Treatment of an illness with a substance similar to the causative agent of the disease
Homeopathic preparations of substances are of low concentrations (sometimes even not a single molecule)
A pseudoscience
Proven ineffective based on large-scale studies
Dogma of drugs, illness, human body, liquids and solutions contradict science
Effectiveness only as a placebo effect and normal recovery from illness
What are Some Homeopathic Belief Systems?
Miasms
Underlying causes of disease were caused by miasms
Miasms can be acted upon using homeopathics
Homeopathics/ Homeopathic preparations and Remedies
Main Idea
Undiluted doses of medicine caused reactions, so preparations be given at lowest possible dose via dilutions
Because potency and side effects is reduced, potency is restored by vigorous shaking and sriking on elastic surface
NOTE: In science, homeopathic preparations have no objectively detectable active ingredient.
Preparation and Manufacture: Dynamisation/ Potentisation
A process of continuous dilution and succession
Dilution
Chosen substance repeated diluted in alcohol or distilled water
Dilution Until no molecules of original substance remain
Insoluble solids like granite, diamond and platinum are diluted by grinding them with lactose (trituration)
Schutteln/ Succession:
With each dilution, vessel is bashed against an elastic material (e.g. leather-bound book)
This increases safe potency
Substances Used in Preparations
animal, plant, mineral and synthetic susbstances in their Latin or faux-latin names
arsenicum album (arsenic oxide)
Natrum muriaticum (salt)
Lachesis muta (Venom of bushmaster snake)
thyroidinum (Thyroid hormone)
nosodes: Made from diseased or pathological products such as feces, urine, respiratory discarges, blood and tissue
sarcodes: Made from healthy specimens
Imponderables Do no originate from substances but from other phenomenon "captured" by alcohol or lactose
X-rays
Sunlight
Other modes of Preparations
Paper Preparations: substance and dilution are written on pieces of paper and pinned to patients' clothing, put in their pockets or placed under glasses of water
Radionics: Use of Radio Waves
Flower Preparations:
Homeopathic Vaccines
Use of Isopathy: where nosodes are made from things that cause disease or are products of disease e.g. pus
Consultation
Homeopaths begin detailed examination of patients' history: physical, mental and emotional states, life circumstances and any physical or emotional illness
Similum:
Translation of information into a complex formula of mental, physical symptoms with likes, dislikes, innate predispositions and body type
Creates a totality of symptoms
Choice of therapy using Provings
by matching a single preparation to the similum
In clinical homeopathy: combinations of preparations based on various symptoms of an illness
Provings
A method where the profile of a homeopathic preparation is determined
Usually with lengthy records of self-experimentation
Uses both Repertories and Materia medica
Repertories
Reference books where homeopathics are indexed and Selected based on the totality of the patient's symptoms, personal traits, physical and psychological state, life history
Materia medica
Collection of "drug pictures" organised alphabetically
Describe the symptom patterns associated with individual preparations
How and Why Homeopathy Works (From a homeopathic perspective)
Water Memory
water 'remembers' the substances mixed in it, and transmits the effect of those substances when consumed.
Theoretical Physics: Quantum Entanglement , Quantum nonlocality, theory of relativity and chaos theory
Use of abstract concepts in Physics theories to explain how and why the preparations work
Homeopathic Potency
Hormesis: Higher dilutions or higher potency produce stronger medicinal effects
BUT: Physicist Robert L Park:
" since the least amount of substance in a solution is 1 molecule, in a 30cc solution requires 10^60, a container has to be 30billion times the size of the earth"
to get one molecule of substance in 30Xpills, 2 billion pills have to be consumed, which would also contain a thousand tons of lactose
Is Homeopathy Efficacious?
Explanation of Perceived Effects
Placebo Effect: Intensive consultation process and expectations for the homeopathic preparations may cause effects
Therapeutic effect of consultation: Care, concern and reassurance a patience experiences with a compassionate caregiver has positive effect on feelings of well-being
Unassisted Natural Healing: Time and body's ability to heal itself
Unrecognised Treatments: Unrelated food, exercise, environmental agent or treatment for a different ailment.
Regression toward the mean: Some disease are cycical and symptoms vary over time, and correct timing of homeopathic visits may attribute homeopathics with improvement
Non-homeopathic treatment: Patients may receive standard medical care at same time as homeopathic treatment
Cessation of unpleasant treatment: Patients may stop medical treatement like surgery or drugs that can cause unpleasant side-effects.
"Scientific" Positive results usually the result of
chance
flawed research methods
reporting Bias
Warnings from health organizations
WHO: comes with warning against the use of homeopathy to treat severe diseases such as HIV and malaria
US: CFI's (Center for Inquiry) proposal to FDA
Testing for homeopathic products The FDA will mandate that all homeopathic products on the market to perform and pass safety and efficacy tests equivalent to those required of non-homeopathic drugs.
Labeling for homeopathic products To avert misleading label that the product is regulated by the FDA, all homeopathic products will be required to have prominent labels stating: 1) the products claimed active ingredients in plain English, and 2) the product has not been evaluated by the FDA for either safety or effectiveness.
Regular consumer warnings Encouraged by the FDA's recent warning of the ineffectiveness of homeopathic products, CFI urged the FDA to issue regular warning to the consumers in addition to warning during public health crises and outbreaks.
Australian National Health and Medical Research Council (March 2015)
There is no reliable evidence that homeopathy is effective for treating health conditions.
Homeopathy should not be used to treat health conditions that are chronic, serious, or could become serious.
People who choose homeopathy may put their health at risk if they reject or delay treatments for which there is good evidence for safety and effectiveness.
People who are considering whether to use homeopathy should first get advice from a registered health practitioner. Those who use homeopathy should tell their health practitioner, and should keep taking any prescribed treatments.
British National Health and Medical Research Council
Swiss Federal Health Office
History of Homeopathy
400BC - Hippocrates used small dose of mandrake root to treat mania despite knowing it causes mania in large doses
16th Century - Paracelsus declared small doses of "what makes a man ill also cures him"
1796 - Coined by Samuel Hahnemann and dogma based on his doctrine of like cures like (similia similibus curentur), First use of the word appeared in print in 1907
18th and 19th Century - Mainstream medicine use of methods
bloodletting
Purging
Complex Mixtures: Venice treacle uses 64 substances including opium, myrrh and viper's flesh
19th Century - For and Against
For Homeopathy: Most popular when homeopathic institutions, colleges and practitioners sprang up in US and Europe.
1835 - First homeopathic school in the US
1844 - The American Institute of Homeopathy was established
1900 - 22 colleges, 15000 practitioners in US
Against Homeopathy
1843 - Sir John Forbes (Physician to Queen Victoria) - extremely small doses of Homeopathy are useless and "an outrage to human reason"
1853 - James Young Simpson: "No poison, however strong or powerful, the billionth or decillionth of which would in the least degree affect a man or harm a fly"
1842 - Oliver Wendell Holmes, Sr. 's essay: "Homeopathy and its Kindred Delusions"
1867 - French Homeopathic society observed most practitioners were abandoning the practice and no longer defend it.
1920 - Last Homeopathic school in US closed down
20th Century - Revival
1938 - US's Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act of 1938 recognised homeopathic preparations as durgs
1950s - 75 Pure homeopaths
1970s - Sales of homeopathic companies increased 10 fold
2007 - Sales of over the counter homeopathic medicines $2.7 billion
Other Related Treatments and Practices
Isopathy
invented by Johann Joseph Wilhelm Lux in 18302
e.g. Nosodes are made from things that cause the disease or are products of the disease such as pus.
Used in Homeopathic vaccines
Flower Preparations
Homeopathics are prepared in 'gentler' ways without succusion
Placing of flowers in water and exposing them to sunlight
e.g. Bach flower remedies
Veterinary Homeopathy
Used by Vets
Endorsed in the UK by Faculties of Homeopathy in universities or British Association of Homeopathic Veterinary Surgeons
Electrohomeopathy
Treatment devised by Count Cesare Mattei
different "colors" of electricity used to treate cancer