My Rules
The Slide Rule
Perform numerical operations has been a need for the human been since very remote times. As early civilizations became more and more complex and sophisticated, the complexity and amount of numerical calculations they had to perform increased. Present or past advanced civilizations are characterized by a notorious development of Mathematics. Every ancient civilization invented and/or adapted a numerical system, and with these symbols they were able to perform all the basic arithmetic operations, as well as more complex operations like square roots or cubic roots.
Solar eclipses were predicted by Chinese astronomers by 2,300 BC, Egyptians made the necessary calculations to build their huge pyramids and temples, volumes of regular solids were precisely calculated by the Greeks, and all of them were able to calculate square and cubic roots. During the Middle Age and Renaissance solutions were approached for exponential equations to calculate compound interest problems.
But in all times, arithmetic calculations have been an annoying process, mainly when many have to be performed. So since early times humans have created devices to perform numerical calculations in a simpler way. So, about 3800 years ago, Chinese invented a very efficient device to perform additions and subtractions, and able also to do multiplications and divisions: the abacus. 2500 years ago Greeks and Romans added - subtracted integers and fractions using counters on a small board or "Calculi".
However the more complex operations: multiplication and division, remained as an annoying process. It was until 1617 that a Scottish amateur mathematician: John Napier, invented the first device to perform multiplications and divisions: the "Virgulas" (Rods), known in present times as "Napier's Bones".
These were a series of rods (by that time carved from bones) that had squares and numbers inscribed in them. Using the rods, one could perform multiplication by looking up partial products and summing them. Division was a more complex process but could be performed similarly as a series of look-ups and subtractions. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Napier%27s_bones)
Other invention to ease multiplications-divisions, roots and powers computations, also surged from John Napier's bright mind: The Logarithms.
After 20 years of tedious calculations, Napier published in 1614 his " Canon of Logarithms" containing tables of numbers that allowed compute multiplications and divisions as simple additions and subtractions. Napier set forth his motivation writing at the beginning of his book:
Seeing there is nothing that is so troublesome to mathematical practice, nor doth more molest and hinder calculators, than the multiplications, divisions, square and cubical extractions of great numbers, which besides the tedious expense of time are for the most part subject to many slippery errors, I began therefore to consider in my mind by what certain and ready art I might remove those hindrances...
Logarithms were so useful that the illustrious French mathematician Pierre Simon Laplace wrote that logarithms were: "an admirable artifice which, by reducing to a few days the labor of many months, doubles the life of the astronomer, and spares him the errors and disgust inseparable from long calculations". A very interesting story of the invention of logarithms, can be found in the lecture: John Napier and the Invention of Logarithm. 1619, given by E.W. Hobson, Math Professor at Cambridge University, in 1914, to commemorate the 300th anniversary of the invention of the Logarithms.
But even though the great help the tables of logarithms were to make computational work easier, they were not fully efficient because additions or subtractions had to be performed "by hand", and the conversions "numbers - to - logs - to - number" were annoying.
However logarithms were quickly adopted and used by the scientific community, and in 1620, a English clergy and mathematician: Edmund Gunter, engraved a logarithmic scale (a number line where logarithms of numbers 1 to 10, and some fractions between them are represented) on a wood ruler. With this device he was able to perform basic calculations with the aid of compasses.
In 1630, William Oughtred, another English clergy and mathematician, combining two Gunter's logarithmic scales carved on wooden rulers, was able to perform multiplications and divisions, sliding one scale on the other one, and reading the answer directly on the scales.
In the figure below, the number 1 on the lower scale is aligned with the number 2 on the upper scale, then it is easy to see that above the number 2 on the lower scale is the number 4, and above the number 2.5 is the number 5, and above the number 3 is the number six and so on... the results to multiply the numbers in the lower scale by two can be read directly above on the upper scale! With this procedure William Oughtred invented the Slide Rule.
Oughtred's had to hold together and slide by hand the two rulers to perform the operations. Ougthred also drew the logarithmic scales on circular cardboards of different sizes, then pivoting them at the center, performed the operations rotating one of the circles. Oughtred included in these first slide rules logarithms of the natural and trigonometric numbers, but only in one of the faces.
By the years William Oughtred was creating his first slide rule prototypes, that he called Rulers of Proportion, Edmund Wingate (1596-1656), an English lawyer interested in Mathematics, working in Paris as tutor of princess Henrietta Maria, (who later become wife of Charles I of England), also credited the invention of sliding Gunter scales in his book L'usage de la Regle de Proportion en Arithmetique, (The Use of the Ruler of Proportion in Arithmetic) published in Paris by 1624.
Besides the earlier publication of his Ruler of Proportion invention, Wingate was not finally credited as the inventor of the slide rule by the Swiss Mathematician Florian Cajiori (1850-1930), top researcher and authortity in the early 1900's on history of the logarithmic slide rule, and who initially credited Edmund Wingate as the inventor in his book A History of the Logarithmic Slide Rule and Allied Instruments, published in 1909, but corrected himself giving this credit to William Oughtred in his brochure On the History of Gunter's Scale and the Slide Rule during the Seventeenth Century, published in 1920.
In 1657, Seth Partridge, an English surveyor and mathematician, made up the first slide rule with three strips of wood, with the two outer strips held together by bridging cleats, and the strip at the middle sliding freely. Partridge included scales on both faces... the duplex slide rule was born
In 1675, Sir Isaac Newton, devised a method to solve cubic equations using three movable slide rule scales, and a separated edge or marking line laid across them to bring together three numbers on the scales.
This was the first use of the runner or primitive slider. But it was until 1775 that John Robertson, Librarian of the Royal Society of London, created the first moving mechanical marking line, as a part of the slide rule itself... the slide rule cursor was born, but it took almost a century to become a standard component of the slide rule.
The use of the slide rule quickly spread to other countries, and during the next centuries modifications and additions were made to the original designs, Additional to the basic logarithmic scales to perform multiplications and divisions, other scales to compute squares and square roots, cubes and cubic roots, values for trigonometric functions were added, and the slide rule's power grew when scales to compute any power or any root for a number, the Log-Log scales ,were created by the English physician Peter Roget (Yes!, the creator of the Thesaurus!) in 1845. The slide rule was an important tool for scientist and engineers during the Industrial Revolution.
The slide rule had also the possibility to be adapted to perform calculations for specific disciplines, so it was not only a tool for engineers, scientists and mathematicians, but creating specific logarithmic scales, was very useful for accountants, bankers, tax men, or merchant's.
But the modern general purpose slide rule was created by the French Artillery Lieutenant Amedee Mannheim in 1851. He created a simple arrangement with one pair of two-cycle logarithmic scales labeled A-B, and one pair of one-cycle logarithmic scales labeled C-D. The positioning of the A-B scales above the C-D scales, with B and C scales engraved on the rule's slider, allowed to calculate, multiplications-divisions, squares and square roots, and mixed multiplications-divisions of numbers with squares-square roots, in a very simple way. At the back of the slide sine and tangent scales were engraved. The array (A/B, C/D) remained the foundation for all further slide rule models, but Mannheim's greatest contribution was the reintroduction and refinement of a functional cursor. Mannheim described his slide rule design in a note in the Nouvelles Annales de Mathematiques in 1853 .
The technological advance of the next years and the development of new materials, made possible to produce slide rules of better quality and precision. The first line cursor was produced by the French Company Tavernier-Gravet in 1905, and this added to the invention of the plastic celluloid, gave to the slide rule its modern face.
With only the use of logarithmic scales, the slide rule became a powerful aide to solve problems. But scientists and engineers required to perform more complex operations to solve also more complex problems, so more sophisticated scales were created and slide rules became also more complex. Next are shown some masterpieces created during 1959-1975 (Click on the images to see the ISRM panoramic picture):
For about 350 years, the slide rule was the most efficient and effective calculating device, until it was displaced by the pocket electronic calculators, these, by the way, were designed with the help of the slide rule. The Empire State Building, the Eiffel Tower, The Golden Gate Bridge, the Panama Channel, Airplanes, Automobiles, Electrification, Radio and TV, Nuclear Power, Space Rockets, and all the great scientific and engineering achievements done from the 1700's to the early 1970's, were calculated with a slide rule.
Below is the famous picture of Buzz Aldrin using a Pickett N-600 in the Apollo 11. It is known that when the Gemini XII computer docking system failed, Buzz Aldrin calculated the docking trajectory using a sextant and a slide rule.
But the inexorable advance of science and technology during the 1960's and early 1970's quickly changed this panoramic, In 1961, with the help of their slide rules, IBM scientist and engineers produced the first transistor computer for engineering applications: the 7030 Stretch System, with much more computer power and precision than the best slide rule, but even though these computers were compact compared with those built with vacuum tubes, they were accessible only to a reduced number of privileged users (Original cost: $7,780,000, equivalent to $68,000,000 in 2021), so for the common people, or for working on your desk or at home, the slide rule was still necessary and useful, so, during the 1960's the slide rule market steadily expanded, and excellent and new fancy models were produced (see pics of the rules above).
By the same time, Casio Electronics produced in 1957 the first desktop electronic calculator: the Model 14-A, In the early 1960's were produced the first solid state calculators, but these devices were quite expensive for the standard user.
However, technological developments continued and in 1972 Hewlett Packard introduced the first pocket scientific calculator: the HP-35, with capabilities that made the slide rule look a very primitive gadget, but the not very affordable price of the HP-35, $395.00 USD (about $2,600.00 in 2021), compared with the lower cost of an "engineering" slide rule, (about $25 USD, ~$160 in 2021) gave to the slide rule market a few more years.
Unfortunately for the slide rule manufacturers, a new road was already open and nothing stopped the advance in that direction. In 1973, Texas Instruments produced its pocket scientific calculator TI-SR10, with a selling price of $150.00 USD (~ $850.00 USD in 2021). This price was already affordable for professionals and small companies, but still not very much for the common people.
Some slide rule manufacturers tried to ride on the new wave. In 1974, Faber-Castell introduced the TR1, TR2 and TR3 Electronic Slide Rules, handheld electronic calculators with slide rules attached on the back, but unfortunately for them, that same year, Texas Instruments launched the TI-30 at a cost of only $24.95 USD (~$112.00 USD in 2021), cheaper than some high end slide rules! The slide rule market had no way to compete now. During the next year, all manufactures stopped production, and slide rules were put in drawers, or simply throwed away. There were even plans from Pickett Co, manufacturer of the aluminum slide rules, (Yes, the ones used in the Mission Apollo), to sell the unsold production as scrap metal in Mexico.
The first Scientific Calculators: Hewlett-Packard HP-35, Texas Instruments TI-SR10, and the Texas Instruments TI-30
Here is a scan of the central pages of the November 1972 Life magazine, showing the prices of the new fast-selling electronic gadgets for that Christmas:
Something like this have never seen before, or after. A flourishing market with a production around the 40 million of pieces, collapses to zero in less than two years. As Cliff Stoll wrote in his classic paper When Slide Rules Ruled: ...the slide rule helped to design the very machines that would render it obsolete...
Is then the Slide Rule useless now? Well... we can say that compared with the modern technology the Slide Rule is obsolete, but it is not useless... Why?
Before answer this question I would like to ask the next: Why people ride bikes when automobiles are more efficient transportation vehicles? In a car you go faster and longer distances in less time... Well, even though bikes are a form of transportation for some, most people ride bikes for fun and as a way to be physically fitted.
To use slide rules can be compared as riding bikes: we can use slide rules for fun, but there is also a plus, we develop our mental math and our numerical sense; the slide rule user must mentally estimate the order of magnitude of the result, in other words, slide rules force us to think if our results are reasonable! Additionally it forces users to work more efficiently the Algebra to get expressions into more computable form, the less operations the better...These were the arguments my High School Physics teacher, Mrs. Elena Oria, gave to us when she required the use of a slide rule as the calculation tool for the 1977 fall course. By this time, electronic pocket calculators began to be affordable for students, and there were many complains to use this "obsolete device", but she was inflexible and we had to learn how to use a slide rule... the required rule for that course was the Aristo Studio 868.
Same as automobiles, that do not require you make an effort to go large distances, electronic calculators do not require users to make the effort to think to get a result, only a few keystrokes and... voila!... the answer is there! For many people the results obtained with an electronic calculator are unquestionable, undoubtedly correct, they ignore or don't know the Computer Sciences GIGO rule: garbage in, garbage out... flawed, or nonsense input data produces nonsense output...
Additionally, slide rules are very ingenuous devices. They are the materialization of the use of logarithms to solve problems, and a hands-on example that logarithms were invented to make complex operations simpler, and not to make math students' lives miserable...
Mastering of the slide rule was not only a need, but also was a passion that was taken into competitions, and participant students spent several hours per day learning tricks and practicing methods, but progress is at the end unstoppable, and those slide rule contests became calculator contests...
Finally, the slide rules versatility to be adapted to different disciplines and problems, and their intrinsic charm and beauty, make them very interesting collectibles. I personally declare myself a slide rule lover, and of course an irremediable collector. Click on the link below to see my little collection.
References.
I. Slide Rules History
(1). Wikipedia: Suanpan, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suanpan
(2). Wikipedia: Roman Abacus, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roman_abacus
(3). Maor, Eli: e: The Story of a Number, Princeton University Press, 1994
(4). Wikipedia: John Napier, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Napier
(5). Wikipedia: Napier's Bones, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Napier%27s_bones
(6). Keuffel & Esser Slide Rules: DECI-LON, An Instruction Manual, 1962
(7). Thompson, J.E.: A Manual of the Slide Rule, Its History, Principle and Operation. D. Vasn Nostrand Company Inc. 1930
(8). Cajori, Florian: A History of the Logarithmic Slide Rule and Allied Instruments. Univerity of Michigan Library. Reprint of First Edition 1909
(9). History of Computing; How the Slide Rule got its Cursor, https://www.nzeldes.com/HOC/Cursors.htm
(10). The Oughtred Society: The Slide Rule History, http://www.oughtred.org/history.shtml
(11). University of Florida, Department of Mechanical & Aerospace Engineering: How the Slide Rules Helped to Win the War. A Brief Story of the Slide Rule, https://mae.ufl.edu/sliderule/pages/lesson01_reading01.html
(12). Dutch Circle for Historical Calculating Instruments. http://rekeninstrumenten.nl/index.htm
(13). International Slide Rule Museum; https://www.sliderulemuseum.com/
(14). Wyman, Tom: Numeracy and the Slide Rule. Journal of the Oughtread Society. Vol 10 No.2 Fall 2001. https://osgalleries.org/journal/pdf_files/10.2/V10.2P55.pdf
(15). Stoll, Cliff. When Slide Rules Ruled. Scientific American, May 2006, pp. 80-87. http://damien.wyart.free.fr/sliderules_sciam_2006.pdf
(16). Davis, Richard - Hume, Ted: Slide Rule Reference Manual (All about slide rules). The Oughtred Society. Roseville California 2012. http://www.oughtred.org/books/OSSlideRuleReferenceManualrevA.pdf
(17). Nadworny, Elissa: The Slide Rule: A Computing Device That Put A Man On The Moon. nprED How Learning Happens. Tools of Trade. October 22, 2014. https://www.npr.org/sections/ed/2014/10/22/356937347/the-slide-rule-a-computing-device-that-put-a-man-on-the-moon
(18). TESSERACT. Early Scientific Instruments. Calculation. http://www.etesseract.com/Calculation/Calculation.html?fbclid=IwAR3p0XO54__MeFlrhOzV_SRsOMQmz-T8vcSunVV_GS-MYxXFo9yKu9uLBMU
(19). Uberroth, C.J.: Bring Back the Slide Rule. The Electric Agora. A Modern Symposium for the Digital Age. Post by Daniel Kaufman. September 7, 2018.https://theelectricagora.com/2018/09/07/bring-back-the-slide-rule/
(20). Rosenberg, Yuval. The Invention that altered history: The Slide Rule. The Jerusalem Post. June 27, 2022. https://www.jpost.com/science/article-710472?fbclid=IwAR0G_AS9RDtfdIhjxnJ2A7qliSqejDWn3URoDjxrzw15A5wf4nL_-VOLWd4
(21). Von Jeziersky, Dieter: Slide Rules, A Journey Through Three Centuries. Astragal Press. Mendham, New Jersey. 2000
II. Slide Rule Tutorials
Next is a link to Professor Herning's YouTube Channel where you can find with many good videos teaching how to use slide rules:
(1). https://www.youtube.com/c/ProfessorHerning/featured
III. Slide Rule Collectors.
The next links will take you to other collectors' great websites, so you will see that I'm not the only one with this crazy hobby:
(1). Steve K. Seale: Steve's Slide Rule Collection (steves-sliderules.info)
(2). Greg Scott: Greg's Slide Rules - How to contact me (ozmanor.com)
(3). Christian Hamman - Nancy Shaw: SLIDE RULES (beuth-hochschule.de)
(4). Rod Lovett: Rod's Slide Rules (lovett.com)
(5). Tina Cordon: https://tinas-sliderules.me.uk
(6) Mike Syphers: Introduction | Following the Rules — A Slide Rule Collection
(7). David Rance: David's calculating sticks, my collection of slide rules
(8). Clark McCoy: K&E Collection (mccoys-kecatalogs.com)
(9). Eric Marcotte: Eric's Slide Rule Site
(10). Giovanni Breda: Giovanni Breda's Slide Rule Collection
(11). Richard Davis: https://osgalleries.org/collectors/davis/davisthumbnails.cgi
(12). Cliff Frohllich: https://osgalleries.org/collectors/frohlich/frohlichthumbnails.cgi
(13). Louis Gotlib: https://osgalleries.org/collectors/gotlib/gotlibthumbnails.cgi
(14). Paul Tarantolo: https://osgalleries.org/collectors/tarantolo/tarantolothumbnails.cgi
(15). Tom Wyman: https://osgalleries.org/collectors/wyman/wymanthumbnails.cgi
(16). Daniel Toussaint: JFZAZZA ARC reglasdecalculo.com WEB
(17). Bob Adams: Bob's Calculators and Slide Rules - Slide Rules (google.com), archive of electro rules
https://osgalleries.org/electronic/index.html Sliderule Gallery - Bob's Sliderule Site (google.com)
(18). Mort Hans: Slideshow: Slide rules and charts - a personal collection - EDN
(19). Jay Ballahuer: www.Astro.com - Jay's Slide Rules. https://www.allaboutastro.com/sliderules.html