Problem Test

Find out if anybody cares about your idea...

...is the problem really real to anyone? And what is the real problem?

Why

Before you build a product, you will want to understand what problem it solves. Otherwise you may end up with a solution looking for a problem.

When we understand the problem from the customers perspective we will be able to build the right solution.

Note of caution: It is true that some solutions are solving problems that customers never knew the had. They gain something that they are not aware that they need until they see it. So you may also look for customers blind spots: Ways to improve their life that they never knew they could ask for.

When

The Problem Test is useful when you ask yourself the question: Do people care?

Usually early in the innovation process when you have decided which idea you want to pursue and develop. And before you go into detail with your product innovation. Even before you actually have a clear idea about the final solution.

How

Arrange meetings with potential users and customers and go through the following 4 steps:

  1. Perceived problem - describe the problem you think you have identified and the way you perceive it.
  2. Existing solutions - summarize the most important existing solutions in the market and how they solve the same problem. Existing solutions are not necessarily the same type of solution, but the best current alternatives to solve the problem.
  3. Own solution - present how you intend to solve the problem yourself. Not necessarily with a visualisation if you don't have it yet. A verbal description of your overall idea will be fine at this point.
  4. Ask for other leads - who might be interested in the solution. It is partly a test of whether other topics exist, but also of whether the customer is so enthusiastic that one will pass on the names of others.

Find a more detailed manual below...


Resources

Books & Articles

Steve Blank & Bob Dorf: The Startup Owners Manual, 2012. The method is well described in chapter 5, p. 189-226.


Elaborate manual for Problem Test

Preparation

Prepare a problem presentation

Before you meet with a customer or user you should prepare a Problem Presentation. A problem presentation has 4 steps:

  1. Perceived problem - describe the problem you think you have identified and the way you perceive it.
  2. Existing solutions - summarize the most important existing solutions in the market and how they solve the same problem. Existing solutions are not necessarily the same type of solution, but the best current alternatives to solve the problem.
  3. Own solution - present how you intend to solve the problem yourself. Not necessarily with a visualisation if you don't have it yet. A verbal description of your overall idea will be fine at this point.
  4. Ask for other leads - who might be interested in the solution. It is partly a test of whether other topics exist, but also of whether the customer is so enthusiastic that one will pass on the names of others.

Remember that the word "presentation" does not automatically mean PowerPoint.


Three key answers

Define the three most important things to find out during the customer meeting. What do you want to prove or disprove?

This will help you stay focused as the conversation wanders.

Problem interview

Be at least two people doing the interview. It is very demanding both to conduct interviews, to record answers and to be aware of the customer's body language and other unsaid signals.

Let one person focus on the interview while the other focuses on listening and observing. Listening and observing could even be shared between two people.

Don't sound like you're trying to sell something. If you do, the customer may become defensive and less honest.

But in the end, try to get the customer to commit to something - at least if the customer has been positive about your solution. It may just be a request for a new meeting when your solution is more ready for display.

Asking the customer to commit to something is a test of whether they mean, what they say.


Key Questions and steps

Problem:

  • Describe the problem as you see it.
  • What is the customers reaction? Does he see it the same way? Or even as a problem.
  • Importance: What does the problem mean to the customer? Are there any related problems?
  • How is the customer solving - or trying to solve - the problem today?

Solution:

  • What is the customer's immediate reaction to our idea?
  • What are the critical features and functions?
  • What are the barriers? What may prevent the customer from buying?
  • How would the customers life be different with this solution?
  • Whom else does the customer know, who might want a solutions like this?

Business Model:

  • At what price would it be too expensive? At what price would it be suspiciously cheap?
  • Where would the customer prefer to read about the product?
  • Where would he prefer to buy it?