Isa believe Jesus Isa was dead so that Mary Maryam and the disciples of Jesus Isa would suffer for their sins on the earth instead of in the hereafter is a rewriting of the Gospel Injil of Jesus Isa by Mark, Matthew, Luke and John.
Error 29 Jesus Isa was called Allaah and son of Allaah so in order that he not be mocked by the demons on the Day of Judgement Allaah willed that Jesus Isa be mocked in this world by the death of Judas until the arrival of Prophet Muhammad is a rewriting of the Gospel Injil of Jesus Isa by Mark, Matthew, Luke and John.
Error 30 Jesus Isa tells his disciples that he did not die on the cross but it was Judas who died on the cross and Jesus Isa is raised into heaven a second time is a rewriting of the Gospel Injil of Jesus Isa by Mark, Matthew, Luke and John.
Error 31 the last paragraph the ending in the Gospel of Barnabas is a rewriting of the Gospel Injil of Jesus Isa by Mark, Matthew, Luke and John.
Error 32 Prophet Jesus Isa said he will not die until near the end of the world which contradicts Quran 3:55, 3:144, 5:75, 5:117, 33:40 and 39:42.
Error 33 Jesus Isa is the Christ but he is not the messiah therefore the only true book from Allaah with humans today according to the Gospel of Barnabas is the Gospel of Barnabas because all other books disagree with the Gospel of Barnabas.
Error 34 those who are not circumcised cannot enter Paradise Jannah contradicts the Quran.
Error 1 The Jewish Jubilee is every one hundred years contradicting Taurat Torah Leviticus 25:10.
The Gospel of Barnabas confuses the Jewish Jubilee with the Christian Jubilee.
The Gospel of Barnabas incorrectly states that in the time of Jesus Isa the Jewish Jubilee Festival when slaves and prisoners were freed was celebrated every 100 years but it is every 50 years as decreed in Torah Leviticus 25:10.
This error shows that the Gospel of Barnabas could have been written in the late Middle Ages between 1300 – 1342 (1300 – 1342 CE, 699 – 742 AH) which is around 1300 years after the time of Prophet Jesus Isa and 700 years after the time of Prophet Muhammad because the idea that the Jubilee was every 100 years started on 22 February 1300 CE 699 AH in Rome Italy when the Christian Pope Boniface VIII introduced a holy year celebration granting full pardon of all sins under certain conditions which would occur every one hundred years which Roman and foreign writers called a Jubilee. This was changed in 1343 CE 743 AH by Pope Clement VI to celebrate every fifty years starting in 1350 CE 750 AH.
The Gospel of Barnabas contradicts the Quran and Torah Taurat and Gospel Injil.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/the-gospel-of-barnabas-true-or-false
16. How to find false hadith stories invented after the death of Prophet Muhammad which contradict the Quran.
1. All hadith stories that claim Prophet Muhammad did something or said something that is opposite to what Allaah teaches in the Quran are false hadith stories invented after the death of Prophet Muhammad
2. When all the books of Allaah (the Torah Taurat and the Gospel Injil and the Quran) support each other it is proof that you have correctly understood what Allaah has revealed.
3. Satan Shaitan who whispers to some Christians "Jesus Isa is Allaah" (which cannot be found in the four Gospel Injil) also whispers hundreds of false hadith stories to some Muslims (which cannot be found in the Torah Taurat or in the Gospel Injil or in the Quran) that stop them from correctly understanding the stories of Allaah and correctly helping Christians by explaining to them that after Jesus Isa was saved on the cross Jesus Isa taught his people he is not Allaah until his natural death and that Christians can read this in the Gospel Injil that is with them today and is confirmed by the Quran.
Instead of doing this important work on the earth some Muslims are kept busy thinking about stories that have no benefit in the hereafter because they are stories which are opposite to what Allaah and Prophet Muhammad teach in the Quran.
4. The Quran confirms the Gospel Injil and the Torah Taurat but Satan Shaitan has deceived some Muslims to believe that the Gospel Injil and the Torah Taurat are false only because they do not agree with hundreds of invented false hadith stories.
In this way Satan Shaitan in the hereafter might claim that his stories were equal or better than the Quran because some people could not see any difference between the stories of Allaah in the Quran and the false hadith stories which are opposite to what Allaah teaches in the Quran.
In the hereafter Satan Shaitan might boast he obeyed Quran 17:88 by whispering hundreds of false hadith stories which teach the opposite to what Allaah and Prophet Muhammad teach in the Quran.
In the hereafter Satan Shaitan might be told that those who disbelieved every hadith story that was opposite to what Allaah teaches in the Quran is proof that Satan Shaitan failed to produce anything like the Quran.
Quran 17:88 Koran 17:88 Say (Prophet Muhammad), "If humans and jinn (such as Satan Shaitan) came together to help each other to produce something like the Quran, they could not do it."
5. When a dishonest story teller makes a living by telling stories for his meals he will need to invent stories because no one is interested to hear the same story twice.
a. When Abu Bakr who lived in the time of Prophet Muhammad wrote down hadith stories that were recited to him after the death of Prophet Muhammad by a man who visited him during meal time he began to understand that some of these stories contradicted what Allaah teaches in the Quran and one night he could not sleep because he understood that it was impossible for him to trust stories which came from a man who recited stories contradicting the Quran and therefore he destroyed his collection of 500 hadith stories so that Allaah in the hereafter will not blame him for passing on false hadith stories.
b. When Umar ibn Al-Khattab who lived in the time of Prophet Muhammad heard that after the death of Prophet Muhammad people were writing hadith stories he ordered everyone who had written books or had a book of hadith to give it to him and he destroyed all those books in a fire because like Muslims today he found that many of these stories contradicted what Allaah teaches in the Quran meaning they were false hadith stories and he did that so that Allaah in the hereafter will not blame him for allowing the passing on of false hadith stories during his period of leadership of the Muslim community.
Quran 17:88 Koran 17:88 Say (Prophet Muhammad), "If humans and jinn (such as Satan Shaitan) came together to help each other to produce something like the Quran, they could not do it."
Note 1. In the hereafter Satan Shaitan might boast he obeyed Quran 17:88 by whispering hundreds of false hadith stories which teach the opposite to what Allaah and Prophet Muhammad teach in the Quran.
Note 2. Hadith stories which contradict the Quran were invented by story tellers after the death of Prophet Muhammad and repeated by people who were deceived to believe false stories.
c. What does the Quran say about information that contradicts Allaah in the Quran?
Quran 77:50 Koran 77:50 In what statement (words, news, reports, information, message, hadith), after it (the verses of Allaah in the Quran), shall they (the humans and the jinn) believe?
Note 1. Quran 7:185, Quran 25:29, Quran 25:30, Quran 31:6, Quran 39:23, Quran 45:6 and Quran 77:50 asks when you have the word of Allaah in the Quran what other report would you believe?
Do not twist inside your mind the meaning of the words of Allaah in the Quran to agree with hadith stories.
If hadith stories and the actions of humans agree with the Quran then accept it and learn from it.
If hadith stories and the actions of humans do not agree with the Quran then reject it and also learn from it.
On the Day of Judgement Allaah judges by the words in the protected Quran.
On the Day of Judgement Allaah does not judge by the words in unprotected human hadith stories.
The Quran is the protected word of Allaah including the words and actions of Prophet Muhammad which are described and protected by Allaah.
d. When Allaah tells Prophet Muhammad what happened after his death what will Prophet Muhammad say to Allaah on the Day of Judgement?
Quran 25:30 Koran 25:30 And (on the Day of Resurrection and Judgement) the messenger (Prophet Muhammad) said, “My Lord (Allaah) my people have abandoned (deserted) this Quran (to follow false messages, false words, false news, false reports, false information, false statements, false hadith).”
Note 1. On the Day of Resurrection and Judgement Prophet Muhammad will say “My Lord my people have abandoned this Quran (to follow false messages, false words, false news, false reports, false information, false statements, false hadith).”
6. Misguidance.
When people are taught how to twist the words of Allaah to agree with hadith stories which teach the opposite to what Allaah teaches in the Quran instead of teaching people to ask the question "does this hadith story agree with the teachings of Allaah in the Quran" the result can be people who follow the mistakes of other people instead of people who are led by the teachings of Allaah in the Quran.
7. The danger of believing false stories.
People who believe false stories invented by other humans after the death of a prophet can be made to believe other false stories invented by humans as seen in some Christian cults and some Muslim cults who followed stories supporting their killing of people and their killing of themselves.
8. Education.
Teaching people to ask "is this story contradicting the teachings in the books of Allaah" will help protect people from other people who are following false stories instead of following the stories in the books of Allaah.
9. What is the purpose of Islam and Muslims?
The purpose of Islam and Muslims is not to rewrite the Books of Allaah but to explain the Books of Allaah which existed 1400 years ago with the Jews and the Christians and which have existed continuously with the Jews and the Christians to this day.
When Prophet Muhammad explained the Torah Taurat and the Gospel Injil Prophet Muhammad was explaining what was with the Jews and with the Christians 1400 years ago which are the same books that are with the Jews and the Christians today.
1400 years ago Prophet Muhammad was not explaining books that the Jews and the Christians had never seen or books that were hidden or books that were corrupted.
The book with the Jews is the Torah Taurat and the book with Christians is the Gospel Injil of Jesus Isa by Mark, Matthew, Luke and John.
Allaah says In Quran 4:136 whoever has no faith in the Books of Allaah (the Torah Taurat and the Gospel Injil and the Quran) has stayed far away from Allaah.
Any hadith story that is opposite to what is taught in the Books of Allaah (the Torah Taurat and the Gospel Injil and the Quran) is a false hadith story.
How to find false hadith stories invented after the death of Prophet Muhammad which contradict the Quran.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/invented-hadith-stories
17. A better way to understand examine teach study and check hadith stories by contradictions with the Quran.
1. Abu Bakr explained where false hadith stories come from.
2. Umar ibn Al-Khattab explained where false hadith stories come from.
1. Abu Bakr explained where false hadith stories come from.
Abu Bakr who lived in the time of Prophet Muhammad shows that some hadith stories regarded as trustworthy and recited after the death of Prophet Muhammad were in fact untrustworthy hadith stories.
Hadith story 1.
It has been narrated that Aishah (the wife of Prophet Muhammad) said, my father (Abu Bakr) collected the hadīth (stories of the Messenger of Allaah), which was five hundred texts.
He spent that night so sleeplessly and restlessly that I was sad for him.
I therefore asked, ‘Are you moving restlessly due to an ailment or information that you received?’
In the morning, he asked me to fetch him the collection of hadīth that he had put with me.
When I fetched them, he set fire to them.
As I asked for the reason, he replied, ‘I anticipated that I would die while I still have this collection among which there might be reports of a man that I deemed trustworthy while he was the opposite; therefore, I would be the narrator of such false reports.’
(Recorded in 1. Al-Dhahbiy: Tadhkirat al-Huffādh 1:5,
Recorded in 2. Al-Qāsim ibn Muhammad (died in 1029 AH): al-I`tisām bi-Habl-illāh al-Matīn 1:30,
Recorded in 3. `Abd al-Ghaniy `Abd al-Khāliq: Hijjiyyat al-Sunnah 394).
If hadith you believed was true you later understood cannot be true you would not be able to sleep.
Who is the man Abu Bakr deemed trustworthy while he was the opposite meaning untrustworthy?
Abu Bakr does not name him.
The trusted man was not related to the prophet.
The trusted man is someone Prophet Muhammad trusted and therefore all Muslims trusted during the life of Prophet Muhammad.
The trusted man was invited to eat in the house of Prophet Muhammad and therefore it was thought that this trusted man had direct knowledge about the sayings of the prophet.
The trusted man did not recite hadith stories during the life of Prophet Muhammad.
The trusted man made a living reciting hundreds of hadith stories after the death of Prophet Muhammad.
The trusted man is someone who recited more than the five hundred hadith stories that Abu Bakr had collected after the death of Prophet Muhammad.
Abu Bakr could not sleep because like Muslims today he understood that many hadith stories are opposite to what Allaah and Prophet Muhammad teach in the Quran.
Any hadith story that is opposite to what Allaah and Prophet Muhammad teach in the Quran is a false hadith story.
The hadith stories collected by Abu Bakr were from a man Abu Bakr considered trustworthy.
When Abu Bakr understood that this trustworthy man was in fact untrustworthy Abu Bakr destroyed his 500 hadith story collection.
The destruction of these 500 hadith stories show that these stories where not stories that Abu Bakr heard directly from the prophet.
Abu Bakr says these stories came from a trusted man.
These stories were collected after the death of Prophet Muhammad by Abu Bakr from a man who was trusted to have direct knowledge of the sayings of the prophet because that trusted man was invited to eat with the prophet.
In the later part of the life of Abu Bakr he began to understand that these stories were untrustworthy because they were opposite of what Allaah and Prophet Muhammad teach in the Quran.
After the death of Prophet Muhammad the trustworthy man showed he was untrustworthy by inventing false hadith stories as a way to make a living.
These are hadith stories which cannot be true because they teach something that is opposite to what Allaah and Prophet Muhammad teach in the Quran.
These hadith stories are false hadith stories because they contradict the stories of Allaah and Prophet Muhammad which are protected in the Quran.
2. Umar ibn Al-Khattab explained where false hadith stories come from.
Why did Umar ibn Al-Khattab who lived in the time of Prophet Muhammad collect all hadith story books in his time and burn them? The following hadith shows that Umar thought that hadith books were not the fairest and the straightest of Allaah’s most beloved books meaning some hadith was not fair and some hadith was not straight meaning hadith was interfering with the correct understanding of what Allaah and Prophet Muhammad say in the Quran as Muslims today also understand when they find false hadith stories which teach the opposite to what Allaah and Prophet Muhammad teach in the Quran.
Hadith story 2.
It has been narrated on the authority of al-Qasim ibn Muhammad ibn Abu Bakr that Umar, after he had received news confirming that people started to hold (or write) books, denied and disliked the matter saying, ‘O people: I have been informed that you have started to hold books. Allaah’s most beloved books must be the fairest and the straightest.
Now, I order you all to bring me all the books that you hold so that I will decide about them.’
Thinking that `Umar wanted to correct and submit the books to a certain criterion, all people brought their books to him. Instead, he set them all to fire and said, ‘This is a false wish just like that of the Christians and the Jews.’
(Recorded in Abd al-Ghaniy `Abd al-Khāliq: Hijjiyyat al-Sunnah 395).
Note 1. ‘This is a false wish just like that of the Christians and the Jews’ means ‘This (human writing) is a false wish (desire) just like that of the (human writing of the) Christians and the Jews.’
The following hadith (with my comments added in the brackets) explains why Umar thought that hadith books that existed in his time were not the fairest and the straightest of Allaah’s most beloved books meaning hadith was interfering with the correct understanding of what Allaah and Prophet Muhammad say in the Quran.
Hadith story 3.
According to Ibn Sa’d, in his al-Tabaqat al-Kubra, Umar said, ‘This (hadith) is a Mishna (meaning human writings) just like that of the Christians (for example the priests who invented the idea that Jesus Isa is Allaah and Jesus Isa will return to this earth in Christian writings that are not in the Gospel Injil) and the Jews (for example the rabbis who invented the idea of the anti messiah Armilus in Jewish writings known as the false messiah the Dajjal Dijjal which is not in the Torah Taurat).’
(Recorded in Ibn Sa`d: al-Tabaqāt al-Kubrā 1:140).
See 1. When a prophet dies Satan Shaitan whispers stories that contradict the Books of Allaah.
The description of the Dajjal Dijjal is Armilus.
“… In Rome there is a splendid marble statue of a beautiful girl which god himself made in the beginning of the world. Through sexual intercourse of evil men, or even of Satan himself, with this statue, a terrible creature in human form was produced, whose dimensions as well as shape were equally monstrous.” … “Armilus is bald-headed, with one large and one small eye, deaf in the right ear and maimed in the right arm, while the left arm is two and one-half ells long.”
Reference https://jewishencyclopedia.com/articles/1789-armilus
See 2. Anti Messiah (anti Christ) is not in the Quran.
Anti Messiah (anti Christ) is not in Tanakh Jewish scripture.
Anti Messiah (anti Christ) is in Christianity.
Armilus in Judaism is not an Anti Messiah (anti Christ) but represents Romulus the founder of Rome In the Roman story of Amulius.
In Judaism Armilus represents the defeat of Rome in the end of days and was misunderstood by Christians as an anti Messiah (anti Christ) however there is no anti Messiah (anti Christ) in Tanakh Jewish scripture or in the Quran.
Hadith stories about the Dajjal in Islam are not confirmed in the Quran meaning such hadith stories were written after the death of the prophet.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xVG8lPB1Les
See 3. A better way to understand hadith stories.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/a-better-way-to-understand-hadith-stories
17A. Quran 51:47 the expansion of the Universe?
1. Quran 51:47 shows how humans who reject the Tanakh and claim Quran 51:47 is about the expansion of the Universe are misguided by humans because they have rejected the Books of Allaah which confirm and explain each other.
Quran 51:47 Koran 51:47 And the heavens (the sky) We (Allaah) have constructed it with (Our) power (in Quran 21:32 Allaah has made the sky to be like a protected roof over the earth like a dome. In Quran 17:92, Quran 22:65, Quran 26:187 and Quran 52:44 the sky is held up by Allaah to prevent it from falling down and in Quran 31:10 Allaah made the heavens meaning the sky to be like a high roof without supports that you can see and in Quran 52:5 the sky is like a roof that has been raised high up above you and in Quran 79:27–79:28 Allaah is the one who raised the sky up high above you) and We (Allaah) are its expanders (meaning “We are its spreaders” in the Jewish Tanakh Job 9:8, meaning “We stretched out the heavens” in the Jewish Tanakh Isaiah 40:22, Isaiah 42:5, Isaiah 44:24, Isaiah 45:12 and Zechariah 12:1 meaning “We spread out the heavens” in the Jewish Tanakh Isaiah 48:13 and “We spread out the earth” in Quran 91:6, meaning Allaah is the one who created what you can see from one horizon to another horizon meaning Allaah is the one who spread out the heavens from one horizon to another horizon meaning the stars and the Moon and the Sun and the planets across the blue sky in the day and the black sky at night which you can see above the earth from one horizon to another horizon meaning Allaah is the expander of the sky that you see above you from one horizon to another horizon in the same way as Allaah spread out the land across the earth from one horizon to another horizon meaning Allaah is the expander of the land that you see from horizon to horizon meaning Allaah is the one who created everything that you can see in the sky which is like a protected dome around the earth meaning Allaah made the atmosphere in which you can see the heavens spread out across the sky meaning Allaah is the expander or spreader of everything you see across the sky).
2. The Tanakh Jewish scripture explains and confirms the Quran.
Expanders means spreaders.
Job 9:8 Who by himself spread out the heavens (the sky from horizon to horizon) and rules (has power over) the waves of the sea?”
Psalm 19:2 The heavens (the sky) declare the glory of Allaah, the ceiling of heaven (the sky) reveals his (Allaah’s) handiwork.”
Psalm 102:26 In times of old you (Allaah) lay the foundation of the earth; and the heavens (the sky) are the work of your (Allaah’s) hands.
Psalm 104:2 “… (It is Allaah) who stretches out the heavens like a curtain.
Isaiah 40:22 It is He (Allaah) that sits above the circle of the earth, and the inhabitants there (on the Earth) are like grasshoppers; (It is Allaah) that stretches out the heavens like a curtain (in the sky), and spreads them out (the heavens) like a tent to dwell in (is spread out);
Isaiah 42:5 So said Allaah the LORD, creator of the heavens who stretched them out (from horizon to horizon), who spread out the earth (from horizon to horizon) and (gave) that (life) which comes out of it, and who gave a soul to the people on it, and a spirit (to understand righteousness) to those that walk on it:
Isaiah 44:24 So said the LORD (Allaah), your Redeemer (Saviour), the one who formed you from the womb: I am the LORD (Allaah), that makes all things; that alone stretched out the heavens (from one horizon to the other horizon); that spread out the earth by Myself;
Isaiah 45:12 I (Allaah) have made the earth, and created man upon it; My (Allaah’s) hands, have stretched out the heavens (the sky from horizon to horizon), and all their host (creatures) have I (Allaah) commanded.
Isaiah 48:13 My (Allaah’s) hand has laid the foundation of the earth, and My right hand has spread out the heavens (the sky from horizon to horizon); when I (Allaah) call to them (everything in the heavens and the earth), they stand up together (by obeying what I Allaah have decreed).
Zechariah 12:1 A prophecy: The word of the LORD concerning Israel says the LORD, who stretched out the heavens (the expander of the heavens from one horizon to the other horizon) and laid the foundation of the earth and formed the spirit of man within him:
3. The Quran confirms the Torah Taurat.
Quran 2:41 Koran 2:41 And believe in what I (Allaah) have revealed (in the Quran) confirming that which is with you (in the Torah Taurat as proof to the stone idol worshipers of Makkah in Quran 6:114, Quran 46:10 and Quran 10:94 that the Quran is not an invented story) ..."
Note 1. The Quran confirms the Torah Taurat which is with the Jewish people forever.
Quran 4:136 Koran 4:136 "… Whoever has no faith in His (Allaah’s) … Books then he has strayed far away (from Allaah).
Quran 28:49 Koran 28:49 Say (Prophet Muhammad to the stone idol worshippers of Makkah Arabia), “Then bring a Book from Allaah that gives better guidance than these two (the Torah Taurat and the Quran) so that I (Prophet Muhammad) may follow it, if you are telling the truth.”
Note 1. The best guidance is the Quran and the Torah Taurat meaning both are correctly understood when they confirm and explain each other.
https://sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel/allaah-answers-3
17B. Quran 21:30 the big bang theory?
Some people who claim the Torah Taurat scroll containing 304,805 letters which is located in every Jewish Synagogue in every country in the world is corrupted also claim Quran 21:30 is about the big bang theory.
Protect Islam by rejecting invented false stories which claim the Quran is a book of science.
The Quran is not confirming the science books of the future which people 1400 years ago did not know about but is confirming what was revealed before it which is the knowledge contained in the Torah Taurat which every Jew 1400 years ago and today knows as proof the Quran is from Allaah meaning no one was successful in changing the word of Allaah because this is the proof Allaah is real.
A religion made by humans is easy to invent by claiming “all other books are corrupted.”
The Quran never claims any book of Allaah is corrupted but is “confirming the books of Allaah” not denying them or correcting them as proof Allaah is real because it is only some people in every religion who claim “books of Allaah have been corrupted”, meaning the claim that the Books of Allaah became corrupted is not from Allaah and is not from the Quran and is not from Prophet Muhammad and is not from any prophet of Allaah and is not from any Book of Allaah.
Quran 21:30 Koran 21:30 Do those who disbelieve not know that the heavens and the earth were one entity (called “smoke” in Quran 41:11 and called the “formless empty” entity in Torah Genesis 1:2), then We (Allaah) separated them (in Torah Genesis 1:6 – 1:8 dividing by separating the earth from the heavens with the firmament meaning the sky and in Quran 41:11 by raising the sky above the earth to separate the earth and the lowest heaven so that water can fall on the Earth and bring life as confirmed in the interpretation Tafsir of Ibn Kathir where Ibn Abi Hatim recorded that Ibn Umar sent a man who asked the meaning of this verse to Ibn `Abbas and confirmed in Quran 21:32 Allaah has made the sky to be like a protected roof over the earth like a dome to separate the heavens from the earth. In Quran 17:92, Quran 22:65, Quran 26:187 and Quran 52:44 the sky is held up by Allaah to prevent it from falling down and to separate the heavens from the earth and in Quran 31:10 Allaah made the heavens meaning the sky to be like a high roof without supports that you can see to separate the heavens from the earth and in Quran 52:5 the sky is like a roof that has been raised high up above you to separate the heavens from the earth and in Quran 79:27 – 79:28 Allaah is the one who raised the sky up high above you to separate the heavens from the earth), and We (Allaah) made every living thing from water (in Quran 24:45. The authority of Allaah was over water in Torah Genesis 1:2 and Quran 11:7 meaning life would be created from water by the permission of Allaah in Quran 21:30, Quran 24:45, Torah Leviticus 26:4 and Zabur Psalm 147:8)
Quran 41:11 Koran 41:11 Moreover He (Allaah) directed Himself towards the heaven when it was smoke (described as a “formless empty” entity in Torah Genesis 1:2 and as “one entity” in Quran 21:30), and He (Allaah) said to it (the heaven) and to the Earth (which were both formless empty smoke), "Come both of you willingly or unwillingly (into existence)." They (the heaven and the Earth) both said, "We come willingly" (into existence from the formless empty smoke. In Quran 21:32 Allaah has made the sky to be like a protected roof over the earth like a dome to separate the heavens from the earth. In Quran 17:92, Quran 22:65, Quran 26:187 and Quran 52:44 the sky is held up by Allaah to prevent it from falling down and to separate the heavens from the earth and in Quran 31:10 Allaah made the heavens meaning the sky to be like a high roof without supports that you can see to separate the heavens from the earth and in Quran 52:5 the sky is like a roof that has been raised high up above you to separate the heavens from the earth and in Quran 79:27 – 79:28 Allaah is the one who raised the sky up high above you to separate the heavens from the earth and confirmed in Torah Genesis 1:6–1:8 separating the earth from the heavens with the firmament meaning the sky).
Quran 41:12 Koran 41:12 And He (Allaah) completed them (the creation of the heavens in Quran 41:11) as seven heavens (meaning 7 Universes one above the other) in two Days (meaning in two periods of time in day 1 in Torah Genesis 1:1–1:5 and day 4 in Torah Genesis 1:14–1:19 which were “completed” within the two days “as seven heavens” or 7 universes in Quran 41:12) and decreed His (Allaah’s) command for each heaven (meaning for each of the 7 Universes). And We (Allaah) put lamps (stars) in the nearest heaven (which is the sky of the earth created in Quran 41:11) and made them (our sky and the 7 Universes) secure (protected by Allaah). That is the decree of (Allaah) the almighty, the all knowing.
Quran 2:29 Koran 2:29 He (Allaah) created for you (humans) all that is on Earth (in Quran 41:10 in 4 days or 4 periods of time which is confirmed by day 2 in Torah Genesis 1:6 – 1:8, day 3 in Torah Genesis 1:9 – 1:13, day 5 in Torah Genesis 1:20 – 1:23 and day 6 in Torah Genesis 1:24 – 1:31). Moreover He (Allaah) turned to the heaven and He (Allaah) made them seven heavens (7 Universes in 2 days or 2 periods of time in Quran 41:12 which are confirmed by the construction of the sky and the first heaven in day 1 in Torah Genesis 1:1 – 1:5 and day 4 in Torah Genesis 1:14 – 1:19 which were “completed” within the two days “as seven heavens” or 7 universes in Quran 41:12). He (Allaah) has knowledge of everything.
The Quran confirms the Torah Taurat.
Quran 2:41 Koran 2:41 And believe in what I (Allaah) have revealed (in the Quran) confirming that which is with you (in the Torah Taurat as proof to the stone idol worshipers of Makkah in Quran 6:114, Quran 46:10 and Quran 10:94 that the Quran is not an invented story) ..."
Note 1. The Quran confirms the Torah Taurat which is with the Jewish people forever.
Quran 4:136 Koran 4:136 "… Whoever has no faith in His (Allaah’s) … Books then he has strayed far away (from Allaah).
Quran 28:49 Koran 28:49 Say (Prophet Muhammad to the stone idol worshippers of Makkah Arabia), “Then bring a Book from Allaah that gives better guidance than these two (the Torah Taurat and the Quran) so that I (Prophet Muhammad) may follow it, if you are telling the truth.”
Note 1. The best guidance is the Quran and the Torah Taurat meaning both are correctly understood when they confirm and explain each other.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/quran-chapter-41-surah-41
17C. Prophet Ishmael Ismail or Prophet Isaac Ishaq to be sacrificed?
Why is the name of the son in the vision dream of the sacrifice important?
1. If the son to be sacrificed is Ishmael Ismail it means the Quran is teaching that the Torah Taurat which names Isaac Ishaq as the son to be sacrificed and commands the Jewish people to observe the Sabbath Day in all their generations forever was changed meaning the Quran contradicts the Torah Taurat and the Torah Taurat contradicts the Quran.
2. If the son to be sacrificed is Isaac Ishaq it means the Quran is teaching that the Torah Taurat which names Isaac Ishaq as the son to be sacrificed and commands the Jewish people to observe the Sabbath Day in all their generations forever was not changed meaning the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat and the Torah Taurat confirms the Quran.
Quran 2:41 Koran 2:41 And believe in what I (Allaah) have revealed (in the Quran) confirming that which is with you (the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat as proof to the stone idol worshipers of Makkah in Quran 6:114, Quran 46:10 and Quran 10:94 that the Quran is not an invented story) ..."
Note 1. The Quran confirms the Torah Taurat which is with the Jewish people forever.
3. Tafsir in the link below shows most early Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed was Isaac Ishaq meaning they believed the Torah Taurat is the truth.
4. Later Muslims claimed the son to be sacrificed was Ishmael Ismail and this explains why later Muslims accepted “proofs” that Allaah’s Torah Taurat with the Jewish people was corrupted by Prophet Ezra Uzair (meaning they claimed a prophet of Allaah corrupted the Torah Taurat) without asking a knowledgeable rabbi about their “proofs” in the same way as some Christians have accepted hundreds of “proofs” against Allaah’s Quran without asking a knowledgeable Muslim about those “proofs.”
5. This means the earliest Muslims believed the Torah Taurat and explains why later Muslims disbelieved the Torah Taurat meaning later Muslims believed the word of humans above the Books of Allaah by forgetting the warning in Quran 4:136 to “have faith in the Books of Allaah.”
6. After the death of Prophet Jesus Isa some Christians made Allaah into a man because they believed the words of humans above what is in the Gospel Injil and the Torah Taurat.
7. After the death of Prophet Muhammad some Muslims believed Allaah failed to protect His Torah Taurat which is with the Jewish people in which Allaah commanded that the Sabbath Day be observed by every generation of the children of Israel forever which is confirmed in Quran 2:65 – 2:66, Quran 5:60, Quran 7:163 – 7:166 and Quran 16:124.
8. Quran 2:40 - 2:42 and the Gospel of Matthew 5:17 - 5:20 confirm the Torah Taurat with the Jewish people is the truth and will never change and will be with the Pharisees meaning the Orthodox Jews forever.
Gospel of Matthew 5:17 Do not think that I (Jesus) have come to abolish the law (the Torah) and the prophets; I have come not to abolish them but to fulfill them.
Note 1. The Torah Taurat is protected forever.
Gospel of Matthew 5:18 For truly I say to you, until the sky and the earth pass away (meaning until the end of the earth), not one iota, not one serif (not a dot of one letter), will by any means pass away from the Law (in the Torah) until everything is carried out (on the Day of Judgement which is after the end of the earth).
Note 1. The Torah Taurat is protected forever.
Gospel of Matthew 5:19 Therefore, whoever looses one of the least of these commandments (in the Torah), and teaches people the same, will be called least in the kingdom of heaven, but whoever practices them and teaches them, this one will be called great in the kingdom of heaven.
Note 1. The Torah Taurat is protected forever.
Gospel of Matthew 5:20 For I tell you that unless your righteousness surpasses that of the Torah scholars and Pharisees (meaning unless you use religion to serve Allaah and to serve other humans instead of using the name of Allaah to gain attention for yourself or for your pride or for your arrogance), you will by no means enter the kingdom of heaven.
Note 1. There is a difference between the righteous Torah scholars (students of the Torah) and righteous Pharisees (orthodox Jews who followed the Torah and the oral law) and the Torah scholars and Pharisees who were arrogantly using the name of Allaah for their pride to gain attention for themselves.
Gospel of Matthew 23:1 Then Jesus spoke to the crowd and to his disciples,
Gospel of Matthew 23:2 saying, "The Torah scholars and Pharisees took the seat of Moses;
Gospel of Matthew 23:3 therefore whatever they say to you, you should do and keep …”
Note 1. Jesus says that the scripture that cannot be changed and must be followed forever is with the Pharisees meaning the Orthodox Jews and Jesus says “whatever they say to you, you should do and keep” meaning the Orthodox Jews have the correct word of Allaah in the Tanakh Jewish Scripture that cannot be changed and must be followed forever” meaning any opposite teaching is a false teaching.
Quran 2:41 Koran 2:41 And believe in what I (Allaah) have revealed (in the Quran) confirming that which is with you (the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat as proof to the stone idol worshipers of Makkah in Quran 6:114, Quran 46:10 and Quran 10:94 that the Quran is not an invented story) ..."
Note 1. The Quran confirms (not denies and not corrects) the Torah Taurat which is with the Jewish people forever.
Quran 3:93 “… Say (Prophet Muhammad, to the Jews of Yathrib), "Bring the Torah Taurat here and recite it (to me as evidence) if what you say is true."
Note 1. Allaah tells the Jews to bring the Torah Taurat and recite from the Torah Taurat as evidence of the truth meaning the Jews have the Torah Taurat and no one changed it.
Quran 4:136 says "Whoever has no faith in His (Allaah’s) … Books then he has strayed far away (from Allaah).
Note 1. Allaah says have faith in His books because the Books of Allaah are the guidance of Allaah which will not lead you astray inshallah (Allaah willing).
Note 2. The words of humans are the guidance of humans which can led you astray so be careful by measuring the truth of human claims with the words of Allaah is His Books .
Quran 5:43 Koran 5:43 How is it that they (the Jews of Yathrib Arabia) come to you (Prophet Muhammad) for judgment when they have the Torah Taurat in which Allaah has already revealed to them judgment …”
Note 1. Allaah tells the Jews to follow the Torah Taurat meaning the Jews have the Torah Taurat and no one changed it.
Quran 5:68 Koran 5:68 Say (Prophet Muhammad to the Jews of Yathrib in Arabia today in Medina, Saudi Arabia and to the Christians), “O People of the Scripture (the Jews and the Christians), You have nothing (of guidance) until you observe the Torah Taurat …”
Note 1. Allaah tells the Jews to observe the Torah Taurat meaning the Jews have the Torah Taurat and no one changed it.
9. The proof that the Torah Taurat and Gospel Injil and the Quran are man made inventions would be a corrupt Torah Taurat because both the Gospel Injil and the Quran say they are confirming the Torah Taurat and commanding the Jewish people to observe the Torah Taurat in Gospel of Matthew 5:17 - 5:20, Gospel of Matthew 23:1 - 23:3, Quran 2:40 - 2:41 and Quran 5:68.
10. Most early Muslims believed the Torah Taurat was not corrupted and believed the son to be sacrificed was Isaac Ishaq..
Most later Muslims believed the Torah Taurat was corrupted and believed the son to be sacrificed was Ismail.
This might explain why Allaah chose the Israelites and gave them the Torah Taurat and told them to observe the Sabbath Day in all their generations forever meaning Allaah decreed Judaism and the Torah Taurat forever so that the following might be fulfilled.
A. The Torah Taurat shows which verses in the Gospel Injil confirm the Torah Taurat meaning they came from Jesus and which verses in the Gospel Injil contradict the Torah Taurat meaning they came from Mark, Matthew, Luke or John in a test described in 1 Kings 13:14 - 13:24 teaching that the word of Allaah will not change and do not believe anyone who claims the word of Allaah has changed.
B. In the same way Allaah is testing Muslims in every generation in the story of the sacrifice in a test described in 1 Kings 13:14 - 13:24 teaching that the word of Allaah will not change and do not believe anyone who claims the word of Allaah has changed.
Quran 44:32 Koran 44:32 And We (Allaah) knowingly (with a purpose, for a reason) chose them (the children of Israel, the Jews, the Israelites who were called the Hebrews in the time of Prophet Moses Musa) over all the other people in the world (through an agreement covenant with Allaah in the Torah Taurat which is confirmed in Quran 2:40 - 2:41).
a. Library chats E7: Ismā`īl vs. Isḥāq as the sacrifice: A case study of tafsīr and scholarly influence.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CANtmlGngiw
b. Which son was to be sacrificed?
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/which-son-was-to-be-sacrificed
c. Quran chapter 37. The story of the sacrifice.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/quran-chapter-37-surah-37
d. Was Abraham commanded to sacrifice Isaac or Ishmael?
http://www.judaism-islam.com/was-abraham-commanded-to-sacrifice-isaac-or-ishmael/
17D. Hadith Jew is hiding behind me so kill him.
This is not in the Quran and is not confirmed by the Quran and Allaah warns in Quran 7:185, Quran 25:29, Quran 25:30, Quran 31:6, Quran 39:23, Quran 45:6 and Quran 77:50 follow the Quran above all other information.
Sahih al-Bukhari 2926 about the hour is false hadith because Quran 7:187 says the hour will come suddenly however if stones (or trees in Sahih Muslim 2922) talk as claimed in the hadith then everyone will know the hour is coming and no one will be surprised which contradicts Quran 7:187 where everyone will be surprised when the hour arrives.
The guidance of Allaah.
Quran 77:50 Koran 77:50 In what statement (words, news, reports, information, message, hadith), after it (the verses of Allaah in the Quran), shall they (the humans and the jinn) believe?
Note 1. Quran 7:185, Quran 25:29, Quran 25:30, Quran 31:6, Quran 39:23, Quran 45:6 and Quran 77:50 asks when you have the word of Allaah in the Quran what other report would you believe?
Quran 17:88 Koran 17:88 Say (Prophet Muhammad), "If humans and jinn (such as Satan Shaitan) came together to help each other to produce something like the Quran, they could not do it."
Note 1. In the hereafter Satan Shaitan might boast he obeyed Quran 17:88 by whispering hundreds of false hadith stories which teach the opposite to what Allaah and Prophet Muhammad teach in the Quran.
Quran 25:30 Koran 25:30 And (on the Day of Resurrection and Judgement) the messenger (Prophet Muhammad) said, “My Lord (Allaah) my people have abandoned (deserted) this Quran (to follow false messages, false words, false news, false reports, false information, false statements, false hadith).”
Note 1. On the Day of Resurrection and Judgement Prophet Muhammad will say “My Lord my people have abandoned this Quran (to follow false messages, false words, false news, false reports, false information, false statements, false hadith).”
If hadith stories agree with the Quran then accept it and learn from it.
If hadith stories do not agree with the Quran then reject it and also learn from it.
On the Day of Judgement Allaah judges by the words in the protected Quran.
On the Day of Judgement Allaah does not judge by the words in unprotected human hadith stories.
The Quran is the protected word of Allaah including the words and actions of Prophet Muhammad which are described and protected by Allaah.
See https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/hadith-Jew-is-hiding-behind-me-so-kill-him
Index B.
A better way to understand hadith stories is by using critical thinking and the Quran as shown in these examples..
Example 1. Did Prophet Muhammad say "there is punishment in the grave?"
Did Prophet Muhammad say "Prophet Jesus Isa is returning to this earth?"
Example 2. What is the meaning of “Do not curse fever. Verily, it removes the sins of the children of Adam just as a furnace removes dirt from iron”
Example 3. Why is stoning to death for adultery not in the Quran?
Example 4. Did Prophet Muhammad say “whoever changed his Islamic religion then kill him?”
1. Abu Bakr explained where false hadith stories come from.
2. Umar ibn Al-Khattab explained where false hadith stories come from.
3. Conclusion.
4. References.
A better way to understand hadith stories is to use critical thinking and the Quran.
Example 1.
Did Prophet Muhammad say "there is punishment in the grave?"
Did Prophet Muhammad say "Prophet Jesus Isa is returning to this earth?"
A. These stories are not in the Quran.
The protected word of Allaah is the Quran which include some words and some actions of Prophet Muhammad which are protected in the Quran by Allaah.
B. These are hadith stories.
The unprotected words of humans are hadith stories that were passed from one human to another human.
C. Today we know some hadith stories were invented by people who made a living telling stories and falsely using the name of Prophet Muhammad and his people after his death or told by people who were deceived to believe false stories.
Today we need to look at each hadith story very carefully including all stories that were classified or graded Sahih mean genuine, sound, reliable, authentic because some of the most well known hadith stories which were graded sahih meaning authentic contradict the Quran meaning they teach the opposite to the teaching of Allaah in the Quran meaning those hadith stories were invented after the death of Prophet Muhammad which means they are not sahih meaning they are not authentic.
D. Where do false hadith stories come from?
Quran 17:88 Koran 17:88 Say (Prophet Muhammad), "If humans and jinn (such as Satan Shaitan) came together to help each other to produce something like the Quran, they could not do it."
Note 1. In the hereafter Satan Shaitan might boast he obeyed Quran 17:88 by whispering hundreds of false hadith stories which teach the opposite to what Allaah and Prophet Muhammad teach in the Quran.
Note 2. Did Prophet Muhammad say there is punishment in the grave?
Quran 2:259, Quran 7:187, Quran 18:19, Quran 18:21, Quran 20:103, Quran 20:104, Quran 23:113, Quran 30:55, Quran 46:35 and Quran 79:46 is proof that all hadith stories about punishment in the grave are false stories invented by dishonest people who made a living by claimed their stories came from Prophet Muhammad because people loved listening to stories about Prophet Muhammad or told by people who were deceived to believe false stories.
The Psalm Zabur recited by Prophet David Dawud and the Quran recited by Prophet Muhammad confirm there is no life in the grave and no feeling in the grave and no talking in the grave and no sight in the grave and no voices in the grave and no consciousness in the grave between the time of death and the Day of Resurrection.
Zabur Psalm 6:6 For there is no memory of You (Allaah) in death; in the grave, who will thank You (Allaah)?
Quran 7:187 Koran 7:187 They ask you (Prophet Muhammad) about The Hour (of the Day of Resurrection) and when it shall come. … It shall come to you suddenly. …”
Quran 20:104 Koran 20:104 We (Allaah) know very well what they (the people) shall say, when the best of them in behaviour shall say (to the others, that Quran 2:259, Quran 7:187, Quran 18:19, Quran 18:21, Quran 20:103, Quran 20:104, Quran 23:113, Quran 30:55, Quran 46:35 and Quran 79:46 said the truth that on the Day of Resurrection every human both the righteous and the wrong doer will swear that it feels like), "You did not stay for more than one day (sleeping in death on the Earth before you were resurrected on a new earth, a new ground, a new land in the hereafter)."
Quran 30:55 Koran 30:55 And on the day when the Hour (of Resurrection) comes the wrong doers shall swear (in the Hereafter) that they only stayed (sleeping in death) for an hour (meaning only one hour had passed since they had died on the Earth), showing how wrong they were (because the time between death and resurrection only feels like an hour or part of a day).
Quran 46:35 Koran 46:35 So be patience (Prophet Muhammad) like the steadfast of the messengers (of the past) and do not be impatient (for Allaah’s punishment to come) to them (the stone idol worshippers of Makkah Arabia). On the Day when they (the stone idol worshippers) see what they were promised (in the Day of Resurrection and Judgement which is decreed, it shall seem to them) as though they had stayed (sleeping for) only one hour of a day (before they were resurrected from death to life on the Day of Resurrection and Judgement). This is a notification (to you so that no one can deny they were not warned that the Day of Resurrection is real). Shall any perish (by losing the mercy of Allaah and living forever in Hell Jahannam) except the disobedient people?
Quran 79:46 Koran 79:46 On the day they see it (the Day of Resurrection), it shall be as if they (each human) had not stayed (sleeping in death) except for an evening or a morning.
See hadith punishment in the grave
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/hadith-punishment-in-the-grave
Note 3. Did Prophet Muhammad say Prophet Jesus Isa is returning to this earth?
Quran 3:144 (see Quran 5:75), Quran 4:157, Quran 4:158 (see Quran 39:42), Quran 5:75 (see Quran 3:144), Quran 5:117 (see Quran 7:6), Quran 7:6 (see Quran 5:117), Quran 21:95, Quran 33:40 (see Gospel of Jesus Isa by Mark 13:5 – 13:6, 13:21 – 13:22) and Quran 39:42 (see Quran 4:158) is proof that all hadith stories about Prophet Jesus Isa returning to this earth are false stories invented by dishonest people who made a living by claimed their stories came from Prophet Muhammad because people loved listening to stories about Prophet Muhammad or told by people who were deceived to believe false stories.
There is nothing in the Quran about Jesus Isa returning to this Earth or the guided one the Mahdi Mehdi or the false messiah the Dajjal Dijjal.
After the life of the messenger Jesus Isa was saved on the cross Jesus Isa lived with the children of Israel until his natural death in the Quran exactly confirming what is in the Gospel Injil of Jesus Isa by Mark, Matthew, Luke, and John where Jesus Isa was alive 3 days after the crucifixion as proof no one killed him on the cross and he lived with the children of Israel until his natural death teaching them "Allaah is my Allaah and your Allaah" meaning Allaah is my Lord and your Lord and “Allaah is my Father and your Father” meaning Allaah is my Creator and your Creator exactly confirming Quran 3:144 (see Quran 5:75), Quran 4:157, Quran 4:158 (see Quran 39:42), Quran 5:75 (see Quran 3:144), Quran 5:117 (see Quran 7:6), Quran 7:6 (see Quran 5:117), Quran 21:95, Quran 33:40 (see Gospel of Jesus Isa by Mark 13:5 – 13:6, 13:21 – 13:22) and Quran 39:42 (see Quran 4:158) and all the four Gospel Injil that are with the Christians today as proof Allaah is real because no one can change the word of Allaah in Allaah’s Books which were with humans 1400 years ago and are still with humans today.
The Gospel Injil of Jesus Isa by Mark, Matthew, Luke and John containing the words delivered by the messenger Jesus Isa and the Quran recited by the messenger Muhammad confirm that Prophet Jesus Isa will not return to this earth.
Gospel of Mark 13:5 (Jesus Isa foretold what will happen in future after Jesus Isa has left the Earth) and Jesus Isa proceeded to tell them, "See that no one misleads you.
Note 1. The warning from Jesus Isa for humans not to be misled and misguided after Jesus Isa has left the earth.
Gospel of Mark 13:6 Many will come in my name (Jesus Isa), saying, 'I am He (Jesus Isa),' and they will deceive many.
Note 1. The warning from Jesus Isa that Satan Shaitan will deceive many people to believe Jesus Isa has returning to this earth.
Gospel of Mark 13:21 And at that time (when people will claim to be Jesus Isa), if anyone says to you, 'Look, here is the Messiah (Jesus Isa)' or, 'Look, there (is the messiah Jesus Isa)!' do not believe it.
Note 1. The warning from Jesus Isa not to believe anyone who claims the messiah Jesus Isa has returned to this earth.
Gospel of Mark 13:22 For false Messiahs and false prophets will appear, and they will do signs and miracles, trying to deceive, if possible, the elect (the righteous).
Note 1. The Gospel of Barnabas is a false book because it claims Prophet Muhammad is the messiah and it claims Jesus Isa said “I am not the Messiah.”
See The Gospel of Barnabas
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/the-gospel-of-barnabas-true-or-false
Note 2. The Quran confirms Jesus Isa is the messiah and never claims Prophet Muhammad is the messiah.
Note 3. Prophet Muhammad delivered the message of Allaah in the Quran without the false miracles mentioned in Gospel of Mark 13:22.
Note 4. The Gospel of Mark 13:22 warns that Satan Shaitan will try to deceive even the righteous to believe that the messenger and messiah and prophet Jesus Isa has returned to this earth.
Gospel of Mark 13:23 But you, you be watchful; I (Jesus Isa) have told you everything ahead of time (before it happens).
Note 1. The messenger and messiah and prophet Jesus Isa ends the warning by saying “I have told you everything” about Satan Shaitan who will deceive many by whispering “Jesus Isa has returned to this earth” which is opposite to the teachings in Quran 5:75 and Quran 3:144 in the same way Satan Shaitan whispered “Jesus Isa is Allaah” which is opposite to the teachings in the Gospel Injil of Jesus Isa by Mark, Matthew, Luke and John where Jesus Isa prays to Allaah in all the four Gospel Injil.
The special purpose of Quran 5:75 and Quran 3:144.
Allaah knew how the first Muslims would feel about the death of Prophet Muhammad.
To help the first Muslims accept the death of Prophet Muhammad Allaah revealed in Quran 5:75 that the messengers before Jesus Isa died and Jesus Isa and his mother Mary Maryam “both use to eat food” meaning they also both died (Allaah is saying this so that the first Muslims will understand that if all the messengers died would you not also expect that Prophet Muhammad will also die).
The same words are in Quran 3:144 except now Allaah says the messengers before Prophet Muhammad have died meaning Prophet Jesus Isa who is the messenger before Prophet Muhammad has died (Allaah is saying this so that the first Muslims will understand that if all the messengers died would you not also expect that Prophet Muhammad will also die).
In these two revelations the hearts of the first Muslims are comforted by Allaah making it easier for the first Muslims to accept the death of the prophet.
This is proof from Allaah in the protected Quran that all hadith stories about Jesus Isa returning to this earth because he did not die a natural death like every human before him and after him were invented after the death of the prophet.
The hadith stories are opposite to the story Allaah is teaching the first Muslims in the Quran.
It is proof from Allaah that these are false hadith stories invented by story tellers who lived their life inventing stories or told by people who were deceived to believe false stories which are opposite to what Allaah and Prophet Muhammad are teaching in the protected Quran.
See hadith Prophet Jesus Isa returning
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/hadith-prophet-jesus-returning
E. Today some people in Islam are claiming Allaah protects hadith stories like Allaah protects the Quran.
This is false.
Such claims are the same as a person in Christianity claiming Allaah protects the story that Jesus Isa is Allaah in a Trinity.
Allaah does not protect human story books.
The only Books Allaah protects from Satan Shaitan are the Books of Allaah as proof Allaah is real.
Punishment in the grave and the story that Jesus Isa is returning to this earth because Jesus Isa never died 2000 years ago are among the hundreds of fake invented hadith stories and the proof is they are opposite to what Allaah teaches in the Quran.
All these hadith stories are classified Sahih meaning sound reliable authentic by humans not by Allaah.
All hadith stories that are opposite to what Allaah teaches in the Quran are fake invented stories.
It is Allaah in the Quran who shows which “Sahih” meaning sound reliable authentic hadith are fake invented stories.
It is now hard to know which hadith stories are true and which are invented as explained above so test each hadith story with the Quran.
This analysis is required for every hadith story so that it can be examined in the light of what Allaah is teaching in the Quran.
Misguidance comes by forcing the Quran to agree with hadith stories that did not come from the messenger Muhammad or forcing the Gospel Injil to agree with stories that did not come from the messenger Jesus Isa.
When the Gospel Injil is forced to agree with the story that “Jesus Isa is Allaah” which is nowhere to be found in any of the four Gospel Injil of Jesus Isa by Mark, Matthew, Luke and John the result is that the words of Allaah are corrupted in the human mind because humans are forcing words in the Gospel Injil to have meanings that are not stated by Allaah in the Gospel Injil.
When the Quran is forced to agree with the story that “Jesus Isa is returning to this earth” or “Punishment in the grave” which is nowhere to be found in the Quran the result is that the words of Allaah are corrupted in the human mind because humans are forcing words in the Quran to have meanings that are not stated by Allaah in the Quran.
This corruption of the words of Allaah “in the human mind” is the same distortion or hiding of the words in the Torah Taurat which the Quran mentions.
The Quran never says the written word of Allaah which is with the Jews or with the Christians were changed because that would be proof that Allaah does not exist meaning the words of Allaah can only be corrupted and hidden and distorted inside the human mind.
See 1. Muslims in the first 350 years of Islam believed the Torah Taurat
http://www.judaism-islam.com/islam-teaches-torah-is-corrupted-tahrif-but-what-does-that-mean/
See 2. Allaah protects the Torah Taurat and the Gospel Injil of Jesus Isa by Mark, Matthew, Luke and John and the Quran
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/allaah-protects-the-taurat-injil-and-quran
F. Examine what hadith stories teach by the words of Allaah in the Quran.
G. Explain why the hadith story and the Quran are in agreement or disagreement.
H. Due to the widespread fabrication of hadith stories described in C, D and E above it might not be possible to know if Prophet Muhammad really used the words reported in hadith stories however if we interpret every hadith story according to what the Quran teaches then our knowledge in how to examine a hadith story and our understanding of how we can apply such knowledge in our everyday life will increase Allaah willing inshallah.
I. On the Day of Judgement no one would be happy if Prophet Muhammad denies he said the words reported in some hadith stories so the safest thing to do is to use hadith stories as examples without claiming they are the words of the Prophet and then use the Quran to examine what the hadith story is teaching as we have done in this example.
Learning to critically examine hadith stories will help Muslims to avoid believing false stories by knowing how to use the Quran to examine what a story is teaching.
Such training will help Muslims to examine their daily lives in relation to the Quran in the same way they examine hadith stories in relation to what the Quran teaches.
Knowing how to critically examine information will help Muslims avoid being easily misled by people who are not following the teachings in the Quran Allaah willing inshallah.
J. Both true and false hadith stories have great value if they are used as examples that teach Muslim students how to critically analysis the meaning of hadith stories and then analysis how they agree or disagree with what Allaah is teaching in the Quran.
If hadith stories agree with the Quran then accept it and learn from it.
If hadith stories do not agree with the Quran then reject it and also learn from it.
On the Day of Judgement Allaah judges by the words in the protected Quran.
On the Day of Judgement Allaah does not judge by the words in unprotected human hadith stories.
The Quran is the protected word of Allaah including the words and actions of Prophet Muhammad which are described and protected by Allaah.
Example 2.
What is the meaning of “Do not curse fever. Verily, it removes the sins of the children of Adam just as a furnace removes dirt from iron”
Jabir reported: The Messenger of Allaah, peace and blessings be upon him, entered the home of Umm Sa’ib and he said, “What ails you, O Umm Sa’ib? You are shivering.” She said, “It is a fever. Allaah has not blessed it.” The Prophet said, “Do not curse fever. Verily, it removes the sins of the children of Adam just as a furnace removes dirt from iron.”
Source: Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 2575
Grade: Sahih (authentic) according to Muslim.
Reference https://www.abuaminaelias.com/dailyhadithonline/2014/01/29/do-not-curse-fever-expiation/
1. Test the hadith story with the Quran.
a. “Do not curse a fever …”
This agrees with the Quran in that “Do not curse a fever” in the hadith is like “speak with good words” in the Quran.
Quran 17:53 Koran 17:53 Tell My (Allaah’s) servants (the humans) to speak in the best manner (with good words) because Satan Shaitan makes disagreement among them (humans). Satan Shaitan is an open enemy against humans.
b. Verily, it removes the sins of the children of Adam.
Meaning “… certainly using good words (instead of bad words) and patient (instead of impatient) during hardship removes the sins of humans ...”
This agrees with the Quran where good deeds can remove bad deeds when a person repents for their sin to Allaah and compensates those they have wronged.
Good deeds meaning good behaviour can be used by Allaah to forgive bad behaviour when Allaah decrees judgement in the hereafter.
Quran 2:177 Koran 2:177 It is not (a sign of) righteousness if you turn your faces towards the East or the West (in prayer), but righteousness is this, that one should believe in Allaah and the Last Day and the Angels and the Book (the Quran) and (all) the Prophets and give away (your) wealth out of love for Him (Allaah) to your near relations and the orphans and the needy and the traveller and those who ask for help and for the freedom of captives and keep up prayer and pay the tax to help the poor (Zakah) and fulfill agreements that have been promised, and those who are patient in times of distress, sickness and in time of conflicts, these are the people who fear and obey (Allaah).
Quran 2:153 Koran 2:153 “… Allaah is with the patient.”
Quran 2:155 Koran 2:155 And We (Allaah) shall test you with some fear and hunger and loss of wealth and (loss of) lives and (loss of) property but (We Allaah) give good news (of Paradise in the hereafter) to those who are patient.
Quran 2:250 Koran 2:250 When they (the small force who believed among the children of Israel) advanced to meet (their enemy) Goliath Jalut and his forces, they prayed, "Our Lord, make us patient (to endure hardship) and make our steps steadfast (firm) and give us help against the people that have no faith."
Quran 67:2 Koran 67:2 (It is Allaah) who has created life and death (meaning, Allaah has created you) to test which of you is best in behavior. He (Allaah) is mighty and forgiving.
Quran 70:5 Koran 70:5 So (Prophet Muhammad) be patient by being gracious in (your) patience (towards the stone idol worshippers in Makkah).
Quran 73:10 Koran 73:10 And have patience with what they (the stone idol worshippers in Makkah) say and when you leave them be polite (to them).
Quran 90:17 Koran 90:17 And be a person who believes (in Allaah who is your creator) and encourage each other to be patient and to show compassion.
Quran 103:2 Koran 103:2 Humans are lost (from the mercy of Allaah) –
Quran 103:3 Koran 103:3 Except those who believe and who do righteous deeds and who encourage each other to the truth and encourage each other to have patience.
c. “… just as a furnace removes dirt from iron.”
This agrees with the Quran in that “just as a furnace removes dirt from iron” in the hadith is like “just as obeying Allaah cleans a person of their sin” in the Quran.
Quran 26:88 Koran 26:88 “The day (of Resurrection) when wealth and sons do not help (any person).”
Quran 26:89 Koran 26:89 “Except the person who brings to Allaah a sound heart (a heart that loves and fears Allaah and contains good deeds from good behaviour in the first life).”
Note 1. Belief is not sufficient to save anyone in the hereafter.
Satan Shaitan believes in the hereafter but that shall not save him from the fire in the hereafter.
Satan Shaitan believes in Allaah but that shall not save him from the fire in the hereafter.
Belief without righteous deeds is a false belief in the eyes of Allaah.
Quran 39:53 Koran 39:53 Say, “My (Allaah’s) servants who have transgressed against themselves, Do not despair of the (thought that you have lost the) mercy of Allaah because Allaah forgives all sins (if you repent and correct yourself and ask Allaah’s forgiveness). He (Allaah) is forgiving and merciful
Note 1. The people who are described in Quran 4:93 in d below and in any other sin should not lose hope if they sincerely repent to Allaah and compensate those they have wronged and correct their behaviour.
Allaah will judge everyone according to their sincerity to Allaah and their deeds in this world.
Quran 87:14 Koran 87:14 The person who cleans them self (of their sins through repentance and praying to Allaah for forgiveness) shall succeed (in the hereafter) –
Quran 91:8 Koran 91:8 And (I Allaah swear to the truth by Myself) who inspired its (the human souls) wickedness (according to its evil deeds) and its righteousness (according to its good deeds).
Note 1. Allaah swears by His name.
Quran 91:9 Koran 91:9 (And for the human to understand that) the person who cleans it (the soul of its sins) has succeeded (in the hereafter).
Note 1. Allaah swears that the person who is clean of wrong doing will succeed in the hereafter.
Quran 91:10 Koran 91:10 And (for the human to understand that) the person who corrupts it (the soul with sin) has failed (in the hereafter).
Note 1. Allaah swears that the wrong doer will fail in the hereafter.
d. Important note.
It is important to make a note at the end of this hadith story that:
Firstly the Quran says sin is removed by faith in Allaah and doing good deeds meaning having faith without good deeds does not remove sin and doing good deeds without faith does not remove sin.
Secondly the Quran shows that faith without good deeds is a false belief in Allaah.
Satan Shaitan believes in Allaah and in the angels and in the Day of Resurrection but he will not go to Paradise Jannah because his belief in Allaah is a false belief and the proof is he does not do good deeds in this world meaning his home will be in Hell Jahannam because Satan Shaitan never sincerely asks Allaah for forgiveness and his deeds are bad meaning he has a false belief in Allaah.
Quran 4:93 Koran 4:93 Whoever kills a believer (in Adonai Allaah Elohim God G-d Jehovah Yahweh YHWH) intentionally (meaning whoever among the Muslims kills a believer intentionally, see Quran 4:92 which is the punishment for a Muslim who unintentionally killed a Muslim) then his recompense (result) is Hell Jahannam, staying in it forever and Allaah's wrath will fall on him and He (Allaah will) curse him and He (Allaah) has prepared for him a great punishment (because whoever intentionally kills one innocent person Muslim or non Muslim it is as if that person killed all of humankind in the judgement of Allaah see Quran 5:32. Quran 6:158 confirms that "... belief in Allaah and the Day of Resurrection and Judgement shall not help any soul …. if in belief he or she did not earn good by doing righteous deeds in their life ...." meaning belief in Allaah without doing good deeds is a false belief in Allaah meaning belief in Allaah with good deeds is true belief in Allaah).
Note 1. Those who made any sin including the sin in Quran 4:93 should read Quran 39:56 in c above.
Quran 4:123 Koran 4:123 (Entry to Paradise Jannah) shall not be based on your (the Muslim's) desires or on the desires of the people of the Scripture (the Jews and the Christians). (Instead) whoever does wrong (on the earth) shall earn (the punishment for the wrong) and that person shall not find any protector or helper other than Allaah (in the hereafter).
Quran 6:158 Koran 6:158 "... belief in it (Allaah and the Day of Resurrection and Judgement) shall not help any soul …. if in belief (he or she) did not earn good (by doing righteous deeds in their life). ....”
Quran 41:8 Koran 41:8 “For those who believe and do good deeds, for them is an everlasting reward (in Paradise Jannah).”
2. Conclusion.
a. “Do not curse fever. Verily, it removes the sins of the children of Adam just as a furnace removes dirt from iron” means; speak with good words at all times especially difficult times (in 1a above) certainly using good words (instead of bad words) and patient (instead of impatient) during hardship removes the sins of humans (in 1b above) just as a furnace removes dirt from iron meaning just as obeying Allaah cleans a person of their sin (in 1c above).
b. The words in this hadith story have been interpreted by the words of Allaah in the Quran.
c. The hadith story and the Quran are in agreement.
d. Due to the widespread fabrication of hadith stories described in C, D and E in “A better way to study hadith stories” in 1 above it is not possible to know if Prophet Muhammad really used these words however if we interpret every hadith story with what the Quran teaches then our knowledge in how to examine a hadith story and our understanding of how we can apply such knowledge in our everyday life will increase Allaah willing inshallah.
e. See E, F, G, H, I and J in “A better way to study hadith stories” in example 1 above.
Example 3.
3. Why is stoning to death for adultery not in the Quran?
Forgiveness for all sins including adultery is in Quran 3:135 – 3:136, Quran 4:17 – 4:18, Quran 4:110 and Quran 25:68 – 25:71.
Allaah put the law of stoning to death for adultery in the Torah Taurat which is the protected word of Allaah for the Jewish people until the Day of Judgement so why did Allaah not put the law for stoning to death for adultery in the Quran if stoning to death for adultery is the protected word of Allaah for the people of Islam until the Day of Judgement?
Quran 3:93 Koran 3:93 “… Say (Prophet Muhammad, to the Jews of Yathrib), "Bring the Torah Taurat here and recite it (to me as evidence) if what you say is true."
Note 1. Allaah told Prophet Muhammad to ask the Jews to bring the Torah Taurat and recite their evidence from the Torah Taurat meaning the Torah Taurat which is with the Jewish people is protected by Allaah until the Day of Judgement.
Quran 5:43 Koran 5:43 How is it that they (the Jews of Yathrib Arabia) come to you (Prophet Muhammad) for judgment when they (the Jewish people) have the Torah Taurat in which Allaah has already revealed to them (the Jewish people) judgment …”
Note 1. Allaah tells the Jewish people to follow the judgements in the Torah Taurat which Allaah has given to them to follow until the Day of Judgement.
Quran 5:48 Koran 5:48 “…. For each (community of Jews, Christians and Muslims) We (Allaah) have appointed a divine law and a way (of religion). If Allaah willed He (Allaah) could have made you (the Jews, the Christians and the Muslims) one community. But He (Allaah) tests you (the Jews, the Christians and the Muslims) by what He (Allaah) has given you (in the Torah Taurat and the Gospel Injil and the Koran Quran to show who is best in behaviour). So strive for all that is good. To Allaah you shall all return and He (Allaah) shall then inform you (in the Hereafter) about (the correctness of) the religious matters in which you (the Jews, the Christians and the Muslims) argue among each other.
Note 1. Allaah is testing the Jews with the Torah Taurat and the Christians with the Gospel Injil of Jesus Isa by Mark, Matthew, Luke and John and the Muslims with the Quran and all will return to Allaah in the hereafter.
Quran 5:68 Koran 5:68 Say (Prophet Muhammad to the Jews of Yathrib in Arabia today in Medina, Saudi Arabia and to the Christians), “O People of the Scripture (the Jews and the Christians), You have nothing (of guidance) until you observe the Torah Taurat and the Gospel Injil and what has been revealed to you from your Lord ..."
Note 1. Allaah confirms that the Jewish people are to observe the Torah Taurat.
In Quran 2:106 and Quran 13:39 Allaah explains that the laws for the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat which are not in the Quran have been replaced with better or similar laws in the Quran as a mercy from Allaah for the people of Islam.
This means the laws for the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat such as stoning to death for adultery have been replaced with better or similar laws in the Quran as a mercy from Allaah to the Muslim people.
Quran 2:106 Koran 2:106 (Allaah says in 1 Samuel 15:29 Allaah does not change His mind promises covenants agreements because only humans change their mind promises covenants agreements so the Jews asked Prophet Muhammad about the Torah and the Quran. Allaah reveals) We (Allaah) do not abolish a verse (in the Torah for the Jewish people) or let it be forgotten (by the Jewish people until the Day of Judgement as Allaah promised in Quran 2:40 - 2:41, Quran 2:62, Quran 3:113 - 3:115, Quran 5:69, Exodus 2:24, Leviticus 26:4 - 26:45, Deuteronomy 4:2, Deuteronomy 4:31, Deuteronomy 5:10, Deuteronomy 7:7 - 7:8, Deuteronomy 12:1, Deuteronomy 29:28 in Jewish Tanakh or Deuteronomy 29:29 in a Christian Bible, 2 King 13:23, Psalm 19:8 - 19:12 in Jewish Tanakh or Psalm 19:7 - 19:11 in Christian Old Testament Bible, Psalm 111:7 - 111:9, Hosea 3:4 - 3:5, Daniel 12:2, Isaiah 59:21 is the promise to the Jewish people mentioned in Isaiah 36:11 and Isaiah 36:13 and Gospel of Matthew 5:17 - 5:20). We (Allaah) bring (to the Muslims in the Quran) something better than it or similar to it (confirming the Torah which is in the hands of the Jewish people until the Day of Judgement in Quran 2:40 - 2:41 and explaining the story of Jesus which is in the four reports that are in the hands of the Christian people until the Day of Judgement in Quran 5:46 - 5:47 and Allaah told the Jewish people to observe the Torah Taurat and told the Christians to observe the Gospel Injil in Quran 5:68. Allaah reminded the Jewish people in the Quran to observe the Sabbath and confirmed Prophet Ezra is a human servant of Allaah like every human is a willing or unwilling servant of Allaah. Allaah reminded the Christian people in the Quran that Prophet Jesus is a human servant of Allaah like every human is a willing or unwilling servant of Allaah). Do you not know that Allaah is capable of everything? (including protecting the Jewish Scriptures that are with the Jewish people until the Day of Judgement as shown in the story of the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran chapter 37 where Allaah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq and leaves no other blessings in the story of the sacrifice and this famous vision dream is remembered in the next chapter Quran chapter 38 where Allaah blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq with the vision dream in Quran 38:45 – 38:47 and shows in the next verse that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not the son in the vision dream and Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not living with his father during the vision dream by blessing Prophet Ishmael Ismail without his father and without the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:48. This is confirmed in Quran 12:6 and in Torah Genesis 22:2 “And Allaah said: Take now your son, your only son” who still lives with you, reminding him that Allaah had earlier taken Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar away from him into Allaah’s care in the desert, “whom you love” Allaah makes the test very hard by demanding his second son and reminding him that this is his only remaining son and reminding him that he already gave Allaah one son and reminding him of his love for these sons, “even” namely, that is “Isaac Ishaq and go into the land of Moriah” today in the Temple and Al-Aqsa mosque area in Jerusalem Al-Quds in Israel and Palestine; “and offer him there for a burnt-offering on one of the mountains which I Allaah will tell you of.” The proof Allaah is real is the Quran confirming the Torah Taurat is correct in Quran 2:41 “And believe in what I Allaah have revealed” in the Quran “that confirms what you already have” in the Torah Taurat and in Quran 3:93 “… Bring the Torah Taurat here and recite it as evidence if what you say is true" and in Quran 5:43 “How is it that they come to you for judgment when they have the Torah Taurat in which Allaah has already revealed to them judgment …” and Quran 5:68 “… You the Jewish people have nothing until you observe the Torah Taurat …” as explained in this video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kQ3o3ybc-KA so hold tightly to what Allaah is teaching in the Quran and beware of stories which contradict the Books of Allaah. Allaah explains the story of Jesus which is in the hands of the Christian people by explaining in the Quran what the human eye could not see without adding anything to the story in the Gospel of what the human eye saw in the story of Prophet Jesus Isa in Quran 3:144 see Quran 5:75, Quran 4:157, Quran 4:158 see Quran 39:42, Quran 5:75 see Quran 3:144, Quran 5:117 see Quran 7:6, Quran 7:6 see Quran 5:117, Quran 21:95 see Quran 23:99 – 23:100, Quran 33:40 see Gospel of Jesus Isa by Mark 13:5 – 13:6, 13:21 – 13:22 and Quran 39:42 see Quran 4:158. In Quran 3:144 and Quran 5:75 see “passed away” in the Quran always means died see in Quran 2:134 and Quran 2:141 and Quran 7:38 and Quran 13:30 and Quran 41:25 and Quran 46:17. The Quran gives humans freedom to find their religion).
Note 1. In Quran 2:106 Allaah says the Quran is similar to what is with the Jewish people or better and this is explained in Quran 13:39 where Allaah does not include in the Quran some laws that are binding only on the Jewish people.
See Quran 2:40 comments.
Quran 13:39 Koran 13:39 (In 1 Samuel 15:29 Allaah does not change His mind promises covenants agreements because only humans change their mind promises covenants agreements so the Jews asked Prophet Muhammad about the Torah and the Quran. Allaah revealed that Allaah confirms His covenant with the Jewish people in Quran 2:40 - 2:41 which is the Torah Taurat until the Day of Judgement as Allaah promised in Quran 2:40 - 2:41, Quran 2:62, Quran 3:113 - 3:115, Quran 5:69, Exodus 2:24, Leviticus 26:44 - 26:45, Deuteronomy 4:2, Deuteronomy 4:31, Deuteronomy 5:10, Deuteronomy 7:7 - 7:8, Deuteronomy 12:1, Deuteronomy 29:28 in Jewish Tanakh or Deuteronomy 29:29 in a Christian Bible, 2 King 13:23, Psalm 19:8 - 19:12 in Jewish Tanakh or Psalm 19:7 - 19:11 in Christian Old Testament Bible, Psalm 111:7 - 111:9, Hosea 3:4 - 3:5, Daniel 12:2, Isaiah 59:21 is the promise to the Jewish people mentioned in Isaiah 36:11, Isaiah 36:13 and Gospel of Matthew 5:17 - 5:20 and Allaah revealed that) Allaah eliminates (from the Quran the laws which are only binding on the Jewish people such as the Sabbath Day) and confirms what He (Allaah) wills (in the Quran which confirms the Torah which is in the hands of the Jewish people until the Day of Judgement in Quran 2:40 - 2:41 and explaining the story of Jesus which is in the four reports that are in the hands of the Christian people until the Day of Judgement in Quran 5:46 - 5:47 and Allaah told the Jewish people to observe the Torah Taurat and told the Christians to observe the Gospel Injil in Quran 5:68. Allaah reminded the Jewish people in the Quran to observe the Sabbath and confirmed Prophet Ezra is a human servant of Allaah like every human is a willing or unwilling servant of Allaah. Allaah reminded the Christian people in the Quran that Prophet Jesus is a human servant of Allaah like every human is a willing or unwilling servant of Allaah) and with Him (Allaah) is the Mother of the Book (the Preserved Tablet, Al-Lauh al-Mahfuz which contains the basis of each Scripture as Allaah intended in the Torah Taurat for the Jews and the four reports about Jesus Isa in the Gospel of Jesus Isa by Mark, Matthew, Luke and John which are with the Christians and the Quran which is with the Muslims as explained in Quran 2:106, Quran 5:48 and Quran 7:170. Allaah protects the Jewish Scriptures that are with the Jewish people until the Day of Judgement as shown in the story of the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran chapter 37 where Allaah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq and leaves no other blessings in the story of the sacrifice and this famous vision dream is remembered in the next chapter Quran chapter 38 where Allaah blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq with the vision dream in Quran 38:45 – 38:47 and shows in the next verse that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not the son in the vision dream and Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not living with his father during the vision dream by blessing Prophet Ishmael Ismail without his father and without the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:48. This is confirmed in Quran 12:6 and in Torah Genesis 22:2 “And Allaah said: Take now your son, your only son” who still lives with you, reminding him that Allaah had earlier taken Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar away from him into Allaah’s care in the desert, “whom you love” Allaah makes the test very hard by demanding his second son and reminding him that this is his only remaining son and reminding him that he already gave Allaah one son and reminding him of his love for these sons, “even” namely, that is “Isaac Ishaq and go into the land of Moriah” today in the Temple and Al-Aqsa mosque area in Jerusalem Al-Quds in Israel and Palestine; “and offer him there for a burnt-offering on one of the mountains which I Allaah will tell you of.” The proof Allaah is real is the Quran confirming the Torah Taurat is correct in Quran 2:41 “And believe in what I Allaah have revealed” in the Quran “that confirms what you already have” in the Torah Taurat and in Quran 3:93 “… Bring the Torah Taurat here and recite it as evidence if what you say is true" and in Quran 5:43 “How is it that they come to you for judgment when they have the Torah Taurat in which Allaah has already revealed to them judgment …” and Quran 5:68 “… You the Jewish people have nothing until you observe the Torah Taurat …” as explained in this video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kQ3o3ybc-KA so hold tightly to what Allaah is teaching in the Quran and beware of stories which contradict the Books of Allaah. Allaah explains the story of Jesus which is in the hands of the Christian people by explaining in the Quran what the human eye could not see without adding anything to the story in the Gospel of what the human eye saw in the story of Prophet Jesus Isa in Quran 3:144 see Quran 5:75, Quran 4:157, Quran 4:158 see Quran 39:42, Quran 5:75 see Quran 3:144, Quran 5:117 see Quran 7:6, Quran 7:6 see Quran 5:117, Quran 21:95 see Quran 23:99 – 23:100, Quran 33:40 see Gospel of Jesus Isa by Mark 13:5 – 13:6, 13:21 – 13:22 and Quran 39:42 see Quran 4:158. In Quran 3:144 and Quran 5:75 see “passed away” in the Quran always means died see in Quran 2:134 and Quran 2:141 and Quran 7:38 and Quran 13:30 and Quran 41:25 and Quran 46:17. The Quran gives humans freedom to find their religion).
Note 1. In Quran 2:106 Allaah says the Quran is similar to what is with the Jewish people or better and this is explained in Quran 13:39 where Allaah does not include in the Quran some laws that are binding only on the Jewish people.
3-1. What is the law for adultery in the Quran which is a mercy from Allaah for the people of Islam?
3-1a. In the Quran the law for illegal sexual intercourse by unmarried Muslims is Quran 4:15 – 4:18.
Quran 4:15 Koran 4:15 And those of your (unmarried, see Quran 4:25 which refers to married people who have a different punishment) women who commit obscenity (fahishah, fornication, illegal sexual intercourse) take the evidence against them from four (reliable male) witnesses from amongst you and if they testify (that they saw the actual sexual penetration), confine them (the women) to houses until death comes to them (meaning, take good care of them and confine them in their houses indefinitely) or (until) Allaah provides for them some (other) way (out of the punishment, such as if they repent by promising Allaah that they shall not repeat their behaviour and correct themselves with good behaviour as is revealed in Quran 4:16). – (Continued in Quran 4:16).
Note 1. Why does Quran 4:15 only mention women?
Quran 4:15 refers only to women because the first question about punishment came from men asking about the penalty for women.
Quran 4:16 was revealed immediately after to confirm that both men and women receive similar punishment and similar forgiveness.
Note 2. How do we know that Quran 4:15 is a punishment for unmarried women?
Quran 4:15 and Quran 4:16 refers to unmarried women because the more severe punishment for married women is given in Quran 4:25.
Note 3. How do we know that Quran 4:15 is not about a death penalty?
Quran 4:15 is not talking about a death penalty and this is clear in the next verse Quran 4:16 where Allaah reveals Quran 4:16 “... And if they repent (by promising Allaah that they shall not repeat their behaviour) and correct themselves (with good behaviour) then leave them alone, for Allaah is the one who accepts repentance and (Allaah is) most merciful.
Note 4. In Quran 4:15 Allaah revealed the punishment for unmarried women who commit illegal sexual intercourse. Then in Quran 4:16 Allaah reveals that both unmarried men and unmarried women who commit illegal sexual intercourse receive the same punishment.
Note 5. After Quran 4:15 was revealed Allaah then revealed Quran 4:16 which explained “the (other) way (out of the punishment of illegal sexual intercourse by unmarried people).”
Note 6. There has been a lot of confusion about the meaning of Quran 4:15 because people have looked at the word of Allaah not to understand it but to try and put a hadith story from humans about stoning to death for adultery into the Quran.
Some people have said Quran 4:15 – 4:16 is beyond their understanding and understanding is not needed because Quran 4:15 – 4:16 was replaced by stoning to death for adultery.
Allaah answers them in Quran 77:50 asking who will believe the Quran and who will believe a teaching that is different to what Allaah teaches in the Quran?
Quran 77:50 Koran 77:50 In what statement (words, news, reports, information, message, hadith), after it (the verses of Allaah in the Quran), shall they (the humans and the jinn) believe?
Note. Quran 7:185, Quran 25:29, Quran 25:30, Quran 31:6, Quran 39:23, Quran 45:6 and Quran 77:50 asks when you have the word of Allaah in the Quran what other report would you believe?
See Quran 25:30 comments with examples of hadith stories which contradict the teachings of Allaah in Quran chapter 25.
Quran 4:16 Koran 4:16 – And the two persons (unmarried male and unmarried female, see Quran 4:25 which refers to married people who have a different punishment) who commit it (“it” refers to the word fahishah, fornication, illegal sexual intercourse in Quran 4:15) among you, punish them both (by confining them in houses or jail as commanded in Quran 4:15). And (as mentioned in Quran 4:15 Allaah has now made for them a way out of this punishment) if they repent (by promising Allaah that they shall not repeat their behaviour) and correct themselves (with good behaviour) then leave them alone, for Allaah is the one who accepts repentance and (Allaah is) most merciful. – (Continued in Quran 4:17).
Punishment and forgiveness in the Quran for illegal sexual intercourse by unmarried Muslims.
Note 1. Quran 4:16 was added after Quran 4:15 was revealed.
Note 2. Quran 4:15 and Quran 4:16 are talking about exactly the same offence of illegal sexual intercourse between unmarried men and unmarried women.
Note 3. Quran 4:15 and Quran 4:16 refers to unmarried people as is shown in Quran 4:25 which refers to married people who receive a more severe punishment.
Note 4. After Quran 4:15 was revealed Allaah then revealed Quran 4:16 which explained “the (other) way (out of the punishment of illegal sexual intercourse by unmarried people).”
This shows that the following hadith story was invented after the death of Prophet Muhammad by someone who did not understand that Quran 4:16 is “the way (out of the punishment)” which Quran 4:15 mentioned.
Hadith story collected by Sahih Muslim, Book 017, Hadith number 4191.
'Ubada b. as-Samit reported: Allaah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) as saying: Receive teaching from me, receive teaching from me. Allaah has ordained a way for those women. When an unmarried male commits adultery with an unmarried female, they should receive one hundred lashes and banishment for one year. And in case of married male committing adultery with a married female, they shall receive one hundred lashes and be stoned to death.
Note 1. This hadith refers to “or until Allaah provides for them a way” in Quran 4:15 without understanding that Allaah revealed “a way” in the next verse Quran 4:16 as proof that this hadith story was invented after the death of Prophet Muhammad.
Note 2. In Quran 4:15 “Provides for them a way” is not talking about a death penalty and this is made clear with the ruling or “the way” in the next verse Quran 4:16 “punish them both (by confining them in houses or jail as commanded in Quran 4:15). And (as mentioned in Quran 4:15 Allaah has now made for them a way out of this punishment) if they repent (by promising Allaah that they shall not repeat their behaviour) and correct themselves (with good behaviour) then leave them alone, for Allaah is the one who accepts repentance and (Allaah is) most merciful.
Note 3. For humans to give or to receive a hundred lashes followed by stoning to death is impossible to believe and is not in the Quran because it exceeds the limits of acceptable human behaviour and shows that this hadith story was invented after the death of Prophet Muhammad.
Quran 4:17 Koran 4:17 – Allaah accepts only the repentance of those who sin out of ignorance (that means a sin that is not planned intentionally) and who repent (sincerely regret what they have done) soon after (the sin). Allaah shall forgive them. Allaah is all knowing and all wise. – (Continued in Quran 4:18).
Punishment and forgiveness in the Quran for illegal sexual intercourse by unmarried Muslims.
Note 1. Quran 4:17 – 4:18 confirms that Allaah’s mercy and forgiveness includes illegal sexual intercourse by unmarried people who sincerely repent.
Allaah’s mercy and forgiveness in Quran 4:17 – 4:18 follows after Quran 4:15 – 4:16 which describes the punishment for illegal sexual intercourse by unmarried people.
Note 2. Allaah’s mercy and forgiveness includes adultery which is illegal sexual intercourse by married people who sincerely repent as confirmed in Quran 3:135 – 3:136, 4:17 – 4:18, 4:110 and 25:68 – 25:71.
Quran 4:18 Koran 4:18 And the forgiveness (of Allaah) is not for those who continue to do evil deeds until death faces one of them and the person says, "Now I repent" nor for those who die while they are disbelievers (in Allaah). For them We (Allaah) have prepared a painful punishment (in the hereafter).
Punishment and forgiveness in the Quran for illegal sexual intercourse by unmarried Muslims.
Note 1. See Quran 4:17 comments above.
3-1b. In the Quran the law for adultery by married Muslims is Quran 4:25 and 24:1 – 24:2.
Quran 4:25 Koran 4:25 And if you do not have the means (not wealthy enough) to marry free believing women then you may marry believing girls from among those (slave girls) whom your right hands possess (meaning whom you own). Allaah has full knowledge about your faith. You (humans are offspring) from (one) another (meaning you are equal in the sight of Allaah). You shall obtain permission from their guardians before you marry them and give them (the girl) their bridal money according to what is reasonable. The (slave girl) should be chaste (and not) commit unlawful intercourse randomly (prostitution) nor have secret lovers. After marriage if she commits illegal sexual intercourse (fahishah, illegal sexual intercourse after marriage, adultery) then her punishment is half of that of a free (married) women (meaning a punishment of fifty lashes). This (rule from Allaah) is for those who are afraid of committing sin (afraid they might commit illegal sexual intercourse if they do not marry someone) but it is better for you to be patient. Allaah is always ready to forgive and most merciful (to those who sincerely repent for their sins).
Note 1. Quran 4:25 is about a married person who commits adultery.
Quran 4:25 is about a married person whose punishment is not the punishment of an unmarried person such as in Quran 4:15 and Quran 4:16.
Note 2. Quran 4:25 is about a married person whose punishment is half of the punishment for a married person which is in Quran 24:1 – 24:2.
Note 3. In Quran 4:25 Allaah tells us that for a married slave girl “After marriage if she commits illegal sexual intercourse (fahishah, illegal sexual intercourse after marriage, adultery) then her punishment is half of that of free women (meaning a punishment of fifty lashes)” and “Allaah has full knowledge about your faith and you are equal to one another as far as religion is concerned …”
This shows that 100 lashes is the punishment for any (married) adulterer or adulteress who is a free person. However for a girl who was a slave when she married the punishment is halved to 50 lashes.
Note 4. Punishment for adultery is halved for a girl who was a slave when she married shows that the punishment for a married person who commits adultery is not stoning to death because no one can halve the punishment of stoning to death.
Where is the justice in killing a free married woman but not killing a woman who was a slave at the time of her marriage who does the same crime of adultery meaning death for a Muslim who is a free woman and only 50 lashes for a Muslim who was a slave when she married and did the same crime make no sense.
The adultery punishment of 100 lashes for a married free Muslim in Quran 24:2 and 50 lashes for a Muslim who was a slave when she married in Quran 4:25 make sense and this is exactly what the Quran commands.
Note 5. Why is the punishment for adultery halved for a girl who was a slave when she married?
A girl who was a slave when she agreed to marriage compared to a free girl have the punishment for adultery halved because in accepting marriage it is uncertain if the reason for such acceptance is the desire for marriage or the desire for freedom from slavery.
Some people say that the punishment in Quran 4:25 is half of that of free UNMARRIED women but that is not what Allaah has said.
Allaah is telling us about a slave who has MARRIED and her punishment for adultery is “half of that of a free” MARRIED “woman.”
Allaah has said about the slave girl and her free husband in Quran 4:25, “You are equal to one another as far as religion is concerned.”
To justify believing hadith stories from humans that claims stoning to death is the punishment for adultery people are adding to what Allaah has not ordered in Allaah’s Holy Quran so that they can reject what Allaah says in Allaah’s protected Quran and instead believe hadith stories from humans that Allaah gave no guarantee to protect from Satan Shaitan.
However Allaah guarantees that Allaah’s Quran is protected, guaranteed and correct and Allaah guarantees that you shall never go astray if you hold tightly to Allaah’s Quran.
In the hereafter who shall succeed?
Is it the person who holds tightly to Allaah’s word in Allaah’s holy book or the person who believes hadith stories that are against what Allaah has ordered in Allaah’s holy book?
Quran 77:50 Koran 77:50 In what statement (words, news, reports, information, message, hadith), after it (the verses of Allaah in the Quran), shall they (the humans and the jinn) believe?
Note. Quran 7:185, Quran 25:29, Quran 25:30, Quran 31:6, Quran 39:23, Quran 45:6 and Quran 77:50 asks when you have the word of Allaah in the Quran what other report would you believe?
See Quran 25:30 comments with examples of hadith stories which contradict the teachings of Allaah in Quran chapter 25.
Note 6. If stoning to death for adultery is true why did Allaah not order a punishment of 100 lashes for girls who commit adultery and were slaves at the time of their marriage?
Certainly 100 lashes is nothing compared to being stoned to death?
This shows that 100 lashes are Allaah’s punishment for adultery committed by free married women because the punishment for those who were slaves when they accepted marriage and later committed adultery is 50 lashes which is half the punishment of free married people who commit adultery.
Note 7. Allaah did not order “stoning to death for adultery” in Allaah’s Holy Quran just as Allaah did not order belief in “trinity” in the Gospel Injil of Jesus Isa by Mark, Matthew, Luke and John which shows how those who believe stories that are opposite to what Allaah teaches go astray in their understanding of the words of Allaah which are written in His Books.
Allaah tests the Jews and the Christians and the Muslims to show who believe Allaah’s word in Allaah’s Holy Books and who believe the word of humans in hadith stories which are opposite to what Allaah teaches in His books.
Note 8. Quran 24:1 – 24:2 decrees 100 lashes as Allaah’s punishment for free married women who have committed adultery.
Girls who were slaves when they accepted marriage and then commit adultery have half that punishment (50 lashes) because in accepting marriage it is uncertain if the reason for such acceptance is the desire for marriage or the desire for freedom from slavery.
Quran 24:1 Koran 24:1 We (Allaah through Angel Gabriel Jibril to Prophet Muhammad) have revealed this chapter which We (Allaah) have made a duty (for humans to obey) and in which We (Allaah) have revealed clear signs (in verses, as evidence, as proofs, in lessons) so that you remember (to follow what Allaah has commanded in this chapter).
Quran 24:2 Koran 24:2 The (married) woman and the man (who voluntarily confess to illegal sexual intercourse or who are seen by four male witnesses in the act of being) guilty of (doing illegal) sexual intercourse, flog each one of them with a hundred lashes. Do not let pity for them stop you from obedience to (the law of) Allaah, if you believe in Allaah and the Last Day. And let a group of believers witness the punishment.
Note 1. Where does Allaah reveal that Quran 24:2 is for married men and women who commit illegal sexual intercourse?
Quran 4:25 reveals that Quran 24:2 is for married men and women.
Quran 4:25 confirms that Allaah has not commanded stoning to death for free married persons who commit adultery.
See Quran 4:15 and Quran 4:16 and Quran 4:25 in 3-1a above.
3-1c. Forgiveness for all sins including adultery is in Quran 3:135 – 3:136, 4:17 – 4:18, 4:110 and 25:68 – 25:71.
Quran 3:135 Koran 3:135 And those (people) when they did immorality (evil behaviour, adultery, dishonesty, wickedness) or wronged their own soul (by some wrong doing) and remember Allaah and then ask forgiveness for their sins (from Allaah) because who can forgive the sins except Allaah? And do not knowingly continue in what they have done (thinking it shall be forgiven. Continued in Quran 3:136).
Quran 3:136 Koran 3:136 – For those (people), the reward is forgiveness from their Lord and gardens where rivers flow underneath (in Paradise) and where they shall live forever. (This is) an excellent reward for the workers (that are working for the reward of Paradise in the hereafter).
Note 1. Forgiveness for all sins is given by Allaah the most merciful, to those who truly repent and who ask Allaah for forgiveness and do not continue doing that sin (Quran 3:135 – 3:136).
Note 2. There is no stoning to death for adultery because the forgiveness of Allaah includes the decree that the sinner does not continue sinning which means their life continues after they have asked Allaah for forgiveness.
Quran 4:17 Koran 4:17 see in 3-1a above.
Quran 4:18 Koran 4:18 see in 3-1a above.
Quran 4:110 Koran 4:110 – Yet whoever wrongs (by making a sin that harms others) or wrongs them self (by making a sin that harms oneself, a sin that harms your soul) and then asks forgiveness from Allaah then that person shall find Allaah is always ready to forgive and most merciful.
Note 1. There is nothing that Allaah is not ready to forgive if you sincerely repent and ask Allaah for forgiveness. This includes illegal sexual intercourse by unmarried Muslims and adultery by married Muslims.
Quran 25:68 Koran 25:68 – And those who do not pray to any other god along with Allaah, nor kill someone who Allaah has forbidden (to be killed) except in the right (by accident, by self defence, in battle against the oppression of religion under the wisdom and command of the Prophet of Allaah and his companions), nor commit illegal sexual intercourse. And who ever does that shall pay a penalty. – (Continued Quran 25:69).
Note 1. See Quran 25:69 - 25:70
Quran 25:69 Koran 25:69 – The punishment shall be doubled for them on the Day of Resurrection and they shall live there in disgrace. – (Continued Quran 25:70).
Note 1. See Quran 25:70
Quran 25:70 Koran 25:70 – Unless that person repents and believes (in Allaah) and does righteous work then Allaah shall change their evil deeds to good deeds. Allaah is always ready to forgive and (Allaah is) merciful.
Note 1. Allaah knew there would be disagreement over the punishment of adultery and stoning to death for adultery in Quran chapter 24 and makes things clear in the next chapter 25
Allaah knows the past present and future.
Allaah decreed how each chapter of the Quran would be numbered.
After the story of the punishment for adultery in Quran chapter 24 Allaah confirms in the next chapter Quran chapter 25 that there is no death penalty for adultery in Quran 25:68 – Quran 25:71 because after the sin Allaah says they repent and “do righteous work” meaning there is no death penalty for illegal sexual intercourse in Quran 25:69 - 25:71.
This is similar to the way in which after the story of the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim described in Quran chapter 37 Allaah in the next chapter in Quran 38:45 – 38:48 names the father and the son in the story of the vision dream in Quran 38:45 – 38:47 and clearly shows it was not Prophet Ishmael Ismail in Quran 38:48.
See Quran 38:45 – 38:48 comments in Quran chapter 38.
Quran 25:71 Koran 25:71 And whoever repents and does righteousness then that person surely turns to Allaah with true repentance (that is accepted by Allaah the Most Merciful).
Note 1. Whoever repents and does righteousness he surely turns to Allaah with true repentance that is accepted by Allaah the Most Merciful means there is no death for adultery in Quran 25:68 – 25:71 because after repenting Allaah has ordered humans to do righteous deeds in Quran 25:71.
There is no sexual sin that Allaah does not forgive for those who repent to Allaah including adultery.
Punishment in this world and in the hereafter is not for those who have repented for corruption and waging war against the messenger of Allaah in Quran 5:33 – 5:34 or repented for the corruption of theft in Quran 5:38 – 5:39 below.
In the same way punishment in this world and in the hereafter is not for those who have repented for the corruption of adultery in Quran 3:135 – 3:136, 4:17 – 4:18, 4:110 and 25:68 – 25:71 above.
Quran 5:33 Koran 5:33 The only recompense (the only result) for those (like the Pharaoh Firon) who wage war (against) Allaah and His Messenger (Prophet Moses Musa) and strive in the earth spreading corruption is that they (the Pharaoh Firon) be killed (because the Pharaoh Firon killed innocent people violating Quran 5:32 revealed to the children of Israel and now revealed to the Muslims) or they (the Pharaoh Firon) be crucified (because the Pharaoh Firon crucified innocent people violating Quran 5:32 revealed to the children of Israel and now revealed to the Muslims) or be cut off their hands and their feet on opposite sides (of the body because the Pharaoh Firon cut off their hands and their feet on opposite sides of the body of innocent people violating Quran 5:32 revealed to the children of Israel and now revealed to the Muslims) or they (the Pharaoh Firon) be exiled from the land (because the Pharaoh Firon exiled innocent people from the land violating Quran 2:84 revealed to the children of Israel and now revealed to the Muslims). That is disgrace for them (the Pharaoh Firon) in the world and for them is a great punishment in the Hereafter. – (Continued in Quran 5:34)
Quran 5:34 Koran 5:34 – Except for those who repent before they fall into your power, in their case know that Allaah is always ready to forgive and is most merciful.
Quran 5:38 Koran 5:38 As for the man or woman who commits theft, cut off their hands (except see Quran 5:39). It is the reward for what they did, a punishment that is a warning from Allaah (to others who think to steal). Allaah is all powerful and wise. – (Continued 5:39)
Quran 5:39 Koran 5:39 – But whoever repents after their wrongdoing and corrects their behaviour then surely Allaah shall pardon them. Allaah is forgiving and merciful.
Comment 1. Forgiveness.
Quran 5:39 states forgiveness and mercy for those who are sincerely sorry for theft in Quran 5:38. There are many examples where Prophet Muhammad forgave his biggest enemies who had fought against him or who had persecuted him but later sincerely asked for his forgiveness and was forgiven.
The crime of theft is a less serious crime compared to treachery against Allaah and his prophet.
The example of forgiveness for treachery against Allaah and his prophet shows that the same forgiveness is available for lesser crimes such as theft for those who sincerely repent.
3a. Why did Prophet Muhammad say about stoning to death for adultery “I cannot write it down anymore.”
The first time Allaah stopped stoning to death for adultery was when Prophet Muhammad said about the stoning to death verse “I cannot write it down anymore.”
Quran 2:106 and Quran 13:39 explain why stoning to death is in the Torah Taurat but not in the Quran meaning there is no stoning to death for adultery in Islam meaning there is no death penalty for adultery in Islam and this is confirmed in the words “I cannot write it down anymore.”
Hadith story collected by Abu Ya‘la al-Mawsili who died 307 AH recorded in his Musnad and al-Nasa`I who died 303 AH recorded in his Sunan record.
Imam ibn Kathir narrated the story hadith that, “people were sitting around Merwan and Zayd bin Thabit was also present.”
He (Zayd) said, “we used to recite in the Quran that punishment for married adulterer and adulteress is stoning to death.”
Merwan asked, “So why did you not write this in the Quran?”
He (Zayd) said “listen, when we started talking about this, we went to Umar bin Khattab and he told us, one man came to the Prophet and he started talking about the verse about stoning to death (ayah al rajm).”
Someone from the gathering asked “O Allaah’s messenger write this verse of stoning.”
Prophet Muhammad said “I cannot write it down anymore or something similar/same.”
Why was the verse about stoning to death for adultery al rajm no longer written?
In Quran chapter 24 Allaah explains to Prophet Muhammad that his Muslim people where not afraid to falsely accuse of illegal sexual intercourse Aishah who was the innocent wife of the prophet of Allaah.
Quran 24:12 Koran 24:12 Why did not the believers (both) men and women when you heard it (the lie that Aishah the wife of Prophet Muhammad had committed illegal sexual intercourse with another man) think good about your own people and say, “This is clearly a lie?”
It was only revelation from Allaah that allowed Prophet Muhammad to know the truth of Aishah’s innocence that saved the life of Aishah (if the punishment of stoning to death for adultery existed).
If such a false accusation had come after the death of Prophet Muhammad then an innocent woman would have been stoned to death (if the punishment of stoning to death for adultery existed).
Allaah clearly showed Prophet Muhammad the injustice that would happen after Prophet Muhammad left the earth.
If the people of Prophet Muhammad were not afraid to lie to the Prophet of Allaah then who would they be afraid of after Prophet Muhammad left the earth?
Prophet Muhammad understood why Allaah had brought adultery to him through his wife and Prophet Muhammad later said about stoning to death for adultery, “I cannot write it down anymore.”
The idea that “I cannot write it down anymore” is proof that this verse was not written but was implemented is not supported by the hadith story in 3c below where Zayd would not write the verse about stoning to death for adultery in the Quran because Umar was alone in his testimony meaning Zayd would have written down that verse in the Quran if a second person had testified meaning both Umar who gave testimony for it to be written and Zayd who was ready to write any verse for which he could find two people willing to testify shows that both did not consider the writing of that verse in the Quran as abrogated because this hadith shows that both were ready to write it meaning the idea of abrogation or the hadith story or both was invented after the time of Prophet Muhammad.
The idea of abrogation is also not supported in 3d below were Umar said “were it not that the people shall say I have inscribed in the Book of Allaah what is not there, I would have inscribed it as it was sent down” meaning if Umar thought the people in the general population would not object to him writing in the Quran then he would have written the verse about the stoning al rajam in the Quran meaning Umar did not consider the writing of that verse in the Quran as abrogated because he said he would write it meaning the idea of abrogation or the hadith story or both was invented after the time of Prophet Muhammad.
Hadith story collected by Sunan Al-Baihaqi - Classed Sahih by Baihaqi & Sheikh Albani In: Silsilat Al-Sahiha, 6/974 - Source. Also In Sunan Nasai, 3046.
"Narrated Zaid Bin Thabit:
We used to read: "The old man and the old woman."
Marwan said: "Shouldn't we write it down as part of the written Quran?"
He replied: "Don't you see that the two young married (adulterers) are to be stoned?"
And Umar Bin Al Khattab – (may Allaah be pleased with him) was with us then, so he said: "I will get the answer."
We both said: "How?"
He said: "From the Prophet, and I will mention such and such to him, and when I get to stoning, I will say: Oh Messenger of Allaah, allow me to write the stoning verse."
He (Umar) said: "O Messenger of Allaah, let me write the stoning verse. He said: "I can't."
Note 1. If the work was to write the Quran during the life of the prophet where is the written Quran which Marwan says was written during the life of the prophet? (He said "shouldn't we write it down as part of the written Quran?")
Note 2. If they were writing the Quran for themselves they knew the words for the verse so why would they ask permission from the prophet to write it? (They said we used to read: "The old man and the old woman.")
Note 3. If everyone knew the verse about stoning should not be written why would they ask permission to write it?
Note 4. Why did they not ask the Prophet “can we write this verse” instead of plotting by saying “I will mention such and such to him, and when I get to stoning, I will say: ...”
Note 5. This hadith describes those who wrote the Quran as people who were not straight forward with the prophet (He said “I will mention such and such to him, and when I get to stoning, I will say Oh Messenger of Allaah, allow me to write the stoning verse”) instead of people who were open and honest in asking the prophet directly what they wanted to know.
Would the closest friends of the prophet who are writing down the Quran speak to a prophet in a way that is not completely and fully honest and open and direct especially about a matter concerning the Quran?
Ibn Hajar - Fathul Bari - Hadith commentary of Bukhari, 6441 - 1407 AH/1986.
"Umar said: "When this verse came down I approached the Prophet (peace be upon him) so I asked him: Should I write it down? It is as if he hated that. Then Umar said: "Can’t you see that if the old man if he commits adultery he does not get the whip, and that if the young man if he commits adultery he gets stoned?"
Note 1. Allaah ordered the writing of the Quran with the pen in the chapter containing the first revelation of the Quran so why would the Prophet hate writing what came from Allaah?
Quran 96:4 Koran 96:4 (It is Allaah) who taught (the messengers of Allaah, Prophet Moses Musa, Prophet David Dawud, Prophet Jesus Isa and Prophet Muhammad) how to use the pen (for writing the Torah Taurat and the Psalms Zabur and the Gospel Injil and the Koran Quran and thereby) –
Quran 96:5 Koran 96:5 Taught the human (by revealing the Torah Taurat and the Psalms Zabur and the Gospel Injil and the Koran Quran) what (knowledge of Allaah) they (the humans) did not know.
Note 2. Allaah ordered the writing of the Quran with the pen in the chapter containing the second revelation of the Quran so why would the Prophet hate writing what came from Allaah?
Quran 68:1 Koran 68:1 Nun (From the Tablet Lawhin containing the decrees of Allaah, the Quran has descended in Quran 3:3 with the story of Nun Prophet Jonah Yunus who tried to run away from Allaah in a ship so as not to deliver Allaah's warning to a people Prophet Jonah Yunus hated but in Quran 68:48 Allaah tells you Prophet Muhammad do not do that because no one can run away from Allaah. In Quran 68:49 comments and in the Torah Taurat Allaah shows Prophet Jonah Yunus through the birth and death of a plant that Prophet Jonah Yunus’s wish for bad things to happen to people who have beliefs and traditions that are different to his is wrong because every human deserves help and mercy to find Allaah during their life in this world. Allaah teaches Prophet Jonah Yunus by showing him that if you care for plants and animals then how much more are humans deserving of your care and kindness and mercy). (I Allaah swear that this is the truth) by (the truth of the existence of) the pen and (by the truth of) what they (the messengers of Allaah, Prophet Moses Musa, Prophet David Dawud, Prophet Jesus Isa and Prophet Muhammad) write (in the Torah Taurat and the Psalms Zabur and the Gospel Injil and the Koran Quran, that) –
Note 3. The verse was written when it came down and was eaten by an animal on the day of the death of the prophet so how could this hadith claim that "When this verse came down” the prophet hated writing it when in fact he already wrote it and had no reason to hate writing what Allaah was revealing to him.
Can you image the prophet received a verse from Allaah and hated it on the day he received it? (Umar said: "When this verse came down I approached the Prophet” so I asked him: Should I write it down? It is as if he hated that.”).
3b. Why did a goat eat the paper containing the verse al rajm stoning to death for adultery?
The second time Allaah stopped stoning to death for adultery was when a goat ate away the word of Allaah meaning Allaah decreed the removal of stoning to death in Islam.
Quran 2:106 and Quran 13:39 explain why stoning to death is in the Torah Taurat but not in the Quran meaning there is no stoning to death for adultery in Islam meaning there is no death penalty for adultery in Islam and this is confirmed by Allaah when a goat ate away the word of Allaah meaning Allaah decreed the removal of stoning to death in Islam.
Only Allaah has the power to command an animal to devour and take away the “Word of Allaah.”
Aishah clearly understood what had happened when Prophet Muhammad had just died and a goat immediately came and ate away the paper with the verse of stoning to death for adultery and she did not write it again.
Once the word of Allaah had been written by Prophet Muhammad no one could remove it.
Even Prophet Muhammad could not remove it even though he had said that he “cannot write it anymore” in 3a above.
Only Allaah himself had the power to remove His word by commanding a goat to eat it away on the day of the death of Prophet Muhammad.
Allaah himself removed stoning to death for adultery from Islam by commanding an animal to eat it away.
Hadith story collected by Sunan Ibn Majah, Book of Nikah, hadith 1934 and Sunan ibn Majah, Volume 2, Page 39 and Sunan Ibn Majah in Arabic, Book of Suckling 2020.
Aishah (the wife of Prophet Muhammad) said “When the verses “Rajm” (Stoning) and ayah “Rezah Kabir” descended, they were written on a piece of paper and kept under my pillow.
Following the demise (death) of Prophet Muhammad a goat ate the piece of paper while we were mourning.”
3c. Why would Zayd not write the verse about stoning to death for adultery in the Quran when Umar gave it to him?
The third time Allaah removed stoning to death for adultery from the Quran was when it was compiled in the form we have today.
Quran 2:106 and Quran 13:39 explain why stoning to death is in the Torah Taurat but not in the Quran meaning there is no stoning to death for adultery in Islam meaning there is no death penalty for adultery in Islam and this is confirmed by Allaah who has protected the Quran as it is day.
Zayd bin Thabit is ready to write the verse about stoning to death for adultery if there is a second witness and Umar gives testimony that the verse should be written meaning they are both acting opposite to the claim that the writing of that verse was abrogated.
Zayd bin Thabit and Umar show that if a second person gave testimony then the verse about stoning to death for adultery would be in the Quran today,
Zayd bin Thabit who wrote the Quran did not accept the verse given to him by Umar because there was no second person to confirm it meaning Quran chapter 24 is the verse about adultery by married women confirmed by the story it contains about what happened to Aishah the wife of the prophet who was falsely accused of adultery.
Allaah himself removed stoning to death for adultery from Islam by prohibiting a second person from confirming the testimony of Umar.
Hadith story collected by Al-Suyuti as quoted in ‘Awn al-Ma‘bud 3130 and "The Itqan" by Suyuti Part 1, Page 168.
Ibn Abi Shaybah reported, concerning al-masahif, from al-Layth bin Sa‘d who said, “The first to collect the Quran was Abu Bakr and Zayd bin Thabit wrote it.
And people came to Zayd bin Thabit (with parts of the Quran but) Zayd did not write anything (in the Quran) without the testimony of two reliable witnesses.
The last part of Surah Bara`ah (Repentance) was not found except with Khuzaymah bin Thabit.
He (Zayd) said, “Write it, for the Messenger of Allaah had declared the testimony of Khuzaymah equivalent to that of two men.”
So he wrote it.
And ‘Umar came with the verse of stoning (rajm) but Zayd would not write it because ‘Umar was alone (in his testimony)
3d. Why did Umar say “were it not that the people shall say I have inscribed in the Book of Allaah what is not there, I would have inscribed it as it was sent down” if writing it down had been abrogated?”
Umar shows that if he had thought that the people meaning the general public in the general population would not object then he would have written the verse on stoning to death for adultery in the Quran and today we would say it was the will of Allaah because Allaah is the protector of the Quran.
However Allaah did not allow the verse on stoning to death for adultery in the Quran and it was not because its writing had been abrogated because Umar said he was ready to write it in the Quran except he feared the people would not accept it.
Hadith story collected by Ahmad 333.
Muhammad bin Ja‘far and Hajjaj said that, Shu‘bah said that, Sa‘d bin Ibrahim said that, ‘Ubayd allah bin ‘Utbah said that, Ibn ‘Abbas said that, ‘Abd al-Rahman bin ‘‘Awf said, Umar (Umar bin Khattab) performed hajj and intended to address the people.
Abd al-Rahman bin ‘Awf said (to ‘Umar), all kinds of riff raff (ra‘a‘) have gathered around you (in the season of hajj), so delay it till you go to Madinah.
When he arrived in Madinah, I sat close to him near the minbar and I heard him (Umar bin Khattab) say, There are people who say, “What is this al-rajm (the stoning) when in the Book of Allaah there is only flogging?”
The Messenger of Allaah stoned and we stoned after him.
Were it not that they (the people) shall say I (Umar bin Khattab) have inscribed in the Book of Allaah (the Quran) what is not there, I (Umar bin Khattab) would have inscribed it as it was sent down (by Allaah).”
3e. Why did Umar say “were it not that the people shall say I have inscribed in the Book of Allaah what is not there, I would have inscribed it as it was sent down” if Allaah commanded it?”
In this hadith (see in 3d) Umar is more afraid of the people than the command of Allaah which Umar said should be written by him in the Quran.
Quran 2:40 Koran 2:40 “… fear no one except Me (Allaah).”
Quran 2:150 Koran 2:150 “… So do not fear them (humans) but fear Me (Allaah) so that I (Allaah) may complete My (Allaah’s) blessings on you and that you may walk on the right path.
Quran 2:155 Koran 2:155 “And We (Allaah) shall test you with some fear …”
Quran 3:173 Koran 3:173 Those to whom the people said, "the people have gathered against you so fear them" instead increased the faith of the faithful and they said, "Allaah (alone) is all we need and He (Allaah) is our best protector."
Quran 2:189 Koran 2:189 “… righteous (is the person) who fears Allaah.”
Quran 3:175 Koran 3:175 It is only Satan Shaitan that suggests that you fear his supporters, so do not fear them but fear Me (Allaah), if you have (true) faith (in Allaah).
Quran 4:77 Koran 4:77 “… then suddenly some of them feared humans as they feared Allaah or even feared humans more than they feared Allaah …. The Hereafter is much better for those who fear Allaah …”
Quran 5:3 Koran 5:3 “… Today those without faith have despair of (not being able to destroy) your religion, so do not fear them (humans) but fear Me (Allaah) instead …”
Quran 5:44 Koran 5:44 “… So do not fear humans but fear Me (Allaah) … Whoever does not judge by what Allaah has revealed is a disbeliever in Allaah.”
Quran 5:54 Koran 5:54 O you who have faith (in Allaah), Whoever leaves his religion, (know that soon) Allaah shall bring a people (to replace them) whom He (Allaah) loves and who love Him (Allaah) and (they shall be) humble toward those with faith (in Allaah) and stern toward those without faith (in Allaah), striving in the way of Allaah and without fear of anyone who may criticize them. …”
Quran 9:13 Koran 9:13 “… Surely Allaah has more right that you should fear Him (Allaah), if you are (true) believers (in Allaah).”
Quran 12:57 Koran 12:57 “… And the reward of the Hereafter is better for those who believe and who used to fear Allaah.
Quran 16:50 Koran 16:50 They (who believe in Allaah) fear their Lord (Allaah) above them (humans) and they do what they are commanded.
Quran 16:52 Koran 16:52 To Him (Allaah) belongs whatever is in the heavens and the earth and to Him (Allaah) is due constant worship. Shall you then fear anyone other than Allaah?
If you were Umar would you say “Were it not that they (the people) shall say I (Umar bin Khattab) have inscribed in the Book of Allaah (the Quran) what is not there, I (Umar bin Khattab) would have inscribed it as it was sent down (by Allaah).”
Surely Umar would have said “I am not afraid of the people but I am afraid of Allaah so I am going to write this command in the Quran so that I can face Allaah on the Day of Judgement.”
If Umar wrote in the Quran then today we would say it was the will of Allaah because Allaah protects the Quran.
However Umar did not write in the Quran because it was the will of Allaah to remove stoning to death for adultery from Islam confirmed by Prophet Muhammad who said “I cannot write it down anymore” in 3a above and confirmed on the day of the death of Prophet Muhammad when Allaah commanded a goat to eat away the verse on stoning to death for adultery in 3b above and confirmed by the words of Allaah today in Quran chapter 4 and chapter 24 in 3-1a and 3-1b above.
Umar would not fear people more that he feared Allaah.
Quran 24:12 Koran 24:12 Why did not the believers (both) men and women when you heard it (the lie that Aishah the wife of Prophet Muhammad had committed illegal sexual intercourse with another man, or in this example of the lies in hadith stories that Umar said he was more afraid of people than Allaah) think good about your own people and say, “This (hadith) is clearly a lie?”
3f. No verse in the Quran is abrogated.
a. The belief in stoning to death for adultery comes from hadith stories and uses the theory of abrogation where a verse on stoning for adultery was revealed to Prophet Muhammad and then abrogated as a text in the Quran but its ruling continued to be valid and operative.
The verse called the stoning al rajam which is not written in the Quran is said to be like the following:
Hadith story collected by Muwatta Malik Book 41 Hadith 10.
… "The full-grown man and the full-grown woman, stone them absolutely." … (meaning the man and the woman who have been married, stone them absolutely).
Other variations of the stoning verse al rajam al rajm.
a. If al-Sheikh and al-Sheikha commit Zina, you have to stone them to death as a form of punishment of Allaah (meaning if a married man and married woman commit adultery, you have to stone them to death as a form of punishment of Allaah).
b. The old man and the old lady if they committed adultery then stone them (meaning if a married man and married woman commit adultery then stone them).
c. The old man and the old lady if they committed adultery then stone them as a punishment from Allaah and Allaah is the Most Mighty, Most Wise (the meaning of ‘’old man and old lady” means the married man and married lady).
d. The man and the woman who have been married, stone them absolutely.
Hadith story collected by Sahih Bukhari Volume 8 Hadith number 817.
Narrated by Ibn 'Abbas
“... 'Umar (Umar Ibn al-Khattab) sat on the pulpit and when the call-makers for the prayer had finished their call, 'Umar stood up, and having glorified and praised Allaah as He deserved, he said, "Now then, I am going to tell you something which (Allaah) has written for me to say. I do not know; perhaps it portends my death, so whoever understands and remembers it, must narrate it to the others wherever his mount takes him, but if somebody is afraid that he does not understand it, then it is unlawful for him to tell lies about me. Allaah sent Muhammad with the Truth and revealed the Holy Book to him, and among what Allaah revealed, was the Verse of the Rajam (the stoning of married person male & female) who commits illegal sexual intercourse, and we did recite this Verse and understood and memorized it. Allaah's Apostle did carry out the punishment of stoning and so did we after him.
I am afraid that after a long time has passed, somebody will say, 'By Allaah, we do not find the Verse of the Rajam in Allaah's Book,' and thus they will go astray by leaving an obligation which Allaah has revealed. And the punishment of the Rajam is to be inflicted to any married person (male & female), who commits illegal sexual intercourse, if the required evidence is available or there is conception or confession. And then we used to recite among the Verses in Allaah's Book: 'O people! Do not claim to be the offspring of other than your fathers, as it is disbelief (unthankfulness) on your part that you claim to be the offspring of other than your real father.' ...”
Note 1. This hadith confirms that the order to stone to death for adultery is not in the Book of Allaah so the question is do humans follow the orders of Allaah in His protected Book or follow stories which are in the same unprotected books which carry the stories of punishment in the grave and the return of Prophet Jesus Isa to this earth which were invented after the death of Prophet Muhammad as explained in example 1 above.
This question is answered by Allaah in the Quran in 3g part d below and by Allaah in the Hebrew Bible 1 Kings 13:18 – 13:24 in 3g part c below.
Note 2. In this hadith the words "I am going to tell you something which (Allaah) has written for me to say shows that both the name of Umar and Allaah are being used falsely because the claim that “O people! Do not claim to be the offspring of other than your fathers ...” was also part of the Quran like stoning but both are now not in the Quran seeks to make humans testify that the Quran was written and then verses were removed because that is proof of the work of humans and not the work of Allaah who reveals verses in the Quran which can never be abrogated except when the word abrogated means not including in the Quran some of the judgements in the Torah Taurat and the Gospel Injil.
The proof of Allaah is that nothing is abrogated inside the Quran as explained below in Quran 4:82, Quran 2:106, Quran 13:39 and Quran 16:101.
This hadith seeks to make humans unknowingly testify that Allaah does not exist by claiming some verses revealed by Allaah in the Quran were later removed from the Quran because that is proof of the work of a human meaning this hadith was invented after the death of Prophet Muhammad the same way all hadith about punishment in the grave and the return of Prophet Jesus Isa to this earth were invented after the death of Prophet Muhammad as explained in example 1 above.
If there was a person who was revealing revelation and then removing revelation from the written text how many people would continue to believe in him?
The theory of abrogation of verses inside the Quran in Islam is an innovation that came after the death of Prophet Muhammad and is not supported by Quran 4:82, Quran 2:106, Quran 13:39 and Quran 16:101.
Quran 4:82 says there are no contradictions in the Quran as proof the Quran is from Allaah and not from humans.
There are no abrogated verses in the Quran as proof the Quran is from Allaah and not from humans.
Satan Shaitan wants Muslims to testify against the Quran by searching for verses that contradict each other and then claiming one verse abrogates another verse meaning they testify they have found a contradiction in the Quran.
Satan Shaitan wants Muslims to testify against the Quran by claiming some verses revealed by Allaah were abrogated because they were removed from the Quran meaning they unknowingly testify to the proof that the Quran is the work of humans and not Allaah because Quran 4:82 or Quran 2:106 or Quran 13:39 or Quran 16:101 have been violated.
When did Allaah or Prophet Muhammad give anyone permission to claim that any verse in the Quran has been abrogated when the Quran says it has no contradictions as proof it comes from Allaah?
The theory of abrogation is a human invention in the same way as the theory of the Trinity is a human invention.
There is no abrogation in Islam in the same way as there is no Trinity in Christianity because both are the inventions of humans meaning those concepts do not come from the Books of Allaah but came after the death of Prophet Jesus Isa and after the death of Prophet Muhammad.
Quran 4:82 Koran 4:82 Do they not think about the Quran (and where it came from)? Had it (the Quran) been (revealed) from someone other than Allaah surely they would have found in it (the Quran) much contradiction (within it and between it and the Torah Taurat and the Gospel Injil. The Quran confirms the Tanakh Jewish Scripture is correct and the Quran explains the story of Jesus in the Gospel Injil of Jesus Isa by Mark, Matthew, Luke and John).
Quran 2:106 Koran 2:106 (Allaah says in 1 Samuel 15:29 Allaah does not change His mind promises covenants agreements because only humans change their mind promises covenants agreements so the Jews asked Prophet Muhammad about the Torah and the Quran. Allaah reveals) We (Allaah) do not abolish a verse (in the Torah for the Jewish people) or let it be forgotten (by the Jewish people until the Day of Judgement as Allaah promised in Quran 2:40 - 2:41, Quran 2:62, Quran 3:113 - 3:115, Quran 5:69, Exodus 2:24, Leviticus 26:4 - 26:45, Deuteronomy 4:2, Deuteronomy 4:31, Deuteronomy 5:10, Deuteronomy 7:7 - 7:8, Deuteronomy 12:1, Deuteronomy 29:28 in Jewish Tanakh or Deuteronomy 29:29 in a Christian Bible, 2 King 13:23, Psalm 19:8 - 19:12 in Jewish Tanakh or Psalm 19:7 - 19:11 in Christian Old Testament Bible, Psalm 111:7 - 111:9, Hosea 3:4 - 3:5, Daniel 12:2, Isaiah 59:21 is the promise to the Jewish people mentioned in Isaiah 36:11 and Isaiah 36:13 and Gospel of Matthew 5:17 - 5:20). We (Allaah) bring (to the Muslims in the Quran) something better than it or similar to it (confirming the Torah which is in the hands of the Jewish people until the Day of Judgement in Quran 2:40 - 2:41 and explaining the story of Jesus which is in the four reports that are in the hands of the Christian people until the Day of Judgement in Quran 5:46 - 5:47 and Allaah told the Jewish people to observe the Torah Taurat and told the Christians to observe the Gospel Injil in Quran 5:68. Allaah reminded the Jewish people in the Quran to observe the Sabbath and confirmed Prophet Ezra is a human servant of Allaah like every human is a willing or unwilling servant of Allaah. Allaah reminded the Christian people in the Quran that Prophet Jesus is a human servant of Allaah like every human is a willing or unwilling servant of Allaah). Do you not know that Allaah is capable of everything? (including protecting the Jewish Scriptures that are with the Jewish people until the Day of Judgement as shown in the story of the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran chapter 37 where Allaah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq and leaves no other blessings in the story of the sacrifice and this famous vision dream is remembered in the next chapter Quran chapter 38 where Allaah blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq with the vision dream in Quran 38:45 – 38:47 and shows in the next verse that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not the son in the vision dream and Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not living with his father during the vision dream by blessing Prophet Ishmael Ismail without his father and without the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:48. This is confirmed in Quran 12:6 and in Torah Genesis 22:2 “And Allaah said: Take now your son, your only son” who still lives with you, reminding him that Allaah had earlier taken Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar away from him into Allaah’s care in the desert, “whom you love” Allaah makes the test very hard by demanding his second son and reminding him that this is his only remaining son and reminding him that he already gave Allaah one son and reminding him of his love for these sons, “even” namely, that is “Isaac Ishaq and go into the land of Moriah” today in the Temple and Al-Aqsa mosque area in Jerusalem Al-Quds in Israel and Palestine; “and offer him there for a burnt-offering on one of the mountains which I Allaah will tell you of.” The proof Allaah is real is the Quran confirming the Torah Taurat is correct in Quran 2:41 “And believe in what I Allaah have revealed” in the Quran “that confirms what you already have” in the Torah Taurat and in Quran 3:93 “… Bring the Torah Taurat here and recite it as evidence if what you say is true" and in Quran 5:43 “How is it that they come to you for judgment when they have the Torah Taurat in which Allaah has already revealed to them judgment …” and Quran 5:68 “… You the Jewish people have nothing until you observe the Torah Taurat …” as explained in this video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kQ3o3ybc-KA so hold tightly to what Allaah is teaching in the Quran and beware of stories which contradict the Books of Allaah. Allaah explains the story of Jesus which is in the hands of the Christian people by explaining in the Quran what the human eye could not see without adding anything to the story in the Gospel of what the human eye saw in the story of Prophet Jesus Isa in Quran 3:144 see Quran 5:75, Quran 4:157, Quran 4:158 see Quran 39:42, Quran 5:75 see Quran 3:144, Quran 5:117 see Quran 7:6, Quran 7:6 see Quran 5:117, Quran 21:95 see Quran 23:99 – 23:100, Quran 33:40 see Gospel of Jesus Isa by Mark 13:5 – 13:6, 13:21 – 13:22 and Quran 39:42 see Quran 4:158. In Quran 3:144 and Quran 5:75 see “passed away” in the Quran always means died see in Quran 2:134 and Quran 2:141 and Quran 7:38 and Quran 13:30 and Quran 41:25 and Quran 46:17. The Quran gives humans freedom to find their religion).
Note 1. In Quran 2:106 Allaah says the Quran is similar to what is with the Jewish people or better and this is explained in Quran 13:39 where Allaah does not include in the Quran some laws that are binding only on the Jewish people.
See Quran 2:40 comments.
Quran 13:39 Koran 13:39 (In 1 Samuel 15:29 Allaah does not change His mind promises covenants agreements because only humans change their mind promises covenants agreements so the Jews asked Prophet Muhammad about the Torah and the Quran. Allaah revealed that Allaah confirms His covenant with the Jewish people in Quran 2:40 - 2:41 which is the Torah Taurat until the Day of Judgement as Allaah promised in Quran 2:40 - 2:41, Quran 2:62, Quran 3:113 - 3:115, Quran 5:69, Exodus 2:24, Leviticus 26:44 - 26:45, Deuteronomy 4:2, Deuteronomy 4:31, Deuteronomy 5:10, Deuteronomy 7:7 - 7:8, Deuteronomy 12:1, Deuteronomy 29:28 in Jewish Tanakh or Deuteronomy 29:29 in a Christian Bible, 2 King 13:23, Psalm 19:8 - 19:12 in Jewish Tanakh or Psalm 19:7 - 19:11 in Christian Old Testament Bible, Psalm 111:7 - 111:9, Hosea 3:4 - 3:5, Daniel 12:2, Isaiah 59:21 is the promise to the Jewish people mentioned in Isaiah 36:11, Isaiah 36:13 and Gospel of Matthew 5:17 - 5:20 and Allaah revealed that) Allaah eliminates (from the Quran the laws which are only binding on the Jewish people such as the Sabbath Day) and confirms what He (Allaah) wills (in the Quran which confirms the Torah which is in the hands of the Jewish people until the Day of Judgement in Quran 2:40 - 2:41 and explaining the story of Jesus which is in the four reports that are in the hands of the Christian people until the Day of Judgement in Quran 5:46 - 5:47 and Allaah told the Jewish people to observe the Torah Taurat and told the Christians to observe the Gospel Injil in Quran 5:68. Allaah reminded the Jewish people in the Quran to observe the Sabbath and confirmed Prophet Ezra is a human servant of Allaah like every human is a willing or unwilling servant of Allaah. Allaah reminded the Christian people in the Quran that Prophet Jesus is a human servant of Allaah like every human is a willing or unwilling servant of Allaah) and with Him (Allaah) is the Mother of the Book (the Preserved Tablet, Al-Lauh al-Mahfuz which contains the basis of each Scripture as Allaah intended in the Torah Taurat for the Jews and the four reports about Jesus Isa in the Gospel of Jesus Isa by Mark, Matthew, Luke and John which are with the Christians and the Quran which is with the Muslims as explained in Quran 2:106, Quran 5:48 and Quran 7:170. Allaah protects the Jewish Scriptures that are with the Jewish people until the Day of Judgement as shown in the story of the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran chapter 37 where Allaah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq and leaves no other blessings in the story of the sacrifice and this famous vision dream is remembered in the next chapter Quran chapter 38 where Allaah blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq with the vision dream in Quran 38:45 – 38:47 and shows in the next verse that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not the son in the vision dream and Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not living with his father during the vision dream by blessing Prophet Ishmael Ismail without his father and without the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:48. This is confirmed in Quran 12:6 and in Torah Genesis 22:2 “And Allaah said: Take now your son, your only son” who still lives with you, reminding him that Allaah had earlier taken Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar away from him into Allaah’s care in the desert, “whom you love” Allaah makes the test very hard by demanding his second son and reminding him that this is his only remaining son and reminding him that he already gave Allaah one son and reminding him of his love for these sons, “even” namely, that is “Isaac Ishaq and go into the land of Moriah” today in the Temple and Al-Aqsa mosque area in Jerusalem Al-Quds in Israel and Palestine; “and offer him there for a burnt-offering on one of the mountains which I Allaah will tell you of.” The proof Allaah is real is the Quran confirming the Torah Taurat is correct in Quran 2:41 “And believe in what I Allaah have revealed” in the Quran “that confirms what you already have” in the Torah Taurat and in Quran 3:93 “… Bring the Torah Taurat here and recite it as evidence if what you say is true" and in Quran 5:43 “How is it that they come to you for judgment when they have the Torah Taurat in which Allaah has already revealed to them judgment …” and Quran 5:68 “… You the Jewish people have nothing until you observe the Torah Taurat …” as explained in this video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kQ3o3ybc-KA so hold tightly to what Allaah is teaching in the Quran and beware of stories which contradict the Books of Allaah. Allaah explains the story of Jesus which is in the hands of the Christian people by explaining in the Quran what the human eye could not see without adding anything to the story in the Gospel of what the human eye saw in the story of Prophet Jesus Isa in Quran 3:144 see Quran 5:75, Quran 4:157, Quran 4:158 see Quran 39:42, Quran 5:75 see Quran 3:144, Quran 5:117 see Quran 7:6, Quran 7:6 see Quran 5:117, Quran 21:95 see Quran 23:99 – 23:100, Quran 33:40 see Gospel of Jesus Isa by Mark 13:5 – 13:6, 13:21 – 13:22 and Quran 39:42 see Quran 4:158. In Quran 3:144 and Quran 5:75 see “passed away” in the Quran always means died see in Quran 2:134 and Quran 2:141 and Quran 7:38 and Quran 13:30 and Quran 41:25 and Quran 46:17. The Quran gives humans freedom to find their religion).
Note 1. In Quran 2:106 Allaah says the Quran is similar to what is with the Jewish people or better and this is explained in Quran 13:39 where Allaah does not include in the Quran some laws that are binding only on the Jewish people.
Quran 5:48 Koran 5:48 “…. For each (community of Jews, Christians and Muslims) We (Allaah) have appointed a divine law and a way (of religion). If Allaah willed He (Allaah) could have made you (the Jews, the Christians and the Muslims) one community. But He (Allaah) tests you (the Jews, the Christians and the Muslims) by what He (Allaah) has given you (in the Torah Taurat and the Gospel Injil and the Koran Quran to show who is best in behaviour). So strive for all that is good. To Allaah you shall all return and He (Allaah) shall then inform you (in the Hereafter) about (the correctness of) the religious matters in which you (the Jews, the Christians and the Muslims) argue among each other.
Quran 16:101 Koran 16:101 And when We (Allaah) replace one verse (in the Quran) by another verse (meaning reveal verse after verse in the Quran about similar matters, these verses do not abrogate each other but together they add more details and understanding) and Allaah knows best what He (Allaah) should reveal, they (the stone idol worshippers in Makkah) say, “You (Prophet Muhammad) are an inventor (of the Quran and of verses because Allaah would have revealed His command in one verse on one day because Allaah needs no time to think instead of several verses on different days which a human would do because a human needs time to think).” But most of them (the stone idol worshippers of Makkah Arabia) do not understand (the way Allaah reveals His verses which is explained in Quran 16:102).
Quran 16:102 Koran 16:102 Say (Prophet Muhammad, to the people), “The Holy Spirit (Ruh Al-Qudus, Angel Gabriel Jibril) has descended it (meaning brought down from heaven the revelations in the Quran) from your Lord (Allaah) with the truth, in order to strengthen (the faith of) those who believe and as a guidance and Good News to the Muslims (Muslim is an Arabic word meaning those who submit, to the will of Allaah. Islam is an Arabic word meaning submission, to the will of Allaah. Muslims submit to Allaah in Quran 47:19 “…there is no Allaah except Allaah …” and Jews submit to Allaah in Torah Exodus 20:2 “.... You shall have no other gods before Me Allaah” and Christians submit to Allaah in the Gospel of Jesus Isa by Luke 4:8 “… You shall worship the Lord your Allaah, and him only shall you serve” because Allaah inspired the same belief in the one creator of every creation among many communities of Allaah throughout history as explained in Quran 5:48 where Allaah said He could have made humans to be one community of Allaah but made more than one community of Allaah and gave laws to each community of Allaah and told them to strive for all that is good so that Allaah can show who are the best in behaviour within and between the different communities of Allaah such as the Jews and Christians and Muslims and others).
See: Are there abrogated verses in the Quran?
Does one verse in the Quran abrogate another verse in the Quran?
Nasikh and Mansukh. Nasikh wal Mansukh.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/abrogation-in-the-quran
3g. Hadith stories.
a. Fabricated hadith story about unlawful sexual intercourse zina and punishment in the grave azab-e-qabar.
The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) has told us of the punishment that those who commit zina will receive in their graves before the Hour begins, and that they will be punished with fire. Narrated by al-Bukhaari (1320).
Note 1. All hadith stories about punishment in the grave were fabricated after the death of Prophet Muhammad as explained in example 1 above.
b. Hadith story collected by Saheeh Bukhari Volume 8, Book 82, Number 816:
Narrated Ibn 'Abbas: 'Umar said, "I am afraid that after a long time has passed, people may say, "We do not find the Verses of the Rajam (stoning to death) in the Holy Book," and consequently they may go astray by leaving an obligation that Allaah has revealed. Lo! I confirm that the penalty of Rajam be inflicted on him who commits illegal sexual intercourse, if he is already married and the crime is proved by witnesses or pregnancy or confession." Sufyan added, "I have memorized this narration in this way." 'Umar added, "Surely Allaah's Apostle carried out the penalty of Rajam, and so did we after him."
Note 1. In the Judgement of Allaah taking one life is equal to the great sin of destroying all human life in Quran 5:32 so why would Allaah not include the law of stoning to death for adultery in the Quran like Allaah did in the Torah Taurat if it is the command for Muslims from Allaah?
Note 2. Satan Shaitan deceived millions of people to believe in punishment in the grave and in the return of Prophet Jesus Isa to this earth which both contradict the teachings of Allaah in the Quran as shown in example 1.
Note 3. Satan Shaitan deceived millions of people to believe in abrogation in the Quran when abrogation is about the laws in the Torah Taurat which are not found in the Quran as explained in 3f above.
Note 4. This hadith says "We do not find the Verses of the Rajam (the stoning) in the Holy Book" meaning this is a warning that the command al Rajam the stoning to death for adultery is not in the Quran.
Quran 77:50 Koran 77:50 In what statement (words, news, reports, information, message, hadith), after it (the verses of Allaah in the Quran), shall they (the humans and the jinn) believe?
Note 4a. Quran 7:185, Quran 25:29, Quran 25:30, Quran 31:6, Quran 39:23, Quran 45:6 and Quran 77:50 asks when you have the word of Allaah in the Quran what other report would you believe?
See Quran 25:30 comments with examples of hadith stories which contradict the teachings of Allaah in Quran chapter 25.
c. Hadith story collected by Saheeh Muslim Book 017, Number 4194:
'Abdullah b. 'Abbas reported that 'Umar b. Khattab sat on the pulpit of Allaah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) and said: Verily Allaah sent Muhammad (may peace be upon him) with truth and He sent down the Book upon him, and the verse of stoning was included in what was sent down to him. We recited it, retained it in our memory and understood it. Allaah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) awarded the punishment of stoning to death (to the married adulterer and adulteress) and, after him, we also awarded the punishment of stoning, I am afraid that with the lapse of time, the people (may forget it) and may say: We do not find the punishment of stoning in the Book of Allaah, and thus go astray by abandoning this duty prescribed by Allaah. Stoning is a duty laid down in Allaah's Book for married men and women who commit adultery when proof is established, or it there is pregnancy, or a confession.
Note 1. This hadith says "We do not find the punishment of stoning in the Book of Allaah" meaning this is a warning that the command al Rajam the stoning to death for adultery is not in the Quran.
Quran 77:50 Koran 77:50 In what statement (words, news, reports, information, message, hadith), after it (the verses of Allaah in the Quran), shall they (the humans and the jinn) believe?
Note. Quran 7:185, Quran 25:29, Quran 25:30, Quran 31:6, Quran 39:23, Quran 45:6 and Quran 77:50 asks when you have the word of Allaah in the Quran what other report would you believe?
See Quran 25:30 comments with examples of hadith stories which contradict the teachings of Allaah in Quran chapter 25.
Allaah asks who will believe the Quran and who will believe a teaching that is different to what Allaah teaches in the Quran?
Quran 2:102 Koran 2:102 “… These Angels (when they taught the first humans this knowledge) first said “We are a test for your faith, do not disbelieve in Allaah (by learning magic from us) and to those who disbelieved they taught the magic …”
Note 1. The angels first gave a warning “do not disbelieve Allaah” before teaching what Allaah has forbidden to those who do not obey Allaah.
Quran 17:88 Koran 17:88 Say (Prophet Muhammad), "If humans and jinn (such as Satan Shaitan) came together to help each other to produce something like the Quran, they could not do it."
Note 1. In the hereafter Satan Shaitan might boast he obeyed Quran 17:88 by whispering hundreds of false hadith stories which teach the opposite to what Allaah and Prophet Muhammad teach in the Quran as explained in example 1 above.
Tanakh Jewish scripture 1 Kings 13:18 And he said to him: 'I also am a prophet as you are; and an angel spoke to me by the word of the LORD (Allaah), saying: Bring him back with you into your house, so that he may eat bread and drink water.' - He lied to him (telling him to do what Allaah told him not to do to show if he obeys the command of Allaah or followed the story of a human).-
1 Kings 13:20 And it came to pass, as they sat at the table, that the word of the LORD (Allaah) came to the prophet that brought him back.
1 Kings 13:21 And he cried to the man of Allaah that came from Judah, saying: 'The LORD (Allaah) has said this: because you have rebelled against the word of the LORD (Allaah), and have not kept the commandment which the LORD your Allaah commanded you,
1 Kings 13:22 but came back, and have eaten bread and drunk water in the place of which He (Allaah) said to you: Eat no bread, and drink no water; your body shall not come to the grave of your fathers.
1 Kings 13:24 And when he had left, a lion met him by the road way, and killed him; and his body was thrown on the road way, and the ass stood by it; the lion also stood by the body.
Note 1. If there are two different stories would you follow the story of Allaah or the story of a human who uses the name of a prophet to say the story in the Book of Allaah was abrogated and there is a new story which you will not find in the Book of Allaah?
Do you put your trust in Allaah or in humans?
Success comes by obeying the word of Allaah not the words of humans that contradict the words of Allaah.
d. Warning to believe the Quran above all other stories.
If there are two different stories would you follow the story in the Book of Allaah or the story of humans who say the story in the Book of Allaah was abrogated and there is a new story which you will not find in the Book of Allaah?
Do you put your trust in Allaah or in humans?
Success comes by obeying the word of Allaah not the words of humans that contradict the words of Allaah.
Quran 6:112 Koran 6:112 And in this way We (Allaah) have made for every prophet an enemy that are the devils to humans and to jinn who inspire (false) nice sounding words as (a way of) deception (through which they deceive humans and jinn). If your Lord (Allaah) willed then they (the devils) would not have done it (deceived humans and jinn with false nice sounding stories) so leave them and what they invent (of false nice sounding stories).
Note 1, Satan Shaitan whispers nice sounding false stories to humans and jinn.
Quran 7:185 Koran 7:185 Do they not look in the dominion of the heavens and the earth and everything that Allaah has created and that their (life span) term might be coming near to its end? In what statement (words, news, reports, information, message, hadith) after (they have heard) this (Quran) would they believe?
Note 1. Allaah asks who will believe the Quran and who will believe a teaching that is different to what Allaah teaches in the Quran exactly the same as Allaah is teaching in 1 Kings 13:20 – 13:24 in 3g part c above?
Quran 25:29 Koran 25:29 – “He (Satan Shaitan with false messages, false words, false news, false reports, false information, false statements, false hadith) has led me astray from the reminder (of Allaah in the Quran) after it (the Quran) had reached me.” Satan Shaitan always betrays humans (by leading them astray away from the Quran).
Note 1. Satan Shaitan misleads some people away from the Quran with nice sounding stories that contradict the Quran.
Quran 25:30 Koran 25:30 And (on the Day of Resurrection and Judgement) the messenger (Prophet Muhammad) said, “My Lord (Allaah) my people have abandoned (deserted) this Quran (to follow false messages, false words, false news, false reports, false information, false statements, false hadith).”
Note 1. On the Day of Resurrection and Judgement Prophet Muhammad will say “My Lord my people have abandoned this Quran (to follow false messages, false words, false news, false reports, false information, false statements, false hadith).”
Note 2. Quran 7:185, Quran 25:29, Quran 25:30, Quran 31:6, Quran 39:23, Quran 45:6 and Quran 77:50 asks when you have the word of Allaah in the Quran what other report would you believe?
See Quran 25:30 comments with examples of hadith stories which contradict the teachings of Allaah in Quran chapter 25.
Quran 25:31 Koran 25:31 And in this way We (Allaah) have made for every prophet an enemy among the criminals. But Allaah is sufficient as a guide (in this world) and helper (on the Day of Judgement).
Quran 31:6 Koran 31:6 Among people is the person who shall accept baseless stories (words, news, reports, information, statement, hadith) without knowledge (of the truthfulness of the story) so that they may mislead (people) from Allaah’s way (in the Quran) and (by believing false stories they) make mockery of it (the Quran). For them is a humiliating punishment (in the Hereafter).
Note 1. Some people in Christianity (not all) believe the false story that “Jesus Isa is Allaah” or “a biological part of Allaah” or “a biological partner with Allaah” so no matter what is written in the Gospel of Jesus Isa by Mark, Matthew, Luke and John even when Jesus Isa prays to Allaah they cannot understand that Jesus Isa is no more than a human like Prophet Moses Musa is only a human.
Note 2. Some people in Islam (not all) believe the false story of “punishment in the grave” and “the return to this earth of Prophet Jesus Isa” which contradicts what Allaah is teaching about the grave and about the death of Prophet Jesus Isa in the Quran as explained in example 1 above.
Quran 39:23 Koran 39:23 Allaah has revealed the best statement (the best message, the best word, the best news, the best report, the best information, the best story, the best hadith in) a Book (the Quran) whose statements confirm each other. The skins shiver among those who fear their Lord (Allaah) and then their skins and their hearts relax when they remember Allaah (in praise of Allaah and in prayer to Allaah). That (Quran) is the guidance of Allaah, He (Allaah) guides with it (the Quran) whom He (Allaah) wills. And whoever Allaah lets go astray for them there is no guide (to righteous behaviour).
Note 1. Allaah says “The Quran is the guidance of Allaah.”
Allaah says “Allaah guides with the Quran whom Allaah wills.”
Quran 45:6 Koran 45:6 These are the verses of Allaah, We (Allaah through angel Gabriel Jibril) recite them to you (Prophet Muhammad) truthfully. In what statement (words, news, reports, information, message, hadith) will they (the humans and jinn) believe (and trust in) after Allaah and His verses (which they have in the Quran until the Day of Judgement)?
Note 1. Allaah asks who will believe the Quran and who will believe a teaching that is different to what Allaah teaches in the Quran exactly the same as Allaah teaches in 1 Kings 13:20 – 13:24 in 3g part c above?
Note 2. Quran 7:185, Quran 25:29, Quran 25:30, Quran 31:6, Quran 39:23, Quran 45:6 and Quran 77:50 asks when you have the word of Allaah in the Quran what other report would you believe?
See Quran 25:30 comments with examples of hadith stories which contradict the teachings of Allaah in Quran chapter 25.
Quran 77:50 Koran 77:50 In what statement (words, news, reports, information, message, hadith), after it (the verses of Allaah in the Quran), shall they (the humans and the jinn) believe?
Note 1. Allaah asks who will believe the Quran and who will believe a teaching that is different to what Allaah teaches in the Quran exactly the same as Allaah teaches in 1 Kings 13:20 – 13:24 in 3g part c above?
Note 2. Quran 7:185, Quran 25:29, Quran 25:30, Quran 31:6, Quran 39:23, Quran 45:6 and Quran 77:50 asks when you have the word of Allaah in the Quran what other report would you believe?
See Quran 25:30 comments with examples of hadith stories which contradict the teachings of Allaah in Quran chapter 25.
e. The belief in stoning to death in Islam comes only from hadith stories and is explained here.
Video: Misconception of stoning to death - Mufti Menk
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_5R2Qo48XCo
3h. Conclusion.
a. After the death of Prophet Jesus Isa Satan Shaitan whispered Jesus Isa is Allaah or part of Allaah or a partner with Allaah to move people away from correctly understanding what Allaah is teaching in the Gospel Injil of Jesus Isa by Mark, Matthew, Luke and John where Jesus Isa prays to Allaah in all four Gospel Injil.
After the death of Prophet Muhammad Satan Shaitan whispered Punishment in the Grave and the Return of Jesus Isa to this Earth in example 1 above and Stoning to Death for Adultery in this example to move people away from correctly understanding what Allaah is teaching in the Quran.
b. Quran 4:15 – 4:18 is the law for illegal sexual intercourse for unmarried Muslims in 3-1a above.
Quran 4:25 and 24:1 – 24:2 is the law for adultery by married Muslims in 3-1b above.
Quran 3:135 – 3:136, 4:17 – 4:18, 4:110 and 25:68 – 25:71 is forgiveness for all sins including adultery in 3-1c above.
c. Due to the widespread fabrication of hadith stories described in C, D and E in “A better way to study hadith stories” in Example 1 above we need to check and interpret every hadith story by what the Quran teaches so that our knowledge in how to examine a hadith story and our understanding of how we can apply such knowledge in our everyday life will increase Allaah willing inshallah.
d. The widespread fabrication of hadith stories mean all beliefs based on hadith stories need to be tested.
The belief that the punishment for adultery is stoning to death if the person is married is not supported by what Allaah is commanding in the Quran in this conclusion part b above.
Hadith stories about stoning to death for adultery warn that some people will not believe those stories in the same way as stories about punishment in the grave and the return of Prophet Jesus Isa to this earth also warn that some people will not believe those stories. Example 1 above shows all such stories were invented after the death of Prophet Muhammad.
Hadith stories about stoning to death for adultery warn that the Quran does not confirm what hadith stories say which is similar to the tests Allaah gives to humans in Quran 2:102, Quran 17:88 and Hebrew Bible 1 Kings 13:18 - 13:24 in 3g part c above showing that success comes by obeying the word of Allaah and not the words of humans that contradict the words of Allaah.
e. See E, F, G, H, I and J in “A better way to study hadith stories” in example 1 above.
Example 4.
4. Did Prophet Muhammad say “whoever changed his Islamic religion then kill him?”
A. Test the hadith story with the Quran.
This story is not in the protected Quran which comes from Allaah and contain the verses which Prophet Muhammad recited to the people.
This story comes from the unprotected hadith stories passed from one human to another human.
What does Allaah teach in the Quran about changing religion?
1. Quran 5:54 says Muslims can leave Islam if that is the will of Allaah meaning all hadith stories which claim Prophet Muhammad said “whoever changed his Islamic religion then kill him” were invented after the death of Prophet Muhammad.
Quran 5:54 Koran 5:54 O you who believe (in Allaah), whoever among you turns back (leaves) from his religion (allow them to leave), soon Allaah shall bring a people (to replace those who leave) whom He (Allaah) loves and who love Him (Allaah) and (they shall be) humble toward those with faith (in Allaah) and stern (by standing up for their rights) toward those without faith (in Allaah), striving in the way of Allaah and without fear of anyone who may criticize them (for their faith in Allaah). This is the grace that Allaah gives to whomever He (Allaah) wills. Allaah encompasses all (the things in our life) and (Allaah) knows all things.
Note 1. Prophet Muhammad did not punish people for peacefully leaving religion instead Prophet Muhammad said what Allaah revealed in Quran 5:54 that “whoever leaves religion will be replaced by people whom Allaah loves and who love Allaah.”
2. Quran 4:137 says every human can change their religion until the time of their natural death meaning all hadith stories which claim Prophet Muhammad said “whoever changed his Islamic religion then kill him” were invented after the death of Prophet Muhammad.
Quran 4:137 explains that the purpose of life is to find your true belief which would be impossible if humans were forced to stay in a religion in which they did not believe.
Allaah does not force people to stay in one religion against their belief and against their will because the purpose of life is for every human to find their true belief before the time of their natural death as explained in Quran 4:137.
Quran 4:137 Koran 4:137 Those who believed (in Allaah and) then disbelieved (in Allaah meaning for the first time they left Islam or they left Christianity or they left Judaism meaning for the first time they lost their belief in Allaah and), then again believed (in Allaah for a second time meaning they returned to Islam or Christianity or Judaism meaning for a second time they found their belief in Allaah and) then again disbelieved (in Allaah for a second time meaning they left Islam or Christianity or Judaism meaning for a second time they lost their belief in Allaah and) then increased in disbelief (in Allaah meaning they did not return to Islam or Christianity or Judaism meaning their belief in Allaah did not return to them before the time of their natural death), Allaah shall not forgive them (on the Day of Judgement) and will not guide them to the (right) way (of behaviour in this world).
Note 1. Prophet Muhammad did not punish people for peacefully leaving religion instead Prophet Muhammad said what Allaah revealed in Quran 4:137 that humans have a life time to find their true belief because it is not until the time of natural death that the true belief of each human is shown.
In the first part of Quran 5:48 Allaah gave Prophet Muhammad authority to deliver the message to all the religions of Allaah including Islam and Christianity and Judaism.
Quran 5:48 Koran 5:48 And to you (Prophet Muhammad) We (Allaah) revealed the Scripture (the Quran) with the truth that confirmed the Scripture that was before it (in the Gospel Injil and the Torah Taurat) and (for you Prophet Muhammad to be) a guardian over it (the Quran). So judge between them (the Jews, the Christians and the Muslims) by what Allaah has revealed (to you Prophet Muhammad) and do not let their desires move you away from the truth that has come to you. …”
In the second part of Quran 5:48 Allaah explains why Allaah has given each religion of Allaah its own laws and its own Book meaning Allaah is protecting the Books of the Muslims and the Christians and the Jews as proof Allaah is real until the Day of Judgement.
Quran 5:48 Koran 5:48 “…. For each (community of Jews, Christians and Muslims) We (Allaah) have appointed a divine law and a way (of religion). If Allaah willed He (Allaah) could have made you (the Jews, the Christians and the Muslims) one community. But He (Allaah) tests you (the Jews, the Christians and the Muslims) by what He (Allaah) has given you (in the Torah Taurat and the Gospel Injil and the Koran Quran to show who is best in behaviour). So strive for all that is good. To Allaah you shall all return and He (Allaah) shall then inform you (in the Hereafter) about (the correctness of) the religious matters in which you (the Jews, the Christians and the Muslims) argue among each other.
Note 1. Prophet Muhammad did not punish people for peacefully leaving religion instead Prophet Muhammad said what Allaah revealed in Quran 5:48 that no one can believe unless it is the will of Allaah and to Allaah everyone will return for judgement.
Only when there are no threats from humans can a human find their true belief meaning Allaah has ordered freedom for humans to find their true belief before their natural death as explained in Quran 4:137 in 2 above.
Quran 2:62 Koran 2:62 Truly those (Muslims) who believed and those who became Jews, Christians and Sabians, whoever believed in Allaah and the Last Day (The Day of Resurrection) and did good deeds, they shall have their reward from their Lord, and they shall not fear or grieve in the hereafter.
Note 1. The Jews who believed in Allaah and did good deeds go to Paradise Jannah.
Note 2. The Christians who believed in Allaah and did good deeds go to Paradise Jannah.
Note 3. The Sabians who believed in Allaah and did good deeds go to Paradise Jannah.
Note 4. The Muslims who believed in Allaah and did good deeds go to Paradise Jannah.
Note 5. Everyone who believed in Allaah and did good deeds goes to Paradise Jannah.
Note 6. This revelation is so important that Allaah has repeated it in Quran 5:69
In Quran 2:62 and Quran 5:69 the promise of Paradise Jannah is not for those who “believe” but only for those who “believed” meaning who died (past tense) because it is not until the time of death that your true belief or disbelief and your good and evil deeds are judged,
Allaah repeated Quran 2:62 and Quran 5:69 two times because it is only with Quran 2:62 and Quran 5:69 that there are no contradictions within the Quran and between the Quran and the Torah Taurat and between the Quran and the Gospel Injil as proof in Quran 4:82 to the Jews in the time of Prophet Muhammad who are promised Paradise Jannah in Quran 3:113-3:115 and to the Christians in the time of Prophet Muhammad who are promised Paradise Jannah in Quran 5:82-5:85 and to the stone idol worshippers 1400 years ago who are not promised Paradise Jannah in Quran 3:85 and to all people today and in the future that the Quran is from Allaah because the Quran contains no contradictions.
If Quran 2:62 and Quran 5:69 did not exist then it would be proof that the Quran was not from Allaah because without Quran 2:62 and Quran 5:69 the Quran would contradict its self and contradict the Torah Taurat and contradict the Gospel Injil.
Quran 2:62 and Quran 5:69 is good news for Jews, Christians, Sabians, Muslims and all the people in the world confirming they will all come together again in a life after death.
Note 7. Prophet Muhammad did not punish people for peacefully leaving religion instead Prophet Muhammad said what Allaah revealed in Quran 2:62 and Quran 5:69 that no one can believe unless it is the will of Allaah and to Allaah everyone will return for judgement.
In Quran 4:123 the desires of Jews and Christians and Muslims is not a concern of Allaah because Allaah created every religion and gave each religion their laws and their Book and every person in every religion will be judged fairly in the hereafter meaning Allaah orders freedom for humans to find their true belief until their natural death as explained in Quran 4:137 in 2 above.
Quran 4:123 Koran 4:123 (Entry to Paradise Jannah) shall not be based on your (the Muslim's) desires or on the desires of the people of the Scripture (the Jews and the Christians). (Instead) whoever does wrong (on the earth) shall earn (the punishment for the wrong) and that person shall not find any protector or helper other than Allaah (in the hereafter).
Note 1. Prophet Muhammad did not punish people for peacefully leaving religion instead Prophet Muhammad said what Allaah revealed in Quran 4:123 that to Allaah everyone will return for judgement.
3. Quran 10:99 – 10:100 explains that Allaah has no interest in forcing people to stay in a religion in which they do not believe because the purpose of life is for each human to find their true belief before the time of their natural death meaning all hadith stories which claim Prophet Muhammad said “whoever changed his Islamic religion then kill him” were invented after the death of Prophet Muhammad.
Quran 10:99 Koran 10:99 And if your Lord (Allaah) had willed then all who are on the earth would have all believed together. (Allaah asks Prophet Muhammad), “Would you force people (against their will) to believe (in Allaah when it is Allaah who decrees who will believe and who will disbelieve)? (The answer is no, Islam does not force belief in Allaah because -).”
Quran 10:100 Koran 10:100 It is not for any soul to believe except by the permission of Allaah and He (Allaah) will place the anger (of Allaah in the hereafter) on those who do not use reason (to follow good behaviour).
Note 1. Prophet Muhammad did not punish people for peacefully leaving religion instead Prophet Muhammad said what Allaah revealed in Quran 10:99 – 10:100 that no one can believe unless it is the will of Allaah and it is not for humans to force a person to believe if they disbelieve.
4. In Quran 109:2 – Quran 109:6 Allaah teaches respect towards people who have different religions.
Quran 109:2 Koran 109:2 “I do not worship what you (the stone idol worshippers in Makkah) worship (that are stone idols).”
Quran 109:3 Koran 109:3 “Nor do you (the stone idol worshippers in Makkah) worship what I worship (that is Allaah).”
Quran 109:4 Koran 109:4 “And I shall not worship what you worship (that are stone idols).”
Quran 109:5 Koran 109:5 “Nor shall you worship what I worship (that is Allaah).”
Quran 109:6 Koran 109:6 “For you is your way (of religion, of belief) and for me is my way (of religion, of belief).”
Note 1. Prophet Muhammad did not punish people for peacefully leaving religion instead Prophet Muhammad said what Allaah revealed in Quran 109:2 – Quran 109:6 that no one can believe unless it is the will of Allaah and that people with different beliefs must be respected as you would like them to respect your belief in Allaah.
5. Belief in Allaah must not come from fearing humans because that is a false belief.
The only true belief in Allaah comes from the heart and not from the fear of humans meaning all hadith stories which claim Prophet Muhammad said “whoever changed his Islamic religion then kill him” were invented after the death of Prophet Muhammad.
Quran 2:40 Koran 2:40 “… fear no one except Me (Allaah).”
Quran 2:150 Koran 2:150 “… So do not fear them (humans) but fear Me (Allaah) so that I (Allaah) may complete My (Allaah’s) blessings on you and that you may walk on the right path.
Quran 2:155 Koran 2:155 “And We (Allaah) shall test you with some fear …”
Quran 3:173 Koran 3:173 Those to whom the people said, "the people have gathered against you so fear them" instead increased the faith of the faithful and they said, "Allaah (alone) is all we need and He (Allaah) is our best protector."
Quran 2:189 Koran 2:189 “… righteous (is the person) who fears Allaah.”
Quran 3:175 Koran 3:175 It is only Satan Shaitan that suggests that you fear his supporters, so do not fear them but fear Me (Allaah), if you have (true) faith (in Allaah).
Quran 4:77 Koran 4:77 “… then suddenly some of them feared humans as they feared Allaah or even feared humans more than they feared Allaah …. The Hereafter is much better for those who fear Allaah …”
Quran 5:3 Koran 5:3 “… Today those without faith have despair of (not being able to destroy) your religion, so do not fear them (humans) but fear Me (Allaah) instead …”
Quran 5:44 Koran 5:44 “… So do not fear humans but fear Me (Allaah) … Whoever does not judge by what Allaah has revealed is a disbeliever in Allaah.”
Quran 5:54 Koran 5:54 O you who believe (in Allaah), Whoever among you turns back (leaves) from his religion (allow them to leave), soon Allaah shall bring a people (to replace those who leave) whom He (Allaah) loves and who love Him (Allaah) and (they shall be) humble toward those with faith (in Allaah) and stern (by standing up for their rights) toward those without faith (in Allaah), striving in the way of Allaah and without fear of anyone who may criticize them (for their faith in Allaah). This is the grace that Allaah gives to whomever He (Allaah) wills. Allaah encompasses all (the things in our life) and (Allaah) knows all things.
Quran 9:13 Koran 9:13 “… Surely Allaah has more right that you should fear Him (Allaah), if you are (true) believers (in Allaah).”
Quran 12:57 Koran 12:57 “… And the reward of the Hereafter is better for those who believe and who used to fear Allaah.
Quran 16:50 Koran 16:50 They (who believe in Allaah) fear their Lord (Allaah) above them (humans) and they do what they are commanded.
Quran 16:52 Koran 16:52 To Him (Allaah) belongs whatever is in the heavens and the earth and to Him (Allaah) is due constant worship. Shall you then fear anyone other than Allaah?
Note 1. Prophet Muhammad did not punish people for peacefully leaving religion instead Prophet Muhammad said what Allaah revealed above where belief must come from the fear and love of Allaah and not from the fear of humans and threats from humans.
6. The good news message from Allaah for Jews and Christians delivered 1400 years ago by Prophet Muhammad in Quran 28:54, Quran 34:37 and Quran 57:28.
1. Jews and Christians who follow their Book and also believe the Quran shall receive a double reward in the hereafter in Quran 28:54, Quran 34:37 and Quran 57:28.
2. Jews who follow the Tanakh Jewish scripture and believe the Quran are correctly observing the Torah Taurat.
3. Christians who follow the Gospels and believe the Quran are correctly observing the Gospel Injil.
4. Muslims who follow the Quran so that it agrees with the Tanakh Jewish scripture and the Gospel Injil are correctly observing the Quran.
Quran 28:53 Koran 28:53 And when it (the Quran) is recited to them (the Jews who truly believe the Torah Taurat and the Christians who truly believe the Gospel Injil), they (those Jews and Christians) say, “We believe in it (the Koran Quran). It is the truth from our Lord (Allaah). Even before it (the Quran was revealed to us) we were of those (Jews and Christians) who submitted (to Allaah. The English word submitter is the Arabic word Muslim. Islam the religion means submission and Muslim the believer means submitter. Submitter and submission for the Muslim people is in Quran 47:19 “…there is no Allaah except Allaah …” and submitter and submission for the Jewish people is in Torah Exodus 20:2 “.... You shall have no other gods before Me Allaah” and submitter and submission for the Christian people is in the Gospel of Jesus Isa by Luke 4:8 “… You shall worship the Lord your Allaah, and him only shall you serve” meaning Allaah inspired the same belief of Islam which is an Arabic word meaning submission, to Allaah in Judaism, Christianity, Islam and in others). - (Continued in Quran 28:54).
Note 1. The Quran confirms the Torah Taurat and explains the story of Jesus in the Gospel of Mark, Matthew, Luke and John.
Quran 28:54 Koran 28:54 They (the Jews who truly believe the Torah Taurat and the Christians who truly believe the Gospel Injil and also believe the Quran) shall be given their reward twice (in Quran 28:54 meaning twofold in Quran 34:37 meaning double in Quran 57:28) because they are steadfast (in their belief in Allaah) and they repel evil with good (deeds) and they spend (in charity) from what We (Allaah) have provided to them. (Jews and Christians who follow their Book in Quran 5:68 and also believe the Quran will receive a double reward in the hereafter in Quran 28:54, Quran 34:37 and Quran 57:28 meaning the reward for every good deed they do will be doubled because they believed the Quran which tells the Jewish people to follow the Torah Taurat which is their eternal covenant between Allaah and the Hebrew people forever and tells the Christian people to follow the Gospel Injil which is explained in the Quran and tells the Muslim people to follow the Quran in Quran 2:40, Quran 2:41, Quran 2:62, Quran 2:106, Quran 3:93, Quran 4:123, Quran 5:43, Quran 5:47, Quran 5:48, Quran 5:69 and Quran 13:39).
Note 1. Jews and Christians who follow their book and also believe the Quran will receive their reward twice in the Hereafter.
Quran 34:37 Koran 34:37 – It is not your wealth or your children that shall bring you close to Us (Allaah), but the person who believes and does good (deeds). Theirs shall be a twofold reward (twice in Quran 28:54, twofold in Quran 34:37 and double in Quran 57:28) for what they (the Jews like Quran 3:113 - 3:115 and the Christians like Quran 5:82 - 5:85 who follow their Book in Quran 5:68 and also believe the Quran) did (because they believed the Quran which tells the Jewish people to follow the Torah Taurat which is their eternal covenant between Allaah and the Hebrew people forever and tells the Christian people to follow the Gospel Injil which is explained in the Quran and tells the Muslim people to follow the Quran is confirmed in Quran 2:40, Quran 2:41, Quran 2:62, Quran 2:106, Quran 3:93, Quran 4:123, Quran 5:43, Quran 5:47, Quran 5:48, Quran 5:69 and Quran 13:39) and they (those Jews and Christians) shall live secure in the high dwellings (in Paradise Jannah).- (Continued in Quran 34:38).
Note 1. Jews and Christians who follow their Book and also believe the Quran will be given a twofold reward in the hereafter.
Quran 34:38 Koran 34:38 (Jews and Christians who followed their Book and also believed the Quran will receive their reward twice in Quran 28:54, twofold in Quran 34:37 and double in Quran 57:28 in the hereafter however) Those (Jews and the Christians who did not believe the Quran for example if Jews did not correctly observe the Torah Taurat by keeping the Sabbath Day which is their everlasting covenant with Allaah in every generation forever or if Christians did not correctly observe the Gospel Injil where Prophet Jesus said he is not Allaah "Allaah is my Allaah and your Allaah" meaning Allaah is my Lord and your Lord and "Allaah is my Father and your Father" meaning Allaah is my Creator and your Creator in Gospel of John 20:17 and) who strive against Our (Allaah’s) revelations by trying to make them (Allaah’s revelations) to fail (for example Jesus is the son of Allaah means Jesus is the servant of Allaah delivering the message of Allaah so his mention with angels in Gospel of Mark 13:32 and Gospel of Matthew 24:36 means that angel messengers of Allaah and human messengers of Allaah both do not know the hour meaning do not confuse angel and human messengers with Allaah because only Allaah knows the hour but His angel and human messengers like Jesus and Moses and angels do not know the hour meaning pray only to Allaah and not to the angel and human messengers of Allaah because those who do), they shall be brought to the punishment (of Hell Jahannam in the Hereafter).
Quran 57:28 Koran 57:28 All you (the Jews and the Christians in Quran 57:27 and Quran 57:29) that believe, Fear Allaah and believe in His (Allaah’s) messenger and He (Allaah) shall give you a double portion of His (Allaah’s) mercy and provide for you a Light (of righteous knowledge meaning Jews who follow the Tanakh Jewish scripture and believe the Quran are correctly observing the Torah Taurat and meaning Christians who follow the Gospel and believe the Quran are correctly observing the Gospel Injil and Muslims who follow the Quran so that it agrees with the Tanakh Jewish scripture and the Gospel Injil are correctly observing the warning from Allaah in Quran 4:136 that whoever has no faith in Allaah’s Books has strayed far away from Allaah because the Books of Allaah are the light) by which you shall walk (on the correct path in Quran 2:40 - 2:41, Quran 4:136 and Quran 28:48 - 28:49) and (in the hereafter) He (Allaah) shall forgive you (of your past sins). Allaah is forgiving and merciful. (Jews like Quran 3:113 - 3:115 and Christians like Quran 5:82 - 5:85 who follow their Book in Quran 5:68 and also believe the Quran will receive their reward twice in Quran 28:54, twofold in Quran 34:37 and double in Quran 57:28 in the hereafter meaning the reward for every good deed they do will be doubled because they believed the Quran which tells the Jewish people to follow the Torah Taurat which is their eternal covenant between Allaah and the Hebrew people forever and tells the Christian people to follow the Gospel Injil which is explained in the Quran and tells the Muslim people to follow the Quran is confirmed in Quran 2:40, Quran 2:41, Quran 2:62, Quran 2:106, Quran 3:93, Quran 4:123, Quran 5:43, Quran 5:47, Quran 5:48, Quran 5:69 and Quran 13:39). - (Continued in Quran 57:29).
Note 1. Jews and Christians who follow their Book and also believe the Quran will be given a double reward in the hereafter.
Quran 57:29 Koran 57:29 (Jews and Christians who followed their Book and also believed the Quran will receive their reward twice in Quran 28:54, twofold in Quran 34:37 and double in Quran 57:28 in the hereafter) so that the people of the Book (the Jews and the Christians who did not believe the Quran for example if Jews did not correctly observe the Torah Taurat by keeping the Sabbath Day which is their everlasting covenant with Allaah in every generation forever or if Christians did not correctly observe the Gospel Injil where Prophet Jesus said he is not Allaah "Allaah is my Allaah and your Allaah" meaning Allaah is my Lord and your Lord and "Allaah is my Father and your Father" meaning Allaah is my Creator and your Creator in Gospel of John 20:17 and that Jesus is the son of Allaah means Jesus is the servant of Allaah delivering the message of Allaah so his mention with angels in Gospel of Mark 13:32 and Gospel of Matthew 24:36 means that angel messengers of Allaah and human messengers of Allaah both do not know the hour meaning do not confuse angel and human messengers with Allaah because only Allaah knows the hour but His angel and human messengers like Jesus and Moses and angels do not know the hour meaning pray only to Allaah and not to the angel and human messengers of Allaah because those who do) may know (in the hereafter) that they do not have power over anything from the bounty of Allaah and that (all) the bounty is in Allaah’s hand. He gives it (Allaah's bounty) to whom He (Allaah) wills. And Allaah is the possessor of the great bounty (of Paradise Jannah).
Quran 4:40 Koran 4:40 Allaah is not unjust not even as much as the weight of an atom (to people such as Jews and Christians and Muslims and all others). When any good (deed is done) He (Allaah) doubles it (meaning Allaah doubles the value of your good deeds) and He (Allaah) gives a great reward (of Paradise Jannah in the hereafter).
Note 1. The good news from Allaah for Muslims delivered 1400 years ago by Prophet Muhammad in Quran 2:265, Quran 4:40 and Quran 33:31 is that the reward to Muslims for doing good deeds is also doubled in the hereafter meaning the reward for every good deed they do in this world will be doubled in the hereafter.
Quran 42:15 Koran 42:15 So (Prophet Muhammad) invite (the people to Allaah), and stay on the correct path as you (Prophet Muhammad) are commanded and do not follow their (the peoples) desires (concerning religion) but say, "I believe what Allaah has sent down of the Book (in the Quran and in the Torah Taurat in Quran 2:41, Quran 3:3, Quran 3:93, Quran 5:43, Quran 5:44, Quran 5:68, Quran 20:133 and in the Gospel Injil in Quran 3:3, Quran 5:47, Quran 5:68 and Quran 20:133) and I am commanded that I do justice between you (the Jews, Christians and Muslims). Allaah is our Lord and your Lord (meaning Allaah is the Lord of the Muslims and the Lord of the Jews and the Christians). For us (Muslims is the responsibility for) our deeds and for you (Jews and Christians is the responsibility for) your deeds. There is no argument between us (Muslims) and between you (the Jews and the Christians because Allaah has revealed the same message to all of us to worship Allaah who created you and do good in the world and reject evil in the world). Allaah shall bring us (Muslims and Christians and Jews and all humankind) together and to Him (Allaah) is the final destination (in the hereafter in Quran 2:62, Quran 3:64, Quran 4:123, Quran 5:48 and Quran 5:69).”
Note 1. There is no argument between Muslims and Jews and Christians because the Tanakh Jewish scripture and the Gospel Injil and the Quran contain the same message to worship Allaah and strive for all that is good.
Quran 28:51 Koran 28:51 And We (Allaah) have made the Word (of Allaah in the Quran) to reach them (the stone idol worshippers of Makkah Arabia) so that they might be reminded (of Allaah, their creator).
Quran 28:48 Koran 28:48 But when the truth came to them (the stone idol worshippers of Makkah Arabia) from Us (Allaah), they said, “Why is he (Prophet Muhammad M Mim م M-uhammad م-uhammad) not given (signs) like what was given to Prophet Moses Musa (represented by Mount Sinai S’ Sin س Sin-ai س-ai)? But did they (the stone idol worshippers of Makkah Arabia) not disbelieve in what was given to Prophet Moses Musa in the past? (Because) they say, “(They are both only books about magic) two magic (books the Torah Taurat T Ta ط Ta-urat ط-urat given by Allaah to Prophet Moses Musa and the Quran Q Qaf ق Qaf-uran ق-uran given by Allaah to Prophet Muhammad) supporting each other” and they (the stone idol worshippers of Makkah Arabia) say, “In all (that is in the Torah Taurat and the Quran) we do not believe.”
Quran 28:49 Koran 28:49 Say (Prophet Muhammad to the stone idol worshippers of Makkah Arabia), “Then bring a Book from Allaah that gives better guidance than these two (the Torah Taurat and the Quran) so that I (Prophet Muhammad) may follow it, if you are telling the truth.”
Note 1. The best guidance is the Quran and the Torah Taurat meaning both are correctly understood when they confirm and explain each other.
Quran 3:199 Koran 3:199 And there are among the people of the Scripture (the Jews and the Christians) those who believe in Allaah and in that which has been revealed to you (Prophet Muhammad in the Quran) and revealed to them (in the Torah Taurat and in the Gospel Injil), (they) humble themselves to Allaah. They do not trade away (abandon) the revelations of Allaah for a little gain (by wrongly using the revelations of Allaah to increase their pride or arrogance), for them is a reward with their Lord. Allaah is quick to account (for what you do).
Note 1. The Quran confirms the Tanakh Jewish scripture is correct and explains the story of Prophet Jesus Isa in the Gospel of Mark, Matthew, Luke and John.
Quran 3:113 Koran 3:113 Not all of them (the Jews of Yathrib Arabia later Medina Arabia today Madinah Saudi Arabia) are the same, some of the people of the Scripture (the Jews of Yathrib) stand for what is right (correct) and they recite the revelations of Allaah during the hours of the night prostrating themselves in prayer (to Allaah).
Quran 3:114 Koran 3:114 Those (Jews of Yathrib) believe in Allaah and the Last Day and they do what is right and forbid what is wrong and they are quick to do good deeds and they are among the righteous.
Quran 3:115 Koran 3:115 And whatever good they (the Jews of Yathrib) do, it shall be accepted and Allaah knows very well who are the righteous (among the Jews of Yathrib).
Note 1. The righteous among the Jews were promised Paradise Jannah in the time of Prophet Muhammad and this promise would apply to the righteous among Jews worldwide.
Quran 5:82 Koran 5:82 "... And you shall find that those who say, “We are Christians” have the most affection to the believers (of Allaah, the Muslims in Yathrib Arabia). That is because the priests and monks are not proud (meaning they love Allaah more than they love their pride).
Quran 5:83 Koran 5:83 When they (the Christian priests and monks) listen to what has been revealed to the messenger (Prophet Muhammad), you shall see their eyes overflow with tears because they recognise it is the truth (from Allaah). They say, “Our Lord (Allaah), we believe, so write us as among the witnesses (that recognize the truth from Allaah).”
Quran 5:84 Koran 5:84 Why should we (Christian priests and monks) not have faith in Allaah and in the truth that has come to us since we hope that our Lord (Allaah) shall admit us (to paradise) with the righteous people?
Quran 5:85 Koran 5:85 For what they (the Christian priests and monks) said they are rewarded with gardens with rivers flowing underneath (in Paradise) where they shall live forever. That is the reward for those (people) that do good.
Note 1. The righteous among the Christians were promised Paradise Jannah in the time of Prophet Muhammad and this promise would apply to the righteous among the Christians worldwide.
See 1. Video: Torah and Injeel were corrupted? (The Quran says no).
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kQ3o3ybc-KA
See 2. Allaah protects the Torah, Gospel and Koran. Allaah protects the Taurat, Injil and Quran.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/allaah-protects-the-taurat-injil-and-quran
7. Prophet Muhammad is not a controller of people he is only a warner.
Quran 88:21 - Quran 88:26 shows that Allaah makes humans afraid of Allaah with punishment in the hereafter and confirms that Prophet Muhammad is not a controller of humans but only a warner to humans meaning all hadith stories which claim Prophet Muhammad said “whoever changed his Islamic religion then kill him” were invented after the death of Prophet Muhammad.
The only true belief in Allaah is belief which comes from the heart and not from the fear of humans meaning all hadith stories which claim Prophet Muhammad said “whoever changed his Islamic religion then kill him” were invented after the death of Prophet Muhammad because such a statement seeks to control humans by making humans afraid not of Allaah but afraid of humans who threaten to kill humans showing that all such hadith stories were invented by humans who wanted to control humans by making humans afraid of humans.
Quran 88:21 Koran 88:21 So remind them (of Allaah who is their creator); you (Prophet Muhammad) are only a reminder (meaning, a messenger from Allaah).
Quran 88:22 Koran 88:22 You (Prophet Muhammad) do not control them.
Note 1. The controller of the creation is Allaah who is the creator of the creation.
Note 2. Only Allaah determines who will believe and who will disbelieve in Quran 10:99 – 10:100 in 3 above.
Note 3. Only Allaah determines when people will believe and when people will disbelieve in Quran 4:137 in 2 above.
Note 4. Allaah allows humans to leave or change their religion in Quran 5:54 in 1 above,
Note 5. Allaah has decreed freedom to join or not to join religion in Quran 2:256 in 9 below.
Note 6. Allaah has decreed freedom to leave religion or to change religion in Quran 5:54 in 1 above.
Note 7. Allaah has decreed freedom to believe or to disbelieve until the time natural death comes to a human in Quran 4:137 in 2 above.
Note 8. Quran 2:256 Allaah says there is no compulsion in religion meaning Allaah gives every human the freedom to join or not to join religion and the freedom to change religion and this is confirmed in notes 1 – 7.
Note 9. Prophet Muhammad did not punish people for peacefully leaving religion instead Prophet Muhammad said what Allaah revealed in Quran 88:22 that Prophet Muhammad does not control a person meaning the punishment for disbelief comes in the hereafter from Allaah who is the judge of belief.
Quran 88:23 Koran 88:23 But whoever turns away (from the word of Allaah) and disbelieves.
Quran 88:24 Koran 88:24 Then Allaah shall greatly punish them (in the hereafter).
Note 1. Punishment for disbelief comes from Allaah in the hereafter and not from humans in this world because Allaah gives every human their life until their natural death to find their true belief.
Quran 88:25 Koran 88:25 To Us (Allaah) they shall return (in the hereafter).
Quran 88:26 Koran 88:26 Then to Us (Allaah) they shall account (for what they did in their life).
Note 1. Punishment for disbelief comes from Allaah in the hereafter and not from humans in this world because Allaah gives every human their life until their natural death to find their true belief.
8. Prophet Muhammad is not a compeller of people he is only a warner.
Prophet Muhammad is not a person to compel people to believe in Allaah because no one can believe in Allaah without the permission of Allaah as explained in Quran 10:99 – 10:100 in 3 above.
A person who says “anyone who leaves their Islamic religion must be killed” is compelling people to believe in Allaah meaning all hadith stories which claim Prophet Muhammad said “whoever changed his Islamic religion then kill him” were invented after the death of Prophet Muhammad.
Quran 50:45 Koran 50:45 We (Allaah) are best aware of what they (the stone idol worshippers in Makkah Arabia) say (about resurrection) and you (Prophet Muhammad) are not over them the one to compel (people to believe in Allaah and the resurrection of the dead back to life in the hereafter). But remind with the Quran whoever fears My (Allaah’s) threat (of punishment for evil doers and reward for righteousness in the hereafter).
Note 1. Prophet Muhammad did not punish people for peacefully leaving religion instead Prophet Muhammad said what Allaah revealed in Quran 50:45 that Prophet Muhammad is not a compeller who forces people to believe but only a warner meaning the punishment for disbelief comes in the hereafter from Allaah who is the judge of belief.
9. In Islam there is “no compulsion in religion” because every human in the world is given life until the time of their natural death to find their true belief meaning all hadith stories which claim Prophet Muhammad said “whoever changed his Islamic religion then kill him” were invented after the death of Prophet Muhammad.
Quran 2:256 Koran 2:256 There is no compulsion in religion (meaning, religion must come voluntarily from the human heart and not from the fear of humans or by force) …”
Quran 18:29 Koran 18:29 And say, “The truth (of the Quran) is from your Lord (Allaah)" so whoever wishes let them believe and whoever wishes let them disbelieve. We (Allaah) have prepared for the wrongdoers a Fire whose walls shall surround them (in the Hereafter). …”
Note 1. Prophet Muhammad did not punish people for peacefully leaving religion instead Prophet Muhammad said what Allaah revealed in Quran 2:256 that there is no compulsion in religion and in Quran 18:29 whoever wishes let them believe and whoever wishes let them disbelieve and that punishment for disbelief comes from Allaah in the hereafter not from humans in this world.
10. Allaah did not tell Prophet Muhammad to kill the people who might have wanted to leave Islam in Quran 3:159.
Quran 3:159 Koran 3:159 So because of the mercy of Allaah you (Prophet Muhammad) dealt gently with them (who disobeyed your orders at the battle of Uhud), If you (Prophet Muhammad) had been rude and harsh in your heart then surely they would have dispersed from around you (and abandoned the religion of Allaah but they did not do that because of the goodness Allaah has put in your heart which is an excellent example to them of the religion of Allaah). So pardon them (for having left their positions in the battlefield to collect war booty) and ask forgiveness (from Allaah) for them and consult with them about the matter (which occurred at the battle of Uhud). Then when you have (all) decided the matter then put your trust in Allaah. Allaah loves those who put their trust (in Allaah).
Note 1. In Quran 3:159 Allaah did not tell Prophet Muhammad to kill the people who might have wanted to leave Islam because in Quran 5:54 in 1 above Allaah says Muslims can leave Islam if that is the will of Allaah.
Note 2. In Quran 3:159 Allaah did not tell Prophet Muhammad to kill the people who might have wanted to leave Islam because in Quran 4:137 in 2 above Allaah says every human can change their religion until the time of their natural death.
Note 3. In Quran 3:159 Allaah did not tell Prophet Muhammad to kill the people who might have wanted to leave Islam because in Quran 10:99 – 10:100 in 3 above Allaah has no interest in forcing people to stay in a religion in which they do not believe because the purpose of life is for each human to find their true belief before the time of their natural death.
Note 4. In Quran 3:159 Allaah did not tell Prophet Muhammad to kill the people who might have wanted to leave Islam because in Quran 109:2 – Quran 109:6 in 4 above people in each religion should be respected like you would want them to respect your religion.
Note 5. In Quran 3:159 Allaah did not tell Prophet Muhammad to kill the people who might have wanted to leave Islam because belief in Allaah must not come from fearing humans because that is a false belief.
Note 6. In Quran 3:159 Allaah did not tell Prophet Muhammad to kill the people who might have wanted to leave Islam because in Quran 28:54 in 6 above the changing of religion within the religions of Allaah is acceptable to Allaah because every religion of Allaah worships the same Allaah and this is confirmed and explained in Quran 2:62, Quran 4:123 and Quran 5:48 in 2 above and Quran 3:85 in 12 below.
Note 7. In Quran 3:159 Allaah did not tell Prophet Muhammad to kill the people who might have wanted to leave Islam because in Quran 88:21 – Quran 88:26 in 7 above Allaah says Prophet Muhammad is not a controller of people he is only a warner.
Note 8. In Quran 3:159 Allaah did not tell Prophet Muhammad to kill the people who might have wanted to leave Islam because in Quran 50:45 in 8 above Allaah says Prophet Muhammad is not a compeller of people he is only a warner because no one can believe in Allaah without the permission of Allaah as explained in Quran 10:99 – 10:100 in 3 above.
Note 9. In Quran 3:159 Allaah did not tell Prophet Muhammad to kill the people who might have wanted to leave Islam because in Quran 2:256 in 9 above Allaah says there is “no compulsion in religion” because every human in the world is given life until the time of their natural death to find their true belief in Quran 4:137 in 2 above.
Note 10. In Quran 3:159 Allaah did not tell Prophet Muhammad to kill the people who might have wanted to leave Islam because in Quran 18:29 in 9 above Allaah says "whoever wishes let them believe and whoever wishes let them disbelieve" and that punishment for disbelief comes from Allaah in the hereafter not from humans in this world because every human in the world is given life until the time of their natural death to find their true belief in Quran 4:137 in 2 above.
Note 11. The only true belief in Allaah is belief which comes from the heart and not from the fear of humans meaning all hadith stories which claim Prophet Muhammad said “whoever changed his Islamic religion then kill him” were invented after the death of Prophet Muhammad because such a statement seeks to control humans by making humans afraid not of Allaah but afraid of humans who threaten to kill humans showing that all such hadith stories were invented by humans who wanted to control humans by making humans afraid of humans.
Note 12. In Quran 3:159 Allaah said people did not leave Islam because Allaah put goodness in the heart of Prophet Muhammad so that he would be an excellent example of Islam meaning people who have goodness in their heart bring people to Islam and encourage people to stay in Islam without force or threats because there is no compulsion to join religion or to stay in religion.
This means Allaah puts goodness in hearts of people who bring people into Islam and Allaah removes goodness in the hearts of people to cause other people to remove themselves from Islam meaning in all cases it is Allaah who brings people to Islam and it is Allaah who is removing people from Islam.
11. Prophet Muhammad did not say “whoever changed his Islamic religion then kill him” because belief in Allaah from the fear of threats from humans is a false belief in Allaah.
Allaah does not want people in Islam who do not believe in Allaah that is why Allaah told Prophet Muhammad to say in Quran 5:54 in 1 above people can leave Islam if that is the will of Allaah and Allaah shall bring a people to replace those people who leave whom He Allaah loves and who love Him Allaah.
In the same way belief without doing good deeds is also a false belief in Allaah.
Satan Shaitan believes in the Last Day which is the Day of Resurrection and Judgement and Satan Shaitan believes in Allaah but it is a false belief in Allaah because Satan Shaitan does not do good deeds.
Quran 2:62 Koran 2:62 Truly those (Muslims) who believed and those who became Jews, Christians and Sabians, whoever believed in Allaah and the Last Day (The Day of Resurrection) and did good deeds, they shall have their reward from their Lord, and they shall not fear or grieve in the hereafter.
Quran 6:158 Koran 6:158 "... belief in it (Allaah and the Day of Resurrection and Judgement) shall not help any soul …. if in belief (he or she) did not earn good (by doing righteous deeds in their life). ....”
Quran 41:8 Koran 41:8 “For those who believe and do good deeds, for them is an everlasting reward (in Paradise Jannah).”
12. The same message of Islam in Judaism and in Christianity of submission to Allaah is protected until the Day of Judgement in Taurat Torah Exodus 20:2 “.... You shall have no other gods before Me Allaah” and in the Gospel of Jesus Isa by Luke 4:8 “… You shall worship the Lord your Allaah, and him only shall you serve” and in the Quran 47:19 “…there is no Allaah except Allaah …”
Quran 3:85 Koran 3:85 And whoever seeks a religion other than submission (to Allah Adonai Allaah Elohim G-d Allah HaShem Jehovah Yahweh YHWH which includes every human from the beginning of time until the end of time, for example stone idol worship) it shall not be accepted by Him (Allaah) in the Hereafter and (such a person) shall be one of the losers (in the hereafter. The word Islam has two meanings, the general meaning is submission in Quran 3:85 meaning anyone who submits to Allaah).
Note 1. The Muslim religion Islam is the religion of submission to Allaah (Quran 3:64).
Note 2. The Jewish religion Judaism is the religion of submission to Allaah (Quran 3:64).
Note 3. The Christian religion Christianity is the religion of submission to Allaah (Quran 3:64).
Note 4. Islam means submission and the Quran tells the Jews to observe the Sabbath Day meaning all Jews who observe the Sabbath Day are submitting to Allaah which means the word in Quran 3:85 is submission otherwise it would contradict other verses in the Quran and the Quran says it has no contradictions.
This means only one word "submission" is correct because it is the word with which there are no contradictions in the Quran.
B. Summary.
a. Quran 5:54 says Muslims can leave Islam if that is the will of Allaah in 1 above.
b. Quran 4:137 says every human can change their religion until the time of their natural death in 2 above.
c. Quran 10:99 – 10:100 explains that Allaah has no interest in forcing people to stay in a religion in which they do not believe because the purpose of life is for each human to find their true belief before the time of their natural death in 3 above.
d. Quran 109:2 – Quran 109:6 shows that Allaah teaches respecting people who have different religions in 4 above.
e. Belief in Allaah must not come from fearing humans because that is a false belief in 5 above.
f. Quran 28:54 in 6 above shows that changing religion within the religions of Allaah is acceptable to Allaah because every religion worships the same Allaah and this is confirmed and explained in Quran 2:62, Quran 4:123 and Quran 5:48 in 2 above and Quran 3:85 in 12 above.
g. Quran 88:21 – Quran 88:26 in 7 above Allaah says Prophet Muhammad is not a controller of people he is only a warner.
The only true belief in Allaah is belief which comes from the heart and not from the fear of humans meaning all hadith stories which claim Prophet Muhammad said “whoever changed his Islamic religion then kill him” were invented after the death of Prophet Muhammad because such a statement seeks to control humans by making humans afraid not of Allaah but afraid of humans who threaten to kill humans showing that all such hadith stories were invented by humans who wanted to control humans by making humans afraid of humans.
h. Quran 50:45 in 8 above Allaah says Prophet Muhammad is not a compeller of people he is only a warner because no one can believe in Allaah without the permission of Allaah as explained in Quran 10:99 – 10:100 in 3 above.
A person who says “anyone who leaves their Islamic religion must be killed” is compelling people to believe in Allaah by making humans fear humans instead of fearing Allaah meaning all hadith stories which claim Prophet Muhammad said “whoever changed his Islamic religion then kill him” were invented after the death of Prophet Muhammad.
i. Quran 2:256 in 9 above Allaah says there is “no compulsion in religion” because every human in the world is given life until the time of their natural death to find their true belief.
j. In Quran 18:29 in 9 above Allaah says."whoever wishes let them believe and whoever wishes let them disbelieve" and that punishment for disbelief comes from Allaah in the hereafter not from humans in this world.
k. In Quran 3:159 in 10 above Allaah shows how he forgives and prevents people from leaving religion not with punishment but with kindness as a mercy to them from Allaah.
l. In Quran 4:137 in 2 above Allaah shows how he makes people leave religion and makes clear that punishment comes in the hereafter because whoever leaves religion has a lifetime to find their true belief which means they have a lifetime to return to religion before the time of their natural death.
m. The forgiveness of people who were saved from leaving religion in Quran 3:159 in 10 above with no punishment and the lifetime given to each human to find their true belief as they accept religion and reject religion and again accept religion and again reject religion in Quran 4:137 in 2 above with no punishment in this world shows that the idea that people are to be killed for leaving their Islamic religion is opposite to what Allaah teaches in the Quran meaning this hadith story is invented by people who desire to be the controller of other people contradicting Quran 88:21 – Quran 88:26 in 7 above and these hadith stories are invented by people who wanted to compel other people contradicting Quran 50:45 in 8 above meaning these hadith stories were invented after the death of Prophet Muhammad.
n. Allaah sent down Quran 2:256, Quran 3:159, Quran 4:137, Quran 5:54, Quran 10:99 – 10:100, Quran 28:54, Quran 50:45, Quran 88:21 - 88:26 and Quran 109:2 –109:6 meaning Prophet Muhammad never said “anyone who leaves their Islamic religion must be killed.”
o. Prophet Muhammad delivered the message in Quran 2:256, Quran 3:159, Quran 4:137, Quran 5:54, Quran 10:99 – 10:100, Quran 28:54, Quran 50:45, Quran 88:21 - 88:26 and Quran 109:2 –109:6 meaning Prophet Muhammad never said “anyone who leaves their Islamic religion must be killed.”
p. Allaah repeats many times that the correct story is the story in the Quran.
Then Allaah asks many times who will believe a different story to what Allaah has said in the Quran? meaning all hadith stories that claim Muslims who leave their religion are to be killed were invented after the death of Prophet Muhammad in the same way as all hadith stories about punishment in the grave and the return of Prophet Jesus Isa to this earth were invented after the death of Prophet Muhammad as explained in Example 1 above in the same way as stories claiming Prophet Jesus Isa is Allaah were invented after the death of Prophet Jesus Isa.
Quran 7:185 Koran 7:185 “... In what statement (words, news, reports, information, message, hadith) after (they have heard) this (Quran) would they believe?
Note 1. Allaah asks who will believe the Quran and who will believe a teaching that is different to what Allaah teaches in the Quran?
Quran 24:12 Koran 24:12 Why did not the believers (both) men and women when you heard it (the lie that Aishah the wife of Prophet Muhammad had committed illegal sexual intercourse with another man or in this example of the lies in hadith stories that Prophet Muhammad said 'whoever changed his Islamic religion then kill him” which contradicts the teaching of Allaah in Quran 2:256, Quran 3:159, Quran 4:137, Quran 5:54, Quran 10:99 – 10:100, Quran 18:29, Quran 28:54, Quran 50:45, Quran 88:21 - 88:26 and Quran 109:2 –109:6) think good about your own people and say, “This (hadith) is clearly a lie?”
Quran 25:29 Koran 25:29 – “He (Satan Shaitan with false messages, false words, false news, false reports, false information, false statements, false hadith) has led me astray from the reminder (of Allaah in the Quran) after it (the Quran) had reached me.” Satan Shaitan always betrays humans (by leading them astray away from the Quran).
Note 1. Satan Shaitan misleads some people away from the Quran with nice sounding stories that contradict the Quran.
Quran 25:30 Koran 25:30 And (on the Day of Resurrection and Judgement) the messenger (Prophet Muhammad) said, “My Lord (Allaah) my people have abandoned (deserted) this Quran (to follow false messages, false words, false news, false reports, false information, false statements, false hadith).”
Note 1. On the Day of Resurrection and Judgement Prophet Muhammad will say “My Lord my people have abandoned this Quran (to follow false messages, false words, false news, false reports, false information, false statements, false hadith).”
Quran 31:6 Koran 31:6 Among people is the person who shall accept baseless stories (words, news, reports, information, statement, hadith) without knowledge (of the truthfulness of the story) so that they may mislead (people) from Allaah’s way (in the Quran) and (by believing false stories they) make mockery of it (the Quran). For them is a humiliating punishment (in the Hereafter).
Quran 39:23 Koran 39:23 Allaah has revealed the best statement (the best message, the best word, the best news, the best report, the best information, the best story, the best hadith in) a Book (the Quran) whose statements confirm each other. The skins shiver among those who fear their Lord (Allaah) and then their skins and their hearts relax when they remember Allaah (in praise of Allaah and in prayer to Allaah). That (Quran) is the guidance of Allaah, He (Allaah) guides with it (the Quran) whom He (Allaah) wills. And whoever Allaah lets go astray for them there is no guide (to righteous behaviour).
Note 1. Allaah says the statements in the Quran confirm each other and this can be seen in Quran 2:256, Quran 3:159, Quran 4:137, Quran 5:54, Quran 10:99 – 10:100, Quran 18:29, Quran 28:54, Quran 50:45, Quran 88:21 - 88:26 and Quran 109:2 –109:6 which confirm there is no punishment in this world for peacefully leaving religion or peacefully changing religion.
Allaah says “The Quran is the guidance of Allaah.”
Allaah says “Allaah guides with the Quran whom Allaah wills.”
Quran 45:6 Koran 45:6 These are the verses of Allaah, We (Allaah through angel Gabriel Jibril) recite them to you (Prophet Muhammad) truthfully. In what statement (words, news, reports, information, message, hadith) will they (the humans and jinn) believe (and trust in) after Allaah and His verses (which they have in the Quran until the Day of Judgement)?
Note 1. Allaah asks who will believe the Quran and who will believe a teaching that is different to what Allaah teaches in the Quran?
Quran 77:50 Koran 77:50 In what statement (words, news, reports, information, message, hadith), after it (the verses of Allaah in the Quran), shall they (the humans and the jinn) believe?
Note 1. Allaah asks who will believe the Quran and who will believe a teaching that is different to what Allaah teaches in the Quran?
Note 2. Quran 7:185, Quran 25:29, Quran 25:30, Quran 31:6, Quran 39:23, Quran 45:6 and Quran 77:50 asks when you have the word of Allaah in the Quran what other report would you believe?
See Quran 25:30 comments with examples of hadith stories which contradict the teachings of Allaah in Quran chapter 25.
q. If hadith stories agree with the Quran then accept it and learn from it.
If hadith stories do not agree with the Quran then reject it and also learn from it.
On the Day of Judgement Allaah judges by the words in the protected Quran.
On the Day of Judgement Allaah does not judge by the words in unprotected human hadith stories.
The Quran is the protected word of Allaah including the words and actions of Prophet Muhammad which are described and protected by Allaah.
C. Conclusion.
a. The claim in hadith stories that Prophet Muhammad said “'whoever changed his Islamic religion then kill him” is opposite to what Allaah teaches in Quran 2:256, Quran 3:159, Quran 4:137, Quran 5:54, Quran 10:99 – 10:100, Quran 18:29, Quran 28:54, Quran 50:45, Quran 88:21 - 88:26 and Quran 109:2 –109:6.
b. These hadith stories and the verses in the Quran do not agree with each other.
c. This hadith story contradicts (is opposite) to what Allaah is teaching in the Quran.
d. Due to the widespread fabrication of hadith stories described in C, D and E in “A better way to study hadith stories” in Example 1 above today it is necessary to check the truthfulness of every hadith story by comparing it to what Allaah teaches in the Quran.
e. The correct behaviour towards those who leave religion or change religion is to show them respect and maintain friendship with them so that they know they will be welcomed to return to religion. See Quran 3:159 in 10 above where Allaah shows how he forgives and prevents people from leaving religion not with punishment but with kindness as a mercy to them from Allaah.
The reason there is no death penalty for leaving religion or changing religion is because if a person is killed then the purpose for which they were created which is for each humans to find their true belief is violated.
It is not for one creation to destroy another creation because of belief because the only judge of belief in Allaah is Allaah on the Day of Judgement.
f. See E, F, G, H, I and J in “A better way to study hadith stories” in example 1 above.
1. Abu Bakr explained where false hadith stories come from.
Abu Bakr who lived in the time of Prophet Muhammad shows that some hadith stories regarded as trustworthy and recited after the death of Prophet Muhammad were in fact untrustworthy hadith stories.
Hadith story 0.
It has been narrated that Aishah (the wife of Prophet Muhammad) said, my father (Abu Bakr) collected the hadīth (stories of the Messenger of Allaah), which was five hundred texts.
He spent that night so sleeplessly and restlessly that I was sad for him.
I therefore asked, ‘Are you moving restlessly due to an ailment or information that you received?’
In the morning, he asked me to fetch him the collection of hadīth that he had put with me.
When I fetched them, he set fire to them.
As I asked for the reason, he replied, ‘I anticipated that I would die while I still have this collection among which there might be reports of a man that I deemed trustworthy while he was the opposite; therefore, I would be the narrator of such false reports.’
(Recorded in 1. Al-Dhahbiy: Tadhkirat al-Huffādh 1:5,
Recorded in 2. Al-Qāsim ibn Muhammad (died in 1029 AH): al-I`tisām bi-Habl-illāh al-Matīn 1:30,
Recorded in 3. `Abd al-Ghaniy `Abd al-Khāliq: Hijjiyyat al-Sunnah 394).
If hadith you believed was true you later understood cannot be true you would not be able to sleep.
Who is the man Abu Bakr deemed trustworthy while he was the opposite meaning untrustworthy?
Abu Bakr does not name him.
The trusted man was not related to the prophet.
The trusted man is someone Prophet Muhammad trusted and therefore all Muslims trusted during the life of Prophet Muhammad.
The trusted man was invited to eat in the house of Prophet Muhammad and therefore it was thought that this trusted man had direct knowledge about the sayings of the prophet.
The trusted man did not recite hadith stories during the life of Prophet Muhammad.
The trusted man made a living reciting hundreds of hadith stories after the death of Prophet Muhammad.
The trusted man is someone who recited more than the five hundred hadith stories that Abu Bakr had collected after the death of Prophet Muhammad.
Abu Bakr could not sleep because like Muslims today he understood that many hadith stories are opposite to what Allaah and Prophet Muhammad teach in the Quran.
Any hadith story that is opposite to what Allaah and Prophet Muhammad teach in the Quran is a false hadith story.
The hadith stories collected by Abu Bakr were from a man Abu Bakr considered trustworthy.
When Abu Bakr understood that this trustworthy man was in fact untrustworthy Abu Bakr destroyed his 500 hadith story collection.
The destruction of these 500 hadith stories show that these stories where not stories that Abu Bakr heard directly from the prophet.
Abu Bakr says these stories came from a trusted man.
These stories were collected after the death of Prophet Muhammad by Abu Bakr from a man who was trusted to have direct knowledge of the sayings of the prophet because that trusted man was invited to eat with the prophet.
In the later part of the life of Abu Bakr he began to understand that these stories were untrustworthy because they were opposite of what Allaah and Prophet Muhammad teach in the Quran.
After the death of Prophet Muhammad the trustworthy man showed he was untrustworthy by inventing false hadith stories as a way to make a living.
These are hadith stories which cannot be true because they teach something that is opposite to what Allaah and Prophet Muhammad teach in the Quran.
These hadith stories are false hadith stories because they contradict the stories of Allaah and Prophet Muhammad which are protected in the Quran.
2. Umar ibn Al-Khattab explained where false hadith stories come from.
Why did Umar ibn Al-Khattab who lived in the time of Prophet Muhammad collect all hadith story books in his time and burn them?
The following hadith shows that Umar thought that hadith books were not the fairest and the straightest of Allaah’s most beloved books meaning some hadith was not fair and some hadith was not straight meaning hadith was interfering with the correct understanding of what Allaah and Prophet Muhammad say in the Quran as Muslims today also understand when they find false hadith stories which teach the opposite to what Allaah and Prophet Muhammad teach in the Quran.
Hadith story 1.
It has been narrated on the authority of al-Qasim ibn Muhammad ibn Abu Bakr that Umar, after he had received news confirming that people started to hold (or write) books, denied and disliked the matter saying, ‘O people: I have been informed that you have started to hold books. Allaah’s most beloved books must be the fairest and the straightest.
Now, I order you all to bring me all the books that you hold so that I will decide about them.’
Thinking that `Umar wanted to correct and submit the books to a certain criterion, all people brought their books to him. Instead, he set them all to fire and said, ‘This is a false wish just like that of the Christians and the Jews.’
(Recorded in Abd al-Ghaniy `Abd al-Khāliq: Hijjiyyat al-Sunnah 395).
Note 1. ‘This is a false wish just like that of the Christians and the Jews’ means ‘This (human writing) is a false wish (desire) just like that of the (human writing of the) Christians and the Jews.’
The following hadith (with my comments added in the brackets) explains why Umar thought that hadith books that existed in his time were not the fairest and the straightest of Allaah’s most beloved books meaning hadith was interfering with the correct understanding of what Allaah and Prophet Muhammad say in the Quran.
Hadith story 2.
According to Ibn Sa’d, in his al-Tabaqat al-Kubra, Umar said, ‘This (hadith) is a Mishna (meaning human writings) just like that of the Christians (for example the priests who invented the idea that Jesus Isa is Allaah and Jesus Isa will return to this earth in Christian writings that are not in the Gospel Injil) and the Jews (for example the rabbis who invented the idea of the anti messiah Armilus in Jewish writings known as the false messiah the Dajjal Dijjal which is not in the Torah Taurat).’
(Recorded in Ibn Sa`d: al-Tabaqāt al-Kubrā 1:140).
See 1. When a prophet dies Satan Shaitan whispers stories that contradict the Books of Allaah.
The description of the Dajjal Dijjal is Armilus.
“… In Rome there is a splendid marble statue of a beautiful girl which god himself made in the beginning of the world. Through sexual intercourse of evil men, or even of Satan himself, with this statue, a terrible creature in human form was produced, whose dimensions as well as shape were equally monstrous.” … “Armilus is bald-headed, with one large and one small eye, deaf in the right ear and maimed in the right arm, while the left arm is two and one-half ells long.”
Reference https://jewishencyclopedia.com/articles/1789-armilus
See 2. Anti Messiah (anti Christ) is not in the Quran.
Anti Messiah (anti Christ) is not in Tanakh Jewish scripture.
Anti Messiah (anti Christ) is in Christianity.
Armilus in Judaism is not an Anti Messiah (anti Christ) but represents Romulus the founder of Rome In the Roman story of Amulius.
In Judaism Armilus represents the defeat of Rome in the end of days and was misunderstood by Christians as an anti Messiah (anti Christ) however there is no anti Messiah (anti Christ) in Tanakh Jewish scripture or in the Quran.
Hadith stories about the Dajjal in Islam are not confirmed in the Quran meaning such hadith stories were written after the death of the prophet.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xVG8lPB1Les
See 3. A better way to understand hadith stories.
https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/a-better-way-to-understand-hadith-stories
Hadith test.
Are these hadith useful in religion?
Yes. These hadith explain where false hadith came from.
Hadith stories are false if they teach something that is opposte to the teachings of the stories of Allaah and Prophet Muhammad which are protected in the Quran.
When a prophet leaves the earth Satan Shaitan whispers false hadith stories that hide, distort and corrupt the correct understanding in the human mind of the words of Allaah and his prophet which are recorded in the Books of Allaah.
When Prophet Jesus Isa left the earth Satan Shaitan whispered “Jesus Isa is Allaah” which cannot be found in the Gospel Injil as proof that Allaah has protected the Injil of Isa the Gospel of Jesus by Mark, Matthew. Luke and John which is with the Christians today in the same way as Allaah protects the Quran which is with the Muslims today.
Hadith information.
Hadith 0. Aishah (Aishah bint Abu Bakr, born 8 BH 614 CE, died 57 AH 678 CE) wife of Prophet Muhammad.
Hadith 1. Al-Qasim ibn Muhammad ibn Abu Bakr.
Aishah (Aishah bint Abu Bakr, born 8 BH 614 CE, died 57 AH 678 CE) taught her nephew Qasim ibn Muhammad ibn Abu Bakr (born 38 AH 662 CE, died 108 AH 730 CE).
Many Hadith are quoted through Qasim.
Al-Qasim ibn Muhammad ibn Abu Bakr was one of the seven most famous jurists in Madinah and was considered as the most knowledgeable among them.
He was highly influential in disseminating early traditions of hadith, fiqh (jurisprudence) and tafsir (exegesis) of the Qur'an.
Hadith explaining why hadith books were destroyed by Umar ibn Al-Khattab were narrated by Aishah to her nephew Al-Qāsim ibn Muhammad ibn Abu Bakr.
Hadith 2. Ibn Sa`d (Abu Abd Allaah Muḥammad ibn Sa‘d ibn Mani‘ al-Baṣri al-Hashimi katib al-Waqidi, born 168 AH 784 CE, died 230 AH 845 CE) was trained by teachers such as Al-Waqidi who was a biographer writing about Prophet Muhammad and an early historian who wrote some of the earliest and most detailed history books on Islam.
Ibn Sa’d wrote the Book of the Major Classes (Kitab Tabaqat Al-Kubra) about the life of Prophet Muhammad, his Companions and Helpers, and those who fought at the Battle of Badr and about the following generation called the Followers who received their traditions from the Companions.
3. Conclusion.
When a dishonest story teller makes a living by telling stories for his meals he will need to invent stories because no one is interested to hear the same story twice.
a. When Abu Bakr in 1 above who lived in the time of Prophet Muhammad wrote down hadith stories that were recited to him after the death of Prophet Muhammad by a man who visited him during meal time he began to understand that some of these stories contradicted what Allaah teaches in the Quran and one night he could not sleep because he understood that it was impossible for him to trust stories which came from a man who recited stories contradicting the Quran and therefore he destroyed his collection of 500 hadith stories so that Allaah in the hereafter will not blame him for passing on false hadith stories.
b. When Umar ibn Al-Khattab in 2 above who lived in the time of Prophet Muhammad heard that after the death of Prophet Muhammad people were writing hadith stories he ordered everyone who had written books or had a book of hadith to give it to him and he destroyed all those books in a fire because like Muslims today he found that many of these stories contradicted what Allaah teaches in the Quran meaning they were false hadith stories and he did that so that Allaah in the hereafter will not blame him for allowing the passing on of false hadith stories during his period of leadership of the Muslim community.
Quran 17:88 Koran 17:88 Say (Prophet Muhammad), "If humans and jinn (such as Satan Shaitan) came together to help each other to produce something like the Quran, they could not do it."
Note 1. In the hereafter Satan Shaitan might boast he obeyed Quran 17:88 by whispering hundreds of false hadith stories which teach the opposite to what Allaah and Prophet Muhammad teach in the Quran.
Note 2. Hadith stories which contradict the Quran are false hadith stories which were invented by story tellers after the death of Prophet Muhammad and repeated by people who were deceived to believe false stories.
c. What does the Quran say about information that contradicts Allaah in the Quran?
Quran 77:50 Koran 77:50 In what statement (words, news, reports, information, message, hadith), after it (the verses of Allaah in the Quran), shall they (the humans and the jinn) believe?
Note 1. Allaah says in Quran 7:185, Quran 25:30, Quran 39:23, Quran 45:6 and Quran 77:50 if anything contradicts the Quran then reject it and follow what Allaah is teaching in the Quran.
Note 2. Quran 7:185, Quran 25:29, Quran 25:30, Quran 31:6, Quran 39:23, Quran 45:6 and Quran 77:50 asks when you have the word of Allaah in the Quran what other report would you believe?
See Quran 25:30 comments with examples of hadith stories which contradict the teachings of Allaah in Quran chapter 25.
Do not twist inside your mind the meaning of the words of Allaah in the Quran to agree with hadith stories.
If hadith stories agree with the Quran then accept it and learn from it.
If hadith stories do not agree with the Quran then reject it and also learn from it.
On the Day of Judgement Allaah judges by the words in the protected Quran.
On the Day of Judgement Allaah does not judge by the words in unprotected human hadith stories.
The Quran is the protected word of Allaah including the words and actions of Prophet Muhammad which are described and protected by Allaah.
d. When Allaah tells Prophet Muhammad what happened after his death what will Prophet Muhammad say to Allaah on the Day of Judgement?
Quran 25:30 Koran 25:30 And (on the Day of Resurrection and Judgement) the messenger (Prophet Muhammad) said, “My Lord (Allaah) my people have abandoned (deserted) this Quran (to follow false messages, false words, false news, false reports, false information, false statements, false hadith).”
Note 1. On the Day of Resurrection and Judgement Prophet Muhammad will say “My Lord my people have abandoned this Quran (to follow false messages, false words, false news, false reports, false information, false statements, false hadith).”
Video: Obsession with false hadith culture Is corrupting Islam.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SOQGOaNvLSU
e. Misguidance.
When people are taught how to twist the words of Allaah to agree with hadith stories which teach the opposite to what Allaah teaches in the Quran instead of teaching people to ask the question "does this hadith story agree with the teachings of Allaah in the Quran" the result can be people who follow the mistakes of other people instead of people who are led by the teachings of Allaah in the Quran.
In Christianity some people follow the story that Jesus is Allaah which is not in the four Gospels however because they believe something from outside the Gospel they twist every verse in the Gospel to show that Jesus is Allaah even when Jesus prays to Allaah in all the four Gospel Injil and even when Allaah says in the Gospel that both Jesus and the angels do not know "the hour" because only Allaah knows
In Islam some people follow hadith stories which teach the opposite to what Allaah and Prophet Muhammad teach in the Quran as shown in the reference below and like some Christians they also twist every verse of Allaah in the Quran to agree with some thing that came from outside the Quran.
In this way some Christians and some Muslims have beliefs which contradict the teachings of Allaah in the Gospel and in the Quran.
f. The danger of believing false stories.
People who believe false stories invented by other humans after the death of a prophet can be made to believe other false stories invented by humans as seen in some Christian cults and some Muslim cults who followed stories supporting their killing of people and their killing of themselves.
g. Education.
Teaching people to ask "is this story contradicting the teachings in the books of Allaah" will help protect people from other people who are following false stories instead of following the stories in the books of Allaah.
Corrections and questions are welcome and can be emailed to somaliahamradio@yahoo.com
The meaning of verses in the Quran and Tanakh and Gospel are on these websites.
The meaning of verses in the Koran and Torah and Injil are on these websites.
YOU ARE HERE Allaah https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran
Allaah index https://sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/index
Allah https://sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran
Allah index https://sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/index
God https://sites.google.com/view/islamandthekoran
God index https://sites.google.com/view/islamandthekoran/index
Q&A https://sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel
Q&A index https://sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel/index