Why aren't you home?: The Pressures of Balancing Tradition and Culture with College Endeavors
Why aren't you home?: The Pressures of Balancing Tradition and Culture with College Endeavors
.
Cochiti Pueblo
Kewa Pueblo
Valdo Christa. Cochiti Pueblo Plaza. Accessed April 9, 2024.
Valdo, Mikayla. Image of Mikayla. August 23, 2023. Personal Photo.
The reason I chose this topic is because growing up I knew I wanted to be successful. This meant going to a good college and having a career. I grew up as a minority and being Native American, I want to do good for my community and be able to give back. However, now being in high school and having to think about what I am going to do after school, the decision of choosing to go to school far from home has been a difficult one. I feel that in order to get a good education, I have to go far since New Mexico doesn’t offer as many opportunities as a college someplace else would. Then there is the guilt of leaving behind obligations at home that holds me back. I know I have a role to fill in my community and leaving would prevent me from fulfilling that role. Also the fear of losing my identity while being away from home prevents me from wanting to leave home. So I created my Senior Honors Project with the intent of educating native students and their families about being in college away from home.
Valdo, Mikayla. Morphy Lake. August 7, 2024.
Identity
Valdo, Mikayla. Cochiti Pueblo sunset. September, 2022. Personal Photo.
In the article, “Sharing One Skin” by Jeanette Armstrong, she talks about being connected to our physical, emotional, thinking-intellectual, and spiritual self. She emphasizes the importance of each of these things by telling us how they are important in her community. She expresses how each person has a role to contribute to their community. Being connected to yourself allows you to connect with the land.
Armstrong, Jeanette. 1996 “Sharing One Skin: The Okanagan Community” Pp. 460-470 in Jerry Mander and Edward Goldsmith (eds.) The Case Against the Global Economy, San Francisco, CA: Sierra Club Books.
Valdo, Mikayla. Chaco Canyon. April, 2021. Personal Photo.
In the article, Toastie talks about the importance of places and how their names have significant meanings. Each name has a story and it is sacred to native people. It gives the people connection to the land and their identity. Giving places special names gives it power and meaning. He says that when places are renamed after colonizers or other random names, people lose respect for those places and it loses its value.
Toastie, B. “How place names impact the way we see landscape.” High Country News: Know that West, 1 May 2022, https://www.hcn.org/issues/54.5/people-places-how-place-names-impact-the-way, Accessed 27 August 2022.
Valdo, Mikayla. Chaco Canyon. April, 2021.
Joe Suina describes his home life before attending school and how he was changed after attending school. He describes his comfortable home life and how his school was strange and so was his "white" teacher. Over time he began to adapt to the white man's way and felt himself drifting from his old life. He longed to reconnect to his Pueblo but knew he would have to find a balance between the two.
Suina, Joe. “And Then I Went to School” , the New Mexico Journal of Reading, https://rethinkingschools.org/articles/and-then-i-went-to-school/ Vol. V, No.2. 1985.
History
In the article, “Indian Reorganization Act (IRA)” by Katherine Liapis Segrue. The intended purpose of the IRA was to reform relationships between the federal government with Native Americans and to restore self-governance and cultural Pride to Native Americans. John Collier, an advocate for natives, wanted to give tribes autonomy over their land, local policies, and cultural identity. If tribes chose to accept the IRA, an election for Tribal Council would take place. If a tribe rejected the IRA, they would remain under BIA jurisdiction. The article states, “The Indian Reorganization Act failed to significantly improve the economic and social conditions of Native Americans living on reservations, though it did have some residual success.” Although the IRA was not as effective as Collier envisioned, there were good things that came out of it. For example, the allotment program ended, the assimilation policy was reversed, and the sense of unity among natives was reignited.
Segrue, Katherine Liapis. “Indian Reorganization Act (IRA).” The Great Depression and World War II, Third Edition, Facts On File, 2017. American Indian History, online.infobase.com/Auth/Index?aid=18626&itemid=WE43&articleId=193613. Accessed 19 Oct. 2023.
Wikipedia Contributors. “Indian Reorganization Act.” Wikipedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 17 Aug. 2019, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_Reorganization_Act.
The article, “Report calls for equity changes for Native students” talks about the goals, problems, and solutions are presented concerning the lawsuit Yazzie/Martinez v. State of New Mexico. The problem was New Mexico failed to ensure children (especially Native children) the tools necessary during remote learning due to covid-19. The politicians should be the ones bringing this to light but they are not. There is also a lack of indigenous teachers. The solutions that were presented were increased tribal control over education in these districts serving native children, Community-Based education made by tribal communities, and development of a balanced yet culturally and linguistically relevant education. “The strength of our people and our Sovereign Nation is dependent upon the education of our children and caring for the knowledge of our ancestors gift to us and at the same time acquiring the skills necessary to protect our lands, our way of life, are people, all that defines who we are.”
“Report Calls for Equity Changes for Native - ProQuest.” Www.proquest.com, www.proquest.com/docview/2480343338?accountid=39531&parentSessionId=tujcputOwkt00vWxGYZW%2BhGJmtwaA1UGWuGVWEdGYNw%3D. Accessed 20 Oct. 2023.
Times, Navajo. “Calls Continue for Top Aide to Step Down.” Navajo Times, 23 Aug. 2021, navajotimes.com/reznews/calls-continue-for-top-aide-to-step-down/. Accessed 19 Oct. 2023.
The last article, “Boarding Schools” by Martha K. Robinson, Talks about the different aspects of Indian boarding schools. This includes assimilation, curriculum, legislation, assumptions, and the truth coming out. When native children were sent to boarding schools far away from home, they were forced to abandon their native tongues, customs, and identity. After a short period of studying, they had to provide working labor that kept the schools running. legislators began to think the schools were too expensive and educated to a few students. assumptions that natives were inherently inferior and were unskilled laborers began to rise. The focus became on teaching the students a trade to do manual labor. the schools were underfunded and the children were from to be malnourished and experience harsh punishments. “Indians might have the capacity to be assimilated into American society, but only as unskilled or semi-skilled laborers.”
Robinson, Martha K. “Boarding Schools.” Encyclopedia of Native American History, Volume 1, Facts On File, 2011. American Indian History, online.infobase.com/Auth/Index?aid=18626&itemid=WE43&articleId=359101. Accessed 19 Oct. 2023.
Carlisle Indian School Reading Class. online.infobase.com/Auth/Index?aid=18626&itemid=WE43&iid=42497. Accessed 17 Oct. 2023.
Current State of the Issue
“Esther Martinez: Protecting the Intangible Heritage of the Tewa People | National Trust for Historic Preservation.” Savingplaces.org, savingplaces.org/stories/esther-martinez-protecting-the-intangible-heritage-of-the-tewa-people.
The Esther Martinez act expired back in 2012 but was kept alive via annual appropriations. However an identical version was passed by the senate and Ben Ray Lujan spoke in support of the bill. The Esther Martinez Act allocated $10 million dollars to language programs for American Indian, Alaska Native, and Native Hawaiian students. This was done to ensure the survival and growth of language because, "The survival of native languages is fundamental to the success of Native communities and survival of traditional Native cultures."
Languagepolicy.org, 2015, www.languagepolicy.org/post/esther-martinez-native-american-languages-program-passes-house.
Hope, Native. “The Issues Surrounding Native American Education.” Blog.nativehope.org, blog.nativehope.org/the-issues-surrounding-native-american-education#:~:text=Because%20of%20the%20impoverished%20economies.
This article talks about the academic challenges that Native Americans face. When Native students are getting ready to go back to school, it is a time filled with stress and anxiety instead of excitement. This is due to the historical trauma of boarding schools. From this came stereotypes of Native Americans leading them to having low self-esteem. Most Natives have a negative attitude toward school and it gets passed down, Native Americans are always trying to find a balance between the contemporary and native world. "These resilient people are on a journey of rediscovery and healing." Living in a world that does not understand their customs can lead to isolation and self-doubt. The article also mentions that schools are underfunded and leads to insufficient opportunities.
Hope, Native. “The Issues Surrounding Native American Education.” Blog.nativehope.org, 17 Aug. 2023, blog.nativehope.org/the-issues-surrounding-native-american-education#:~:text=Because%20of%20the%20impoverished%20economies.
Bareti, Gracia. “Education System v. Cultural Competence.” Www.ted.com, www.ted.com/talks/gracia_bareti_education_system_v_cultural_competence.
In the Ted Talk, "Education System v. Cultural Competence", Gracia Bareti shares her experience growing up and navigating different cultures in a school setting. She expresses that she had always felt different from other students because she had different beliefs, food, and customs. Bareti felt as though the school system failed to teach about cultural awareness. When she was taught about African American history, only slavery was taught and never more in depth about the cultural side. She says, "I went from being taught it is 'not in our culture' to 'not in our curriculum'" She feels as though she has to take on the teacher role because schools are not being culturally competent.
TEDx Talks. “Education System v. Cultural Competence | Gracia Bareti | TEDxDirigo.” YouTube, 12 Dec. 2019, www.youtube.com/watch?v=UBJBWenlIjY.
Global Connections
Hispanic girls face many challenges wgen going into college. This includes barriers, family loyalty, and teenage motherhood. 15 year-old Valarie Sanchez had a hard time transitioning educationally after she moved from Mexico when she was 9. Taking English classes was a challenge and she was held back in 8th grade. Latinas face "cultural, economic, and educational barriers to finishing high school and entering and completing college" The other challenges some may face are immigration status, poverty, discrimination, low self-esteem, higher rates of depression and attempted suicide, gender stereotypes, and limited English proficiency, Latinas also have great loyalty to their families. Often times they take care of the younger children and elderlies. They are sometimes expected to live with their parents until they are married. Saray Argumedo says, "I thought that they would be proud of me, but why are they so angry?" Her mother questions why she spends so much time with her education and not family. Family loyalty causes some Latinas to choose less competitive schools closer to home. Teenage pregnancy is also a problem. 52% of Latinas become pregnant before age 20.
Unmuth, Katherine Leal. “Hispanic Girls Face Special Barriers on Road to College.” Education Week, 2 June 2012, www.edweek.org/leadership/hispanic-girls-face-special-barriers-on-road-to-college/2012/06.
Unmuth, Katherine Leal. “Hispanic Girls Face Special Barriers on Road to College.” Education Week, 2 June 2012, www.edweek.org/leadership/hispanic-girls-face-special-barriers-on-road-to-college/2012/06.
The cycle of poverty, educators, and UNICEF's educational efforts are a major issue in Sudan. Due to poverty, many people abandon their education to find work in order to provide for their families. The curriculum lacks active learning and teaching materials are often outdated or non-existent. There are only 7,315 employed teachers in Sudan and 3,692 are unqualified. UNICEF is making efforts to provide children with a more quality education starting at a young age.
“The Education and Poverty Crisis in Sudan.” The Borgen Project, 6 Jan. 2021, borgenproject.org/education-and-poverty-crisis-in-sudan/.
“South Sudan: The Primary Eight Heroes of Maban.” JRS, jrs.net/en/story/south-sudan-the-primary-eight-heroes-of-maban/. Accessed 2 Feb. 2024.
The Ted Talk by Andrea Hernandez discusses the expectations and challenges a first generation college student faces. Her parents never attended college but they greatly value her education. So they have high expectation they put on her. She had no idea what college was like and when she got there, she felt ashamed to be a first gen. student. She had no support and didn't ask for help because she didn't want anybody's pity. With no resources she had to work 10 times harder than her peers. She almost failed out of college until she met another staff member who was a first generation student that supported her.
“The Invisible Difference of a First Generation College Student | Andrea Hernandez | TEDxHopeCollege.” Www.youtube.com, www.youtube.com/watch?v=J6roTbQEABk.
Hernandez, Andrea. “The Invisible Difference of a First Generation College Student | Andrea Hernandez | TEDxHopeCollege.” YouTube, 20 July 2023, www.google.com/url?sa=i&url=https%3A%2F%2Fm.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DJ6roTbQEABk&psig=AOvVaw19SVF_JY4qV5cMXKiyrQ7J&ust=1706979632122000&source=images&cd=vfe&opi=89978449&ved=0CBMQjRxqFwoTCPDb_eiQjYQDFQAAAAAdAAAAABAD. Accessed 2 Feb. 2024.
Action Plans
My Hero