Shop Highlights: A do-it-all bakery with exceptional baked goods and bagels

Total Package Review: I was not expecting the experience I got from this wonderful bakery. They are a full service bakery that also happen to bake their own NY style bagels. We got the last sesame bagel of the day and DAMN was it good. High density double sided seed coverage, proper crust and chew, hand rolled and very likely boiled. They offer simple egg and cheese and CC options. The bagel was easily rawdog-able. 

"10 out of 10 bagel" -Ali O'Rourke

"Putting anything on this bagel would ruin it!" -Taylor Skorik

Total Package Score: 6 / 10

Bagel Score: 9 / 10

Shop Ambiance: Located in what seems to be a retired fire department but perhaps that's just because it's painted red. Right on the main drag in Milford just blocks from the train station. Baked goods on display behind glass and open air bakery where you can watch the bakers work their magic. Plenty of outdoor seating but none indoors when we visited. 

Personal History with Shop: Ate here in 2024 with Taylor Skorik and Ali O'Rourke on our weekend trip to visit New Haven.

Ownership: One-of-a-kind Small Business 

Page last updated November 2024