I Corinthians 14 contains instructions on how a church service is to be administered, it limits the number of speakers per service and limits women speakers, etc. Other parts of I Corinthians give instructions on payment of teachers. One group of the COC, known as the non-institutional, have long divided away from other COC with claims that they started acting outside the instructions of I Corinthians. Is it true other COC acted outside the instructions of Paul?
First, it does matter since we are to follow apostolic commands. Peter gives the instruction in his writings. So, if an apostle gives instructions we should follow them. Im not arguing that such are no longer necessary. I believe they are and we need to understand them and practice them. We should seek understanding without bias however.
The arguments began in Chilicothe Missouri where a young baptist was corrected by COC preachers for having an incomplete baptism, and the COC ministers explained some unbiblical practices of the baptist churches. The young man spent the rest of his life trying to prove the COC was itself unscriptural and he succeeded in turning some his way, but he was never right. He argued from bias and not a clear perspective. Some of his arguments were over.
speakers per assembly
Paid preachers, Paid elders, Paid deacons, Paid teachers, etc
Starting or giving to orphanages by the congregation
Joint congregational works between congregations, using money joined for the projects.
Eating food at the church building.
Some judged Sunday Schools invalid.
Two services on Sunday and mid-week services.
In other words every thing the church did was judged according to their criteria and understanding. They made themselves judges and blacklisted any congregation or person that didn't do exactly as they wanted. All of their arguments can be summarily disproven, but the damage was done and splits happened. I could go through each of these to show biblical support for each. Realize they may be the ones needing blacklisting according to I Corinthians 5:9, :Not to eat with a reviler", that is someone who talks bad about something or someone that is ok. They do a lot of that.
Realize im not saying all COC have practiced what is right, they are made up of humans, i'm not unity in diversity where we all do what we feel like. I do believe there is room to let people mature. There is room for differences of opinion in study that are not so bad it disrupts fellowship. So lets take some of these and see if they are correct.
They claim we should have two or three speakers and we have a paid preacher that does it all, keeping everyone else from voicing their knowledge. They are similar to quakers who had open pulpits where all could speak, but they limit to three per meeting. This is biblical and I believe in allowing two or three. So, what is the problem? They do not accept what constitutes speaking. We have someone give a lesson and we have someone give a message during the Lord's Supper, they call one speaking but not the other. A short message of the death of Jesus isn't accepted as speaking. The Greek word is prophesy, which is a topic we could write a pamphlet on. The point is we do have two or three speakers they just dont recognize all of them. There are other times speaking takes place such as short messages before prayer, announcements, giving sermonettes before giving to projects, and others like a call to worship by a song leader. All of these could fall under prophesying if honest about it. Realize the verses in question are limiting the number, not saying there must be more than one. The second speaker was conditional, "if something comes to another sitting by", it was conditional and not a command to do it every time.
Some allow all men to speak and look down on churches that don't. This isn't biblical. The verses in question, "let two or three prophets speak", are for prophets and not all men in the congregation. "You may all prophesy one by one", this is the prophets. The antecedent in Greek for all is the prophets mentioned just prior. They chose spiritually mature men. This is consistent with the giftedness concepts of I Corinthians 12, where gifted teachers were used. "Are all teachers". Having men who have natural talents and some education is the way the early church chose speakers. Having a paid preacher or a set of paid preachers doesn't violate this principal.
Paying men for their labor is biblical. Even if you see them as hirelings. Many use John 10 to dismiss hirelings as teachers. It isn't saying you cant compensate men. It is saying Jesus himself wasn't a hireling and the Jewish rabbis were. It actually proves God used hirelings for his purpose in the Old Testament. John 10 calls Jesus the shepherd, calls the sheep his own, and he calls the previous men thieves and robbers and hired men. Were all hired men thieves and robbers, did all flee? When you look at servants and hired hands in the Old Testament some had great character. Jesus wasn't saying all hired hands flee, but that hired hands have a greater propensity to leave and owners have a propensity to stay. Peter denied Christ before being strengthened. Hirelings can be both. Jesus said the kingdom contains hirelings, see Matthew 20:1-14. Yet, Christian teachers aren't hirelings in this sense. Wage earners agree on an amount of work for an amount of pay. Giving ones life isn't in that contract. Christians work isn't a wage, it is for eternal life, yes we work but the reward is thousands of times greater than any money we get. We aren't technically hirelings who abide outside the masters household and only work by contract. We are household servants and stewards. Getting money isn't a salary but a servants stipend and stewardship. Remember Joseph was placed over Pharoah's house. He took care of a lot of goods and money and had wealth, he wasn't a hireling who worked by the hour. We are in God's household and not hirelings. As abiding in God's house we are stewards entrusted with the grace God has given us. That includes money to have a living and to finance our work. We aren't hirelings from outside the household. John 10 doesn't say money is the problem, but relationship and love. "The hireling fleeth, because he is an hireling, and careth not for the sheep. " The difference between a hireling and a household servant is relationship and love and a contract for hours worked. Christians are part of the household of God, Elders are stewards and we are stewards. So, we can receive a living through church funds for work in the household. I Corinthians 9 has a list of relationships of parties, (soldiers, vineyard planters, shepherds and milk, priests, all have material gain through their labors. The plowman and thresher) no one goes to war at his own expense. Is the individual required to pay or the church that is owned by Christ? Paul admitted to taking money from other churches, plural. 2 Corinthians 11:8. They will admit apostles and evangelists received support, but not local elders or teachers. This is just bias really. You see the wording in In I Corinthians 9 opens the principal to all including women. The word is "Who" or "whoever", which means there are restrictions as long as it is good stewardship. Anyone can receive support if appropriate. See Phil. 4:3 and helping women who work in the Gospel.
Joint works between congregations are allowed in the church and appropriate at times, but non-institutional restricts the work by saying all funds must remain under the control of Elders that sent funds. This restriction is unbiblical. The churches chose men to carry the funds and these men worked and travelled together II Cor. 7-10. The churches collectively chose the men. You can also compare Acts 20:4-6, where the men from different areas travelled to Judea. So from collection to delivery the churches worked together. There were no known Elders traveling with them. The Elders trusted the chosen men to do the delivery. Plus there were times these men separated so they weren't always under joint control. They were trusted and did their service faithfully.
Joint works like nursing homes and orphanages or children's homes have been attempted but with interference from different parties. Sometimes the state interferes. Sometimes competing denominations, they feel like it is their sovereign right to control society. Yet, the biggest roadblock may simply be a lack of trust among congregations. Anti church theory makes any such works difficult. True religion is caring for widows and orphans and i'm not sure God restricts how. Peter called for the appointment of deacons in Acts 5 because of neglected widows, but orphans aren't mentioned there. The word orphan in Greek doesn't just mean parentless, it means any child held in darkness because they don't have proper teachers and examples. They can be children with really bad parents. Bringing these children to the light is true religion. These can be from fatherless in the church to parentless in the world to kids with parents who need to know Christ. Our visitation can be meeting physical needs to meeting spiritual. The word orphan is only mentioned twice in the New Testament, so there are no positive examples or negative examples of how we should do it. My guess is any way we can. We can bring them light and hope and help structure lives in a positive way. Non-institutional people try to restrict the process to private donations or private adoption. Foster parents would meet this obligation. Many teach it is a private action outside of the church. Yet this doesn't make complete sense when adopted children would be brought to church for its benefits once adopted. So there is no way to limit this to private help or instruction. The non-institutional position is untenable. Establishing classes and other opportunities to instruct orphans is possible and I believe necessary for true religion. Since there are no limiting verses we must use common sense. The Greek word "to visit" actually means "to consider carefully" which can have broad scope and meaning, there are no actual commands involved other than careful consideration and thereby caring for them, even private adoption isn't authorized directly. So the non-institutional try to act by authority but have no authority for what they allow. Our authorization is to "carefully consider" the orphans and widows, which with widows led to the appointment of deacons. We should be able to use deacons to relieve orphans. Thus acting institutionally through the church. The root is used in Matthew 25:35-38 and it entails several actions. Specifically, I was sick and you visited me. I presume spiritual sickness is just as important here. Jesus didn't use orphan here but it is logical they are included in his context. It is supposed James 1 is an individual context, but chapter 2 is a context of the assembly and they are actually joined together. Receiving and helping the "Poor of this world" involves a much broader context of helping people. God has chosen the poor of this world rich in faith.