Avoiding Discussion Board Pitfalls

Below are examples of discussion board 

"Passes" and "Fails." 

Example of a Bad Discussion Post

WRONG!!!!! Based on book it clear he was dumb & didn’t not understand the way people actually live life. I have a Facebook page for long time & I can tell U I don’t act like this & my friends don’t either cuz we ain’t all fake. The people who agreeing w/this R fake & don know how 2 be a real person online. There ain’t no proof that the way ppl act on soc media is different then how they act IRL. U gotta be stoopid to belive this 😛

Example of a Good Discussion Post

Goffman says “The expressiveness capacity to give impressions appears to involve two radically different kinds of sign activity: the expression that he gives, and the expression that he gives off” (The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life, p. 2). This relates to social media because sometimes people may think they are posting one thing, but the public takes it differently. One recent example of this was when Roseanne Barr posted what she thought was a harmless joke on Twitter. She said she was only kidding when she compared Valerie Jarrett to an ape, and according to The New York Times, she claimed she thought Jarrett was Jewish and Persian, not African American. Nonetheless, the expression she thought she was giving (a joke) was not the one people thought she was giving off (a racist comment), which made her lose her job. 

More Tips

“Many students simply do not address the writing prompt thoroughly in their post. Sometimes a prompt will require that a student addresses two to three points, but students don’t do that,” said Anne Adcock, Associate Professor and the Bachelor Program Director at the Carver School of Social Work at Campbellsville University.  “Responses also are sometimes written in a way that does not reflect that they have read the original post well. The response does not continue the discussion. Responses often appear rushed and unplanned. Students should put effort into their posts and responses in a way that adds to the learning of both them and their classmates.”

Although some of the topics covered in a class may remind students of personal experiences, an online discussion board is not the appropriate forum to discuss their problems or ask for advice on issues not related to the course. Students should limit their conversation to the relevant topics and avoid discussing their personal lives in too much detail.

“Unless there is a word count required by the instructor, try to develop shorter posts, much shorter than a screen-worth of information,” David L. Stoloff, Professor in the Education Department at Eastern Connecticut State University who teaches online courses in the Educational Technology master's program,  said. “Please be polite and supportive, commenting and connecting the ideas of others into new learning for oneself and the community.”

Waiting until the last minute to make a required post can decrease the quality of the conversation about a subject. Posting earlier allows other students to respond to a post and engage in debates that help everyone in the class get the most out of the conversation.

“One mistake students make is not doing the reading or assignment in advance. I once had a student who did not read an assigned case study about Sonoco, a packaging company, and made a post about Sunoco, a gasoline company,” said Mitchell Langbert, Associate Professor at Brooklyn College who teaches undergraduate human resources and management courses online. “Another mistake is not reading other students’ posts and responding to points already made. Instead, many students repeat points already made without acknowledging that they are repeating the same ideas. Naturally, these don’t get full credit.”

Grading? Check the Syllabus

Before you participate into the discussion board, check the syllabus to learn about expectations and grading.  If this information is not in the syllabus, contact the instructor.