One Nation, One Identity? Understanding France’s Assimilation Policy.

Responding to Socio-Cultural Diversity

Imagine living in a neighbourhood where people speak different languages, celebrate different festivals and practise different religions. How can everyone live together peacefully and feel that they belong?

Socio-cultural diversity makes our society richer, but differences can sometimes lead to misunderstandings, prejudice and conflict. Living together is not just about accepting our differences. It is about learning to respect one another and working together.

So, who is responsible for building a harmonious society? The answer is both citizens and the government.

What do you think is the message of this poster?

Responding to Socio-Cultural Diversity

So, who is responsible for building a harmonious society?

Both citizens and the government are responsible.

In this Google Site, you will explore how individuals, community groups, and the government can respond to socio-cultural diversity. You will also learn about social cohesion and solidarity, why they matter, and how they can be weakened.

What do you think assimilation in France looks like?

Learning Objectives

By the end of this topic, you should be able to:

Explain how individuals and community groups can promote social cohesion and solidarity.
Describe how social cohesion and solidarity can be weakened.
Explain how the government can manage socio-cultural diversity.
Recognise how citizens and the government can work together to build a harmonious society.

Think About It!

How can we build a society where people from different backgrounds feel respected, connected and united?

Responses of governments

France’s Assimilation Policy: Building a Common Identity

France's assimilation policy encourages immigrants to adopt French culture, speak French, and follow French values. The aim is to build a common national identity and promote social cohesion. However, this may create tension when immigrants want to keep their own cultural and religious practices.(Textbook page 190 to 191)

Three Main Principles

1. Universalism: Everyone Is Equal

France believes that all citizens should be treated equally, regardless of their race, culture or religion. People are seen as individuals who share the same rights and responsibilities.

2. Laïcité (Secularism): Keeping Religion Separate from Government (Textbook page 192)

France believes that religion and government should be kept separate. Public institutions should not favour any religion. For example, students in French public primary and secondary schools are not allowed to wear conspicuous religious symbols, such as Islamic headscarves or large Christian crosses.

3. Integration Requirements: Learning French Values

Some immigrants must meet certain requirements to stay in France for a long time. These may include learning French, attending lessons about French society and understanding French laws and values.

Liberty, equality, fraternity

Meaning of the Three Core Values

Liberté (Liberty): The right to live freely without oppression, tyranny, or undue restriction by the authorities.
Égalité (Equality): The principle that all people are viewed and treated equally under the law, without special privileges or discrimination.
Fraternité (Fraternity): The idea of solidarity, mutual support, and being a united community where people look out for one another.

1. Education

Immigrant children learn the French language and about French culture and values in school.
Public schools promote a common French identity and follow the principle of secularism, which separates religion from government.

2. Employment

Immigrants are encouraged to learn French so that they can communicate and work with others in French society.
Workers are expected to follow French laws and workplace rules, helping them take part in the country's working life.

3. Naturalisation

Immigrants who want to become French citizens must meet requirements, such as demonstrating knowledge of the French language and French values.
They are expected to respect the principles of the French Republic, including equality and secularism, as part of becoming French citizens.

Bonjour! Let’s Pick Up Some French Words

Bonjour, Monsieur

Bonjour,

Madame /Mademoiselle

Excusez-moi

S’il vous plaît

Merci

Bon appétit !

C’est très bon

Au revoir

Tensions Arising from France’s Assimilation Policy

France’s assimilation policy encourages immigrants to adopt French values and ways of life. However, tensions may arise when the expectations of French society conflict with immigrants’ cultural and religious practices.

1. Preserving French National Identity

Some French people believe that immigrants should adopt French values and avoid openly displaying religious symbols in public institutions.

They may view the open expression of religious beliefs as a challenge to French national identity and secular values. This can lead to disagreements between those who support strict assimilation and immigrants who wish to maintain their religious practices.

2. Respecting Immigrants’ Religious Freedom

Immigrants may regard their culture and religion as essential aspects of their identity.

They may feel that restrictions on religious symbols limit their freedom to practise their religion and express their cultural identity.

This can create resentment towards the French government and tension between immigrants and those who support strict assimilation policies.

Discussion Uno

Let's discuss

Should France prioritise French national identity

over immigrants’ religious freedom?

Guiding Question for Students

Which position do you agree with? Explain your choice using one reason and supporting evidence.

Position 1:

Support France’s Assimilation Policy

Stakeholder: A French government supporter

What I stand for:

I believe that immigrants should adopt French values and respect secularism. Restricting conspicuous religious symbols in public schools helps to maintain a common national identity and promotes social cohesion.

Position 2:

Respect Immigrants’ Religious Freedom

Stakeholder: An immigrant who values religious freedom

What I stand for:

I believe that immigrants should be free to practise their religion and express their cultural identity. They should be able to maintain their religious beliefs while respecting French laws and being part of French society.

Please fill up this Google form

What Is the Main Challenge?

France wants immigrants to share a common national identity. However, some immigrants may want to continue practising their religion and keeping their cultural traditions.

This raises an important question:

Read the following articles

Police in Cannes stop Muslim women wearing banned burkinis

Why burkinis are banned in some French cities

How can France promote national unity while respecting the different cultures and religions of its people? (Textbook page 195)

Case Study: Managing Socio-Cultural Diversity in France

Extract 1

France promotes a common national identity by encouraging people to follow French values and respect the principle of laïcité, or secularism. In French public primary and secondary schools, students are not allowed to wear conspicuous religious symbols, such as Islamic headscarves and large Christian crosses. The policy aims to keep public schools religiously neutral. However, some students and their families feel that the restrictions limit their freedom to express their religious beliefs.

Extract 2

Some French people believe that immigrants should adopt French values and respect the country’s secular principles. They feel that keeping public institutions, such as schools, free from conspicuous religious symbols helps to promote a common national identity. They believe that this can encourage people from different backgrounds to live together under shared values.

Extract 3

Some immigrants believe that their religion and culture are important parts of their identity. They feel that restrictions on religious symbols may prevent them from expressing their beliefs freely. They may see these restrictions as unfair because they feel that they should be able to maintain their religious practices while being part of French society.

Extract 1 shows how France promotes a common national identity.

In your opinion, why might some Muslim students disagree with France’s policy on religious symbols in public schools? Explain your answer with reference to one reason.

Extracts 2 and 3 show the opinions of different groups of people regarding French identity

Explain how France’s assimilation policy can create tension between upholding French national identity and respecting immigrants’ religious freedom.

Page updated

Report abuse