B1 Monitoring and evaluating customer service provision
• Using research from customers to identify improvements and monitor complaints.
• Monitoring using: o customer profiles, data, e.g. types of customer, products or services provided, customer care and service o sources of information, e.g. customers, colleagues, management
o methods, e.g. questionnaires, comment cards, quality circles, suggestion boxes, staff surveys, mystery shoppers, recording and sharing information.
• Evaluating customer service, including:
o analyse responses, e.g. level of customer satisfaction, quality of product or service, meeting regulatory requirements, balancing cost and benefits o planning for change, resolving problems/complaints.
Does customer opinions matter to a business?
How might a business monitor it's customer service provision?
Pick a local business of your choice, what 3 methods would you suggest they might use to monitor customer service?
In this section, you are going to explore the ways in which businesses find out about their customers' satisfaction levels, both internal and external. Businesses can and do make claims about customers' reactions which lack credibility and integrity. By finding out about customer's real impressions, businesses can make improvements, change their business models or extend their products to meet customer needs. More importantly, they can also learn what it is they do well and then do more of it.
You have probably been asked to complete satisfaction surveys at your place of study. Sometimes this can be online or via a paper form and it can be a nuisance if you are busy or not motivated to complete it. In this section, you will learn about other ways to gather this information (data) and then what happens to the data once it has been gathered.
In Unit 1 you were introduced to the Office of National Statistics (ONS) and using demographic trends as a means for business to better meet local customer needs. Using this data only provides a small portion of the picture; primary research is often an invaluable resource. Primary research is new research which aims to answer specific issues or questions. It can involve interviews, questionnaires or surveys of individuals or small groups.
Think about a business you use regularly and have a loyalty card/account for. What information do they have about you and how might they use it to best meet your needs and increase their sales.
Businesses can get an idea of what customers like about products or their preferences by what they buy and do not buy. However, not every customers buys something. They may make enquiries of a business, in person or by other means, but that does not necessarily tell the business why they did not make a purchase. You can use the following information to fill in the gaps in your knowledge.
Customer Profiles
It is vital for any business to know their customers, in other words, their customers' characteristics. They use this information to build a customer profile which includes characteristics such as gender, income and/or age group.
Data. eg types of customer, products or services provided, customer care and service
Customer's characteristics help inform businesses about their specialist needs as well as general needs. For example, simple questionnaires of ten ask for your gender or perhaps your age group. More complex and lengthy surveys request information about your ethnic group, financial status and other personal information. All these details are then analysed and the evaluations provide valuable sources of information to businesses.
Supermarkets and other large businesses collect customer data by offering loyalty cards and via payment methods. They can then target groups or individuals with information, offers, vouchers and other enticements to encourage spending/visits to stores.
Completing the National Census survey is compulsory. The ONS relies on this collection of data in the UK every 10 years to produce statistics about our habits, movements, population etc. The government can then plan and predict for the future. As the statistics are in the public domain, businesses can use them to find out about their local, regional and national market opportunities.
The UK Customer Satisfaction Index (UKCSI) exists as a national measure of customer satisfaction based on analyses from six-monthly online consumer surveys. Data is gathered based on several categories including quality and complaints.
Non-government organisations exist for the purpose of gathering data, which they sell to other businesses. These businesses use the data to monitor customer preferences and evaluate provision by, for example, making assumptions about the area in which customers live in relation to their likely purchasing power and suitability of products.
Some businesses request email addresses, sometimes with offers of discounts or other enticements to gather customer data.
Imagine you own a business.
Why is it important to seek the feedback of internal customers (staff)?
How might you collect feedback from internal customers (staff)?
Information can come from customers, colleagues and management. This information could provide information about internal customers as well as external customers. For example
McDonald's rewards employees for their customer service qualities, relying on gathering feedback from internal and external customers.
Cunard and several other cruise companies, collect nominations from passengers, colleagues and management in recognition of quality service. Crew and officers alike are then recognised by their photographs, which are displayed in key public areas.
Feedback tools need to be created carefully so that you can find out what you need to know. Invitations for customers to provide data can appear in different forms such as:
questionnaires
online comments and feedback requests
comment cards inviting feedback and offering incentives
telephone surveys
compliments, suggestions and complaint boxes
quality circles where staff members, normally in similar roles, meet to discuss ways of making improvements and resolving problems
staff surveys which are used to gather the views from all staff and, when analysed, can be compared with the feedback received from customers
mystery shoppers who are employed to portray a customer over a period of time and in different circumstances to gather data on their experiences- business staff are unaware of the true intentions of these shoppers or the timing of their visits to better replicate realistic situations.
Recording and sharing information by telephone- this is used frequently by businesses, especially in customer service or call centres; there are legal guidelines about recording communications, in any form, to protect both sides of the communication, such as:
-The Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act
-Data Protection Act
-Human Rights Act
You have probably experienced a taped message at the start of a phone call advising uou that a recording will be made, usually for training purposes. Businesses can then analyse the contents of calls to improve services and resolve complaints. The Financial Services Act 2012 requires recorded communications when related to specific instructions.
Once feedback is collected, the results need to be analysed. This can be a time-consuming and highly skilled job and relies heavily on the quality of the feedback mechanisms and the way in whcih the methods, such as questionnaires, are structured. It is vital to consider the key information you wish to collect and develop a range of questions which will gather this information in an effective manner.
Analyse Responses
Some responses will be quantitative (numeric/closed responses) and others qualitative( text information open responses both of these need to be evaluated suitablly. The main areas businesses usually want to explore include:
Level of customer service
Quality of product/service
Meeting regulatory requirements
Balancing cost and benefits
Most types of survey seek to analyse satisfaction levels and quality. Businesses also seek confirmation of compliance, businesses are also looking to gather feedback which is easy to analyse, effective and cheap with maximum impact.
A pitfall or presenting responses by percentages is that they can be misleading. For example, saying that 89% of survey participants would recommend a product appears impressive to a customer but there may have only been 100 respondents. 89 people is not many in relation to the whole population.
Planning for Change/Resolving Problems or Complaints
Businesses also use analysis of feedback to plan for change by resolving problems, responding to complaints or finding ways to do more of what they already do well. Microsoft does this by gathering and analysing data from users of their software to improve and refine their products and develop new software. For example when computers crash or programs close during operation the information can be fed back to Microsoft, helping them to improve the coding of the software for future updates.
First Direct's online banking services' methods of gathering feedback (including Twitter) and trustworthiness have helped them to trade on customer recommendation above any other bank by being more customer-centric (Putting customers at the centre of operations). An apparently minor complaint might become more serious according to ythe number of times similar complaints are lodged.