NY PROTEST of IDSA LYME GUIDELINES 2006
Report From Lyme Disease Education & Support Groups of Maryland
Patients from across the state of Maryland drove in groups or took a bus to NY to attend a protest of the Infectious Disease Society of America's Lyme Disease Guidelines.
Lyme Disease Education and Support Groups of Maryland members do not support the Infectious Disease Society of America (IDSA) Lyme Disease Treatment Guidelines and feel they are a dangerous tool being used to deny treatment to patients.
Patients to Protest Lyme Disease Guidelines at Westchester Medical Center
Hundreds of patients from throughout the country will rally outside Westchester Medical Center/NY Medical College in Valhalla, NY, from 12pm to 3pm today, to protest the latest Infectious Diseases Society of America (IDSA) guidelines for Lyme disease. Organizers chose the venue because it is the workplace of three of the IDSA committee members, including guideline chair Dr. Gary Wormser.
Featured speakers include New York officials─ U.S. Representative Nita Lowey (NY-18), Assemblyman Joel Miller, and Jim Martorano, Deputy Supervisor of Yorktown Heights. Dr. Joseph Burrascano, world renowned East Hampton, NY Lyme expert who is vice president of the International Lyme and Associated Diseases Society (ILADS) and others.
“It is time to nationally address this travesty masquerading as the best science has to offer,” said Pat Smith. “The range of ticks is increasing, reported Lyme disease case numbers are on the rise, and it is evident that quite a number of patients develop chronic disease after failing a short course of treatment or after having a delayed diagnosis and treatment. We know testing is highly unreliable, missing up to 50% of the cases, and the bull’s eye occurs in maybe half the patients. Yet we have guidelines recommending that doctors be deprived of their clinical discretion in diagnosing and treating patients and that they diagnose only with a bull’s eye or a positive test. The final outrage is the guidelines not recommending any treatment for chronic Lyme disease, leaving patients suffering a disability equal to that of congestive heart failure.”
Earlier this month, Connecticut Attorney General Richard Blumenthal launched an investigation into whether the IDSA violated antitrust laws in setting the new guidelines for treating Lyme disease.
Lyme, the most common vector-borne disease in the United States, is caused by the bite of a bacteria-infected tick. Lyme disease has been reported in 49 states. In 2005, more than 23,300 Lyme cases were reported by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, which estimates a 10% reporting rate, meaning about 233,000 Americans contracted Lyme in 2005. With global warming, ticks continue to be active over the winter, and experts predict 2006 may surpass 2005 for reported Lyme cases. Symptoms of Lyme vary for each individual patient, but may include fever, chills, headache, backaches, fatigue, and a rash. More information at www.LymeDiseaseAssociation.org.
Baltimore Sun Editorial- Missing the Mark
"Lyme patients- many of them afflicted with debilitating ailments that began with the bite of a tiny tick- have traveled from Maryland and many other states to a Medical Center in Valhalla, NY, where today they will demand that the Infectious Diseases Society of America retract medical treatment guidelines it released last month."
Local Residents Join Lyme Disease Protest- Maryland
"Three of the guideline authors- Gary Wormser, Raymond Dattwyler and Robert Nadelman- all work at the Westchester Medical Center, which the protestors picketed outside for three hours."
WABC-TV New York 'Lyme Wars' patients rally in Westchester
http://www.rally11-30-06.lymerights.org/html/abc_news_article.html
"If they weren't so seriously flawed I would say it was a joke", he said of the guidelines. He urged those at the rally to fight back by "uncovering the truth."
Hundreds Rally to Protest New Lyme Disease Treatment Guidelines
http://www.rally11-30-06.lymerights.org/Journal_News_Westchester_NY.pdf
"An attempt to reach Wormser for a response through a Westchester Medical Center spokeswoman was unsuccessful."
"A 19 ft-long scroll was displayed remembering hundreds who have died from Lyme disease."
Lyme Disease Activists to Protest
"But the guidelines-- now posted on the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention-- deny the existence of chronic Lyme disease, saying there's no medical evidence that the bacteria that causes Lyme survives antibiotic treatment."
Lyme Disease Spurs Patient's Rights Protest
"These guidelines take away the ability of doctors to use their clinical judgement," Berenbaum said. "They are extremely restrictive and are essentially claiming that anything beyond 30 days is not an active, persistent infection and should not be treated."
"Patients and doctors have had difficulty at times getting insurance companies to pay for the treatment, and the guideline could be used to deny the treatments they say they need."