Axe of the Dwarvish Lords reward
In mid 1166, the players helped the King of the dwarves on Hurin Island and his sons recover the Axe of the Dwarvish Lords, and he offered them a generous reward. After a feast in the king's palace at Hurin, the king offered the adventurers their choice of a reward - name a weapon or piece of armor, and they will give it (or make it), as close as they can. If you want money, you were pointed to a chest of gems, and encouraged to just reach in with both hands and grab whatever you could. [Note that unlike some of your rewards, this didn't seem to be a time for negotiation or haggling, dwarves consider such to be rude - assume they'll be generous if you ask for an item, and don't spend time trying to pick out the best group of gems, just grab some and be happy - you will be getting tens of thousands of gold worth of gems, easily.]
One person asked if it would be possible to get a house on the island somewhere, and at first the king said no as non-dwarves aren't look upon well on the island, but later he relented - after all, he's the king, he can do what he wants, and you did just bring him the Axe of the Dwarvish Lords!