Deceitful Maps!

Click the play button for the audio version of this page - scroll down and follow along as the text is read to you.

Have you ever wondered why maps don't always look like the real world? Why do some countries appear larger or smaller than they actually are? It's all because of something called map distortion. In this article, we'll dive into the fascinating world of map projections and explore why maps can be distorted. We'll also discuss how mapmakers can be influenced by politics and why maps should be seen as models rather than exact mirrors of the Earth.

Understanding Map Projections:

Mapmakers use a variety of map projections to represent the round Earth on a flat piece of paper or a screen. Each projection has its own way of translating the Earth's curved surface onto a 2D map. Some popular map projections include:

The Peters projection was developed to address the distortion of land areas in the Mercator projection. It accurately represents the sizes of countries but distorts their shapes.

The Influence of Politics:

Did you know that mapmakers can be influenced by politics when creating maps? Borders, territorial claims, and the sizes of countries can be depicted in ways that reflect political interests or ideologies.
For example:

During the colonial era, maps were often drawn in a way that favored the interests of colonizing countries. For example, when European powers were colonizing parts of Africa, the borders on the maps were often drawn without consideration for the existing ethnic or tribal boundaries. Instead, the maps were designed to suit the colonial powers' economic and political interests, resulting in borders that divided communities or merged distinct groups.

Naps can also be influenced by nationalistic agendas, where countries may want to portray themselves as more powerful or influential. This can lead to distortions in the sizes and positions of countries.

Maps can play a role in territorial disputes between nations. In some cases, conflicting claims over a particular region or border can lead to maps being drawn differently by each party involved. Each side may emphasize their own claims and distort the boundaries or sizes of territories to support their position.

Maps as Models, Not Exact Mirrors:

It's important to understand that maps are not exact replicas of the Earth's surface. They are models or representations created to help us understand and navigate our world. Here are a few key points to keep in mind:

Distortion is Inevitable: Due to the challenge of representing a spherical Earth on a flat surface, some degree of distortion is inevitable in all map projections. Each projection has its strengths and weaknesses, and it's important to choose the right projection for the purpose at hand.

The Importance of Map Key and Scale: To interpret maps correctly, it's crucial to use the map key or legend provided. The key explains the symbols, colors, and features represented on the map. Additionally, the map scale helps us understand the relationship between distances on the map and the real world.

Ever-changing Earth:

Did you know that the Earth's landscapes are constantly changing? Natural forces like wind, water, and even the movement of tectonic plates can shape our land over time. This continuous change can make it difficult for maps to always show the exact picture of what the land looks like. When mapmakers create maps, they try their best to capture the current state of the land, but it's challenging to keep up with all the changes happening on our planet. Mountains can erode and become smaller, rivers can change their course, and new islands can form in the ocean. These changes happen slowly over time, so it takes a while for mapmakers to update their maps with the latest information. That's why sometimes the maps we use may not perfectly match what the land actually looks like. However, maps are still helpful tools that give us a good idea of our surroundings and help us find our way. Just remember, while maps are valuable, it's important to stay curious and be aware that the Earth is always changing, and there may be new features that the maps haven't captured yet.

Making maps simple: 

When we look at a map, we want it to be easy to understand, right? That's why mapmakers simplify things to make them clearer. For example, when it comes to showing mountains, they don't draw every single detail of the mountains' intricate shapes. Instead, they use something called contour lines. These lines are like wavy lines that show the different heights and shapes of the mountains. They help us understand that there are mountains in that area and give us an idea of their size and steepness.

The same goes for bodies of water like lakes and rivers. Mapmakers don't draw every single curve and bend of a river or the irregular shape of a lake. Instead, they use simple shapes like circles or wavy lines to represent them. This way, we can quickly see where the rivers and lakes are and how they flow, without getting overwhelmed by too many details.

By simplifying these complex features, maps become easier to read and understand. However, it's important to remember that this simplification can sometimes cause distortions. For example, the contour lines may not capture every little bump and dip of the mountains, which could make them look smoother or flatter than they actually are. The simplified shapes of bodies of water might not show all the little twists and turns. But despite these distortions, the main goal of maps is to give us a clear overall picture of the land, so we can navigate and find our way around.

Final Thoughts: 

Maps are powerful tools that help us navigate, explore, and understand our world. However, they can be distorted due to the challenge of representing a spherical Earth on a flat surface. Different map projections, influenced by politics and other factors, have their own strengths and limitations. It's essential to be aware of these distortions and use maps as models that provide valuable information rather than exact mirrors of reality. So, the next time you use a map, remember to explore, question, and appreciate the fascinating art and science of cartography!

Johnson's version of the Mercator map, made in 1862. The cartographer's choice was to center the map on the Americas

You will notice this map is centered on the Pacific Ocean. This map is from Japan, which is the reason it is Pacific Centered

Check out this amazing site where you can see the true size of countries compared to others! 

Information compiled in this site come from the following sources; British Museum, Metropolitan Museum of Art, Smithsonian Institute, Brooklyn Museum of Art, Acropolis Museum, Encyclopedia Britannica, Egypt Time Travel, Journey to Egypt, Getty Institute, Boston Museum of Fine Art 

If you have edits you would like to suggest, please email Michael.Veley@ship.k12.pa.us