DISCUSSION QUESTIONS
8. Maj. Gen. Curtis LeMay said after the March 9-10 Tokyo bombing, "There are no innocent civilians…The entire population got into the act and worked to make those airplanes or munitions…men, women, and children." Do you agree or disagree with LeMay? Why?
9. Do you think international laws should define the “rules” of war that might prevent the usage of weapons like gas, napalm, rockets, submarines, and atomic weapons? Why or why not?
The first American bombing of the Japanese capital occurred during the famed “Doolittle Raid” by 16 medium-sized aircraft under Lieutenant Colonel James “Jimmy” Doolittle had bombed Tokyo on April 18, 1942. Flying off of aircraft carriers for the first time, Doolittle's small force attacked the city and then flew off to attempt landings in friendly bases in China. Although the raid did little to cripple Japan’s war-making powers, it was a major boost to American morale after the shock and devastation of the Pearl Harbor attack and brought the war home to the Japanese, proving that their home islands would not be immune to enemy bombers.
After Germany surrendered in May 1945, America wanted to quickly end the war against Japan. As plans went ahead for a costly invasion of the Japanese islands, Major General Curtis LeMay took command of the bombing campaign against Japan, which had started in late 1944. Having studied British area-bombing tactics, LeMay decided to adopt them in a final effort to force the Japanese to surrender.
On the night of March 9-10, 1945, LeMay's B-29 bombers attacked Tokyo, a city of 6 million people. Nearly 600 bombers dropped 1,665 tons of fire bombs on the Japanese capital. An hour after the first fires started, the conflagration spread beyond the target area, and LeMay’s desired firestorm was achieved with devastating results. The citizenry in the target area ran through the streets in panic, desperate to find any form of safety from the searing heat. The heat, which is reported to have reached an unimaginable temperature of 1,800 degrees in some locations, sucked the oxygen out of the air, asphyxiating those it did not simply roast to death. The clothes on people’s backs, those that weren’t on fire from the actual bombs, literally burst into flames from the heat. The glass in windows began to liquify. The superheated air and cyclonic winds from the firestorm blew the liquified glass into the air, where it fell on people like some terrible rain, embedding itself into their scalps where it continued to melt into the hair and skin.
The resulting firestorm destroyed 16 square miles of the city and killed 100,000 people, more than died at Hiroshima or Nagasaki from atomic bombs a few months later. Most of the victims were women, children, and old men. The B-29 crew members put on oxygen masks to keep from vomiting at the smell of burning human flesh.
LeMay's planes continued firebombing Tokyo and more than 60 other Japanese cities in the following months. He thought he could end the war quickly by destroying Japan's economy and crushing the morale of the Japanese people. LeMay argued against using atomic bombs. He believed that his firebombing tactics would force Japan to surrender before American forces were scheduled to invade the homeland.
The Allied area bombing of civilians played an important role in undermining the will of the German and Japanese people to continue the war. But unlike the predictions of military strategists before the war, this did not happen quickly. For a long time, the bombing of German and Japanese civilians only stiffened their resolve to fight on. They wanted to surrender only after their countries lay in ruins, hundreds of thousands had perished, and all hope of victory was lost.
DISCUSSION QUESTIONS
8. Maj. Gen. Curtis LeMay said after the March 9-10 Tokyo bombing, "There are no innocent civilians…The entire population got into the act and worked to make those airplanes or munitions…men, women, and children." Do you agree or disagree with LeMay? Why?
9. Do you think international laws should define the “rules” of war that might prevent the usage of weapons like gas, napalm, rockets, submarines, and atomic weapons? Why or why not?
Information provided by: http://www.crf-usa.org/bria/bria15_3.html#atomic