In 1958, retiring UCC president, Richard Hurd, donated the Bonnie Pipers Challenge pin to be competed for by curlers with less than five years experience, later changed to seven years experience. At some point, it was no longer a challenge, or limited to curlers with a certain number of years of curling, but became a league for experienced skips to introduce newer curlers to league play. In 2017, the medal was retired. In 2025, it was played in the later weeks of the second half, with inexperienced skips being mentored by more experienced skips
When Monday, second half
Heather Dockstader
In 2025, the Bonnie Piper was revived
2025: Linda Krumme, Cindy Brown, Courtney Hance, M.J. Walsh
In 2017, the Bonnie Piper was retired
2016: Michelle MacEnroe, Jan Rishel, Tami Dunnigan, Dawn Lazovik*
2015: Brenda Citriniti, Knyoca Law, Vicki Sheardown, Toni Roskinski
from 2011-2014, the All-American replaced the Bonnie Piper
2010: Cindy Brown, Knyoca Law, Peggy Pratt, Jackie Strife
2009: Laura Jacon, Melon Sofinski, Carrie Casab, Dawn Scherer
2008: Susan Williams, Cindy Brown, Clare Bareiss, Liz Nolan
2007: Susan Williams, Colleen Welch, Linda Kenney, Melissa Foote*
2006: Melon Sofinski, Cheri Gaebel, Claire Bareiss, Sarah Hapanowicz*
2005: Cindy Brown, Kathy Palazzoli, Lisa Magnarelli, Pat Milhalko*
2004: Diane Higgins, Laura Jacon, Cheri Gaebel, Edie Savett
2003: Kathy Palazzoli, Liz Williams, Kim Freeley, Cameo Voltz*
2002: Sue Williams, Mary Sexton, Jeanne Galvin, Barb Mazzotta
2001: Caitlin Costello, Marie Costello, Cindy Brown, Marty Jones
2000: Caitlin Costello, Donna Evans, Barb Felice, Barb Kicinski
1999: Cindy Brown, Pam Jones, Terri Flemma, Jane Mahoney
1998: Caitlin Costello, Eydie Savett, Joyce Tencza, Pat Zumpano
1997: Erlene Daley, Donna Evans, Joyce Tencza, Mary Hopsicker*
1996: Chris Gleason, Eydie Savett, Marty Jones, Cindy Brown*
1995: FIRE
1994: Erlene Daley, June Balduf, Jacquelyn Schmidt, Lisa Firsching
1993: Chris Gleason, Peggy Caneen, Deb Morehouse, Jane Mahoney
1992: Diane Caine, Erlene Daley, Linda Whitney, Jeanne Galvin*
1991: Colleen Welch, June Balduf, Betty Reilly, Eileen Christianson*
1990: Martha Hoffman, Erin Clark, Michelle Whitney*
1989: Ylva Cortright, Robbie Trosset, Mary Ann Knapp, Marj Moore*
1988: Jean Zulak, Ginger Zillioux, Linda Rance, Colleen Welch
1987: Diane Pirnie, Donna Yando, Fern Capstraw, Carol Scarlino*
1986: Sharon Evans, Cindy Brown, Diane York, Jackie Hogan
1983-84: Angela Nassar, Linda Martin, Molly Provosnik, Jo Zangrilli
1982-83: S. Osio, M. Curri, B. Clark, B. Brennan
1981: Barbara Kogut, Flo Korrie, Kathy Howard, Mollie Provasnik
1980: Ruth Kuchler, Kitty Griffin, Jean Dutton, Rugh Ridgway
1979: Mary Ruth Callan, Rosemary Diehl, Ruth Kuchler, Joyce Shaffer
1978-79: Jean Axelson, Carol Lobalbo, Gail Macner, Carol Bremer
1977-78: Val Clark, Candy Jacobs, Linda Fanning, Flo Korrie
1976-77: Rose Mary Diehl, Val Clark, Kitty Griffin, Robbie Trossett
* first year curler indicated when known