Remember, extraction depends on coffee ground size, tamping pressure, pressure of machine, the amount of coffee you use and heat applied (water temperature as well as how fast the water is heated in the case of stove-top makers) -- if you
under-extract coffee (too fast) => sour, acidic
over-extract coffee (too slow) => bitter, no finer coffee tones
error: Finely ground like for an espresso machine
correct: Coarsely ground (but finer than for French press)
error: Tamping down like for a higher pressure espresso machine
correct: Loosely fill
error: Piling a peaked mountain of coffee grounds in the funnel (8) -- when you screw on the top/coffee collector (4) , the grounds essentially get tamped down, which is not good (see previous)
correct: Just leveled off to height of the funnel (8).
error: On high
correct: medium-low for slow percolation
Related to heat, but also on how long you voluntarily leave it on the stove:
error: Forgetting about it or not noticing that the water has percolated through and letting the coffee start boiling
correct: Take the maker off before the liquid starts bubbling -- keeping the lid open
error: Not stirring
correct: Stir it...if you want a homogeneous coffee! The first drops are the most concentrated. If you don't stir it, it will remain at the bottom.
Best tutorial on how to properly use your stovetop espresso maker from Illy coffee: