RISD

Zixuan Zhang Brief from Alessandro Foti

Progettare un servizio dedicato allo scacciapensieri, antico strumento musicale della Sicilia e della Sardegna creato inizialmente per la comunicazione tra i pastori e i contadini a grandi distanze. Il servizio offrirà un'esperienza completa per apprendere e migliorare l'abilità nell'utilizzo dello strumento. Una comunità di appassionati potrà condividere l'esperienza e immergersi completamente nella pratica dell'utilizzo dell'antico strumento in modo innovativo.

Persona profile

Designing a service around the scacciapensieri musical instrument might face several challenges:

1. Niche market: The scacciapensieri is a relatively obscure instrument with a limited audience. Creating a service around it might not attract a large user base, making it difficult to maintain and grow the platform.

2. Accessibility: Sourcing and providing access to the instrument itself could be a challenge. As it's an ancient and region-specific instrument, it might not be widely available, and users might have difficulty obtaining one for practice.

3. Expertise: Finding experienced instructors or musicians who can teach and guide users in playing the scacciapensieri could be a challenge. As it's not a mainstream instrument, there may be a limited pool of skilled individuals available.

4. Cultural context: Part of the appeal of the scacciapensieri is its cultural significance in Sicily and Sardinia. Conveying that context to a global audience may be difficult, and retaining authenticity could be challenging.

5. Engaging content: Developing engaging and varied content to maintain user interest in the service might be a challenge. To keep users motivated and learning, the service would need to offer different levels of instruction, tutorials, and opportunities for interaction within the community.

6. Monetization: Finding a sustainable way to monetize the service could be challenging, given its niche appeal. The platform might need to explore alternative revenue streams, such as premium memberships, workshops, or merchandise sales, to remain viable.

7. Competition: While the scacciapensieri is a unique instrument, there is competition from other music learning platforms and apps that cater to a broader range of instruments. The service would need to differentiate itself and offer unique features to attract users.

Feedbacks

Good Job! I really like the trait of an Ethnomusicologist (I didn’t really know what it is, I searched on the web LOL), it is Interesting. Honestly, I laughed a lot when I read “Alessandro has become a skilled instructor in playing… the instrument” because it isn’t so hard to learn compared to a piano, violin and other instruments.

From the analysis of this profile I didn’t find a lot of biases, except for:

• the surname "Rossi” because it is really common in Italy but not in Sicily 

• the difficulty of playing the instrument presumed, it proves that ChatGPT doesn't know what a Scacciapensieri is in the Sicilian tradition. 

Next time for changes or corrections try to ask for a “marranzanu”, it is in dialect, maybe we could be more lucky with this. 

I would like to see what Alessandro looks like and know more about him. I suggest exploring his needs, difficulties or what he really cares about Sicilian culture. The desire of Alessandro to share his traditions and culture all around the world is really fascinating.

Nowadays it is rare to find someone busking scacciapensieri, it could be cool finding a way to reintroduce this tradition.

Thank you for your work, I’m impatient to know what the concept will be

Concept

Feedbacks (first concept)

Summary of feedbacks given:

-The profile generated by midjourney has the typical characteristics of the average Sicilian: dark complexion, dark hair. The image depicts on a background of vases, wooden boards, typical of Sicily in the 1930s-60s, seems to be a bias. The outfit is also a bias: the AI generated a man in dungarees, typically used by those who do manual labor, despite the fact that it is not indicated in the prompt.

-Today the cities are more modern and a bit bigger: the prompt for the image presents another bias: it talks about a small village, in Sicily there are no more villages, they are almost all cities.

-I would like to see what Alessandro Rossi's interests and needs might be, we might unearth other biases.

-The concept is very interesting, it includes moments of training, others of community and events. Thinking about physical moments where the sense of community could get stronger. 

(thought post live feedback) the app is definitely a way to spread the niche culture of mind-blowing but is it the best way? The question is, is it possible to spread this tradition around the world? Is the app powerful enough?

Feedbacks (second concept)

v2

Fantastic design, midjourney returns amazing images as always. As for the fidelity of the object, I confirm that I gave you a difficult task. Despite the directions you visibly entered in the GPT chat command "When held by a human, the scacciapensieri easily fits in the palm of a hand or between the fingers, showcasing its delicate, yet elegant contours and balance," the result is more like a stringed instrument such as the lyre. That confirm that Chat GPT doesn't know what a scacciapensieri is.

v3

This version reflects the suggestions during the peer review. Photos generated by Midjourney give a sense of community. I note a bias related to the age of people appearing: as the scacciapensieri an ancient and traditional instrument, Midjourney assumed that all users are elderly. The scene in the pictures is typical of small towns in Sicily. Usually the elderly gather in a circle in a square or by a café talking about the past or talking about their surroundings. I find this practice and the application proposed in the first concept are great ways to bring younger people closer to the tradition of scacciapensieri and create a community from all over the world. 

v4

The event narrated in the image looks very interesting, although the instruments depicted are not scacciapensieri, they give me the idea of a concert in which the scacciapensieri can also participate. Very interesting. This image may give the idea to propose an innovative and different way to play the scacciapensieri in a different context.

Thank you very much for the updates, they are very interesting.

Notes and reflections

write here