Profiles in Courage Essay
Peer Response
1. Does it read well?
2. Does the essay revolve around an incident that's told well?
3. Is the narrative interesting?
4. What mechanical improvements can be made (spelling and grammar)?
5. Are there 20 citations?
6. Are the citations varied or all the same?
7. Are there 10 sources?
8. Are these sources academically reliable?
9. How would you improve the paper if your were writing it?
10. Suggest ways to make it more interesting.
11. Is courage defined?
12. How was this person courageous?
13. Do you understand the courage of the paper's subject?
14. Is the Kennedy book cited?
15. Does the paper make sense.
- - - - - -
16. Are there at least 20 superscripts?
17. Do they correctly correspond to the footnotes/endnotes?
18. Is there an alphabetized Bibliography?
19. Is Chicago 1 (notes/bibliography) done correctly?
20. What format changes need to be made?