Group 1
Line - Adam
Scatter with trend line - Anne, Chakiera, Kim, Yiyang, Zhongshan
Scatter without trend line - Lingjie, Melissa
Scatter with trend line and box plot - Lance, Miranda, Stephanie
Bars with trend line - Chana
Bars without trend line - Jessica
Bars of regressions - Cheng
Adam - line (line suggests relations between points, bad for this exercise)
Anne - scatter with trend line
Chakiera - scatter with trend line
Chana - bars with trend line
Cheng - bar of regressions (only one who made a visualization based on the regressions)
Jessica - bar (missing trend line to show correlation)
Kim - side-by-side scatter with trend line
Lance - scatter with trend line & box plot
Lingjie - scatter without trend line (needs trend line)
Melissa - scatter without trend line (needs trend line)
Miranda - scatter with trend line & box plot
Stephanie - scatter with trend line & box plot
Yiyang - scatter with trend line (multiple)
Zhongshan - scatter with trend line
We think that the overall best solution is a scatter plot with a trend line. We especially liked the scatter plots with color-coded dots to show the trends for each gender. The trend line was necessary to show the levels of correlation.
Anne's was our overall favorite because she used distinct colors to separate male and female and included the trend line. We would have liked, however, that these be presented side-by-side the way that Lingjie's were.
We also appreciate Cheng's straightforward approach but feel that this would be more meaningful if paired with some other graphs which show us slopes/trend lines.