Location: Whitby, ON, Canada
Date Designed / Built: Opened in 1996
Client: Whitby Mental Health Center
Designer: Mary Jane Lovering, Vertechs Design, Inc.
Bordering Lake Ontario and located in Whitby's suburbs, Whitby Mental Health Center (WMHC) is an institute that provides consultation, treatment, rehabilitation and assessment to individuals suffering from mental illness. The hospital's reach encompasses a catchment area inhabited by 3.2 million individuals. The facility itself spans 50,000 square feet and takes the form of a low-rise structure, accommodating 325 beds. The ultimate objective is to facilitate their reintegration into the community at an independent level. The outdoor courtyards are the semi-public areas in the institute, while the interior features of the building fosters strong connection with the outdoors (e.g. the patient care units are positioned on the outer edge of the building).
After undergoing rebranding in 2009 to more accurately reflect its objectives and visions, the institute's name was changed to Ontario Shores Centre for Mental Health Sciences (Ontario Shores).
The overarching design strategy aimed to reflect the residential aesthetic of the nearby neighborhoods. This was achieved by implementing a front entrance to the building and a rear entrance to each courtyard. The use of earth tones for hardscaping materials, along with the incorporation of earth tones, was an effort to prevent excessive sensory stimulation. Ultimately, the design sought to evoke sensations of quiet, calm, and continuity (Marcus and Barnes, 1999). The purpose behind the courtyard spaces was to offer a visual and textural contrast to the regularity and dimensions of the buildings. Furthermore, there are courtyards connected to each distinct unit within the facility, as well as to the admission area and the cafeteria. These courtyards are tailored to cater to the specific patient population of the respective units, addressing their specific needs (e.g., some courtyards have larger space with more grass and less pavement to create a "backyard" feeling, while another courtyard has more paving and is filled with arbors and trees).
Photo of a courtyard attached to one of the patient care in 2010, specifically designed to cater the specific needs of the unit.
Image source: https://flic.kr/p/8EMFu1
The significance of the courtyards lies in their dedication to fostering an environment that embraces and utilizes outdoor spaces for therapeutic advantages, whether through passive or active means. Moreover, the courtyards reflects the initial phases of implementing a horticultural therapy program.
The grounds are open to the general public, which has the potential to reduce societal fears regarding mental illness and cultivate a sense of shared ownership within the community. Nevertheless, even with careful consideration, this choice could potentially lead to challenges for both patients and staff, giving rise to concerns related to privacy and confidentiality.
Designing for the unique needs of patients in their respective units is feasible.
A successful design can consist of simple and low maintenance planting, along with deliberately utilizing non-toxic plant materials.
Cooper Marcus. C. and M. Barnes. 1999. Healing Gardens. New York: John Wiley & Sons. Pg. 261-270.
Location: San Francisco, CA, USA
Date Designed / Built: 1990
Client: San Francisco General Hospital
Designer: Peter Richards ("Companion Place")
The first buildings officially designated as San Francisco General Hospital were established at the base of Portrero Hill in the year 1872. However, outbreaks of bubonic plague, the rampant spread of tuberculosis, the devastating 1906 earthquake, and the 1918 influenza epidemic all led to a serious problem of overcrowding in this hospital, as well as in numerous other healthcare institutions in San Francisco. The San Francisco General Hospital's present-day buildings, constructed between 1915 and 1920, were designed in the Italianate style by the city architect Newton Tharp. These structures are surrounded by lush green lawns and vibrant flowering plants.
On the hospital's expansive campus, you'll find the Comfort Garden, a small but heavily utilized outdoor area. This garden is somewhat hidden, located adjacent to outpatient clinic buildings at the hospital and is separated by fences on two sides. In June 1990, it was dedicated as a "living memorial" in honor of hospital employees who had passed away. A plaque in the garden, commemorating its establishment, concludes with these words: "It is intended to be a place of solace, where the beauty of nature can bring you comfort" (Marcus and Barnes, 1999).
The garden is surrounded by the buildings on two sides and is enclosed by fences on the other two sides, separating it from a street and a parking lot. It offers a residential-scale atmosphere with lush greenery and vibrant colors. Several large trees, including a cedar and two Monterey pines, provide shade to the space. The garden features five lawn areas, bordered by concrete pathways and flower beds. While most paths are designed for easy and direct pedestrian movement, one is made of decomposed granite, and another is created with wooden "steppingstone" blocks for casual strolling through a garden bed with shrubs and flowers (Marcus and Barnes, 1999). The garden emanates a sense of love and care in its maintenance, with creative features such as arranged tree stumps bordering the flower beds, an arbor made from nearby tree branches, and strategically placed rocks among the perennials. In addition, the presence of various annuals adds to its vibrant appearance.
In 1994, a portion of the garden was transformed into a more formal sculptural area called "Companion Place." It includes a curvilinear path, granite seating blocks, and formal flower beds with African marigolds and lobelia. The garden overall has a casual, "country cottage" appearance, with a blend of formality (Marcus and Barnes, 1995).
The gardeners plays a pivotal role in the planting design process of the garden, utilizing donated plants and materials scavenged from other parts of the medical campus effectively.
Image source: Marcus and Barnes, 1999
A view of the "Companion Place" that a portion of the garden was transformed into in 1994.
Image source: https://www.peterrichardsart.com/companion-place.html
The double helix path, outlined by granite curbstones, prompts contemplation of human life's cyclical nature, symbolizing the garden's role as a sanctuary for all stages of life. The flat stone resembles a dolmen, a spiritual space for departed souls (Richard, 2023).
Image source: https://www.peterrichardsart.com/companion-place.html
The project succeeded in bringing about a significantly positive shift in the emotional well-being of most individuals who spent time in it. People leaving the hospital or returning to work in the hospital reported feeling less stressed, invigorated, and generally more content. Furthermore, the garden's social aspects were highly valued as it served as a meeting place for support groups from various clinics and was also casually utilized by patients. Many of those interviewed, whether they were hospital staff, for whom the garden was dedicated, or outpatients from the methadone and HIV clinics, affectionately regarded this garden as "their own" (Marcus and Barnes, 1995).
The garden's environment evokes a sense of personal ownership, encouraging the users to consider it their own special sanctuary. Numerous individuals have expressed deep connections and emotions through this garden, particularly in relation to its memorial component. They view it as a secure space where they can freely express their emotions, including crying, as documented in Laurie Barkin's memoir "The Comfort Garden: Tales from the Trauma Unit."
The residential scale of the garden, smaller benches designed to match the garden's scale and create an intimate atmosphere, along with the colorful planting that changes through the seasons, all plays an important role in enhancing the psychological comfort experienced by its users.
The gardeners have a significant role in the design (maintenance), as they are responsive to both the needs of the people and the plants (e.g. donated plants, "scavenged" materials).
Barkins, Laurie. 2012. The Comfort Garden: Tales from the Trauma Unit. San Francisco: Fresh Pond Press.
Cooper Marcus. C. and M. Barnes. 1999. Healing Gardens. New York: John Wiley & Sons. Pg. 176-181.
https://www.peterrichardsart.com/companion-place.html
Location:Valparaiso Region of Chile
Date Designed / Built: 1929
Client: Maritime Sanatorium
Designer: Nilsa Zúñiga
Memorial of the Maritime Sanatorium of San Juan de Dios is selected for this case study. The hospital is located in the Valparaiso Region of Chile, where the site is situated in a gorge with sweeping South Pacific Ocean view. The health facility, operating for almost 90 years as a non-profit organization, serves children and young people facing severe neurological issues and rights challenges. Its purpose is to enhance their quality of life through medical, educational, psychosocial, occupational, and inclusive care. The institution has created an outdoor area to aid recovery and facilitate therapeutic activities. This space is accessible to users, families, caregivers, volunteers, Special School students, and collaborators of the institution.
This building incorporates natural spaces into hospital compound that helps to achieve effective sensory-based therapeutic treatment that has been proven to give lot of advantages to the human mind and body. After a few considerations based on the patients’ conditions and the layout of the space, the project participants decided that the existing fruit trees may greatly help in sensory treatments. The garden is also equipped with three workspaces that are connected to each other by a walking trail. The design approach allows occupants to experience variety of smells, colors, and textures during their visit in the healing garden (Truffa, 2021).
Truffa (2021) stated that the garden also consists of an area with lavender and pomegranate plants for hands-on exploration, a space for horticultural therapy and workshops. Visitors can participate in the harvesting plants and also witness the life cycle of the plants. This physical interaction provides an educational experience, and it helps in developing their sensory and motor skills.
The spatial connection between the building and the garden allows the patient to interact directly with the trees, flowers, and bushes. This interaction effectively reduces stress. These activities can be a helpful distraction for patients and contribute to their quicker recovery. The design of the garden is not bounded in a greenery notion, but the space accommodates significant activities such as bird viewing, planting, walking, and watering the plants. These activities can distract the patients and allow them to recover instantly.
The space and the garden have provided:
A space that provide personal attachments (experience and secure atmosphere),
View to nature scenes,
Contact to outside environment,
Environment that accommodate patients with declining visual, auditory, and kinesthetic senses.
Healing Gardens: Nature as Therapy in Hospitals by Truffa, L
https://www.archdaily.com/972112/healing-gardens-nature-as-therapy-in- hospitals
https://valparaisoinforma.com/noticias/vuelve-la-campana-del-panal-del-sanatorio-maritimo-san-juan-de-dios/
Location: Wilmington, DE
Date Designed / Built: 1985, 2014
Client: Christiana Care
Designer: Robinson Anderson Summers Inc.
As part of the Christiana Care Hospital’s Wilmington campus expansion, RAS designed a courtyard garden in the area that was the hospital’s original vehicular drop off area. The garden design created a sense of tranquility and relaxation, but also as a place for healing (Christiana Care – Wilmington Hospital Healing Garden, 2018). The atrium connects the hospital addition and café to a new courtyard, and there is also a new interior healing garden. There are water features in both the atrium interior garden and the outdoor courtyard healing garden (staff, 2019).
Healing courtyard garden / image: (Christiana Care – Wilmington Hospital Healing Garden, 2018).
Healing courtyard garden / image: (Christiana Care – Wilmington Hospital Healing Garden, 2018).
The garden provides a new healing area for patients who have limited outdoor access due to mobility or health issues. Each patient room offers a view of the garden, enhancing its healing impact. Natural light and elements like water contribute to the well-being of patients and staff.
The garden exemplifies how to make a space functional for patients in wheelchairs, with features like wide areas to turn, and raised beds. It also demonstrates how to create distractions from physical issues, like fountains for soothing sights and sounds, plants that attract birds and butterflies, and vertical greenery. Additionally, the garden showcases ways to encourage social interaction, with seating at wheelchair-friendly heights.
Water features, natural light, and different types of surfaces highlights the significance of incorporating diverse sensory and textural elements into the garden design.
The courtyard views from patient rooms and ensuring the garden can be seen from various points promote positive mental states and contribute to the healing process.
The courtyard spaces with various surfaces, steps, and ramps offers therapists the opportunity to engage patients in activities that support their recovery and rehabilitation, aligning the garden with the hospital's therapeutic goals.
https://news.christianacare.org/2014/07/healing-garden-dedicated-at-wilmington-hospital/
https://raslainc.com/project/christiana-care-wilmington-hospital-healing-garden/#info
https://thefield.asla.org/2019/02/21/nature-healing-and-creativity/
Place: Crown Sky Garden, Chicago, IL, USA
Designer: Mikyoung Kim Studio
Description: This interactive park located in the Chicago Lurie Children’s Hospital was designed to help with patient recovery time. Using light, color, water, and more, the design elements of the park are intended as a space for patients to relieve stress and promote physical rehabilitation. The components of the site appeal to the Five Senses such as interactive speakers of sounds of nature in the wooden benches and the colored resin wall filled with LED lights that turn into images of water activated through sensors.
Image source: https://myk-d.com/projects/crown-sky-garden/
Place: Lucas Gardens School, NSW, Australia
Designer: Good Manors, Landscape Architects
Description: This healing garden was designed to accommodate young users with wheelchairs (universal designs). There is a sensory garden in the middle, with series of curvy raised garden beds acting as “activity stations” for the children, including splash tables for children to play with water. There are also many spaces of quieter areas suitable for music therapy sessions and time with family members. Other spaces include compost area, grassy field, potting shed, earthworm bins, shade house, outdoor concert stage, and native plant propagation area (Severtsen, 2006).
Image source: https://depts.washington.edu/open2100/Resources/2_OpenSpaceTypes/Open_Space_Types/healing_gardens.pdf
Barkins, Laurie. 2012. The Comfort Garden: Tales from the Trauma Unit. San Francisco: Fresh Pond Press.
Bowles, N. 2011. Laurie Barkin’s memoir “Comfort Garden” On Trauma. SFGATE.
https://www.sfgate.com/homeandgarden/article/laurie-barkin-s-memoir-comfort-garden-on-trauma-
2335092.php
Hatcher, M. 2023. Landscape design ideas for a healing, Therapeutic Garden at a medical facility or hospital.
Landscaping Memphis. https://www.hatcherlandscape.com/blog/landscape-design-ideas-healing-
therapeutic-garden-medical-facility-hospital
Marcus. C. and M. Barnes. 1999. Healing Gardens. New York: John Wiley & Sons.
Marcus, C. and M. Barnes. 1995. Gardens In Healthcare Facilities: Uses, Therapeutic Benefits, And Design
Recommendations. The Center for Health Design, 70.
Nemes, G. (n.d.). Chicago Lurie Children’s Hospital: Crown Sky Garden. Mikyoung Kim Design. https://myk-d.com/projects/crown-sky-garden/
Ontario Shores Centre for Mental Health Sciences, 2010. Unit Courtyard at Ontario Shores Centre for Mental
Health Sciences. https://flic.kr/p/8EMFu1
Richards, Peter. 2023. Companion place. Peter Richards Art. https://www.peterrichardsart.com/companion-
place.html
Severtsen, Betsey. 2006. Healing Gardens.
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/319508681_Healing_Gardens
Truffa, L. (2021). Healing Gardens: Nature as Therapy in Hospitals.
ArchDaily. Retrieved from https://www.archdaily.com/972112/healing-gardens-nature-as-therapy-in- hospitals
Informa, P. V. (2023, May 23). Vuelve la “Campaña del pañal” Del sanatorio marítimo san juan de dios. Valparaíso Informa. https://valparaisoinforma.com/noticias/vuelve-la-campana-del-panal-del-sanatorio-maritimo-san-juan-de-dios/
Christiana Care – Wilmington Hospital Healing Garden. (2018, May 17).
Robinson Anderson Summers Inc. https://raslainc.com/project/christiana-care-wilmington-hospital-healing-garden/#info
staff, A. (2019, February 21). Nature, Healing, and Creativity. The Field. https://thefield.asla.org/2019/02/21/nature-healing-and-creativity/