Explain the advantages and limitations of waterfall and agile methodologies
Assessment
Report
Advantages of waterfall methodology, for example:
• suited to smaller-sized projects
• easier to manage
• quicker implementation of the project
• easier to manage dependencies within a project
• easier to consistently document the process and
results
Assessment guidance
Limitations of waterfall methodology, for example:
• requirements must be explicit from the start
• lack of flexibility to make changes in the previous stages
• testing is at the end of the process, so there is a greater chance of bugs and it can be more expensive to fix
Advantages of agile methodologies, for example:
• clear roles and responsibilities of all team members
• more efficient and cost-effective, as development and testing take place concurrently
• easier to meet clients’ evolving requirements
Limitations of agile methodologies, for example:
• requires more intensive project management
• easier for the project to go off-track
• can be more costly in practice
Advantages:
Easier to Manage: Waterfall is straightforward because it follows a linear sequence. Everyone knows the plan and what needs to be done next.
Easier to Manage Dependencies: Since you're moving one step at a time, it's simpler to see how each phase relies on the one before it.
Consistent Documentation: The structure makes it easy to document each step, making it clear what was done and why.
Limitations:
Not Suited for Smaller-Sized Projects: The rigid structure often means a longer timeline, making it less ideal for small, quick projects.
Slower Implementation: Since you can't move on to the next stage without completing the previous one, it can take longer to see the finished project.
Advantages:
Suited to Smaller-Sized Projects: Agile's flexibility and short "sprints" make it ideal for smaller projects that need quick turnarounds.
Quicker Implementation of the Project: You're developing and testing simultaneously, which can speed up the overall timeline.
Easier to Adapt: If a client changes their mind or if an issue pops up, Agile can adapt more easily.
Limitations:
Harder to Manage: Because Agile is so flexible, it can be challenging to manage. Team members need to be very disciplined to keep everything on track.
Managing Dependencies Can Be Complex: When things are changing rapidly, it can get complicated to see how each part depends on others.
Inconsistent Documentation: The fast pace and frequent changes can make it harder to maintain detailed documentation.
Waterfall is great when you have a clear plan and need thorough documentation but can be cumbersome for small, fast-moving projects. Agile, on the other hand, is flexible and quick, which is great for smaller projects or when you expect changes, but it requires a disciplined approach to manage effectively.
Advantages:
Easier to Manage: Think of Waterfall like a to-do list that you follow from top to bottom. It's clear and simple, so everyone knows what they need to do and when.
Easier to Manage Dependencies: Waterfall is like building a house. You can't put up walls before you lay the foundation. Each step is dependent on completing the one before it, and it's easy to see those relationships.
Consistent Documentation: Because you move step by step, it's like writing a diary of what you did, so anyone can pick it up and understand what happened and why.
Limitations:
Not Great for Small, Quick Projects: Waterfall can be slow. If you need something done quick and simple, it might feel like overkill.
Slower Implementation: It's a "finish one step, then move to the next" approach. This means you won't see the finished product until the very end.
Advantages:
Perfect for Small Projects: Agile is all about quick moves and adjustments. Imagine a basketball player dodging and weaving through defense, that's Agile.
See Progress Sooner: Because you're doing lots of things at the same time, you get to see progress way sooner than in Waterfall.
Easy to Change Course: If something unexpected happens or you get new ideas, Agile lets you change direction easily.
Limitations:
Can Be Hard to Manage: Agile needs a really coordinated team. Imagine a group of friends deciding where to go for dinner: If everyone wants something different, it can get messy.
Dependencies Can Get Tricky: When everything is moving fast and changing, it's like trying to juggle while riding a bike. You have to pay attention to how everything relates to each other.
Documentation Can Be Inconsistent: Because you're moving so fast, sometimes you forget to write down what you did, which can be a problem later.
Waterfall is like following a detailed cooking recipe step by step. Great when you have all the ingredients and time but not so good if you're in a hurry. Agile is like freestyle cooking, throwing in ingredients as you go. Great for quick dishes and experimentation, but you might end up forgetting what you put in!