8.1 Sustainable Development
Essential idea:
Companies and businesses can utilize a range of different strategies to develop products, services and systems.
Nature and Aims of Design
Nature of Design
Designers utilize design approaches that support sustainable development across a variety of contexts. A holistic and systematic approach is needed at all stages of design development to satisfy all stakeholders. In order to develop sustainable products, designers must balance aesthetic, cost, social, cultural, energy, material, health and usability considerations.
Aims
Triple bottom line sustainability does not only focus on the profitability of an organization or product, but also the environmental and social benefit it can bring. Organizations that embrace triple bottom line sustainability can make significant positive effects to the lives of others and the environment by changing the impact of their business activities.
Guidance
As a student of Design Technology, you should be able to:
How using resources more productively and redesigning production, it is technically possible to deliver the same or equivalent goods and services with lower environmental impact while maintaining social and equity benefits.
Consider the benefits and limitations of decoupling as an appropriate strategy for sustainability
How international and national laws encourage companies to focus on something other than shareholder value and financial performance
Benefits of sustainability reporting for governments, manufacturers and consumers
Product stewardship examples include organic foods, genetically modified food, green cotton, forest stewardship and bio-plastics
Concepts and principles:
When discussing sustainability and sustainable development, it is important to understand the distinction between these two terms. Sustainability refers to the long-term maintenance of responsibility, and is environmental economic and socialAspects. Sustainable developmentIs focused on meeting the needs of the futureStill dollars focus on meeting the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs.
There are a variety of strategies that can be used to support sustainable development. All of these strategies share the approach of looking at the whole system surrounding the product or service.
Triple bottom line sustainability
Decoupling: Disconnecting economic growth and environmental impact
Sustainability reporting
Product stewardship
The use of international national laws to promote sustainable development is another driver that designers and companies must consider when introducing product to market.
Resource
Our common future, Chapter 2: Toward sustainable development; Report of the world commission on the environment and development
Triple Bottom Line (TBL)
The Triple Bottom Line (TBL) is a framework that incorporates three measures: social, environmental, and financial. It is sometimes referred to as "The 3 P's" (people, planet, profit).
TBL has become an important tool for measuring and supporting sustainability goals.
Within TBL, there are a three types of measures that can be used to assess sustainability.
Social Impact Measures
How society and people are impacted.
quality of life
education level and access
social capital
equity and access to social resources
mental and physical health
Environmental Impact Measures
How the environment is impacted.
air and water quality
energy consumption
use, replacement, or protection of natural resources
waste generation
Financial Impact Measures
How money flows in the system.
Income levels
expenditures
taxes
business climate
Measuring and Calculating TBL
"The trick isn't defining TBL. The trick is measuring it." Essentially, there is not a common, agreed upon method for calculating TBL. The two main strategies are:
Monetizing the social, environmental and financial components. While this uses a common financial unit, it raises philosophical issues of placing a dollar-value on intangible things. What is the cost of an endangered species, an unemployed worker, or polluted stream?
Indexing the value of TBL components. This allows for the comparison of different entities. In addition, indexes can be adjusted or designed for specific use-cases. The different LCA systems use different indexes with different weightings.
Use of TBL
Interest in TBL has been growing in for-profit, non-profit, and governmental sectors as a way to evaluate sustainability of systems, services, and products.
Businesses are interested in TBL because of its influence of sustainability on longterm profitability. TBL's focus on resource and energy reduction, health and safety of the workers and the environment, has a direct relationship to cutting costs and increasing profits.
Business also see benefits of partnering with non-profit organizations who have goals aligned with social equity, environmental protection, and decreasing the wealth gap.
Governments and policy makers use the TBL framework to assess impacts of decisions and evaluate performance of a project or policy decision.
Decoupling
Decoupling is a concept that describes an economy's ability to grow without harming the environment.
Decoupling is a concept that describes an economy's ability to grow without causing harm to the environment. Typically, when an economy grows, it puts more strain on the environment by using up resources like water and fossil fuels. However, if an economy can continue to grow while using fewer resources and not damaging the environment, then it is considered decoupled. This can be measured by looking at the pollutants released into the environment. By comparing the amount of pollution produced to the growth of the economy, we can determine the level of decoupling that has been achieved.
In the chart above, we can see three trends:
In the "No Decoupling" section, the economic output (green) and resources use (grey) are growing at the same rate.
In the "Relative Decoupling" section, we can see that economic output (green) is continuing to increase, and that rate of resource use has decreased - however the rate of resource use is still rising, just at a slower rate.
In the "Absolute Decoupling" section, we can see that the two trends are now "decoupled". The economic output continues to grow while the resource use is declining.
Korean text
분리는 경제가 환경에 해를 끼치지 않고 성장할 수 있는 능력을 설명하는 개념입니다. 일반적으로 경제가 성장하면 물과 화석 연료와 같은 자원을 사용하여 환경에 더 많은 압력을 가합니다. 그러나 경제가 자원을 적게 사용하고 환경을 파괴하지 않으면서 계속해서 성장할 수 있다면, 그것은 분리되었다고 간주됩니다. 이는 환경에 방출되는 오염물질을 살펴봄으로써 측정할 수 있습니다. 생산된 오염물질의 양과 경제의 성장을 비교함으로써 우리는 달성된 분리 수준을 결정할 수 있습니다.
Chinese text
脱钩是一个概念,描述了一个经济在不对环境造成伤害的情况下能够增长的能力。通常情况下,当一个经济增长时,它会通过使用水和化石燃料等资源对环境造成更大的压力。然而,如果一个经济能够在使用更少的资源并且不破坏环境的情况下继续增长,那么它被认为是脱钩的。这可以通过观察释放到环境中的污染物来衡量。通过比较产生的污染物数量与经济增长的关系,我们可以确定已经实现的脱钩水平。
International and National Laws
The use of international and national laws can promote sustainable development and encourage companies to focus on sustainable goals in addition to shareholder value and financial performance. These types of laws particularly at the national level focus on transparency of corporate sustainability and sustainability assurance and are designed to ensure that businesses, public services and national resources have the means to continue in the years ahead.
Some examples of different international laws are below.
As an IB DT student, you do not need to know the details of each of these agreements - just that international laws and agreements can influence how companies and governments approach sustainability
1992: Rio Earth Summit focused on economic development and halting the destruction of natural resources and pollution of the planet.
Resources
1997: Kyoto Protocol introduced legally binding limitations on the amount of emissions and greenhouse gases that developed countries could produce. The overall goal of the Kyoto Protocol was to reduce pollution and Emissions while increasing the adoption of renewable energy and promoting energy efficiency.
Resources
2015: Paris Climate Change Conference further emphasize the need for reducing greenhouse gas emissions emissions.
Resources
2009: Copenhagen Accord stated that global warming should be limited to below 2 degrees C.
Resources
Sustainability Reporting
Benefits to manufacturers
Sustainability reports are an important driver of innovation for businesses to create a competitive advantage by reducing costs. Sustainability reports can highlight opportunities to reduce resource consumption improve energy use and highlight areas in the business where waste can also be reduced.
Benefits to the government
Governments can use sustainability reports to assess the impact of a company or business sector on the economy. Governments can ensure that companies are complying with legislation and are transparent in their business practices. Likewise sustainability reports also highlight areas that need to be addressed an industrial sector or by the economy as a whole.
Benefits to Consumers
Sustainability reports build trust and highlight a company's commitment to sustainable goals, particularly with regards to environmental stewardship and social impact such as workers rights and consumer health and safety.
Product Stewardship
Product stewardship is a sustainable development strategy that emphasizes that everyone involved in the making selling buying or handling of a product takes responsibility for minimizing environmental impact at all stages in the design cycle / life cycle. As product stewardship becomes more important to consumers, consumer pressure on companies means that designers need to take into consideration the environmental impact of their designs.
Product stewardship can also be viewed as a shift of the placing responsibility of disposal of a product from the local governments and users, back to the manufacturers themselves.
Resources
Northwest Product Stewardship Institute: Descriptions about some of the stewardship challenges for different products.
10 Principles for Product Stewardship, Greenbiz.com: summary of some of the sustainability strategies we have studied and how they are related to product stewardship.