Bat Conservation through Acoustic Monitoring

Emily Eilers

MA Biology Student

AIP Project Dragonfly

Miami University

eilersed@miamioh.edu

Bats-Nature's Unsung Heroes

Source: Public Domain

Introduction

Bats are mammals of the Order Chiroptera, or “hand wing”, as their forelimbs have been adapted into wings (2). Due to this adaptation, they are the only mammal capable of true and sustained flight (2). They are the second largest order of mammals with over 1400 species (2).

Bats are found all over the world except in Antarctica. The majority of bats in the Midwest US are classified as microbats (Microchiroptera). The microbats utilize echolocation and are mainly insectivores; however, some feed on fruit, nectar, pollen, fish, frogs, small mammals, or blood. The external ears of microbats do not close to form a ring with the edges separated from each other at the base of the ear (17). Their cousins, the megabats (Megachiroptera), are mainly frugivores (fruit-eaters) or nectarivores (nectar-eaters). The megabats mainly live in tropical regions and do not utilize echolocation. Megabats have a well-developed eyesight and a claw on the second finger of the forelimb (17).

According to Jack Stenger, Conservation Biologist at Great Parks of Hamilton County, in the Midwestern USA, there are 12 species of bats which are typically found in caves, rock crevices, old buildings, bridges, mines and trees. There are a few species of bats that will migrate south during the winter, but most species will stay in the same area and hibernate.

The various species of Midwestern US bats have wingspans between 5-15 inches long and weigh between 5-30 grams.

Bats only have one pup per year which makes them extremely vulnerable to extinction (2).

Globally, there are 21 bat species critically endangered and face imminent risk of becoming extinct, 83 bat species endangered, 109 bat species considered vulnerable and 242 bat species considered "data deficient", which is an indicator that more conservation attention is needed for these species (2).

Flying Fox. Source: Public Domain

Ecosystem Services

Pest control is one of the most important ecosystem services that bats provide. One bat can eat up to 1,000 mosquitos in one hour! In addition, they save farmers approximately $3.7 billion annually (14). Along with pest control, bats provide pollination and seed dispersal, their guano (feces) as fertilizer, and in some countries, they are a food source for both humans and animals (12). Thus, if the bat population severely declines, the US could experience higher prices of food, due to the loss of pollination of crops, increased insects leading to increased use of pesticides and greater spread of disease (12).

Threats

There are currently declines in the bat populations due to habitat loss and fragmentation, White-Nose Syndrome, insect population declines, wind energy development, climate change, and human disturbance. White-Nose Syndrome is caused by a fungal pathogen called Pseudogymnoascus destructans. It causes them to wake more frequently during hibernation due to increased body temperature as the bat is fighting the fungus. White-Nose Syndrome, along with human disturbances during hibernation, cause the bats to wake frequently, depletes their energy stores, and leads to their death. Wind energy development is detrimental to the migrating bat populations as the bats run into the wind turbines as they are migrating and die. Insect population declines lead to a smaller food source for bats. In addition, habitat loss and fragmentation and climate change leads to less areas for bats to roost, raise young, and find food (16).

A little brown bat with visible symptoms of fungal growth typical of white nose syndrome. Photo courtesy U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service

Conservation Efforts

Due to several Midwestern US species of bats becoming endangered and entering the IUCN Red List, such as the Northern Long-eared Bat (Myotis septentrionalis), Indiana Bat (Myotis sodalis), Little Brown Bat (Myotis lucifugus) and Tri-Colored Bat (Pipistrellus subflavus), many conservation groups are trying to stop the declines in population through conservation efforts (9). Those efforts include gating entrances to caves and mines, building bat houses, educating the public, research, and saving and restoring forest ecosystems (2).

Juvenile female Indiana Bat. Photo by Adam Mann. GAI Consultants

Based on the time, intensity and direction that the echolocation waves come from, the bat can determine where objects are located. Source: Public Domain

Source: IncredibleBats (YouTube) (8)

How Do Bats Communicate-And Why Does It Matter?

Bats communicate with one another, locate food sources and navigate their environment through a series of high frequency pitches and clicks called echolocation. Many of these sounds are of a frequency that the human ear cannot detect. Based on the time, intensity and direction that the frequency waves come from, the bat can determine where objects are located (15).

Echolocation provides a window through which the behavior and ecology of bats can be evaluated (15).

Click on the link below to learn more exciting facts about echolocation!

Leaf nosed bats flying. Source: Public Domain

What Is Acoustic Monitoring?

Using acoustic monitroing in the field. Source: UConn Natural Resources Conservation Academy (13)

Introduction

Acoustic monitoring, which has been used since 1950, is one piece of research equipment that allows us to learn more about bats and their populations through echolocation. It is a set of high frequency microphones connected to a storage media device (5).

Other species which acoustic monitoring is being used to help learn more about them include birds, amphibians, marine mammals, and insects (11).

How It Works

The standard protocol for recording bat echolocation calls typically involves recording from sunset to sunrise (5). The high frequency microphones record bat echolocation (ultrasonic waves) and save the information onto a storage device. From there, the bat pass (series of calls) is transferred to a computer analysis software. The analysis software allows the researcher or scientist to see sound wave frequencies and hear the bat calls. Based on the unique features of each call, researchers are able to narrow down the bat species present (5). To help determine the species, there are several bat call libraries available online (4).

There are two types of acoustic monitors available and in use in the field, which are passive and portable (or active). These monitors are also known as stationary surveys and mobile transects, respectively. Passive acoustic monitors entail large microphones and a recording device attached to a pole which is placed in a field, riparian environment, or forest and left for long periods of time. Portable (active) acoustic monitors are small and handheld with microphones that can be attached to the outside of a car or carried around (3). Bat researchers or volunteers then drive slowly through areas with the monitors and collect data. Both forms have been found to be highly successful in obtaining information on bats.

Wavelengths and frequencies of a bat call. Source: Keystone Environmental Ltd.

Types

Heterodyne detectors-detect narrow range of frequencies and convert sounds of those frequencies to audible (to humans) sounds in real time. This provides a quick method to listen for bat presence (1, 4).

Broadband detectors-detect a range of frequencies simultaneously, to identify species, especially in communities where calls vary in frequency (1, 4).

There are many questions that need to be answered when determining the type of detector that you want to use in the field. For more information on the questions that you should be asking prior to buying a detector, please refer to https://www.batcon.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/Bat_Echolocation_Research_2nd_Ed_20200918.pdf.

Microphone sensitivity is equally important as the detector. Bats using low-intensity echolocation calls dominated by higher frequencies are harder to detect than those using high-intensity calls dominated by lower frequencies. Thus, researchers must be aware of the bat community that they are studying prior to selecting an acoustic monitoring device (1, 4).

Some acoustic monitoring system examples include (1):

1) Anabat detecting and recording system by Titley electronics (www.titley.com.au)

2) AR125 detector and FR125 eld recorder by Binary Acoustic Technology (BAT; www.binaryacoustictech.com)

3) Song Meter SM2BAT+ detector/recorder by Wildlife Acoustics (www.wildlifeacoustics.com)

An acoustic monitor used to record supersonic bat calls. Photo © Lisa Feldkamp / The Nature Conservancy

Acoustic monitoring as a Conservation Strategy

Acoustic monitoring can help to determine:

1) biodiversity or community structure

2) distribution

3) activity patterns and habitat selection

4) behavior

5) population monitoring

6) seasonal and cyclical patterns (4)

According to Adam Mann, Endangered Species Biologist and Environmental Manager at GAI Consultants, Inc., when acoustic monitoring is used over time, researchers can gather trends in species composition changes. Sometimes acoustic monitoring is used alongside mist netting and harp traps to make sure that the species heard in one area have been correctly identified. This allows conservation protocols and plans to be set up in order to help save the bats.

BatRack

There is a newer piece of equipment, which is currently being used to study bats in the United Kingdom, called the Bat Rack. It combines ultrasonic audio recordings, automatic radio telemetry and video camera recordings to help researchers to identify and follow bat movements. However, it is still quite expensive and not currently being used in the US (6).

Why Is Acoustic Monitoring So Important?

Acoustic monitoring:

  • Detects maximum species richness with minimal effort and cost effectiveness

  • Non-intrusive and capable of recording large quantities of data on bats

  • Guides important wildlife management decisions

  • General public can participate in collecting data with little training (5)

Source: Public Domain

Source: Public Domain

There are other citizen science projects involving bats and acoustic monitoring across the United States!

Click on the following links to find out more about these projects and how you can get involved!

Join in Citizen Science!

Citizen Science is when the public voluntarily helps conduct scientific research and helps scientists and researchers to collect data (10). One widely used citizen science application is iNaturalist.

iNaturalist allows the public to:

  1. record their findings of animals and plants (photos and sounds)

  2. connect with experts who can help ID the animal or plant

  3. connect with naturalists and others to learn more about nature

  4. help scientists and researchers know when and where animals and plants are found

  5. interact with maps to see where specific animals and plants have been found

  6. Locate other citizen science projects to participate in (7)

Click the link below to check out iNaturalist and learn how you can become a citizen scientist for bats!

Look What You Can Do!!

The following graph from the Ohio Department of Natural Resources shows the activity levels of various species of bats in Ohio, which is based on their calls detected by acoustic monitoring. Conservationists can follow these trends and determine when, where and how conservation plans to save bats are created.

All data for this graph was collected by volunteers.

You too can be a part of bat conservation by participating in one of the aforementioned citizen science projects!

(Graph courtesy of Eileen Wyza, Wildlife Biologist, Ohio Division of Wildlife)

Now On The Bat Channel

I have had the pleasure of talking to 3 local biologists about their experiences in the field with acoustic monitoring and how it can support bat conservation:

  • Eileen Wyza

    • Wildlife Biologist at Ohio Division of Wildlife

  • Jack Stenger

    • Conservation Biologist at Great Parks of Hamilton County

  • Adam Mann

    • Endangered Species Biologist/Environmental Manager at GAI Consultants, Inc.

My YouTube video summarizes the information about bats and acoustic monitoring that I learned from them.

What are your thoughts about acoustic monitoring? Please take a minute to fill out a questionnaire about tracking bats by clicking here!

References

  1. Adams, A. M., Jantzen, M. K., Hamilton, R. M., Fenton, M. B., & Freckleton, R. (2012). Do you hear what I hear? Implications of detector selection for acoustic monitoring of bats. Methods in Ecology & Evolution, 3(6), 992–998. https://doi-org.proxy.lib.miamioh.edu/10.1111/j.2041-210X.2012.00244.x

  2. Bat Conservation International. (2022). Bats 101. Bat Conservation International. https://www.batcon.org/about-bats/bats-101/

  3. Braun de Torrez, E. C., Wallrichs, M. A., Ober, H. K., & McCleery, R. A. (2017). Mobile acoustic transects miss rare bat species: implications of survey method and spatio-temporal sampling for monitoring bats. PeerJ 5:e3940 https://doi.org/10.7717/peerj.3940

  4. Fraser, E., Silvis, A., Brigham, R. M., & Czenze, Z. J., Eds. (2020). Bat Echolocation Research: A handbook for planning and conducting acoustic studies. (2nd ed.). Bat Conservation International. https://www.batcon.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/Bat_Echolocation_Research_2nd_Ed_20200918.pdf

  5. Frick, W. F. (2013). Acoustic monitoring of bats, considerations of options for long-term monitoring / Monitoreo acústico de murciélagos, consideraciones de opciones para el monitoreo a largo plazo. Therya, 4(1), 69–70. https://doi-org.proxy.lib.miamioh.edu/10.12933/therya-13-109

  6. Gottwald, J., Lampe, P., Höchst, J., Friess, N., Maier, J., Leister, L., Neumann, B., Richter, T., Freisleben, B., & Nauss, T. (2021). BatRack: An open‐source multi‐sensor device for wildlife research. Methods in Ecology & Evolution, 12(10), 1867–1874.

  7. iNaturalist. (n.d.) iNaturalist. Retrieved April 15, 2022, from https://www.inaturalist.org/

  8. IncredibleBats. (2018, May 2). Bat Echolocation. [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kp5jyZtoTIg

  9. IUCN Red List. (2022). Bats. IUCN Red List. Retrieved March 15, 2022, from https://www.iucnredlist.org/

  10. National Park Service. (n.d.) What is Citizen Science? National Park District. Retrieved April 12, 2022 from https://www.nps.gov/subjects/citizenscience/citizen-science.htm

  11. Penar, W., Magiera, A., & Klocek, C. (2020). Applications of bioacoustics in animal ecology. Ecological Complexity, 43. https://doi-org.proxy.lib.miamioh.edu/10.1016/j.ecocom.2020.100847

  12. The Nature Conservancy. (2022). Bats. The Nature Conservancy. https://www.nature.org/en-us/get-involved/how-to-help/animals-we-protect/bats/

  13. UConn Natural Resources Conservation Academy. (2020, July 8). Bat Acoustic Monitoring with NRCA (extended version). [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9Whj9t9nfxs

  14. US National Park Service. (2020, August 17). Benefits of Bats-Bats. US National Park Service. https://www.nps.gov/subjects/bats/benefits-of-bats.htm#:~:text=%20Benefits%20of%20Bats%20%201%20Supporting%20Cave,Americas%20eat%20nectar.%20Many%20types%20of...%20More%20

  15. US National Park Service. (2016, October 18). Echolocation-Bats. US National Park Service. https://www.nps.gov/subjects/bats/echolocation.htm

  16. US National Park Service. (2019, November 20). Threats to Bats-Bats. US National Park Service. https://www.nps.gov/subjects/bats/threats-to-bats.htm

  17. Virginia Bat Pros. (2018, January 5). The differences between megabats and microbats. Virginia Bat Pros. https://www.virginiabatpros.com/blog/the-differences-between-megabats-and-microbats/