Federal Republic of Somalia: A Geopolitical Assessment (2025)

Introduction and Overview

Somalia, situated on the Horn of Africa, presents a unique and complex geopolitical landscape shaped by its specific history, clan dynamics, and precarious security situation. Its predominantly arid to semi-arid climate, interspersed with regions of heavier rainfall, influences its economic activities, predominantly livestock rearing and subsistence agriculture. The country's population of approximately 17.6 million, primarily ethnic Somalis, is divided into numerous clans, which function as key social and political units. This clan system, with its complex hierarchies and inter-clan rivalries, has historically shaped and continues to influence political dynamics, resource allocation, and conflict resolution mechanisms. Somalia's strategic importance derives from its location along the Bab-el-Mandeb Strait, a vital chokepoint for global maritime trade, and its persistent instability, which has regional and international security implications.

Geopolitical Risks and Strategic Considerations

Somalia faces a confluence of interconnected challenges, creating a volatile geopolitical landscape:

• Resurgence of al-Shabaab: The al-Qaeda-affiliated group, al-Shabaab, having lost control of major urban centers in the past, maintains a presence in rural areas and continues to pose a significant threat to national security. Its attacks on government targets, civilians, and international forces, coupled with its control over key supply routes and its sophisticated financial networks, pose a major challenge to stabilization efforts. Furthermore, al-Shabaab's distortion of Islamic principles to justify violence and its imposition of harsh taxes exacerbate social and economic grievances, undermining efforts to build community resilience and foster social cohesion.

• Political Instability and Fragile State Capacity: Decades of civil war and state collapse have left Somalia with weak state institutions and a fragmented political landscape. The FGS, though internationally recognized, struggles to exert effective control beyond major urban centers. Clan-based political competition, coupled with limited state resources and capacity, further complicates efforts to deliver essential services, implement reforms, and build public trust. The ongoing constitutional review process, essential for clarifying the relationship between the FGS and the federal member states (FMS), has stalled, hindering progress toward a more stable and unified political system.

• Climate Change Impacts: Somalia is highly vulnerable to the impacts of climate change, including increasingly frequent and severe droughts, floods, and extreme weather events. These shocks exacerbate existing challenges, including food insecurity, resource scarcity, displacement, and conflict. The prolonged drought of 2020-2023, followed by devastating floods in 2024, has had a severe impact on the country's economy, particularly on agricultural production and livestock, and has led to large-scale displacement and humanitarian crises. The lack of adequate climate adaptation and mitigation measures, coupled with limited state capacity to respond effectively to climate-related disasters, amplifies the risks.

• Great Power Competition: Somalia has become an arena for great power competition, particularly between the United States and China, each seeking to expand its influence and secure access to strategic resources. While the United States has historically provided security and development assistance, China's growing economic engagement, including investments in infrastructure and ports, presents a new dynamic. This competition, coupled with Somalia's strategic location and its vulnerability to external influence, creates a complex geopolitical landscape requiring careful navigation by Somali leaders.

• Regional Tensions: Somalia's relations with its neighbors, particularly Ethiopia and Kenya, are often fraught with tension and mistrust, owing to historical border disputes, unresolved territorial claims, and competition over resources. The recent diplomatic dispute between Somalia and Ethiopia over the latter's recognition of Somaliland has further strained relations and raised concerns about regional stability. The deployment of troops from neighboring countries as part of the African Union Transition Mission in Somalia (ATMIS) adds another layer of complexity to regional dynamics.

Data Synthesis and Organization

I. Historical Context and Colonial Legacies 

• Clannism and Political Identity: British and Italian colonial authorities deliberately exacerbated existing clan divisions through policies of divide and rule, employing a strategy of indirect rule that empowered certain clans over others. This historical legacy of manipulation has created lasting cleavages that continue to shape political identity and fuel inter-clan conflicts, hindering efforts to build national unity and foster a shared sense of Somali identity.

• Weak State Capacity: The colonial legacy of limited state-building and investment in public institutions has left Somalia with a chronically weak state apparatus, lacking the capacity to effectively govern, deliver essential services, and enforce the rule of law. The post-colonial period, marked by decades of civil war and state collapse, further weakened state capacity, creating a vacuum that non-state actors, including clan militias and extremist groups, have filled.

II. Political Developments 

• Al-Shabaab's Resilience: Despite military offensives and territorial losses, al-Shabaab has demonstrated remarkable resilience, adapting its tactics and exploiting governance failures to maintain its insurgency. The group's ability to regroup, recruit new fighters, and generate revenue through illicit activities, including extortion and taxation, underscores the need for a comprehensive counter-insurgency strategy that addresses the root causes of its appeal and strengthens community resilience.

• Contested Elections and Political Transitions: Somalia's political transitions have been marred by delays, disputes, and allegations of manipulation, undermining efforts to build a credible and legitimate political system. The 2022 elections, though hailed by some as a step forward, faced criticism for its lack of inclusivity and transparency, with clan elders playing a significant role in the selection process. These issues exacerbate political tensions and fuel mistrust in the FGS and the electoral process.

III. Institutional and Electoral Processes

• 4.5 Clan Formula and Marginalization: Somalia's political system operates under a "4.5" clan formula, which allocates parliamentary seats based on clan affiliation. This system has been criticized for marginalizing smaller clans and minority groups, undermining their political representation and exacerbating social inequalities. Efforts to move toward a one-person-one-vote system, crucial for ensuring equal representation for all citizens, have faced setbacks due to insecurity and lack of political consensus among clan leaders.

• Lack of Direct Elections: The absence of direct national elections since 1969, with parliamentary seats allocated through clan-based selection processes, perpetuates a system of political representation that is not fully representative of the Somali people's will. This system reinforces clannism, limits political accountability, and hinders efforts to build a more inclusive and democratic political system.

IV. Socio-Economic Factors 

• Remittances and Economic Dependence: Somalia's economy is highly dependent on remittances from the Somali diaspora, which provide a vital lifeline for many households. While remittances contribute significantly to household consumption and investment, they also create a dependency on external sources of income and can mask the need for structural economic reforms to create sustainable domestic economic opportunities.

• Limited Access to Basic Services: Decades of conflict and state collapse have left Somalia with a severely underdeveloped infrastructure and limited access to basic services, including education, healthcare, sanitation, and clean water. These deficits exacerbate poverty, inequality, and vulnerability to shocks, particularly in rural areas and among marginalized groups. The lack of investment in human capital, coupled with the brain drain of skilled professionals, further hinders efforts to build a more resilient and prosperous society.

V. Security and Conflict Dynamics 

• ATMIS Withdrawal and Security Vacuum: The planned withdrawal of ATMIS forces by the end of 2024 raises concerns about a potential security vacuum, particularly if the Somali National Army is not adequately prepared to assume full responsibility for national security. The SNA's limited capacity, coupled with its fragmentation along clan lines, poses a significant risk, potentially allowing al-Shabaab to regain territory and further destabilize the country.

• Inter-Clan Conflicts: Competition over scarce resources, including land and water, often exacerbated by climate change, fuels inter-clan conflicts, undermining efforts to build national cohesion and fostering instability. These conflicts, often involving the use of militias and heavy weapons, result in civilian casualties, displacement, and disruption of economic activity. The lack of effective conflict resolution mechanisms, coupled with the prevalence of impunity for perpetrators, further perpetuates the cycle of violence.

VI. Foreign Policy Environment

• Balancing Regional and International Interests: Somalia's foreign policy is characterized by a delicate balancing act between regional and international interests. While seeking to maintain good relations with its neighbors and secure regional stability, the country also faces pressure from major powers, each vying for influence and access to strategic resources. Navigating these competing interests, while safeguarding Somalia's sovereignty and promoting its national interests, presents a formidable challenge.

• Aid Dependence and Conditionality: Somalia's heavy dependence on foreign aid, particularly from Western countries, creates vulnerabilities to donor influence and conditionality. While aid is essential for addressing humanitarian needs and supporting development efforts, it can also create dependencies and distort local priorities. The challenge for Somalia is to leverage aid effectively while also promoting self-reliance and building its own capacity to finance its development needs.

VII. Unique to Country Topics

• Somaliland's Unrecognized Status: Somaliland's self-declared independence and its functional government create a unique challenge for Somalia, as the FGS does not recognize Somaliland's status while the international community has adopted a wait-and-see approach. The continued impasse over Somaliland's status, coupled with unresolved territorial claims with Puntland, hinders efforts to build national unity and foster a more comprehensive approach to addressing shared challenges, including security, economic development, and resource management. Moreover, the presence of a separate and relatively stable government in Somaliland creates a potential for future conflict if these issues are not addressed through dialogue and negotiation.

• Restoring Social Cohesion and Trust: Decades of conflict and instability have eroded social cohesion and trust in Somalia, creating a deep societal rift that hinders efforts to build a more peaceful and prosperous society. The lack of trust in government, institutions, and even between communities, requires a multifaceted approach to reconciliation that prioritizes addressing past grievances, promoting accountability for human rights abuses, and fostering a shared sense of Somali identity. Building social cohesion and trust is a long-term process that demands sustained commitment from all stakeholders, including government, civil society, and community leaders.

Sources Cited

• Alene, Tsion Belay, et al. "Funding for Somalia's new AU peace mission hangs in the balance." ISS Today, Institute for Security Studies, 2025.

• Amnesty International. "Somalia 2023." Amnesty International, 2024.

• Bertelsmann Stiftung. "Somalia Country Report." BTI 2024, Bertelsmann Stiftung, 2024.

• Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS). Transcript: Into Africa, "Power, Politics, and Peace in Somalia" CSIS, 2025.

• Kotikula, Aphichoke, et al. "Somalia Poverty and Equity Assessment." World Bank Group, 2024.

• Ouedraogo, Abdoulaye, et al. "Somalia Economic Update, Ninth Edition: Addressing Climate Change Challenges for Economic Growth." World Bank, 2024.

• Reva, Denys, and David Willima. "Maritime issues should top Somalia's UN Security Council agenda." ISS Today, Institute for Security Studies, 2025.

• United States Department of State. "2024 Investment Climate Statements: Somalia." U.S. Department of State, Bureau of Economic and Business Affairs, 2024.

• United States Department of State. "Somalia 2023 Human Rights Report." U.S. Department of State, Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights, and Labor, 2024.

• Williams, Paul D. "Peacekeepers and Political Stability in Somalia." Georgetown Journal of International Affairs, 2024.

• World Bank. "Somalia Overview: Development news, research, data." World Bank, 2024.

• Zeyede, Tamrat, et al. "Funding for Somalia's new AU peace mission hangs in the balance." ISS Today, Institute for Security Studies, 2025.