See the Guide to the Matter Fundraiser for general/team info for our annual fundraiser.
*And that's how we like it to maintain sustainability and editorial independence!*
The bulk of our funding comes from 140 members who give to Matter monthly, who make us more sustainable.
The next biggest chunk of our funding comes from grant dollars from NewsMatch, an organization that fundraises from major news funders and then matches the donations nonprofits newsrooms across the country get each November and December.
note: next year (end of 2021), we hope to have secured a "local match", a company, foundation, or other organization that wants to triple match the funds we receive during NewsMatch, so that we can further incentivize donors.
The rest of our funding comes from one-time donations (the average donor - both one-time and monthly - gives $10) and other grants ($2,000 from Comfest and $3,000 from the U.S. Press Freedom Accountability Project).
We have yet to secure large gifts + have yet to sell advertisements, but we are thinking about it.
Note: Ads will be for aligned local businesses and never make up a significant portion of our funding.
We will look more into platforms for getting donations through other foundations, companies, orgs, platforms etc., however, some require we have our own nonprofit status.
i.e. Columbus Foundation The Giving Store / Donor Advised Funds, Combined Charities (Franklin County), etc.
DONOR FUNDRAISING
Based on how we did with NewsMatch this year, it’s likely we can stick with our current trajectory/plan of fundraising super hard during NewsMatch and then being pretty light, but consistent with donation asks during the year. I think the one question we need to consider is whether we want to begin doing a mini-drive mid-way through the year. I could be in favor of having an optional May or June fundraiser each year that we essentially don’t have to do if we hit our budget for that FY, but that could be used as a way to raise any funds we may be short? I really think it could be minimal effort/repurposing a lot of NM content and templates, etc. (obviously removing NM branding and info) and it wouldn’t be too much of a lift and could be a big payoff simply to make extra asks that month.
GRANTS
In the fall, we talked about focusing on networking and cultivating new donors/large donors and reducing grant apps to like 1x/quarter; I think we could probably up that to 2x/quarter during non-NewsMatch, especially considering some apps aren’t bad and sometimes we can repurpose existing apps.
EARNED INCOME
Probably not worth our time/effort at our current stage of growth and given we aren’t behind. Managing even tshirt sales is a bit much and getting us outside of what we have capacity for. I do think footage is an easy way to make some $, but don’t think we have time to be very proactive about making $ that way. Ads could be an easy way to make some money, but once again, who is going to manage all that?
Pop ups+ banners on site (need to check with CMS)
How best to incorporate asks with content?
Messaging new followers/engagers on social media
Merchandise
Advertising / sponsorships for podcast
Partner with OSU and other universities
Fiscal Sponsorship
Consulting
Corporate sponsor guidelines and effort
Secure local matches much ahead of NewsMatch
Columbus Foundation / Columbus Media Fund
NRH Salesforce dashboard + our new audience dashboard
These are things that INN suggests having:
DONOR DATABASE:
Your organization has a functional donor management system in place with automated data tracking and reporting capabilities.
CRM GUIDELINES:
Your organization has written customer relationship management (CRM) guidelines in place for managing the data in your donor management system.
PROSPECT RESEARCH:
Your organization uses third-party data to inform major gift strategies and donor prospects are researched as part of a strategic fundraising process.
DONOR PROFILES:
Your organization uses donor profiles to identify your best major gift and planned giving prospects and effectively uses donor profiles in fundraising strategies.
DONOR POLICIES:
Your organization has written policies in place that protect the donor and their privacy when giving to your organization.
GIFT PROCESSING: Your organization has written guidelines in place for processing gifts and standardized procedures followed by all staff.
GIFT ACCEPTANCE: Your organization has written policies in place outlining the acceptance of gifts and funding priorities that are consistent with the strategic goals of your organization.
ENDOWMENT POLICY: Your organization has a written policy regarding how the endowment is invested, monitored and managed.
FUNDRAISING PLAN: Your organization has a written fundraising plan in place to ensure alignment of board and staff around goals, priorities, strategies and roles for a determined period of time.
STRETCH GOALS: Your organization has fundraising stretch goals in place based on revenue data analyzed from past years and performance indicators.
STRATEGIC PLAN:
Your organization has a strategic plan in place to ensure the alignment of board and staff around the goals, priorities, strategies and roles for achieving long-term sustainability.
ENDOWMENT PLAN:
Your organization has an endowment plan in place to raise funds for the ongoing support of and investment toward achieving long-term sustainability.
CASE FOR SUPPORT:
Your organization has a written case for support that demonstrates the needs of your community, how your organization impacts the need and the results and outcomes achieved by your activities.
STEWARDSHIP PLAN:
Your organization has a written stewardship plan in place that outlines who, when and how you will follow up with, acknowledge and recognize your donors.
ENGAGEMENT TOOL:
Your organization has an Engagement Tool that drives donor engagement during a visit and which includes a funding plan with short- and long-term organizational priorities and major gift opportunities.
RETENTION PLAN:
Your organization regularly performs retention analysis of certain fundraising metrics (frequency of contact, donor growth) and has a strategy to increase your donor retention rate to AT LEAST the national average (currently 45%).
BOARD AGREEMENTS:
Your organization has written board agreements in place that outline how your board contributes financially to your annual giving plan.
CULTURE OF PHILANTHROPY:
100% of your board and staff has a defined role in the fundraising process and supports the philanthropic effort of your organization.
MAJOR GIFTS TEAM:
Your organization has a Major Gifts Team of board and staff dedicated toward achieving long-term financial sustainability.
BOARD DIVERSITY:
Your organization has recruitment strategies in place to attract and retain board members of diverse backgrounds, competencies and industries that drive your fundraising.
ANNUAL GIVING:
Your organization has a board- and staff-driven annual giving (i.e. gifts below $1,000) plan in place to secure unrestricted operating funds from individual donors during a specific period of time.
MID-RANGE GIVING:
Your organization has a written mid-range giving (i.e. gifts between $1,000-$4,999) plan in place to manage, grow and steward donors to establish mid-level giving and increase donor retention rates.
MAJOR GIVING:
Your organization has a written major giving (i.e. gifts of $5,000 or more) plan in place that includes identifying, cultivating and stewarding major donors that raise sustainable sources of individual giving revenue.
PLANNED GIVING:
Your organization has a written planned giving (i.e. bequests, IRA charitable rollover, charitable gift annuities, charitable trusts, real estate, etc.) plan in place to ensure the long-term sustainability of the organization.
People/things suggested to us (by investigative journalism Mya Frazier)
Contact INN members who are similar but years ahead and ask re: funding strategies/funders
Outlets a Dennison narrative writing prof I met w/ this week suggested could be good inspo for us and we could check into who funds them since they're similar.
100 Days in Appalachia - WVU
Mountain State Spotlight - Ken War Jr. - Charleston Gazette - force to be reckoned with, great model
Good at going after the governor
Y City News - Zanesville
Richland / Mansfield
Joel Oliphant -
Mary Lynn Plagman - long-standing editor at Dispatch, Reiter now
Linda Cass - Mya’s friend, don’t tell her she said, but her husband is Continental
Pizzuti
Ann trubic - belt publishing, accomplished writer / journalist - we should know who they are - could give fundraising advice maybe? To the left politically, very skilled. Would like what we are doing. She could give us an hour of her time maybe? Mya just thinks we should look at their writings on the midwest
Lumina Foundation owner, need to form a personal relationship with that guy
Sources for fundraising:
join button (website)
donate button (website)
FindYourNews.Org
+note that we can make a unique link for each of these platforms for a specific campaign. For example, for NewsMatch21.
Stripe - our main donation/payment processor
Facebook - we fundraise some on fb/ig
upside: no transaction fees
downside: don't get donor info auto (they have to opt into sharing)
Paypal - we have Paypal account as a backup for accepting donations/payments. We had to use it in July and Nov 21 for events
Fundraising guide and resources + email newsletters
was founded by an experienced team of publishers, journalists and newsmedia marketing executives to create a sustainable future for independent local media. We do so by deploying world class technology, and delivering the expertise and professional services to build and support subscription, membership and donation models for long-term success. In early 2020, BlueLena as formed specifically to support community-based alternative news and emerging digital media with audience management, and the creation of long-term sustainable reader revenue models.
There are a variety of coaching programs and learning resources available to assist publishers with charting a path to successful reader revenue strategies, including the Membership Puzzle Project, GNI Subscription Lab, the Facebook Accelerator Program and the Table Stakes Local News Transformation Program.
However, to pursue this strategic path successfully, publishers are faced with the daunting challenge of investing in the technology, the talent AND the expertise to successfully implement consumer revenue strategies that are critical to long-term viability.
BlueLena removes those barriers and helps accelerate transformation.
Info districts are special districts that fund participatory media and civic communications projects to meet local news and information needs. Modeled after other kinds of special districts – like business improvement or library districts – info districts are established democratically, funded by a local tax, and accountable to the community they serve through a public board.
When people are told about
the financial situation of the news industry
how local journalism supports a healthy democracy
they are more likely to donate to a nonprofit news organization
Keep messages short and sweet/simple
The primary CTAs/nudges should be for sustaining/monthly donations (AKA for people to become members)
Organization
Nonprofit
Locally-owned, operated, and focused
Woman-owned and led
Millennial/Gen Z-owned and led
Diverse
Content
Accessible
Free and available for republishing
Humanizing
Investigative
Multimedia
Digital
Deep and contextualized information on the most pressing issues affecting Columbus
What are our highest viewed pieces? Which ones do we have feedback on?
Protest coverage
Gentrification Explainer
Economic Segregation Map
Tear Gas Explainer
VVC mini doc
Area Commissions explainer
Emphasize strengths, be honest about challenges, highlight opportunities, and create a small sense of urgency by mentioning threats.
Strengths
Diversity - team/board reflects city
Understanding tech and how it can boost our work
Intentionality, innovation, adaptability, trying new things
Challenges
Bottleneck - management/editing
Staying focused on the specific gap we are focused on - OWMC
Small team, side jobs
Aren't able to afford high rates for content
Opportunities
Collabs - community partnerships / universities and media
Community insight model (meaningfully engaging communities in editorial process)
Empowering action with investigations around policing
Matter Mobile (community engagement)
Events (host more in person and streaming)
Threats
Dip in donations due to pandemic
Rise of nonprofit news means less resources - $8,500 less match this year
Not being established / being a startup / independent makes it hard to make inroads
Legal action in response to our investigations (a small newsroom may not be able to survive a lawsuit)
What we raised last year
What we did with that $
what we spent it on
What we accomplished
Fundraising goal this year
What we want to do with that $
What we will spend it on
Content production
What we intend to accomplish this year
financial goals re: new donors, nm goals, $15,000
What we intend to accomplish in 3-5 years
Video, photo, or graphic testimonials with:
Staff
Contributors
Board
Volunteers
Donors
against accusations of a liberal bias, “fake news” attacks and swirling misinformation
2. Explain what you do and don’t cover
including your story selection process and how you handle wire news
how facts can change quickly, when and how you cite polls and how you report election results
4. Explain how you work to be fair
clear up accusations of bias in news coverage, and separate opinion coverage from the newsroom
FACTS FOR MARKETING
Franklin County lost 63% of its newspaper jobs from 2004-2017.
Among elderly, middle-aged, and young: the elderly are the most likely age to pay for news subscriptions, while young people are the most likely to donate to news organizations and pay for memberships.
Americans who consume local news are more politically engaged.
Americans take pride in their local newspaper: 59% see it as an important symbol of civic pride in their community.
73% of Americans consider news media bias to be “a major problem”
More than 8/10 Americans believe the news is important “critical” or “very important” to democracy
44% of Americans think the news media is performing poorly at providing objective news reports.
86% of Americans currently see “a great deal” or a “fair amount” of political bias in news coverage.
Government inefficiencies, taxes, and county deficits grow when a newspaper closes its doors.
2018 study published in the Journal of Financial Economics
Since 2014, 30% of Ohio’s newspapers have changed ownership.
UNC Media Deserts report
5 of the nation’s largest news chains own nearly 120 newspapers in Ohio
UNC Media Deserts report
The largest newspaper company in the U.S. owned a handful of Ohio's newspapers before 2015, and now owns 61.
UNC Media Deserts report
Communities of color are more likely to rely on local news sources for information their daily lives than white communities.
Pew Research Center.
Website is one of your most powerful promo channels
CTAs in byline, in middle, in footer - diff places at once
Use pop ups with a healthy delay before showing the message to target the most heavily engaged readers and can reduce annoyance factor - 10-15 secs and even experimenting with that
Include donation links
In-house ads
Ideally, have donate button in your pop up
Go where your audience is
(Marisa, insert info here?)
Have targets for each month of NM campaign, communicate them to the audience
Have quarterly goals for 2021 and have campaign drives at certain times of the year
Aim to convert 1-5% of your audience to donors
5% is on the high end of where people get
60% of your donors should be sustaining
Would be good to see what our breakdown is
Some clients have as much as 80%
Churn rate - how many people cancel + cohort based churn analysis - look at when people were onboarded and when cancel happens - certain times for sign up are stickier for retention, but may not have been most engaged cohort of donors and can look @ techniques for keeping those people
# of donors per 1,000 unique visitors/page views
Can help identify top performing articles/journalists/sections
Top performing sources (sm, email, web)
Look @ surveys, as readers why they became a donor
Averages Press Patron's clients' supporters give
$11 monthly
$80/annual
$70 one-time
Hire a community engagement intern
Donation experience:
Be able to dive in and out of each page/step
A comprehensive playbook that offers publishers strategies and real-world examples to help with building and optimizing a reader revenue model
A set of interactive exercises, including an Opportunity Sizing exercise to help publishers estimate their potential reader revenue opportunity, a User Funnel diagnostic to identify areas for improvement across key reader revenue performance metrics and a Goal Setting exercise to build a plan for long-term reader revenue growth
Workshops led by top industry experts offering business recommendations
GNI Labs which provide a group of publishers with personalized support and one-on-one coaching from our industry partners
News Giving Roadmap
email from 4/30/20 to Cassie from jeffrey@investigativenewsnetwork.org
Thank you for completing the Program Intake and Service Request Form. Here, please find the following docs based on your scoring results:
News Giving Roadmap Assessment (results as of 4.15.21)
News Giving Roadmap Action Plan Template
Action recommendations based on your assessment results
Customizable using the "dropdown" feature and/or with text
NOTE: There are two worksheet tabs that align with the News Giving Roadmap design (rows/columns). You can choose whichever layout makes the most sense as you track your Roadmap Action Plan.
To help you along with your Roadmap Action Plan, please find attached the following resources:
Donor Policy Samples
Confidentiality
Donor Privacy
For other sample policies recommended by INN, please CLICK HERE
Fundraising Plan Template (for the fiscal year 2021)
Fundraising Plan Guide
Step-by-step instructions on how to complete and utilize the Fundraising Plan Template for your organization
Annual Giving Guide, including:
Cultivation Plan Template
Range of Gifts Table Template
OFFICE HOURS: To discuss these resources and the next steps, please feel free to access my office hours (Tuesdays, 3:00 - 4:00 pm ET).
Thanks so very much, Cassie. I look forward to speaking with you again soon!
Please do enjoy a great weekend. Most Kindly,
Jeffrey Woolverton, Network Philanthropy Director
jeffrey@inn.org | (404) 530-9153 | ET
News Giving Roadmap Intake
This brief intake consists of a series of "yes-no" questions aligned with the News Giving Roadmap. The intake — once completed — will generate a score that highlights your organization’s strengths in fundraising to create an Action Plan toward revenue growth.
DONOR DATABASE:
Your organization has a functional donor management system in place with automated data tracking and reporting capabilities.
CRM GUIDELINES:
Your organization has written customer relationship management (CRM) guidelines in place for managing the data in your donor management system.
PROSPECT RESEARCH:
Your organization uses third-party data to inform major gift strategies and donor prospects are researched as part of a strategic fundraising process.
DONOR PROFILES:
Your organization uses donor profiles to identify your best major gift and planned giving prospects and effectively uses donor profiles in fundraising strategies.
DONOR POLICIES:
Your organization has written policies in place that protect the donor and their privacy when giving to your organization.
GIFT PROCESSING: Your organization has written guidelines in place for processing gifts and standardized procedures followed by all staff.
GIFT ACCEPTANCE: Your organization has written policies in place outlining the acceptance of gifts and funding priorities that are consistent with the strategic goals of your organization.
ENDOWMENT POLICY: Your organization has a written policy regarding how the endowment is invested, monitored and managed.
FUNDRAISING PLAN: Your organization has a written fundraising plan in place to ensure alignment of board and staff around goals, priorities, strategies and roles for a determined period of time.
STRETCH GOALS: Your organization has fundraising stretch goals in place based on revenue data analyzed from past years and performance indicators.
STRATEGIC PLAN:
Your organization has a strategic plan in place to ensure the alignment of board and staff around the goals, priorities, strategies and roles for achieving long-term sustainability.
ENDOWMENT PLAN:
Your organization has an endowment plan in place to raise funds for the ongoing support of and investment toward achieving long-term sustainability.
CASE FOR SUPPORT:
Your organization has a written case for support that demonstrates the needs of your community, how your organization impacts the need and the results and outcomes achieved by your activities.
STEWARDSHIP PLAN:
Your organization has a written stewardship plan in place that outlines who, when and how you will follow up with, acknowledge and recognize your donors.
ENGAGEMENT TOOL:
Your organization has an Engagement Tool that drives donor engagement during a visit and which includes a funding plan with short- and long-term organizational priorities and major gift opportunities.
RETENTION PLAN:
Your organization regularly performs retention analysis of certain fundraising metrics (frequency of contact, donor growth) and has a strategy to increase your donor retention rate to AT LEAST the national average (currently 45%).
BOARD AGREEMENTS:
Your organization has written board agreements in place that outline how your board contributes financially to your annual giving plan.
CULTURE OF PHILANTHROPY:
100% of your board and staff has a defined role in the fundraising process and supports the philanthropic effort of your organization.
MAJOR GIFTS TEAM:
Your organization has a Major Gifts Team of board and staff dedicated toward achieving long-term financial sustainability.
BOARD DIVERSITY:
Your organization has recruitment strategies in place to attract and retain board members of diverse backgrounds, competencies and industries that drive your fundraising.
ANNUAL GIVING:
Your organization has a board- and staff-driven annual giving (i.e. gifts below $1,000) plan in place to secure unrestricted operating funds from individual donors during a specific period of time.
MID-RANGE GIVING:
Your organization has a written mid-range giving (i.e. gifts between $1,000-$4,999) plan in place to manage, grow and steward donors to establish mid-level giving and increase donor retention rates.
MAJOR GIVING:
Your organization has a written major giving (i.e. gifts of $5,000 or more) plan in place that includes identifying, cultivating and stewarding major donors that raise sustainable sources of individual giving revenue.
PLANNED GIVING:
Your organization has a written planned giving (i.e. bequests, IRA charitable rollover, charitable gift annuities, charitable trusts, real estate, etc.) plan in place to ensure the long-term sustainability of the organization.