Hi! My name is Natalie Jacobo and I am a Human Biology Major. While I have many favorite foods, the two that stand out the most are huevos con chorizo and albondigas soup. Both are dishes in which I have grown up loving and have meaningful recipies that have been passed down from generation to generation.
Cilantro, one of the most popularly eaten herbs around the world, is also referred to by many different names such as Coriander; Chinese Parsley; Mexican parsley; Stinky herb; and Coriandrum Sativum plant. Cilantro has a unique and strong history that has been domesticated for almost 7000 years. When I first began my research, I first believed that it had originated in Mexico because of how popular it is in Mexican dishes. Despite that, I learned that this old-world herb originated from places like Europe, Asia, and Egypt. However, the distribution of different varieties of the Coriandrum Sativum plant was scattered and spread everywhere throughout the world. In Figure One, the diagram is a good representation of the geographical spread of the ten ‘botanical’ varieties of coriander and how they each evolved. (Diederichsen; Hammer 2019) I was reminded of the website from our class readings, A Map of Where Your Food Originated May Surprise You, and was surprised when I researched that cilantro had originated and domesticated in areas that I did not even consider. It became so popular and widely used in different cultures and countries that I never truly realized that cilantro was a foreign crop. For example, “More than two-thirds of the crops that underpin national diets originally came from somewhere else - often far away.” (Cherfas 2016) I was first introduced to cilantro through many Mexican dishes so it was very surprising to learn that it first appeared in Egyptian tombs and has centers of origin from continents like Europe and Asia. It is so interesting that cilantro is believed to have originated from Mexico or the United States, despite the fact that it has been cultivated and adapted throughout many years and throughout many different countries. Cilantro can be traced back to almost 6000 B.C. and was discovered that it was commonly grown in Egyptian gardens and was mentioned in many of their texts and hieroglyphics. The seeds from a cilantro plant were found in the tomb of King Tutankhamun, even though it was a relatively new herb at the time. Eventually, during the medieval and Renaissance periods, cilantro was deemed to be an aphrodisiac, and if one was to consume then one would gain immortality for life. It was strongly affiliated with love and romance, and in many cultures, this herb was said to be a symbol of love. Not only that, but it also appeared as an ingredient in many love potions throughout Chinese culture. Cilantro, to this day, still continues to play a significant role in different cultures around the world. This plant has become one of the most commonly used herbs around the world and has given me a new perspective on this old-world plant. With its deep and fascinating history, cilantro remains one of the most polarizing and unique herbs that has been used since early history.
The Globalization of Cilantro
How has cilantro changed throughout the globalization of different countries? Globalization refers to the exchange of food, technologies, and cultural practices on a global scale. In regards to cilantro, it is important to understand how globalization has affected its production, spread, and consumption throughout the world. Cilantro was not always a common and popular herb utilized in dishes throughout the United States. For example, “Until recently, however, when Mexican food became more popular and widespread, cilantro was little known in the United States.” (Kiple; Ornelas 2000) That being said, cilantro is now commonly grown in other countries, which shows the domestication of crops, how it was once foreign in origin, and how that ingredient became globalized. Currently, cilantro is one of the most popular herbs in the world. How did that come to be? Produce, like cilantro, became more available and countries like India, Russia, Ukraine, China, and Mexico became important farmers and producers in the global market. At the top of that list, the United States receives the most imports of cilantro from other countries. Globalization played a significant role in the production and distribution of cilantro because the more popular it became, the more in demand it was needed. For example, in the class reading, Glocalization of Subway in India, they state, “Although every culture has its own indigenous fast foods, contact with worldwide chains has increased, with many consumers (poor and rich) highly fascinated by these items.” (Simi; Matusitzi 2017, pg 574) In addition, this quote is so important in understanding how cilantro is impacted on a global scale because it helped put in perspective the influence a food can have on a country and how that might affect its popularity and usage. Cilantro has always been used in many Latin American and Asian dishes, although Americans never used this herb until the 1960s or until it became popular. Cilantro has become one of the most utilized ingredients in many culinary dishes throughout the world and globalization played a small, yet crucial role in making that happen.
What is the difference between coriander and cilantro? Something people don’t realize is that there is a huge difference between cilantro and coriander and they often get mixed up. Cilantro refers to the leaves and stem of the plant, while coriander alludes to the dried seeds. “In North America, cilantro refers to the leaves and stalks of the plant. The word “cilantro” is the Spanish name for coriander leaves. Meanwhile, the dried seeds of the plant are called coriander.” (Raman 2023) In addition, even though they are both obtained from the same plant, they are not interchangeable and share different tastes, aromas, health benefits, and are used in different cuisines. Cilantro consists of higher quantities of vitamins and lower quantities of minerals and is also made up of 92.2% of water. Cilantro tastes and smells more citrus-like, despite the fact that a majority of individuals consider the herb to taste like soap due to a genetic variant. In addition, it is often used in dishes around the world such as in Latin America, Asia, and the Middle East. Cilantro is more commonly used in items like salsa; guacamole; chutney; and soup. The leaves are also widely used as a garnish and can either be eaten raw or cooked. Cilantro seeds require a sunny and dry location and are best planted in spring and summer. They should be one-half deep and spaced two inches apart so it has enough room for its leaves to grow. It is necessary to be harvested when the stems are at least four to six inches tall and should be stored by either freezing or drying the leaves. If you freeze the plant, then it is best to place it in a plastic bag and store it away in the freezer. However, if you do dry it, then it is recommended to hang it upside down in a warm area. (Miller; Drost 2006, pg 1-2) Coriander, on the other hand, is the exact opposite and contains more minerals and less vitamins. The seeds are made up of 8.9% of water and have a spicier and nutty flavor that is used in dishes like curries; rice dishes; soups and stews; pickled vegetables; and Dhana Dal. (Raman 2023) Both of these herbs are also similar in regards to their health benefits. They are both filled with antioxidants, which help reduce inflammation; blood sugar levels, the risk of heart disease; and are known to help fight infections in the body. To garden coriander, you must plant the seeds eight to ten inches apart and you must wait for the plant to turn brown to then harvest the seeds. Once the plant is brown, you can place the seed heads in a bag upside down and wait until the seeds fall off to then be stored in a container. (Miller; Drost 2006, pg 1-2) Even though my history of cilantro runs so far back, I had never heard of coriander seeds and it was very fascinating to learn that there was a difference between the two. After all, even though they are derived from the same plant, they both have different culinary traditions, uses, and growing techniques.
Cilantro does not just serve as an ingredient in traditional dishes but can be a source of medicinal value. This herb is healthy, low in calories, and rich in vitamins and minerals. It is helpful in removing harmful metals, like mercury, lead, and aluminum, from the body so antibiotics and medicines can work more smoothly. Nutrition Today states, “In traditional remedies, coriander was used for relief of gastrointestinal maladies, although other historical uses included as an aphrodisiac, antibiotic, a remedy for respiratory ailments, and pain, and a treatment for loss of appetite and memory.” (Singletary 2016) This herb is commonly viewed as a ‘miracle plant,’ and plays a larger medicinal role in other countries. Cilantro and coriander both are used medicinally and work to aid “antihypertensive, anti-atherogenic, antiarrhythmic, hypolipidemic as well as cardioprotective effects.” (Singletary) Table 2 is an example of many ways that the Coriandrum Sativum plant has traditional uses and how it still remains to be an effective remedy and method for curing ailments.
Why does cilantro taste different for everyone? The big reason why I chose cilantro as my topic was because in high school I discovered I had a gene that influences my taste and smell in regards to cilantro. I became aware that cilantro is found to have a genetic component present that controls taste and smell by means of an olfactory receptor. Those who carry this receptor, perceive cilantro’s flavor differently. One such example that explains the biological side of cilantro and how that influences people’s perception of this herb, “We propose that one of a cluster of olfactory receptor genes, perhaps, OR6A2, may be the olfactory receptor that contributes to the detection of a soapy smell from cilantro in European populations.” (Eriksson 2012) The OR64A2 receptor is a likely gene that contributes to sensing the soapy and dirty smell and taste of cilantro. This gene binds to many different chemicals which gives rise to this weird flavor. There are several sets of aldehydes, and in terms of cilantro, there are two in particular that help create this distinction of flavor. One set of aldehydes is described as fruity and pungent, while the other set is described as soapy and bitter, which shows the different ways people can taste this herb. People who carry this gene are more susceptible and sensitive to the specific aldehydes that are present in this plant. This distaste contributes widely by ancestry, however, there is most likely a combination of different genetic changes as well as exposures, such as the foods that you grow up with that can affect this like and dislike. The proportion of people who thought cilantro tasted bitter and soapy was primarily of European descent. African Americans, Latinos, and Asians are all less expected to sense a soapy taste and Europeans are more likely to detect this abnormal taste. This is due to the exposure of cilantro to specific ethnic and cultural groups and how that can influence their taste of this eccentric herb. An example that shows how different population groups can taste cilantro differently, “The Middle Eastern, Hispanic and South Asian groups had the lowest proportions of cilantro dislikers. This may be due to frequency of exposure, as cilantro is most popular in these styles of cuisine, and culture does modify food-related behaviors.” (Mauer 2012) It was found, in a study that I researched, that 21% of East Asians, 17% of Caucasians, 14% of African Americans, 7% of South Asians, 4% of Hispanics, and 3% of Middle Eastern participants do not like cilantro. This means that the amount of cilantro dislike differs largely between different ethnocultural groups. I noticed that the Middle Eastern, Hispanic, and South Asian groups have the lowest numbers of cilantro dislikes, while Europeans have the largest numbers. This is possibly due to the common exposure to cilantro since it is most popular in these countries and cultures that maintain certain food-related behaviors. Knowing the biological aspects of this herb has shown me that it is one of the most exquisite plants to exist because of the unique characteristics that make it stand out further than other plants.
Cilantro, is to be believed, one of the most controversial herbs to exist. It not only has such an absurd background but there are so many different qualities and details that make up this polarizing herb. Not only can this plant provide medicinal value, but it has played a significant role in globalization, genetics, and cultural cuisine. Cilantro, a member of the parsley family, is a staple in popular cuisines from places like India, Latin America, and South Asia. During my research, I have come to love this herb even more and have earned a greater knowledge of this plant that is so popularly used in my culture. This ingredient has become and continues to be an essential and crucial part of Mexican cookery. Even though I do not like cilantro, it is so important to my culture and serves as the backbone of many Mexican dishes that I still continue to eat. It is a reminder of my family and traditions that have been passed down from generation to generation. My favorite dishes that contain cilantro are albondigas soup; cilantro rice; and guacamole, which are all used as a garnish in these dishes. While this may just be an herb to others, it is a reminder of where I came from. It is a reminder of how important family is to me and how food, like cilantro, can bring people together. Cilantro is a feeling, an emotion, but most importantly, it is love. Cilantro is so multifaceted and the culture, the smell, and the taste permeates my memory. Some like it, some don’t. Are you ready to enter the world of cilantro?
Citations
Cherfas, Jeremy. “A Map of Where Your Food Originated May Surprise You.” NPR, NPR, 13 June 2016, www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2016/06/13/481586649/a-map-of-where-your-food-originated-may-surprise-you.
Diederichsen, A., and K. Hammer. “The Infraspecific Taxa of Coriander (Coriandrum Sativum L.) - Genetic Resources and Crop Evolution.” SpringerLink, Kluwer Academic Publishers, 19 July 2019, link.springer.com/article/10.1023/A:1022973124839.
Eriksson, Nicholas, Shirley Wu, Chuong B Do, Amy K Kiefer, Joyce Y Tung, Joanna L Mountain, David A Hinds, and Uta Francke. “A Genetic Variant near Olfactory Receptor Genes Influences Cilantro Preference - Flavour.” BioMed Central, November 29, 2012. https://doi.org/10.1186/2044-7248-1-22.
Kiple, Kenneth F., and Kriemhild Coneè Ornelas. The Cambridge World History of Food. Cambridge University Press, 2000.
Mauer, Lilli, and Ahmed El-Sohemy. “Prevalence of Cilantro (Coriandrum Sativum) Disliking among Different Ethnocultural Groups - Flavour.” BioMed Central, May 2, 2012. https://doi.org/10.1186/2044-7248-1-8.
Miller, Colt, and Dan Drost. CILANTRO/Coriander in the Garden - Just Food, Jan. 2006, justfood.ca/wp-content/uploads/2017/09/Growing-and-Saving-Cilantro-Seeds.pdf.
Raman, Ryan. “Cilantro vs Coriander: What’s the Difference?” Healthline, Healthline Media, 14 Apr. 2023, www.healthline.com/nutrition/cilantro-vs-coriander.
Simi, Demi, and Jonathan Matusitz. "Glocalization of subway in India: How a US giant has adapted in the Asian subcontinent." Journal of Asian and African Studies 52.5 (2017): 573-585.
Singletary, Keith PhD. Coriander: Overview of Potential Health Benefits. Nutrition Today 51(3):p 151-161, 5/6 2016., journals.lww.com/nutritiontodayonline/fulltext/2016/05000/coilant__overview_of_potential_health_benefits.8.aspx. Accessed 20 Mar. 2024.
Spence, Charles. “Coriander (CILANTRO): A Most Divisive Herb.” International Journal of Gastronomy and Food Science, Elsevier, 11 July 2023, www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1878450X2300121X#bib114.