Batman Incorporated v2 #5 Annotations

Commentary

Featuring the long-awaited return of both Batman 666 and Doctor Hurt - and this could well be the last time that we see either - this issue really starts to bring some of the themes and plot points of Morrison's epic run towards a conclusion. And in the end it didn't really matter that #0 and #4 were published in the opposite order than originally intended; in fact it works out quite well.

The collected edition of Batman Incorporated v2 #1-12 and #0 was solicited this week, a sharp jolt to remind us all that there's only 7 issues left now before Morrison leaves Batman behind. Still hoping that DC will announce the book will continue with Chris Burnham as writer/artist after Grant leaves, but time seems to be rapidly running out. Would make an excellent Christmas present though wouldn't it?

Annotations

Cover - Stirling work as usual from Burnham/Fairbairn and Frazer Irving on the covers. I love everything Irving does at the minute and his take on Damian-Bats is no exception.

Nice work on Burnham's cover integrating the logo into the Arkham Asylum scroll work on the gate.

Page 1 -Picking up right where we left off last issue, the police arrive at the Kill Box house to pick up what remains of the League of Assassins. I'm pretty sure the guys being crowded into the back of the meat wagon are amongst the many, many Burnham originals from last issue.

"I saw the future..." Bruce revealed the details of his vision at the end of the Leviathan Strikes oneshot and recounted them in Batman Incorporated #0 (which, if the scheduling had gone as originally planned would have preceded this issue) - "The world in flames... Two headstones... Kali the Destroyer"

"If you become Batman... Everything falls apart." A reference to W.B. Yeats' poem The Second Coming -

"Things fall apart, the centre cannot hold; Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world."

Damian recites The Second Coming to (Comissioner) Barbara Gordon at the beginning of 'Batman In Bethlehem' from Batman #666, our first glimpse at the future world we pay our final visit to this issue.

Page 2 - Presumably the story here picks up directly after the end of the 'Batman 666' chapter of Batman #700 - the last time we visited the Damian-as-Batman future. In that issue 'The Laughing Death' - "weaponized Joker Venom in the form of nerotoxic rain" - had already been unleashed over Gotham by Max Roboto and 2-Face-2, turning the population into crazed Jokerized zombies.

The baby Damian's carrying is Terry McGinnis, who'll grow up to become Batman Beyond. Damian rescued him from 2-Face-2 in #700. At the end of that story the baby succumbed to the virus but Damian had an antidote he'd extracted from Roboto's blood. This time around the idea seems to be that he has some sort of natural immunity.

The Ro-Bat is a new addition to Damian's arsenal. It's smashing through the window recalls the bat that entered Wayne Manor in a similar fashion back at the very beginning of the Batman story.

BATMAN INCORPORATED #5

Asylum

DC Comics, January 2013, Color, 32pgs, $2.99

Written by GRANT MORRISON ; Art by CHRIS BURNHAM; Cover by CHRIS BURNHAM and NATHAN FAIRBAIRN; 1:25 Variant Cover by FRAZER IRVING

• Return to the future world seen in BATMAN #666, where Damian has taken over the mantle of the Bat!

• The whole world has gone mad. The only sane people left are in Arkham Asylum – where Batman is the warden!

Page 3 - The machine-gun fire and wholesale slaughter of the zombified-Gothamites are pretty clear pointers that, like Jean Paul Valley's AzBats way back in the 90's, Damian's not your grandpa's Batman.The pull-back reveals that we're in Damian's Batcave in the penthouse of the Wayne Enterprises building. The burning effigies of Bruce, Damian and Dick were first seen on page 9 of Batman #666, and Burnham matches Andy Kubert's poses closely here.

Page 4-5 - 'The World in flames' = Gotham City here. Arkham Asylum has a history of drastically different exterior designs and locations within Gotham. Though it's been destroyed and rebuilt in-story a number of times, its as much a long-standing tradition for Bat-artists to put their own spin on the exterior of Arkham Asylum as it is with the Batmobile, something Morrison addressed explicitly way back in his Animal Man run. The ornate Arkham gates that feature on the cover and in the last panel are seemingly the institutions one immutable feature

Looking back over Morrison's run, the only previous exterior shots of Arkham I could find were silhouettes in the Tony Daniel-drawn 'Batman R.I.P.', like Burnham's complete with clock-tower and waterfront location, Maybe the asylum has gotten a lot more 'on-model' since the rip-roaring success of the video game named after it.

The title 'Asylum' mirrors the original 666 story 'Bethlehem', in reference to the Bethlehem Hospital in London, a notorious insane asylum - Europe's first and oldest - from whose name we derive the word 'Bedlam'.

Police Comissioner Barbara Gordon, daughter of Jim Gordon and current Batgirl. Barbara was long confined to a wheelchair after the Joker shot her in Alan Moore and Brian Bolland's Killing Joke, and thanks to John Ostrander and Kim Yale eventually carved out a second succesful superhero career as Oracle, star of the long-running Birds of Prey series. She recently got better with the advent of DC's New 52 initiative and resumed the Batgirl identity. Batman #666 went to great lengths to establish that Gordon and Damian don't enjoy the comfy relationship that Bruce and Jim did.

Page 6-7 - Damian's "->tt<-" is of course his spin on dad's "-Hh-"

As usual, pulse-pounding action scenes from Burnham and Morrison here. Great stuff.

Page 8 - Smoking in comics? Its been a while... This must be a future dystopia.

Alfred the cat first appeared alongside Damian-Bats in Batman #666.

"What do you know about dying? Nothing can kill you." Back in Batman #666 Damian revealed that he'd made a deal with the Devil on the day that Batman died - Gotham's survival in return for his soul. He demonstrated his supernatural resilience when Comissioner Gordon and the Gotham P.D. riddled him with bullets at the end of that issue and he emerged unscathed.

Page 9 - "...a cargo cult reconstruction of how things used to be." All the elements are in place - Batman, Gordon, Gotham, Arkham, even The Joker, but twisted into a distorted echo of what they used to be. Cargo cult recreations - in effect a reduction of something to the purely symbolic, entirely removed from it's original context or meaning - also cropped up in Final Crisis, where Darkseid described the Miracle Machne as a "Cargo cult Motherbox".

Shades of Romero's Night/Dawn/Day of the Dead and current zombie apocalypse torch-bearer The Walking Dead - holed-up in a repurposed municipal facility, surrounded on all sides by encroaching death. Morrison and Burnham get a lot of mileage out of classic zombie story tropes over the next few pages. I wonder if any of it was re-purposed form Morrison's un-used World War Z pitch from a few years back?

"Some higher power is aligned against me... And it always has been." Damian's right of course, but the juxtaposition with the Jokerized zombie seems to imply that the 'higher power' Damian is referring too might be The Joker himself. Of course we'll see different later in the story,

Page 10 - The old 'President's dilemma' - to nuke a city in a seemingly inescapable disaster spiral or leave it to our heroes to save the day at the last minute against insurmountable odds - featured heavily in this years' comic-book blockbusters The Avengers and The Dark Knight Rises. As we'll see later in the issue, given who their top man is it's clear that this group advising the President is the new inner circle of the Black Glove.

"The Sphynx knows what to do Batman" Another fleeting glimpse of one of Damian's rogues gallery; Morrison is a master at suggesting an interesting character with the barest of information and letting the reader's imagination fill in the gaps (see the Mindless Ones' Rogues Review for Joker 666 for a previous example from this very Elseworld). Incidentally, Le Sphinx has long been the name given to The Riddler in French translations of Batman comics.

"Open the doors, dark destroyer", no Knight or Detective for Damian

Jackanapes, an intelligent gorilla dressed as a clown, appeared in both previous 'Batman 666' stories. Love what Burnham's done here with his prison cell - the contrast between his fully-stocked molecular biology lab and the cat food tins and fetid sheets. The cigar is also an excellent flourish.

Page 11 - Jackanapes is refering to this quote from the Bible's Book of Revelation - "And I looked, and behold a pale horse: and his name that sat on him was Death". It's a good job that Gotham's laughing itself to death, otherwise internet pedants would be all over Jackanapes for that Revelations/Revelation thing.

Jackanapes, like Grodd in Morrison's JLA Classified arc, is a man-eater. I spent ages scouring Batman comics looking for a previous scene detailing Jackanapes hunger for human flesh, only to eventually find the one I was thinking of in this fanfic Batman 666 script. Though Amypoodle's (excellent) take on Damian-Bats has since been contradicted in places by the comics that followed Batman #666, given Batman Incorporated's current status in the New 52 I think we can all agree that's not a problem. It's a fascinating and skilfully written story and well worth a read. With a bit of searching you should be able to find all ten scripts on the Mindless Ones site.

More Biblical references, this time to the Fall of Babylon. There's evidently some discussion amongst Biblical scholars as to whether the Fall of Babylon as described in the Bible is recounting a historic event or a prophecy of the future. This arises because the catastrophic description of it's sudden collapse in the Old Testament is seemingly at odds with what history tells us actually happened.

Damian already had an antidote in Batman #700. The chronology between the two issues seems to be a bit wonky.

Brr... Damian bringing a seemingly unaffected child into the 'safe zone' who's actually a carrier for the virus is reminiscent of Juan Carlos Fresnadillo's 2007 film 28 Weeks Later.

Page 12 - The flashback to the night of Bruce's apparent death, under the streetlamp in Crime Alley. Burnham again echoes Kubert's similar panel in Batman #666, with Bruce as the Tarot's Hanged Man, though this time around they're wearing their Burnham-designed Batman Incorporated costumes.The Hole In Things - Doctor Hurt. We last saw the not-at-all good doctor, poisoned with Joker venom, slipping on a banana and being buried alive by The Joker in the Wayne family plot in Batman and Robin #16. He's been consistently portrayed as an agency almost outside the confines of the story throughout Morrison's run - a vaguely defined ultimate anti-dad that tries to tempt, corrupt and degrade all that is good about Batman - before his mildly-risible 'secret origin' was revealed in the 'R.I.P. as farce' arc 'Batman and Robin Must Die!'. Hopefully there is no story to tell regarding *how* he got out of the grave or anything as mundane as that. He merely did. That's all that matters. Appearing to Damian at his darkest hour, his lowest ebb, to offer him everything in return for his soul and his betrayal of the creed of Batman.Hurt implies that it was Damian entering Bruce's life that made him vulnerable, that opened the 'Hole in Things'. In fact it was just the opposite - Damain first appeared immediately following Bruce's emergence from the (still ongoing?) Thorgal ritual, after he'd reconciled the darkness in himself and after gained the strength to survive Darksied, death and time travel; the strength to take on the Hole in Things and win.Hurt's still smiling. A redsidual effect of the Joker venom maybe? Gotham was marked from the very beginning, right back to the Stone Age as we saw in The Return of Bruce Wayne, because of Darkseid's manipulations - attacking Bruce with a weapon that used his own family tree - indeed history itself - against him.

Page 13 - The virus creeping through the facility whilst panic reigns reminded me a lot of Romero's super-bleak final installment of the original 'Dead' trilogy, Day of the Dead.

Page 14 - Holy crap! Having read Chris Burnham and Joe Casey's excellent Officer Downe I don't suppose a panel like that should come as too much of a surprise but... wow. We sure are a long way from the Comics Code Authority these days eh? And there's no way that baby's growing up to be Batman Beyond...

Page 15 - A twisted mirror-image of the Joker shooting (and crippling) Barbara from Alan Moore and Brian Bolland's The Killing Joke, though there the "Smile" quote was on the cover.

And Hurt again, the ever-present devil on your (president's) shoulder, ushering in the End Times for Batman's world (i.e. Gotham)

Page 16 - Shades of Day of the Dead again - Captain Rhodes' "Choke on it!!" as the zombies tear him limb from limb, Salazar opening the silo and letting the zombies in when all is lost.

Page 17 - Leaping out through the doors of the asylum is The Weasel, with The Flamingo below him in pink. We saw a lot more of The Flamingo in Batman and Robin #4-6 but he first appeared, briefly, alongside The Weasel and Jackanapes in Batman #666. The guy with the green mohican next to Flamingo is one of The Mutants, the Gotham gang introduced in Frank Miller's Dark Knight Returns who've cropped up a few times in Morrison's run so far.

"Mother of the beast", Kali the Destroyer, Talia. Is her ultimate goal to destroy Gotham as in The Dark Knight Rises? But here as a lover spurned rather than a daughter following through on her father's wishes?

Damian was the Third Ghost all along - The ghost of Batman future - The Antichrist who made a deal with the devil, betrayed the spirit of Batman and became more than a man - The Beast. This is what Bruce saw when he tumbled through time; that Damian can never be Batman. But where now for him?

Incidentally, the revelation that the future Damian-bats is the Third Ghost makes Grant Morrison's decision to let the Bat-office make Michael Lane into the new Azrael make much more sense in hindsight. He was only ever a cypher in this story, an unwitting party to his own deal with the devil; a sleight of hand for the real Son of the Demon to hide behind.

Page 18 - Only Hurt is still smiling after Apocalypse comes...

Page 19 - The background shatters as Damian's world falls to pieces

Page 20 - That's The Squire, The Knight, Looker, Batwing, Freight Train and Halo investigating Leviathan's hidey-hole, opposite the Monarch Theatre on Park Row, aka Crime Alley. Almost all of them managed to survive being blown up in the last volume of Batman Incorporated, I have high hopes they'll do the same here.

And that's Kali The Destroyer in the last panel, wearing the skulls of El Gaucho, Batwing, Batman, Damian and The Knight around her neck...

-----------

Blimey, this is all very exciting. As ever, please let me know if you have any comments or corrections. See you in a couple of weeks for #7!

Previous Home Next