Exams fell out of favor during COVID, but AI is bringing them back. Consider a 2026 study (below) in which researchers found that AI use was associated with 18% higher homework scores, but 20% lower closed-book exam scores after six months.
This does not mean every course needs a proctored exam, but rather that summative assessments must make students’ knowledge, reasoning, decision-making, or skills visible. That could be an oral defense, case analysis, simulation, performance task, professional product, or a proctored exam.
Researchers followed 26,811 Chinese students in grades 7-12 over time. They identified when each student adopted AI and how their homework and exam performance changed afterward. Then compared that change with students who had not adopted AI. Access the paper.
Measure
Homework scores
Homework completion time
Monthly closed-book exam scores
High school entrance exam scores
College entrance exam scores
Result
+18%
64 → 45 min
−20% after ~6 months
−24% after 2+ years
−18% after 2+ years
Before choosing an exam, consider whether an exam is the best way to gather evidence of the intended learning. Case studies, performances, simulations, oral assessments, projects, and other formats may provide stronger evidence for some outcomes. See Develop Assessments & Activities to learn more.
First, when feasible, first consider adapting exams into more manageable assessments. High-stakes, single-performance assessments such as mid-term and final exams can be challenging to facilitate in fully online courses. These high-pressure assessments can also be stressful for students and may not provide the most holistic evaluation of their learning. Consider other assessments, such as projects, presentations, or portfolios.
Second, Federal Regulation 34 CFR § 602.17 requires verification that the student taking your online course is the one registered for the course. Many assessments and scaffolded assessments can deter academic dishonesty, but high-stakes exams are different. If one exam is 25% of your grade, fear of failure is great, and the desire to cheat increases. Check that ID and design the environment to ensure academic integrity.
Multiple low-stakes assessments reduce the overall stress students associate with an exam. Reducing the weight of an exam reduces the desire to take extreme measures to get every answer correct because an incorrect answer will not impact their grade as much. Additionally, more frequent assessments (e.g., weekly quizzes or problem sets) give students more opportunities to practice and receive feedback on their performance, which can help them master the content and be more prepared for any summative assessments.
If the exam is worth a significant portion of their grade, you can allow students to earn points back on questions that they missed. Before giving feedback, ask students to submit a written explanation of why their answers were wrong, attempt the problems again, and resubmit their answers for partial credit. This technique places more value on learning than performance.
Another option is two-stage exams. Students first work on an exam independently, then work on (a subset of) the questions with a group immediately after that. Students receive immediate peer feedback on their answers and an opportunity to increase their individual scores.
Open or low-control exams
open-resource or take-home,
applied problem,
oral follow-up,
individualized work.
Moderately controlled exams
timed exam,
randomized question pools,
restricted resources,
oral exam, one question at a time.
Highly controlled (proctored)
closed-resource exam,
licensure preparation,
competency progression,
accreditation or certification requirements.
These procedures provide consistent guidance for administering proctored exams in face-to-face, Zoom, and Respondus Monitor environments. Use the guide that matches your testing method for preparation, exam-day procedures, accommodations, and follow-up.
(Hover over the Doc and click the icon in the upper-right corner to open the Doc.)
See Quizzes for more information on setting up an exam in Brightspace.
See Developing Assessments & Activities for more information on creating authentic, AI-resistant assessments.
Western Governors University. (2026, April 15). WGU @ ASU+GSV: Evolving assessments in the age of AI. YouTube. (43m)