Location: Wheaton, Illinois
Date Designed / Built: 2006
Client: Northwestern Medicine Marianjoy Rehabilitation Hospital
Designer: Hitchcock Design Group
Northwestern Medicine Marianjoy Rehabilitation Hospital is a non-profit teaching hospital that offers inpatient and outpatient care for those recovering from illness or injury. The Enabling Garden at Marianjoy Hospital is part of a larger network of healing gardens meant to aid patients in their physical rehabilitation journeys. This particular garden features many elements aimed specifically at senior patients and is designed to accommodate for their needs, abilities, and rehabilitation goals.
The Enabling Garden is an open-air courtyard designed for both relaxation and rehabilitation. Programming elements were chosen to accommodate a range of physical abilities and to “challenge” patients who are regaining strength and mobility. Surfaces of varied textures (like concrete, brick, and wooden boardwalks) were used throughout the site to help patients become accommodated to walking on different materials. Stairs and ramps of varying slopes were also added and equipped with handrails to aid in the recovery of walking abilities and to help patients become comfortable using walkers or wheelchairs. The garden offers opportunities for a range of patients to engage in horticultural therapy by utilizing planters in various heights and sizes, accessible for those using different mobility aids. A vertical flower wall was also added to allow patients who are regaining strength to practice reaching.
Individual and group seating was added throughout the courtyard to encourage relaxation and to provide ample space for group gatherings and family visitations. A bench-height water feature adds a sensory element to the design and allows patients to sit and watch pollinators visit the pond’s plants while providing a relaxing background noise for the space.
The Enabling Garden is focuses on the specific physical needs of elderly patients undergoing rehabilitation, but the benefits of the garden are more than just physical. According to Sarah Herron, an occupational therapist at the hospital, the garden is used to help patients with "mobility, arm strength, coordination and balance, cognition, sequencing, problem-solving and pathfinding." However it also serves as a beautiful space where "patients and visitors tend to gravitate [...] to connect with each other and nature." (Brown 2020).
Senior patients have specific physical needs that can be accommodated through design elements.
Horticultural therapy can be part of an effective treatment plan for elderly patients.
A design for and senior care facility should include comfortable and accessible seating for both individual relaxation and group gatherings.
Attention to detail is important -- different materials have different effects on patients and should be chosen carefully (i.e. certain paving patterns can confuse depth perception and lead to falls) (Brown 2020).
Sensory elements, like brightly colored flowers and strongly scented plants, help to engage patients.
https://www.nm.org/locations/marianjoy-rehabilitation-hospital
https://production.nm.org/healthbeat/healthy-tips/the-healing-power-of-gardens
https://www.hitchcockdesigngroup.com/portfolio/hospital-courtyard-design/
Location: Bamber Bridge, UK
Client: Age Concern Central Lancashire
Designer: Dr. Garuth Chalfont, Chalfont Design
The gardens at Charnley Fold Enhanced Dementia Day Support are designed to benefit the mental health of elderly patients. The facility offers a 12-week course, in which patients dealing with dementia, impaired memory and cognition, impaired language skills, challenging behavior, and depression can participate in daily group programs (Chalfont 2011). Many activities are centered around the facility's extensive outdoor space that utilizes specific design elements to aid in building and regaining mental well-being.
The outdoor space at Charnley Fold is separated into seven differentiated areas, deemed the "Seven Meaningful Spaces", each meant for different skill-building activities. Extensive gardens and chicken houses allow patients to undergo necessary daily chores, like weeding, planting, pruning, and caring for the animals. Elements like this allow patients to fully participate in the space, and that "participation and ownership becomes therapeutic". Many circulation loops wind throughout the space, connecting open doors and archways to encourage movement. This also encourages a sense of "ownership" as users can choose their own path through the garden (also aiding in path-finding skills), but are never out of sight of a caretaker. Elements are all "tightly integrated" in the space, allowing patients to feel a sense of participation even if simply sitting near an activity, encouraging them to join in. Two water features create a sense of "flow" throughout the site and help to build a sense of natural wonder. A "bubbling boulder fountain" is chest-height, encouraging users to interact with the feature physically and providing a sensory ambiance to the space. A "flow form" also swirls water in "energetic" patterns, which is pleasing to watch and adds to the "flow of life" metaphor that guides the design. Diverse plantings provide year-round sensory interest and require little maintenance. However, plantings are intentionally sparse to give the garden a sense of being "undone", encouraging users to plant what they like in the space. All design features are placed with windows in mind, creating open views of plants and wildlife (and chickens) from each courtyard-facing window, creating a sense of participation in the space even when sitting inside the facility (Garuth 2011).
A case study done through interviews of staff members found that patients at Charnley Fold who utilized the outdoor space seemed to exhibit improved communication and mood from participating in group activities and spending time in a pleasing outdoor envrironment. Memory seemed to be reinforced from visiting the garden over time. Skills and mobility improved, and patients seemed more motivated to perform tasks independently. Happiness, enthusiasm, calmness, and confidence were also terms used to describe the improvements of patients who participated in the gardens (Garuth 2011).
Designs for the elderly should follow the basic guidelines of Universal Design -- spaces should be accessible, comfortable, participatory, ecological, legible, multi-sensory, predictable, and walkable/traversable (Bianchini et al. 2019).
Gates that always remain open help to invite people to explore and utilize spaces.
Natural elements should be more than just visually pleasing. They should also encourage participation in nature and appeal to multiple senses.
Features that give patients opportunities to perform daily tasks create a sense of ownership over the space and help to build mental skills. Patients do not feel they are participating in "busy work", but instead feel necessary to the daily operations of the space (Garuth 2011).
Attention should be paid to the views created from inside the facility and should allow those stuck inside to enjoy the healing benefits of the space.
Pathfinding ability and memory skills can be built through implementing winding pathways with multiple options for circulation, though patients should never have the opportunity to be too far from a caretaker if they get lost.
https://www.chalfontdesign.com/media/Charnley_Fold_Design.pdf
ASLA Professional Practice Networks' Blog. (2021.). Healthcare & Therapeutic Gardens Interview Series: Dr. Garuth Chalfont. The Field. https://thefield.asla.org/2021/10/14/healthcare-therapeutic-gardens-interview-series-dr-garuth-chalfont/.
Bianchini, J., King, A., & Green, J. (2019, August 27). Aging. THE DIRT. https://dirt.asla.org/category/aging/
Brown, Laura. (2020, September 25). Healing gardens. West Suburban Living. https://www.westsuburbanliving.net/archives/healing-gardens/article_04132c9e-3440-577c-9a10-17a9696f9bf0.html
Chalfont, Garuth. (2011). Charnley Fold: A practice model of environmental design for enhanced dementia day care. Social Care and Neurodisability. 2. 71-79. 10.1108/20420911111142740.
Chalfont, G. (n.d.). Charnley Fold Design. Bamber Bridge, Lancashire; Age Concern Lancashire Care NHS Foundation Trust.
Farage MA, Miller KW, Ajayi F, Hutchins D. (2012). Design principles to accommodate older adults. Glob J Health Sci.;4(2):2-25. doi: 10.5539/gjhs.v4n2p2. PMID: 22980147; PMCID: PMC4777049
Northwestern Medicine. (n.d.). Marianjoy Rehabilitation Hospital: Wheaton, IL. https://www.nm.org/locations/marianjoy-rehabilitation-hospital
Northwestern Medicine. (n.d.). The Healing Power of Gardens. https://www.nm.org/healthbeat/healthy-tips/the-healing-power-of-gardens
Hitchcock Design Group. (2024.). Hospital courtyard design: Marianjoy rehabilitation hospital, enabling garden. https://www.hitchcockdesigngroup.com/portfolio/hospital-courtyard-design/