Different schools handle their concerns in different ways. Local municipalities often have little influence on the policies, and any interactions these governing bodies have with student is often symbolic. Governments, instead, leave these local issues up to the administration of the school district.
#1 In our rankings and accepting of free speech is the Pittsburgh Public School System. Pittsburgh Public Schools (the urban educational atmosphere of the three) lead the three studied environments in terms of allowing their students an abundance of free speech. The handbook for Pittsburgh Public was descriptive and established the proper laws and rules for a school environment. The document also left an abundance of caution in terms of limiting student rights. As shown in the table, these students enjoy the most free schooling environments in terms of speech and these students benefit from a seemingly very supportive administration.
#2 in our Power Rankings for speech goes to Mt. Lebanon High School (suburban.) For a very detailed look at this school's handbook, check out our case study page. Mt. Lebanon students benefit from a mostly supportive environment in terms of speech, but these kids must be careful for many broad, "umbrella" type rules. For the most part, however, Mt. Lebanon students enjoy plenty of free speech liberties with slight censorship from the administration.
#3 in our Power Rankings falls to Plum Borough. The students at Plum, most recently, were forced to protest after administration told them that they could not discuss scandals currently plaguing the school staff. We found the handbook rhetoric rather strong and harsh, limiting most of the liberties that would be found at Mt. Lebanon or especially Pittsburgh Public. The administration should consider major changes in their policies, so that their students may benefit from a diverse marketplace of ideas critical to a meaningful education.
These differences based on school only further show the variance in policy based on location, school district, and the general beliefs of administrators. As Principal McFeeley stated, besides established precedents and laws, these educators have broad rights to establish rules as they see fit. Though changing schools/moving homes due to day to day rules is often impractical, knowing your rights is an important part of fitting into your educational environment. If you feel, after research, that your rights have been infringed upon by your institution, we recommend that you contact the ACLU. The American Civil Liberties Union may not agree with your actions, but they will fight for your rights to act that way. Furthermore, we recommend accepting the injustice in the moment, and then later suing to defend your rights. In the moment, act civil, be courteous, and prepare for your legal battle ahead.
You never know: You could end up with the next big Supreme Court Precedent on our site!
Stay informed, kids.