Go to Newer version
................
OLDER VERSION:
"5thCommandment.com": 'Honor thy father & mother...': the purchasers of the system produced as a result of the project would be children of the elderly, clients acting on behalf of their parents.
The Goal: Catalyzing the disruption of elder-care via coordinating the existing efforts of many teams worldwide in order to bring about the creation of a complete integrated aging-in-place system.
Initially: for those elderly who do not need constant medical attention and who have a child involved in their care, thus enabling them to stay at home instead of being in an 'institution', and without the need of a live-in aide.
The problem: Some industries are disrupted by a single innovation, some by combining a few. However it seems to me that disruption of elderly-care (for those in the above-mentioned category) will require the combined work of perhaps hundreds of entrepreneurs working in very many countries. Also, after all the needed product exist, there will be required great additional effort to mesh all the hundreds of products into the seamlessly-workable system it will have to be in order to be adopted disruptively.
The fact that so many teams are working independently can brings about unnecessary duplication of effort as well as leaving some niches unfilled. Also, solving problems in different ways and with different standards complicates the creation of a complete integrated system, and all this may add years to the time when such a system emerges.
Two solution for this problem in smart-homes:
Project: eHUB (e for 'elderly'; elderHUB, 'respect your elders'):
A website-platform serving as a hub to coordinate the efforts of entrepreneurs worldwide so that the combination of all their products will constitute a complete elderly-aide replacement-system.
The hub: An interactive, cooperative site to coordinate between researchers, inventors & developers, organizations & government departments etc, funciotning as an integrator for the ecosystem to provide a solution for the client. The HUB will bring about:
1. identification of the needed devices;
2. coordination of those developing the devices, apps etc;
3. coordination to produce seamless integration of all the devices into a self-sufficient disruptive system.
The first task: Identifying and highlighting the needs:
a. all parts of a home where some assistance is generally required would be indicated in a schematic of a home/apartment;
b. all parts of the time-cycle would be noted along with the need at that time (and place);
c. all activity-types would be listed along with the need of an elderly person in that connection.
The above would be accomplished via guidance by experienced caregivers and other professionals.
Step two: Programatically compiling a list of needed hardware devices, software, and services (separately and in combination) in order to provide the types of assistance outlined in step 1, and coordination of their development.
A database can be constructed of the components, allowing lists to be compiled based on the room they are designed for, which of the five senses they relate to, keywords for the types of activity which are relevant etc, the time of day or day of the week or holiday-need etc.
Entrepreneurs can enter - at the appropriate location in the schematic or time-schedule or activity-type - information about their ongoing-projects, and coordinate between them to take on specific niches, until all is eventually accounted for.
The Illustration is not related to this project, it is merely intended to demonstrate the type of diagram whch would be created for the 'place' needs (in addition one would have the 'time-slot' needs: the diagram is from http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/graphic/2010/05/05/GR2010050505248.html?tid=a_inl
Goal: an apartment, home, or even a ‘granny-flat’ within a larger apartment or home, equipped with a complete self-contained system.
Example of time-chart: Interventions which are generally required for elderly people when:
Models of overall-projects with clear-cut final goals:
A more modest model which was perhaps not entirely premeditated but has nevertheless already been implemented: creating computer & software-systems, as well as telecommunication infrastructure and various hardware devices to replace the need for a receptionist, secretary and book-keeper (photocopy machine, video door entry intercom system, email and appointment software etc), thus enabling the transition from a three-person firm in an office-building, to a one-person home-office.
Initial stage: limited to the simplest case of need: a system for elderly people who:
a. are mostly capable of living on their own but require some assistance (and do not need constant immediate medical personnel nearby);
b.have at least one person willing and able to be involved directly in being part of the system, but remotely (they are notified by devices in the older person's home as needed etc: ‘virtually-assisted living’, enabling children living far away, or remote hired staff to be in charge).
Funding for the HUB project: Governments and insurance companies which spend vast amounts on elder-care for the population indicated above can potentially achieve significant savings by funding a project which catalyzes the development of such an integrated system years ahead of when it would otherwise emerge.
Eventually the purchasers, eg the insurance companies, will want metrics (perhaps via an independent source); even if most of the overlap between companies providing the individual products is reduced there probably will be competing components, and so I can use different equivalent components in systems filling the same need to test their relative efficacy to provide a relative-metric.
Potential clients for the complete system:
The above possibilities suggest various paths towards a business model to support the creation and maintenance of the envisioned 'hub'.
identify challenges and needs via input from those in the field...
Note: In Israel, as a testing ground: approach Meuchedet Zahav, which is actually an insurance policy paying for foreign workers aides, and perhaps a government figure (bituach leumi pays but they may not have motivation to reduce costs; perhaps someone in the finance ministry, but they are focused on short term, worried about elections in 2 years, not interested in a system which will save money in 5 years.).
Once there is 'approval' in theory for insurance reimbursement for an integrated system, approach government representatives.
Consult with local EU representative to ask to whom to apply for a grant to create the HUB.
Hire a business development expert to handle more of this.
In preparation for creating the HUB, consult with companies to see thier reaction and get thier input - they will be motivated to be part of a government-recognized insurance-reimbursable system.
A description of the envisioned hub: towards a device dream-team to disrupt elderly-care:
1.The site matches existing products to the relevant interventions on the list, and the result is indicated on the diagram and time-chart.
[Compiling a comprehensive list of all the 'interventions' which are usually made for older people (in the targeted-category) by an aide, or by an adult-child caretaker, or by a nursing home employee; this list is compiled by professionals and by children with experience care-taking for their parent; the information is provided by them either via a paid consultation, or is volunteered, uploaded when they browse the site (perhaps limited to moderators authorized by site staff, or by an algorithm, eg by recognizing email addresses as being from reputable institutions) Appropriate professionals, institutions, and government agencies can be solicited, requested to browse and provide the needed information. Then: List all relevant existing hardware and software products which enable a specific intervention to be done without an aide: automatically, or by the elderly person themselves, or by their adult child or aide remotely].
collaborative annotating software for HUB diagram Usage Guide for Confluence 5.X – Creately : Support Community
The Best Flowchart and Diagramming Apps of 2017 - Software Reviews
Streamline Your Creative Workflow | Filestage
Visio Alternatives: 10 Best Diagramming Software
Drawing Flowcharts Online Using Creately Diagramming Tool - YouTube
How to Edit a Creately Diagram - Experts Knowledge Base - Experts
collaboratively annotating a diagram - Google Search
2. For those interventions for which there is no existing product, people are invited to suggest possible mechanisms, on the site. Entrepreneurs can indicate which one they are working on, organizations and government can offer incentives or funding, and teams can be formed as needed.
3. Ways are suggested for all the existing and proposed systems to be integrated into one complete system, to be packaged to be sold to the children of the the elderly. This can be accomplished in coordination with those who created each individual component of the system. Entrepreneurs can indicate which integration-approach they are working on, teams can be formed as needed, etc.
…
Tasks
· Craft an animation indicating the operation of the elements of the system through a complete 24/7 cycle.
· Coordinate the creation of an actual full scale model, and its use with volunteer subjects.
Steps: consult with insurance companies and government, then see if can get a grant, if so, build the HUB, and then invite companies to come aboard.
......
Algorithm: The situation of the client is input to the Site, and using the database of existing components an Algorithm or on-Site expert matches each client to a complete system geared for their needs, ie the many specific individual components they will need, given their specific situation.
........
....
Alternate applications of the HUB model
The software for the HUB, the ecosystem-approach it involves and its business model can perhaps be applied towards creating systems designed as a complete solution for other situations:
...
Towards possible business models
..................
As mentioned above, potential clients for the complete system can be:
Possible governmental partners/grant sources:
The Chinese government may support developing this platform since it is struggling with the new demand created by a number of factors: the one-child policy has led to the full burden of caring for two elderly parents falling on one person's shoulders, leading to increased stress and loss of work-time leading to decreased productivity, and the same policy has also led to there being only one working person in the economy to provide the government with the tax-base to support an additional two non-working adults. Also of course, the Chinese are now facing the same issues already common in the West - people living longer, and the greater expectations by the new young and middle-aged middle class that their government owes their parents reasonable care.
The Japanese have a shrinking, ageing population, and have turned to robotics as a partial solution both in industry and housework. Since there are mechanical aspects of daily life which may not be sufficiently handled by software and electronic devices - such as mobility, fall-protection and the type of use of ones arms which an arthritic elderly person might find impossible - this can be a very valuable aspect of the eventual disruptive system. Also, the Traditional Japanese respect for the elderly would motivate interest in the goal of the project. Perhaps therefore the Japanese government may show interest.
The EU has an ageing shrinking population and skyrocketing health costs, and of course the US has its own version of the problem, and both are natural potential sources of funding for such an initiative.
………………………………
For related ‘hub-type’ projects see for example:
1. http://newsnetwork.mayoclinic.org/discussion/mayo-clinic-creates-healthy-aging-and-independent-living-lab/ The Healthy Aging and Independent Living (HAIL) Program within the Kogod Center on Aging designs, prototypes and pilots new services and technologies that can help keep older adults healthy and independent for as long as possible.
This research effort includes developing advanced technologies to promote independence; monitoring and predicting changes in function and clinical status; enacting and coordinating community-based pharmacological, physical and provider interventions; and educating patients and caregivers. (I am in correspondence with the HAIL Program director, Nathan LeBrasseur.)
2. http://www.aplaceformom.com/blog/6-30-15-technology-for-independent-living/ ; http://simply-home.com/blog/
…………………….
B) Website to enable children of the aging to jointly plan to create appropriate housing for parents with similar situations and needs:
…………..
C) Minimizing disorientation in the elderly when placing them in a new environment by replicating the features of a home-environment most crucial to retaining a sense of familiarity
· For elderly people being moved from a large home far from their grown children to a smaller place close to them, or even in a granny-flat located in their home, in which case one can design the space carefully and utilize some of the actual objects from their original home.
· For hospitals, where large screens can be fed the relevant information specific to the patient in that room to lessen the chance of hospital delerium.
· The intermediate case of nursing homes, where one can place both screens and fixed objects, some from the inhabitants original home.
· In terms of objects: perhaps miniaturized replicas can suffice, though they are smaller and only symbolic, for example a toy-sized couch which is the same color and shape of a beloved old one in their original home. Or perhaps a specially-designed wall-hanging collage of familiar color schemes and shapes to evoke the subconscious feeling induced when being in a particular room
· One needs to obtain detailed relevant information about the interior of an elderly person's home in order to determine the factors which should be replicated. For example the layout, amount and relative sizes of rooms, ceiling height, window placement, amount and type of lighting, specific wall-hangings and displayed photos, furniture, favorite displayed objects, wall-paint-color, street sounds etc etc.
· Then to use various techniques to identify and re-create the minimum necessary for that person to feel comfortable and be less disoriented in their new surroundings.
http://newsnetwork.mayoclinic.org/discussion/mayo-clinic-creates-healthy-aging-and-independent-living-lab/ The Healthy Aging and Independent Living (HAIL) Program(I am in correspondence with the HAIL Program director, Nathan LeBrasseur: LeBrasseur, Nathan K., M.S., Ph.D.)
Prof LeBrasseur, hello: Perhaps you would know where I could find relevant research on this topic (the features of a home-environment most crucial to replicate when moving an elderly person).
His reply: Interesting, Avi, but I simply don't have recommendations for resources for you. We've started thinking more carefully about the built environment, but not in this context. Good luck! -Nathan
…………………END of A), B), C) ……………………
More detail below
[1] The main elements which will be missing are: 1. the personal warmth, the fulltime human-presence rather than automated monitoring+child’s occasional visual remote monitoring as will be the case with this system; 2. the ability to render assistance physically, whether helping to walk, or to carry or to pick up off the floor (like the robots being developed in Japan etc), to accompany to a doctor or to a store etc. These will have to wait for more advanced systems.
......
................
http://www.pcworld.com/article/2925232/internet-of-things/want-smarthome-devices-to-get-along-get-the-industry-to-do-it-first.html
smarthomegallery.com/insights/integrating-smart-home-devices/
INTEGRATING SMART HOME DEVICES. by George McKechnie. The ads make it sound so simple: just download an app or two to your phone or tablet, plug in ...
www.momentumenergy.com.au/habitat/at-home/integrate-your-homes-smart-devices/
Learn the ins and outs of integrating your household's smart devices without needing to be a rocket scientist, and make your smart home as smart as it should ...
https://www.cnet.com/topics/smart-home/best-smart-home-devices/
Jun 27, 2017 - CNET editors' reviews of the best smart home devices include ... Its simple interface,integration with HomeKit, and reliability earned it an ...
https://www.pcmag.com › Reviews › Consumer Electronics › Smart Home
Jun 21, 2017 - Alexa works with a number of smart home devices directly, as well as with ... The latest version integrates tightly with Apple devices, but still has ...
www.hongkiat.com/blog/smart-devices-home-automation/
Smart Home devices also can let you monitor the safety of your home, unlock doors ... integratedinside the device that allows you to view your house remotely.
www.computerweekly.com/feature/A-guide-to-smart-home-automation
Unless it is a new build, the challenge in creating a smart home is that technology must ... a new industry is emerging to integrate computer control into the home. ... Every device is connected; Everydevice has some level of intelligence; The ...
www.pcworld.com/.../want-smarthome-devices-to-get-along-get-the-industry-to-do-it...
May 20, 2015 - IoT may simplify home automation, but not without a lot of hard work behind ... The issue of device integration loomed over discussions at the ...
blog.z-wave.com/integration-of-smart-home-devices-can-save-homeowners-money
For instance, electricity powers dozens of machines in our homes, including our HVAC systems, cooking appliances, refrigerators, dishwashers, and an ...
Learn the ins and outs of integrating your household's smart devices without needing to be a rocket scientist, and make your smart home as smart as it should be. http://www.momentumenergy.com.au/habitat/at-home/integrate-your-homes-smart-devices/
https://www.cnet.com/topics/smart-home/best-smart-home-devices/
https://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,2817,2410889,00.asp
https://www.einfochips.com/blog/addressing-smart-home-automation-challenges-using-devops/
https://www.cbinsights.com/blog/smart-home-market-map-company-list/
http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/6781157/?reload=true
http://www.quest-trendmagazine.com/en/articles-archive/fdt-group.html
https://www.cerner.com/solutions/device-connectivity
.....
..
See below:
o section A(4 pages): what is needed in general
o section G (12 pages): Existing (already available) assistive tech: devices & systems
......................................................
…………Now returning to the beginning, more in detail………..
A) Proposing a few specific devices, including a 'reminder-system' for the memory-impaired:
(4 pages): The devices which are needed: Assistive technology - devices to help with everyday living
focusing on adult children and their aging parents (“boomers and seniors”).
Creating an “Online real-time remotely-monitored & controlled smart parent’s-home”
When someone rings the front-door bell, the child is notified in real-time with a special tone, a flashing icon etc (on their work computer system and smart-phone), and can press the icon to see who is at the door, and can speak with them. They also can have control over the door-lock, to be able to admit people (visitors when the parent is ill, a doctor, someone to clean while the parent is sleeping or away, or an electrician etc). Also if there is a security alarm system on the door, it notifies the child, who can also then communicate with police or the security company etc. (Similarly for balcony doors.)
If it is a private home: back door etc is controlled this way. Camera on roof has 360 degree view of the house’s surroundings. Motion sensor installed.
Bathroom/shower-room door: voice communication-system in/near bathroom to establish if there is need to remotely-unlock the door.
Drone in home can deliver items to parent in bed. Pills etc. Guided via video + remote.
If child spots items on the floor which can be a trip-hazard, they can remotely operate a device similar to a vacuum cleaner robot to remove it.
Perhaps it can also approach a parent on the floor after a fall to make communication simpler.
Phone-numbers of neighbors and relatives, emergency services, doctors etc, all appear when the emergency button on the device is activated/pressed. Also: icons for their ID numbers, medical records etc.
Certain windows have electrically-controlled mechanical openers, which can be operated remotely. Either to obtain fresh air, or if there is gas in the kitchen, or in case of fire etc.
To prevent flooding when parent forgets to shut off the water: a device which detects overflow of kitchen & bathroom sinks and bathtub/shower etc. All faucets including shower have off-switches connected to the handles, which can be operated via remote-control.
Same for any gas range, or other electrical devices – excess gas notifies child, and they can switch it off, or there is an automated system to do this and the child is notified as it occurs. They can then open the windows remotely and then turn the gas back on.
Electricity: fuse-switches can be controlled. If there is a fire, all electricity can be closed, which then causes the emergency lighting to go on. Child is notified as this is occurring, and the relevant emergency phone numbers and neighbor-contacts appear and pressing them calls them.
Heating and cooling system of the house can be controlled (easiest is central heating A/C, but also if it is separate AC’s and radiators etc).
Special mailbox installed with video and remotely-controlled separator arm, to be able to see what has arrived.
If necessary, device to melt snow near front door (or even to clear a path; or phone connection to people nearby who can do it).
For specific tasks:
· Creating menus for meals based on nutritional needs and personal tastes.
· Before a meal, a menu can be posted to appear on the elderly person’s kitchen wall
· Inventory: some feedback is needed as to what is in the pantry (video cameras installed inside the closet, with flash-light source so as to create a weekly shopping list; perhaps grocery items and other foods can be ordered online by the child, and delivered to the parent.
· There can also be reminders as to which stores sell which items, and where the stores are located.
· Reminders about to do list for the week and day.
· Assistance making calls, with access to the elderly parent’s telephone, so that one can remotely-control the number being dialed. Access to the voice mail.
· Remote access to the computer and entertainment system: the child can create a day-program with youtube exercise videos playing which the parent can join with, then news, then a favorite show or movie, then a documentary, then set it up to read and send email, make video-calls to friends etc, all via remote or with remote assistance.
· Daily schedule, and special days: [eg for RR erev shabbos buy JP, make cholent/egg&onion, need also recipe, and reminder on Th for shopping list to include Heinz B Beans etc, and check other ingredients. Remind which helpers come when, which days at which times she goes to a lecture, to call Fanny before to accompany heretc.][& to say: next week you have the x wedding, in two weeks y is coming as guest, in 4 weeks in tubshvat and then purim and pesach].
…..
Even self-sufficient elderly may at specific points of the day/evening need (or benefit from) some moral-support, company or guidance. For example when eating meals, they can benefit from guidance as to what to eat, where implements and food items are located or how to prepare certain foods.
…
When there is a task to be done, or an emergency, all the children are notified, and as soon as the task is accepted by the child whose turn it is or who is responsible for that category of task, the rest of the children are notified (for example: emergency tasks appear as a red icon, non-emergency tasks appear as a blue icon and when someone accepts the task by pressing the icon it turns green).
Some or all of the remote tasks can be handled by people hired for the purpose.
There can be an entire system of ‘virtual staff’ handling the tasks for several elderly people.
…..
...................
Device: 24/7 hardware/software audio-visual ‘companion’
For the elderly, but purchased and installed at the request of their adult children.
The children are the actual clients, they control the device, and receive automated reports.
Can also be for various non-elderly impaired adults: settings specifies the 'disability' to be overcome, ie whether it is for hearing/speech-impaired, blind etc
Geared to a new demographic: reasonably tech-savvy children of aging parents, who have money for gadgets, and some time to spend on care-taking, but do not live in the same home, or even the same city as their parent.
Settings appropriate for these categories:
· One parent living alone;
· Both parents when they are both infirm;
· an elderly person taking care of an ailing spouse - to remove the care-taking burden from them;
· when there is a paid-caretaker in the home: to assist them; to catch abuse [search: "caretaker caught on video abusing", see eg this]; to compile a record for the use of a medical practitioner.
Two types of device are integrated:
· Accessed by the elderly person: has information input by the children, or by their surroundings, which is fed to them via audio (an earphone or aloud), or visually (via a tablet, or a watch-screen, or a wall-mounted monitor etc);
· Accessed by the children rather than by their elderly parent: Monitors the elderly person, with software to process the input in order to present relevant information to the children in real time and as periodic reports.
What technology is involved:
· wearable-tech
· medical-device remote-reporting
· web-cam for remote monitoring
· a "smart home" (smart-home remote-controls for children of elderly)
· subject-mounted camera
· inegrated calendar, to-do list, GPS, photo-recognition, navigation/maps
· remote-viewing & control of a different computer
· photo-sharing
· AI systems
· Automated study-aides and test-taking
Some business and marketing aspects:
Can also be or involve a business for 'outsourced' trained human remote-monitors.
Perhaps some of the expenses can be insurance-reimbursable.
An associated site can allow people to find each other to organize a group to share caretaking, ie for people whose parent has a similar situation such as:
· they live in the same city/neighborhood/building
· they have the same level of disability
· the same temperament, or the same interests
· speak the same language, have the same religion or culture etc
· they have the same set of devices/systems installed in their home
Associated devices:
Tablet on wall of each of the children (and possibly others: friends or relatives or a profesisonal:
· to see parent;
· to be updated with info
· to see to do list
· to see website below
· etc.
Website to coordinate their activities, division of responsibilities, each does one or more of these:
· medical/dental/pharmaceutical/vision/hearing/physical therapy/social worker;
· finances, bank accounts, benefits, bill payments etc;
· arranging shopping, entertainment, outdoor activities;
· assistants, cleaning, repairs, installing & maintaining communication systems;
· etc.
Software to display transcript of doctor visits, with medical input and recommended actions to take re tests, x-rays, procedures, pills, physical therapy etc.
Children can check off the to-do list and their name appears next to it, with their comments and reports, updates, for accomplishing that task.
24/7 monitoring and activity-reminders: from sleep-time, morning wakeup …to pills before bedtime
Night:
Sleep-lab: Video while sleeping, software detects motions, sounds (snoring, talking during sleep, sighing etc), determines when the eyes are open for extended periods while in bed, detects when leaving the bed… After the person has left the bed and stayed away and is active elsewhere in the room/home, a record of the nigh (time in bed) is created, and a periodic report (weekly, monthly etc) is compiled.
Perhaps sensor on the person’s head can detect neural activity changes (such as during REM, dreaming), and determine the quality of their sleep.
Report is available to children.
Near toilet: door-opening or motion sensor (can be located outside the bathroom), with log of how many times used during day, night, and how long spent there. Report is available to children.
Shower Audio-sensor detects use, and possible calls for help.
Morning:
· Device near bed can determine when the person has awoken even if they are still lying in bed: it tracks eye opening, eye motion, head and body motion (perhaps eventually has sensor on the person’s head and can detect neural activity changes).
· As soon as they are awake, the device ‘whisper’ to them in their ear, or says out loud and or displays on a monitor visible from the bed: “today is DAY OF WEEK, DATE, YEAR”, reminds which pills need to be taken and at what times of the day; reads the to do list, and reminders of what is expected to happen that day (your aide will come today at 3pm, your daughter will call at 4 to ask you about…, tomorrow is the wedding of X, yesterday you took care of Y, and were at Dr K, who said you will need a flu shot soon etc).
· Reminder is given to eat breakfast, even the menu they prefer. Smart refrigerator can be integrated.
· Meals can be pre-packaged and labeled, with large letter labels and an audio guide to take out the correct one. Similarly for other meals.
· A smart pill-box or a video monitor determines whether the day’s pills have been taken.
· Gas detector determines when have turned off the gas, correlates to the presence of flame on the stove.
· Children can remotely turn on AC, set timers, etc;
· A video-pan throughout the house to check if night-light is on near bedroom, to check cleanliness of kitchen and bathroom, to see whether pills were taken at night.
· The fire-alarm, smoke-detector, kitchen cooking-gas-detector: all notify children, who are given the relevant local emergency phone numbers etc, and who have emergency override switch control (to turn off the gas etc)
· When going somewhere by public transport (some of this can be not only for the elderly): gps tells you (can be discretely in your ear) when you are close to the destination, why you are going there, and what you need to say, and do.
· This information can be fed in by the children, or by one’s self earlier in the day etc, or on a previous day, set to play back on that day and half hour before the time of the appointment or when gps detects travel to that location etc.
…..
http://www.top5reviewed.com/the-5-best-calendar-clocks-for-the-elderly/
………
Other Devices
Record of a doctor-visit: audio or text: sent to the children, with option for them to be ‘present in real-time. Information re tests to be taken, specialists to be consulted, prescriptions, can also perhaps be eventually tied to one’s medical file; re medications: notification to pharmacy, or even via a chip on the pill container, or scanning the bar code of the medication into the device etc.
Electric window-opener: for airing it out, to cool the house, and if house has gas or smoke: controlled by remote.
Wearable med-tech for health-monitoring remotely by children.
Wearable device like Apple-watch, giving them needed cues etc, and also detects falls (via accelerometer , gps etc) and getting lost, gives direciotns and prompts according to the present surroundigs.
a. http://www.imedicalapps.com/2013/01/device-elderly-signal-alert-fall-sensor-gps/.
b. http://smartwatches.org/learn/best-senior-wearables-gps-trackers/
c. http://www.livescience.com/43016-best-medical-alert-systems.html
e. a counter to detect bathroom use frequency: In doorway or nearby: proximity-detector or electric-eye, heat detector, linked to counter) how many times the bathroom door opened, or the toilet flushed etc, with a record to keep track, to see if there is a sudden change.
f. Alarmed pillbox, to alert/remind the remote caretaker when pills are to be taken, and notifies when one has not been taken (perhaps by detecting the presence of the individual pills? also: the video-capture of the camera near the pill box can be consulted)
g. After recording conversation with doctor during visit (if doctor permits) or afterwards: software keeps track of questions to ask, recognizes relevant medical terms, identifies using intelligent phrase-detecton the issues which the doctor said are to be followed up on, lists the medications and tests recommended during the visit etc. [This can be much simpler if the doctor participates/cooperates by using specific catch-phrases to alert the software.]
These may not yet exist, need to be created:
· Software like ‘team-viewer’ etc to enable a remote-viewer to assist their elderly parent in using their home computer, eg to use the internet, for watching online-TV, videos, writing/editing, viewing photos etc: On-screen there are two concentric "windows". The outer 'window' shows explanations, with a live-chat with the child, settings, and icons to choose the desired application; the inner window displays the current application, making it availabel for use by the parent: eg MSWord, email, Web browsing, viewing photos/videos etc. The outer window has explanaitons and capabilities with various levels for different ability, and can change with time, etc.
· Videos to watch, either by the parent alone, or with them in real-time: Child can arrange the 'favorites', and there is a 'recently watched' list.
· Also: can set Youtube exercise videos to be watched while parent does the exercise along wiht the youtube intsructor/class, maybe while they are on video-chat so they can see the parent if they are doing the exercise correctly and safely, and the parent sees the child in the chat windo on the outer rim window.
.............
……
Reviews, business analysis, government programs, organizations. actual homes as examples, (and a diagram, plus some videos)
Business analysis: http://www.mckinsey.com/industries/healthcare-systems-and-services/our-insights/spurring-the-market-for-high-tech-home-health-care Technology-enabled home health care should be thriving in the United States What’s holding the market back? We observe a daunting array of financial and operational barriers, including the misalignment of incentives between payers and providers, the need to demonstrate a strong clinical value proposition, and the problem of designing attractive, easy-to-use products that facilitate adoption by patients.
........
Israel: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/joan-gage/high-tech-advances-to-help-seniors_b_4843554.html 02/24/2014 06:30 pm ET | Updated Apr 26, 2014 High-Tech Advances to Help Seniors: Scary or Reassuring? In Israel the Senior Network service is free to seniors who want it. Someone will pay a site visit to the home to connect the computer to the Watchitoo video platform. Watchitoo was developed by Rony Zarom, a former Israeli paratrooper who created the technology so he could visit with his young son via video when he was traveling, and they could watch YouTube clips together. Watchitoo is now based in New York and combines HD video conferencing, streaming and multimedia collaboration on a Web browser platform. Yale University uses it for virtual classrooms and some TV networks use it for “after parties” following a TV show—so that viewers can discuss the program they just saw and ask questions of the stars.
Watchitoo and the Senior Network in Israel are just one of the ways I’ve learned that people around the world are creating new technology that will help in eldercare. Here are some more:
...
Actually creatying a hitech home for elderly: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/technology/2422167.stm Tuesday, 12 November, 2002, Hi-tech homes to help the elderly Ten homes were packed with sensors linked to a base station where the welfare of elderly residents could be monitored unobtrusively.The long term goal of the institute is to develop technology systems that can improve social and health care for vulnerable people outside of hospital.The Huntleigh Research Institute has launched a project aimed at providing hi-tech homes for the elderly.
....
A) Proposal: Branding Israel as the hub for projects of this type
AR: Is there any interest on the part of a governmental ministry, or some organization, in doing this? Is there any need for something like this, or a benefit to Israel or to the project? Would it be easier to obtain development grants?
..............
Gadget review: http://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/columnist/2014/05/11/tech-gadgets-for-the-elderly/8804955/ (watch 0:45-1:13)
Low-tech: https://www.openplacement.com/community/blog/retrofitting-versus-assisted-living/ According to the National Association of Home Builders, based out of Washington D.C., the primary retrofits that are necessary to the systems in the house, such as security and electrical systems, to create a safe living space for seniors aiming to age in place are:
· Light switches by each entrance to halls and rooms;Light receptacles with at least two bulbs in vital places (exits, bathroom).
· Light switches, thermostats, and other environmental controls placed in accessible locations no higher than 48 in. from floor.
· Electrical outlets 15 in. on center from floor; may need to be closer than 12 ft apart.
· Clear access space of 30 in. by 48 in. in front of switches and controls. Rocker or touch light switches.
· Audible & visual strobe light system to indicate doorbell, telephone, or smoke or carbon monoxide detectors.
· security/intercom system which can be monitored, with the heating, air conditioning, and lighting, from any TV in the house.
· Easy-to-see and read thermostats; Pre-programmed thermostats.
· Flashing porch light or 9-1-1 switch direct-wired to police, fire, and EMS (as option).
· slanted walkway rather than steps to use to enter and leave the house.
· “Telewellness” systems: reminders to take medicine, quick means to contact emergency services. cameras at floor level so that any falls can be seen by caregivers logging in from a distance, or shoes with GPS systems for seniors with Alzheimer’s that alert the police and/or caregivers when the senior has moved outside of an approved area.
Granny pods
see 1:10-1:36 for indoor tour (the rest is not neccessary to watch) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dIoqivTHS3Y
AARP, would they help? : http://www.aarp.org/home-garden/housing/info-10-2010/abcs_of_adus.html Prefab 'In-law' Cottages Mix High-tech Features, Comfort
https://www.ft.com/content/8a6a4960-c396-11e2-aa5b-00144feab7de (refers to http://www.eskaton.org/village-roseville.html)
http://www.countryliving.com/home-design/a37788/granny-pods/ The small dwelling is hooked up to the main home's existing sewer, water and power lines. Standard safety features include hand railings, defibrillators, first aid supplies, lighted floorboards and a soft floor to minimize damage from falls.
See diagram below: http://www.theblaze.com/news/2012/11/27/high-tech-granny-pods-allow-elderly-family-members-to-live-comfortably-in-a-backyard-cottage-for-125k/ High-Tech ‘Granny Pods’ Allow Elderly Family Members to Live Comfortably in a Backyard Cottage for $125K Washington Post reported that even the floor is specially designed to be cushioned in case someone falls. Several firms have entered the market for auxiliary dwelling units, or ADUs, as they’re known in the building industry. These include FabCab, a Seattle-based company that makes ADUs and full-size homes. Practical Assisted Living Solutions, or PALS, a firm based in Meriden, Conn., makes freestanding modules; and the Home Store, which is headquartered in Whately, Mass., sells modular “in-law” additions called “Elderly Cottage Housing Opportunity” additions.The company — N2Care — that creates the cottages was started by Rev. Kenneth J. Dupin. The Virginia Tech Corporate Research Center helped design them, according to the Post.
...........
http://hitechhomepros.com/assistive-domotics-elderly-care-givers/ Assistive Domotics for Elderly and Care Givers Assistive domotics is an application of home automation that focuses on making it possible for senior or physically challenged individuals to live at their home instead of a health care center. These items use Bluetooth sensing units to track movements in the home, or lack thereof, of elderly moms and dads. Sensing units affixed to any item, including pillboxes, doors, and keychains. GPS technology documents exact place details of the individual, logs activity, and reports it to a family member living somewhere else.
...
Would governments help?
Patients in Fylde and Wyre will be among the first to benefit from a major new drive to modernise how the NHS delivers care. The scheme was unveiled by NHS chief executive Simon Stevens at the World Economic Forum in Davos. ... items such as sensors and other wearable technologies to help people look after themselves in the home as well as smartphone apps.Peter Tinson, chief operating officer for the Fylde and Wyre Clinical Commissioning Group, which is teaming up with Lancashire Care NHS Foundation Trust, Lancaster Health Hub and Philips said: “We are delighted and excited by the opportunity this programme will provide to work with a leading technology company and be at the forefront of innovation in health and care services.
,........
http://www.ukauthority.com/news/2758/elderly-scots-offered-hi-tech-home-care Elderly Scots offered hi-tech home care
Scottish Government public health minister, Shona Robison, said, "Investing in telecare is vital if we are to remain ahead of the game in meeting the needs of our growing older population. Telecare can help older people remain independent in their own homes - something we must explore further if we are to rise to the challenges we face."
.......
HiTech homes for people with disabilities rather than aging: organizations: http://fortune.com/2015/02/01/disabled-smart-homes/ Living Resources, a New York nonprofit that works with people who have disabilities, recently built a smart home for six people. It included lights, fans, blinds and TVs that residents can operate from their iPad, as well as stoves that shut off automatically when there’s no activity. The entire house cost $600,000 while the technology alone cost about $100,000 said Fred Erlich, the organization's CEO.
Tunnel to Towers, a nonprofit which works with disabled war veterans, runs a program to build smart homes for disabled war veterans. It spends $400,000 to $500,000 per house, using grants and donations, to make them more livable for veterans who are missing limbs.
https://www.ageinplacetech.com/ Industry Market Trends, Research & Analysis;
https://www.ageinplacetech.com/blog/ces-2015-part-3-3-six-more-innovations-useful-older-adults Aging In Place Technology Watch
Review of some gadgets at the 2015 tech show http://www.orlandosentinel.com/health/senior-helpers/os-senior-inhome-care-agency-new-hightech-products-and-innovations-focus-on-senior-needs-20150116-story.html Senior In-Home Care Agency: New High-Tech Products and Innovations Focus on Senior Needs
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-3068832/High-tech-sensors-help-kids-eye-aging-parents.html The ultimate OAP app: Smart home system can monitor everything from pill boxes to TVS so concerned children can keep an eye on elderly parents: has videos: see 0 -0:33http://www.dailymail.co.uk/video/sciencetech/video-1181160/OAP-app-lets-concerned-kids-eye-elderly-parents.html
http://newatlas.com/wonderwall-tum-elederly-care/26287/ Wonderwall: High-tech home-assisted living for the elderly February 20th, 2013
...
http://www.homecaremag.com/top-10-technology-devices-seniors An elder care industry veteran offers her picks for must-have aging-in-place technology. Laurie M. Orlov, a technology industry veteran, writer, speaker and elder care advocate, is the founder of Aging in Place Technology Watch, a market research firm that provides thought leadership, analysis and guidance about technologies and related services that enable boomers and seniors to remain longer in their home of choice.
.......
JAPAN: http://web-japan.org/trends/11_tech-life/tec120910.html HIGH-TECH NURSING CARE For Elderly-Friendly Societ
.....
http://www.usnews.com/news/business/articles/2015/05/05/high-tech-sensors-help-kids-keep-eye-on-aging-parents In this March 17, 2015 photo, Phil Dworsky shows off an app on his phone that displays the movements of his parents, Dorothy, 80, left, and Bill Dworsky, 81, rear, at their home in San Francisco. Each time an elder Dworksy opens the refrigerator, closes the bathroom door or lifts the lid on a pill container, tiny sensors in their home make notes on a digital logbook, which the younger Dworsky monitors daily on his smartphone. (AP Photo/Eric Risberg) THE ASSOCIATED PRESS
……
Articles, associations
Sleep and agitation in nursing home residents with and without dementia
· Donnamay T. Brown (a1) (a2), Juanita L. Westbury (a2) and Benjamin Schüz (a1)
…
http://dailycaring.com/amazon-echo-for-dementia-technology-for-seniors/
………………………
C) Existing assistive tech: devices & systems already available
This kind of technology is called “assistive technology” and can promote independence and autonomy, manage potential safety risks around the home and reduce stress. Here is a list of the top tech innovations on the market today for people with Alzheimer’s and their caregivers:
1. Reminder Messages Reminders can help keep properties and loved ones safe when the caregiver can’t. These messages are recorded on a device in the home and then played back out loud at the appropriate time. For example, a caregiver may record a message to play that reminds a person to take a medication at the correct time. Some devices can play messages depending on the person’s activity. For example, if a person with dementia leaves their home, a reminder message could tell them to lock the front door. This technology can also remind both caregiver and patient of appointments. Other reminder messages can also let those who have dementia know not to open the door, to go back to bed and to provide reassurance when the caregiver is not present.
2. Clocks Clocks specifically designed for those with Alzheimer’s and dementia can help ease anxiety associated with a diagnosis. Someone who has dementia may confuse night and day and an easy to read clock can help them distinguish the time. This can also help caregivers who are trying to set a routine by showing their loved one that it actually is the time they say it is.
3. Medication Management Medication management technology can be as simple as a pillbox marked with days of the week, or as high tech as automated pill dispensers which beep and open to remind caregivers and those with dementia to take their medication. Some medication reminders are also as simple as a vibrating alarm on a watch. This technology serves the busy caregiver well by allowing them to trust the device for a medication reminder.
4. GPS Location and Tracking Devices Location tracking devices are a great option for those who have Alzheimer’s or dementia and may wander. Tracking devices can be worn or attached to the person in some way and many have alert systems that let a caregiver know if their loved one has left a certain area. This type of technology can also alert emergency personnel to ensure a speedy and safe recovery.
5. Picture Phones Specifically designed for people who cannot remember phone numbers and may need to contact someone quickly. These phones have large numbers and are pre-programmable with frequently called phone numbers. Some of the phones come with clear buttons where photos can be placed so that the person can just push the button associated with the photos to call their loved one quickly.
6. Electrical Use Monitoring This new piece of technology is specifically designed for caregivers who do not live with their loved ones. It monitors their use of electrical appliances by plugging into a wall outlet or power strip and will alert caregivers if their commonly used appliances have not been turned on or off.
Technologies like the ones listed above do not make an Alzheimer’s diagnosis easy. The disease is still devastating. But, with new
…….
Assistive technology - devices to help with everyday living www.alzheimers.org.uk/site/scripts/documents_info.php?documentID=109
This factsheet does not cover some basic items that can help people to cope with memory loss (eg a simple calendar, a noticeboard or sticky notes). For more information on these see Alzheimer's Society booklet 1540, The memory handbook.
Similarly, items designed for problems with mobility, continence, sight and hearing are not considered to be assistive technology. These include mobility aids, continence devices and pressure relief mattresses. For information about these types of solutions see factsheet 429, Equipment, adaptations and improvements to the home.
Many assistive technology devices are electronic, but the term does not just refer to high-tech devices. However, devices such as smartphones and tablets, coupled with widespread internet coverage, are making technology more accessible for everyone in ways that we couldn't predict just a few years ago. Widespread use of social media (such as Twitter and Facebook) also means that many people now live some of their life in a virtual environment, as well as in a more traditional face-to-face one.
All this means that the nature of assistive technology for people with dementia is changing. Technologies and 'apps' (applications or programs for smartphones and tablets) that have been developed for the general public are increasingly being used by people with dementia as well. Over time these mainstream technologies will probably replace many of the products that were developed specifically for people with dementia or disability.
Technology can be used in a variety of ways, and for a variety of purposes. It can support people in carrying out everyday tasks and activities, enhance a person's safety, support theirsocial participation, and monitor their health. Assistive technology can help people who have problems with:
technology can never replace human contact and interaction and it should never be used for this purpose. Doing so may lead to feelings of isolation and loneliness .
Products may not have been designed with the specific wants of the person with dementia in mind and, as a result, there may be less focus on this. Instead, it is expected that the person will adapt to the technology, not the other way round. Expecting the person with dementia to adapt, without listening to their views, can affect how keen they are to use the technology. This in turn will affect how successful it is.
Automated prompts and reminders: One type of reminder, based on a motion sensor, plays a pre-recorded voice prompt when there is movement nearby. For example, a sensor placed near the front door could remind someone to lock the door, or one in the kitchen could remind someone to turn the oven off.
Another kind of reminder does not detect movement but is set to play a message at a certain time. For example, someone may record a message reminding them to take their medication or telling them that they have an appointment. They could also set their phone calendar to remind them.
Technology now also allows family members or other people not living with the person with dementia to access a tablet in the person's home and support them with reminders. This means the person with dementia has a display of appointments, visitors and activities, as well as the reassurance of knowing where people who can help are and how to contact them.
Automatic calendar clocks apps can also be downloaded for tablets, which you can set up to suit your own tastes and needs.
OnKöl simultaneously notifies selected family members and other caregivers of everything from vital signs to incoming and outgoing calls to emergency or panic situations. That way, the caregivers and interested parties can get out in front of specific events or anomalies, before they become full-blown emergencies.
There has never been a better, easier, less invasive way to stay connected to someone you care about.
Medication Simple boxes for pills (known as dossette boxes) have separate compartments for days of the week and times of day eg morning, afternoon, teatime, bedtime.Automatic dispensers for pills that are taken regularly are also available. These are pre-filled - ask your local pharmacist whether they offer this service - and then locked. When the medication needs to be taken, the dispenser sets off an alarm and the right compartment opens, allowing the person to access their medication. The alarm may continue until the pills are removed from the dispenser. There are also devices that can send an alert to a friend or relative to notify them if the medication hasn't been taken, or if the device isn't working, has low battery or needs refilling.
Locator devices and solutions: keys or a wallet. A small electronic tag is attached to each item.In one system, the person has a dedicated locator device and, if they mislay the item, they can click a button on the locator device to make the tag beep. The locator device will need to be kept somewhere obvious. These systems can be confusing and difficult to use for some people with dementia. They may be more helpful for carers, or when carers are able to support the person to use them. An alternative (and less intrusive) approach is to attach a small tile to each item and link these to a smartphone using a simple app. One system like this stores the last place your phone 'saw' the tile. This location can then be displayed on the phone's map function.
Communication aids telephones pre-programmed with frequently used numbers. video chat. For a person who has problems with speech, communicating using cards that combine pictures and text may help. Someone caring for the person might use these cue cards to offer different options for an activity, for example. The person would then point or nod to choose the one they want. Talking mats is a popular app which takes this idea onto a tablet or computer. People can communicate how they feel, or who they want to spend time with - for example, by selecting the picture or symbol from the options offered. Talking mats is increasingly used to engage people with dementia living in care homes.
Technology designed to support a person's safety includes the following:
Types of safer walking device include:
The location of the person carrying the device can be viewed on a computer, tablet device or mobile phone. Many tracking devices also allow the person to press a panic button if they get lost. Many new mobile phones also have location finder technology. This could be considered instead of a stand-alone tracking device. When purchasing a device to enable safer walking, it is important to consider how reliable it is. For example, will it work when the person is indoors, and how often will it need charging?
The signal required for tracking devices to work can be patchy, which means the device may not work in all areas. Some of the devices can be difficult to use (especially for a person with dementia) and the person may not want to wear a device or risk forgetting that they should have the device with them. The person with dementia may also not be able to respond appropriately when an alert happens (eg being told to stay where they are).
Safer walking technology can enable some people with dementia to have greater freedom and independence, and can ultimately reduce the use of unpleasant solutions such as drugs and physical restraints. It may also mean that carers worry less about the person's safety.
The use of safer walking technology has many possible benefits, but it also raises important ethical questions around capacity and consent (see 'Ethical considerations' below).
Telecare systems are often used to support independence and personal safety. They may help to reduce the risks associated with living alone, and can be useful for people living with dementia. Telecare can provide assistance to the person to help them to do things (eg a phone call to remind them to take their medication). It can also alert others of dangerous situations (eg if they were to have a fall or leave the gas on). Sensors around the home can be linked to a nominated person or call centre. The system monitors a person's activities and can trigger an alarm to the person or call centre if a problem occurs. The alarm can also be triggered by a person pressing a panic button or community alarm.
Telecare has traditionally been provided by a community alarm or monitoring service provided through social services. However, it is now possible to set it up privately.
Telecare comes in various forms and may be used for a range of situations:
More information on what is available in the person's local area will be available from their local authority, local assisted living centre, or by searching online.
As with tracking devices, using telecare systems poses ethical challenges (see 'Ethical considerations' below).
While assistive technology has traditionally been used to help people with dementia remain safe and continue with everyday activities, it is increasingly being used to support a person's social life and provide opportunities for activities and enjoyment. This can help them to maintain their relationships, skills and wellbeing.
With the increasing availability of tablets, smartphones and apps, there are many new options to help people stay in touch and engage with those close to them. They also offer opportunities for activities, which is important for supporting the wellbeing of a person with dementia. These can include reminiscence, creative activities (eg music), video calling and life story work.
Other types of assistive technology that can be used for leisure include:
A tablet used to deliver these can itself become a topic of conversation, and so lead to more interactions for the person. This is particularly true for 'intergenerational' interactions, where the shared experience of the technology gives a younger person a connection that might otherwise not have existed.
Many devices can be bought independently, but before doing so it is advisable to seek professional advice. An occupational therapist, adult social services assistive technology or telecare team (contact your local council), or a local assisted living centre will all have expertise in this area. Your GP or social worker is less likely to have the detailed expertise themselves, but they should be able to help you find an expert and get an assessment. Even if these professionals can't offer the devices directly, the person with dementia may find that they are eligible for an assessment, or are able to get help in finding the best device orfinancial assistance.
There is no one-size-fits-all approach to choosing assistive technology - what works for one person may not work for another. For example, one person might find it helpful to have a recorded message reminding them to take their keys with them, while another person might find this confusing. It can help to think carefully about the person's specific needs and capabilities, and consider what the benefits of using the technology might be.
It is important to make sure the technology is supporting the person and not restricting them. It is also a good idea to look at the person's living space and see if there are adaptations to the environment that may help (eg making sure there are good lighting levels and removing trip hazards). For more information see factsheet 429, Equipment, adaptions and improvements to the home.
When choosing assistive technology, some things to consider include:
You can also find a list of questions to consider when choosing a solution in the Dementia-friendly technology charter.
It is also worth being aware that the earlier the technology is introduced, the more successful it is likely to be. This is because the person will have more time to get used to it before their dementia gets worse. Some people with dementia choose to refer to the use of assistive technology, particularly tracking technology, when they are documenting their wishes for the future (advance care planning).
…….
http://www.sallyabrahms.com/ intergenerational retirement communities
companies focusing on adult children and their aging parents (boomers and seniors).
…
Small homes specially designed: https://www.dilgp.qld.gov.au/infrastructure/ageing-in-place-pilot-project.html
http://www.agingmo.com/ AgingMO is a centralized online home for the University of Missouri’s Aging in Place (AIP) program and its related projects. Our unique AIP model allows older adults to receive health care in their preferred place of living. As their care needs increase, residents contract for more care in the same setting, eliminating the need for a move to a more restrictive living environment such as a nursing home. This project, which began in 1996, is a multidisciplinary project including MU’s School of Nursing, College of Electrical and Computer Engineering, School of Social Work, Department of Physical Therapy, Department of Management and Informatics, Biostatistics Group, and Department of Family and Community Medicine, along with outside consultants.
How to remodel your home: http://ageinplace.com/at-home/aging-in-place-home-ideas/
· https://www.caring.com/checklists/useful-gadgets-for-elderly
· http://www.makeuseof.com/tag/8-devices-elderly-relatives-safe-at-home/
· https://myageingparent.com/technology/communication/mobile-apps-help-monitor-older-people/
· http://www.safewise.com/blog/wearable-technologies-keeping-tabs-elderly/
· The ultimate OAP app: Smart home system can monitor everything from pill boxes to TVS so concerned children can keep an eye on elderly parents : http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-3068832/High-tech-sensors-help-kids-eye-aging-parents.html#ixzz4SGG99C8l
….
................
http://www.techhive.com/article/3206310/connected-home/best-smart-home-system.html
IDG.TV | Mar 15, 2016
With smart appliances and windows that go from clear to opaque, this modular, stackable home is already a reality in Austin, where we toured one at SXSW.
........
http://www.techhive.com/article/3206310/connected-home/best-smart-home-system.html
From smart light bulbs and thermostats that think for themselves to Bluetooth door locks, wireless security cameras, and all manner of sensors, today’s home technology can sound awfully sophisticated while actually being a messy hodgepodge of gizmos and apps. Whether you call it home automation or the connected home, installing all this stuff in your house is one thing. Getting it to work together smoothly and with a single user interface can be something entirely different.
Here’s the essential gear to get you there, which we’ve separated into two categories: all-around smart home systems, which are designed to coordinate a wide variety of smart home products, and security-focused systems, which are built around sensors and sirens. You should also note that some of our picks are starter kits, consisting of a smart-home hub and a handful of devices, while others are just the hub. You'll need to add the components you want to the latter, choosing from products certified by the hub manufacturer.
Technologies Help Adult Children Monitor Aging ParentsBy HILARY STOUTJULY 28, 2010
Elizabeth Roach’s health is remotely monitored by her son. A screen on her end in Virginia displays e-mail, photos, games and her blood pressure. CreditLuke Sharrett/The New York Times
IN the wee hours of July 14, Elizabeth Roach, a 70-year-old widow, got out of bed and went to the living room of her Virginia ranch home. She sat in her favorite chair for 15 minutes, then returned to bed.
She rose again shortly after 6, went to the kitchen, plugged in the coffee pot, showered and took her weight and blood pressure. Throughout the morning, she moved back and forth between the kitchen and the living room. She opened her medicine cabinet at 12:21 and closed it at 12:22. Immediately afterward, she opened the refrigerator door for almost three minutes. At 1:36, she opened the kitchen door and went outside.
All this information — including her exact weight (126 pounds) and blood pressure reading (139/98) — was transmitted via the Internet to her 44-year-old son, Michael Murdock, who reviewed it from his home office in suburban Denver.
All was normal — meaning all was well.
“Right now she’s not home,” Mr. Murdock said. That he deduced because the sensors he had installed throughout his mother’s home told him that the kitchen door — which leads outside — had not been reopened since 1:36, more than an hour earlier. The opening of the medicine cabinet midday confirmed to him that his mother had taken her medicine. And he was satisfied that she had eaten lunch because the refrigerator door was open more than just a few seconds.
In the general scheme of life, parents are the ones who keep tabs on the children. But now, a raft of new technology is making it possible for adult children to monitor to a stunningly precise degree the daily movements and habits of their aging parents.
The purpose is to provide enough supervision to make it possible for elderly people to stay in their homes rather than move to an assisted-living facility or nursing home — a goal almost universally embraced as both emotionally and financially desirable. With that in mind, a vast spectrum of companies, from giants like General Electric to start-ups like iReminder of Westfield, N.J., which has developed a system to notify families if loved ones haven’t taken their medicine, are looking for a piece of the market of families with an aging relative.
Many of the systems are godsends for families. But, as with any parent-child relationship, all loving intentions can be tempered by issues of control, role-reversal, guilt and a little deception — enough loaded stuff to fill a psychology syllabus. For just as the current population of adults in their 30s and 40s have built a reputation for being a generation of hyper-involved, hovering parents to their own children, they now have the tools to micro-manage their aging mothers and fathers as well.
Wendy A. Rogers, a psychology professor at Georgia Tech, who has studied such systems and seniors’ reactions to them, recalled a man who went into high alert when a sensor system showed a high level of activity in a room of his mother’s home. He called her to find out what was wrong — and it turned out that she had decided to paint the sunroom.
“I think the critical question is: Is this something the parent wants?” said Nancy K. Schlossberg, a counseling psychologist and professor emerita at the University of Maryland. She compared monitoring technology for elderly people to the infamous “nanny cams” — hidden cameras some parents use to spy on their children’s baby sitters. “Big Brother is watching you — there’s something about it that’s very offensive,” she said.
Michael Murdoch remotely tracks the well-being of his mother, Elizabeth Roach, from his home in Aurora, Colo. CreditJamie Schwaberow for The New York Times
The decision, she said, must ultimately be made by the aging parent. “It has to be negotiated with the parents,” Dr. Schlossberg said. “You want to keep the relationship co-equal. If it’s not an agreement with the parent, it can be a very destructive thing.”
The system Mr. Murdock persuaded his mother to install is calledGrandCare, produced by a company of the same name based in West Bend, Wis. It allows families to place movement sensors throughout a house. Information — about when doors were opened, what time a person got into and out of bed, whether there’s been any movement in a room for a certain time period — is sent out via e-mail, text message or voice mail. He said his GrandCare system cost $8,000 to install — about as much as two months at the local assisted-living facility, Mr. Murdock said — plus monthly fees of about $75. The company says that costs vary depending on what features a client chooses.
In addition to giving him peace of mind that his mother is fine, the system helps assuage that midlife sense of guilt. “I have a large amount of guilt,” Mr. Murdock admitted. “I’m really far away. I’m not helping to take care of her, to mow her lawn, to be a good son.”
His mother, Mrs. Roach, was nervous at first when her son brought up the idea of using the system. “I didn’t want to be invaded,” she said. “I didn’t understand the system and was concerned about privacy.” Now that it’s in place, she said, she’s changed her mind: “I was all wrong. I’m not feeling like I’m being watched all day.” And she really enjoys the system’s feature that lets her play games and receive photos and messages from her children and grandchildren. (She never learned to use e-mail.)
Mrs. Roach has no major health issues that require the kind of watching she is getting, and oddly enough, that is the ideal scenario. Elinor Ginzler, senior vice president for livable communities at AARP, said it’s best to discuss using such technology long before a parent’s health has slipped to a point where she might actually need it. “You frame it that way: ‘We’re so happy that things are going so well. We want to make sure to keep it that way. Let’s talk about what we can do to make sure.’ ”
What often follows is pushback. After all, this is not a generation known for its ease with technology.
“My parents’ first reaction to technology is, ’Get it away from me,’ ” said Rachel Meyers, 45, of Brooklyn, whose father, an 80-year-old retired math professor, put at the top of his course syllabus each year: “Do Not E-mail Me.” When her mother, who just turned 84 and lives with her husband in Minneapolis, developed kidney disease, Rachel and her far-flung siblings worried about how to ensure that she was taking the complicated regimen of pills needed daily for her condition.
Their father was not going to be a reliable enforcer. “My father is going to be in his own cave reading a math book with his socks and sandals,” Ms. Meyers laughed. “He is not that guy.”
Through her work as director of community initiatives at the Metropolitan Jewish Health System in Brooklyn, Ms. Meyers learned about a medication management system called MedMinder. It is basically a computerized pillbox. The correct daily dosages of her mother’s 10 different medications are arranged in boxes. When it is time to take them, the pillbox beeps and flashes. If she takes them, Ms. Meyers gets a phone call in Brooklyn saying, essentially, Mom took her pills. Her siblings, including a brother who lives in Australia, get e-mail notifications.
But if her mother doesn’t take the pills within a two-hour window, the system starts nagging. It calls her. It flashes and beeps. Then Ms. Meyers gets a phone call in New York with a message saying her mother missed her dose. “So that’s been interesting,” Ms. Meyers said. “I can call and say, ‘Hey Mom, have you taken your medicine?’ She’ll say, ‘No, I’m on my way.’ I’ll say ‘Do it as a favor for me and take it while we’re on the phone.’ She’ll take it.”
Usually it all works out. But “what does get us into hairy, difficult emotional ground,” Ms. Meyers said, is when her mother’s daily routine changes and her children neglect to reprogram the pillbox to keep up with the shift. For example, as thedialysis began taking a toll, her mother began sleeping later in the morning, but the MedMinder still expected her to take her pills at 7.
“The machine is beeping and she’s not up yet,” Ms. Meyers said. “We get stuck in our own busy lives” and forget to reprogram it. “She says, ’I don’t want it any more.’ Now we’re in a defensive place.”
However, in an interview, Ms. Meyers’s mother, Harriet Meyers, said she had come to appreciate the contraption. “At first I was rebellious. I said, ‘Look, I’m lining up my pills, Rachel.’ I said, ‘I know what I’m doing.’ ” But now she looks at it differently. “I decided to try and now I’m hooked.”
Several academic studies have been undertaken to see just where the line between loving watchfulness and over-intrusion might be drawn. Researchers at Georgia Tech have created an experimental house (called the Aware Home) outfitted with various sensors and motion detectors as well as systems that provide support for medication andmemory. They brought in older adults to see how they felt about the devices. “They were quite positive about the idea,” said Ms. Rogers, who is a director of the university’s Human Factors and Aging Laboratory. But the key, she said, is control. The older person is much more amenable if he or she “can control who has access to the information and what information they have access to,” she said.
Other research suggests that having the monitors in place may be enough to give family members peace of mind, and that they are less likely than one might expect to spend time poring over the information. Kelly Caine, a researcher at Indiana University, is just completing a study that found that for all the handwringing over whether to install monitoring technology, the people who received the information from such systems “rarely checked in on the older adults using the monitoring technology more than once per day.” The findings are preliminary, cautioned Ms. Caine, the principal research scientist at the university’s Center for Strategic Health Information Provisioning.
Adult children who call parents to check up on them have learned to be careful about how they phrase their questions. “I personally don’t make it so that I’m watching,” Mr. Murdock said. “I don’t say, ‘Mom, I was looking and you didn’t do this.’ I say, ‘Mom, are you O.K.? I noticed you didn’t take your medicine.’ It’s a balancing act, but it’s an easy conversation. It’s not like I’m calling every day saying, ‘Did you do this or did you do that?’ ”
Other families have also found that the systems reduce the need for nagging conversations. Ray Joss, 91, of Flushing, Queens, has been using a sensor-based system called QuietCare that she found throughSelfhelp, a social services company in New York that helps seniors use technology to allow them to live independently. She says that she and her son, who lives in New Jersey, don’t have to dwell on her well-being in conversations because the monitoring system has already let him know how she is. “We talk about other things rather than just how I feel. He doesn’t have to ask me.”
Despite their increasing familiarity with the technology, many elderly people draw the line at cameras.
Susan Oertle has been using a wireless monitoring system calledBeClose to check on her aunt, who was recently widowed and had no children of her own. Though the 83-year-old woman recently broke her hip and suffers from a lung condition that compromises her breathing, she is still fiercely independent and likes to stay up till 1:30 a.m. Thanks to wireless sensors in her aunt’s bed, Ms. Oertle can roll over in the middle of the night and notice an e-mail message flashing on her phone reassuring her that her aunt went to sleep. But enough is enough. If there had been cameras to monitor her, Ms. Oertle said, “I think she would have had a bird.”
..................
Questions to be posed at the end of the project-description: